C'est grandiose. Je suis un ancien fan des Pink Floyd que j'ai vu en concert dès le début des années '70, mais bien sûr je n'avais pu assister à une représentation d'Atom heart mother en live. Ce long morceau est un chef d’œuvre bien moins populaire que beaucoup d'autres oeuvres des Pink Floyd, toutefois, il combien à merveille plusieurs monde musicaux.: Musique classique, rock et même musique contemporaine plus abstraite . Un vrai voyage musical !! J'ai toujours chez moi, outre le cd, l'album 33 tours acheté dès sa sortie . Merci d'avoir posté cette vidéo. Désolé de répondre en Français.
2 месяца назад
Don't be discouraged! You'll get there in human language one day.
Concordo pienamente. Io sono del 1961 e la musica dei PF ha accompagnato e continua ad accompagnare tutta la mia vita. Semplicemente UNICA E IRRAGGIUNGIBILE 😊
Wow, a really amazing performance of this piece -- Ron Geesin would be proud! Amazingly faithful to the original, I don't think I've ever heard anyone handle the dissonant musical collage part 3/4 of the way through so well. Every little nuance was there, from the ethereal keyboards to the "Silence in the studio!". Kudos to the musicians and choir, and whoever had the cojones to put this whole thing together.
Wow, I am a musician and I think all you are great, but I must to say something about the drumer...... really he is amazing, he is an atomic clock. Really a great musician. Congratulations for him.
I am writing this on 13 Aug 2023 that I've never felt sorry or repented selecting Yes, ELP and Pink Floyd as my most favorite, my most beloved musicians since 1973 after buying their albums: Yes Album, Trilogy and Dark Side of the Moon in the same year. I hope they will be with me wherever I'll go in future. God, I have to thank you for the music you gave me!
Stunning! An incredible performance of a truly amazing piece of music. I bought the Atom Heart Mother LP in 1971 and have listened to it for over 50 years. This is a superb rendition.
Ha! Isn't life great when you're looking for chicken soup recipes and you stumble across an unexpected musical delight. Pink Floyd's ''Atom Heart Mother'' is a masterpiece and this LIVE performance is pretty much as close as you can get to the studio album. Dig it.
The best version of ATOM HEART MOTHER i've ever heard, I have to experience live at some point !!! Congratulations to all musicians and singers !!! 👍👍🙌🙌👏👏❤❤
Una delle più belle interpretazioni mai ascoltate ! ❤ bravi bravissimi ! Drums top ! Vocals super top 😂! From italy 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Music's healing power, i hope that everything goes well with you now, life is difficult for some of us but appreciate the beauty and positive things my friend ❤
An excellent, powerful kick-ass rendition of this Pink Floyd classic! Fearless and yet faithful to the spirit of the original. Thanks to all performers!
I don’t know how the band themselves can keep rubbishing this piece. Performances like this one prove that it’s an amazing and original classical suite that will endure forever.
It's a mystery to me, but you're right. I've never heard any of the members of Pink Floyd say anything nice about this piece or the album itself. I think it stands on its own as a great piece of composition and performance. I wonder if there might have been other, perhaps unpleasant things going on at the time the album was recorded that influences their attitude about the piece.
Perhaps they are more focussed on the confusion and lack of direction that went with recording the original rather than the quality of the final song. I think I am right in saying that Ron Geesin didn't actually finish the job and the final album version is somewhat due to John Alldis? It was also on the back of the abortive attempt to provide music for the film Zabriskie Point. However, it is clearly popular with fans - and rightly so!
Nice interpretation! Lighting is definitely the best of the live recreations of AHM. Interesting that they sound tighter than they should because of the smaller ensemble size.
Roger Waters is phenomenal for being able to create this together with his band members and everyone who contributed to it! this video is proof of his mastery, congratulations to everyone in this video.Bravo 👏
My personal favourite piece of music ever since I first heard it in 1970 as an 11 year old, almost 12 lol. This is the first time I've ever had the privilege of watching it being performed " live" so to speak and therefore approached it with a critical ear lol... What an amazing rendition I thoroughly enjoyed it. Full marks to all concerned. Toodle Pip!
I was completely amazed when I found this - I've got the album, and I never thought this piece could be played live! You pretty much nailed it! (Edit: I just read Pink Floyd did it themselves in the early years, but it appeared to be very difficult to play it with a choir and orchestra...)
My absolute favorite piece by Pink Floyd. It has haunted me, filled me with wonder and finally joy the very first time I heard it. PF has produced many great albums with incredible songs, but Atom Heart Mother will also stand out on top.
Maravilhosa 'performance' desses músicos e cantores, a primeira soprano é simplesmente primorosa, adoro essa obra de Pink Floyd, e, para essa apresentação, meus aplausos e gratidão. ❤️🇧🇷🇯🇵🤍 Bravo!
Boah - c‘est somptueux!❤❤❤ Merci pour cette interprétation géniale du premier 33 tours des Pink Floyd de ma vie - et qui restera aussi mon dernier. BRAVO!
Bonjour sublime interprétation,j'ai pleuré de joie en visionnant cette vidéo.un monument musical, bravo à tout les musiciens et organisateurs pour ce chef-d'œuvre merci beaucoup
It's great to see musicians playing the lesser appreciated elements of Pink Floyd's catalog. For some reason Atom Heart Mother seems to be given short shrift by even the most devoted Pink Floyd fans. But I think it's fantastic. And this is a beautiful rendition that is true to the original vision.
This was an experimental project that Pink Floyd made in their early years. It was a necessary step in order to get to the next step. Because nobody else had tried this type of musical piece on such a grand scale it was open to interpretation. ( the Moody Blues and Deep Purple had success with symphonic backing and they were quite successful). So Pink Floyd decided to go further with this concept and I think they did a brilliant job. The suite is varied and full of interest and deserves a fond place in their vast library. I like it a lot!
C'est grandiose. Je suis un ancien fan des Pink Floyd que j'ai vu en concert dès le début des années '70, mais bien sûr je n'avais pu assister à une représentation d'Atom heart mother en live.
Ce long morceau est un chef d’œuvre bien moins populaire que beaucoup d'autres oeuvres des Pink Floyd, toutefois, il combien à merveille plusieurs monde musicaux.: Musique classique, rock et même musique contemporaine plus abstraite . Un vrai voyage musical !!
J'ai toujours chez moi, outre le cd, l'album 33 tours acheté dès sa sortie .
Merci d'avoir posté cette vidéo. Désolé de répondre en Français.
Don't be discouraged! You'll get there in human language one day.
pourquoi desolee !? on est pas obbigee a respirer en anglais ! ognuno parli come mangia ! ciao !
Traduzir
Concordo pienamente. Io sono del 1961 e la musica dei PF ha accompagnato e continua ad accompagnare tutta la mia vita. Semplicemente UNICA E IRRAGGIUNGIBILE 😊
Pau no cú dos inglesofonos. Respeitem as culturas muito mais ricas historicamente.
Wow, a really amazing performance of this piece -- Ron Geesin would be proud! Amazingly faithful to the original, I don't think I've ever heard anyone handle the dissonant musical collage part 3/4 of the way through so well. Every little nuance was there, from the ethereal keyboards to the "Silence in the studio!". Kudos to the musicians and choir, and whoever had the cojones to put this whole thing together.
Wow, I am a musician and I think all you are great, but I must to say something about the drumer...... really he is amazing, he is an atomic clock. Really a great musician. Congratulations for him.
Да, барабанщик что надо. Очень атмосферная и бережная интерпретация, Райту бы понравилось😎👍
Hi was also the point in my eye
Fantastic ,,very beautiful ,,,Thanks for sharing ,,,,,SHINE ON ALL,,,,,
I am writing this on 13 Aug 2023 that I've never felt sorry or repented selecting Yes, ELP and Pink Floyd as my most favorite, my most beloved musicians since 1973 after buying their albums: Yes Album, Trilogy and Dark Side of the Moon in the same year. I hope they will be with me wherever I'll go in future. God, I have to thank you for the music you gave me!
You forgot early Genesis
@@Aleksandardelicdingeyou’re right. And Van Der Graaf Generator
Thanks a lot for give me this explended masterpiece , Pink Floyd.
@@Aleksandardelicdinge
Еще Crimson King
И Led Zeppelin
)
Stunning! An incredible performance of a truly amazing piece of music. I bought the Atom Heart Mother LP in 1971 and have listened to it for over 50 years. This is a superb rendition.
no seas pendejo guey!
Ha! Isn't life great when you're looking for chicken soup recipes and you stumble across an unexpected musical delight. Pink Floyd's ''Atom Heart Mother'' is a masterpiece and this LIVE performance is pretty much as close as you can get to the studio album. Dig it.
Szerintem meg sem közelíti az eredeti művet.😒
I think that I never enjoyed this as much as now with visual delivery
Über das Aushalten, Warten und die Erlösung:
Wunderbares Werk, wunderbare Interpretation!☺️
The best version of ATOM HEART MOTHER i've ever heard, I have to experience live at some point !!! Congratulations to all musicians and singers !!! 👍👍🙌🙌👏👏❤❤
I seriously think this one is better. Same musicians, same year but in March, sounds smoother.
ruclips.net/video/yTXbSSH8ZkY/видео.html
Complètement d'accord avec vous
Não consigo entender a tamanha criatividade do Pink Floyd . Sou eternamente grato por ter nascido ,crescido e ser fã do Pink Floyd.
Comparto con usted todo lo antes mencionado
la orquestaciones los coros todo es impecable
Muito certo Jarisson. Eu também.
The drummer captured the very essence of this piece. Brilliant version of one of my favourite Floyd tracks.
素晴らしいです、
ピンクフロイドを超えていると思いました、
原子心母、を初めて聞いた、数十年前と同じ気持ちになりました、
ありがとうございます
Superbe version..
Tout est parfait 👍🙏
WOW! WOW! Incredible live version!
Fantástica homenagem aos Pink Floyd, a maior e mais fantástica banda de rock de todos os tempos. Bem hajam
Bellissimo, un'opera d'arte dei Pink Floyd
Una delle più belle interpretazioni mai ascoltate ! ❤ bravi bravissimi ! Drums top ! Vocals super top 😂! From italy 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Exceptional performance and one of my favourites from the Pink FLOYD catalogue even if the band themselves hated it! Props to the higher soprano!
こういうLIVEを観に行きたい！素晴らしい！涙が止まらないです！😢昨年秋頃から今年1年間は辛いことばかりで生きていくのが嫌になりそうなくらいでした…久しぶりにピンクフロイドの名曲聴いて救われました。ありがとうございます！
Music's healing power, i hope that everything goes well with you now, life is difficult for some of us but appreciate the beauty and positive things my friend ❤
日本にピンク・フロイドのこの楽曲を再現する彼ら彼女らがいる事を誇りに思う。いつかは、この耳で直に聞いて体験したい。
You're welcome, l'm à fan of Pink Floyd too
Bravi esecuzione ottima bello vedere che i Pink Floyd vengono amati oltre i confini del mondo....
La mejor versión que he escuchado, siempre quise escuchar Atom heart mother versión del siglo XXI y creo que lo he logrado
encore plus vrai que nature que l'original. Et ces coeurs ! dommage qu'on n'en sait pas plus sur la magistrale cheffe d'orchestre
An excellent, powerful kick-ass rendition of this Pink Floyd classic! Fearless and yet faithful to the spirit of the original. Thanks to all performers!
Excellent!!! And I really don't comprehend all this explosion of modesty from the side of the director(rin)
I don’t know how the band themselves can keep rubbishing this piece. Performances like this one prove that it’s an amazing and original classical suite that will endure forever.
It's a mystery to me, but you're right. I've never heard any of the members of Pink Floyd say anything nice about this piece or the album itself. I think it stands on its own as a great piece of composition and performance. I wonder if there might have been other, perhaps unpleasant things going on at the time the album was recorded that influences their attitude about the piece.
Perhaps they are more focussed on the confusion and lack of direction that went with recording the original rather than the quality of the final song. I think I am right in saying that Ron Geesin didn't actually finish the job and the final album version is somewhat due to John Alldis? It was also on the back of the abortive attempt to provide music for the film Zabriskie Point. However, it is clearly popular with fans - and rightly so!
The voices of paradise. Amazing version of Floyd . For eternity
R.I.P. lovely reina
Totally excellent reading of this masterpiece. The whole ensemble is spot on. Congratulations
Nice interpretation! Lighting is definitely the best of the live recreations of AHM. Interesting that they sound tighter than they should because of the smaller ensemble size.
良質、忠実に、「原子・心・母」を再現している。半世紀前、レコード盤に耳を傾けたのを思い出す。いい曲だ。
Beautiful solo by two women, and some tactlessness of the soloist in all this, amazing choir, I love playing with Pink Floyd's music
Purchased on vinyl at around age 17. I'm almost 69 now
I remember....😊😊
i much prefer this video because you have a full band and the conductor. ir adds to the feeling
fantastic version please come México to bring some of your inspiration
すごい再現力、迫力！
これ聴きに行きたい✨✨
Roger Waters is phenomenal for being able to create this together with his band members and everyone who contributed to it! this video is proof of his mastery, congratulations to everyone in this video.Bravo 👏
The genius of Pink Floyd re-presented in a n admirable version❤
My personal favourite piece of music ever since I first heard it in 1970 as an 11 year old, almost 12 lol. This is the first time I've ever had the privilege of watching it being performed " live" so to speak and therefore approached it with a critical ear lol... What an amazing rendition I thoroughly enjoyed it. Full marks to all concerned. Toodle Pip!
素晴らしい、ありがとうございます
魂の曲です。涙出ます。
Great! Pink Floyd has become Classic Music!
They have always been, there is only music, one kind or as many as parts
Una delle più belle originali commistioni di generi. Assolutamente meraviglioso.
行くはずだったライヴ
観れて 聴けて 嬉しいです！
この 乾いた様な ドラムの音
存在感凄いのに ふわっとした
ギター
そして大本命 三国さんの鍵盤
どれもこれも 素晴らしいです！
ありがとうございます🥰
I was completely amazed when I found this - I've got the album, and I never thought this piece could be played live! You pretty much nailed it!
(Edit: I just read Pink Floyd did it themselves in the early years, but it appeared to be very difficult to play it with a choir and orchestra...)
Qualcosa che mi commuove, che ho vissuto e che appartiene al futuro. Anche ascoltare e apprezzare è comunque un contributo a immortalare meraviglie.
stunning performance
C'est réellement prodigieux. Quels musiciens, quelle chef!
Spectaculaire ! Bravo !
"Atom Heart Mother Suite" contains literally everything already that made the following albums famous
Well, except it had no lyrics! And ... PF are also renowned for their lyrics!
😍....j'en ai rêvé et vous l'avez fait!...
No quiero morir sin antes escuchar esta obra de arte en vivo. Pink Floyd fue más allá de lo idílico con esta canción. ☄️💜
rivaliza mucho con echoes
50年以上前の曲とは思えない。20歳前に良く聴きました。
Complimenti,un arrangiamento perfetto! Un saluto a voi tutti e grazie di ❤🙏. Mi sono emozionato.
BRAVISSIMI tutti eccezionale esecuzione
Geweldig mooie uitvoering, en zeker wel een van de betere.
Klasse!
バンドが団結しているのを見るのは素晴らしいことです...他のミュージシャンや楽器をこの素晴らしい音楽に統合しています...あなたは私にとってあなたがどれほど重要かわかりません...あなたがするすべての仕事に感謝します...ありがとうあなたはそんなに！...
Espectacular!. Mucho respeto por la canción original.
❤merci pour ce monument historique de la musique 🎵
Interplanétaire et interprété avec Brio !
3年前か行きたかったなーフロイドはこれが一番好きだ最高 !
Brings back fantastic memories, from "George" Peace out!
My absolute favorite piece by Pink Floyd. It has haunted me, filled me with wonder and finally joy the very first time I heard it. PF has produced many great albums with incredible songs, but Atom Heart Mother will also stand out on top.
50数年前の感動を堪能この楽曲を聞いて当時ジャンルなどは吹っ飛びました。聴きまくった青春が懐かしく感動をありがとう。ジャンルを超えて集まったスタッフに感謝感謝感謝😂😂😂😂😂
Very Gold! I Love This álbum of Pink Floyd played now here.Thanks.
Gigantesque ... Merci
Musicalmente precioso, grandes acordes sonantes y disonantes, musicalmente perfectos y al mismo tiempo música atona, Me gusta!!!!
Uma obra-prima de um Pink Floyd muito inspirado, reproduzido com maestria nesse evento.
...me eseñas mucho con este tipo de videos..
Gracias..
ETERNETY PINK FLOYD
Obras-primas revisitadas com maestria.
Parabéns...
Bravo! Great performance of a classic suite.
Maravilhosa 'performance' desses músicos e cantores, a primeira soprano é simplesmente primorosa, adoro essa obra de Pink Floyd, e, para essa apresentação, meus aplausos e gratidão.
❤️🇧🇷🇯🇵🤍
Bravo!
Super performance like Pink Floyd
Stupenda versione , la piu' bella che ho sentito ! Complimenti♥
Boah - c‘est somptueux!❤❤❤ Merci pour cette interprétation géniale du premier 33 tours des Pink Floyd de ma vie - et qui restera aussi mon dernier. BRAVO!
Wow, a very powerful version! Phantastique!
This awesome very professional musical interpretation I loved 🥰 ❤❤❤
Very good version! Great!
Vraiment très belle version
Merci du fond du cœur
Awesome, thanks for sharing
Everywhere astonishing.
The sunset of western world.
Blown away at the 6+ minute part......
世界中から寄せられる賛辞。高校の時ジャズ喫茶で初めて聞いて衝撃を受けた世代にはとても嬉しい。
Absolutely phenomenal performance, this is one of my favorite pieces of music ever and they nailed it.
Bonjour sublime interprétation,j'ai pleuré de joie en visionnant cette vidéo.un monument musical, bravo à tout les musiciens et organisateurs pour ce chef-d'œuvre merci beaucoup
It is always a pleasure to watch the performance of this iconic masterpiece... ❤
It's great to see musicians playing the lesser appreciated elements of Pink Floyd's catalog. For some reason Atom Heart Mother seems to be given short shrift by even the most devoted Pink Floyd fans. But I think it's fantastic. And this is a beautiful rendition that is true to the original vision.
It's closer to a classical music piece.
Totally agree. I don't think even Roger could complain about this performance.
Not given short shrift by this devoted Pink Floyd fan! It's my favourite album.
Muito bom! Pink Floyd orquestrado, experiência imersiva.
amazing performance
great performance. thank you
Very very beatiful
This was an experimental project that Pink Floyd made in their early years. It was a necessary step in order to get to the next step. Because nobody else had tried this type of musical piece on such a grand scale it was open to interpretation. ( the Moody Blues and Deep Purple had success with symphonic backing and they were quite successful). So Pink Floyd decided to go further with this concept and I think they did a brilliant job. The suite is varied and full of interest and deserves a fond place in their vast library. I like it a lot!
superb rendition! lovely
Sé que en algún momento la escucharé en vivo.
❤❤❤
Fantastic interpretation! Really great!
この曲は数十年前に箱根でのコンサートで聞いた懐かしい曲です。大好き名曲です。75才。
素晴らしい! Such an absurd, great piece in a very great performance!
If I close my eyes it really sounds like the Original thanks for sharing this Masterpiece!!!!
もう『第九』みたいに年末の恒例にしちゃいましょう。
really spectacular, congratulations and thanks
Fantastic🔥