However it’s important not to just discount all inaccuracies with the excuse that “it’s just a game”. I think it’s absolutely fine when inaccuracies exist because of gameplay first. Since gameplay is more important. However inaccuracies, less in Far Cry, more in other games such as AC, are sometimes just the result of lazyness by Ubisoft for ex. Since the point of AC is that ur getting to go back in time, inaccuracies should be eliminated when possible. Since it’s what a good chunk of the fanbase play AC for in the first place.
@@leonardodavid2842 Well some liberties are always taken when adapting reality into fiction. But the plus side on the inaccuracies is that it provides content for people who for example review the historical or practical inaccuracies on you tube and provides an interesting way to learn about history.
I feel bad for the lady with the red dress since she didn’t seem to know much about that time period compared to the other one so she doesn’t have much to say
Imagine being a island goddess and see a man getting shot 27 times about to die but then he eats a piece of meat and unbreaks his fingers and is somehow fine.
Brandon Welsh - The Beginning is Realistic - but they wouldn’t send in 3 Police Officers to Arrest Joseph - especially when they have footage of a Murder and know it’s Dangerous.. They’d send the National Guard
@@lba4746 If any real viking would see that game, or generally how pop culture presents Norse culture, they would throw up their guts and die. There is nothing historical about it, just fantasy bs that for some reason became iconic to the Norse.
Having played the game, there is so much more that perfectly fits what they were describing: The Izila already having agriculture, wheras the Wenja learn it in the game through Roshani. Female hunters, especially the main hunter you learn from being Jayma an old experienced huntress. Your village starting out just as a cave and then when more people join and you learn agriculture it becomes a whole villiage. Wogah having survived with an amputated arm. The worldbuilding in general is really awesome, even if some animals wouln't be living there. But when it comes to different tribes, way of live (clothing, food, agriculture, priests and believes, structure building) it is very thoughtful.
There's also some other things about FC Primal that should be noted: 1. Neanderthals like the Udam would have no longer existed in the time period Far Cry Primal takes place. At that point, the Neanderthals went extinct about at least 30,000 years ago, meaning that the Udam were anachronisms. The Udam, in truth, would've been far more distant from the Wenja than even the ancient Sumerians were from us. 2. The Wenja and the Izila are listed as separate subspecies of humans in the Far Cry wiki, which is actually incorrect. In reality, both clans would've been the same race of Cro-Magnon homo sapiens, with the only thing separating them being that the Izila were more technologically advanced.
@@thebatmanofneo-gotham5667 Point 1 is compeltly true, but your second point refears to the wiki that uses non game maker sources, so it's hard to say if this is corrector or not. The Izila article uses the source of the linguist who made all the languages in Primal but the only canon confirmation on that is that the language used is Pro-Indo based for all tribes if you look at other articles from him. Which honestly is kind of strange considering this would have been quiet early, but I suppose it was used because it is better studied. The source who activly links the Izila to the farming tribes of Mesopotamia is not from Ubisoft. It's a published article, that is sadly behind a paywall and links to migration which wouldn't be impossible, but it's not Ubisoft confirmed, this is from a wiki writer.
@@thebatmanofneo-gotham5667 The Udam are not Neanderthals. They have the "look" of them for sure but they are stated to be just another tribe of Sapiens.,
Or someone from a different culture that practice survival skills til this day. Their are plenty Islanders & Aborginals that do. They'll make excellent commentary on the ancient tools & survival techniques.
The stupid thing that saber tooth cat is a legendary very rare cat in far cry primal only one cat exists in the game but gamology didn't tell them that
@@Immafraid the historians reacted in the clip and said that there were no sabertooth back in primal time sequencing that the game isn't real when the sabertooth actually is legendary animal in farcry primal and they didn't mention that so they were false
I love that at 5:58 she's acknowledging that we don't have evidence of things, but that it's entirely possible we just haven't found it. Meanwhile most other people doing videos like this sit there and crap on it.
Yeah, that's the difference between a lifetime of studying subjects like this and just reading a Wikipedia entry about it. The former deals in likelihoods, which the latter assumes are proven beyond all doubt.
Honestly that was the only part that actually confused me since crocodiles are pretty much modern dinosaurs. Unless she meant humans hunting them, in which case I should've watch tgis before smoking a J
@@JennyGormanRitter I think she was referring to the crocodiles being in Europe as implausible, rather than the crocodiles being around somewhere in the world at that time. Same situation as the Saber Tooth... right species, wrong location
@@GeneralGrievousCISyeah, I believe by now they would have found SOME evidence for crocodiles being in Europe if there had been any. From what I recall, the latest known crocodiles to live in Europe was in Spain, and that was around 5,000,000 years ago - so it's more like extremely unlikely. But I don't care in the sense of the game, they probably just used it because they had them in Far Cry 3 and 4 (I believe it's the exact same animation and model even)
@@hotdogpepper8410the whole females were hunters at that time is another fishy claim. The only substantial evidence I could find was in Peru, and it’s still up in the air on whether the body was a female
I once had a 48 pound lynx as a pet. Her name was Baby Cakes, best pet I ever had... Well except for all the furniture she tore up and she was VERY vocal when she came into heat. Broke my heart when she died, never had a pet since. Don't think I will again. I don't know if that counts as a "big cat" but she definitely was a power house of a animal.
I really feel the need to correct them, when they burst out laughing at the concept of a domesticated cheetah, while it's true big cats cant be bred into domestication they CAN be tamed and theres a huge difference
I absolutely *LOVE FARCRY PRIMAL* so much! What an amazing concept for a video game. I just wish we could keep adding to our village meaning more and more huts and all that are made.
The lady said that the hunting party should have been mixed sex. One question: In all the primitive societies that still exist today (Africa, South America, Papua New-Guinea and so forth), is there any form of mixed sex hunting? The reason I ask is I have read a bit over the years about various such cultures (just for fun, no deep studies), and nowhere have I encountered anything like that. And to me, it makes sense. Women are valuable - they make more people. Why would you risk them if you didn't have to? The reason we find ancient skeletons of both males and females that show injuries is probably because the ancient hunter-gatherer life was kinda hard. Just a thought.
Looking at the hunter-gatherer societies that are left today you would actually find evidence of both, like the Aeta people in the Philipines where women and men hunt, or some tribes in africa where only men hunt. But you also have to bear in mind, that the cultures of the Paleolithic were incredibly diverse, that making statements like "Man the Hunter, Woman the Gatherer" would be incredibly simplistic and reductionist. And women are more valuable from a populational standpoint, but, in the situation of the game, where they "Kill the mammoth or we all die", would you really get rid of roughly 50% of your available manpower and skill?
@@GabrielSoares-qp1he How ironic that your comment is incredibly simplistic and reductionist. Sure women did hunt when there was no other possible way of avoiding it to survive. But at least somewhat stable tribes would never go on a hunt with a woman, that is so stupid, its absurd to even think of. Not only men are naturally more competitive and physically stronger to take down a prey, but women could not simply "go to hunt" while they are pregnant or have children to take care at home and chores like berries to gather, clothing to craft, food to cook. These "historians" are just another victims of left propaganda.
@@GabrielSoares-qp1heSo you think that back in the day Men would stay at home and take care of the Children and Women would go out Hunting. Now don't fell Personally attacked. But Personally to me, it really shocks me how peopel are even able to miss understand, really such core truths about Human Nature and the Core of Society. In my tribe i would banish you. 😅
@@tiwaz4598 of course women hunted in the ice age dude lmao, many tribes in modern times have women as hunters so why not then? Besides when you're hungry whoever's good at hunting hunts, simple as that😂
Actually, there were saber toothed cats in europe. The last specimen of a sabertoothed cat named homotherium latidens was found to be only 28‘000 years old...humans deffinetly met them in europe.
@@yyg4632 I didn‘t correct anyone per se, just wanted to add some info for the people interested. Also she is an archeologist not a historian. Saber toothed cats were found across the world and that‘s a simple fact. They were no saber toothed cats in europe at 10000 bc, that‘s true but scimitar toothed cats like homotherium were deffinetly a „europe thing“ aswell. She was probably refering to smilodon with saber tooth cat which were mostly a north america thing although two of the three species, including the biggest one were found in south america aswell. Like I said. I wasn‘t correcting her since she didn‘t state anything wrong, I was just elaborating and adding some info
@@James-ru7nz yes I know that ac has some historical accuracies but there are some major fuck-ups in there For example, the plague doctor outfit thing was supposed to be invented nearly a century after the events of AC2 but instead it’s just there
@@obamium9692 What do you mean man? The bubonic plague which happend in 1290 or something made the doctors that time wear that outfit. It continued until the end of Reniessance.
@@alekksu4293 I mean the guns, vehicles and even some map is almost accurate. The Rotterdam map for example is really good, it can represent a city before and after the carpet bombers. Or the single player campaigns had a lot of historycal accurate (Bf1 of course, but The Last Tiger too).
@@DriversofLondon I don’t hate all the buzzfeed channels, (gaming being one that I actually sometimes enjoy watching) but a lot of that channel is gender oriented and it’s weird and unnecessary
That was an absolute fucking legendary video. I loved this so much. They're so full of charisma, and they know how to [NOT] take this so seriously, and understand that is a game. I really wish to see them more around here.
Also correct me if I'm wrong I'm pretty sure only neanderthals in that period had women and men hunting while our ancestors were mostly hunter-gatherers. this was because neanderthals hunted only big game while our ancestors hunted and harvested wild plants. which is why theythen decided to split labor between sexes
@Yo Momma well I'm saying this because she never specified she just said some tribes and does it say on google if its our ancestors, or is it the neanderthals because that's what I want to make sure of.
Since Earth isn't 30,000 years old, it would make more sense for them to use less speculation, and something where more forensic evidence and documentation actually exists, and compare / contrast based on that. Red Dead lends itself well to this.
I’ve always been interested in history, myself. Specifically pre-gunpowder weapons history. Granted my knowledge of the subject is amateurish at best, but still.
I mean, for some reason I’ve always had a lot of questions, with the history of various civilizations. Especially in the Americas, prior to Columbus ‘discovering’ them, since all we really have to go on is word-of-mouth traditions and archeological/paleological remains.
Classical Antiquity, the Golden age and the Bronze age is important and really cool to learn about. Those are our ancestors and forfathers. They were absolute badasses too.
Not to mention even in modern day we see tons of wildcats and bears being conditioned and some even raised by a person who then become domesticated enough to see them as their family, literally everything has been.
Have the historians react through Assassin's Creed from start to current year Assassins Creed game. And make sure to tell them about the history of Ubisoft claiming to be 'historically accurate' about their games.
At 3:54 where she talks about the conference where mammoth meat was served, it turns out that was inaccurate. The conference in question was actually in 1951 and indeed a mysterious “prehistoric meat” was served. Later it was determined that the meat in question was green sea turtle meat advertised differently for fun.
It's mostly true that Cave Bears were vegetarians but recent revaluation of bones say that they were more herbivorous than most bears nowadays, but they were still omnivores.
3:04 - 3:10 I’m not sure either but I do think it’s more than probable that they did have natural forming dreads, since this type of hair style doesn’t require any maintenance for it to curl and naturally form dreads
Most of the historic evidence is underneath the water unless they're also divers. There weren't only migrating hunter gatherers in that time period. They had villages, temples, boats, advanced fishing traps.
You may not have sabre-toothed cats in 10,000 BC, but sabre-toothed cats, a lot different to the North and South American smilodon, were living in Europe during the ice age. Evidence has been found in the North Sea.
Yeah, I like that they mentioned people in the upper Paleolithic living on a strict diet of meat being beyond absurd. They were omnivorous just like us. In fact, most historians would agree that game meat was more of a treat. A steady diet of fruits, berries, fungus and fish is far more realistic, as they were more abundant resources, and didn't share the likelihood of loss of manpower as something like a mammoth hunt. Also, as they mentioned, the preservation of meat, even with their adapted immune systems, would have proven problematic, because rancid meat is rancid meat no matter your immune strength.
4:55 I'd like to see a citation for that claim. I think it may be true about neanderthal but all recent hunter gatherers had division of Labor and at some sites like Malta in Siberia and Ohalo in Israel we have evidence of men's and women's spaces.
From my understanding the game take place within the last few hundred years of the last ice age. Hell your tribe still lives in a cave in the beginning. So I imagine those divisions of labor still haven't taken hold.
2:04 actually we have found big cats quite similar to sabers around europe still about 300,000 years too late though also cave bears lived in russia snow leopards are also in this game those live in china all around bot like a single prehistoric animal in this game is in the right spot at the right time except mammoths
I'm not sure why you guys called this "Historians React." The age primal takes place was pre-history so it should really be "archaeologists react" or "anthropologists react." One of them was an archaeologists which makes sense but the other is out of the loop when it comes to this topic. However this "Historians react" has a lot of potential!
@@ludvikholden3103 lol if ur going full “technically” on it. But u could even see that the non-archaeologist/anthropologist didn’t know what to say. That’s a shame and she should be used to analyze the history of other video games
@@FireShoxx maybe, bur we still learns about it in history classes in Norway. And you could say the same thing about the roman empire... or anything else
@@ludvikholden3103 the difference between the Roman Empire and 20,000 years ago is the Roman Empire had writing. When ur approaching history it’s fairly different when ur looking into an age that only has the archeological record to go off of. Although both are history, both have their own field of experts because analyzing each is so much different
Well, there was sabertoothed cats in late Pleistocene in Europe, in the northwestern mostly, it was Homotherium latindens. They could have seen humans but probably they gone extinct far before 10K ago. But homotheriums didn`t have such a giant canines as smilodons did (and as depicted cat did too) who were truly endemic to Americas.
It's interesting how historians have so much knowledge based completely in guesswork and yet seem so sure they're correct because it's commonly accepted.
@@zakbrown676 History isn't science, and anthropology is at best on the intersection of humanities and science. It's why we in the humanities are a cesspool right now where postmodernism flourishes.
I also read about Otzi the Iceman and they say that his entire digestive system was still intact and the scientist could actually see what he ate before he died. A theory on his death was (because he had a bear skin cap with/on him) that a tribe member/a rival tribe shot him by accident thinking he was a bear. He is also believed to have been a shaman or healer of some sort because he carried around anti biotics which were not commonly found with primitive people's
9:15 actually it's shown that cave men used and native Americans used deer hide and antlers as a form of camouflage so they can get closer to there prey without spooning there prey
Well, they were hunting Mammoths, men are physically stronger than women biologically, so while the women might be helping with things like ancient deer, or defend from wolves that arrows and spears need less strength to kill, while a mammoth needs far more strength to be pierced.
"No one's hunting mammoth by themselves." My crazy ass: *ahem* Edit: No, seriously. I've hunted about 6 young mammoth and 2 elder by myself. Yes, I did get yeeted a few times. Pro tip: Throw your spear, clubs, shoot your bow. Just use range.
Now see,we wouldnt be this obvious, wed plant a seed for a job like a writer or artist, then slowly whisperer doubts when the debt inevitably sets in until you sell your soul
2:36 They are showing footage of neanderthals. Neanderthals went extinct in europe between 35.000 to 50.000 years BC. The game is taking place 13.000 years BC. Nice one editors, really backing up the historians.
Sarah is adorable and it is so awesome seeing how excited she gets to share her knowledge with us. i love history and get the same way talking about american history (1600s-1800s). i hope to be that knowledgeable one day
In hunter/gatherer societies, the vast majority of food was gained via the gatherers. More often than not, hunts were unsuccessful for varying reasons. However, when a hunt was successful, the amount of food and materials (bone, sinew, pelts, etc.) gained was immense.
![Baby Kia - GLOVES & DRACS (BLACK AF1s) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ajm8LeB0qQk/mqdefault.jpg)
Historians react has so much potential
Assassin's Creed
Try alternate history games
@@fangi6885 wolfenstein
@@evanm320 Wolfenstain was alternative history,so... nope
Well duh every game has some sort of history behind it LITERALLY every game
5:03 "Oh is he fishing?"
No, the fish is actually humaning.
Lmoa good one
@@planning9930 if you have no clue what you’re talking about, maybe just dont talk?
lolol very good one
You got me dead laughing bro nice one!
Lmao
I love how the historian understands its a game and doesn’t make fun of some of the inaccuracies
However it’s important not to just discount all inaccuracies with the excuse that “it’s just a game”.
I think it’s absolutely fine when inaccuracies exist because of gameplay first. Since gameplay is more important.
However inaccuracies, less in Far Cry, more in other games such as AC, are sometimes just the result of lazyness by Ubisoft for ex. Since the point of AC is that ur getting to go back in time, inaccuracies should be eliminated when possible. Since it’s what a good chunk of the fanbase play AC for in the first place.
@@leonardodavid2842 Well some liberties are always taken when adapting reality into fiction. But the plus side on the inaccuracies is that it provides content for people who for example review the historical or practical inaccuracies on you tube and provides an interesting way to learn about history.
well yeah but like the reasons they got experts to react... is to point out the inaccuracies lmao.
@@leonardodavid2842 absolutely dude
@THX_SKULLKRAKEN *cough* red dead 2
I feel bad for the lady with the red dress since she didn’t seem to know much about that time period compared to the other one so she doesn’t have much to say
She still spurned conversation by asking a lot of questions, which was smart of her
Usually they have experts react to multiple games to make videos so maybe we’ll see one in the medieval times where the other girl specializes in!
@@distinctemerald6794 Exactly! ;)
@@distinctemerald6794 Kingdom come deliverance!
Well she did admit it at the beginning
Imagine being a island goddess and see a man getting shot 27 times about to die but then he eats a piece of meat and unbreaks his fingers and is somehow fine.
Didnt expect to find you here
Literally just fuck you because of the way people play you but also I absolutely adore your character
Imagine being a legion main
Lol
I find it funny people are just insulting the guy for having a legion profile
Them: no ones hunting mammoths on their own.
Dragonborn: hold my beer
Indeed
I used my Thu'um once and accidentally angered the Giants
It resulted with me becoming a true Dragon flying across the heavens
Single shot them with the bow
hold my blackbriar mead
@@markjaygagar8757 Black Briar? How dare you shove that swill in my face. I'd rather drink mammoth drool!
Tiid Klo Ul, 4 arrows and those tusks are yours
*Charles Manson* Reacts to Far Cry 5 Cult
I know this is a joke but they could get a cult expert or two to look at the cutscenes and lore
He dead
Lol
Brandon Welsh - The Beginning is Realistic - but they wouldn’t send in 3 Police Officers to Arrest Joseph - especially when they have footage of a Murder and know it’s Dangerous.. They’d send the National Guard
@@firstlast9846 well I guess that was the plan
It's so obvious that the next video will be them reacting to AC: Valhalla
I need Ragnar to react to it, otherwise its bullshit
@@lba4746 and Erik
Obviously
@@lba4746 If any real viking would see that game, or generally how pop culture presents Norse culture, they would throw up their guts and die. There is nothing historical about it, just fantasy bs that for some reason became iconic to the Norse.
You're God damn right
Having played the game, there is so much more that perfectly fits what they were describing:
The Izila already having agriculture, wheras the Wenja learn it in the game through Roshani.
Female hunters, especially the main hunter you learn from being Jayma an old experienced huntress.
Your village starting out just as a cave and then when more people join and you learn agriculture it becomes a whole villiage.
Wogah having survived with an amputated arm.
The worldbuilding in general is really awesome, even if some animals wouln't be living there.
But when it comes to different tribes, way of live (clothing, food, agriculture, priests and believes, structure building) it is very thoughtful.
There's also some other things about FC Primal that should be noted:
1. Neanderthals like the Udam would have no longer existed in the time period Far Cry Primal takes place. At that point, the Neanderthals went extinct about at least 30,000 years ago, meaning that the Udam were anachronisms. The Udam, in truth, would've been far more distant from the Wenja than even the ancient Sumerians were from us.
2. The Wenja and the Izila are listed as separate subspecies of humans in the Far Cry wiki, which is actually incorrect. In reality, both clans would've been the same race of Cro-Magnon homo sapiens, with the only thing separating them being that the Izila were more technologically advanced.
@@thebatmanofneo-gotham5667 Point 1 is compeltly true, but your second point refears to the wiki that uses non game maker sources, so it's hard to say if this is corrector or not.
The Izila article uses the source of the linguist who made all the languages in Primal but the only canon confirmation on that is that the language used is Pro-Indo based for all tribes if you look at other articles from him. Which honestly is kind of strange considering this would have been quiet early, but I suppose it was used because it is better studied.
The source who activly links the Izila to the farming tribes of Mesopotamia is not from Ubisoft. It's a published article, that is sadly behind a paywall and links to migration which wouldn't be impossible, but it's not Ubisoft confirmed, this is from a wiki writer.
@@thebatmanofneo-gotham5667 what’s an anachronism
@@thebatmanofneo-gotham5667 The Udam are not Neanderthals. They have the "look" of them for sure but they are stated to be just another tribe of Sapiens.,
@@arcotroll8530 How do you know?
**Frantically stabbing a fish biting his leg**
"Oh, is he fishing?"
Looks like normal fishing to me
To be fair if they didn’t have fishing rods then that would be an ideal way of fishing, just take the fish biting his leg out then yeah
I’m a simple man. I liked the comment, saw the profile picture, unliked.
"so what's the bait?"
"me"
@@tobubiify that deserves a like
“no bears”
*laughs in cheeseburger*
Omfg
Rip cheeseburger
diabestus
Next "Cavemen react to Far Cry Primal"
Ooga Booga, unga karabunga. Booga uga Badonga..
@@ФилипРадојковић yes philip, it is nice
@@emiloe6702 😂😂
Get the Cavemen from Geico Lol
Or someone from a different culture that practice survival skills til this day. Their are plenty Islanders & Aborginals that do. They'll make excellent commentary on the ancient tools & survival techniques.
Historians react to Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey
Early hominids (or chimpanzees) react to Ancestors
reject humanity join monke
A real good game
They’d need actual paleontologists lol
@@obviousalias132 Where banana?
"no saber toothed cats at 10,000 years ago in Europe"
Homotherium: Am i a joke to you?
LOL no doubt, and here I thought that a fossil was proof that something had died somewhere rather than that it living there.
*lived
The stupid thing that saber tooth cat is a legendary very rare cat in far cry primal only one cat exists in the game but gamology didn't tell them that
@@Sealth-6y9 What the hell are you talking about? They are absolutely everywhere in the game.
@@Immafraid the historians reacted in the clip and said that there were no sabertooth back in primal time sequencing that the game isn't real when the sabertooth actually is legendary animal in farcry primal and they didn't mention that so they were false
I love that at 5:58 she's acknowledging that we don't have evidence of things, but that it's entirely possible we just haven't found it. Meanwhile most other people doing videos like this sit there and crap on it.
Yeah, that's the difference between a lifetime of studying subjects like this and just reading a Wikipedia entry about it. The former deals in likelihoods, which the latter assumes are proven beyond all doubt.
Honestly that was the only part that actually confused me since crocodiles are pretty much modern dinosaurs. Unless she meant humans hunting them, in which case I should've watch tgis before smoking a J
@@JennyGormanRitter I think she was referring to the crocodiles being in Europe as implausible, rather than the crocodiles being around somewhere in the world at that time. Same situation as the Saber Tooth... right species, wrong location
Because they are women so aren't dominated by an urge to be a condescending jerk.
@@GeneralGrievousCISyeah, I believe by now they would have found SOME evidence for crocodiles being in Europe if there had been any. From what I recall, the latest known crocodiles to live in Europe was in Spain, and that was around 5,000,000 years ago - so it's more like extremely unlikely.
But I don't care in the sense of the game, they probably just used it because they had them in Far Cry 3 and 4 (I believe it's the exact same animation and model even)
i love how passionate this archeologist is
Historians react to Kingdom Come Deliverance
Funny thing about that game is many of the larger settlements in that game exist to this day and the monastery is still under construction.
One thing they're gonna say
"No crossbows?"
I think that would allow both of them talk about the game instead of one asking questions and the other leading.
Yes yes yes
They can't complain about the shitty gameplay if they don't play it
There was a female hunter in the group btw
On my playthrough there were like three females in the hunting party.
Yeah that was bs what they said
@@hotdogpepper8410the whole females were hunters at that time is another fishy claim. The only substantial evidence I could find was in Peru, and it’s still up in the air on whether the body was a female
And that axe she said about, was actually a club.
They need to go back to school
I once had a 48 pound lynx as a pet. Her name was Baby Cakes, best pet I ever had... Well except for all the furniture she tore up and she was VERY vocal when she came into heat. Broke my heart when she died, never had a pet since. Don't think I will again. I don't know if that counts as a "big cat" but she definitely was a power house of a animal.
ye dude lynx is a big cat
Smh
rip
I really feel the need to correct them, when they burst out laughing at the concept of a domesticated cheetah, while it's true big cats cant be bred into domestication they CAN be tamed and theres a huge difference
Thank you, totally agree these ladies are way off track when it comes to that one
@@lindaakesson8403 They were way off track on almost everything. These are clearly PC revisionists and not real experts.
Dude thank you was gonna say sum
@@DireHammer Yea felt a bit forced on some of it. Pretty sure Men did most of the hunting, maybe not all, but most.
Historian: No Pet Bears
People in Russia: You underestimate our power
*Sad Russian Noises*
You messed up the quote
@@manbat1011 no i didnt what're you talking about
Polish artillerymen:bruh
@@manbat1011 you don't doubt the people of motherland, commarade.
I absolutely *LOVE FARCRY PRIMAL* so much! What an amazing concept for a video game. I just wish we could keep adding to our village meaning more and more huts and all that are made.
I wish make a sequal i love this game and holds pretty good 2016 game
The concept and theme was perfect but the game was dull and repetetive. It could have been better as a linear game or a smaller dlc
@Rahat Zaman But there's the dude hitting his nuts...
I thought farcry primal was the only game with the radar when I forgot about farcry 4 and 3
And multiplayer
The lady said that the hunting party should have been mixed sex. One question: In all the primitive societies that still exist today (Africa, South America, Papua New-Guinea and so forth), is there any form of mixed sex hunting? The reason I ask is I have read a bit over the years about various such cultures (just for fun, no deep studies), and nowhere have I encountered anything like that. And to me, it makes sense. Women are valuable - they make more people. Why would you risk them if you didn't have to? The reason we find ancient skeletons of both males and females that show injuries is probably because the ancient hunter-gatherer life was kinda hard. Just a thought.
Looking at the hunter-gatherer societies that are left today you would actually find evidence of both, like the Aeta people in the Philipines where women and men hunt, or some tribes in africa where only men hunt. But you also have to bear in mind, that the cultures of the Paleolithic were incredibly diverse, that making statements like "Man the Hunter, Woman the Gatherer" would be incredibly simplistic and reductionist. And women are more valuable from a populational standpoint, but, in the situation of the game, where they "Kill the mammoth or we all die", would you really get rid of roughly 50% of your available manpower and skill?
@@GabrielSoares-qp1he How ironic that your comment is incredibly simplistic and reductionist. Sure women did hunt when there was no other possible way of avoiding it to survive. But at least somewhat stable tribes would never go on a hunt with a woman, that is so stupid, its absurd to even think of. Not only men are naturally more competitive and physically stronger to take down a prey, but women could not simply "go to hunt" while they are pregnant or have children to take care at home and chores like berries to gather, clothing to craft, food to cook. These "historians" are just another victims of left propaganda.
@@GabrielSoares-qp1heSo you think that back in the day Men would stay at home and take care of the Children and Women would go out Hunting.
Now don't fell Personally attacked.
But Personally to me, it really shocks me how peopel are even able to miss understand, really such core truths about Human Nature and the Core of Society.
In my tribe i would banish you. 😅
Yes, there were Sabre tooth cats in Europe. Different ones than the ones in America. But they absolutely were in Europe.
Yes agreed, big fail, much earlier than in America.
The one which they portrayed in far cry primal was Smilodon Populator which lives in south America. Yes there were sabertooth cats in Europe.
Yes indeed. Also there is a lot of evidence only men did the hunting and women the gathering. Seems like this women doesn't really know her stuff.
Well, there were "sabretooth" cats in Europe, but not Smilodon and not in game period, but like 1 m.y.a. Megantereon
@@tiwaz4598 of course women hunted in the ice age dude lmao, many tribes in modern times have women as hunters so why not then? Besides when you're hungry whoever's good at hunting hunts, simple as that😂
Actually, there were saber toothed cats in europe. The last specimen of a sabertoothed cat named homotherium latidens was found to be only 28‘000 years old...humans deffinetly met them in europe.
True but the game takes place in 10,000 BC so it wouldn't have existed in that time period regardless
@A crying burrito it is BCE
@A crying burrito BC used to mean "before christ". But the atheists changed it to "before current Era " or bce
nah no need to correct a historian.
@@yyg4632 I didn‘t correct anyone per se, just wanted to add some info for the people interested. Also she is an archeologist not a historian. Saber toothed cats were found across the world and that‘s a simple fact. They were no saber toothed cats in europe at 10000 bc, that‘s true but scimitar toothed cats like homotherium were deffinetly a „europe thing“ aswell. She was probably refering to smilodon with saber tooth cat which were mostly a north america thing although two of the three species, including the biggest one were found in south america aswell. Like I said. I wasn‘t correcting her since she didn‘t state anything wrong, I was just elaborating and adding some info
Wonder how they'd do with Assassin's Creed-
I was just about to comment this lmao
Surprisingly not that good since assassin’s creed isn’t as historically accurate as you’d think
@@obamium9692 actually Assassin's Creed has some historical truth to it but mostly historical fiction
@@James-ru7nz yes I know that ac has some historical accuracies but there are some major fuck-ups in there
For example, the plague doctor outfit thing was supposed to be invented nearly a century after the events of AC2 but instead it’s just there
@@obamium9692 What do you mean man? The bubonic plague which happend in 1290 or something made the doctors that time wear that outfit. It continued until the end of Reniessance.
I would really love to see historians react to Battlefield1 or/and Battlefield V.
Just BF1, BF5 isnt even real ww2, just some kind of futuristic punk and females on main front
@@alekksu4293 I mean the guns, vehicles and even some map is almost accurate. The Rotterdam map for example is really good, it can represent a city before and after the carpet bombers. Or the single player campaigns had a lot of historycal accurate (Bf1 of course, but The Last Tiger too).
Scratch BFV, that game is just a feminist fantasy.
BF1 though it's great.
ww 1 full auto weapon everywhere
@FBI Guy You mispelled it, change it to *World At War.
Women: No bears as pets
Wojtek the bear: Am I a joke to you?
To be far, Wojtek evolved into a Soldier, not a pet, lol. But good call mate.
@@BaronNate yeah, a soldier who worked for booze🤣
the girls: no one hunts mammoths alone
Steve when he got a mammoth mod:
These "professionals" were actually pretty annoying ngl
Do Medic reacts to Rdr2 injuries.
That’s already been done
As much as I hate buzzfeed, they did that a long time ago
@@mr.derpknight2272 why do you hate buzz?
@@DriversofLondon I don’t hate all the buzzfeed channels, (gaming being one that I actually sometimes enjoy watching) but a lot of that channel is gender oriented and it’s weird and unnecessary
ruclips.net/video/6DYwvuQKHMc/видео.html
Here you go
Alternative title: two girls reacting to me and the *BOIZ*
Bad title
Ok?
@@skell6134 i still like it lol
I remember when I played this game it was mostly me riding a bear lol
@@skell6134 good title
That was an absolute fucking legendary video. I loved this so much. They're so full of charisma, and they know how to [NOT] take this so seriously, and understand that is a game. I really wish to see them more around here.
true
I'm so happy you guys and girls at Gamology included these two amazing historians into the channel! Historians react has sooo much potential
yea and they included more too its a cool series
taker gets attacked by bite fish the historians "is he fishing"
Takar not taker
Yes and he is the bait, LOL
@@nadiamasri7250 Takkar*
Chris Hansen reacts to Predator: Hunting Grounds.
Hahaha
Heheheh
this is probably my second favourite far cry game (after 3)
Same rll good game from 2016
Also correct me if I'm wrong I'm pretty sure only neanderthals in that period had women and men hunting while our ancestors were mostly hunter-gatherers. this was because neanderthals hunted only big game while our ancestors hunted and harvested wild plants. which is why theythen decided to split labor between sexes
You're probably right
@Yo Momma well I'm saying this because she never specified she just said some tribes and does it say on google if its our ancestors, or is it the neanderthals because that's what I want to make sure of.
I’ve heard my entire life the typical hunter gatherer. Since when were women hunting with men?
@@aeternavictrix7861 lil
@@aeternavictrix7861 lol
"Bears don't make good pets"
Russians: Hold my vodka
Dr. Lacy is so cool! She teaches at my university and it’s always fun listening to her talk about her research in the Paleolithic era
This was actually a pretty fun, albeit short, game. Taming wild animals and learning about the evil tribes was awesome.
Also Dah deserved better 😤
Historians react to Red Dead Redemption 2.
Since Earth isn't 30,000 years old, it would make more sense for them to use less speculation, and something where more forensic evidence and documentation actually exists, and compare / contrast based on that. Red Dead lends itself well to this.
Historians react to Kingdom Come: Deliverance could be very interesting, sice the red dressed woman knows about the Medieval Period
Yessir I’m about to buy that and this game this week I have the whole AC collection and Ghost of Tsushima and Red Dead 2
4:39 she’s clearly a Karen lmfaoo
“Oh is he fishing?”
No the fish is- humaning?
I’ve always been interested in history, myself. Specifically pre-gunpowder weapons history. Granted my knowledge of the subject is amateurish at best, but still.
I'm more of a war kind of guy I know alot of ww2 and quite a bit about ww1 but primitive that is one of my best subjects
@@Chris-H02 yeah, history in general is pretty cool.
I mean, for some reason I’ve always had a lot of questions, with the history of various civilizations. Especially in the Americas, prior to Columbus ‘discovering’ them, since all we really have to go on is word-of-mouth traditions and archeological/paleological remains.
Classical Antiquity, the Golden age and the Bronze age is important and really cool to learn about. Those are our ancestors and forfathers. They were absolute badasses too.
It was tuff
Architects react to Bloodborne.
Lady in the right: Explains a lot of things.
Lady in the left: *agree and laugh at random moments*
10:50 she actually nailed it, love how much work the Ubi team put into the details
The pets in game are not domesticated. They are just conditioned and have a dependency on a certain caveman. Thats real behavour that happend
Yes, I am glad you pointed this out
Not to mention even in modern day we see tons of wildcats and bears being conditioned and some even raised by a person who then become domesticated enough to see them as their family, literally everything has been.
@@raionshishi8290 Flashback to the dude with 17 tigers owning a tiger farm
yeah but would they have the balls to approach a bear that is taller than them on it's four legs and give it food
@@debildebilov7504 Am, they had the balls to hunt mammoths.....
2:18 is it eating the rabbit or giving it a comforting hug lmao
*They Are Snuggling*
"Bears dont make good pets"
Me:well you see they are just fluffy gigantic dogs and many like gigantic and furry dogs
It always be like that: 2 Experts are invited, one does the talking, the other one just sits there.
Have the historians react through Assassin's Creed from start to current year Assassins Creed game. And make sure to tell them about the history of Ubisoft claiming to be 'historically accurate' about their games.
At 3:54 where she talks about the conference where mammoth meat was served, it turns out that was inaccurate. The conference in question was actually in 1951 and indeed a mysterious “prehistoric meat” was served. Later it was determined that the meat in question was green sea turtle meat advertised differently for fun.
Far Cry Primal was so underrated.
It is too expensive. I want to play it but shitty price for a short game.
@@TheLudwigWan 50 bucks for a 2016 game is nuts.
@@sneezebiscuits7239 Yep. And only singleplayer. BOOM.
Best Far Cry in my opinion.
Agreed.
Historians react to WW2 games?
It's mostly true that Cave Bears were vegetarians but recent revaluation of bones say that they were more herbivorous than most bears nowadays, but they were still omnivores.
Yeah that's most likely the case.
Even the giant panda eats meat from time to time cave most likely did too
3:04 - 3:10 I’m not sure either but I do think it’s more than probable that they did have natural forming dreads, since this type of hair style doesn’t require any maintenance for it to curl and naturally form dreads
8:44
Sarah: So Dogs are probably the first animal that we domesticated
Wolves During the Ice Age: *Am I A Joke To You?*
please keep bringing them, their commentary is fascinating!
Pets a cute kitty
Expert lady: Probably NOT
AM I JOKE TO YOU !
Still waiting for cavemen react to far cry primal.
Same
Most of the historic evidence is underneath the water unless they're also divers. There weren't only migrating hunter gatherers in that time period. They had villages, temples, boats, advanced fishing traps.
You may not have sabre-toothed cats in 10,000 BC, but sabre-toothed cats, a lot different to the North and South American smilodon, were living in Europe during the ice age. Evidence has been found in the North Sea.
8:40 say that to Russia my dude
In america they get dogs
In mother russia we have bears
@@rexflamevermillion5527 Конечно братан
@@rexflamevermillion5527 In UGANDA we have elephants 😎
2:00
-Oh it’s the saber-toothed tiger
-But we’re in Europe
(Laughs) 😂😂😂
Oblivious people who didn’t get it: 🤔
Yeah, I like that they mentioned people in the upper Paleolithic living on a strict diet of meat being beyond absurd. They were omnivorous just like us. In fact, most historians would agree that game meat was more of a treat. A steady diet of fruits, berries, fungus and fish is far more realistic, as they were more abundant resources, and didn't share the likelihood of loss of manpower as something like a mammoth hunt. Also, as they mentioned, the preservation of meat, even with their adapted immune systems, would have proven problematic, because rancid meat is rancid meat no matter your immune strength.
You realize there are more animals than mammoths? Don't think anyone's dying hunting a squirrel.
4:55 I'd like to see a citation for that claim. I think it may be true about neanderthal but all recent hunter gatherers had division of Labor and at some sites like Malta in Siberia and Ohalo in Israel we have evidence of men's and women's spaces.
From my understanding the game take place within the last few hundred years of the last ice age. Hell your tribe still lives in a cave in the beginning. So I imagine those divisions of labor still haven't taken hold.
2:04 actually we have found big cats quite similar to sabers around europe still about 300,000 years too late though also cave bears lived in russia snow leopards are also in this game those live in china all around bot like a single prehistoric animal in this game is in the right spot at the right time except mammoths
Snow leopards live in Canada too
I'm not sure why you guys called this "Historians React." The age primal takes place was pre-history so it should really be "archaeologists react" or "anthropologists react." One of them was an archaeologists which makes sense but the other is out of the loop when it comes to this topic. However this "Historians react" has a lot of potential!
It is history tho
@@ludvikholden3103 lol if ur going full “technically” on it. But u could even see that the non-archaeologist/anthropologist didn’t know what to say. That’s a shame and she should be used to analyze the history of other video games
@@FireShoxx maybe, bur we still learns about it in history classes in Norway. And you could say the same thing about the roman empire... or anything else
@@ludvikholden3103 the difference between the Roman Empire and 20,000 years ago is the Roman Empire had writing. When ur approaching history it’s fairly different when ur looking into an age that only has the archeological record to go off of. Although both are history, both have their own field of experts because analyzing each is so much different
@@ludvikholden3103 and of course those fields inter-lap but they’re different enough that they should be separate
Well, there was sabertoothed cats in late Pleistocene in Europe, in the northwestern mostly, it was Homotherium latindens. They could have seen humans but probably they gone extinct far before 10K ago. But homotheriums didn`t have such a giant canines as smilodons did (and as depicted cat did too) who were truly endemic to Americas.
I love this since I relate to them on an academic level. Studying Anthropology and watching those who studied before me makes me happy.
It's interesting how historians have so much knowledge based completely in guesswork and yet seem so sure they're correct because it's commonly accepted.
Its not based completely in guesswork. Take forensics for example. Scientists can glean facts based on evidence. Forensic anthropology does this.
@@andrewschort724 That just makes it an educated guess.
All science is best guess, thats why its the best method of figuring things out we have ever created as a species 😁
@@zakbrown676 I guess you aren't smart.
@@zakbrown676 History isn't science, and anthropology is at best on the intersection of humanities and science. It's why we in the humanities are a cesspool right now where postmodernism flourishes.
Man: **Gets eaten alive by giant salmon**
Girls: *fIsHiNg?*
Other men:NOTED
This was great thanks ladies! You were great!
Do Historians react to the Assassins Creed Franchinse
This was so much more informative than any history class I've ever taken during school
You clearly never attended any sort of post-secondary educational institution, then..
Typical american.
I also read about Otzi the Iceman and they say that his entire digestive system was still intact and the scientist could actually see what he ate before he died. A theory on his death was (because he had a bear skin cap with/on him) that a tribe member/a rival tribe shot him by accident thinking he was a bear. He is also believed to have been a shaman or healer of some sort because he carried around anti biotics which were not commonly found with primitive people's
?
@@user-ye9bc7nw2c Look up "Otzi the Ice man"
@@GLITCHED1 ok
9:15 actually it's shown that cave men used and native Americans used deer hide and antlers as a form of camouflage so they can get closer to there prey without spooning there prey
3:57 I'd totally risk getting poisoned if it ment I could be one of the few people on the planet who gets to eat the meat of an extinct species
2:10 They did exist in Europe though.
These two are my favorite professionals so far!
Well, they were hunting Mammoths, men are physically stronger than women biologically, so while the women might be helping with things like ancient deer, or defend from wolves that arrows and spears need less strength to kill, while a mammoth needs far more strength to be pierced.
Tell me now how these "experts" never heard about these saber toothed cat species that lived in europe:
Eusmilus bidentatus
imravus brachyops
Albanosmilus jordani
Barbourofelis fricki
Prosansanosmilus
Homotherium latidens
Metailurus
Machairodus aphanistus
M. pseudaeluroides
Machairodus palanderi
Megantereon cultriden
Dinofelis aronoki
Dinofelis barlowi
Dinofelis cristata
Dinofelis darti
Dinofelis diastemata
Dinofelis paleoonca
Dinofelis petteri
Dinofelis piveteaui
Paramachairodus maximiliani
Proailurus lemanensis
Pseudaelurus quadridentatus
"No one's hunting mammoth by themselves."
My crazy ass: *ahem*
Edit: No, seriously. I've hunted about 6 young mammoth and 2 elder by myself. Yes, I did get yeeted a few times. Pro tip: Throw your spear, clubs, shoot your bow. Just use range.
Why did I think you were talking about real life 😂
@@fartedididnot3685 fr man
Mammoth extincted so ur lying
@@nadiamasri7250 I mean Far Cry Primal you baffoon
2:46 Ironic how they said "by themselves" together
Historians react to kingdom come deliverance. That game has so much accuracy its insane
''No one hunts mammoths by them selfs'' me proceeds to hunt a pack of mammoths by myself with a bow..
"Crocodiles didn't exist"
Crocodiles first appeared 95 million years ago.
In centric Europe 10 000 yrs ago?
@@weronikak47 They were in Europe about 5 million years ago.
@@insertjokehere212crocodiles are not warm blooded and this is right after pleistocen
@@weronikak47 I literally looked it up. Crocodiles lived in Europe 5 million years ago.
@@insertjokehere212 Yes, but not 10 000 yrs ago
8:36 "no bears as pets" *Russia will remember that*
Real early hominids reacts to Ancestors: The Humankind Odyssey
Professional demons react to Demon Soul
Now see,we wouldnt be this obvious, wed plant a seed for a job like a writer or artist, then slowly whisperer doubts when the debt inevitably sets in until you sell your soul
“Bears don’t make good friends” thinks of that one guy that has a bear as a pet
2:36 They are showing footage of neanderthals. Neanderthals went extinct in europe between 35.000 to 50.000 years BC. The game is taking place 13.000 years BC. Nice one editors, really backing up the historians.
1:23
WAIT we had pockets then?
let me guess next one gonna be scientists react do bioshock
Love historians, please make more videos with historians.
Sarah is adorable and it is so awesome seeing how excited she gets to share her knowledge with us. i love history and get the same way talking about american history (1600s-1800s). i hope to be that knowledgeable one day
In hunter/gatherer societies, the vast majority of food was gained via the gatherers. More often than not, hunts were unsuccessful for varying reasons. However, when a hunt was successful, the amount of food and materials (bone, sinew, pelts, etc.) gained was immense.