@@igor20igor He didn't seem cold to me, he looked and sounded like he was very distressed, just not in such an outwardly way as in the books, I guess. Everyone else seemed less worried tbh.
@@antonionunes1905 Only Ron and Harry cares about Hermione. Harry is shaking. Look at him when he is holding the mirror. I don't want to talk about Luna. For me, it is different to be calm from what she is here, as if she didn't even care about Hermione.
I hate that the movie didn't kill Pettigrew off the way he did in the books! The way he dies just shows just how merciless voldermot was to even his own most loyal followers! How that miniscule sense of remorse that the rat felt was a betrayal to the dark lord!
SAME! That was an important moment. A short moment of hesistance showed us that Pettigrew had some of his old character in there and that he was necessarily 100% evil. This and the battle between Harry and Voldemort was a big miss. (book battle was a lot better than outside in the backyard (movie))
@@Maatjuhhh 2 years later, but I have to comment . Remorse is a powerful theme in Deathly Hallows, it is presented as one of the most powerful human emotions, just like love was often described in the books. Wormtail felt remorse and he hesitated and that was enough for Voldemort's magical hand to kill Wormtail. Even the slightest betrayal, even though crime was enough for Voldemort. I think we can conclude (with the whole book in mind) that his soul was saved as a result. That also adds to the portrayal of Voldemort: a despicable creature, barely human who is incapable of feeling love or remorse. As a result of his actions, he suffered fate worse than death with what little was left of his shattered soul. Harry Potter even warned him about this in the books, and gave him a chance, told him to try to feel some remorse over what he did. Harry knew that true remorse was the only thing that could restore the soul of anyone who created a horcrux , however the pain of doing so would so great that it would kill them. But Voldemort was terrified of death and also completely incapable of feeling love and remorse. He was beyond saving.
Overall I think they did this whole Malfoy Manor scene well. Luna calling Dobby "Sir" and his reaction was one of my favourite moments of the film (along with Bellatrix saying "stupid elf! You could have killed me!" and Dobby replying "Dobby never meant to kill. Dobby only meant to maim or seriously injured!" 😂) Emma played her part really well and her and Helena's brainwave with the mudblood scar was genius given how ambiguous the book was on Hermione's post-torture injuries (I find it difficult to believe that she escaped a "girl to girl conversation" with Bellatrix Lestrange with only a cut into her throat). I understand why they didn't show Wormtail being strangled by his own metal hand because the scene was already intense enough as it was with what was going on with Hermione and Bellatrix. But the one negative I find about this scene is the boys are way too calm. Their best friend has just been left at the mercy of the most psychotic and merciless Death Eater and is screaming her head off, and they're both just standing around calmly like nothing is happening.
@@benten3212 Yes, it was. In the book, it was this artificial hand that strangled Wormtail to death. Harry and Ron even tried to save him, but the more they tried, the more the hand tightened around Pettigrew's neck.
"hey dobby, I'm going into this crazy maze and voldemort might come alive, could you get us out of there before he kills someone" "hey dobby, we're headed into the forbidden forest to meet a giant spider, could you be ready to teleport us out before he potentially eats us" "hey dobby, dementors are attacking us in public, could you apparete us out of there" "hey dobby, I'm a the quidditch world cup and death eaters are burning everything, could you get us out of here" "hey dobby, we need to secretely move harry potter we were wondering if you could transport us, or should we rather use a convoluted plan with broomflight and polyjuice potion" "hey dobby we need to get into hogwarts secretly, could you get us in or do we have to visit dumbledore's brother so that he can let us through the door"
In the book he was significantly madder. Not a fan of the much more reduced reaction in the film, it’s a bit weak and not really in character. Also in the book they take out Petigrew themselves rather than Dobby doing it. So they are much more active in the books. Though I am aware that this whole scene was reduced to keep the film rating down, the torture scene was longer in the books, Ron’s reaction was significantly more distraught, wormtail getting jumped and then strangling himself probably wouldn’t be great for a pg rating, nor would Hermione almost getting eaten by fenrir. So the book scene was honestly better, darker etc… but I see why they changed it.
One of my favorite facts about the torture scene is that Daniel, Tom and Rupert? (Dont know if her was there) needed to removed because they thought Emma was really in pain and strarted to become belligerent.
Ok after the flash there’s mud on the wall behind Pete that looks like blood… I fucking thought Ron put a suppressed round through his fucking back 😂 fuck, going full ghost recon I see
@@madmax2518 I wish that Hermione got a moment to sock Bellatrix in the final battle like she did Malfoy. But Get Away From My Daughter, You Bitch makes up for it
House elf magic is different from wizard magic. That's why Dobby can Apparate and Disapparate from places with the strongest protection spells. And that’s also why Kreacher survived in the cave where Voldemort hid Slytherin’s medallion . Wizards are in the habit of ignoring this fact because they consider elves (and not just elves, but goblins too) inferior.
They couldn't. They made it that way on purpose. Otherwise Mr Olivander could have left at any time. I think the whole of the cell area was made to be anti-apparition.
![Yailin La Mas Viral, @kreizyk.official - Dale 2 (Remix) [Video Oficial]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/JaYHBzgqz94/mqdefault.jpg)
“Sir? I like her very much.” 😁
Dobby is us in that moment
Fufigkgkgkk❤😊
@@ilonavai6999what
Oh I love you so much Dobby!😍
No matter what anyone thinks about her, Dobby likes her for her kindness and her respect for him❤️
Shouldn't that line be "Sir? Dobby likes Luna very much"?
1:54
“Whenever your ready, sir”
“Sir. I like her very much”
Yeah I couldn’t stop replaying that
Gacha Life Noob same
I love the way he says “of course, I’m an elf”😂💕
Like "Duh."
Don’t sass me dobby
It would be better if the reply was "of course, Dobby is an elf"
He looks so confused over Harry's confusion. :D Makes you wonder what they teach in school about the unique magic of non-humans.
I wish Dobby and Luna met before
It would had been the most precious and wholesome moments
Yesss.... It'd be awwdorable
Agreed! Those two are so pure and wholesome it’s amazing!
Doesn’t she call him the king of the house elf’s?
be glad it actually happened
@@christinedomagala3781 Agreed
I like when Dobby said he likes Luna. But the scene when Hermione was being tortured give me goosebumps.
I didn't really like Ron's cold reaction.
In the book, he was screaming all the time, hitting bars, completely out of control.
@@igor20igor He didn't seem cold to me, he looked and sounded like he was very distressed, just not in such an outwardly way as in the books, I guess. Everyone else seemed less worried tbh.
@@igor20igor HERMIONE, HERMIONE!
Same
@@antonionunes1905 Only Ron and Harry cares about Hermione. Harry is shaking. Look at him when he is holding the mirror. I don't want to talk about Luna. For me, it is different to be calm from what she is here, as if she didn't even care about Hermione.
*Of course Sir I’m an elf*
"Of course Sir, Dobby is an elf" would have been better 🤔
"Dobby will always be there for Harry Potter"
OH GOD DAMMIT DOBBY! I DIDN'T NEED TO CRY TODAY, I'VE GOT SHIT I NEED TO DO!
This scene with Dobby is honestly one of my favorites in the whole series 😂
"Whenever you're ready, sir."
"Sir? I like her very much."
If I were a character I call Dobby sir any time
I hate that the movie didn't kill Pettigrew off the way he did in the books! The way he dies just shows just how merciless voldermot was to even his own most loyal followers! How that miniscule sense of remorse that the rat felt was a betrayal to the dark lord!
SAME! That was an important moment. A short moment of hesistance showed us that Pettigrew had some of his old character in there and that he was necessarily 100% evil. This and the battle between Harry and Voldemort was a big miss. (book battle was a lot better than outside in the backyard (movie))
@@Maatjuhhh AGREED!
Pettigrew wasn't loyal. He only served Voldemort out of fear. He's nothing but a coward
@@Maatjuhhh
2 years later, but I have to comment . Remorse is a powerful theme in Deathly Hallows, it is presented as one of the most powerful human emotions, just like love was often described in the books.
Wormtail felt remorse and he hesitated and that was enough for Voldemort's magical hand to kill Wormtail. Even the slightest betrayal, even though crime was enough for Voldemort. I think we can conclude (with the whole book in mind) that his soul was saved as a result. That also adds to the portrayal of Voldemort: a despicable creature, barely human who is incapable of feeling love or remorse. As a result of his actions, he suffered fate worse than death with what little was left of his shattered soul. Harry Potter even warned him about this in the books, and gave him a chance, told him to try to feel some remorse over what he did.
Harry knew that true remorse was the only thing that could restore the soul of anyone who created a horcrux , however the pain of doing so would so great that it would kill them.
But Voldemort was terrified of death and also completely incapable of feeling love and remorse. He was beyond saving.
Overall I think they did this whole Malfoy Manor scene well. Luna calling Dobby "Sir" and his reaction was one of my favourite moments of the film (along with Bellatrix saying "stupid elf! You could have killed me!" and Dobby replying "Dobby never meant to kill. Dobby only meant to maim or seriously injured!" 😂)
Emma played her part really well and her and Helena's brainwave with the mudblood scar was genius given how ambiguous the book was on Hermione's post-torture injuries (I find it difficult to believe that she escaped a "girl to girl conversation" with Bellatrix Lestrange with only a cut into her throat). I understand why they didn't show Wormtail being strangled by his own metal hand because the scene was already intense enough as it was with what was going on with Hermione and Bellatrix.
But the one negative I find about this scene is the boys are way too calm. Their best friend has just been left at the mercy of the most psychotic and merciless Death Eater and is screaming her head off, and they're both just standing around calmly like nothing is happening.
Even i like Luna very much. She is so kind.
1:42 ofcourse sir im an elf🥺
of course sir Dobby is an elf would have been better 🤔
dobbys death represented the last of there childhood the last of the trios child like innocence if they had any left he was almost child like .....
I love how he’s like uh duh in a polite way 😂
Its so sad that when dobby said "dobby will always be there for Harry potter!" And then he died...saying harry's name😭
Why didn’t ron just snatch the wand when it was inches away from him
Prolly cause Pettigrews hand is very strong (the artificial one)
@@benten3212 Yes, it was. In the book, it was this artificial hand that strangled Wormtail to death.
Harry and Ron even tried to save him, but the more they tried, the more the hand tightened around Pettigrew's neck.
OoOoOf........ Eow *falls*
No no, not me dying of laughter 😂
Dobby so cute
Yes
Peter actually was strangled by the fake hand given by voldemort for not being faithful enough to voldmort. I wished they added that to movies :(
That Son of a 🤬 Killed Cedric 😭
I know. Cedric didn’t want to die. I wanted him in Harry Potter and The Order of the Phoenix, the Half-Blood Prince and Deathly Hallows Part 1 and 2.
It was heartbreaking to see that in Harry Potter and The Goblet of Fire
Cedric was Mr. Amos Diggory’s son. His only family he had
"hey dobby, I'm going into this crazy maze and voldemort might come alive, could you get us out of there before he kills someone"
"hey dobby, we're headed into the forbidden forest to meet a giant spider, could you be ready to teleport us out before he potentially eats us"
"hey dobby, dementors are attacking us in public, could you apparete us out of there"
"hey dobby, I'm a the quidditch world cup and death eaters are burning everything, could you get us out of here"
"hey dobby, we need to secretely move harry potter we were wondering if you could transport us, or should we rather use a convoluted plan with broomflight and polyjuice potion"
"hey dobby we need to get into hogwarts secretly, could you get us in or do we have to visit dumbledore's brother so that he can let us through the door"
In the book, you don't hear Hermione's screams. Absolutely terrifying.
Honestly, i'd be as mad as Ron if it was my girlfriend getting tortured like that!
In the book he was significantly madder. Not a fan of the much more reduced reaction in the film, it’s a bit weak and not really in character. Also in the book they take out Petigrew themselves rather than Dobby doing it. So they are much more active in the books. Though I am aware that this whole scene was reduced to keep the film rating down, the torture scene was longer in the books, Ron’s reaction was significantly more distraught, wormtail getting jumped and then strangling himself probably wouldn’t be great for a pg rating, nor would Hermione almost getting eaten by fenrir. So the book scene was honestly better, darker etc… but I see why they changed it.
One of my favorite facts about the torture scene is that Daniel, Tom and Rupert? (Dont know if her was there) needed to removed because they thought Emma was really in pain and strarted to become belligerent.
Don't you just hate it when a person goes "reeeeee!" when you're torturing them?
I noticed that Dobby isn't talking in third person like he usually did
I feel mio's pain- the poor thing
I hope they added Dean Thomas here, he was with them in the book.
Dobby could be more powerfull than any wizard. Including voldemort
Ok after the flash there’s mud on the wall behind Pete that looks like blood… I fucking thought Ron put a suppressed round through his fucking back 😂 fuck, going full ghost recon I see
Lord drakkon help Hermione save her life
1:43
O-of course-, im an elf.. :[
Of course Sir, Dobby is an elf would have been better 🤔
Hermione get that woman out of your face
She can't; otherwise, she would have.
I miss Fred
mauriel mcintosh Who doesnt miss him
I miss him too
I will morph into the lord drakkon
2:14
Get that woman out of your face Hermione
she can’t :(
@@madmax2518 I say get she out of your face
@@lunalg5166 told that bad women talk to Hermione
@@madmax2518 I wish that Hermione got a moment to sock Bellatrix in the final battle like she did Malfoy. But Get Away From My Daughter, You Bitch makes up for it
Who hit wormtall'sback?
It was him who killed off Cedric
@@isaiahtwasabi9402 I know but it was dobby takes wormtall's wand hit back and then lock the rat boy!
Yes Dobby. We all rather like her
In a deleted scene after his death, Luna calls him "Mister Dobby" 💖💖
You know it’s amazing when Luna has beautiful respect for elves
“Who gets his wand?” Lol 😆
1:29 Love Harry's silent reaction: WTF ?! XD
I have to say it's so flipping funny when pettigrew says oooowwwww!! 😂😂
That moment when Luna calls Dobby sir was very sweet and canon. ❤
Whan i was a kid i did not like her
No i think she is cute
2:14 That’s For Betraying Lily & James, And For False Incrimination Against Sirius!
Poor hermoine
I told you keep your hands off my girlfriend
Elves should have enslaved humans not the other way around given their power.
I just don't get it, they could have disapparate ..
Dobby did it why can't they?
I’m not sure but house elf’s can apperate in places like Hogwarts when students can’t so I’m assuming this is basically the same thing
House elf magic is different from wizard magic. That's why Dobby can Apparate and Disapparate from places with the strongest protection spells.
And that’s also why Kreacher survived in the cave where Voldemort hid Slytherin’s medallion
. Wizards are in the habit of ignoring this fact because they consider elves (and not just elves, but goblins too) inferior.
They couldn't. They made it that way on purpose. Otherwise Mr Olivander could have left at any time. I think the whole of the cell area was made to be anti-apparition.
Because elves are stronger and more powerful than humans
Quit hide in the Wall