Reacting to Attack on Titan's Fan Made Ending || Attack on Titan no Requiem
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 май 2021
- We shall see how this goes
139 Analysis :
• Attack on Titan's Endi...
Links:
Personal and Art instagram
/ faeleur
/ faenova_
redbubble store:
www.redbubble.com/people/faernova
*E-mail me for inquiries about bookings, commissions, and collaborations.
mccaffreymartone@gmail.com 
Кино
![Eminem - Houdini [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/22tVWwmTie8/mqdefault.jpg)
So Eren telling Zeke :
“If someone is willing to take my freedom away, I won’t hesitate to take theirs. Father didn’t make me this way. I have always been like this since the day I was born.”
was nothing but a big fat lie? Why would he lie to Zeke in paths? What is the benefit of him lying to his brother in Chapter 121.
No , it wasn’t a lie but neither is the rest of the story either. That’s not the only aspect of who he is and what he fights for
@@McCaffreyMelon fair. He also fought for his friends. I just wish he valued freedom more than anything. The number one core theme of Attack on Titan.
@@morganadays3530 And the concept freedom was completely lost in the original last chapters.
@@morganadays3530 To say it was THE number one thing in Attack on Titan ? I dunno about that. And as the OP of this video put beautifully and what everyone seems to ignore, Eren is not just one thing. He can be all of the things we've seen.
Y'all not enjoying My War Opening theme?
Zeke's victim blaming mentality felt perfectly in character to me, keep in mind that his solution for ending the hatred between Eldians and non-Eldians was to force-sterilize his own people and have them die out.
Yeah. In the original it contradict Zeke's motive cus he was admiring having baby infront of Armin but now he says maybe the reason is survival and finding meaning
you're right, it's definitely in character after looking back at it
It's actually started after 136 😆 In my honest feedback.
AnR Part 1 is better than 137. 😆
The reason why people hate the 139 eren
there was no build up eren isn't a hero in traditional sense as he genocides the rest of the world to save his people.131 already humanised him.It is not simply That "he cuck not chad we mad" it came out of nowhere and incredibly forced.This is his natural progression from innocent kid to moody teenager set on revenge to breaking down in S3 part one to regaining motivation then realising everything was a lie and learning the truth to stohic flawed man doing what he can to protect his people though it morally wrong.Not devolving into a crybaby to a bird then a tree lol.hope you guys understand:)
Im happy you liked the ending. Me personally its drove me up the wall.
I also like the fact that you disagree with what what AOTnoRequiem is going with as of now, but being respectful all the same.
I personally hated the ending, but never once cheered or contoned any of the hate Isayama or his publication has gotten. Isayama's story is his story, but fanfiction writers and artist alike can go about whatever they want. AOTnoRequiem team even stated as much saying: This isnt for everyone.
I personally dont know why more mangaka dont license out their work for royalties for stuff like this. That would be cool for any story in my book.
I have high hopes for the chapter. This was only the first 20 pages but it already closed up a lot of plotholes from the original. But I'm sure they will still maintain Eren's emotional side
If they give Eren more dimension then I will like it more
@@McCaffreyMelon I'm confident since I follow the creators on Twitter and they love erens break down in 131
As you said, the writing and conversation is somewhat off..
Yes it is.
I think that's normal since they're not 'real' mangaka (they have jobs and school duties) so yeah..
And why the original ending needs to be defended? AnR team stated multiple times that it is just fan fiction..
Yaa 7:27 we better read it as AU from the original ending, the ending where ANR happens (since the original ending is reverse anr)
Eren here is still acting evil (that's what I get)
So, hmm as Kaiki Deishu said:
"The fake is of far greater value. In its deliberate attempt to be real, it's more real than the real thing".
Anr fanmade is not trying to be real..
So no matter how great it is or how much people like it.. it's just fanfic afterall.. :D
Love you All ♥️
Ahhh I'm sooo happy you posted gurl I've missed your smiling face and I loved your vlogs gurl and you are sweetheart
No requiem is amazing 🙀🙀🙀🙀
Don’t be a troll, m8
2:31 I mean anybody could guess what "freeing herself" means. Even her. It meant death, that's the entire REAL reason Ymir blocked the spear. Not because she loved the abusive bastard. She yearned for freedom, and what she learned through the creation of paths is that there is freedom in death, since she would be going to paths after she dies anyways.
Turned the likes and dislikes off cause she knows she's wrong
I’ll turn them back on when y’all realize that people have different opinions
@@McCaffreyMelon HAHAHAHA
@@McCaffreyMelon I you really believe in your own opinion you would keep the like/dislike on.
why u guys so worried about that? Omg u guys looks like kids, its her channel, she can do whatever she wants, at least she doesn't hide her face to express her opinion
@@matiasguzman7635 If she did it only for herself then why not private video? Its public video and I expressed my opinion which is why comment section is a thing in the first place. I love how people call you kid when they don't like someone opinion. btw I'm not even hate on her I just state the facts
any line of AOTnR: ---
Her: "doesn't make sense AOTnR......"
Lol
Love your video❤️ keep it up
Isayama definitely changed his course in the last chapters.
copy and pasted from another comment on AnR video :
Willy Tybur mentioned that their family built relationships with influential people around the world to IMPROVE SOCIAL STANDING OF ELDIANS.
Eren killed him just to turn Armin into a FAILED tybur with less connections.
Armin failed because the world still bombed Paradis.
Eren gambled the fate and future of Paradis,
and he lost.
He put all of the burdens and responsibilities on his friend’s descendants and the future generation of his people.
Which completely betrays one of the biggest themes of Attack on Titan.
I think
Karl Fritz and Tybur family was able to establish peace for 100 years
Thus the same was
Eren and Armin was able to establish peace for 150 or atleast 100+ years
Peace is not eternal and violence will always there in human nature
The main difference between karl Fritz and Eren is that the main priority of the king is the humanity on the other hand Eren was more concerned about the Eldians of Paradise and particularly his friends...
@@piyalidasgupta9500 agreed, whose to say when and why the next ww would happen. Humanity is a slave to war
and failed miserably
@@ArchiduquesaMA Who and How
@@piyalidasgupta9500 because paradise was destroyed if he rumbled entire world then his people would never have been destroyed the only thing that would happen was infighting between them but it's still way better than their entire race getting destroyed
armin is not hope he is naruto clone and unrealistic as a character he got what he wanted that is death of eldians at the end. All hail umi da. this is better written than chapter 137.
Yeah, Armin being hope was a glaring flaw that had no place in such a story. Armin didn't have to sacrifice shit to get anything in the end, nor did he do any real work, yet because he showed Zeke a leaf he gets the shifters help and Zeke kills himself?! Sorry that's just not good writing.
I love your voice
I believe you are reviewing this is in good faith so I want to clarify your doubts
2:24 that dialogue means, if she didn't chose to attach to life and created paths all this suffering could be avoided
5:52 CH131 still happened but that panel of him crying was back in Marley, after that Eren went to war and stayed in Marley for months, then attacked Libertio by himself. That emotional Eren is gone, no one can take his complexity away is just that his duality was gone once he started the Rumbling because realistically something that mayor CAN'T be half done, you have to be really commited.
Great video !
You SAID that eren season 4 is a facade? He did not pretend when he told his father with dead and serious eyes that he must kill innocent children and the founding titan to achieve a future. Here is another example as well. When eren talks to reiner in marley, eren's facial expressions were to realistic to reflect his character development. He accepts the fate and he abused an innocent child (falko) and transformed into a titan and was ready to kill falco and the family above eren who were listening to willy. How could this eren be in the end a crybaby who cares about unimportant stuff like mikasa after he killed 80% of humanity. dont think thats just hilarious? The eren in anr just accepts the reality. He abides to his character because he is focused only on his goal. And erens rumbling goal in anr is also better.
Anr rumbling results
-paradise is permantly safe from other nations
-historia was not sacraficed
-titans dont need to be removed from reality since only eldians are left
Anr rumbling cost
-100% outside paradise was killed
Isayama ending results
- paradise is temporarily safe
- titans are removed somehow Not explained at all?
-historia was not sacrafice
Isayama ending cost
-80% of humanity is dead
-eren dies
Therefore the results and costs in anr rumbling are more advantageous for the sake of paradise. Thats why eren decides to go for the 100% rumbling plan in anr, because he is not stupid and selfish enough to do a rumbling ONLY FOR HIS FRIENDS.
Like the original ending as well. It makes more sense to me.
SIGNS THAT EREN LOVED MIKASA?!?! yea AS A SISTER and they had no chemistry you know who did HISTORIA THEY WERE BOTH THE SAME PERSON
Read AOT 1-136 stop at AoTnR (Attack on Titan no Requiem) How does it feel reading to flipping endings.
I hated the end and that same day I block everything that has to do with SNK.
One day in ING they published the extras and I saw so many annoyed people, I just come back to laugh at the situation.
And there I found out about this Fanmade and GOD, thank you they returned my love for SNK.
I know it is not Canon but for me it will be and I will omit 137-138 and 139.
Zeke's always disliked people not giving up on their life. In his mind, i think, it's so that they and the ones they inspire suffer less in the end. Wich applies to Ymir 'the slave' ...and yes it's pretty victing blamey.
Example: Like when he thinks about the scouts led by Erwin in their reckless charge
Like 6 Bang Bang happy Monday ♥️
All things are temporary only GOD EREN YEAGER IS ETERNAL .
Simp eren is temporary
God eren is eternal
Why like and dislike are turned off ?
She knows what's coming
@@bander-Coolb haha yeah people aren't happy. y'all can still dislike it if you want, i just don't care to see it for now
@@McCaffreyMelon why hide like and dislike ?
@@KIRA-cn8hi Because she's a coward
I think that in paths only the consciousness of Eldians is shifted...
Then how the child Eren and the Adult Eren exists at the same time...
But the art is really good
I believe what they were trying to convey was adult eren was talking to his kid self in the paths telling him all that he needed to do to complete his future objective hence why he said you won’t remember any of what I’m telling you until the time is right,( when he kissed historias hand) but you will still feel a yearning for freedom. And adult eren told him it would feel like a long dream.(when eren woke up under the tree at the beginning) he was just setting his past self on the course.
@@partyfitnessexperience3857
He can also do this by only sending memories of future to his past self...
Two consciousness of the same person can not exist at the same time...(not even in ther original story)
@@piyalidasgupta9500 they aren’t existing at the same time this conversation he’s having with kid eren is just imagery of what adult eren is sending to him through the paths. Kid eren isn’t physically there just his consciousness.
Its actually better than the original chapter. It closed lot of plot holes. The original chapter just contradict Zeke's motive. And maybe Eren acting infront of Armin. And in chapter 137 he was still acting, it was only revealed in chapter 139 that Eren was still a cry baby. I bet you were thinking that too when you read the original chapter 137. But here you r mocking them. Its just part 1. Same thing Isayama did. He showed chad Eren till chapter 138 and in Chapter 139 he completely changed it. You can't just mock their first chapter. You r just a show off fan who thinks that Original ending was great but it wasn't.
Give them time, its after chapter 131 and don't compare it to ORIGINAL chapter 137 cus its completely different. I will give them time and I think they will give Eren different side to. He is just putting a facade just like he did in the og but you get to know this in chapter 139. And you r saying it in part 1 lol.
Loved the video, I agree with you, good work!
thank you
No no no, this is canon now. Don’t care what anyone says, original was to soft. Original was a shit show.
Original was a masterpiece
THIS is a shit show and it's disrespectful af
The ending was pure poetry
Imo Isayama actually don't know his characters no offense but after the ending that's what I feeled
His characters acted differently than you thought they would so that means he’s wrong about his own characters ?
@@McCaffreyMelon Sorry no hating, in chapter 130 or 131. I kinda forgot, Eren said something like "I'm gonna destroy them, every last one of those animals". In chapter 139, he said that he will only kill 80% of the population outside Paradis. To me, It felt that Eren faked his own inner monologue. Why would a character do that ? Correct me if i'm wrong, just wanna hear your thought
@@yup7380 ikr also worth mentioning is that he was always an Edgy character since nine years old when he killed those two people without hesitation in cold blood to save Mikasa. That look on his eyes also said it too. I’m tying it back to this fanmade version because he had the exact same look as that time in the cabin when he was taking to his kidself about Ymir not being free yet.
@@cs6011 True, this is just my opinion but my problem with chapter 139 is that Eren's character development was just a mask. In truth, he doesn't really know what he is doing. I'm not going to trash on Eren's character, but if you compare it to Lelouch who had development not as much as Eren but still significant which is that he is using himself as the sacrificial pawn. Not just a king who takes the first step but also willingly to be sacrificed. That development wasn't a mask. His mask is his dictator persona.
Neverthless AoT still hold a special place in my heart. Right now, I'm curious whether this no requiem ending will get better or not.
@@McCaffreyMelon he destroyed his own characters arcs and leave more plot holes than a cheese
Exactly
Ur voice is so sweet hearing u talk about aot is so mesmerizing 😌😌
Thank you so much !
I´m late but IDC because I watched the video. Noice keep up the nice work.
But still I support this fan made ending 😁😁😁
Interesting reaction. By the way, I highly recommend you should react to the masterpiece fan animations created by Kane Pixels about the parts of the manga that have not yet been adapted to anime. Kane Pixels's channel: ruclips.net/channel/UC8X4WT5_lUXqMjeN8bGFk9w
I also think you should react to this next fanmade trailer for the second part of the final season, especially since its creator has achieved the closest thing to the audio of Yuki Kaji (Eren's seiyu) when Eren apologizes to Ramzi: ruclips.net/video/uN5vmDcmkB8/видео.html
First of all they already disclaimed that they are not trying to be an alternative Canon ending.
They have been emphasizing that this is a FAN made ending like every fanfic
Second, Isayama in his after thought interview already said he has some regrets when making this. Where he said he could not do a good writing afterall(imo a bad excuse even though we already have the masterpiece of the journey before the last Arc)
If he wanted to make the same ending we all know but needed more fleshing out? Or he wanted something similar to his original interview where he referenced the tragic ending of the mist?
Who knows. That's up to him.
Third, he clearly stated he was influenced in some of the major parts of where the direction of some of the characters should go. As he said the editors didn't like how tragic his original ending in mind was and how he shouldn't kill Sasha early on for example.
So no, it was not entirely what he wanted when he has regrets and clearly says he was influenced to a degree. Now he is moving on by getting what he wanted like the hotspring, making a parody of the story on a recent newspaper release, his profit and many more, so good for him at least.
And no, a fanfic claiming to only remain as a fanmade ending for people who want to see a what if scenario is no where disrespectful on under the logic that all fanfics are what if scenarios. In fact this is because they love the story and respect what Isayama made that gave way to their passion to make something like this, a what if scenario like many others.
It would only be disrespectful if the team making this says they want to be the alternative Canon ending for everyone to read instead of a fanmade what if ending. And many times over they emphasized the latter.
Now whoever enjoys this fanfic ending or hates it is subjective. Good for you if you love the original or the fanmade.
=====) =
And to those who just want to hate on other people cuz they disagree and have their own opinions, they can just shut up and suck on pacifiers because a Fandom should like what they enjoy not hate on people for being different. You are not a real fan if you hate someone for loving the original or fanmade ending, be civilized ffs.
The original to me feel empty of they action, it was more like "for" me they look more like people without a goal an the drastical change of character in the last chapter it was not pleasant, I like more the AoTNR ending that explore more they motive and action
My biggest gripe with this chapter is that it misunderstands the meaning of freedom as Isayama framed it. Leaving that aside, I hope they manage to create something satisfying
Not only that but they are making eren lack any other emotion. Specifically depression. Yes eren is angre boy but his character development was about him recognizing that the world is grey and it fk sucks but he has to bit the anyways even if he doesn't want to. I would have loved to see that shot but rather than eren just staring off in anger he looks down at his younger self, blind to the reality of the world. He looks in sadness and disappointment.
@@kurokamina8429 Yeah, I meant that too. I think that the fans who are disappointed with the ending think that freedom just means getting rid of any external factor that could possibly shackle you (concept that the immature Eren very much embodies). The eastern concept of freedom instead implies that one should accept his own limits and do his best to fulfill his destiny within them. AoT presents both sides of the coin when taken to the extreme (Floch - Zeke) but the answer is somewhere in the middle. After growing up Eren did mature a little and he understood that he could not just slaughter anyone in his way without remorse, which is why he goes for 80% instead of 100%
The freedom panel in 131 has been especially misunderstood, as his blurred eyes two pages later suggest, in that scene Eren is very much not free, but a slave to his own concept of freedom.
Sorry for ranting and going a bit off topic, I needed that out of my system lol
Just pointing out this is only part 1, yes it was a major info dump but I’m sure part will show more Eren emotions considering it’s gonna be with Eren and Armin
The point of No Requiem is not because they think they know better than Isayama they just want to give it a shot and make their own ending, fan fiction and fan endings have been around for a long time and it’s not like they claim their version to be the better or the cannon one, maybe you should do some research on who the creators are and what their reasoning is before running your mouth
Oh please, it's EXACTLY because they think they know Eren better. The whole thing was literally started out of spite.
It just didn't feel like aot anymore, it felt really..different. Kindof awkward
The ending or AnR?
@@mikle6652 Anr
People who like no requiem have this weird Chad Eren fantasy and I'm sure they're all teenage boys going through their edgy phase. Let them, they will mature some day and maybe come around, or they'll stay the same way and be redditors for their whole lives.
teenage but still mature enough to realize the ending was just garbage it was all for nothing paradise ended up getting destroyed anyway And the alliance were just stupid first of all the armin and eren talk was trash you have armin telling eren what he has done to mikasa really mikasa IN THE MIDDILE OF GENOCIDE you should be telling eren to not kill everyone but he wanna talk about mikasa AND EREN BECOMING A CRYBABY SIMP?!??!?! since when
True. I do like this more Chad Eren more than what I saw in the original (yeah, I’m an 18 year-old boy). But I’m not going to trash anyone who likes the original ending. If you like, you like it. Everyone’s got their own tastes when it comes to writing and or media. I just personally prefer AoTR’s portrayal of the last few chapters vs the original. Again, everyone is entitled to their own opinions. I think another main issue is that a good part of the AoTR fandom is taking this version of the ending as fixed/canon. I acknowledge this isn’t the canon ending and it won’t be
You think your really smart huh this is ur "opinion" but I deal with the"harassment" my way and that's my opinion.
People keep forgetting that Eren wasn't always chad. He was whiny, had anger issues and always had emotion outbursts.
And then he grew up. He learned that whining and being angry won’t get you what you want, and that you have to fight for it. That’s why his character development was so good, and that’s why taking it all back is so awful
@@mikle6652 he didn't take anything back. He showed that no matter how "chad" you are there will be a breaking point,there will be a point where your emotions will be overwhelming....
@@peggy5691 and the king slayer never really cared about the people
Aot has the most disrespectful fanbase I have ever seen. They think they know the story better than Isayama himself while it’s clear they understand nothing about the story itself.
I’m sorry no disrespect though but that’s pretty but it’s not disrespectful. How is this fanmade ending disrespectful when Kodansha itself markets fanfiction manga as free advertising😂😂 the story was also retconned to hell to please viewers like you but backfired completely. There’s proof with isayamas interviews and posts years before, so I recommend you go ahead and check that out buddy. Also how are we suppose understand a dark fantasy story that suddenly turned into a romantic out no where between a little slave girl who was raped and forced to bear children and falls in love with king pedofile which was the root cause of all this madness that’s happened. For two thousand years she been following the kings orders creating Titans because she loved him but can’t break free? And she led on this massacre so she can see someone break free of their own painful love? 80% of the world killed off and years later getting destroyed? The main character retconned as well as doing all that he did to ensure paradis’ safety and now it was all for nothing? A protagonist who was always edgy since the age of nine who killed 2 adults in cold blood and had been kept consistent ever since isn’t really an edgy character but just a crybaby? A protagonist suddenly crying like a baby cause he’ll die and he can’t get a girl he wants (note he didn’t even think about her in season 1 when he was in a Titans stomach about to die didn’t think of her once? The protagonist who led a Titan to his mom to eat her to stop another person from dying because it wasn’t their time yet (some say it was Ymir and if it is then that’s even more fucked up)? A romance between a protagonist and his step sister who had zero chemistry besides the end of season 2 that came out of no where? The protagonist not knowing why he did the rumbling but had too? I really didn’t mind his plan on saving his friends but he was retconned to hell. That’s not a good plot. It’s poor writing and I think i can critique something if I don’t like it. I can accept it but I can’t like it. This fanmade chapter had twenty pages and it answered most of the questions I had surprisingly. Anyone who likes the ending then like the ending, support it, or hate it go ahead. Everyone will respect the opinions of others but don’t say the fan base is disrespectful and we don’t know the story when the plots were there but drastically changed. I actually predicted that Eren would pull a lelouch ending but that way it was presented failed in my opinion. Anyway sorry for taking to much of your time and it you read all this thanks for taking the time to read it.
@@cs6011 there’s no way I’m reading that. But the reason it’s disrespectful is because most people refer to it as the fixed ending or the alternate ending, not a simple fan fiction. That’s the disrespect
@@cs6011 eren was never an edge lord he was always an over emotional mess from day 1. The anr ending flattened his character completely just to appease to the power fantasies of some fans. This ending also retcons zekes and Levi’s endings and probably armin and mikasa too. You can’t just assume you know the meaning of this story better than Isayama , he literally wrote it. You either understand it or you don’t…. Anyways chadren or what the jeagerists call him was always cringe and stupid, at least it was a facade
@@Birbatron it’s not the material that’s disrespectful it’s the fans’ attitude about it
@@inininin3901 stfu isayama don't even know his own story lol
🍓 I found it cringe just because I know who’s behind it.
AOT ENDING IS GRABAGE ARE U DRUNK LOL