The Band Everyone Thought Was The Beatles
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 1 июн 2024
- Watch this video ad-free on Nebula: nebula.app/videos/polyphonic-...
If you think this video was worth $3 - ko-fi.com/polyphonic
-
Merchandise: standard.tv/collections/polyp...
TikTok: / watchpolyphonic
Twitter: / watchpolyphonic
Join the Polyphonic Discord: / discord
Theme Music by Pracs: / pracs
00:00 Intro
00:59 Title Card
01:06 Klaatu
01:32 Familiar Sounds
02:51 The Article
04:08 Clues
05:52 Facts
06:53 Fallout
07:19 Conclusion 
Видеоклипы
Are you interested in learning how to make your own video essays?
If so, I've got some exciting news. I'm exploring the possibility of putting together a cohort based course where I can teach video essay skills. This would involve working directly with me and a small group of your peers to put together your own video essay. It would be a hands on class where we would have live sessions learning skills and analyzing other video essays.
This would be less about hard skills like editing in After Effects, and more about high concept knowledge like ideation, creating and sticking to a schedule, writing scripts, and finding visual inspiration.
Right now, I think the price for the first cohort would be ~$800, but I am still playing around with that.
If this is the sort of thing that seems interesting to you, please apply here: ozbx00t5id9.typeform.com/to/a...
The more interest this gets, the more likely it is that this course will come to fruition, so please share this link around as well.
Thanks,
Polyphonic
another moron with a get rich quick failed idea
I hope you get lots of tips, definitely worth a dollar. Good research. I will tip you in the future.
I wish i have a time traveller so i can go to beatles concert.
Lolz probably not the type of responses Polyphonic was hoping for.
A cohort? Can I share the $800 fee among my other cohorts like the nintenfo switch online family plan? Cause I don’t have $800. $100 for a class would still be pretty outrageous when some colleges and universities offer free or reduced classes to some non-students
Imagine being as good as the Beatles that everyone thought you were them until the world found out and then forgot about you.
But they. wasn't as good as the Beatles.
It's easy if you try.
I'd personally be honoured to be compared to The Beatles.
They got paid so I am sure they don't care
Nobody in their right mind thought they were as good as The Beatles lol
Imagine being Klaatu and wanting people to care abt your music rather than who you are, and then everyone starts wondering who you are instead of caring about the music :/
Ironic, isn't it.
Irony used in the correct context.
I think it was kind of their fault. They should have come out immediately and said we're not the Beatles. That way their music would have been the main focus point. Instead they let the rumors continue, which turned their music into a conspiracy theory and entirely something else. Basically the band, record label, and manager played themselves by allowing the music to be turned into a joke. If they wanted their music to stand on its own, they shouldn't have led people to believe that they were the Beatles, which was going to inevitably end up in disappointment.
It was a marketing trick. They sounded just like the Beatles. With all kinds of clues with reference to the Beatles. They knew what they were doing.
Truth is if they didnt sound like the Beatles they never would have gotten a record contract.
Fun fact: The original album release didn’t have the word “Klaatu” above the sun, this was added later when the band gained more popularity. The original release had no wording on the front cover.
No wonder people couldn’t discover them. I think all artists should put their names on their debut album
Still have my album , i won it by being the 910th caller to our local radio station , you know , 1 after 909
And i won my album within the first week of the hoax , getting it as a promo from the radio station , mine has KLAATU over top the sun on front and on moon on back , or Uranus
@@turnupde9918 Your anus, now that's not a nice thing to say!
Now I need to check my copy
A Reporter once said to John Lennon, If the Beatles was still Going on Today, what would you guys Sound like, and John Lennon answered, we Would Sound like E.L.O.
That would be ok. I like ELO
Something tells me that they'd transcend kitschy arena rock drivel.
I love ELO. Would definitely be happy with ELO style Beatles music.
I would be ok with that
Late Beatles did sounds a lot like E.L.O. work, from the mid 1970s, about the time when Lennon made that statement on WNEW-FM in NYC.
But it turns out the real Beatles were the friends we made along the way
hahahahahaha
Goddess of Tea AHAHAHAHAHAHA
@Utah-kin2me? It's only a Northern song...
Fred
Especially if the friends were Paul McCartney, John Lennon, George Harrison, and Ringo Starr.
@@arfansthename i have several Klattu albums on their original vinyl !!
Mom, can we get The Beatles?
- We have Beatles at home.
Beatles at home:
OpiumVEVO LITERALLY THE BEST COMMENT I’VE SEEN SO FAR 😭🤣
@@jonathan7192 I must be dumb, I don't get it...explain please?
Clive Bindley he’s basically using a common meme that mothers tell their children whenever they ask for something, but whatever is “at home” is usually trash compared to what they wanted. And he wants the Beatles, and they have Beatles at home, which is this band 😂😂😂
@@jonathan7192 i feel like its kinda insensitive to call this band "trash". They still were compassionate about their music.
MinceMeat Gaylord no, I didn’t say they are trash, I say that the meme is usually used for trash things, sorry I didn’t make my words more clear ):
Fun Fact: "Calling Occupents of Interplanetary Craft" was covered by the Carpenters a year later on their 1977 release *Passages*.
Imagine the royalty cheques for that !
If you are trying to sound really witty, you'd do a better job of it if you're entirely accurate. The Carpenters album was called "Passage," not "Passages." (I've never heard or read anyone call Al Stewart's "Time Passages" "Time Passage.") It was the first Carpenters album I bought and it was how I learned of Klaatu.
If you are trying to sound rude... you are. No need to correct people so aggressively.
@@bobdavis4848 what are you trying to accomplish
@@norai.5826 I apologize if I worded anything less than optimally, but there is no need to choose to interpret aggression into what I wrote. I made no insult. Growing up, when I’d see the words “fun fact” declared, it was in a media aimed at children, and I’d be more inclined to believe the following was true. It was not always true, and I’d wonder why the writer had and articulated deceptive overconfidence. I was trying to be helpful to viewers, to explain and to give some background. My favorite school subjects included English, and I noticed things like how although many say “less” when “fewer” would have been the grammaticlly correct word, no one seems to make the reverse mistake. That may have been why I wrote the “Time Passages” reference, but also I thought the original commenter might have gotten the Carpenters album title somehow conflated with the song to some degree. The commenter seemed to want to seem witty and I was trying to give free helpful advice, not to be rude. Courtesy is a goal of mine. I'm glad when someone corrects me if I make an error. It was meant as respectful to Jonah that I assumed he'd be fine with it, too. I don't see him expressing hurt feelings, and if he did, I'd further apologize to him for my wording, too. Have a nice day.
Seriously tho, y'all should listen to that album. Calling Occupants, Sub-Rosa Subway and Little Neutrino are criminally underrated
California Jam is my fav, great song to listen with the top down, people always ask me who is that lol
Calling Occupants really is an obscure gem. If it weren't for this video I wouldn't've ever found it.
I haven't heard of this group in literally decades. There was a renewed interest in them years ago.
FR THERE OTHER ALBUMS ARE SO GOOD
@@standard-carrier-wo-chan most people know the Carpenters version
Best tracks by Klaatu:
Hate Me Don't
Raspberry Fields Occasionally
I Desire You (She Has So Much Weight)
24 Hours in the Life
Hey Judy
While My Mandolin Softly Cries
Hate Me Don't featured Yoda on vocals.
How could you forget “The Next Day Always Unknown”
@@Gras_Sho_Pper I'm more of a fan of "Sol is Coming"
Hey Judy ... rofl
Might we record some more tracks, perhaps B-sides?
The Entire Sentence
When I'm 65
Maxwell's Silver Nail
Back in the U.S.S.A
Hardcover Writer
Rained
Orange Submarine
This Boy
And I Liked Her
I Want to Hold Your Ice Cream
How could you forget Night Tripper and Baby You Can Drive my Truck?!?
"Deaf Idiot Journalist Starts Beatles Rumour" is the best headline ever.
Craig Charlesworth
It's good but the best headline ever was in the New York Post:
Headless Woman Found in Topless Bar.
That lying dogfaced pony soldier
@@itwillbefridaythe1354 do you need a hug
@@itwillbefridaythe1354 it was a fucking basic comment lmao noone cares
They roasted the shit outta that guy lmao
Got to admit Sub Rosa Subway has all the flavour of the Beatles…Paul’s bass lines and vocals, George-like guitar licks, Ringo’s drum fills, and John’s lyrical genius and fondness for NYC. Top it all off with a George Martin like use of strings and horns. Klaatu’s music still holds up today!
McCartney pondered how long it would take an audience to recognize them if they started playing on stage in disguise somehow. Lennon responded it would take less than a minute.
McCartney had suggested as a way to put some spark into their recording that they disguise themselves and go play at a pub one evening. Apparently John was against it.
@@tommissouri4871 Never happened. Macca did talk about doing surprise gigs, like he would do in ‘72. No one else was interested. There was never any suggestion of disguises.
Well macca did end up showing up and doing really small surprise gigs around ‘72 with wings
Unfortunately all he had were the rock standards the Beatles used to cover and the songs off of wild life and red rose speedway, not a very good live set
this dont sound alike
@@flamingpi2245 Billy/William is not Macca. Just to get it straight.
never heard of The Beatles but ive been a huge Klaatu fan for awhile.
are you fucking serious
@@Xaviur Obviously not dumbo.
.
Xavoop are you stupid
@@Xaviur r/woooshhh
Isnt this....
exactly what the band didnt want
Everyone seemed to be focoused on who the band was instead of focousing on the music
Yes I agree with that this is the reason why the Beatles stop touring the fans have gone crazy and they don't even care about the Beatles music only to see the Beatles performing and shout like crazy dying fan
@@johnbriancatedrilla4028 Part of it was also that they wanted to do more with the music without being expected to play it live.
A perfect example of how fame can be both a good and bad thing simultaneously.
You can actually fail a drug test from listening to this.
Well maybe that was exactly their plan, someone thought its similar, started rumours, they got famous
It’s sad that when everyone found out it wasn’t the Beatles they stopped listening to klaatu. I mean surely it’s just a testament to how great their music is to be compared to the likes of such a great band, just because it does have John Lennon, Paul McCartney, George Harrison and Ringo Starr doesn’t make them any worse to listen to.
aaa, you know how people r, their Stupid, just because they found out they weren't the Beatles, they Dump the Great, That's real Stupid.
I discovered Klaatu, beacuse calling occupants came on my discover on spotify. I then proceeded to spend the next days listening to all their albums. Hope is just so beautiful
original you know that The Carpenter's did a cover of that track on their last album?
Hope is an amazing album. Such an interesting story told alongside the great compositions. My favorite songs are either prelude or so said the lighthouse keeper.
I love Hope so much, We're Off You Know is so cheery. All of their albums are amazing, but Magentalane is the most beautiful for me.
@@trollanlord85 magentalane is another awesome one. Blue smoke and December dream are my two favs off that
Oh absolutely, it’s probably my 6th or 7th favorite album of all time
"Beatles" has an "a" and a "t" in it. So does Klaatu. Need i say more?
Beatles is a band. So is klaatu
Coincidence? I think not.
dont forget they both have L too
Both are a word and are comprehensible by the human mind
Both make music
Coincidence? Meh! There is no such thing as coincidence
The Beatles released double A sides.
There's a double A in Klaatu..nuff said.
Steve smith is literally the most generic name i could come up with
Lmao
Steve Smith lol
American dad
Steve Smith
RIP
John Jones
Wanting the Beatles to get back together was definitely a thing in the 1970s, culminating with a journalist-driven rumour that John would turn up and play at a certain Wings concert. The only thing I can compare it to is people in the Dark Ages lamenting the Fall of the Roman Empire.
Sure was, I Remember The Jackson 5 had a show and one day am watching it and in the end of the show, Micheal Jackson came out and said that the Beatles was getting back together, and Michael Jackson was so excited, I'll never forget that, this was like 1974 or 1975.....
Nah I was in the eastern Roman empire back then. Wayyy different bruh.
AIUI, in the 70's all four Beatles wanted to get the group back together, but never all four of them at the SAME time.
@@simongleaden2864
If you want to imagine the Beatles in the 70s just take wings, filter out the crap, break up all things must pass and evenly disperse it throughout ten years worth of albums, and sprinkle in the John Lennon hits
My favourite band actually started out as a Beatles ripoff band. They were called Sgt. Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band. Quite sad they only lasted for 3 years.
no you're swtiching them up
🎯🔥
They did in '67..
And they lasted until 1970.
Greatest psyop in music history.
It was 20 years ago today
After Paul McCartney's death of Nov 1966.... They had to hide Billy's true identity!?
Klaatu: we don’t want to be labeled and would rather remain obscure rather than be marked as individual members
Steve Smith: *Does exactly opposite of what they wanted*
medium.com/@ThePhilosophe/ringo-starrs-goodnight-vienna-83736cef882
@@yellowsubmarine6383 thanks for the info yellow submarine
Was Steve Smith later Red Green (and one of Smith & Smith)?
I was in high school in Canada when several people I knew bought & listened to Klaatu and those stupid rumours made there rounds, which I immediately discounted.
I remember as a young kid the rumors of Klaatu being the reunited BEATLES for a while....music fans were so desperate for a Beatles reunion in spite of the success of the solo Beatles at the time.
... its not the same if they're not together :(
yes same with Oasis .. totaly not at the same level
Lol! I remember that also when I was a teen, hell I was waiting for them to reunite. What's so funny is this was a time long before the internet or smart phones, so info traveled much slower.
Had this been during the internet era that rumor would've been debunked fairly quickly.
My theory has always been that Klaatu was a group of studio session musicians who were huge Beatles fans, and were enamored with the "Paul is dead" mythology, who decided to record an album that sounded something like the Beatles and created their own "Beatles reunited" mythology, complete with hints hidden in album tracks and on album covers. Clever. But ultimately, whatever Klaatu's level of fame, it was fame that came from "maybe the Beatles."
I remember this time clearly. Yes, we all hoped it was the Beatles, but we all listened and quickly realized that - while good - this wasn’t a Beatles album. Just a similar type of music a few years later. Years after, I heard (read?) an interview with John Woloschuk who said they were acquaintances of Rush, and saw the negative effects of fame on that group’s lives, so the decided to just stay up identified so they could be normal human beings.
@@jamiewilson3599 Yeah, Rush is also a Toronto band and now really famous today!
@@davidmacphee8348 Yes, I grew up a couple of blocks from Geddy’s house and went to the same schools (a few years after him, but his little brother was a grade behind me). Rush was our local band thst played school dances, small arenas, etc. This was before Neil joined. There are so many Canadian bands and artists, many of whom got started in the Toronto scene of the 60s and 70s.
@@jamiewilson3599 Canada is amazing for its performers but it is a best kept secret. Don't go hurting Americas feelings. They have the BOMB
@@jamiewilson3599 Was that near Jane and Wilson? What area of Toronto was that? Not Yorkville? !! ?
if everyone missed The Beatles try The Son of The Beatles: Electric Light Orchestra
Badfinger was an early band that Apple produced, using songs penned by McCartney & Harrison, I remember people thinking they were grouping with The Beatles, but of course did not. They also recorded Harry Nilsson’s 🎶Without You🎶. Harry was the Beatles favourite American GROUP (he was always just Harry unless he collaborated with John Lennon or others after the Beatles split up.). People really wanted the Beatles reunion so they looked for reasons to believe they were working together. Eventually they each worked with each other, but never all 4 together, as support musicians on individual albums, like they did for others. (Elton, Clapton, Nilsson Etc.) Exception Harrison refused to work with McCartney until they did Beatles Anthology.
Klaatu is the adopted son, they're great, but not remembered
electric light orchestra isnt really similar to the beatles though
Wow, electric light Orchestra does sound like the Beatles, Jeff Lynne is the Beatle that Never was!!!!!!
I think ELO is like a weirdly good mix of beatles, queen and abba
“Deaf idiot journalist starts Beatles rumour” - surely one of the best headlines ever!
'One hundred thousand Yanks'. When the NME was a brilliant paper (i.e. over 30 years ago)
No kidding. Absolutely hilarious
that should have been the video title...
Naturally, the dumb limeys had to get in a dig at the "Yanks."
Amazingly considering what it is now the NME/New Musical Express was the greatest music magazine ever.
Klaatu should have came up with the song like "blueberry Fields occasionally". Or instead of Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds for LSD Klaatu could have had a song called "Tommy in the hills with crystals" meaning THC
Blueberry fields occasionally. 😀😀😀 haha
"Tommy in The Hills with Crystals" is a good idea, and I'm sad to tell you I'll be stealing it for myself !
debby in the mountains with topaz (dmt)
Wow heviy man
Hey Thomas,
Is that where Crystal blue persuasion from Tommy James came from?
A friend of mine in college in the late 70's did a speech in class about why Klaatu was the Beatles. He cited many more reasons including clues on the album cover, the amazing production quality for a band no one ever heard of, and the spoken "it's us" in Sub Rosa Subway. Which btw is a fabulous tune! It's too bad the band didn't get their due because of this. They were quite talented!
Once again, shout out to this video for getting me into Klaatu. Their second album "Hope" is now my favorite album of all time, surpassing every Beatles record lol.
Hope is really good, though I could do without the 'Lone Ranger Theme".
Hope (the song) hits too hard. One of the most beautiful songs I’ve ever heard in my life.
@@oddracir28 "Hope is like a lighthouse keeper's beam." is probably my favorite opening lyric ever. Incredible song, my favorite off the album.
Same here. The middle part of Hope, the song, used to give me chills every time (not anymore though cause I’ve heard it too many times sadly) and they have an all around great discography. They were definitely inspired by the Beatles but went on to be their own thing and make music I can’t imagine the Beatles making but either way I think more people should give them a listen.
In my honest opinion, Klaatu sounds more like ELO, than the Beatles, but I can hear the similarities.
Listen to the Beatles, "Across the universe" song. The song they feature in this video is almost a direct copy of that one in tonality and harmonies.
True!!! Especially the lead singer. Sounds very Jeff Lynne.
Although I have always said that I think ELO was heavily influenced by the Beatles. 😁
@@beckyhunter3035 I literally think almost every single band which formed in the late 60s or early 70s were influenced by the Beatles. In many interviews, so many of those artists admit to that openly. Ozzy Osbourne, for example, stated The Beatles as one of his original reasons for forming Sabbath (as strange as that combination sounds).
DigiFootage FX oh, I know! Even most Christian artists say the same thing. It’s definitely strange, but I mean the Beatles were genius so it actually makes a lot of sense.
The vocalist sounds more like george harrison than paul mccartney
jacobjallen Almost like a mix between em
John Lennon-ish too.
I don’t hear any of the Beatles, the quality of vocals, lyrics, an musician ship not remotely close to, John, Paul, George or Ringo
degree7 sounding similar and the same are not the same thing, it’s very obvious not Paul MacCartney
degree7 do a comparison listen to Klaatu sub rosa subway it was realsed in 1976 then listen to Paul McCartney and Wings Let ‘Em in also release in 76 that sound like the same voice
Klaatu's Hope album was one of the most influential in my teen years. My older brother had the album cover as a mural on his bedroom wall, and to this day I find myself writing material that echoes those songs, along with ELO and Genesis. What a golden age of music we lived through. What an amazing experience that album was!
If you lived in Toronto you knew who Klaatu was. A great Canadian Band.
I bet that conspiracy was absolutely fantastic for their record sales.
lol exactly what i thought. Probobly why Capitol records kept giving cryptic answers and telling people to find clues in the album
Which is exactly why The Beatles thought it up and left fake clues on their albums.
Clive Bindley no that’s a totally different topic
@@josecorrales7998 Actually it isn't. All the clues they put on albums were there to generate more interest and more sales.
Actually, not really.
Their songs "Do You Want to Know a Rumor?", "In My Wife" and "Yellow Sub sandwich" did not make the charts.
At least “ Sup Dude” did
@@coypandora0795 "Cum Together" failed as well
"Gotta get you into my wife" :D
Like "Here Comes The Sunscreen" and "The Long and Brother Road"
@@wind_2876 The Long And Brother Road, I don't get that one,
why " Brother "? Why not The Short And Straight Path?
Listen to "The Rutles" and you'll hear the nearest thing to the Beatles. Neil Innes fronted them and they were really amazing !
R I P Neil 👍👍👍👍👍👍
ALL you need is cash 💖
Love The Rutles! The work Neil Innes did was amazing. Everyone who knows “I Am the Walrus” should listen to “Piggy In the Middle,” and marvel at Innes’ achievement! ruclips.net/video/FKezWLZqRik/видео.html
@@ahcapella Dirk, Stig, Nasty, and Barry...
They enjoyed the pleasant effects of tea
They are great!
The closest thing to a Beatles reunion will be Free as a Bird and Real Love.
And "All Those Years Ago"
Anthology in general.
@@MellowCorn-xs8bn Why? Was Paul on that one?
and anything Yoko does! that lady is talented.
@@MellowCorn-xs8bn - That was just George's song, not a technically-created Beatles song like "Free As A Bird" and "Real Love".
Imagine if The Beatles were Canadian the whole time
Imagine? Of course they were Canadian! That made it a lot easier for Bernard Purdie to fly in to play drums for all of their recordings:
ruclips.net/video/hz9EGGiOuso/видео.html
She Loves Ya, Eh? Eh? Eh?
Eh Jude
Yeah right, or aliens of some kind huh? Some comment!
@@danielblanchet7577 John Alien, Paul Mercury, George Heir-of-the-sun, and Ringo... um, Saturn? No... Sorry, cant think of one for Starr...
Let me guess, this video is about Sgt. Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band. Those guys sound eerily like the beatles.
LOL
Drugs do that.... u know.. 👀
what kind of drugs are you on? those guys sound NOTHING like the beatles! the sgt pepper guys are just wannabes, dont compare them to the fame of the beatles!
@@julianstraubel1395 I think Cheap Trick did the Beatles close when they covered St. peppers album, and they were called “The American Beatles” but no band could ever be confused with the original Beatles!!!!!!
Now you’re just being ridiculous.
"Calling Occupants" was covered by The Carpenters and they made it a top 40 hit.
Doesn't sound half as good as the original.
@@LSUfan Yeah it sounds like ass
Klaatu was magical and a league of their own
This video introduced me to Klaatu and now they are one of my favorite bands of all time ❤️
Imagine how odd it must be to watch people “decode” your lyrics and choices and contribute it all to some grand conspiracy.
I don't put anything past this species.
I mean Lennon wrote I Am The Walrus without any meaning on purpose and people still found meaning out of it anyway
Some people have a lot of time on their hands
It's easy if you try...
That’s how politicians and Hollywood people feel when Alex Jones analyzes their lives to this whole Illuminati conspiracy lol
I always found that Electric Light Orchestra was the band who has the closest sound of The Beatles...never hear about Klaatu, seems really good, a new thing to discover.
Well, ELO was more proggy than The Beatles, and I think that if the Beatles were around in the 70's, instead of going into prog-ish direction the would've gone more psychedelic. I just can't think of any examples of how The Beatles would've sound like because it is such a trip to imagine, they could've went anywhere! One can just imagine.
Ya jeff lynne was influenced by them and theye closer than this band or oasis to them.
But there will never be another beatles....period
I think someone once said that ELO tried to be like the Beatles if they were never stopped their psych Pepper like sound in 1967.
Definitely check out KLAATU. I remember them well and still have the first two albums. They really have a Beatle - Wings vibe.
In my opinion big star had a few Beatles-esque moments throughout their albums
I was a teen in the mid 1970s and bought the initial Klaatu LP. I still listen to their music and find it harmonious and catchy.
As a Canadian youth at the time, I remember buying this album in 1978 in a discount bin. I continued to seek out every album I could find and eventually had them all. I was hooked as a fan even to this day. Long live Politzania!
my favorite song is “I am the Seal” by Klaatu
i am the egg man..kookookachoo
I like " I wanna hold your Ham " and " Saskatoon berry fields forever "
@@zerkfiter i am the chicken man**
My favorite Beatles songs are Above-Rosa Railway and Purplestreet
Amalia ichilov mine personally is stand still and whisper
The band that everyone thought was Led Zeppelin......
Greta Van Fleet
Ha! And Rush back before they were known.
And 80's rock band Kingdom Come
Good one 😂
😂😂
Nope that was Rush...
Ngl though, “Calling Occupants of Interplanetary Craft” slaps
I was 16 years old and living in Rhode Island when this Klaatu/Beatles controversy hit. I remember it well.
Why didn't anyone ask The Beatles..?
They would've denied it either way
sunbeam this is true. 😂
@@santi-xj1qr Exactly. If they officially denied it it would probably cause more people to believe it.
Plus, people just like mysteries and a lot don't want the definitive answer because that would just ruin it for them.
Nobody considered the fact that if the Beatles wanted to reunite, they would have.
Paul would have probably forgot
George would.have ferociously denies it
Paul is gonna deny it, but is gonna hinting something
John would neither deny nor confirm it, too busy with Yoko
Ringo would...deny it but getting a bit emotional
Mr. Blue Sky By Electric Light Orchestra also caused this same craze, and if you listen its obvious why
yup, Mr. Blue Sky is extremely reminiscent of "A Day in the Life", especially with the "running down the avenue" section, which mirrors Paul's "Found my way downstairs and drank a cup, and looking up I noticed I was late".
No, it didn't. ELO were a hugely popular group well before their Out of the Blue album, on which "Mr. Blue Sky" appeared. From the very beginning, they were compared to the Beatles, and both John Lennon and George Harrison were quoted in the media praising the sound of the young band in the early 1970s, John said in a radio interview that ELO was like "Beatles, Jr.". The members of ELO were well-known, the principal members having come from the band The Move: Roy Wood, Jeff Lynne, Richard Tandy and Bev Bevan. The members' names were published on the sleeve of every album. Their leader, primary songwriter and main producer, Jeff Lynne, readily admitted that he idolized The Beatles (and their producer George Martin). Their music does have many elements in common with the Beatles because of their influence on Lynne's songwriting and producing, but they were never, in my recollection, ever actually confused with The Beatles. Comparisons, yes. Craze, no.
@@Weird_Old_Uncle_Kenny well, uh, in america most everyone thought that mr blue sky was the beetles. not sure where you're from
No it didnt
@@Weird_Old_Uncle_Kenny glad somebody knows their shit
I feel like most bands can be called the band that wasn't the Beatles
all bands exepet for the beatles can be called that
The Family - Great point. That tickled my sense of humour!
Thank you so much for this video. Without it, I wouldn't have discovered Klaatu. They were an amazing band
Shoutout to Polyphonic for always introducing or reintroducing me to good music.
Angel Mejia
You should see Polyphonic Pam!
+Eric Gudmunsen
You're right, polythene spam
Opening the video like "He best be talking about Klaatu..." AND WAS NOT DISAPPOINTED
Well, duh! It could only have been Klaatu! Or the Dukes of Stratosphear. Or Two Lips. Or The Rutles. Or the Fraternal Order of the All. Or Utopia. Or Stackridge. Or the Aerovons. Or Sloan. Or ELO. Or The Pillbugs. Or The Masked Marauders. Or Tears For Fears. Or The Knickerbockers. Or Oasis. Or...
Then again, the thumbnail has become quite a damning hint.
Tears for Fears? What song from TFF reminded you of the Beatles?
@@DibIrken You can't guess?: thedailybeatle.blogspot.com/2010/01/inspired-by-beatles-sowing-seeds-of.html
@@kenlieck7756 I checked Wikipedia and it said it's the reviewers giving that connection to The Beatles.
I agree that there is that 60's psychedelic vibe to Sowing The Seesd of Love but unless I hear anyone from Tears for Fears saying they were inspired by The Beatles then I ain't buying it. They could've sampled any 60's song. :/
Plot Twist: It was actually the REAL Paul who was brought back to life but didn't want to create a huge scandal.
Stupid faul believer
@clifford heywood imma just put this plain and simple. you are really really stupid
@clifford heywoodyes, just incredibly brain dead
@clifford heywood ??..
Unbelievable. You make a funny joke, and the trolls come out to crucify you. For shame.
I never moved on. Got my first Beatles album when I was four. The breakup was announced six months later. Never got over it. Then while I was waiting for my school bus with my parents home stereo on, it was announced that John had been shot 45 just mins from my home in NYC. Felt like the world ended. I was the first person to he picked up on my bus every morning, and as I walked on, the hollow look on my grief stricken bus driver as her eyes met mine is something I’ll never forget.
"just 45 mins" and "to be picked up"
I got my first Beatle album when I was 12. It was 1964. The album was “Meet the Beatles”. I got enjoy the whole Beatle ride. I was lucky!
In ‘The Day The Earth Stood Still’, 3:47 EST is the time the spaceship carrying Klaatu (and Gort) land in Washington, D.C.
Nicefisher
I guess the Mona Lisa is old fart art
Klaatu barrada nictu
i was a canadian kid when klaatu came out. we all listened to them but nobody thought they were the fab four. they did have a beatlesque sound but a lot of people were doing that at the time. smoked a few j's while listening to klaatu, the good old days.
You probably remember the Beatles tribute band "Liverpool", they had a couple of hits, "Dolly Don't go Away", but were dead-ringers for the fab four sound.
now you can be an adult smoking a j listening to klaatu
3:47 EST is legit a great album, one of my favorites ever.
Klaatu were not The Beatles, ofc, but still should've had way more attention.
Seemed like Badfinger always had that strong "Beatles-esque" kind of thing going on.
That's because they were signed to Apple Records... I believe that at least one of their hits were actually written by a Beatle or two, and I think at least one of their albums was produced by a Beatle or two.
@@keithmendez6915 That would explain a lot, I was not aware of that. Thanks for the info.
Something I didn’t know about Badfinger, Peter Hamn wrote Nielsen’s “Without You”
Try the knickerbockers " lies " for a Beatle sound
@@beatles1000 He wrote Badfinger's version too!
I'm from Rhode Island and I ran to the local record store (yes such things actually existed) when that Providence Journal article came out. Had to special order the album. You would not believe the excitement of me and my friends when it finally arrived and we had a listening party in my bedroom. I'm going to listen to some Klaatu today! Thanks for reminding me.
ah a fellow statesman. good to see
ayyy rhode island gang
did you go to newburry comics?
Rhode island gang!
I remember a song called "Lies" by the Knickerbockers that many people thought was really the Beatles.
I discovered Klatuu from this great presentation of their music. They have become one of my favorite bands! I literally listen to them everyday now! Magentalane is my favorite tune of theirs. Tokeymore Field is also an endless delight! They are like the Beatles and The Beach Boys blended together. Honestly these Canadian lads are good musicians and good guys😊
I had the pleasure of playing Piano on their Magentalane album back in '80...Canadian Rock Royalty...
What track was the most fun for you to play on?
wait really????!!!!
George Bertok Your work on Blue Smoke is great 🤟
For real? Cool man
Did Hugh Sime do the album artwork? Kind of looks like his work.
For someone who had no clue who Klaatu were this was an awesome video! Well done.
Quantickzz I heard about them through the channel “This Exist.”
@@ThisIsReadyMade why do I think that's your channel xD
I only heard Calling Occupants of Interplanetary because of Carpenters.
Quantickzz Wintersun
ThisIs ReadyMade I had heard of them before, but This Exists made me actually download their album.
In November 1965 a New Jersey band called "The Knickerbockers" released a single, "Lies" which they had intentionally written and recorded to sound like a British Invasion band's song. It reached the top 20 in that year. It's very good and it really does sound like a Beatles recording.
I remember that song and I always thought it was the Beatles Till I found out it wasn't
The video that started it all!!!! THIS is how I got into Klaatu...while scrolling through my RUclips feed in 2019 I came across this video and was SURPRISED...subbed to Polyphonic and became a fan right away.
Anyone who actually thought these guys were the Beatles knows nothing about the Beatles. The vocals alone give it away that it's not the Beatles.
It was just wishful thinking. People wanted to believe that the Fab Four were back.
Indeed.
Klaatu sounds more like ELO, slightly like a McCartney's solo project to me; but definitely not like the Beatles in a whole.
Well a lot of idiots actually believe that Paul died so I am not surprised about some people believing that Beatles came back...
I can't hear a Beatles sound but rather ELO. Like others have pointed out, the vocals are not even close to the Beatles.
Like people actually thinking Your Old Droog was somehow Nas. Fanatics will believe anything
Klaatu was actually a very good band. They had nothing to do with starting or perpetuating the Beatles rumor, but their label Capitol didn't mind the attention and dodged questions to keep the mystery going. 347 EST, and Sir Army Suit, which contained cartoon caricatures of the three members on the cover mixed in with caricatures of several other people, were particularly good albums. No one would realize their faces were on the cover until one of their subsequent albums would show an actual picture of them. Years after Klaatu's breakup one of the members, Dee Long I believe, stayed in the music business and actually met Paul McCartney in a studio in England. Dee relayed the Klaatu/ Beatles rumor story to Paul, who had never heard of the band or the rumor, nor had any if the other Beatles members apparently. As good a band as they were, the closest Klaatu came to having mainstream success was having the Carpenters score a hit with one of their songs, Calling Occupants of Interplanetary Craft.
i like the Klaatu version way better than the Carpenter's ..............
My daughter's name is Christine because I was driving home from working midnight shift in a factory in Michigan in 1978 and Dear Christine by Klaatu came on the radio. It took 7 years to welcome my daughter Christine into the world, and she's just as beautiful as the song is. I had every LP Klaatu made. And I never thought they were the Beatles.
Thanks to this video I actually ended up getting in Klaatu and their later music. I have loved this channel since I saw this video three years ago and I'm so glad it thriving
‘Hope’ by Klaatu is such a beautiful masterpiece, especially the title track, puts tears in my eyes
Burr Anderson Doesn’t mean it isn’t a stunning, amazing record
Roger Coley bro have you listened to that shi???????? hope is an instant classic album for me. it tells an amazing story as a concept album. every song on it is A+. “Prelude” fuses rock and classical music in a way that queen never could
Genuinely the greatest album I've ever heard. Side 1 is already fantastic, but then side 2 somehow manages to be exponentially better, with songs like "Prelude" and "Hope" being absolute masterpieces.
@@MidosujiSen Yes, Hope is great, but I would say Pet Sounds is the best album I’ve ever heard 😉
My favorite Klaatu album is the last one, Magentalane. Absolute gem!
Me before video: "It's Oasis isn't it?"
After video "Oh, okay.."
this comment made me spit out my drink, this was too good.
LmAo
SAME 😭😭
thought it may be The Kinks
Excellent! A good voice and pace.... And great info on the band. I was aware of some of this but your details embellish brilliantly. Thanks
Klattau....very kool fusion trio... I was floored when I heard the Carpenter's cover of "Calling Occupants". It was a great job they did on that cover. Sad that it got WAY more airtime than the orginal.
A huge beatles fan and woowww ima listen to this album
Do you listen to ELO btw? They have quite a few songs that remind me of the Beatles, check them out too!
@@naejimba Heck, ELO's 2001 album ZOOM had more Beatles on it (2) than it had members of ELO (1)!
Of course I listen to Elo! U kidding
Bet you enjoyed it
DespacitoGamer420 I did
Klaatu is one of the most underrated bands of all time
Great band. I never thought they were the Beatles.
They just sounded American and nothing like the Beatles. But I really liked their second album especially.
The Hope album is a masterpiece in every sense of the word, unreal album. Side 2 of that thing is better than most of the Beatles' catalogue in my opinion.
@@thisperson5294 Canadian bands were always assumed to be American.
@@MidosujiSen Agreed. I need to give it another listen. Been a long time for me.
This was a really interesting album at the time. I had this on an 8 track tape.
that ad segway was so clean i’m actually not skipping it
The moment I saw the title I knew it was about Klaatu 😃
Same
i just discovered this band and they are so good !!
Same, my grandpa told me about a year ago that in one of their songs they play a dog whistle and whenever he played the song on vinyl their dog would go crazy
Guilty.
Cliché...
Stumbled on this video. I saw Klaatu at my high school in 1982. GREAT band.
klaatu never toured
american joe maybe *Klaatu* did though?
@@vtwinbuilder3129 Ask Dave Bingham.
bingola45 the baseball coach?
@@vtwinbuilder3129 The Lead Singer & Harmonica.
For a momento I though you finally were going to make a video about The Band, my all time favourite band in history. Great video!
Little Neutrino and So Said The LightHouse Keeper are some of the most HeartWrenching songs I ever heard
Everyone? As an old timer I can tell you that almost no one bought into the Klaatu are The Beatles rumors. Klaatu certainly sounded like they were influenced by The Beatles, like a lot of bands in the early 70s, but very few people at the time took seriously the idea that they were The Beatles re-united, it was just a weird theory that was briefly out there.
I never bought into the beatles thing, but I was stunned they were Canadians. When I first heard the album 'Hope' on vinyl and a decent sound system, I was druling, I was wondering and still do how they plastered so many amazing sounds together. They did not have the electronic kit we have now, On a couple pieces, they played the individual strings of a piano, to get that harp sound
No doubt they were influenced by the Beatles and some of the experiments they did in the studio. Dee Long has spoke about some of tricks they used in some interviews. Sort of ruins the magic, but it is worth knowing
I was 23 in 1977 and big Beatles fan. People DID think - or wonder (for like it) - that it could be the Beatles. But only for a short period of time, a few months. A rumored supposed reason for the subterfuge was that the Beatles wanted their new music to be judged on its musical merits, not through their massive fame. After all, it had been seven years since 1970 when the last Beatles new music (Let It Be LP) was released. For me, though, the more I heard Klaatu, the less it sounded exactly like the Beatles. I finally realized it wasn't them, well before the cover lid of secrecy was blown off.
Quite a few bands are inspired by their mentors... I've heard a few singers that sound like any of the Beatles, Bowie, etc., and so the secrecy really inspired the whole conspiracy theory... I mean... who didn't want the Beatles back together? Their legacy, even after a few years was still very strong, and Capitol would have jumped on this group like a bitch in heat... which, apparently... they did! LOL :-)
Frankly, I would give Klaatu the Badfinger!
@@glennmercer191 hahaha :-)
Listened to 'Calling Occupants' for five seconds and could instantly tell that it wasn't The Beatles.
I thought it was The Carpenters.
@@FigmentSALabel They wrote it
@@chroniclesofbap6170 The song was covered by The Carpenters, the original is by Klaatu
@@chroniclesofbap6170 See ... this is one of the problems with the internet. People can spread misinformation so easily. I mean ... it's so easy to do a quick search and think, "Wait ... before I say this ... is it really true?" It takes about 10 seconds to verify that, in fact, the Carpenters did not write it. Yet you decided instead to spew misinformation.
It's the same on FaceBook with everyone spreading memes that they don't bother to verify simply because it supports their agenda. This is indeed the age of misinformation.
@@chadjohnson-authormusician8072 I'd rather be mistaken than a self-sanctimonious massive twat who pretends he never made a mistake in his entire honey-blessed life. You awful little turd. I bet you practice onenism in front of the mirror so you can admire yourself whilst patting yourself on the back for being perect. I can smell your smug from here. You could have just been informative like the guy above who had already made the point, but your ego went into overdrive and you had to show the world that you knew it too. Sad little fucker.
Klaatu’s best songs:
She likes you.
Love me don’t.
Average mystery tour.
Coin lane.
Klaatu is my favorite band, and the few Beetles songs I listen to are the ones that sound like Klaatu songs to me like Maxwell's Silver Hammer and such
If anyone thought that Klaatu were The Beatles did not listen with both ears.
Makes sense, I lost the hearing in my left ear completely a few years ago and music no longer sounds the same.
@@nicovargas7776 That sucks! For about 20 years I played in a very LOUD rock band.
Back then we did not use any ear protection. My left ear is not the best either.
I played bass and my amp was taller than me. I used to put my left ear directly
on the speaker to see if I still was in tune. Young and stupid! Luckily I was aware of
Klaatu as soon as they released their first album in 1976.
@@patmarcy1210 its okay, i actually wouldn't wish to gain back the hearing i losf if i had the chance. i can still listen to music, I am learning American sign language, going to school (i get notetakers and captionists because i cant hear my teachers or classmates even with hearing aid but no learned to read lips too and so far 4.0 for every semester going on 4th semester now), and I like that I can remove my hearing aids when I want to escape and not hear anything, I no longer hear my boyfriend's loud snoring so I sleep like a baby, and I actually drive better without the random and loud noises that catch my attention and distract me lol only thing that sucks is going to the movies or being in a situation with more than 2 other people directly in front of me and facing me such as being in large rooms, far away from people, background noises, etc like restaurants, parties, and bus stations etc.
@@nicovargas7776
As long as you're happy. You seem to be pretty well adjusted!
I've put on this album by Klaatu to listen to now. It actually sounds a lot more like the Panic At The Disco abum Pretty Odd (which is a 60s psychedelia album which is already very beatles-like anyway and is a great album if you like the genre of 60s psychedelia). The melodies sound very similar to the panic in the disc album, and the instrumentation, even the album cover art. I wouldn't be surprised if Panic was inspired by this album as much as they were Sgt peppers
I remember the hype back in 1976. Wishful thinking, that’s all it was. If anything, Klaatu’s music was more or less continuing in a style of the Beatles, similar to perhaps early ELO.
Nah, I could always hear XTC being the natural evolution of the Beatles sans breakup...
_Calling Occupants_ is now one of my favorite songs of all time, and It's a shame what happened to them.
I listened to this album last night and quite frankly, its one of my favourite albums now
Wow. Big Beatles fan here. Never knew about this band...
That makes two of us.
Three of us
A Fab FOUR of us!
Actually I assumed this would be a out Badfinger. I've heard that their Beatlesque sound and the fact that Paul actually wrote a song or two for them led to folks wondering about similar notions.
Dave Rucci same
seriously??
I didn’t even know what Klaatu was before this video.
My friend owns this on vinyl... We've never listened to it, only agree it looks cool.
“Everyone” thought it was the Beatles ? Bull crap. I was a teenager and into music when Klaatu’s album came out. I remember watching a TV show called Flashez where it was discussed that it could be the Beatles and the commentator specifically said he thought IT WASNT THEM. I and many others hoped it would be them but when I got the album and listened to it I could tell it wasn’t them. It’s too rocky and American sounding to be the Fab Four. There is one song which sounds like Lennon (Dr Marvello?) singing but the rest is clearly unlike them. Having said that, I love KLAATU. This album is a piece of genius work. This and the follow up album feature elements of Steampunk way before it was a thing. And the final track of album one - Little Neutrino- is a piece of cosmic transcendence for the ear and mind. Kinda like travelling on Metron’s chair through time and space. Brilliant band but they couldn’t maintain their creative output. Long live Klaatu 👊🏼
You're right. At best, a lot of people thought that it "might" be the Beatles, because of what a bunch of industry insiders eluded to. And, like you said, it turned a lot of folks on to a pretty good album. Within a year and a half or so, most of the hub-bub was gone and by the time SIR ARMY SUIT came out, all was forgotten.
Hey Al (Alfred Beach? LOL) -- great comment, nice to see Klaatu still (somewhat) relevant 45 years later -- I've been on a one-man crusade to spread the word for years! One of my favorite memories of '76 when I was 9, and beyond; I have "Klaatu" (aka 3:47 EST) and "Hope" 40th Anniversary CD digipak remasters (superb reissues with original & new artwork, lyrics, etc. -- look them up!). The only slight issue I have is that Doctor Marvello sounds more like George Harrison than Lennon (and it's also in the "reluctant" Beatle's more trippy, mystical mode than J.L. would've written) -- and, also, WHAT ABOUT "Sub Rosa Subway" ?! That's one of the best, almost dead-on Paul McCartney impersonations EVER, and the elaborate, ornate composition, replete with symphonic touches & flourishes, suggests Sgt. Pepper / Magical Mystery Tour era Beatles at their finest... Agree wholeheartedly with "Little Neutrino" -- there's never been a song like it before or since (used to include it on "head" mix tapes & CDs for "music to get high by" LOL -- stands proudly alongside "Kashmir," "Us And Them" and any other cloud you'd care to ride...
@@markchristopher420 Another good track in that vein is Fearless 😅
As for Klaatu , I agree the Dr Marvello track could sound like George yes true. The Sub Rosa to me always sounded like the guys were trying hard to replicate Paul’s singing but- to my ears at least,- it obviously wasn’t (I listen to a lot of Wings- a lot!). It is a great homage no doubt.
I encourage you on your endeavour to plug Klaatu. They were unfortunate to get caught up in a Beatles conspiracy no doubt encouraged by greedy record company. But they were awesome and unlike anybody else in music.
@@alhugo4722 You have a good ear, my friend! Hey, another tragically under-rated band with completely different circumstances is TNT -- Norway's finest export, in my honest opinion. They started as a 'power metal' type of band in the early-mid 80's but became so much more than that as the years went by. Ronni Le Tekro is hands-down one of the sickest guitarists you've never heard of (or maybe you have LOL), endorsed by Dokken's George Lynch, Zakk Wylde (ex-Ozzy, Black Label Society) and Pantera's late, great Dimebag Darrell. They ALL tipped their hat to Ronni, whose Brian May fetish is apparent but he also takes it to the next level with machine-gun shred and stunningly acrobatic yet tasteful solo forays. TNT's singer, Tony Harnell (from New York, I believe) hits notes only dogs can hear :-) Their three best discs are (probably) "Tell No Tales" (1987), "Intuition" (1989) and "Realized Fantasies" (1992), although one particular CD from later years, 2004's "My Religion" is quite ridiculous, too. They were a quirky, unique band with an immediately identifiable sound and penchant for heartbreakingly beautiful power ballads like "Child's Play/Smooth Syncopation," "Northern Lights" and maybe their finest composition, "Lionheart." Enjoy, if you do check 'em -- highly recommended!!
I remember Flashez. Mike Meade was a Beatlemaniac (like me). I recall him discussing it, and I recall thinking it unlikely this would be the Beatles.
Don t forget the first Badfinger releases..they were the first to fire up the sounds that had folks feeling the Beatles had re-united using a different name
The artwork and the sound of the music gave me pretty. odd. vibes. I know that was years later and Panic! was inspired by the Beatles but the first song in this video by Klaatu reminded me so much of Behind The Sea by Panic! At The Disco. If you liked Klaatu and the Beatles you should give that song/the album a try!
Yeah exactly. I really think Panic must have been inspired by this album when they made Pretty Odd as much as they were by Sgt peppers
Thoughts on Jellyfish?....
You failed to mention that “calling occupants” became a top 40 cover hit by the carpenters in 1978.
ruclips.net/video/teBV0EoJJY8/видео.html
Irrelevant
Percy Phelps Very relevant. It is quite an interesting trivia point that a cover song by a very obscure group actually made the top 40
Back then there were some who claimed that this proved Klaatu were connected to the Carpenters as it was claimed that the Carpenters didn't do covers.
JohnJ469 which of course is preposterous because the carpenters did not write songs, they just covered really good artists like Paul Williams and Bert Baccarach
Thank you for the great finding will look up and purchase their cd shortly,hope you and your friends prosper greatly.
I listened to the album in 1976 and just thought it was great music. I still sing some of their songs because they were so unique and wonderful
Still, music was so much better, back then, than it is these days. The 1970s,1980s are so much better then music playing today.