first Russia had no fuel, then , russia had only two more days of ammunition, then, it will lose with himars, then, it will lose with all those tanks and stormshadow, then, the counteroffensive is going to crush them, then, it´s a stalemate ..., it´s all a great joke.. didn´t they have only two more days of ammunition?? people forget things tooo fast
It's so funny to hear the Western media now saying that Russia has greater capabilities.....But for a long time, they had been saying that Russia was fighting with shovels and had archaic weapons and artillery....😅
Don't mind the constant losers!! The strongest army in the world has proved her credibility by resisting NATO+ (51 countries combined!). USA cannot boast of defeating Russia in a one on one war less Ukraine that gets support. As of today, Russia has the most tested and effective armed forces way ahead of the USA!!!Don't mind the constant losers!! The strongest army in the world has proved her credibility by resisting NATO+ (51 countries combined!). USA cannot boast of defeating Russia in a one on one war less Ukraine that gets support. As of today, Russia has the most tested and effective armed forces way ahead of the USA!!!
its amazing how DW's tone has changed on this conflict over time...feels like someone's had a real wake up call to whats really happening on the ground and its really starting to show in the type and tone of stories they're releasing this last few weeks and months..
The fact is neither side can win with the evolution of drones, precision guided munitions, and WW1 style trench networks and minefields. Russia is gaining nothing economically, has depleted 50% of effective military equipment, and it's people watch Telegram and see thousands of Russian IFVs and tanks go up in flames.
The tone has changed as the war has changed, Russia was really struggling to have any impact for a long time, poor battlefield tactics repeated again and again, a lack of equipment, poor motivation from conscripted men etc.. However in time Russia has managed to fix some of these issues. Realistically a country with the resources and the political structure of Russia should have been able to take Ukraine quickly, and that has not happened. Causing immense reputational damage, damage that even if Russia manage to carve out some kind of victory will not go away quickly.
They are changing the narrative because they will stop supporting Ukraine. Russia has already won the war when they initiated a mobilization. Ukraine had no capacity to clear out the Russian held positions. They are now ‘mobilizing the army’ but so far everything we’ve seen is people getting snatched off the streets by vans in the night.
@@forgottenheritage2845 that's typical Russia. Nothing new. In all wars they struggle and stumble to start with. But eventually win in the end, one way or another.
War could have been avoided if only the Minsk Agreement had been implemented. Germany and France supported this agreement only until Ukraine was sufficiently armed.
NATO has not even entered the fight yet, time to send modern jets, but the USA needs Russia as an enemy to continue spending 700 Billion Dollars on arms to keep the Military Industrial Complex moving, as warned by President Roosevelt many years ago in the 1950`s.
I like how every expert says that they know exactly what Putin thinks and then we find out that he is still unpredictable. But then all internet warriors translate what the "expert" has said like it was Putin himself. Over time its become very entertaining to watch this theatre unfold. Its like USSR but other way around now.
Thats true. When putins lips move he is lying and when they don't he is thinking about lying so how can they Know? You are correct well done, well said, good for you.
What I find astonishing is that they never quote Putin. Because, you know... he's not exactly saying what they claim he says, especially irt negotiations.
And another point about sanctions and that not all companies have left Russia, the 2nd biggest number of international companies that have stayed and are still operating in Russia are *American*. Only 18% of all American companies in Russia have left. So its abit strange to state that friends of Russia in EU, such as Hungary and Austria, are not making sure that sanctions are followed. Most of western countries are not following sanctions against Russia. But by the looks of it sanctions have benefited Russia much more than those who implemented them. The funniest thing that Russian gas pipe going through Ukraine is still pumping gas to Europe. And Ukraine still gets paid for transition.
as Croatian President Mikanović said in a statement (referring to the German Minister of Foreign Affairs A. Baerbock) "we are not at war with Russia, and if the Germans are at war with Russia... I can tell them - good luck this time!"
What would have been so wrong if, at the beginning of the war, Ukraine had negotiated with Russia not to join NATO? 🤔 Are we OK now that hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian men have now died for Uncle Sam?
I know you're a russian troll but lets address that nonetheless. They did talk about that. But Russia lieerally broke every single treaty and promise it made and attacked regardless. Western people dont understand Russia. Its a country where promises and treaties mean literally nothing. No rules whatsoever. They will lie in your face and break any treaties whenever it benefits them. They will make treaties to benefit them and then break them when they deem it more benefical. Russia only understands military force. The best thing we can do for Russia is to help Ukraine liberate Crimea.
russia anyway would create genocide like they planned all together there is no negotiations with russia, they just playing with you, west audience like kids, so sad....
As there has not been one word mentioned by the Ukrainian military or in the Ukrainian media concerning age I wonder where this number has been plucked from and how accurate it is.
Not only has Ukraine lost soldiers, but it will also lose people from the annexed territories. Russia has lost soldiers, but the people on annexed land will more than make up for it, plus resources on that land.
Russia does not need the resources, only the West needs them. This is why the West interests in Ukraine intensified. aggressively. The real objective push NATO away from the order to destroy the Ukrainian army so it would not be a threat to the future of Russia's national security and free the people of the eastern regions that voted to stay with Russia. Putin has kept his promise.
The attitude of DW expert panels had changed from what it was a few months ago. They were predicting the defeat of Russia, now they are accepting Russian imminent victory
What happened to the 300,000 naf0 trained men? To the $100 billion dollar worth of military aid just only for the Counter offensive? What happened to them? 😂
@@Mr.Clownensky why is russia not in kiev. I thought russia was the second strongest army in the world, but they can't even defeat one of the porest countries in europe? 😅😅
@@frederikpedersen689 Ukraine poorest coutry? Lol, they just received $230 billion dollars worth of military aid from the west, thats 6x rusia's entire military budget, and you ask why Rusia having hrd time in Ukrain? 🤡, lol, remove that 200 billion, you think Ukrain will stand a chance? They wont even last a week without The West's support 🤡,
@@user-cv8xw8zn5u Even the best tanks are useless without air support - vulnerable against enemy planes and helicopters. To advance, they would have to gain air superiority first, hence F-16s.
if Russia wanted all of Ukraine i was gonna despatch +-4 Million Soldiers, since it was 90k, it means it wanted Ukraine to come to the Misks agreement and protect the Donbass area
😂😂😂 they could barely supply 200k (90k is a delusion), today ruSSia has well over a million troops in Ukraine. If ruSSia wanted Minsk 2 then why did they refuse to implement anything they agreed to and then refused multiple invitations by president Zelenskyy in 2019, 2020, and 2021 to sit down and discuss their issues with it (since they refused to implement sections 4, 9, and 10).
" warmongers in the west" So far as Ukraine is concerned, you appear to have invented a new meaning for the word - in your view a "warmonger" is a country which supports a country which was attacked by an imperialist invader.
@@matro2 Iraq - murderous dictator. Afghanistan - terrorist supporting nation which murdered 3500 with twin towers attack. Libya - dictatorship, citizens welcomed western support. Somalia - African Union peacekeepers get support from US. Syria - dictatorship, west is helping public fight for democracy. Ирак - диктатор-убийца. Афганистан - страна, поддерживающая террористов, которые убили 3500 жителей башен-близнецов. Ливия - диктатура, граждане которой приветствовали поддержку Запада. Сомали - миротворцы Африканского союза получают поддержку от США. Сирия - диктатура, Запад помогает населению бороться за демократию.
I don't agree that Russia wants the whole of Ukraine. It would be a constant nightmare to attempt to occupy Ukraine. Russia might push to the Dnipro river and call it a day. Don't forget that the eastern part of Ukraine that it now occupies is Russian speaking and will not fight a guerrilla war.
Bruh ruSSia sent riot police as part of the offensive towards Kyiv. They are delusional about Ukraine society. They already tried to take Mykolaiv and Odesa and claim Kherson. So what you say is BS. Most of the Ukrainian army is russian speaking and there is already a gurila war int eh occupied regions. Here take this L.
The discussion is like "The Taliban could win against the US". Now, we know that the Taliban won against the US. It's pretty obvious that unless the US entered this war directly, Ukraine does not have any chance. The outcome of a war is decided not so much about the overwhelming military power but the will of one side to fight for as long as it takes to win. The Soviet pulled out of Afghanistan because it cost them too much and there was no strategic value for them to stay. The Taliban won against the US because they were willing to fight for as long as it took. Russia considered winning the war in Ukraine as its existential battle against the West and the US. Russia is prepared to fight for as long as it takes while the US and the West have no real existential interests in Ukraine. The US and the West won't be willing to lose 100000 men fighting to Ukraine and also risk a nuclear showdown. So, it's on the wall who will win. US and Western calculus fails so badly. Russian economy continue to grow. Russia is becoming more independent of the US and Western economy every month going by. The West is more desperate about losing the supply of raw materials and energy from Russia. The Global South looks compeletely neutral and even keener to trade with Russia. China and India are trading with Russia more than ever and the West and the US are too afraid to say anything. Why aren't the West and the US sanctioning India and China? Reality will set in. New governments will take over the West and the US. And soon they will pretend nothing ever happened as Ukraine is wiped off the map.
The taliban did lose to the US. In fact, they were only able to regain control after the US left. Your screed lacks nuance and is clearly an opinion of war by someone who’s never experienced it.
@@paulteske4735 if you spent trillions of dollars, man power, 20 years of operation and left the country running in the cover of darkness; it means you lost. they won nearly all the battle, lost the war
Watching DW always feels like catching a transmission from an alternate universe. Edit: Many commentators misinterpret what I meant. So, to explain. DW actually said that it is a stalemate but in the reality of our universe the situation is militarily disastrous for Ukraine. It's like after the battle of Kursk DW said that it's a stalemate between the Soviets and Germany. I guess it's a stalemate in some other universe.
How long will EU and US be able to continue to provide Ukraine support? Russia is just next door and they know how to play the long game, logistics and sanctions are not a major issue for them. Ukraine is screwed either way.. Economically in debt to those who sent hardware to them and Policitically..
Considering that California alone has a substantially larger economy than the entire Russian Federation I think you would be wise to question how long Russia will be able to stay in the game if the West maintains any semblance of support for Ukraine. How did Russia's supposed ability to play the long game during the Cold War fare?
@@keithmorgan3295 Would be interesting to see if they have learnt anything from the Cold War, history indicates they have resiliance when things arent going well in the country. Geographically not much effort is required to move military assets compared to the US as its literally their backyard..and considering they manufacture their own arms means they are only dependent on raw materials which I wouldn't be surprised if it is being supplied by China.
It's also challenging because Russia has no honor and Putin is a pathological liar--he said that Russia wouldn't occupy any territory and they wouldn't use force to make people do stuff. But every second that Russia stays in Uktaine they are shooting themselves in the foot. Its amassive drain on Russian economy, and Rusdia already had a man shortage before the war. All this because Putin wants to stay in power for ever.
@@keithmorgan3295 California's economy is service-based. The Russian economy is based on the material world AND services. Therefore, it is not correct to compare them in absolute numbers. You can compare steel production, for example. Russia's steel production exceeds steel production in the United States, and so on. That is, they can produce material tanks from steel, and California can produce, for example, games about material tanks or services that will post videos of material tanks fighting, but not the tanks themselves. At the same time, the GDP in California will be higher, but tanks will not be built - there are no production chains The USA is a post-industrial country, 80 percent of GDP is services, like insurance, and so on.
A history lesson is important gor Ukraine, such as the Vietnam war is a classic example, the moment US withdrawn support, the war was finish and ended.
@@jensstergard9380 so if south Vietnam puppet regime couldn't win the war with the support of American soldiers, how do you want the Ukrainian puppet regime to win the war without the direct support of any foreign force?!!
Russia was never defeated in the east. They retreated to regroup, while playing possum at the same time. Ukraine, who had nice momentum, quit pushing, as Russia started extensive mining and building defense lines, which can't be penetrated.
There is no military solution for Ukraine. Many wars are the same. My country Vietnam there was military solution...get over it. Nato has failed, the west has failed. Now you must think towards peace..
Too late for Minsk 3. When Boris Johnson killed a peace deal in March 2022 any new Minsk type agreement died with it. Boris has blood on his hands but it doesn't bother him at all.
@@eugenefirebird8938 Ukraine is fighting a a nation three timea its size and it still goes on the offensive. Ukraine doesn't need excuses it needs proper military equipment to be sent in a timely manner to end this war.
Let's be real: Recently, retired General David Petraeus, the former architect of the Iraq war said that before American troops would go on a counteroffensive if American troops were in the place of the Ukrainian troops against Russia, that first B1 Bombers would carpet bomb the trenches and minefields. G9 Bulldozers would finish the job. Warthog ground-support fighters with 50 caliber cannons would make hamburger out of retreating Russian forces and take out troop carriers and tanks and artillery guns. Apache attack helicopters would take out hidden artillery batteries and cover advancing forces, F-16s would be crisscrossing the Russian lines dropping bombs on tanks and firing at fleeing soldiers and keeping Russian jets at bay. The Ukraine does not have bombers, G9 bulldozers, Warthog ground-support fighters, Apache attack helicopters or F16s covering the troops and having air superiority. Does anyone see what I am saying here? Ukraine has gone into a counteroffensive with one hand tied behind its back against the 2nd Superpower on the planet. Asking ourselves questions like "how is it possible that the Ukrainians have made such little progress?" is absurd. We have to give them the weapons they need to win the war. Period.
Retired American general,,, general did not mention one important thing, that is Russia will be busy eating boger and licking ice cream when American will be doing all the attack against them 😂😂😂 very easy to win Russia in dream world
24:30 this guy has described exactly what Ukraine did, the Minsk agreement was supposed to stop the war but Ukraine and it’s allies used it to buy time to strengthen the Ukrainian military
Nope Ukraine carried out all the sections it was supposed to it was ruSSia who refused to carry out what it agreed to (specifically sections 4, 9, and 10). P.s. what do imagine the ruSSian army was doing between 2015 and 2022 (hint: go look at their budget and officer appointments).
@@maryanchabursky9148 yes and what was Ukraine doing? And what did the former president of France, former German chancellor and former Ukrainian president say about the agreement? You are a fool to dispute the people who signed the deal they themselves said it was meant to buy time to arm Ukraine, anything else you are saying is outright nonsense
In 1994, the Budapest Agreement was signed, according to which Ukraine, at the suggestion of the West, renouned nuclear weapons and heavy bombers. And the West, represented by the United States and Great Britain, acted as the guarantor of its territorial integrity, promised support in the event of an attack on Ukraine. Refusal of nuclear weapons effectively left Ukraine vulnerable against Russian aggression. In 2014, Russia annexed the Ukrainian Crimea and part of Donbass, and in 2022 it is attacking Ukraine, bombing its cities and villages, killing Ukrainians. And now the West does not want to give Ukraine enough necessary weapons, although basically these weapons are not new, they are being replaced with more modern ones.
You are still after so many days of this special operation, avoiding the fact that since 2014, the Ukrainian army itself has been killing the ethnic Russian Ukrainians in Donbas and eastern Europe. Why are the Western people so okay with the killings of Westerners but all of a sudden become very HUMANITARIAN when see other countries doing anything wrong??? SUCH HYPOCRISY !!!!
Interesting replies by others, but not on the subject that you mention. Very true that at least the US and GB made a vow to Ukraine. I do not think the Russian losers would have invaded, if Zelensky still would have had nukes.
Even General Zaluzhnij said that the so called summer offensive failed to achieve its primary targets but mainly because Ukraine received way less than what was promised
@@Meeko2689 sure with anything proruzzian retwited by Musk . First KGB officer Dzerzinsky said that the west will pay for the rope it will be hanged on. The West tries hard since, for more than 100 years paying for ruzzian obsessions.
With Russia having LOST as KILLED more soldiers than it has lost in any war other than WWII, I can assure YOU that Russia hasn't WON it's War with the Ukraine!@@lanakulik7516
I wish they could survive at least this winter .I heard that morale in Ukrainian army has dropped significantly because they know they are going for a certain death ,average soldier age is 43yrs now
Yeah, meantime you guys in Poland and EU harboring 650000 draft dodgers, give them free money , shelter, work permits, etc. I wonder where they’ll run once Poland and Baltics will have to deal with Russia AND Ukraine by themselves
@@evaluateanalysis7974 The Ukrainian government has updated their conscription laws and now can mobilise women however,there are suggestions to mobilise even younger people,Since the Ukrainian population has declined by 66% due to migration,the sources are from Scott Ritter The Ukrainian intelligence ranked as the most wanted in the Pro-Russian list,As for those wanting mobilisation was suggested in an interview with an Azov soldier,they’re the national battalions ,these battalions are accused by shooting anyone who flees the combat line,Polish mercenaries do the same,As soon they left The soldiers would start complaining about other battalions or them having a difficult situation,Not saying the Russian don’t ,but such problems were found mostly in Donetsk and Luhansk borders,the soldiers might’ve realised the situation and supposedly shelled Donetsk city with cluster rounds Because the soldiers know that they will lose Adrivika and they can’t do much about it
@@iceescapenice talking points. They want victory and be heros in Russia. It's going to be a major holiday when this is over, some guy will say I helped take bahkmut. It's honor in that
It’s so entertaining to watch this discussion from Russia. They as always fail to understand that Russia doesn’t need western Ukrainian. Or is it something they are not allowed to say?😅
Hundreds of thousands of dead Ukrainian soldiers wished zelensky had just honored the Minsk agreement. So sad. And yes NATO, Europe and America you are also liable for those deaths.
I wonder if Zelensky would now accept the terms to the original peace deal that Boris Johnson told him scrap? Smh. Territory and lives could've been saved.
The truth is not in the words of the panel. They are bound to say things favourable to one side. The truth is in their tone and energy. They are subdued. There is only fear and sadness in their voices.
Reality begins to sick in on mainstream media to say Ukraine has lost its an understatement nato has lost the more this war continues the more pain an suffering for the people of Ukraine 😢
The US/NATO broke the Minsk Agreement with Russia. Nov 1, 2021 - The alleged quote from Henry Kissinger "To be an enemy of the US is dangerous, but to be a friend is fatal". Hirosima was a city. Nagasaki was a city. Mosul was a city. Raqqa was a city. Baghdad was a city. Aleppo was a city. Kabul was a city. Gaza was a city. German War. .. The list of cities obliterated by the US and allies is far longer than Russian forces.
But this the true why lie ? Our governments in Europe have lie enough time to tell us the true we some of us already know Ukraine will not win this war they don't have a chance logistics and mathematics and industry capability win war not begging for everything all over the world ever month just sa stay alive Russia will win 100%
How is ukraine democratic when zelenskiy has got rid of all his competition 😂😂😂. . That women in the panel must be high on something. 😅.. also way to go what a unbiased panel discussion. Glad to see all agreed wit each other 😅
Come back to reality, Zelensky came to power at internationally recognized fair elections. And if you know what War Measures means you won't say nonsense about competition.
triggered much 🤣@@Stan732 ..."fair elections" when has anything in Ukraine been fair .non corrupt, lol Zelensky is a US pawn. u might have dunken the cool aid.
Yes they have failed big time and Ukraine is paying the price. And if this continues,and the west stays weak in its resolve I fear the whole world could pay a big price.
The West has not failed Ukraine and unfortunately Ukraine is not in NATO so real help cannot be given and it is as simple as that. Blame the west but Putin is the true person to blame.
@@johnkooy5327 The democratic countries haven't failed big time and Ukraine is not about to loose the war. But we have failed, and I agree that if we don't do better both Ukraine and the rest of the World might pay a big price. We might loose the possibility to sit here talking for real about the frames of our lives. We might loose the possibility to stop rich being oligarchs sucking out wealth of the societies.
So far, the war has bled Ukraine and the EU. The US and Russia appear to be doing fine. As long as China and India continue to support Russia, they will overcome any US-led sanctions. The EU should have insisted on getting oil and gas from the US and Norway at cheaper rates to compensate for their loss of cheap Russian energy, but alas. Ukraine will be decimated in a protracted conflict.
Ukraine need to sued for peace .give up land to russia . Abandone nato ambition . Work with russian brothers as partners not as enemies . West is now abandoning it . ukraine is a hot potato with europe in recession . Ukraine has sacrifice enough of its young males . Takes two generation or even 4:17 three to built it to prewar prosperity .
if the war goes on for years, Ukraine may have better weapons, but no one left to use them. They could negotiate peace now to avoid sending thousands more to their deaths.
Bot-Name. USA spends 12% of its yearly budget on its Militaries. The USA Military is only spending 5% of its entire budget on Supplying & Supporting Ukraine. *NOT TO MENTION EVERY OTHER NATO ALLY THAT CONTRIBUTES!* USA can keep this up for +10 years. RuZZia will be *LUCKY* to _exist_ in Ukraine by the end of next year.
And how do you see that panning out, any "peace" negotiated now , ( particulary if the West then completely stop support for Ukraine ) will in reality only be a ceasefire that Putin will break as soon as Russia has built up their forces again. Then what after Ukraine is absorbed ? Every success will just embolden Putin , the only way for him to be stopped is for him to be made grasp that continuing is hopeless.
@@Claymann71 China will able to proxy funds through Russia even longer than the United States has been able to proxy the war in Ukraine. Where did everyone get the idea that Russia is isolated and fighting on its own? If this were so, then the sanctions would have worked immediately China benefits from the fact that the Pentagon is flushing out a bunch of assets into this war. Moreover, it costs very little for China, much less than supporting the war costs for the United States In such a scenario, the question will be who will run out of money faster, China with cheap Russian resources or the United States
@@eioclementi1355 Prigozhin let the cat out of the bag. The little green men were Wagners all along. After the Wagner rebellion, Putin stated that Wagners were always operating under Kremlin direction. So, yes, Russia has been failing to regain control of Ukraine since its puppet, Yanukovich, was ousted in 2014. Never mind: at least Lukashenko dons the kneepads.
8:50 accumulated new brigades , on the Same time Russia has accumulated new legions , currently Russia spends more resources training troops than the conflict in Ukraine claimed territories one should fathom the resources on the conflict
It’s not Zelensky. Anyone who’s been to Ukraine will tell you, he’s only echoing Ukrainian citizens, who view Russia similar to how Palestinians view Israel, except instead of 70 years of history and reasons why, Ukrainians have hundreds.
Beautiful to watch like Ukraine nacionalist with bandera ideology, US sponzors, EU papets losing. Putin sad woth Russia want peaceful, non nato, democratic contry who respect human including Russian right.
No one ever said that you just though ruSSia was winning and so everyone who told you reality (that ruSSia is not winning) you though was saying that Ukraine was winning.
Ukraine already lost this conflict late last year when Eastern Ukraine was annexed into The Russian Federation. Nothing will change this painful fact for Ukraine..
That's hopefully the most ludicrous, illogical BS I am going to hear all day today. BTW, I just signed a decree making Russia my personal property. *Respect my authority!*
They will have like less than 1 million young men after this war. Even if they miraculously win, their demographic situation is a sad state. They were a nation of 50 million people in 1991, by 2050 doubt they’ll be more than 10/15 million, with most being women and elderly, and few men and especially few kids.
Notice how ruSSias rocket strikes have gone from multiple times a week to multiple times a year. Yah that is what people meant by “running low” on missiles.
The problems in Ukraine is caused by the Putin regime. Any Ukrainian caring for the life quality of their children will fight to be independent of the Russian regime and strive to get closer to EU. That is actually what the vast majority have done the last ten years.
It is not Ukraine failing against Russia. Now it is the West including Germany failing against Russia. Why the West could not provide Ukraine military gear for the counteroffensive......
Why couldn't? The West supplied Ukraine with more assets than the USSR received during the entire Second World War under Lend-Lease from the USA + UK. Taking into account all inflation of course. The question is where did this crazy money disappear, and not why the West “failed”
No NATO expention would have prevented this war. Wealthy continue to profit while regular people suffer. 😢 Money for war is not the answer. This should be discussed.
its interesting ,when people say ,putin wants the whole of ukraine..is that what he really wants?i thought russia has the largest land mass.,i think its high time western power have a direct engagement with putin to hear his side rather than speculate..we dont need war in the world.
Look at the original SMO objectives, they remain the same Russia does not want to conquer Ukraine or any other European turf - that narrative is fear mongering. Basically Russia demands no NATO in Ukraine, neutrality. Russia demands their security concerns be respected. Russia will not lose this USA/NATO provoked proxy war. Type in Jeffery Sachs - go beyond msm
![Megan Thee Stallion - Neva Play (feat. RM) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/TpYTyAaTRts/mqdefault.jpg)
first Russia had no fuel, then , russia had only two more days of ammunition, then, it will lose with himars, then, it will lose with all those tanks and stormshadow, then, the counteroffensive is going to crush them, then, it´s a stalemate ..., it´s all a great joke.. didn´t they have only two more days of ammunition?? people forget things tooo fast
But they have shovels.
Some really good shovels I guess
Or they make the up too fast. No one ever claimed what you said, you are either making stuff up or “reinterpreting” what people actually said.
Shovels and chips from washing machines are too dangerous
@@maryanchabursky9148 they buy ammunition in North Korea and Iran.
It's so funny to hear the Western media now saying that Russia has greater capabilities.....But for a long time, they had been saying that Russia was fighting with shovels and had archaic weapons and artillery....😅
Don't mind the constant losers!! The strongest army in the world has proved her credibility by resisting NATO+ (51 countries combined!). USA cannot boast of defeating Russia in a one on one war less Ukraine that gets support. As of today, Russia has the most tested and effective armed forces way ahead of the USA!!!Don't mind the constant losers!! The strongest army in the world has proved her credibility by resisting NATO+ (51 countries combined!). USA cannot boast of defeating Russia in a one on one war less Ukraine that gets support. As of today, Russia has the most tested and effective armed forces way ahead of the USA!!!
They are beginning to understand the reality.....
They will solowly change their “opinions” hoping no one will notice and all the things that were written before will go into the memory hole
Opposite, the west still overestimating ruzzia.
Lol that's because America is about to abandon Ukraine, proxy war failed
its amazing how DW's tone has changed on this conflict over time...feels like someone's had a real wake up call to whats really happening on the ground and its really starting to show in the type and tone of stories they're releasing this last few weeks and months..
The fact is neither side can win with the evolution of drones, precision guided munitions, and WW1 style trench networks and minefields. Russia is gaining nothing economically, has depleted 50% of effective military equipment, and it's people watch Telegram and see thousands of Russian IFVs and tanks go up in flames.
The tone has changed as the war has changed, Russia was really struggling to have any impact for a long time, poor battlefield tactics repeated again and again, a lack of equipment, poor motivation from conscripted men etc.. However in time Russia has managed to fix some of these issues. Realistically a country with the resources and the political structure of Russia should have been able to take Ukraine quickly, and that has not happened. Causing immense reputational damage, damage that even if Russia manage to carve out some kind of victory will not go away quickly.
They are changing the narrative because they will stop supporting Ukraine. Russia has already won the war when they initiated a mobilization. Ukraine had no capacity to clear out the Russian held positions. They are now ‘mobilizing the army’ but so far everything we’ve seen is people getting snatched off the streets by vans in the night.
@@forgottenheritage2845 that's typical Russia. Nothing new. In all wars they struggle and stumble to start with. But eventually win in the end, one way or another.
Bravo 😂😂😂
War could have been avoided if only the Minsk Agreement had been implemented. Germany and France supported this agreement only until Ukraine was sufficiently armed.
Russia broke the ceasefire not Ukraine.
Russia broke it, multiple times.
Russia has broken every treaty with Ukraine.
@@treefiddy727Как? Доказательства имеются?! Или СМИ сказали, вашему телевидению только и верить, сплошной обман, всё против России))
@@skeptic3045 There was no ceasfire. The regime in Kiev engaged in indiscriminate shelling of the Donbass cities, towns and villages day in day out.
It’s mind blowing how Russia 🇷🇺 alone defeats over 30 Nato countries in Ukraine.
This is a mini World War 3
It's not mind blowing, it was anticipated not even predicted.
Russia has defeated only itself, and there are exactly 0 Nato countries present in Ukraine.
NATO has not even entered the fight yet, time to send modern jets, but the USA needs Russia as an enemy to continue spending 700 Billion Dollars on arms to keep the Military Industrial Complex moving, as warned by President Roosevelt many years ago in the 1950`s.
@@nijuuseinot even nato mercenary? Or may be the most important Nato weapons?
The blame game has started
Indeed.
😂
Everyone always knew Ukraine would lose. And they have. They threw away all of those men.
I like how every expert says that they know exactly what Putin thinks and then we find out that he is still unpredictable.
But then all internet warriors translate what the "expert" has said like it was Putin himself.
Over time its become very entertaining to watch this theatre unfold.
Its like USSR but other way around now.
Thats true. When putins lips move he is lying and when they don't he is thinking about lying so how can they Know? You are correct well done, well said, good for you.
What I find astonishing is that they never quote Putin.
Because, you know... he's not exactly saying what they claim he says, especially irt negotiations.
the so-called western analyst can you smoke on the pipe 👎😂
War is. Satlamte
Do you think his objective is no longer domination over Kyiv?
And another point about sanctions and that not all companies have left Russia, the 2nd biggest number of international companies that have stayed and are still operating in Russia are *American*. Only 18% of all American companies in Russia have left. So its abit strange to state that friends of Russia in EU, such as Hungary and Austria, are not making sure that sanctions are followed. Most of western countries are not following sanctions against Russia. But by the looks of it sanctions have benefited Russia much more than those who implemented them.
The funniest thing that Russian gas pipe going through Ukraine is still pumping gas to Europe. And Ukraine still gets paid for transition.
Yes Ukraine still get paid from transition while the pipe leading to Germany was destroyed, who are they fooling 😊
Ukraine doing business with them?
Behind the scenes Russia and Ukraine companies still doing business despite war
And we are denying-ourselves cheap-gas because-of Ukraine.
Not true. EU sanctions against Russia work and are strangling their economy.
These so-called Western 'experts' are worth a dozen for a penny!!
I thought Ukraine and west was winning in tv channels.
as Croatian President Mikanović said in a statement (referring to the German Minister of Foreign Affairs A. Baerbock) "we are not at war with Russia, and if the Germans are at war with Russia... I can tell them - good luck this time!"
Exactly 👌🙌😎
E tako je! Bravo!! Žao mi je samo da u Sloveniji nemamo politicare koji imaju muda....
Respect to Croatia.
Bravo!
Croatia is inEU andNATO.
They had no chance from day 1
True
Which is why it's day six hundred and something in Putin's three day war.
3day quote by GenMilley.
Can we trust AmericanGenerals?
@@anthonyhulse1248U S general said it, not Russia
What would have been so wrong if, at the beginning of the war, Ukraine had negotiated with Russia not to join NATO? 🤔 Are we OK now that hundreds of thousands of Ukrainian men have now died for Uncle Sam?
I know you're a russian troll but lets address that nonetheless.
They did talk about that. But Russia lieerally broke every single treaty and promise it made and attacked regardless.
Western people dont understand Russia. Its a country where promises and treaties mean literally nothing. No rules whatsoever. They will lie in your face and break any treaties whenever it benefits them. They will make treaties to benefit them and then break them when they deem it more benefical.
Russia only understands military force.
The best thing we can do for Russia is to help Ukraine liberate Crimea.
russia anyway would create genocide like they planned all together there is no negotiations with russia, they just playing with you, west audience like kids, so sad....
I deduce that we have finally reached the blame game stage.
If grandma had balls she would be grandpa
True wisdom right here.
-wise Man
Average Ukrainian soldiers age on the Frontline is 44.
the modal age is more important than the average age.
As there has not been one word mentioned by the Ukrainian military or in the Ukrainian media concerning age I wonder where this number has been plucked from and how accurate it is.
But Kremlin apologists are pushing the narrative that Ukraine is mobilizing 15 and 16 year olds!
@@steveprocter6241 There are tons of videos of newly conscripted Ukrainian soldiers that look over 60.
@@steveprocter6241 let me find it for you. It was on the news
Imagine having a round table but not a single person with the Russian perspective?
That's how OneSidedBiases are formed.
At least in europe it's legal to have other perspective on tv.
OtherPerspective Channels are QuicklyBanned.
Just saying.
This is a long term western national tradition 😅
Balance fallacy
Not only has Ukraine lost soldiers, but it will also lose people from the annexed territories. Russia has lost soldiers, but the people on annexed land will more than make up for it, plus resources on that land.
Russia does not need the resources, only the West needs them. This is why the West interests in Ukraine intensified. aggressively. The real objective push NATO away from the order to destroy the Ukrainian army so it would not be a threat to the future of Russia's national security and free the people of the eastern regions that voted to stay with Russia. Putin has kept his promise.
those annexed lands are wastelands.
@@ffffuchs not for long, they will be rebuilt
@@Mark-vr5hc lmao sure
@@ffffuchs Mariupol is literally being rebuilt. So yes it is sure
Germany is always on the wrong and losing side of history. 🤦🏻♂️🤣 🇷🇺🫡💯
The attitude of DW expert panels had changed from what it was a few months ago. They were predicting the defeat of Russia, now they are accepting Russian imminent victory
Germans are interesting people.
I suggest you see the video again.
They have no choice; if they keep pushing, as Soloviev warned, a Russian flag will float once more in Berlin 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Most of that so called experts are funded by CIA slush fund.
@upsalarmupsalarm1893
🤡🤡
Kyiv in three days, right?
its OK to say its failed, and its in no terms at a standstill
AdmittingTheObvious.
What happened to the 300,000 naf0 trained men? To the $100 billion dollar worth of military aid just only for the Counter offensive? What happened to them? 😂
@@Mr.Clownensky why is russia not in kiev. I thought russia was the second strongest army in the world, but they can't even defeat one of the porest countries in europe? 😅😅
@@frederikpedersen689 Ukraine poorest coutry? Lol, they just received $230 billion dollars worth of military aid from the west, thats 6x rusia's entire military budget, and you ask why Rusia having hrd time in Ukrain? 🤡, lol, remove that 200 billion, you think Ukrain will stand a chance? They wont even last a week without The West's support 🤡,
@frederikpedersen689 keep coping 🤡 it's quite hilarious at this point.
Wow i guess we really underestimated how effective those Russia shovels are.
Maybe one should have listened to the warnings in München in 2007 😢
Maybe they should stop Putiler earlier.
Agreed. Taking the piss out of Russia and ignoring them was a bad idea? Russia is a superpower.
@braxxian Russia is Not a super power. It is a gas station with nukes. Nothing more.
absolutely, but these western leaders are so so incompetent these days. Thy 'em selfies are responsible the failure of diplomacy.
We didn't give them the planes in time... Now complain they cannot punch through.... Have we lost our minds?
We gave them everything they asked for. They need to look in the mirror.
@@user-cv8xw8zn5u That is so wrong. We talked about tanks for about a year and they still don't have operationel F-16.
They haveAbrams, Leopards, ChaIlengers.
They have StormShadows.
@@user-cv8xw8zn5u Even the best tanks are useless without air support - vulnerable against enemy planes and helicopters. To advance, they would have to gain air superiority first, hence F-16s.
if Russia wanted all of Ukraine i was gonna despatch +-4 Million Soldiers, since it was 90k, it means it wanted Ukraine to come to the Misks agreement and protect the Donbass area
Minsk-Agreements.
😂😂😂 they could barely supply 200k (90k is a delusion), today ruSSia has well over a million troops in Ukraine.
If ruSSia wanted Minsk 2 then why did they refuse to implement anything they agreed to and then refused multiple invitations by president Zelenskyy in 2019, 2020, and 2021 to sit down and discuss their issues with it (since they refused to implement sections 4, 9, and 10).
It just goes to show you how delusional they were. Let that be a lesson to the neocon warmongers in the west.
Spot on 👍
" warmongers in the west" So far as Ukraine is concerned, you appear to have invented a new meaning for the word - in your view a "warmonger" is a country which supports a country which was attacked by an imperialist invader.
@@evaluateanalysis7974 Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Yemen, Somalia, Syria.
@@matro2 Iraq - murderous dictator. Afghanistan - terrorist supporting nation which murdered 3500 with twin towers attack. Libya - dictatorship, citizens welcomed western support. Somalia - African Union peacekeepers get support from US. Syria - dictatorship, west is helping public fight for democracy.
Ирак - диктатор-убийца. Афганистан - страна, поддерживающая террористов, которые убили 3500 жителей башен-близнецов. Ливия - диктатура, граждане которой приветствовали поддержку Запада. Сомали - миротворцы Африканского союза получают поддержку от США. Сирия - диктатура, Запад помогает населению бороться за демократию.
@matroV Syria, Afghanistan originally, Georgia, Ukraine, Mali, Sudan, CAR, etcetc 🙄🤡🪆🪆
I don't agree that Russia wants the whole of Ukraine. It would be a constant nightmare to attempt to occupy Ukraine. Russia might push to the Dnipro river and call it a day. Don't forget that the eastern part of Ukraine that it now occupies is Russian speaking and will not fight a guerrilla war.
Bruh ruSSia sent riot police as part of the offensive towards Kyiv. They are delusional about Ukraine society. They already tried to take Mykolaiv and Odesa and claim Kherson. So what you say is BS. Most of the Ukrainian army is russian speaking and there is already a gurila war int eh occupied regions.
Here take this L.
@@maryanchabursky9148when did you hear that?
@@chakonleung8675 I didn’t hear it there is footage of it happening.
He is right though. There is no insurgency in the occupied parts...
I'm also surprised they still run with the nonsense narrative of russia want the whole Ukraine, western media is a problem
The discussion is like "The Taliban could win against the US". Now, we know that the Taliban won against the US. It's pretty obvious that unless the US entered this war directly, Ukraine does not have any chance. The outcome of a war is decided not so much about the overwhelming military power but the will of one side to fight for as long as it takes to win. The Soviet pulled out of Afghanistan because it cost them too much and there was no strategic value for them to stay. The Taliban won against the US because they were willing to fight for as long as it took. Russia considered winning the war in Ukraine as its existential battle against the West and the US. Russia is prepared to fight for as long as it takes while the US and the West have no real existential interests in Ukraine. The US and the West won't be willing to lose 100000 men fighting to Ukraine and also risk a nuclear showdown. So, it's on the wall who will win.
US and Western calculus fails so badly. Russian economy continue to grow. Russia is becoming more independent of the US and Western economy every month going by. The West is more desperate about losing the supply of raw materials and energy from Russia. The Global South looks compeletely neutral and even keener to trade with Russia. China and India are trading with Russia more than ever and the West and the US are too afraid to say anything. Why aren't the West and the US sanctioning India and China? Reality will set in. New governments will take over the West and the US. And soon they will pretend nothing ever happened as Ukraine is wiped off the map.
The taliban did lose to the US. In fact, they were only able to regain control after the US left.
Your screed lacks nuance and is clearly an opinion of war by someone who’s never experienced it.
Good analysis👍
@paulteske4735 the proof of pudding is in the eating. Who's running Afghanistan, the US or the Taliban? 🤣
ignoramus are ya
@@paulteske4735 if you spent trillions of dollars, man power, 20 years of operation and left the country running in the cover of darkness; it means you lost.
they won nearly all the battle, lost the war
Russia holds 25% of Ukraine territory. Ukraine holds 0% of Russian territory. So who exactly is winning?,.
Not a relevant metric since Ukraine doesn't want any Russian territory. It only wants its own territory back.
According to Russia, Ukraine is holding Russian territory.... 🤪
16%* 25% was over a year ago. Ukraine is fighting to survive while ruSSia is fighting to destroy Ukraine. So who exactly is winning?
Watching DW always feels like catching a transmission from an alternate universe.
Edit: Many commentators misinterpret what I meant. So, to explain. DW actually said that it is a stalemate but in the reality of our universe the situation is militarily disastrous for Ukraine. It's like after the battle of Kursk DW said that it's a stalemate between the Soviets and Germany.
I guess it's a stalemate in some other universe.
Alternative. Truth.
Because you don't like what they are saying.
Wow, the TITLE is weird... usually it says the UrkNazi's are winning the war...
A universe called FSB.
@@SuperAnatolliТолян, забудь про ФСБ, тебя свои же запинают.
How long will EU and US be able to continue to provide Ukraine support? Russia is just next door and they know how to play the long game, logistics and sanctions are not a major issue for them. Ukraine is screwed either way.. Economically in debt to those who sent hardware to them and Policitically..
Considering that California alone has a substantially larger economy than the entire Russian Federation I think you would be wise to question how long Russia will be able to stay in the game if the West maintains any semblance of support for Ukraine. How did Russia's supposed ability to play the long game during the Cold War fare?
@@keithmorgan3295 Would be interesting to see if they have learnt anything from the Cold War, history indicates they have resiliance when things arent going well in the country. Geographically not much effort is required to move military assets compared to the US as its literally their backyard..and considering they manufacture their own arms means they are only dependent on raw materials which I wouldn't be surprised if it is being supplied by China.
It's also challenging because Russia has no honor and Putin is a pathological liar--he said that Russia wouldn't occupy any territory and they wouldn't use force to make people do stuff. But every second that Russia stays in Uktaine they are shooting themselves in the foot. Its amassive drain on Russian economy, and Rusdia already had a man shortage before the war. All this because Putin wants to stay in power for ever.
How’s that inflation? How did ruSSian logistics handle the Kyiv offensive?
@@keithmorgan3295 California's economy is service-based. The Russian economy is based on the material world AND services. Therefore, it is not correct to compare them in absolute numbers.
You can compare steel production, for example. Russia's steel production exceeds steel production in the United States, and so on.
That is, they can produce material tanks from steel, and California can produce, for example, games about material tanks or services that will post videos of material tanks fighting, but not the tanks themselves. At the same time, the GDP in California will be higher, but tanks will not be built - there are no production chains
The USA is a post-industrial country, 80 percent of GDP is services, like insurance, and so on.
A history lesson is important gor Ukraine, such as the Vietnam war is a classic example, the moment US withdrawn support, the war was finish and ended.
And Afghanistan2021
Ukraine and Vietnam can not be compared. USA has no men in Ukraine and the European countries also support Ukraine.
@@jensstergard9380 so if south Vietnam puppet regime couldn't win the war with the support of American soldiers, how do you want the Ukrainian puppet regime to win the war without the direct support of any foreign force?!!
The ability to compare should be encouraged.
Bodybags-with American-Flghters keep coming to USA
What are these?
I'd love to know how the first guest figured out what Russia's war aims were; maybe they have special access to Russian documents.
Kindergarten round table talk 😂😂
Russia was never defeated in the east. They retreated to regroup, while playing possum at the same time. Ukraine, who had nice momentum, quit pushing, as Russia started extensive mining and building defense lines, which can't be penetrated.
There is no military solution for Ukraine. Many wars are the same. My country Vietnam there was military solution...get over it. Nato has failed, the west has failed. Now you must think towards peace..
At this stage both sides are failing. Russia doesn't control all of Ukraine. Ukraine doesn't control all its territory
Ukraine didn't follow through with the Minks Agreement which could had avoided the war.
Zelinskiy wasMocking the MinskAgreements
We need Minsk-3 agreements.
Too late for Minsk 3. When Boris Johnson killed a peace deal in March 2022 any new Minsk type agreement died with it. Boris has blood on his hands but it doesn't bother him at all.
Ukrainian didnt read histories of America's abandoning allies.
Weve had two years to meet demand for 155mm and we cant. Absolute shame
Thank Joe-Biden
That's just another lame excuse for Ukraine's loss.
EU weak , and putler see this
@@eugenefirebird8938 Ukraine is fighting a a nation three timea its size and it still goes on the offensive. Ukraine doesn't need excuses it needs proper military equipment to be sent in a timely manner to end this war.
@@gorishokgo5825 Weak because of weak leadership.
Let's be real: Recently, retired General David Petraeus, the former architect of the Iraq war said that before American troops would go on a counteroffensive if American troops were in the place of the Ukrainian troops against Russia, that first B1 Bombers would carpet bomb the trenches and minefields. G9 Bulldozers would finish the job. Warthog ground-support fighters with 50 caliber cannons would make hamburger out of retreating Russian forces and take out troop carriers and tanks and artillery guns. Apache attack helicopters would take out hidden artillery batteries and cover advancing forces, F-16s would be crisscrossing the Russian lines dropping bombs on tanks and firing at fleeing soldiers and keeping Russian jets at bay. The Ukraine does not have bombers, G9 bulldozers, Warthog ground-support fighters, Apache attack helicopters or F16s covering the troops and having air superiority. Does anyone see what I am saying here? Ukraine has gone into a counteroffensive with one hand tied behind its back against the 2nd Superpower on the planet. Asking ourselves questions like "how is it possible that the Ukrainians have made such little progress?" is absurd. We have to give them the weapons they need to win the war. Period.
Retired American general,,, general did not mention one important thing, that is Russia will be busy eating boger and licking ice cream when American will be doing all the attack against them 😂😂😂 very easy to win Russia in dream world
😂😂😂👍
Ukraine 2023 = Afghanistan 2021
Thank you, Brandon
US army has never fought anyone who can remote fight back.
Oh wait
Vietnam they ran away
Afghan they ran away
US is good at Iosing.
24:30 this guy has described exactly what Ukraine did, the Minsk agreement was supposed to stop the war but Ukraine and it’s allies used it to buy time to strengthen the Ukrainian military
Do you think russia would ever accept a reversed minsk 2 agreement?
Nope Ukraine carried out all the sections it was supposed to it was ruSSia who refused to carry out what it agreed to (specifically sections 4, 9, and 10).
P.s. what do imagine the ruSSian army was doing between 2015 and 2022 (hint: go look at their budget and officer appointments).
@@maryanchabursky9148 yes and what was Ukraine doing? And what did the former president of France, former German chancellor and former Ukrainian president say about the agreement? You are a fool to dispute the people who signed the deal they themselves said it was meant to buy time to arm Ukraine, anything else you are saying is outright nonsense
Russia broke the Minsk agreement just like the broke the 1991 treaty.
Because everyone knew Russia wouldn't honor it.
In 1994, the Budapest Agreement was signed, according to which Ukraine, at the suggestion of the West, renouned nuclear weapons and heavy bombers. And the West, represented by the United States and Great Britain, acted as the guarantor of its territorial integrity, promised support in the event of an attack on Ukraine. Refusal of nuclear weapons effectively left Ukraine vulnerable against Russian aggression.
In 2014, Russia annexed the Ukrainian Crimea and part of Donbass, and in 2022 it is attacking Ukraine, bombing its cities and villages, killing Ukrainians.
And now the West does not want to give Ukraine enough necessary weapons, although basically these weapons are not new, they are being replaced with more modern ones.
You are still after so many days of this special operation, avoiding the fact that since 2014, the Ukrainian army itself has been killing the ethnic Russian Ukrainians in Donbas and eastern Europe. Why are the Western people so okay with the killings of Westerners but all of a sudden become very HUMANITARIAN when see other countries doing anything wrong??? SUCH HYPOCRISY !!!!
Even if Ukraine had nuclear weapons, Russia would still invade and Ukraine wouldn't use nuclear weapons. She knows the consequences
They had Soviet nukes and no access codes form them. In essence they where holding Soviet nukes hostage. More blackmail from Ukraine!
Cry a little bit louder
Interesting replies by others, but not on the subject that you mention. Very true that at least the US and GB made a vow to Ukraine. I do not think the Russian losers would have invaded, if Zelensky still would have had nukes.
Even media now agree that so- called counter Offensive has failed
Eyes are opening
Myself and many others have been saying Ukraine will lose since Jan 2021.
Even General Zaluzhnij said that the so called summer offensive failed to achieve its primary targets but mainly because Ukraine received way less than what was promised
And they are equally wrong. Not achieving your maximalist strategic goals is not the same as failure.
@@Nikowalker007no he said that the war has reached a stalemate for now
But I thought Ukraine was winning 😢😢😂
In life nothing is certain.
Nothing but death.
@@oneshothunter9877 Neji?😅
@@julienckjm7430
Jo!😎
@@oneshothunter9877 I've heard something similar in the fight Neji vs Naruto (iykwim)
@@julienckjm7430
Is that a game?
I'm too old for that now, but my son..., that's different.
Youngsters 😁😎👍
Ukrain already lost.
In kremlin's dreams 😂
@@Stan732The practice shows this dreams are always come true.
@@alexanderlazarev3570 not practice but russian TV rather.
@@Stan732and Ukraine is only winning on Twitter 😂
@@Meeko2689 sure with anything proruzzian retwited by Musk . First KGB officer Dzerzinsky said that the west will pay for the rope it will be hanged on. The West tries hard since, for more than 100 years paying for ruzzian obsessions.
Minsk agreement sounds good now 😆
Yes, that is why Putin broke it before Zilensky was even near politics.
Ukraine can't win at the snails pace the US gives them military equipment and ammo to drag out the war. Jeesh
Can Ukraine survive the war? A rhetorical question
Non-rhetorical answer: It did last year.
With Russia having LOST as KILLED more soldiers than it has lost in any war other than WWII, I can assure YOU that Russia hasn't WON it's War with the Ukraine!@@lanakulik7516
It can never be..... Rassia has 23%of Ukraine in their hands and kramia
Ukraine has already lost - millions of people have left the country, all production in the country has stopped, the economy is in trouble
@@lanakulik7516survived how? an entire generation is dead... You can look this up the average age of a Ukrainian soldier is 43
I wish they could survive at least this winter .I heard that morale in Ukrainian army has dropped significantly because they know they are going for a certain death ,average soldier age is 43yrs now
Yeah, meantime you guys in Poland and EU harboring 650000 draft dodgers, give them free money , shelter, work permits, etc. I wonder where they’ll run once Poland and Baltics will have to deal with Russia AND Ukraine by themselves
Couldn't the same be said for Russian soldiers? Probably more so for Russian soldiers/canon fodder.
"average soldier age is 43yrs" link to evidence?
@@evaluateanalysis7974
The Ukrainian government has updated their conscription laws and now can mobilise women however,there are suggestions to mobilise even younger people,Since the Ukrainian population has declined by 66% due to migration,the sources are from Scott Ritter
The Ukrainian intelligence ranked as the most wanted in the Pro-Russian list,As for those wanting mobilisation was suggested in an interview with an Azov soldier,they’re the national battalions ,these battalions are accused by shooting anyone who flees the combat line,Polish mercenaries do the same,As soon they left The soldiers would start complaining about other battalions or them having a difficult situation,Not saying the Russian don’t ,but such problems were found mostly in Donetsk and Luhansk borders,the soldiers might’ve realised the situation and supposedly shelled Donetsk city with cluster rounds
Because the soldiers know that they will lose Adrivika and they can’t do much about it
@@iceescapenice talking points. They want victory and be heros in Russia. It's going to be a major holiday when this is over, some guy will say I helped take bahkmut. It's honor in that
It’s so entertaining to watch this discussion from Russia. They as always fail to understand that Russia doesn’t need western Ukrainian. Or is it something they are not allowed to say?😅
Hundreds of thousands of dead Ukrainian soldiers wished zelensky had just honored the Minsk agreement.
So sad. And yes NATO, Europe and America you are also liable for those deaths.
Shadow banned comment.
I wonder if Zelensky would now accept the terms to the original peace deal that Boris Johnson told him scrap? Smh. Territory and lives could've been saved.
Yes, if people knew the reality of why this war been dragging on for this long they would be surprised.
No because it is impossible to accept the terms of imaginary “peace deals”.
I don't think it's a stalemate... because Russia keep pushing to gain more ground
and will win
The truth is not in the words of the panel. They are bound to say things favourable to one side. The truth is in their tone and energy. They are subdued. There is only fear and sadness in their voices.
@@Ivan_the_RipperWhy aren't you on the frontline?
@@MikesLeaguewhy ain’t u there too?
@@santanasage00 Do you support Putin?
"Can Ukraine STILL win this war?" -- Ukraine was NEVER going to win this war!!!!!!
I remember early on people were like, “Oh, it’s over for Russia!” 2 and a half years on, now look
Russia always starts conflicts badly. They end them strongly.
@@braxxianFr like in ww2 many blunders in beginning but finished strong
Reality begins to sick in on mainstream media to say Ukraine has lost its an understatement nato has lost the more this war continues the more pain an suffering for the people of Ukraine 😢
The US/NATO broke the Minsk Agreement with Russia.
Nov 1, 2021 - The alleged quote from Henry Kissinger "To be an enemy of the US is dangerous, but to be a friend is fatal".
Hirosima was a city.
Nagasaki was a city.
Mosul was a city.
Raqqa was a city.
Baghdad was a city.
Aleppo was a city.
Kabul was a city.
Gaza was a city.
German War.
..
The list of cities obliterated by the US and allies is far longer than Russian forces.
Exactly
🤣🤣🤣 This western puppets are now understanding that point.
You called them correctIy.
We are puppets but you type BS for a living. I guess that's marginally more logical than getting mobilized.
The guy with the glasses is living far from reality. Germany should be begging russia to help them with the economy
And which planet are you, from planet Troll ??
Germans are not very bright, they want to pay 5 times the price for LNG imported from Russia through Belgium or USA.
😂😂😂 why? ruSSias inflation is insane.
Everybody knows Ukraine will never win against Russia. Its a fact. 😊😮😊
This type of story encourages Putin.
That's the truth. You prefer a fairy-taIe?
The west are facts sensitive. 😂😂
But this the true why lie ? Our governments in Europe have lie enough time to tell us the true we some of us already know Ukraine will not win this war they don't have a chance logistics and mathematics and industry capability win war not begging for everything all over the world ever month just sa stay alive Russia will win 100%
With Gxza drama and how U$A UK EU shameless react, Putin relatively is kind.
Unfortunately he is likely not watch it he already knows Ukraine is finished, maybe what happens after is his concern
How is ukraine democratic when zelenskiy has got rid of all his competition 😂😂😂. . That women in the panel must be high on something. 😅.. also way to go what a unbiased panel discussion. Glad to see all agreed wit each other 😅
More democratic than Russia.
Come back to reality, Zelensky came to power at internationally recognized fair elections. And if you know what War Measures means you won't say nonsense about competition.
triggered much 🤣@@Stan732 ..."fair elections" when has anything in Ukraine been fair .non corrupt, lol Zelensky is a US pawn. u might have dunken the cool aid.
probably true. 👍@@kris8263 but that women is high as kite 🤣
What competition was “got rid off”? You must be high on something of you think Ukraine is not a democracy.
Ulraine alreqdy sending women to the trenches, old men, boys... desperation
Europe & the “West” have failed to rise to the occasion, their reputation & security are on the line, there will be repercussions.
Yes they have failed big time and Ukraine is paying the price.
And if this continues,and the west stays weak in its resolve I fear the whole world could pay a big price.
The West has not failed Ukraine and unfortunately Ukraine is not in NATO so real help cannot be given and it is as simple as that. Blame the west but Putin is the true person to blame.
@@johnkooy5327 The democratic countries haven't failed big time and Ukraine is not about to loose the war. But we have failed, and I agree that if we don't do better both Ukraine and the rest of the World might pay a big price. We might loose the possibility to sit here talking for real about the frames of our lives. We might loose the possibility to stop rich being oligarchs sucking out wealth of the societies.
The biggest failure took place in 2014...
@@anderslagerqvist2642 I agree, the sanctions back then were too weak.
"Russia has already lost the war." - Joe Biden Apr 23
😂😂😂😂typical Joe lmao
That just made Biden look foolish.
So far, the war has bled Ukraine and the EU. The US and Russia appear to be doing fine. As long as China and India continue to support Russia, they will overcome any US-led sanctions. The EU should have insisted on getting oil and gas from the US and Norway at cheaper rates to compensate for their loss of cheap Russian energy, but alas. Ukraine will be decimated in a protracted conflict.
A whole generation of young military age men have been sacrificed in this war... how sad.
Ukraine need to sued for peace .give up land to russia . Abandone nato ambition . Work with russian brothers as partners not as enemies . West is now abandoning it . ukraine is a hot potato with europe in recession .
Ukraine has sacrifice enough of its young males .
Takes two generation or even 4:17 three to built it to prewar prosperity .
Of course zelensky will never say he will give up. Its too lucrative for him and the military industrial complex in usa .
if the war goes on for years, Ukraine may have better weapons, but no one left to use them. They could negotiate peace now to avoid sending thousands more to their deaths.
Bot-Name.
USA spends 12% of its yearly budget on its Militaries.
The USA Military is only spending 5% of its entire budget on Supplying & Supporting Ukraine.
*NOT TO MENTION EVERY OTHER NATO ALLY THAT CONTRIBUTES!*
USA can keep this up for +10 years. RuZZia will be *LUCKY* to _exist_ in Ukraine by the end of next year.
Maybe they will hire Yaroslav Hunka to fight yet another 12 seconds..?
@@Claymann71 Yes, what will you do without your forever wars..?
And how do you see that panning out, any "peace" negotiated now , ( particulary if the West then completely stop support for Ukraine ) will in reality only be a ceasefire that Putin will break as soon as Russia has built up their forces again. Then what after Ukraine is absorbed ? Every success will just embolden Putin , the only way for him to be stopped is for him to be made grasp that continuing is hopeless.
@@Claymann71 China will able to proxy funds through Russia even longer than the United States has been able to proxy the war in Ukraine.
Where did everyone get the idea that Russia is isolated and fighting on its own? If this were so, then the sanctions would have worked immediately
China benefits from the fact that the Pentagon is flushing out a bunch of assets into this war. Moreover, it costs very little for China, much less than supporting the war costs for the United States
In such a scenario, the question will be who will run out of money faster, China with cheap Russian resources or the United States
ukraine has a million soldiers russia only deployed half a million , and yet ukraine is losing
Day 637
@@thePronto Donbass war day 4058
@@eioclementi1355 Prigozhin let the cat out of the bag. The little green men were Wagners all along. After the Wagner rebellion, Putin stated that Wagners were always operating under Kremlin direction. So, yes, Russia has been failing to regain control of Ukraine since its puppet, Yanukovich, was ousted in 2014. Never mind: at least Lukashenko dons the kneepads.
@@thePronto Ah yes, the bald guy who thought he could be King. His delusions were almost epic.
@@Memovox what about the delusions of the current King? Sorry, Emperor of the Universe for all Eternity.
8:50 accumulated new brigades , on the Same time Russia has accumulated new legions , currently Russia spends more resources training troops than the conflict in Ukraine claimed territories one should fathom the resources on the conflict
Theres no way Ukraine can win this war😢😢😢😢😢😢
Zelensky is a war criminal....
Ukraine is still in hallucination and not looking at hard reality but Zelensky is pushing Ukranians into misery.
Economy isDown by 30%.
It’s not Zelensky. Anyone who’s been to Ukraine will tell you, he’s only echoing Ukrainian citizens, who view Russia similar to how Palestinians view Israel, except instead of 70 years of history and reasons why, Ukrainians have hundreds.
Ukrainian people voted for Zelinskiy on the promise ofPeace.
Now maIes areHiding from Zelinskiy's GreenMen grabbingPeople inSteets.
It's easy to criticize someone in distress while sitting in comfort. You have no idea.
Слава России!🇷🇺🇷🇺🇷🇺
Beautiful to watch like Ukraine nacionalist with bandera ideology, US sponzors, EU papets losing. Putin sad woth Russia want peaceful, non nato, democratic contry who respect human including Russian right.
So now Ukraine is not winning 😂😂😂 ? .
You have been telling us so far that FUCKRAINE was winning what happened ? .
Truth hurts .
No one ever said that you just though ruSSia was winning and so everyone who told you reality (that ruSSia is not winning) you though was saying that Ukraine was winning.
Ukraine already lost this conflict late last year when Eastern Ukraine was annexed into The Russian Federation. Nothing will change this painful fact for Ukraine..
Russia’s inevitable defeat will ensure that Ukraine will reinstate its borders.
That's hopefully the most ludicrous, illogical BS I am going to hear all day today. BTW, I just signed a decree making Russia my personal property. *Respect my authority!*
@@thePronto come here, I'll personally pledge my loyalty to you.
@Shining237 True.
@@palar4195I bet you actually want to hit me with your keyboard. Enjoy your potato.
They will have like less than 1 million young men after this war. Even if they miraculously win, their demographic situation is a sad state. They were a nation of 50 million people in 1991, by 2050 doubt they’ll be more than 10/15 million, with most being women and elderly, and few men and especially few kids.
Glory to Ukraine?
no no slava to us and beautifull Ukrainian Women who need warming up this winter :)) @@vkt2805
NATO terrorist Organization was defeated in Ukraine 😂
How can they be defeated in a country they are not in?
At the beginning of the war clear Ukrainian can’t win but they always said no Ukrainian wining . Wink wink …
Ukraine is not "Failing against Russia." Russia is "Failing against Ukraine."
Dont go against russia.. in winter. You should learn from history.
😂😂😂😂 Ukraine was always doomed y’all are so passionately delusional it’s so funny
Whatever happened to Russia is weak and running out of weapons.
@@newmoon1448 Nato has difficulty with pronouns
Isn’t Russia getting weapons from Iran, North Korea, and drones from China? Or are these all Russian made?
Notice how ruSSias rocket strikes have gone from multiple times a week to multiple times a year. Yah that is what people meant by “running low” on missiles.
First they asked if Ukraine can win now they ask if it can survive 😂 Pure Ukraine, look where western guidance brought you.
The problems in Ukraine is caused by the Putin regime. Any Ukrainian caring for the life quality of their children will fight to be independent of the Russian regime and strive to get closer to EU. That is actually what the vast majority have done the last ten years.
“To be an enemy of America can be dangerous, but to be a friend is fatal.”
- Henry Kissinger
TLDR: Yes, the counteroffensive failed. No, the war is not over.
DW's relentless anti-Ukraine bent in its headlines is quite breathtaking.
It´s called reality, try it out.
Ukraine never could. USA has been holding Ukraine up by the hair the whole time.
My country has publicly announced continuos support for Ukraine.
Yup, that's right. We have.
WordsWords. Like hot airComing from yourBack side.
That sucks for you
And ZelinskiySucking thatAir? Ok.
Pity they didn't concentrate on your spelling
Ukraine lost the war a long time ago....The question is- Can NATO put boots on the ground in Ukraine and risk ww3 with nukes?
Ukraine is not a vital intrest for any western country
It is not Ukraine failing against Russia. Now it is the West including Germany failing against Russia. Why the West could not provide Ukraine military gear for the counteroffensive......
Why couldn't? The West supplied Ukraine with more assets than the USSR received during the entire Second World War under Lend-Lease from the USA + UK. Taking into account all inflation of course.
The question is where did this crazy money disappear, and not why the West “failed”
No NATO expention would have prevented this war. Wealthy continue to profit while regular people suffer. 😢 Money for war is not the answer. This should be discussed.
Nato expansion is the cause of the war.
its interesting ,when people say ,putin wants the whole of ukraine..is that what he really wants?i thought russia has the largest land mass.,i think its high time western power have a direct engagement with putin to hear his side rather than speculate..we dont need war in the world.
👍
Look at the original SMO objectives, they remain the same
Russia does not want to conquer Ukraine or any other European turf - that narrative is fear mongering.
Basically Russia demands no NATO in Ukraine, neutrality.
Russia demands their security concerns be respected.
Russia will not lose this USA/NATO provoked proxy war.
Type in Jeffery Sachs - go beyond msm
Most of the Western analysts have zero understanding of the Russian Federation. Still they love to mislead politicians, journalists and the public.
War is what you will get if Putin is not stopped , and giving him Ukraine will not stop him .
He’s said that’s what he wants. Haven’t heard anything different from him.
Ukraine does not have manpower required
Ukranian Women and Children are out, men have lost the will, now they want to leave desperately
Well explained.
Day 637. Writing your cope fantasies online doesn't make them true.
8 million Ukranians in EU. 637days and they are neverGoingBack.
Russia was ready for negotiation in march 2022 BUT johnson said that "ukraine must fight till last ukranians". Don't fool people.
Need to bring more african and asian experts to explain why the world is still dealing with Russia.
Ukraine cannot win against Russia. That is the fact. Unfortunately they put too much hope in the West and they will pay dearly for it.
Russian bot detected.
It seems DW is going insane With this Ukraine thing
Bundesnachrichtendienst BND probably told them to, orders from Langley USA. 😊