It’s amazing how the two people (including the Indian journalist on ground in Bangladesh) and the professor have a completely different view than those who are in India. Respect to the professor and the journalist
India trying to become New Zamidars!! Muslims lost their ownership of land, Hindus become Zamidars from British. The Permanent Settlement, also known as the Permanent Settlement of Bengal, was an agreement between the East India Company and landlords of Bengal to fix revenues to be raised from land that had far-reaching consequences for both agricultural methods and productivity in the entire British Empire and the political realities of the Indian countryside. It was concluded in 1793 by the Company administration headed by Charles, Earl Cornwallis.[1] It formed one part of a larger body of legislation, known as the Cornwallis Code. The Cornwallis Code of 1793 divided the East India Company's service personnel into three branches: revenue, judicial, and commercial. Revenues were collected by zamindars, native Indians who were treated as landowners. This division created an Indian landed class that supported British authority.[1]
No one has any arrogance or bad thought on bangladesh from India here the people are against what's happening in Bangladesh like attacks on people's we are not against all bangladeshis
Smita sharma, wow, for the very first time i am hearing an honest depiction of what has happened in Bangladesh from an Indian media personnel who came to Bangladesh and saw it all in person. Kudos to you and much respect.
Smartest was caught off guard wen Sushant said BNP is ready for election and the comparison of subramanian swamy with a known terrorist. BD man wants us to believe that Bangladesh has just been formed and there is no constitution and everything has to be written again, seriously how was the country running so far. These r just covering fire for the American stooges to continue in power for the next 10 years. And again a new revolution. For the information of BD people who wouldn't know Sushant Sarin (Moderator) he is pretty straight forward with his analysis especially with regards to Pakistan he comes with all gun blazing but I don't know with regards to Bangladesh he has been quite, quite mellowed down version about this whole mobocracy event. Also to BD people i would like to state that no Indian who is not a leftist will ever acknowledge this so called revolution, appreciate it or pay obituary to the people dead of the so called student revolution. The maximum you could have got from the leftist and liberal ecosystem of Indian journalist and intellectuals give you the cover that no Hindu genocide has happened and even if it has happened then it was of Hindu AL people and those violence is perfectly fine. But I am amazed at how Pakistan and Americans have systematically established this anti-India thoughts in the young and old minds of course a kafir Hindu is a great unifying force to play the game.
Prof Shahab’s view is a clear reflection of what the people in Bangladesh thinks about India’s interference in internal affairs of Bangladesh. Indian diplomats & media have wrong understanding of how people of Bangladesh perceive India as the neighbour. All neighbouring countries of India feel the same as Bangladeshi people think. No friendly country of India means there must be some deficiencies in dealing with expectations of the people. Prof Shahab has rightly indicated about a few examples of Indian inference. People of India don’t have any experience in seeing any large scale mass uprising or mass revolution, how the events of protests eventuates & what unfolds. In 53 years of Bangladesh history people have toppled five regimes through (two military overthrow & three people’s movement). Bangladesh people truly like to have mutually beneficial relationships with India. Fresh thinking is required how this can be achieved.
Lmao you're dependent on us not us on you. You're weaker than us. The only benefits India can gain from Bangladesh's progress is one less unstable border and maybe a country that's politically favorable. However if you're not either of them unless you show us who's boss then we'd rather let you fail on your own
Imagine comparing Jamaat to BJP 😅😅 Seems like the consanguinity and trauma from Pakistani soldiers have created a steady flow of brain rotted zombies in Bangladesh. Truly unfortunate. Bengalis were pretty smart back in the day
Maldives started anti india campaign 2 year back, right now he begging to modi and give his 26 island. Sooner or later when dust settles and reality comes you people will understand this
Thanks to Dr. Enam khan. You explained the whole scenerio. But Indian audience are so head in the mud that they can't simply understand progressiveness of Bangladeshi people's revolutionary movement.. Revolution or fighting against establishment - they can't understand the concept.
The Bangladeshi students forced a large number of teachers to resign and those teachers were humiliated. College and university students, even school students at times, , resorting to such means can hardly be termed as "progressiveness" .
@@chhandamandal6798 Brother, do you know who are those teachers? What you have mentioned, all of them has happened in Govt. institutions. Why is that? Let me explain in brief. The fallen resigm was in power more than 15 years. It's a long time, you have to keep in mind. Among all the mechanisms, the resigm had two vital forces in their hand which they used to silence their oppenents as well as the mass people - 1. Student Cadres/Goons (From schools to Universities, from villages to Major cities) 2. Corrupted police force. As an Indian, you should be able to understand what I am saying. In India, some politicians also more or less follow the same tactics to controll people. Now the student goons did not remain student for so long, right? Eventually they came out in employment. The resigm then started to recruite them in all the major govment run sectors including the police force, civil administration, and of course, the educational institutions. You might ask why educational institutions? Because you see, In the history of Bangladesh and in fact, in the history of this sub continent, all the major movements has been initiated or propagated by students. When journalists are sold, when intellectuals are sold, it is the students whose patriotism you can not buy with anything. Even the British could not do that in united India before 1947. So the corrupted authority were always afraid of students. For the past 15 years, students gathered and raised voice on many legal issues like War criminal tribunal, road safety, qouta reformation etcetra. All of the movements were not only ignored but also demolished violently by pro government student goons (i.e. Chatro league). Who sheltered these student goons and their weapons in educational institions? The teachers of course. Who themselves were either former cadre or the adulators of ruling party. Not all teachers of course. But those were in the powerful posts like Principal, Pro Vice Chancellor, Vice chancellor. Even in the July revolution, these backboneless teachers helped the goons to attack girl's hostel. When girls went to VC's house to get help, to tell him to call police, he did not open his door and let the goons beat the general students indiscriminately. There were many teachers in college and school who openly posted on facebook that they are making lists of the students who are opposing govt. Whatever, the bottom line is thousands of teachers are there in Bangladesh who are unharmed and well respected. Even one of the teachers of Dhaka university is now an Advisor of current govt. Only the the so-called 'Teachers' who were actually an extended part of the corrupted dictator in disguise of 'Teacher' were forced to step down.
@@chhandamandal6798 When you judge from far distance, things do not appear as clear as it is. Do you know who are those teachers? I guess not. What you have mentioned, all of them has happened in Govt. institutions. Why is that? Let me explain you in brief. The fallen resigm was in power more than 15 years. It's a long time, you have to keep that in mind. Among all the mechanisms, the resigm had two vital forces in their hand which they used to silence their oppenents as well as the mass people - 1. Student Cadres/Goons (From schools to Universities, from villages to Major cities) 2. Corrupted police force. As an Indian, you should be able to understand what I am saying. In India, some politicians also more or less follow the same tactics to control people. Now the student goons did not remain student for very long, right? Eventually they came out in employment. The resigm started recruiting them in all the major govment run sectors including the police force, civil administration, and of course, the educational institutions. You might ask why educational institutions? Because you see, In the history of Bangladesh and in fact, in the history of this sub continent, all the major movements has been initiated or propagated by students. When journalists are sold, when intellectuals are sold, it is the students whose patriotism you can not buy with anything. Even the British could not do that in united India before 1947. So the corrupted authority were always afraid of students.
@@chhandamandal6798Throughout the past 15 years, students have raised their voice in many legal issues like war crime tribunal, road safety movement, harrassement, killing and rape by pro govt. Student goons, qouta reformation, question leaked in public exams etcetra. All of the movements were eventually demolishes by students goons (i.e. Chatro league) violently. with direct order from the govt. Who sheltered them in campus? Of course those teachers, who were either former student cadre or the adulators of ruling party. Even in the July movement, these teachers abandoned their students and allowed the goons to come into campus with weapon. They even remained silent when the goons attacked girls' hostels at night. Some of them posted on facebook that they were making list of the students who were opposing govt. Do you find any similarities with Nazi party? Anyway, the bottom line is there are thousands of teachers in Bangladesh who are unharmed and well respected. I'll give you a reference to look into google. The vice-chancellor of Khulna university in khulna, the city where I live in, anounced during revolution that he will not allow any violence in his campus. He did not allow any party to fight in his campus. He did not even allow police to come inside saying 'I am the authority here. These students are my responsibility.' This man was neither with ruling party nor with the opposition parties. Do you know what happened to him after the fall of the resigm? He resigned willfully. even though all the students requested him not to. He maintained his dignity as a teacher. The bottom line is, the incidents you have read are those who were merely misusing the 'Teacher' tag. In reality they were extended part of dictators. The progressiveness of the students is that they understood that to destroy a all powerful authority, you have to destroy all of its branches too. If not, these adulators will bring up another dictator in future.
@@chhandamandal6798 When you see from far distance, things are not always as clear as they are. When you say 'Large number', it is misleading. There has been few incidents of such. Not only teachers, some administrators in different universities and colleges were also asked to resign. Who left the office willfully, nobody went to confront them. One thing you failed to understand is that every fascist govment in the history had corrupted state institutions. That is how they solidify their power for long time. And One of the ways is to recruite people belong to their own agenda in everywhere, specially in the educational institutions. Those fractions you mentioned were part of that fallen regime who served only the purpose of the authority. They neither stood for their students nor remained nuetral in the July revolution. Many of them had no proper educational eligibilty to hold the posts. Yet they were put there by ruling party's lobby. Let me assure you, the vacant posts has been replaced with respected teachers/officials, who were neglected or deprived of their rights during the previous regime. These newly appointed teachers are not associated with any political party. Moreover, Dhaka university has banned student politics within the campus followed by other universities and colleges. Student unions are being reactivated which were closed by previous pro-gov. Cultural programmes are being held participated by everyone. If you don't call that progression, then you can live with your opinion.
Please increase your intake on minority safety in India as well as genocide in Kashmir and Manipur . The democratic world is much concerned about radical extremism terrorist politics in India.
You mean the genocide of the Hindus, correct? Those who were driven out at the point of a gun from their ancestral homeland by Islamists with the full support of the Pakistani government. And how many refugees from Manipur are in Bangladesh? For that matter, how many Indian Bengali Muslim refugees are in Bangladesh? And if the minorities in India are having such a bad time why is there a clamor among many Bangladeshis (mostly Muslim) to get an Indian visa - witness the protests at the Indian Visa Centre in Dhaka. There is a higher chance of Chakma refugees coming to India given reports that their villages are being burned than any Indian refugee going to Bangladesh.
What about the minorities in Pakistan? The Baloch are crying for freedom!!! How many Muslims are lining up in Pakistan and Bangladesh borders to cross over???? Shut up!!!!
Riva Ganguli, you understand everything but you don't understand that Awami League ruled the country for the last 15 years without any mandate (I hope you will not ask me for any clarification because I'm sure you know better).
The girl on Shushant’s right in hijab is judging him HARD. Like she may give him 100 lashes as per sharia. Well said Shushant - a leopard never loses its spots.
@@AtibMomin Share copy of quran that you think is authentic according to you . I will help you point out exact aayat . Those aayat will help you understand, what perhaps might have happened to your ancestors before you became momin.
@@reshmanoor7411 income can be generated provided bharat remain bharat. Cultivate relationship with dharmic countries as well as Africa. Cultivate relationship with bangaladesh Hindus as well as ex-muslim . What is the point of having income if we seize to exist as Hindus ?
I saw a video of a Bangla chap beating up Hindu girls for not wearing a hijab in broad daylight. Not a single guy went against the chap to protect the girls although they were begging for help. Please try to save the Hindus instead of asking for help from Hindu majority country.
Dear Mr. Moderator Manufacturing hatred doesn't make you patriot. 170M population in your right abdomen is NOT A JOKE. Better don't instigate. Spread love instead. You never lose. Ambassador Das is restricted by the futile indian foreign policy. It is understandable. But being a journalist, it is no sin to be factual.
Yep. The man is very hateful of India. He enjoys putting the ball in India's court. What the heck man. It is your problme and in dia has better things to do that obsess with Bangladesh. It is a downright confused country, teetering between trying to be Bengali or Pakistani or Muslim. Its only conviction is hatred of Hindus,
The Bangladeshi 'professor' was such an a$$. Whatever sht Bangladeshi parties Jamaat/BNP did to India is 'past' and we shouldn't discuss it, but even the good India did to Bangladesh (financial aid, connectivity, border lands given away etc etc ) should be discussed as 'favors done to Hasina'
@ishtiaquealamin6147,, One word answer HINDUISM IS 10000 YEARS OLD RELIGION.. SO DON'T COMPARE WITH THOSE RELIGION AND GOD WHICH SAYS EARTH IS FLAT. HOPE U UNDERSTAND AS I KNOW THAT U ARE ORIGINALLY FROM WHERE ..
I really appriciate Professor Mr Khan for admitting the fact that Islam specifically in respect of Bangladesh Society is not at all compatable with Secular ethos and values of Modern day and it is according to him is unfair to impose Secularism on Islamic Republic of.Bangladesh. I am afraid that if suited booted English educated people like Mr Khan speaks in this language what liberalism can be expected from the mulla- moulobi class of Bangladesh ??
Probably Bangladesh could try the Indian version of secularism where in every endeavour there will be some jindu gods idol or a person could be beaten to death just for freezing beef.
Yeah blabbering blabbering. He knows if he says if he says anything against the student revolution he will be forced to resign and may be arrested 😂😂😂 On a serious note is he the grandson of Jammat's founder.
Shame on Sushant the way he cut him down.. just like Arnab Goswami. He disagreed with him.. literally Indian diplomatic parlance has got very thin skinned🤦 Zero discussion on way forward aspect nd what to take from here.. everything was on the past..
Are you talking about yourself... A Hindu talking about biases is weird! In regards to help... Just dont take what is ours, especially water...And then you can hang out with your best friends like China and Pakistan... As if everyone in the region is so fond of you!
If I was in the BD government, I would have avoided getting any help from India. If you are still demonstrating disrespect to Bangladesh, then my advise would be : shut up and leave BD alone. You don't have any business in Bangladesh.
Why no one discussed “boycott Indian products “ campaign in Bangladesh? How many Indians travel to Bangladesh? It seems all connectivity initiatives are one-sided?
26 lacs Indians work in Bangladesh illegally. There are several lacs legal Indian workers and 50,000 Indian students who study in Bangladesh (while couple of thousand Bangladeshi studies in India). Bangladeshi goes to India for medical tourism and general tourism. There are many elite markets in Kolkata who are just for Bangladeshi tourists (because locals can’t afford to shop there)- there are reports that those shopping malls are now empty. Railway connectivity and transits only benefits India saving them travel cost at least 10 times; however, Bangladesh doesn’t get anything from that - rather it creates high security risks (since RAW can easily inject more people to destabilize Bangladesh). So Bangladeshis in general are opposed to such connectivity and want to review the agreement to make it beneficial for both countries. Bangladeshis want a win-win situation while Indian foreign policy wants a master-slave relations and interfere in the domestic politics to put a dictator in power who gives everything to India to stay in power. Indian foreign policy is damaging to India itself since it prioritizes short term quick benefits than long term benefits which creates sustainable win-win situations for both. It’s foreign policy is so bad that it failed with every neighbouring country- now all neighbouring countries are enemies due to her self-destructing oreign policy.
Why Indian RAW is interfering directly internal affairs of Bangladesh. There is strong belief that India was involved in the BDR killings. Bangladesh is not getting genuine share of water through Tista river and india killed lot of Bangladeshi at border and Hasina never protested. It’s very clear to us that Indian attitudes are to treat Bangladeshi as Bhutan which no Bangladeshi will tolerate. Try to change your attitudes first, clean your mind, and then come forward.
Make up u r mind, either accuse India of interference or non-interference. Investigate BDR killing who is stopping u as if coup and killing have never happened in BD. Tista water ask china your friend, they have blocked u r water. Entering India is not your right given by u r father, so enter legally and ask BBG to not take money and send in infiltrators.
India formed a relationship with a particular party during the last election in Bangladesh. Despite lack of international support, only India recognized the election as valid. This support has led to the formation of a dictatorial government. It's important to note that understanding this situation doesn't require one to be a politician.
Miss Das, Your assertion is not correct; Bangladesh was unable to enact deeply democratic laws after Mujib's 1975 assassination. Rather, Mujibur killed democracy himself on February 24, 1975, when he declared the creation of the Bangladesh Krishak Sramik Awami League, the nation's only recognized political party (BAKSAL). The announcement automatically abolished all other political parties in the country and eventually made the other parties that did not join BAKSAL. Awami League, whenever in power, tried to establish an autocratic system and always had a fear of competing in elections. They had never been for the people.
that was a different time. Everyone had arms and there was utter lawlessness. There was world wide inflation as high as 400% when the price of oil was spiked up by Arabs. The killers came with Zia Ur Rehman, the Pakistanist General who brought back the Razakars and brougnt Bismillah in Constitution. That made a total mockery of the LIberation war, in which the vast majority of people who were slaughtered by the Pak army and Razakars were Hindus. The Genocide had targeted Hindus, and HIndu women were declared maal e ghanimat, sanctioned to be raped.
@@Pinto_555 depends on what history you read. True histpry was never told. But Zia Ur Rahman first brought changes to the country. He made the country capitalist. Sheikh Mujib ruined the country with his weak leadership and corruption
Great discussion indeed. Overall picture in Bangladesh looks opaque and complex. In one side are the students who are committed for a change the way Bangladesh is run, yet having no clue about appropriate alternative. Political parties on board look confused how to gel with the students. As of now things are at an evolving stage and considering its delicate geopolitical importance, it is a matter of great anxiety for the entire south east Asia.
My father-in-law was one of the Awamileague Presidium member and he never perticipated in any atrocities during Hasina but he got his parental home at the countryside burned down to ashrs like things happened during 47 and 71. He is 84 years old snd now living in fear and fear. Unacceptable that Bangladesh is grabbed by radicals and they are everywhere. Unacceptable.
Burning someone's house is completely wrong and the parpitrators should be punished. By the way, was he in the street to protest when the midnight election happened? We need to save the country from the corrupt politicians of BNP and AL.
Really, India that claims to be secular has the maximum oppression on its minorities, specially the Muslims in Gujrat where Modi was CM. It’s all forgotten or selective amnesia of the ruling party in India. That’s an example of the height of hypocrisy.
Smita Sharma was the best in terms of balance and eloquence. Riva, as a retired diplomat, is certainly better than the likes of Veena Sikri, Pankaj Saran, Pinak Chakravarty. The moderator had his own agenda.
There are no hateful comments in the Quran! What you think of the quays are due to your myopic view without taking into context the entire situation when those lines were revealed. Check the Bible; you’ll be shocked same with the Old Testament! Why only cherry pick the Quran?
Surah 2:191: "And kill them (non-Muslims) wherever you find them ... See they don't see non muslim as human...al takiya order from Allah to protect islam 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Please do not talk about bangladesh politics. This matter is not your problem. We do not talk about your country's politics. If you do, then the people of bangladesh will continue to go against india. Because the people do doubt about Indian's ambitious.
It shows how embarrass India is? Now they are talking about democracy in Bangladesh now!!! Why not last 15 years? You guys should start this process long time back. Relations should be people to people! Hope India rethink about their foreign policies!
@@amittribe7614 there is nothing particular to any religion based language . Arabic is not a muslim language. The arab Christians , Yazidis , they all speak Arabic as their language. Nobody has any sovereignty over any language. The Bengali language is spoken by the people of the Bengal region. In today , the majority of Bengal is muslim whether you like it or not . Similarly Russians ( Christians and muslims) have their own language. Modern day Bengali language is also full of Arabic words , like. Baba , Adalot , Ain , Darja, Sohor, asol , soytan , sonot , khobor ,Saheb , nokol , duniya , tarikh, Gorib, Hisab . Next time don't use these words if you are a bengali speaking hindu as you want to make it a Hindu language .😂😂😂😂😂...
For the last time, Bangladeshi people didn't have the right to vote for 15 years, no political party other than awamileague participated in the election for this reason. So how come you are claiming that Bangladeshies elected her?
Ha , ha , lol, whether democracy returns to Bangladesh ! what a funny "statement ! Was there any democracy at all in Bangladesh during the last 15 years or it was simply an one party fascist ruling backed up by the democracy advocate India ! ? Are the Indian think tanks not aware of how the last election in Bangladesh was held ? ? Wasn't India the first country to congratulate the ousted PM after she held a farcical and joking election in January and declared herself as the winner ? So, whether democracy returns to Bangladeshis statement by the presenter is a very joking statement which is used to misguide the audience .
Wonderful Discussion, but while listening to the panelist Professor from Bangladesh, I can smell a denial that we are now used to hearing from most of the Pakistani panelists on other discussions related to Indo-Pak issues. This denial of any issues, extremosm and terrorism and human rights abuse is a classic example we see from most of the Islamic world.
When you make discussions about the policy of two Countries where the Islamic thing come from !!! When you don't take allegations against you for your terrorism with your power over the small countries in south asia regime you term them with different things.. Where your fuc**ng apologise over 700,800 killings by your allies Awami ligue in Bangladesh, you get ready for the consequences of pushing from all countries together in south asia.
If some one says that Human rights violation and oppression on Muslim minorities in India is one of the highest in the World!! Will that be wrong ??? There are numerous incidents where Muslims were beaten to death for eating beaf.. India should revisit their thought process regarding neighbours.. I hope Indians will think logical in coming days regarding bordering Countries...
@@fya91 we don't deny issues in India, and hence you see so many people in India talking about issues with minorities, including the lynching in our country. But we don't deny that and minorities in India have not reduced to negligible levels what we see in Pakistan and Bangladesh.
India made acting President of Bangladesh during '71 a twenty year treaty which said that Bangladesh will not have any army. That's how you alinieted Bangladesh forever.
Why Bangladesh will not have any Army? India is actually acting like an apartheid, racist, communal state. India must understand that Bangladesh is a free independent sovereign country. Bangladesh got independence through bloody liberation war against Pakistan. 90% citizens of Bangladesh hate Indian Godi media and Modi’s politics of hegemony and hypocrisy. India must stop its dirty interference in the internal affairs and politics of Bangladesh.
This is biggest slap from the people of Bangladesh. We love the brother and sister of India. But we equally hate the policy maker of india who support a serial killer of students.
As a Bangladeshi I want to know some answer from you guys. Could you please answer this? 1. Jamait-I-Islami: Your most controversial issues is this party. I ask you which party is in power in Delhi? What's their activity against Indian's minority? If we are not ask question and work with any party of India what's your problem to work with BD's any party? Which party will in power of Dhaka if you want to decide that how you expect good relation with BD? 2. Bangladeshi Hindu: In Bangladesh (BD) have around 10% of people are Hindu. If 100 being kill 10 will Hindu there. This is not unusual. Thousand of people had kill in July and August revolution. Within this 31 are Hindu which is around of 3% of total killing. Thousands of religions origination are vandalized. Most of them are Mosque and Majar. Within this when India's media just publish Hindu's issue and ignore dozens time more Muslims issues what this mean? Is Indians think only Hindus life matter and Muslims life is nothing? 3. What your countries minority's condition? Are they more secure than Bangladeshis minorities? Any bulldozer destroy Hindus home in Bangladesh? Any Hindus are bitten and kill just for his religious believe? When anyone say anything about Indians Muslim then your voice is, This is our (Indians) internal matter! How Bangladeshis Hindues become Indians matter? 4. Seven sisters: Your main concern is seven sisters insurgences group get support from BD at the time of BNP and Jamat. I ask you why India support, train, and arms BD's (Chittagong Hill zone) insurgent group after 1975? Why BD's biggest terror attack on Holy artisan's (Dhaka) arms come from India? 5. Why Bangladeshi are so angry against India: I ask you guys why you unlawful interference of Bangladeshi's last three Election? When your home minister compare Bangladeshis with insect or declare to bitten BD's people, hanging and torcher and your govt party's people declared to capture BD's northan part, Sylhet or hilly zone of BD, how you expect good reaction from Bangladeshis? Why your country give dam of join river to broken international law? Why you want Bangladesh remains an Indian's slavery government? Why you interference BD's internal issue? N: B: Both country have previous bad and good experiance from both side. We may ensure that, by previous way no one can benefited. So come on guys and make a new journey to overcome previous mistake. And this journey will be positive, progressive, both interest, cooperative for our own self. No one will interference others internal matter. Otherwise both will harm.
1. Jamaat and the BJP are not the same. The BJP's Hindutva ideology is not what many think it to be. According to their way of thinking, anyone who currently lives in the Indian Subcontinent is a Hindu, so they think of that term as a race not a religion. They believe that all are Hindus but those who practice idol-worship are Sanatani. Also Hindutva, in its original form, doesn't differentiate between religions or caste. What it basically says is that irrespective of our faiths, we are essentially a single race that has lived on this land for thousands of years. This is the bedrock of the BJP's Hindutva ideology. I don't think Jamaat has any semblance of equality in their ideology, not to mention their role during the liberation war.
2. Indian TV media has been hopeless for some time, but that doesn't mean they don't show issues in India. But still, India has a constitutionally mandated minorities commission. Minorities enjoy special fundamental rights. Muslims block roads to pray, for God's sake. They are never asked to stop using loudspeakers. They never see the need to tone down their celebrations, and rightfully so.
3. Show me an incident when a Muslim has been lynched because of his faith. As far as bulldozers are concerned, I have seen a Hindu temple being demolished with my own eyes, because it was an illegal construction. You guys call Modi a butcher, but surprisingly during his tenure as the CM of Gujarat, he demolished numerous temples because they were illegal constructions. So, that boils down to the media once again. They selectively show Muslim criminals' properties being demolished, maybe because that gets them more views.
5. We let Hasina run the show however she wanted, and that's the opposite of interference. That's the question Sushant Sareen asked. Why are we being damned for interference when we didn't do so?
Shekh Hasina never came with overwhelming mandate two if the elections were Rigged , with questionable results. And extremely low participation in 2024 election. The Indian relation was Hasina- a cultivated agent if India , not with Bangladeshi people. And now you can see the reactions of the people
Two elements in the fabric of culture of Bangladesh will keep stirring trouble in this country is anti India and antihindu forces. They know Geopolitical aspects not in favour of their own agenda but will continue to persue this due to propakistan stand..
Not a very enlightened gathering I am afraid . Jamaat islami was different from prior to 1930s political gatherings .. 1. It is not very caliphate orientated party or pure movements as prior Muslim activist groups were . 2. It is not a madrassa raised generation party rather it's members had hakim's doctors engineers etc 3. It calls itself a revolutionary Islamic party but in itself it is semidemocratic politics loving party where majority is not madly power hungry or ambitious . 4. It has a communist party like structure but there are no cut throats in it . 5. Bangladesh jamaat was an ordinary semidemocratic party doing it work which is primarily to provide conservative atmosphere in educational institution and trying to get some Islamic laws passed but mujib Goondas started killing not only Bhashani men but also jamaat islami men prior to 1970 elections . Bhashani had militants . 6. So when awami league started killing opponents in Feb 1970 jamaat and Biharis had to do side with Pakistan army to save their skins but USA double crossed Pakistan with Nixon on Pakistani side but usa deep state wanting creation of Bangladesh . 7. India deeply unpopular due to established anti Muslim credentials of Modi and alleged complicity of Modi in killing of students and hanging of jamaat men so Modi is silent on Hasina knowing that trial might expose him too . 8 . Jamaat islami where ever it is usually do not try to control foreign relation in preference to army of that state so it is unlikely that jamaat will have policy completely at variance with Bangladeshi army , that is not their style even in Pakistan . 9. The death of Muslim patriot the kashmiri jamaat leader Gilani was great blow to Muslim cause. 10. Off course Hindus and Muslims cannot be on same trajectory otherwise those Muslims are hypocrite ..But we do not expect jamaat to have policy not in connivance with army . Jamaat is an agitatory but not a militant per se organization but has capacity if it wants too
The professor and the journalists spoke fluently without conveying any idea. The professor was typical Islamic apologist trying to bring similarities between India and Bangladesh, an approach they think will shut the Indian mouth. Sushant, I wish well for your association with the professor and the journalist. And I hope the viewers will be spared of the presence of both.
Why is it only India's responsibility to have people to people relationship with Neighbours? It should be two way street. Im sure islamists will find it very hard
As you heard from the professor from Bangladesh Univ, it is always a mistake of India. So typical Islamist attitude. Educated and centrist will remain silent due to fear, this will provide a loud platform to religious zealots. I have not seen any democratic reform in a single majority Muslim country, Bangladesh is no exception. Just look like what has happened during and since this revolution.
I genuinely thought Bangladesh people are intellectually good. But what I have seen lately it just upset us. Jamaat-e-islami has some radical structures backed by Pakistani ISI as soon as they receive CIA nod they were able to literally create so much of distress. If they think Bangladesh can grow without India give them that just step back as we have done for Pakistan. If anyone creates national security issue you react just disproportionately let them find their identity since this islamic characters are jokers they are some time arabs, turks then they become western people. Let them figure themselves out we should focus on our growth.
@@arifshahariar4519 international crime tribunal has convicted more than 12 jamaat leaders for genocide. Delwar Hossain Sayeedi deputy of Jamaat was found guilty of genocide, rape and religious persecution. Jamaat and their student wing Shibir have been involved in recent violence. How come they were banned on August 1, 2024 and Bangladesh turmoil started on August 5,2024.
@@abhishekverma6098 international crime tribunal setup by hasina.... If you study more you will see how she manipulated the verdict of the courts... There will be clips available of chief justice S.K. Sinha of gave statement about this... Not only this the hindu person who gave statement against sayedi was forced to do do... You will get his statement online... He came in the janaja and said he was forced by the law enforcement agency to do so, and he is sorry for that...
@@arifshahariar4519jamaat is a transnational genocidal organization that has killed lakhs of people in India pak and bangaldesh. how are they not banned in India yet i have no idea
@@abhishekverma6098don’t know what recent violence you’re talking of but majority of that was during the July protests and for like a week after the 5th of August when there was no government or law and order anywhere. For a country to plunge into an anarchy like scenario is not out of the ordinary right after a revolution. What’s sad is that indians still view Bangladesh from the Pakistani lens and think they are the same. Bengalis are much more progressive as an ethnicity than pakis and it shows as well in most human development indexes that where you’ll see Bangladeshi women more integrated into the work force as compared to both India and Pakistan. There are questions on jamat certainly you’re not wrong about that but shibir hasn’t been seen out and about in public causing unrest ever since the 5th and it’s based on public accounts. International crimes tribunal you’re speaking of isn’t international even to start with and it was founded during the Hasina regime so questions have remained always from international observers about the fairness of the trials. Jamat certainly has a lot of tough questions to answer to the general populous in the country if they wanna be accepted by the mass and it’s highly unlikely they’ll come in power but one thing is for sure that is they probably have the most structured and organized political party in Bangladesh currently and that’s cus of the way they function as a political party. Truth of the matter is there isn’t a single political party that has enough going for them in Bangladesh where people find the confidence that they’ll form a good governance. All the parties are equally fucked up. That’s why people are so excited for what the Yunus interim govt will bring to the table for the next few years cus so far all the appointments for the different ministries have been based on pure merit and some of the top intellectuals in the country are in those seats. Not to forget Dr. Yunus is a noble peace prize winner himself and a widely accepted intellectual globally.
Wake up India. Listen to realistic facts. Bangladeshis are also people. They should also have a personal identity. Still have time, don't lose your place in the heart of Bangladesh.
Secularism an elite project not part of Bangladesh common people. How can secularists survive in "Secularism vs Islamism" clash. The "Bengali culture, Secularism" are all un-Islamic. Secularism may win in the West and in Hindu majority India, but it is 'haram'. There is always a distinctive difference between 'East of India' Islam and 'West of India' Islam. It is the "Tolerance and Acceptance of Other ways to Almighty". The Future of politics in 'Indonesia' and 'Bangladesh' will determine the 'West of India' Islam vs 'East of India' Islam conundrum.
The issue in Manipur is about two rival tribes fighting with each other for reservation which is a civil issue. The issue in Ladakh is about chinese incursion which is a military issue.
If you directly invest in the people of another nation without the government. It is understable to favour a particular government that shares compatible views that have greater democratic profiles. It is easy to blame India despite India actually propping the economy on a massive scale. Clearly this opposition against India is driven by crazy extremists with Pakistani mindset. Guess Pakistan is taking its revenge and will reduce to its level. There is no way India can take responsibility for Bagladesh, making a mess of itself, though sharing huge history makes it sad.
ONE SIMPLE QUESTION TO THIS PANEL. WHY ALL OF OUR IMMEDIATE NEIGHBOUING COUNTRIES HAVE TURNED HOSTILE TOWARDS INDIA? ARE WE FOLLOWING COMPLETE FAULTY FOREIGN POLICIES ? WHY DO ALL OUR NEIGHBOURS CONSIDER US AS A BULLY?
I don't think I agree with your opinion on India's relationship with its neighbours, but assuming that's the case, I think the prime reason for the souring of relationships can primarily be attributed to economic downfall. I think COVID had a significant impact on all economies, but significantly more on smaller economies than bigger economies, like India, which is also a consumption driven economy. If the economic situation was any worse, I think the current gov wouldn't have returned to power, and India would also have been in a bad situation, with protesting students and the unemployed population, blaming Modi and probably the US or Europe..
If you have a neighbor who is bigger in all sorts of sector then jeolosy will emerged . It's natural and nothing is new to India even US face such things
@@ashupal4605Your excuse is nothing but bullshit.... None is jealous about your gigantic economy... It is the mentality of common people and media houses that lead to your down fall to your relationship with neighbour. Other than that no fault in your foreign policies.
It is because India is surrounded by failed states. It is shameful the head of the government has to flee or get jailed when the regime changes. It is shameful that Bangladesh has not matured into a responsible country even after 50 years.
I listened to it. Not an educative one. These discussants from India have no real understanding of the aspirations of Bangladeshis, & their ethos! I wasted my time. Same old garbage.
Sir, Even I had the same feeling listening to the professor from Bangladesh and his blabbering and I am not saying this as an Indian I have to counter you but I am serious and plz read me down. But i would like to state that no Indian who is not a leftist will ever acknowledge this so called revolution, appreciate it or pay the obituary to the dead people of the so called student revolution. The maximum you could have got is from the leftist and liberal ecosystem of Indian journalist and intellectuals who have given you the cover that no Hindu genocide has happened and even if it has happened then it was of Hindu AL people and those violence is perfectly fine, like this Indian journalist who was on the road. Also by acknowledging your so called revolution we can be seen inadvertently encourage such an idea in India especially with the kind of relationship we have with china and Americans and the kind deep funding of anti-India liberals they have in India. So Govt of India cannot acknowledge this which is why Modi has a problem with meeting Yunus and at best they can tweet. But I am amazed at how Pakistan and Americans have systematically established this anti-India thoughts in the young and old minds of course a kafir Hindu is a great unifying force to play the game.
From last 5th August 2024 until today, extrajudicial killings have been taking place with the direct support of students of Dhaka University and Jahangirnagar University in Bangladesh. Genocide is going on with the help of communal forces and army. Mosques, temples, shrines were vandalized by arson. In a word, Bangladesh is now unsafe. Sp
From last 5th August 2024 until today, extrajudicial killings have been taking place with the direct support of students of Dhaka University and Jahangirnagar University in Bangladesh. Genocide is going on with the help of communal forces and army. Mosques, temples, shrines were vandalized by arson. In a word, Bangladesh is now unsafe.
Bangladeshi politician-journalist Mushfiqul Fazal Ansarey - in case people do not know the name of the Bangladeshis journalist that Sushant is talking about during course of this discussion. He was former BD PM Khalida Zia's press secretary and had fled to American during Sheikh Hasina's regime and he is now back. He was given a seat by the Americans in the white house journalist press conferences to ask anti-India and particularly anti-Modi questions. Just see planning of the Americans how systematic and long it is from Yunus to this journalist, the Americans are unable forget drubbing in 1971. Just wanted to elucidate this.
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu 71 you guys help your self because of two Pakistan could fokof India 🇮🇳 we are able to get freedom from Pakistan alone, you guys came for your won interest
@@SyedAhmed-qh1ff okay, you got freedom from Pakistan or got separated from Pakistan is something that you guys have to come to terms with but the fact that without India that wouldn't have been possible u r dreams also.
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu we didn’t get freedom from British we fight for our freedom, you guys come to saved Pakistan army who those killed us and looted our property by Indian army so fokoff ….
@@SyedAhmed-qh1ffokay, it is for the same reason that India isn't jumping in to save Yunus because we know in another 2 to 5 years there will be another revolution to dislodge Yunus(American/BD army Govt). I know still you blame India for having not come to the rescue of the loot that Yunus and Americans and army generals coterie have done. But who cares.
It was free Frank and important interaction. Sure this will help people on both sides to understand the situation and relationship better. Jay Hind Joy Bangla 😂
Bangladesh must wake up to the reality that it has border with India, and has a sizable Hindu and Buddhist population. If it can not give its citizens basic rights, no wonder they migrate illegally to India. Which definitely is India’s concern and the concern of various minorities that like in Bangladesh.
At first, make peace within your all states. Stabalize Manipur, Kashmir and stop Genocide & Rape by Indian army in these two states. Let them live with peace. It doesn't suit well talking about neighbours when your own home is on Fire! 🙂🙂🙂
Sushant Sareen has changed tack. One Sushant when BJP has 303 another Sushant when BJP is 240. Yunus effect . He is setting the ball rolling on US's nudge.
Relationship between people to people merely means some scholarship, as a Bangladeshis we feel no country should interferes in Bangladesh internal affair, in international affairs it should be mutually beneficial not unilaterally opposing for example blocking BRICS membership, literally defunct of SARC , repatriation of Rohingya positive responses from India would have been people to people fraternity
The person in car is not wearing a seat belt in the back seat . Exactly a recipe for suicide. My daughter died in an accident 3 weeks ago and we learnt it the hard way.
That they’d do the same if it was any other country. India is closer to dhaka so they imagine better prospects there. The previous regime did nothing for the people at that level, and unfortunately they think that they will have better lives in India, when clearly we can see that is not the case. Food matters to them more than whether they are in Bangladesh or India. I think rather than blaming them and threatening to ‘burn them upside down,’ both states should take pity and see what can be done to help their economic situation by making sure the poorest get a slice of the pie
Sir, Bangladeshis are hindu bengali converts over centuries. Unlike pakistanis the hinduness of bangladeshis is explicit due to bengali language which is diluted sanskrit. Bangladesh has taken a new turn now,mending their fences with pakistan from which they separated in 1971. They appear to start with Pakistani model of governance where army is the prime mover and hindu india is an enemy.
It’s amazing how the two people (including the Indian journalist on ground in Bangladesh) and the professor have a completely different view than those who are in India. Respect to the professor and the journalist
India trying to become New Zamidars!!
Muslims lost their ownership of land, Hindus become Zamidars from British.
The Permanent Settlement, also known as the Permanent Settlement of Bengal, was an agreement between the East India Company and landlords of Bengal to fix revenues to be raised from land that had far-reaching consequences for both agricultural methods and productivity in the entire British Empire and the political realities of the Indian countryside. It was concluded in 1793 by the Company administration headed by Charles, Earl Cornwallis.[1] It formed one part of a larger body of legislation, known as the Cornwallis Code. The Cornwallis Code of 1793 divided the East India Company's service personnel into three branches: revenue, judicial, and commercial. Revenues were collected by zamindars, native Indians who were treated as landowners. This division created an Indian landed class that supported British authority.[1]
How they would be? They have arrogance and jealousness.
@@Truehunter8462When u hear truth then it’s arrogance
Nobody has jealousy of converted people wearing lungi.
No one has any arrogance or bad thought on bangladesh from India here the people are against what's happening in Bangladesh like attacks on people's we are not against all bangladeshis
Smita sharma, wow, for the very first time i am hearing an honest depiction of what has happened in Bangladesh from an Indian media personnel who came to Bangladesh and saw it all in person. Kudos to you and much respect.
She Did not even go beyond Dhaka, where 99% of Hindu genocide is going on...
She simply strolled in Dhaka, had a good time and came back.
@@ShrekJo-we2st You mean how they are buldozing Muslim houses all over India.. especially by lower caste Hindu gangs of Yogi in UP...
@@ShrekJo-we2st another kamasutra erotica moaner spotted!😬😬
@@ShrekJo-we2stagain, that's fake news. She knows it.
@@omairij_yt chup jihadi
The smartest person in the room is not in the room. SALUTE BD Professor!
If that person is not in the room how can you say "smartest person in the room"?
That's the logic of Bangladesh....to call themselves smart 😂😂😂
Smartest was caught off guard wen Sushant said BNP is ready for election and the comparison of subramanian swamy with a known terrorist. BD man wants us to believe that Bangladesh has just been formed and there is no constitution and everything has to be written again, seriously how was the country running so far. These r just covering fire for the American stooges to continue in power for the next 10 years. And again a new revolution.
For the information of BD people who wouldn't know Sushant Sarin (Moderator) he is pretty straight forward with his analysis especially with regards to Pakistan he comes with all gun blazing but I don't know with regards to Bangladesh he has been quite, quite mellowed down version about this whole mobocracy event.
Also to BD people i would like to state that no Indian who is not a leftist will ever acknowledge this so called revolution, appreciate it or pay obituary to the people dead of the so called student revolution. The maximum you could have got from the leftist and liberal ecosystem of Indian journalist and intellectuals give you the cover that no Hindu genocide has happened and even if it has happened then it was of Hindu AL people and those violence is perfectly fine.
But I am amazed at how Pakistan and Americans have systematically established this anti-India thoughts in the young and old minds of course a kafir Hindu is a great unifying force to play the game.
@@valardohaeris...3186 Better than kamasutra erotica veg phuddu mythological logic of RSS poltroons!😂😂😂
That's madrashachap logic
Prof Shahab’s view is a clear reflection of what the people in Bangladesh thinks about India’s interference in internal affairs of Bangladesh. Indian diplomats & media have wrong understanding of how people of Bangladesh perceive India as the neighbour. All neighbouring countries of India feel the same as Bangladeshi people think. No friendly country of India means there must be some deficiencies in dealing with expectations of the people. Prof Shahab has rightly indicated about a few examples of Indian inference. People of India don’t have any experience in seeing any large scale mass uprising or mass revolution, how the events of protests eventuates & what unfolds. In 53 years of Bangladesh history people have toppled five regimes through (two military overthrow & three people’s movement). Bangladesh people truly like to have mutually beneficial relationships with India. Fresh thinking is required how this can be achieved.
And we know what you did to hindus after partition. So we don't care except earning from you. Period 😅
Lmao you're dependent on us not us on you. You're weaker than us. The only benefits India can gain from Bangladesh's progress is one less unstable border and maybe a country that's politically favorable. However if you're not either of them unless you show us who's boss then we'd rather let you fail on your own
@@js913shut up yo fool.
Stop giving visa to bagladeshis , stop electricity, stop rice , let bagladeshi be completely independent country .
@@triptirathore9027 You're welcome to do that, please.
Jamat get 8% vote at Bangladesh but BJP ruled India. India or Bangladesh which is really secular?
No Muslim man stand against Halala for their own sister and daughters so sad
@@bigshot7624 What the F is that? I've never heard of it? I just see Indians commenting this shit.
Secular is a alien 👾 word for most of the Muslims especially newly converted like Bangladesh or Pakistan.
jamati dogs have done islamic terrorism they are considered as terrorists by UN. BJP is superior to both awami league and BNP
Imagine comparing Jamaat to BJP 😅😅
Seems like the consanguinity and trauma from Pakistani soldiers have created a steady flow of brain rotted zombies in Bangladesh. Truly unfortunate.
Bengalis were pretty smart back in the day
OMG no wonder why India lost all its neighbors if you select this type of ambassador good luck.
Maldives started anti india campaign 2 year back, right now he begging to modi and give his 26 island. Sooner or later when dust settles and reality comes you people will understand this
This high level talk... what neigbours..all are asking money.food, employment in india 🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑🤑
Lol all begging neighbors yes , we dont want those bankrupt who are dependent on either USA or china for their own survival
Especially if we are surrounded by mostly newly converted people.
@@aniksinha3734 It's Bangladesh, not Maldives that it depends on India...
Thanks to Dr. Enam khan. You explained the whole scenerio. But Indian audience are so head in the mud that they can't simply understand progressiveness of Bangladeshi people's revolutionary movement.. Revolution or fighting against establishment - they can't understand the concept.
The Bangladeshi students forced a large number of teachers to resign and those teachers were humiliated. College and university students, even school students at times, , resorting to such means can hardly be termed as "progressiveness" .
@@chhandamandal6798
Brother, do you know who are those teachers? What you have mentioned, all of them has happened in Govt. institutions. Why is that? Let me explain in brief.
The fallen resigm was in power more than 15 years. It's a long time, you have to keep in mind.
Among all the mechanisms, the resigm had two vital forces in their hand which they used to silence their oppenents as well as the mass people -
1. Student Cadres/Goons (From schools to Universities, from villages to Major cities)
2. Corrupted police force.
As an Indian, you should be able to understand what I am saying. In India, some politicians also more or less follow the same tactics to controll people.
Now the student goons did not remain student for so long, right? Eventually they came out in employment.
The resigm then started to recruite them in all the major govment run sectors including the police force, civil administration, and of course, the educational institutions.
You might ask why educational institutions?
Because you see, In the history of Bangladesh and in fact, in the history of this sub continent, all the major movements has been initiated or propagated by students.
When journalists are sold, when intellectuals are sold, it is the students whose patriotism you can not buy with anything. Even the British could not do that in united India before 1947.
So the corrupted authority were always afraid of students. For the past 15 years, students gathered and raised voice on many legal issues like War criminal tribunal, road safety, qouta reformation etcetra.
All of the movements were not only ignored but also demolished violently by pro government student goons (i.e. Chatro league).
Who sheltered these student goons and their weapons in educational institions?
The teachers of course. Who themselves were either former cadre or the adulators of ruling party. Not all teachers of course. But those were in the powerful posts like Principal, Pro Vice Chancellor, Vice chancellor.
Even in the July revolution, these backboneless teachers helped the goons to attack girl's hostel. When girls went to VC's house to get help, to tell him to call police, he did not open his door and let the goons beat the general students indiscriminately.
There were many teachers in college and school who openly posted on facebook that they are making lists of the students who are opposing govt.
Whatever, the bottom line is thousands of teachers are there in Bangladesh who are unharmed and well respected. Even one of the teachers of Dhaka university is now an Advisor of current govt.
Only the the so-called 'Teachers' who were actually an extended part of the corrupted dictator in disguise of 'Teacher' were forced to step down.
@@chhandamandal6798 When you judge from far distance, things do not appear as clear as it is. Do you know who are those teachers? I guess not.
What you have mentioned, all of them has happened in Govt. institutions. Why is that? Let me explain you in brief.
The fallen resigm was in power more than 15 years. It's a long time, you have to keep that in mind.
Among all the mechanisms, the resigm had two vital forces in their hand which they used to silence their oppenents as well as the mass people -
1. Student Cadres/Goons (From schools to Universities, from villages to Major cities)
2. Corrupted police force.
As an Indian, you should be able to understand what I am saying. In India, some politicians also more or less follow the same tactics to control people.
Now the student goons did not remain student for very long, right? Eventually they came out in employment.
The resigm started recruiting them in all the major govment run sectors including the police force, civil administration, and of course, the educational institutions.
You might ask why educational institutions?
Because you see, In the history of Bangladesh and in fact, in the history of this sub continent, all the major movements has been initiated or propagated by students. When journalists are sold, when intellectuals are sold, it is the students whose patriotism you can not buy with anything. Even the British could not do that in united India before 1947.
So the corrupted authority were always afraid of students.
@@chhandamandal6798Throughout the past 15 years, students have raised their voice in many legal issues like war crime tribunal, road safety movement, harrassement, killing and rape by pro govt. Student goons, qouta reformation, question leaked in public exams etcetra. All of the movements were eventually demolishes by students goons (i.e. Chatro league) violently. with direct order from the govt.
Who sheltered them in campus?
Of course those teachers, who were either former student cadre or the adulators of ruling party.
Even in the July movement, these teachers abandoned their students and allowed the goons to come into campus with weapon. They even remained silent when the goons attacked girls' hostels at night.
Some of them posted on facebook that they were making list of the students who were opposing govt. Do you find any similarities with Nazi party?
Anyway, the bottom line is there are thousands of teachers in Bangladesh who are unharmed and well respected. I'll give you a reference to look into google.
The vice-chancellor of Khulna university in khulna, the city where I live in, anounced during revolution that he will not allow any violence in his campus. He did not allow any party to fight in his campus. He did not even allow police to come inside saying 'I am the authority here. These students are my responsibility.' This man was neither with ruling party nor with the opposition parties.
Do you know what happened to him after the fall of the resigm?
He resigned willfully. even though all the students requested him not to. He maintained his dignity as a teacher.
The bottom line is, the incidents you have read are those who were merely misusing the 'Teacher' tag. In reality they were extended part of dictators.
The progressiveness of the students is that they understood that to destroy a all powerful authority, you have to destroy all of its branches too. If not, these adulators will bring up another dictator in future.
@@chhandamandal6798 When you see from far distance, things are not always as clear as they are.
When you say 'Large number', it is misleading. There has been few incidents of such. Not only teachers, some administrators in different universities and colleges were also asked to resign.
Who left the office willfully, nobody went to confront them.
One thing you failed to understand is that every fascist govment in the history had corrupted state institutions. That is how they solidify their power for long time.
And One of the ways is to recruite people belong to their own agenda in everywhere, specially in the educational institutions.
Those fractions you mentioned were part of that fallen regime who served only the purpose of the authority. They neither stood for their students nor remained nuetral in the July revolution. Many of them had no proper educational eligibilty to hold the posts. Yet they were put there by ruling party's lobby.
Let me assure you, the vacant posts has been replaced with respected teachers/officials,
who were neglected or deprived of their rights during the previous regime.
These newly appointed teachers are not associated with any political party.
Moreover, Dhaka university has banned student politics within the campus followed by other universities and colleges. Student unions are being reactivated which were closed by previous pro-gov.
Cultural programmes are being held participated by everyone.
If you don't call that progression, then you can live with your opinion.
Please increase your intake on minority safety in India as well as genocide in Kashmir and Manipur . The democratic world is much concerned about radical extremism terrorist politics in India.
kangladeshi seeth
@@AKumar-co7oekangla deshi mat bolo bimaru Bangladeshi thik hai Bengali Hindus idhar rehte hai
You mean the genocide of the Hindus, correct? Those who were driven out at the point of a gun from their ancestral homeland by Islamists with the full support of the Pakistani government. And how many refugees from Manipur are in Bangladesh? For that matter, how many Indian Bengali Muslim refugees are in Bangladesh? And if the minorities in India are having such a bad time why is there a clamor among many Bangladeshis (mostly Muslim) to get an Indian visa - witness the protests at the Indian Visa Centre in Dhaka. There is a higher chance of Chakma refugees coming to India given reports that their villages are being burned than any Indian refugee going to Bangladesh.
What about the minorities in Pakistan? The Baloch are crying for freedom!!! How many Muslims are lining up in Pakistan and Bangladesh borders to cross over???? Shut up!!!!
What about Uyghur Muslim in China, peaceful people never talk about them.
Riva Ganguli, you understand everything but you don't understand that Awami League ruled the country for the last 15 years without any mandate (I hope you will not ask me for any clarification because I'm sure you know better).
Shahab Enam Khan, Professor, Jahangirnagar University, Bangladesh❤❤❤
the way Shushant is trying to cutoff Prof. Shadab Khan, was really funny. Shushant was absolutely oppressing free speech.
He is not but sadab do.... everybody is given a limited time to convey.... that's how this event goes on ...u don't know that different stuff.😮
Sushant told the jamati terrorist professor to shut up
You really need to learn what "Free Speech" means. Free Speech doesn't mean one gets to speak beyond the stipulated time for that particular speaker.
Only Mephistopheles
can survive in our Bangladesh now
The girl on Shushant’s right in hijab is judging him HARD. Like she may give him 100 lashes as per sharia. Well said Shushant - a leopard never loses its spots.
Avg andbhkhat knowledge and logic 😂😂
@@AtibMomin Share copy of quran that you think is authentic according to you . I will help you point out exact aayat . Those aayat will help you understand, what perhaps might have happened to your ancestors before you became momin.
How low this comment... Its as if all the shanty people in India have phones now and commenting here...
@@YaAliSM87 due to internet everyone is accessing quran and what is written in it. Lowest of low is identified.
@@v1234ablebig mouth with zero knowledge... Share the hyperlink please
What are the benefits bharat gets by helping an Islamic country ?
BANGLADESH IS one of our largest income source.
It's a huge market.
Lots of Indians are working there.
No benefits but hate !
@@reshmanoor7411 income can be generated provided bharat remain bharat. Cultivate relationship with dharmic countries as well as Africa. Cultivate relationship with bangaladesh Hindus as well as ex-muslim . What is the point of having income if we seize to exist as Hindus ?
I saw a video of a Bangla chap beating up Hindu girls for not wearing a hijab in broad daylight. Not a single guy went against the chap to protect the girls although they were begging for help. Please try to save the Hindus instead of asking for help from Hindu majority country.
@@Mano1-u5e he is doing what quran says. Our country is thinking about how to do business.
Dear Mr. Moderator
Manufacturing hatred doesn't make you patriot. 170M population in your right abdomen is NOT A JOKE. Better don't instigate. Spread love instead. You never lose.
Ambassador Das is restricted by the futile indian foreign policy. It is understandable. But being a journalist, it is no sin to be factual.
Ha ha love nice joke. Enough enough for the mess that we have created ourselves in 1971.
joirnalists are the main flatterer in modi's India
Bangla guest's ideological leanings are obvious 😂
Yep. The man is very hateful of India. He enjoys putting the ball in India's court. What the heck man. It is your problme and in dia has better things to do that obsess with Bangladesh. It is a downright confused country, teetering between trying to be Bengali or Pakistani or Muslim. Its only conviction is hatred of Hindus,
The Bangladeshi 'professor' was such an a$$. Whatever sht Bangladeshi parties Jamaat/BNP did to India is 'past' and we shouldn't discuss it, but even the good India did to Bangladesh (financial aid, connectivity, border lands given away etc etc ) should be discussed as 'favors done to Hasina'
Would you like to talk about rss bjp terrorists sympathiser susant
@ishtiaquealamin6147,,
One word answer HINDUISM IS 10000 YEARS OLD RELIGION.. SO DON'T COMPARE WITH THOSE RELIGION AND GOD WHICH SAYS EARTH IS FLAT. HOPE U UNDERSTAND AS I KNOW THAT U ARE ORIGINALLY FROM WHERE ..
@@omnicurious2949 Which "borderland" given away to Bangladesh, boss?
I really appriciate Professor Mr Khan for admitting the fact that Islam specifically in respect of Bangladesh Society is not at all compatable with Secular ethos and values of Modern day and it is according to him is unfair to impose Secularism on Islamic Republic of.Bangladesh. I am afraid that if suited booted English educated people like Mr Khan speaks in this language what liberalism can be expected from the mulla- moulobi class of Bangladesh ??
Probably Bangladesh could try the Indian version of secularism where in every endeavour there will be some jindu gods idol or a person could be beaten to death just for freezing beef.
Prof Khan and Smita Sharma 🎉
🙏
The former Diplomat Guguly Das is just a big liar.
Our Professor 🔥
Yeah blabbering blabbering. He knows if he says if he says anything against the student revolution he will be forced to resign and may be arrested 😂😂😂
On a serious note is he the grandson of Jammat's founder.
Shame on Sushant the way he cut him down.. just like Arnab Goswami. He disagreed with him.. literally Indian diplomatic parlance has got very thin skinned🤦
Zero discussion on way forward aspect nd what to take from here.. everything was on the past..
Bogus understanding and desperation to get help from India. Only to back bite. First let them prove to be unbiased
Are you talking about yourself... A Hindu talking about biases is weird! In regards to help... Just dont take what is ours, especially water...And then you can hang out with your best friends like China and Pakistan... As if everyone in the region is so fond of you!
If I was in the BD government, I would have avoided getting any help from India. If you are still demonstrating disrespect to Bangladesh, then my advise would be : shut up and leave BD alone. You don't have any business in Bangladesh.
😮@@Cyrano1971Who wants to be with you all. Beggar of a country.
@@YaAliSM87Surah 2:191: "And kill them (non-Muslims) wherever you find them
@@Cyrano1971😂😂😂😂😂
as an Indian. stop all engagements
We Bangladeshi don’t give a fak to India we will be happy if no more relations with India 😂😂😂😂😂
Lol
Why no one discussed “boycott Indian products “ campaign in Bangladesh? How many Indians travel to Bangladesh? It seems all connectivity initiatives are one-sided?
26 lacs Indians work in Bangladesh illegally.
There are several lacs legal Indian workers and 50,000 Indian students who study in Bangladesh (while couple of thousand Bangladeshi studies in India).
Bangladeshi goes to India for medical tourism and general tourism. There are many elite markets in Kolkata who are just for Bangladeshi tourists (because locals can’t afford to shop there)- there are reports that those shopping malls are now empty.
Railway connectivity and transits only benefits India saving them travel cost at least 10 times; however, Bangladesh doesn’t get anything from that - rather it creates high security risks (since RAW can easily inject more people to destabilize Bangladesh). So Bangladeshis in general are opposed to such connectivity and want to review the agreement to make it beneficial for both countries. Bangladeshis want a win-win situation while Indian foreign policy wants a master-slave relations and interfere in the domestic politics to put a dictator in power who gives everything to India to stay in power. Indian foreign policy is damaging to India itself since it prioritizes short term quick benefits than long term benefits which creates sustainable win-win situations for both. It’s foreign policy is so bad that it failed with every neighbouring country- now all neighbouring countries are enemies due to her self-destructing oreign policy.
Riva Ganguli shows here as she was always, too bias, too subjective , denying the fact and reality.
Why Indian RAW is interfering directly internal affairs of Bangladesh. There is strong belief that India was involved in the BDR killings. Bangladesh is not getting genuine share of water through Tista river and india killed lot of Bangladeshi at border and Hasina never protested.
It’s very clear to us that Indian attitudes are to treat Bangladeshi as Bhutan which no Bangladeshi will tolerate.
Try to change your attitudes first, clean your mind, and then come forward.
How about you tell your fellow lungis not to cross the border illegally?
No one would be shot😅
Make up u r mind, either accuse India of interference or non-interference.
Investigate BDR killing who is stopping u as if coup and killing have never happened in BD.
Tista water ask china your friend, they have blocked u r water.
Entering India is not your right given by u r father, so enter legally and ask BBG to not take money and send in infiltrators.
Well said BD Professor
Did he have a choice 😂😂😂😂
India formed a relationship with a particular party during the last election in Bangladesh. Despite lack of international support, only India recognized the election as valid. This support has led to the formation of a dictatorial government. It's important to note that understanding this situation doesn't require one to be a politician.
We Indians wouldn't like to see the Talibanization of BD so will not recognise this American stooge and will always support the Awami League.
Loved how Smita came back at Sushant’s absolutely ridiculous defence for mota bhai’s termite statement.
Miss Das, Your assertion is not correct; Bangladesh was unable to enact deeply democratic laws after Mujib's 1975 assassination.
Rather, Mujibur killed democracy himself on February 24, 1975, when he declared the creation of the Bangladesh Krishak Sramik Awami League, the nation's only recognized political party (BAKSAL). The announcement automatically abolished all other political parties in the country and eventually made the other parties that did not join BAKSAL.
Awami League, whenever in power, tried to establish an autocratic system and always had a fear of competing in elections. They had never been for the people.
that was a different time. Everyone had arms and there was utter lawlessness. There was world wide inflation as high as 400% when the price of oil was spiked up by Arabs. The killers came with Zia Ur Rehman, the Pakistanist General who brought back the Razakars and brougnt Bismillah in Constitution. That made a total mockery of the LIberation war, in which the vast majority of people who were slaughtered by the Pak army and Razakars were Hindus. The Genocide had targeted Hindus, and HIndu women were declared maal e ghanimat, sanctioned to be raped.
@@Pinto_555 depends on what history you read. True histpry was never told. But Zia Ur Rahman first brought changes to the country. He made the country capitalist. Sheikh Mujib ruined the country with his weak leadership and corruption
Great discussion indeed. Overall picture in Bangladesh looks opaque and complex. In one side are the students who are committed for a change the way Bangladesh is run, yet having no clue about appropriate alternative. Political parties on board look confused how to gel with the students. As of now things are at an evolving stage and considering its delicate geopolitical importance, it is a matter of great anxiety for the entire south east Asia.
How many Bangladeshi people Indian BSF killed up to date?
i would love to Salut Professor Mr. Shahab for his intellectual way of explaining the ongoing situation in Bangladesh.
My father-in-law was one of the Awamileague Presidium member and he never perticipated in any atrocities during Hasina but he got his parental home at the countryside burned down to ashrs like things happened during 47 and 71.
He is 84 years old snd now living in fear and fear. Unacceptable that Bangladesh is grabbed by radicals and they are everywhere. Unacceptable.
Burning someone's house is completely wrong and the parpitrators should be punished.
By the way, was he in the street to protest when the midnight election happened?
We need to save the country from the corrupt politicians of BNP and AL.
Lier u r.
Really, India that claims to be secular has the maximum oppression on its minorities, specially the Muslims in Gujrat where Modi was CM. It’s all forgotten or selective amnesia of the ruling party in India. That’s an example of the height of hypocrisy.
Smita spoke while traveling, the network quality stood out!
Smita Sharma was the best in terms of balance and eloquence. Riva, as a retired diplomat, is certainly better than the likes of Veena Sikri, Pankaj Saran, Pinak Chakravarty. The moderator had his own agenda.
🙏🙏
Sushant is completely biased and trying to push an agenda on this
W
Good discussion. Also good to see in Bangladesh academicians are well salaried unlike other places. The location behind profs flat is great.
Ask him question about hateful aayat of quran and what is bangaladesh going to do about it, all his lofty talks will disappear in a second .
You can personally study on the so called hateful ayat of Quran by yourself... There is plenty of materials available online.
There are no hateful comments in the Quran! What you think of the quays are due to your myopic view without taking into context the entire situation when those lines were revealed. Check the Bible; you’ll be shocked same with the Old Testament! Why only cherry pick the Quran?
@@arifshahariar4519 according to Surah 2:191: "And kill them (non-Muslims) wherever you find them😂😂😂😂😂
@@shah-j1mSurah 2:191: "And kill them (non-Muslims) wherever you find them.
Surah 2:191: "And kill them (non-Muslims) wherever you find them ... See they don't see non muslim as human...al takiya order from Allah to protect islam 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Please do not talk about bangladesh politics. This matter is not your problem. We do not talk about your country's politics. If you do, then the people of bangladesh will continue to go against india. Because the people do doubt about Indian's ambitious.
Stop taking electricity , medical visa , rice , petrol grom india , we have no interst in east Pakistan
Thank you so much Shahab Enam Khan for your outstanding speech.
Very good analysis by the last journalist
Madame, u r really credible sincere courageous journalist! Salute u! Long live !
It shows how embarrass India is? Now they are talking about democracy in Bangladesh now!!! Why not last 15 years? You guys should start this process long time back. Relations should be people to people! Hope India rethink about their foreign policies!
What an arrangement! Agreed that 3:30 on is at another level
O Indian, tell us with which neighbor you have good relation? Even not with Hindu Nepal.
The issue is newly converted be Bangladesh or Pakistan hates Hindu despite having Hindu surnames and speaking Hindu languages.
@@amittribe7614 what is hindu languages 😂😂😂😂??
Do you think English is a Christian language 😂😂😂😂😂.
And you guys say you have higher intellect???😂😂😂😂
Bangla is a Hindu language which you still speak which comes from Sanskrit. You don't speak Arabic.
@@amittribe7614 there is nothing particular to any religion based language . Arabic is not a muslim language. The arab Christians , Yazidis , they all speak Arabic as their language.
Nobody has any sovereignty over any language.
The Bengali language is spoken by the people of the Bengal region. In today , the majority of Bengal is muslim whether you like it or not .
Similarly Russians ( Christians and muslims) have their own language.
Modern day Bengali language is also full of Arabic words , like. Baba , Adalot , Ain , Darja, Sohor, asol , soytan , sonot , khobor ,Saheb , nokol , duniya , tarikh, Gorib, Hisab .
Next time don't use these words if you are a bengali speaking hindu as you want to make it a Hindu language .😂😂😂😂😂...
Majority of Bangla speaking people are muslims in Bangladesh and West Bangla, and Asam. How come Bangla is a hindu language?
The issue here is they hate Hasina but they elected her for 15 years and you blame India for your backwardness, you live in a delta.
Madarsa education 😂😂😂😂😂
For the last time, Bangladeshi people didn't have the right to vote for 15 years, no political party other than awamileague participated in the election for this reason. So how come you are claiming that Bangladeshies elected her?
India should change their foreign policy After 36 July incident ,stop supporting one person one family and one party.
Ha , ha , lol, whether democracy returns to Bangladesh ! what a funny "statement ! Was there any democracy at all in Bangladesh during the last 15 years or it was simply an one party fascist ruling backed up by the democracy advocate India ! ? Are the Indian think tanks not aware of how the last election in Bangladesh was held ? ? Wasn't India the first country to congratulate the ousted PM after she held a farcical and joking election in January and declared herself as the winner ? So, whether democracy returns to Bangladeshis statement by the presenter is a very joking statement which is used to misguide the audience .
Rightly said bhai, but later Prof. Shahabuddin did excellent
Why you can't blame India for Hasina's wrong doings, why you people allowed her to do, you were sleeping.
Do muslim countries have democracy ❓
Bangladesh 🇧🇩 pay your bills
Wont unless the unfair deal is revised which was even questioned by your opposition in your parliament.
@@fardinrahman8184 if you dont keep your promises then nobody will invest in your failed islamic naya kangladesh
@@fardinrahman8184p pakbhikaristaani
Wonderful Discussion, but while listening to the panelist Professor from Bangladesh, I can smell a denial that we are now used to hearing from most of the Pakistani panelists on other discussions related to Indo-Pak issues. This denial of any issues, extremosm and terrorism and human rights abuse is a classic example we see from most of the Islamic world.
When you make discussions about the policy of two Countries where the Islamic thing come from !!! When you don't take allegations against you for your terrorism with your power over the small countries in south asia regime you term them with different things.. Where your fuc**ng apologise over 700,800 killings by your allies Awami ligue in Bangladesh, you get ready for the consequences of pushing from all countries together in south asia.
If some one says that Human rights violation and oppression on Muslim minorities in India is one of the highest in the World!! Will that be wrong ???
There are numerous incidents where Muslims were beaten to death for eating beaf..
India should revisit their thought process regarding neighbours..
I hope Indians will think logical in coming days regarding bordering Countries...
@@fya91 we don't deny issues in India, and hence you see so many people in India talking about issues with minorities, including the lynching in our country. But we don't deny that and minorities in India have not reduced to negligible levels what we see in Pakistan and Bangladesh.
If the diplomats/intelligence are unable to get an idea what the ideological leanings of the students are then they are failing.
India made acting President of Bangladesh during '71 a twenty year treaty which said that Bangladesh will not have any army. That's how you alinieted Bangladesh forever.
Why Bangladesh will not have any Army? India is actually acting like an apartheid, racist, communal state. India must understand that Bangladesh is a free independent sovereign country. Bangladesh got independence through bloody liberation war against Pakistan. 90% citizens of Bangladesh hate Indian Godi media and Modi’s politics of hegemony and hypocrisy. India must stop its dirty interference in the internal affairs and politics of Bangladesh.
This is biggest slap from the people of Bangladesh. We love the brother and sister of India. But we equally hate the policy maker of india who support a serial killer of students.
As a Bangladeshi I want to know some answer from you guys. Could you please answer this?
1. Jamait-I-Islami: Your most controversial issues is this party. I ask you which party is in power in Delhi? What's their activity against Indian's minority? If we are not ask question and work with any party of India what's your problem to work with BD's any party? Which party will in power of Dhaka if you want to decide that how you expect good relation with BD?
2. Bangladeshi Hindu: In Bangladesh (BD) have around 10% of people are Hindu. If 100 being kill 10 will Hindu there. This is not unusual. Thousand of people had kill in July and August revolution. Within this 31 are Hindu which is around of 3% of total killing. Thousands of religions origination are vandalized. Most of them are Mosque and Majar. Within this when India's media just publish Hindu's issue and ignore dozens time more Muslims issues what this mean? Is Indians think only Hindus life matter and Muslims life is nothing?
3. What your countries minority's condition? Are they more secure than Bangladeshis minorities? Any bulldozer destroy Hindus home in Bangladesh? Any Hindus are bitten and kill just for his religious believe? When anyone say anything about Indians Muslim then your voice is, This is our (Indians) internal matter! How Bangladeshis Hindues become Indians matter?
4. Seven sisters: Your main concern is seven sisters insurgences group get support from BD at the time of BNP and Jamat. I ask you why India support, train, and arms BD's (Chittagong Hill zone) insurgent group after 1975? Why BD's biggest terror attack on Holy artisan's (Dhaka) arms come from India?
5. Why Bangladeshi are so angry against India: I ask you guys why you unlawful interference of Bangladeshi's last three Election? When your home minister compare Bangladeshis with insect or declare to bitten BD's people, hanging and torcher and your govt party's people declared to capture BD's northan part, Sylhet or hilly zone of BD, how you expect good reaction from Bangladeshis? Why your country give dam of join river to broken international law? Why you want Bangladesh remains an Indian's slavery government? Why you interference BD's internal issue?
N: B: Both country have previous bad and good experiance from both side. We may ensure that, by previous way no one can benefited. So come on guys and make a new journey to overcome previous mistake. And this journey will be positive, progressive, both interest, cooperative for our own self. No one will interference others internal matter. Otherwise both will harm.
1. Jamaat and the BJP are not the same. The BJP's Hindutva ideology is not what many think it to be. According to their way of thinking, anyone who currently lives in the Indian Subcontinent is a Hindu, so they think of that term as a race not a religion. They believe that all are Hindus but those who practice idol-worship are Sanatani. Also Hindutva, in its original form, doesn't differentiate between religions or caste. What it basically says is that irrespective of our faiths, we are essentially a single race that has lived on this land for thousands of years. This is the bedrock of the BJP's Hindutva ideology. I don't think Jamaat has any semblance of equality in their ideology, not to mention their role during the liberation war.
2. Indian TV media has been hopeless for some time, but that doesn't mean they don't show issues in India. But still, India has a constitutionally mandated minorities commission. Minorities enjoy special fundamental rights. Muslims block roads to pray, for God's sake. They are never asked to stop using loudspeakers. They never see the need to tone down their celebrations, and rightfully so.
3. Show me an incident when a Muslim has been lynched because of his faith. As far as bulldozers are concerned, I have seen a Hindu temple being demolished with my own eyes, because it was an illegal construction. You guys call Modi a butcher, but surprisingly during his tenure as the CM of Gujarat, he demolished numerous temples because they were illegal constructions. So, that boils down to the media once again. They selectively show Muslim criminals' properties being demolished, maybe because that gets them more views.
4. I don't know anything about that so I won't comment.
5. We let Hasina run the show however she wanted, and that's the opposite of interference. That's the question Sushant Sareen asked. Why are we being damned for interference when we didn't do so?
Shekh Hasina never came with overwhelming mandate two if the elections were
Rigged , with questionable results. And extremely low participation in 2024 election. The Indian relation was Hasina- a cultivated agent if India , not with Bangladeshi people. And now you can see the reactions of the people
Two elements in the fabric of culture of Bangladesh will keep stirring trouble in this country is anti India and antihindu forces. They know Geopolitical aspects not in favour of their own agenda but will continue to persue this due to propakistan stand..
Go into the power treaty between Adani Power and Bangladesh. Was that treaty for Bangladesh or for just looting Bangladesh?
Not a very enlightened gathering I am afraid .
Jamaat islami was different from prior to 1930s political gatherings ..
1. It is not very caliphate orientated party or pure movements as prior Muslim activist groups were .
2. It is not a madrassa raised generation party rather it's members had hakim's doctors engineers etc
3. It calls itself a revolutionary Islamic party but in itself it is semidemocratic politics loving party where majority is not madly power hungry or ambitious .
4. It has a communist party like structure but there are no cut throats in it .
5. Bangladesh jamaat was an ordinary semidemocratic party doing it work which is primarily to provide conservative atmosphere in educational institution and trying to get some Islamic laws passed but mujib Goondas started killing not only Bhashani men but also jamaat islami men prior to 1970 elections . Bhashani had militants .
6. So when awami league started killing opponents in Feb 1970 jamaat and Biharis had to do side with Pakistan army to save their skins but USA double crossed Pakistan with Nixon on Pakistani side but usa deep state wanting creation of Bangladesh .
7. India deeply unpopular due to established anti Muslim credentials of Modi and alleged complicity of Modi in killing of students and hanging of jamaat men so Modi is silent on Hasina knowing that trial might expose him too .
8 . Jamaat islami where ever it is usually do not try to control foreign relation in preference to army of that state so it is unlikely that jamaat will have policy completely at variance with Bangladeshi army , that is not their style even in Pakistan .
9. The death of Muslim patriot the kashmiri jamaat leader Gilani was great blow to Muslim cause.
10. Off course Hindus and Muslims cannot be on same trajectory otherwise those Muslims are hypocrite ..But we do not expect jamaat to have policy not in connivance with army .
Jamaat is an agitatory but not a militant per se organization but has capacity if it wants too
The professor and the journalists spoke fluently without conveying any idea. The professor was typical Islamic apologist trying to bring similarities between India and Bangladesh, an approach they think will shut the Indian mouth.
Sushant, I wish well for your association with the professor and the journalist. And I hope the viewers will be spared of the presence of both.
👍👍👍Nice one 😂😂😂😂
Pretty dramatic narration by ms.das , it’s not blank paper it’s pre-filled paper given to Hasina / Bangladesh for mare signatures
Why is it only India's responsibility to have people to people relationship with Neighbours? It should be two way street. Im sure islamists will find it very hard
As you heard from the professor from Bangladesh Univ, it is always a mistake of India. So typical Islamist attitude.
Educated and centrist will remain silent due to fear, this will provide a loud platform to religious zealots. I have not seen any democratic reform in a single majority Muslim country, Bangladesh is no exception. Just look like what has happened during and since this revolution.
The professors admiration for the youth of BD is to clearly position himself as their ally and save his job. 😂
Yeah otherwise they will be at his doors and force him to resign. Hail mobocracy 😂😂😂😂
The professor was speaking for the people's right long before the protest. So I don't think He is talking anything out of biasness
@@hasibalfuad9652 okay but is the grandson of the Jamaat founder or some other important figure. Just wanted to know
I genuinely thought Bangladesh people are intellectually good.
But what I have seen lately it just upset us. Jamaat-e-islami has some radical structures backed by Pakistani ISI as soon as they receive CIA nod they were able to literally create so much of distress.
If they think Bangladesh can grow without India give them that just step back as we have done for Pakistan.
If anyone creates national security issue you react just disproportionately let them find their identity since this islamic characters are jokers they are some time arabs, turks then they become western people. Let them figure themselves out we should focus on our growth.
Please share some info about radiacal structure of jamat
@@arifshahariar4519 international crime tribunal has convicted more than 12 jamaat leaders for genocide.
Delwar Hossain Sayeedi deputy of Jamaat was found guilty of genocide, rape and religious persecution.
Jamaat and their student wing Shibir have been involved in recent violence. How come they were banned on August 1, 2024 and Bangladesh turmoil started on August 5,2024.
@@abhishekverma6098 international crime tribunal setup by hasina.... If you study more you will see how she manipulated the verdict of the courts... There will be clips available of chief justice S.K. Sinha of gave statement about this... Not only this the hindu person who gave statement against sayedi was forced to do do... You will get his statement online... He came in the janaja and said he was forced by the law enforcement agency to do so, and he is sorry for that...
@@arifshahariar4519jamaat is a transnational genocidal organization that has killed lakhs of people in India pak and bangaldesh. how are they not banned in India yet i have no idea
@@abhishekverma6098don’t know what recent violence you’re talking of but majority of that was during the July protests and for like a week after the 5th of August when there was no government or law and order anywhere. For a country to plunge into an anarchy like scenario is not out of the ordinary right after a revolution. What’s sad is that indians still view Bangladesh from the Pakistani lens and think they are the same. Bengalis are much more progressive as an ethnicity than pakis and it shows as well in most human development indexes that where you’ll see Bangladeshi women more integrated into the work force as compared to both India and Pakistan. There are questions on jamat certainly you’re not wrong about that but shibir hasn’t been seen out and about in public causing unrest ever since the 5th and it’s based on public accounts. International crimes tribunal you’re speaking of isn’t international even to start with and it was founded during the Hasina regime so questions have remained always from international observers about the fairness of the trials. Jamat certainly has a lot of tough questions to answer to the general populous in the country if they wanna be accepted by the mass and it’s highly unlikely they’ll come in power but one thing is for sure that is they probably have the most structured and organized political party in Bangladesh currently and that’s cus of the way they function as a political party. Truth of the matter is there isn’t a single political party that has enough going for them in Bangladesh where people find the confidence that they’ll form a good governance. All the parties are equally fucked up.
That’s why people are so excited for what the Yunus interim govt will bring to the table for the next few years cus so far all the appointments for the different ministries have been based on pure merit and some of the top intellectuals in the country are in those seats. Not to forget Dr. Yunus is a noble peace prize winner himself and a widely accepted intellectual globally.
ORF should discuss Manipur and Kashmir like this kind of setup. We Bangladeshis are doing fine. Ask your ground reporter, lol.
Jihadi spotted
Wake up India. Listen to realistic facts. Bangladeshis are also people. They should also have a personal identity. Still have time, don't lose your place in the heart of Bangladesh.
we should not invest in Bangladesh let them solve their internal issues and not bother what is happening within us their country
Don’t lie about Sujata Sen. She came only to force Ershad to join the election to support Hasina.
Secularism an elite project not part of Bangladesh common people. How can secularists survive in "Secularism vs Islamism" clash. The "Bengali culture, Secularism" are all un-Islamic. Secularism may win in the West and in Hindu majority India, but it is 'haram'. There is always a distinctive difference between 'East of India' Islam and 'West of India' Islam. It is the "Tolerance and Acceptance of Other ways to Almighty". The Future of politics in 'Indonesia' and 'Bangladesh' will determine the 'West of India' Islam vs 'East of India' Islam conundrum.
You are hiding your crime against bangladeshi people by supporting hasina under some diplomatic words.
why aren't so much people discussing the Manipur issue? are they not Indian enough or the issue in Ladakh?
The issue in Manipur is about two rival tribes fighting with each other for reservation which is a civil issue. The issue in Ladakh is about chinese incursion which is a military issue.
ma'am today all of what you have said.. it has miserably failed. People of Bangladesh don't believe.
The largest Bangladeshi tourism is in the illegals. Will both sides - India and Bangladesh - at least acknowledge it?
If you directly invest in the people of another nation without the government. It is understable to favour a particular government that shares compatible views that have greater democratic profiles. It is easy to blame India despite India actually propping the economy on a massive scale. Clearly this opposition against India is driven by crazy extremists with Pakistani mindset. Guess Pakistan is taking its revenge and will reduce to its level. There is no way India can take responsibility for Bagladesh, making a mess of itself, though sharing huge history makes it sad.
Great assistance from India ,the Greatest of all is of course is great Autocrat Hasina!
ONE SIMPLE QUESTION TO THIS PANEL. WHY ALL OF OUR IMMEDIATE NEIGHBOUING COUNTRIES HAVE TURNED HOSTILE TOWARDS INDIA? ARE WE FOLLOWING COMPLETE FAULTY FOREIGN POLICIES ?
WHY DO ALL OUR NEIGHBOURS CONSIDER US AS A BULLY?
I don't think I agree with your opinion on India's relationship with its neighbours, but assuming that's the case, I think the prime reason for the souring of relationships can primarily be attributed to economic downfall. I think COVID had a significant impact on all economies, but significantly more on smaller economies than bigger economies, like India, which is also a consumption driven economy. If the economic situation was any worse, I think the current gov wouldn't have returned to power, and India would also have been in a bad situation, with protesting students and the unemployed population, blaming Modi and probably the US or Europe..
If you have a neighbor who is bigger in all sorts of sector then jeolosy will emerged . It's natural and nothing is new to India even US face such things
@@ashupal4605Your excuse is nothing but bullshit.... None is jealous about your gigantic economy... It is the mentality of common people and media houses that lead to your down fall to your relationship with neighbour. Other than that no fault in your foreign policies.
It is because India is surrounded by failed states. It is shameful the head of the government has to flee or get jailed when the regime changes. It is shameful that Bangladesh has not matured into a responsible country even after 50 years.
I listened to it. Not an educative one. These discussants from India have no real understanding of the aspirations of Bangladeshis, & their ethos!
I wasted my time. Same old garbage.
Sir, Even I had the same feeling listening to the professor from Bangladesh and his blabbering and I am not saying this as an Indian I have to counter you but I am serious and plz read me down.
But i would like to state that no Indian who is not a leftist will ever acknowledge this so called revolution, appreciate it or pay the obituary to the dead people of the so called student revolution. The maximum you could have got is from the leftist and liberal ecosystem of Indian journalist and intellectuals who have given you the cover that no Hindu genocide has happened and even if it has happened then it was of Hindu AL people and those violence is perfectly fine, like this Indian journalist who was on the road.
Also by acknowledging your so called revolution we can be seen inadvertently encourage such an idea in India especially with the kind of relationship we have with china and Americans and the kind deep funding of anti-India liberals they have in India. So Govt of India cannot acknowledge this which is why Modi has a problem with meeting Yunus and at best they can tweet.
But I am amazed at how Pakistan and Americans have systematically established this anti-India thoughts in the young and old minds of course a kafir Hindu is a great unifying force to play the game.
Literally if BJP is in power why not Jamaat?
From last 5th August 2024 until today, extrajudicial killings have been taking place with the direct support of students of Dhaka University and Jahangirnagar University in Bangladesh. Genocide is going on with the help of communal forces and army. Mosques, temples, shrines were vandalized by arson. In a word, Bangladesh is now unsafe. Sp
From last 5th August 2024 until today, extrajudicial killings have been taking place with the direct support of students of Dhaka University and Jahangirnagar University in Bangladesh. Genocide is going on with the help of communal forces and army. Mosques, temples, shrines were vandalized by arson. In a word, Bangladesh is now unsafe.
😂😢
All the Indian contributors are not unfortunately accurate in describing the real situation in Bangladesh after 05 August.
Bangladeshi politician-journalist Mushfiqul Fazal Ansarey - in case people do not know the name of the Bangladeshis journalist that Sushant is talking about during course of this discussion. He was former BD PM Khalida Zia's press secretary and had fled to American during Sheikh Hasina's regime and he is now back.
He was given a seat by the Americans in the white house journalist press conferences to ask anti-India and particularly anti-Modi questions. Just see planning of the Americans how systematic and long it is from Yunus to this journalist, the Americans are unable forget drubbing in 1971. Just wanted to elucidate this.
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu 71 you guys help your self because of two Pakistan could fokof India 🇮🇳 we are able to get freedom from Pakistan alone, you guys came for your won interest
@@SyedAhmed-qh1ff okay, you got freedom from Pakistan or got separated from Pakistan is something that you guys have to come to terms with but the fact that without India that wouldn't have been possible u r dreams also.
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu we didn’t get freedom from British we fight for our freedom, you guys come to saved Pakistan army who those killed us and looted our property by Indian army so fokoff ….
@@SyedAhmed-qh1ffokay, it is for the same reason that India isn't jumping in to save Yunus because we know in another 2 to 5 years there will be another revolution to dislodge Yunus(American/BD army Govt). I know still you blame India for having not come to the rescue of the loot that Yunus and Americans and army generals coterie have done. But who cares.
It was free Frank and important interaction.
Sure this will help people on both sides to understand the situation and relationship better.
Jay Hind Joy Bangla 😂
If Bangladeshi are not safe in India. India out movement must continue.
Bangladesh must wake up to the reality that it has border with India, and has a sizable Hindu and Buddhist population. If it can not give its citizens basic rights, no wonder they migrate illegally to India. Which definitely is India’s concern and the concern of various minorities that like in Bangladesh.
At first, make peace within your all states. Stabalize Manipur, Kashmir and stop Genocide & Rape by Indian army in these two states. Let them live with peace. It doesn't suit well talking about neighbours when your own home is on Fire! 🙂🙂🙂
Okay we will make peace and call you. Okay
@@AjitKumar-lo9yu not interested, my apologies! 🙂🙃
@@mountainmoonx Okay, your apologies accepted. Do not repeat it.
Sushant Sareen has changed tack. One Sushant when BJP has 303 another Sushant when BJP is 240. Yunus effect .
He is setting the ball rolling on US's nudge.
Learnt new limitation of P2P from ex diplomat. But we also learnt how India has been destroying P2P by border killings!
Relationship between people to people merely means some scholarship, as a Bangladeshis we feel no country should interferes in Bangladesh internal affair, in international affairs it should be mutually beneficial not unilaterally opposing for example blocking BRICS membership, literally defunct of SARC , repatriation of Rohingya positive responses from India would have been people to people fraternity
Bhikari apni ukat me reh
Surah 2:191: "And kill them (non-Muslims) wherever you find them
India will work on it's interest only, poor people of Bangladesh suddenly woke up.
Loans are unislamic thsn why east and west Pakistan are begging to the world 😂
A new dawn , yes. Is it a bright dawn or is it a gloomy dawn ?
Dr. Khan, can you mention a specific case that you think which is not supported with evidence?
Bangladesh in dark for ever by Dr. Yunus and his allies. Nation will suffer for long time.
The person in car is not wearing a seat belt in the back seat . Exactly a recipe for suicide. My daughter died in an accident 3 weeks ago and we learnt it the hard way.
Very correct Indian Diplomats really did not help.
What do Bangladeshis say about the millions of their citizens illegally entering into India ?
That they’d do the same if it was any other country. India is closer to dhaka so they imagine better prospects there. The previous regime did nothing for the people at that level, and unfortunately they think that they will have better lives in India, when clearly we can see that is not the case. Food matters to them more than whether they are in Bangladesh or India. I think rather than blaming them and threatening to ‘burn them upside down,’ both states should take pity and see what can be done to help their economic situation by making sure the poorest get a slice of the pie
Sir, Bangladeshis are hindu bengali converts over centuries. Unlike
pakistanis the hinduness of bangladeshis is explicit due to bengali language which is diluted
sanskrit.
Bangladesh has taken a new turn now,mending their fences with
pakistan from which they separated in 1971. They appear to start with Pakistani model of governance where army is the prime mover and hindu india is an enemy.
Excellent discussion.
Enam sir true ❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩🇧🇩