This is something that all music teachers should keep in mind!! I’m glad about Bantureethi correction , it has been sung the wrong way by many popular musicians. Great work 👏🏻
Bantu reeti koluvu.....so beautiful. The variations in bhavam for Rama nama mane....... just divine. I loved the way how Shri. Dushyanth Sridharji builds the narrative & Shri. Bharath Sundarji's rendition. 👌👌
I cried cried and cried right from the bottom of my heart for the Mokshaprapthi. (Yes Samasreyanam and Bharanyasam were blessed. Acharyan : Srimad Rangaramanuja Mahadesikan 🙏🙏🙏🙏. Nana deshakalali.......Ninne gathi enba nambithanu. ..
Superb concept ... Something which I have been thinking about a lot ... The syntax is a must but that's only for a greater cause ... It's about the feel, the devotion which the original composer has gone through ... Something which we get to feel in every rendition of MS Amma
Today I cried Several times while I was able to understand that an act mastered was short of higer realisation when a new varient is unexplored. A jugalbandhi not only enlightened both of them and many listening. A big thank you
Biduuuuuuu.... how much can you bring the emotions of the composer out when you understand the context? Beautiful. Thank you for this excellent conversation and program
There were times where musicians knew at least two south Indian languages. And Sanskrit ! I am convinced that with technology , access to learning resources is high ... Current day musicians must spend time on language learning besides voice culture etc etc etc...
Absolutely mesmerising,thought provoking,enjoyable ,blissful,enchanting,what more can Isay…..Simply out of vocabulary to appreciate.Two intellectuals two artists ,two musicians ,two devotees, two with profound knowledge ,how else would the programme be!
Great going - both of you. I had half a dozen goose bumps in part 1,2 and 3. To me - Kannada was best, the explanation and singing brought tears in my eyes. Keep it up!!
Wonderful and intesting discussion by the two stalwarts on the importance of understanding sahityam while rendering carnatic krithis which were composed by the Vaggeyakarars.
Beautiful programme They are not youngsters. According to me they are very old in their knowledge. Music only is their life. Evlo azaghu singing and also explanation. Our best wishes.
God bless both of you. Saraswati resides in you on your tongue and Vishnu in your mind and lakshmi in your heart (prosperity distributed by the knowledge and intent). The breathe of Hanuman as a wind god connecting the jeevatma to paramatma. God bless you
Thank you so much Dushyanth. Just two days back I had a discussion with my junior who happened to sing bantu reeti koluvu as bantu reeti kolu viyavayya rama Nama rama mane as nama rama maaane.......Had to argue with her that she was singing incorrectly .... Will share her this video hopefully she trusts what I said was true.
I was brought up in North and when I lived I got a different bhakti marg but when I came back to tamilnadu not able to read or write tamil. Even speaking you have a senthil/goundermani as one to emulate......as age catches up for bhakti find that my younger breed here are here to teach. I have a pleasure to learn from the younger flock and my understanding is better due to my experience of life
Great to know about Vidwan Sethalapathi Balasubramaniam. His Tamizh viruttam on Muruga from Kandaralankaram was so moving and touching the heart. Om Muruga, Hare Krishna
Thanks Madrasana for having this conversation. The viruttam by Shri Balasubramanium was so beautiful. Thanks to Bharat for playing. Not many recordings are available in the public space and I have heard a lot about his viruttams
Beautiful and loved every bit. The importance of Sahithyam truly stood out. The wonderful message of 'sahithyam rounds-off music' was brilliantly put across
This is brilliant. There were so many things we learnt from watching this.. can't wait to watch other episodes. Both Dushyant and Bharat are ao good and knowledgeable. We need more of such conversations..🙏
Absolutely amazing!! Loving Bantureethi Rama naama mane!!! What a magic, understanding the meaning and various interpretations is a powerful weapon by itself in rendering krithis
Excellent and blessed to hear this conversation 🙏 Naragolage Bidhu - Very true (I and Me) - the whole issue in the world is because as we all fall into this well of I and Me - Thank you 🙏 🙏🙏
Had Goosebumps throughout!! Thanks to both of you legends to bring in this new concept and it's most important to understand the context and the mood let it be any language . Hats off to both of you!!
Awesome! The context and meaning of sahityam definitely adds to the bhavam which is so important.Discussions bears that out.Look forward to next episode.
Mad rasana you are doing a great job! It is very helpfull and useful for music learners. Thank you so much. Expecting more videos from your team. I subscribed your channel after listening to" maa mayura " for the first time. All the best !!😊
I really loved the conversation about Sangeetha and sahityam .at the same time how understanding the sahityam will bring immense bhava am.thank you so much.
Novel concept @Madrasana Official, congratulations! Important to invoke the context as it does gets conveyed in the form of singer's involvement during the rendition of the kriti and also for a rasika(listener) as not only does it move you instantaneously but also transports you immediately into the story as if you are watching from behind the scenes.
We are pro any language that beautifully praises the Bhagawan. All have their own unique beauty, whether it is Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Hindi, Sanskrit or any other language. Language is just a means of communication, something that should bring us together and closer. instead the politicians of my state(Tamil Nadu) use it as an excuse to create conflict and discrimination to separate us as a people, meanwhile their children go to international schools where they learn Hindi, French, English and so on.
@@podangadubukus what I mean is , Brahmins follow North Indian narrative in Tamil Language as they know tamil and are Tamilians ie.. I mean the Thanjavur Shiva is a tamil ancestor for local Tamil people on the contrary to brahmins as the same shiva for brahmins is a god from north indian mountain Kailash. Hence there is a disconnect ie.. Tamil Brahmins are people who belive in a North Indian narrative with Tamil as their mother tongue and idly sambar as their food. When people say Brahmins are Pro - hindi it is because of their cultural orientation / narrative is the same as North Indians / hindi / sanskrit rather than Tamil.
@@bharathmurali712 it’s not the simple ... Tamil iyers are devout murugan, iyyapan, amman, followers and Iyengar’s are Andal and all the versions of perumal followers which are all very very distinctively Tamil and no connection to north India. Also Tamil Brahmins personally fail to associate with north Indians and their culture..
As a practitioner, performer and choreographer of kūchipūdi style of dance ,this is very very interesting, informative and helpful session. Thank you so much and waiting for more and more such wonderful sessions .🙏🙏🙏
Thank you. I do believe the singer brings something more to the song when they know the context and meaning. We were told the story and context before even the first note was taught to us. One thing, I almost wished your whole conversation was in Tamil .. of course for the larger audience it had to be in a mix of Tamil & English! At least more Tamil than English maybe!
Superb, waiting for many more such conversations. A small suggestion, please increase the number of songs you take up for sahitya and exploration. . But both of you, great job.
Excellent Mahesh and Madrasana team!! A very beautifully done video with great insights into how Sahityam is the essence. Would be great to see a Carnatic with a Hindustani performer talking about the similarity and differences in their experiences, especially how they treat the same Ragam / Raag. Congratulations once again!!👍👍👏👏💥💥🌈🌈
Dushyanth u interview & u r questions to the point to Bhirth sunder is good but some other interview with Dushanth they do not ask good question simply they prize only, but lot of analytical question are there with all 18 puranas just for good clarification and understanding of Maha kaviam so u it self Answer lot question section in youtube if possible
Haha.. BharatSundar.. ditto.. what my appa said.. learn Hindi it is useful in life :-) but the attraction to Tamizh is magnetic and it comes from within.. no words to explain what it does to you, true that!
As an American 'westerner' I really struggle sometimes to truly understand Classical Carnatic music, this is a great insight into two great musicians that are explaining their approach and opinions about various topics from music, and particularly Carnatic music. '...a 'real' Carnatic musician should know 1,500 songs by heart (memorized)...' 😲😳😳 Edit: the Lord Krishna sliding across the ground whilst eating a great ball of melting butter is burned into my mind now, and your mention of M.S. Subulakshmi singing, haunting my ear. 😁 ☀️😎☀️🇺🇸
This is something that all music teachers should keep in mind!! I’m glad about Bantureethi correction , it has been sung the wrong way by many popular musicians. Great work 👏🏻
Bantu reeti koluvu.....so beautiful. The variations in bhavam for
Rama nama mane....... just divine.
I loved the way how Shri. Dushyanth Sridharji builds the narrative & Shri. Bharath Sundarji's rendition. 👌👌
I cried cried and cried right from the bottom of my heart for the Mokshaprapthi. (Yes Samasreyanam and Bharanyasam were blessed. Acharyan : Srimad Rangaramanuja Mahadesikan 🙏🙏🙏🙏. Nana deshakalali.......Ninne gathi enba nambithanu. ..
Besh besh beautiful singing of Rama Rama by Bharat Sundar as guided Shri Dushyant Sridhar. 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Exceptional idea this conversation triggered me memories of asking my father and knowing meaning for another beautiful gem Brovabarama.
Superb concept ... Something which I have been thinking about a lot ... The syntax is a must but that's only for a greater cause ... It's about the feel, the devotion which the original composer has gone through ... Something which we get to feel in every rendition of MS Amma
I was very much looking forward to such conversations. Hats off to Dushyant and Bharat
Today I cried Several times while I was able to understand that an act mastered was short of higer realisation when a new varient is unexplored. A jugalbandhi not only enlightened both of them and many listening. A big thank you
Biduuuuuuu.... how much can you bring the emotions of the composer out when you understand the context? Beautiful. Thank you for this excellent conversation and program
oh! wow.....bringing it out ...skill truly. pranams. sri gurubhyo namaha.
There were times where musicians knew at least two south Indian languages. And Sanskrit !
I am convinced that with technology , access to learning resources is high ... Current day musicians must spend time on language learning besides voice culture etc etc etc...
Absolutely mesmerising,thought provoking,enjoyable ,blissful,enchanting,what more can Isay…..Simply out of vocabulary to appreciate.Two intellectuals two artists ,two musicians ,two devotees, two with profound knowledge ,how else would the programme be!
Great going - both of you. I had half a dozen goose bumps in part 1,2 and 3. To me - Kannada was best, the explanation and singing brought tears in my eyes. Keep it up!!
Wonderful and intesting discussion by the two stalwarts on the importance of understanding sahityam while rendering carnatic krithis which were composed by the Vaggeyakarars.
Beautiful programme
They are not youngsters.
According to me they are very old in their knowledge.
Music only is their life.
Evlo azaghu singing and also explanation.
Our best wishes.
God bless both of you. Saraswati resides in you on your tongue and Vishnu in your mind and lakshmi in your heart (prosperity distributed by the knowledge and intent). The breathe of Hanuman as a wind god connecting the jeevatma to paramatma. God bless you
Wow! What a magic... Madrasana + Dushyant + Bharat 👌👌👌🙏
Thank you so much Dushyanth. Just two days back I had a discussion with my junior who happened to sing bantu reeti koluvu as bantu reeti kolu viyavayya rama
Nama rama mane as nama rama maaane.......Had to argue with her that she was singing incorrectly ....
Will share her this video hopefully she trusts what I said was true.
I was brought up in North and when I lived I got a different bhakti marg but when I came back to tamilnadu not able to read or write tamil. Even speaking you have a senthil/goundermani as one to emulate......as age catches up for bhakti find that my younger breed here are here to teach. I have a pleasure to learn from the younger flock and my understanding is better due to my experience of life
Great to know about Vidwan Sethalapathi Balasubramaniam. His Tamizh viruttam on Muruga from Kandaralankaram was so moving and touching the heart. Om Muruga, Hare Krishna
Thanks Madrasana for having this conversation. The viruttam by Shri Balasubramanium was so beautiful. Thanks to Bharat for playing. Not many recordings are available in the public space and I have heard a lot about his viruttams
Beautiful and loved every bit.
The importance of Sahithyam truly stood out. The wonderful message of 'sahithyam rounds-off music' was brilliantly put across
Eagerly waiting to watch!!!!
What I liked most was Bharat sunders improvisation listening to Dushyant sridhars suggeestions
This is brilliant. There were so many things we learnt from watching this.. can't wait to watch other episodes. Both Dushyant and Bharat are ao good and knowledgeable. We need more of such conversations..🙏
Thank you Kamesh. The next episode is coming up soon. Watch out for it.
The thumbnail itself looks so much fun :) waiting!
Yes
Absolutely amazing!! Loving Bantureethi Rama naama mane!!! What a magic, understanding the meaning and various interpretations is a powerful weapon by itself in rendering krithis
Highlighted lines - arumai, aruuumai ,Arrumai.Thanks.namaskaram
Excellent and blessed to hear this conversation 🙏
Naragolage Bidhu - Very true (I and Me) - the whole issue in the world is because as we all fall into this well of I and Me - Thank you 🙏 🙏🙏
The anchor is really good ,searched for more interview by him in this channel ,his hold on langauge is good .
Had Goosebumps throughout!! Thanks to both of you legends to bring in this new concept and it's most important to understand the context and the mood let it be any language . Hats off to both of you!!
Awesome! The context and meaning of sahityam definitely adds to the bhavam which is so important.Discussions bears that out.Look forward to next episode.
Vow,,,,,no words indeed....what an intellectual conversations between u two legends
Mad rasana you are doing a great job! It is very helpfull and useful for music learners. Thank you so much. Expecting more videos from your team. I subscribed your channel after listening to" maa mayura " for the first time.
All the best !!😊
Thank you so much for your kind words.
MadRasana Official you guys are great
Very interesting and thrown light on "sahityam and bhavam" also. 👍👌👏🙏
superb effort...please continue...awaiting eagerly for your videos and explanations to lot more krithis..
Yes, beautiful indeed.. Heartwarming to listen to such dedicated and clear-cut opinions on music, language and baaNi. 👐👐
waiting for this type of lecture for long.Thank you vidwans.
melodious,ardha pushti...,visualisizing balakrishna with melting butter in one hand crawling towards me.
Excellent concept and very well handled by both the experts in their respective fields.👏🏼👏🏼
I really loved the conversation about Sangeetha and sahityam .at the same time how understanding the sahityam will bring immense bhava am.thank you so much.
Awesome, enjoyed listening and watching both of them 🙂👍
Nice presentation and a nice concept. Requires many more such programs. Knowing the context of the songs will also make a good listening experience.
Thank you so much
Excellent!!! Really enjoyed the session!!!!
I have heard him singing sivan songs sitting near hm. In Delhi.
eagerly waiting for episode 2
Rama Rama Rama - Hamasanadham 🙏🙏🙏 beautiful
Very very very informative episode
The best episode.
Thank you mama.
Beautifully complemented act by both 👏 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Pranams to sethalapathi maama, vat a moving sindhu bhairavi
Very interesting, makes people like us who knows very little about music, appreciate it
Wonderful conversation enjoyed thoroughly Thank you very much
Two Legend's are Very nice Speech and Superb
Great session sir. Enjoyed... Acho padhigam by Manicka Vasagar
You guys make a great team in creating musical magic
Beautiful and Brilliant. Thank you.🙏🙏🙏
that was great.. thank you Madrasana..
Glad you enjoyed.
Beautiful :) Thanks for having this conversation. I was thinking how even old Hindi songs oda words were split. Example : Ehsaan Tera Ho-Gaa Mujh Par!
Wow Great intiative by Mad rasana . 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 Wonderful ! One
Thank you so much
I am also a fan of karunagara achaariar's upanyasam. Please can you upload any of his upanyasam
Novel concept @Madrasana Official, congratulations! Important to invoke the context as it does gets conveyed in the form of singer's involvement during the rendition of the kriti and also for a rasika(listener) as not only does it move you instantaneously but also transports you immediately into the story as if you are watching from behind the scenes.
Excellent both of u.God bless.
superb..
Very Nice! Thank you..We must pe proud of our pokkisham.
So much love for Tamil and still Brahmins are thought to be pro Hindi.... :) ... What a paradox
We are pro any language that beautifully praises the Bhagawan. All have their own unique beauty, whether it is Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Hindi, Sanskrit or any other language. Language is just a means of communication, something that should bring us together and closer. instead the politicians of my state(Tamil Nadu) use it as an excuse to create conflict and discrimination to separate us as a people, meanwhile their children go to international schools where they learn Hindi, French, English and so on.
It's very simple , their life revolves around North Indian/sanskrit narrative, ie.. they like Bruhadeeshwaram more than Peruvidayar.(original)
@@bharathmurali712 dint follow the last part about brihadeshwar
@@podangadubukus what I mean is , Brahmins follow North Indian narrative in Tamil Language as they know tamil and are Tamilians ie.. I mean the Thanjavur Shiva is a tamil ancestor for local Tamil people on the contrary to brahmins as the same shiva for brahmins is a god from north indian mountain Kailash.
Hence there is a disconnect ie.. Tamil Brahmins are people who belive in a North Indian narrative with Tamil as their mother tongue and idly sambar as their food.
When people say Brahmins are Pro - hindi it is because of their cultural orientation / narrative is the same as North Indians / hindi / sanskrit rather than Tamil.
@@bharathmurali712 it’s not the simple ... Tamil iyers are devout murugan, iyyapan, amman, followers and Iyengar’s are Andal and all the versions of perumal followers which are all very very distinctively Tamil and no connection to north India. Also Tamil Brahmins personally fail to associate with north Indians and their culture..
Let's have more of these kinds of episodes giving importance to the sahithya please.
Excellent
Amazing insightful conversation!!
Super discussion. Remember the Englush poet, "What was oft thought but ne'er so well expressed". Both justified this in their views.
Aha enna suhanubavam . Kannirai adakka mudiyavillai. Thank u Dushyanth&Barath
As a practitioner, performer and choreographer of kūchipūdi style of dance ,this is very very interesting, informative and helpful session. Thank you so much and waiting for more and more such wonderful sessions .🙏🙏🙏
My namaskarangal to your knowledge
Bharat and Dushyanth - you are so good at teaching. You need to be on Livedemy.
I feel, sahithyam is helps us to express our bhavam about what the song says
Waiting formore
There is a full course of 36 songs done similar to this. For more details you can visit www.madrasana.com. The course starts on Oct 15th
Thank you. I do believe the singer brings something more to the song when they know the context and meaning. We were told the story and context before even the first note was taught to us.
One thing, I almost wished your whole conversation was in Tamil .. of course for the larger audience it had to be in a mix of Tamil & English! At least more Tamil than English maybe!
Superb, waiting for many more such conversations. A small suggestion, please increase the number of songs you take up for sahitya and exploration. . But both of you, great job.
Superb
Today being MS Amma's birth anniversary the song is apt
I don't no music but iwas cried
कुटिल पद घटित सङ्कुल शिञ्जितेनतं
I thought he didn't quite sing sinchitena-tam.
நாநாதேஷகளல்லி தாசர்பாட்டு அர்த்தம் ராகம குழைவுஅர்புதம தாசரதே
Excellent Mahesh and Madrasana team!! A very beautifully done video with great insights into how Sahityam is the essence. Would be great to see a Carnatic with a Hindustani performer talking about the similarity and differences in their experiences, especially how they treat the same Ragam / Raag. Congratulations once again!!👍👍👏👏💥💥🌈🌈
Thank you much. Good idea. Will keep that in mind.
Excellent conversation. Dushyanth and Bharath were great in sahithyam and sangeetham
Neenga angle erukkenge in America why no Tamil please
Bharat is so sweet
ராகம்பாடும்பொழுதுசாகித்யத்தில்சப்தஸ்வரம்முலம்வரும்ராகத்துடன்உச்சரிப்புஅப்பப்படிஇருக்கும்
Thumbnail moment 53:45
Sir .as u rightly said some words or expressions which can express in their mother tongue cannot give exact feeling and meaning in translatio
Dushyanth u interview & u r questions to the point to Bhirth sunder is good but some other interview with Dushanth they do not ask good question simply they prize only, but lot of analytical question are there with all 18 puranas just for good clarification and understanding of Maha kaviam so u it self Answer lot question section in youtube if possible
,.ok
goes to show bhakthi bhavam and bharat are inseparable
Noisy bgm ...why...to listen to what...
Haha.. BharatSundar.. ditto.. what my appa said.. learn Hindi it is useful in life :-) but the attraction to Tamizh is magnetic and it comes from within.. no words to explain what it does to you, true that!
As an American 'westerner' I really struggle sometimes to truly understand Classical Carnatic music, this is a great insight into two great musicians that are explaining their approach and opinions about various topics from music, and particularly Carnatic music.
'...a 'real' Carnatic musician should know 1,500 songs by heart (memorized)...'
😲😳😳
Edit: the Lord Krishna sliding across the ground whilst eating a great ball of melting butter is burned into my mind now, and your mention of M.S. Subulakshmi singing, haunting my ear.
😁
☀️😎☀️🇺🇸
Thank you so much for your kind words. Glad you enjoyed it
@@MadRasana absolutely!
Looking forward to listening (watching) the rest, there are quite a few to choose from.
🇺🇸🤝🇮🇳
🙏
Totally made ravana as bad and rama has good,I will never get goosebumps. தமிழன் epothum
So informative.would be more nice if u speak more in Tamil.
Why don't you converse in Tamil?
kandar Alangaram...
தமிழ் ல பேசினாலே நன்னா இருக்கும். இரண்டு பேருக்கும் தமிழ் மொழி தாய் மொழி தானே.