If killing is so bad, why do carnivores exist at all? || Acharya Prashant (2021)

[@AcharyaPrashant]

To contact the Foundation: acharyaprashant.org/enquiry?formid=210
Online courses on Upanishad and Life: solutions.acharyaprashant.org

[@tapanactivist5644]

COMPASSION IS THE UTMOST FLOWERING OF HUMAN UNDERSTANDING.

[@frankybarrez2113]

He’s not only saying what I want to hear he’s saying it very passionately

[@HaTiM-hp3mu]

He answered nothing, you are a fool and he made you stupid 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@bhoot786]

I should avoid, what is avoidable, superb. 🙏🍁

[@Nileshpandey0907]

The question was very good. And acharya ji explained in a absolutely great way🙏

[@maramandan100]

The question was - "Why there is carnivores?" . God could have created all life vegetarian. But he didn't. Why? The more sensible answer would be God didn't care at that point. He just was just enjoying the process of creation and the sustainability of life.

[@googlesings9938]

In plants the fruits are always the part of the plant that it doesn't need,
if a man doesn't take that fruit it will eventually fall on the ground by itself! We as humans need to understand this basic difference as learnt in 4th standard! Will you eat animal excreta?
Vegetarianism should definitely be a way of life irrespective of religion🙏

[@bbhmm5714]

Being VEGAN is the only way out.
Vegetarianism has made India a top exporter of beef!

[@daraiusdubash]

Who is killing? If the lion is killing, then it is one thing. But if man is killing, then it is a totally different thing.
The question relates to the killer, not killing per se.
The lion kills the deer, the lion had no option. The lion is programmed to kill the deer. The lion kills the deer.
The lion is not programmed to practise compassion. And if the lion will not kill the deer, the lion will die.
If man compares himself to a lion or a wolf, then he is debasing himself.
When I eat the grass or the reddish or the apple, violence is still involved. But I am helpless.
If you won't kill a living being, then you won't survive.
Even as I step on the floor, something is getting killed. I cannot avoid it. But I should avoid what is avoidable. Killing an animal is avoidable. I should avoid it.
Even the purest vegetarian or vegan is committing some level of killing. Keep it to a minimum. Keep it to a level that is unavoidable.
When you eat meat, your are doing damage to both your consciousness as well as your body.
If you want to be vegan without being spiritual, you will not be able to remain vegan for long.

[@Aston_martin69]

Question still remains the same why carnivorous exist ?

[@user-rb1ri2tx5u]

Are we so stupid that couldn't understand the simple thing,that we are human baba....,why aren't we trying to be atleast?

[@rdx1972]

The question is why God make things like this why God make carnivorous
Aisa bhi to ho skta tha ke God sbb ko vegetarian hi bnata

[@samarthadhikary7962]

It’s ecological balance. If all animal were vegeterian, they would overrun the planet and there would be no food source which would ultimately result in killing each other to get it. Carnivores exist to control the number of herbivores in the planet.

[@Aston_martin69]

​@@samarthadhikary7962bhai wohi to question hai bhagwan ne aisa design hi kyu kiya hame ki meat nahi khaye to balance bigad jaye

[@Sagar-wn1po]

The underlying premise of argument is that killing a higher consciousness is wrong when we option of killing something with lesser consciousness. But how this argument is true? What's the logical reasoning. My reason of avoiding meat is climate change. Meat food leads to higher carbon emissions and live in fertile gangetic plains (Haryana precisely), i get all nutrients necessary through veg plate at my home. So i avoid meat. But had i been a resident of coastal area or Island where fishes or other animals are easily available to kill compared to deforestation to produce crops (and it is also not sure that i would be able to grow sufficient crops) , is it correct to eat fishes or meat then?

[@nitishpandey6624]

Pranam Acharyaji 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@tussh2016]

The question is why carnivores and humans are designed like that why God gave them the urge to eat meat ? Herbivores don't have this urge and they don't kill others still they are killed by carnivores. Why they have to suffer?

[@uttam2274]

Very simple and to the point answer - because this world was not created with that purpose which we think of. I should not even talk about its creation in the first place. I'm not so sure about Big Bang, but one thing is for sure that this universe exists for no humane reason, rather for scientific reason. Because you can get nutrition from ingesting the flesh of some animals doesn't mean that was there for you. It's just matter of time, proper conditions, due to which all of these stuff exist.

[@manishmaurya1]

It feels good, if you are already vegetarian 😊😊

[@Mojud_Zikr]

Please be Vegan

[@bbhmm5714]

Plz GoVegan 🌱🌱
Because of vegetarianism India is the top beef exporter in the world

[@voiceofvegans]

There is another angle.
At the level of consciousness that animals and above operate at - they have subjective awareness and ability to feel pain and suffering. This means they have interest in not getting suffering. And protection of this interest is their Right. Hence when humans get involved in killing and using animals they violate animal Rights.

[@rajneeshifollower811]

Pranam acharya shree

[@learnshotdose50]

That's the video I want ❤️

[@dexterslaboratory1272]

Acharya ji do you think Mohammed was a demagogue who destroyed many generations

[@learnshotdose50]

Please dubbed this video in Hindi.
Request sir.
For more awareness 🙏

[@Sagar-wn1po]

Hindi me bhi vegetarian par kaafi videos hai.

[@rhopalocera5160]

Why god created carnivores

[@madhavjha1]

We should consider consisious not our desire...

[@nirajpatil9040]

🙏🙏 Keep it to a minimum , we need to choose which biological form I am eating

[@unknown-sk6ip]

Mere paas ek swaal haii. Ki insaan ko non vegetarian nhi hona chahiye to koi mujhe bata sktaa hai ki kyaa kya agr iske pichhe logic hota to god hme khud vegetarian bna deta pr unhone omnivorous kyu banayaa @AcharyaPrashant

[@riyasreebiswas759]

Thank you so much sir u literally explained all my doubts and now I'm all cleared with the view

[@bad2486]

Sir please give this same video in Hindi language also.

[@SunilKumar-uz9oc]

Similar video already available.
Most recent one is titled 'प्यार से दुर्व्यवहार'

[@JaySehgalMusic]

Follow Acharya Prashant Hindu Channel as well.

[@fr.sxtyxm]

@@JaySehgalMusic arey Bhai aap idhar ? Kaise ho, gaaney nahi aa rahe

[@kishantiwari2555]

🙇🙏

[@kishan2k21]

Right. Spirituality should be the first step to reach veganism. Without it, the movement will fail at some point of time.

[@saurav_advait]

⭐ If you are Spiritual, how will you decide to slaughter consciousness itself? The reason why Veganism is not very successful worldwide and especially in India is because it has no Spiritual moorings. Without a strong Spiritual base, Veganism is bound to fail.
⭐ True Spirituality necessarily begets compassion.

[@ravivyas2285]

Neem ka pipal ka or wath ka tree 🎄 Lagao oxygen bhdawo

[@devanshnarvariya5059]

Go vegan 😍😍😍

[@viveksingh8194]

Go spiritual, veganism would follow

[@subhashkunwar7172]

,🙏🙏

[@mr.explorer7628]

Suppose If anybody killed your brother who had many disabilities like deaf, dumb & blind ,Would u try to compensate and convince the judge to reduce the punishment of killer orr u plea for more punishment for killer then normal case . Life needs life for surviving that's okk. The above idea is given by an famous scholar , at ground level I don't like such talks .so please proceed 🙏🏼😊

[@ANTICHRIS619]

Zakir Naik doesn't know a thing about spiritual...he doesn't even understand khuran properly

[@srimatidas4277]

We need to have a real spiritual movement... Without a strong spiritual base veganism is bound to fail

[@bbhmm5714]

Absolutely.
People are lacking spirituality hence the World is a mess today!!