Just incase you guys forgot, this is a reality show, things get cut out all the time so you can't say they gave Carly the best bit to sing when Bea also sang the chorus while Carly also sang another verse, they just cut it out.
It don’t matter because this is the judges who are deciding not America. And they made their decision from hearing north of their full live performances
Just watched Bea's video about the X Factor. She said that they both had a verse and a chorus but they didn't show it. She also said she burned her forehead, not a pimple lol.
So If They Show The Whole Freaking Songs, These People Sing, You'll Not Watch It. because it would be so freaking long. editing is a necessity . kids just cry . i don't know the reality, but you just can't say that. I have felt the system was rigged on competing myself but you just can't use that to your advantage like this . sue them, if you are so sure , that they are rigged and shit. it's a reality show x{ they do take good looking people with not so good voices but that is because the people want to see that !! SHOW BUSINESS DARLING. and about your heatstroke and all , you can sue them like shit, if you are speaking the truth. no hatred. it's a cute little girl for god's sake xP i feel sad myself but thats is just the way it is. p.s kids do make up stories. and a lot of shows ARE RIGGED.
I just don't feel like Bea had the voice power to go up against Carly. Bea has a beautiful voice but there was really no way for her to overpower Carly. That being said, I also think that it is incredibly unfair to blame Carly for trying hard. She is there to showcase her talent, not to hold back for her competition.
Anon Whoops You're so dumb, this is a competition you can't expect to win if you just copy the vocals of the original song. You NEED to have your own voice and style to appeal to the judges. Idiot.
I'm reading these comments and some petty people are saying that Carly was seeking attention and how she hogged the stage and how Bea is more famous now and stuff and I just want you all to know that 1, it is a competition. 2, when it was Bea's turn she walked up front too. 3, it was not Carly being disrespectful, it was Carly singing her heart out like she always has. 4, Carly is trying to finish school before she goes for the music business. And 4, all you people can hate all day but at the end of the day, both those girls have more talent in their finger nail than you have in your body so if you don't have anything nice to say, dont say it at all. Point Blank.
If they hate they hate but doesn't mean the haters don't have talent. Everyone is talented at some just some haven't found it yet. I don't really have a talent but I can pick up any intrument and learn how to play it rather quickly
They each got a verse and a chorus. They just edited out stuff to make it seem more of a rival thing. First Bea did hers and then Carly. That's why Carly was in front at the end.
+Whos.ashley I read in one of the comments that she's finishing school. And she worked with Timeflies on their song called Runaway. She's also working on music, I hear.
in case you guys didn't know, they both get a verse and a chorus they just don't show the whole song. so we don't know how bea sounded because we didn't get the chance to listen.
I can't believe Carly lost over some country guy no offence but she's waaaaaaaaaaaaay more better than the country guy whom somehow won the X factor 201w
I bet it was all predetermined, and the multiple rounds are just for entertainment. I don’t think many sane people would actually vote for the cowboy guy over Carly or even Beatrice.
Carly is the better singer, but if I was choosing someone to record this song it would be Beatrice all day long; her voice and interpretation is just perfect for the song.
Its 2017 now, and queen Bea is on top of her game. She had a debut album, and she's going to release another one very soon. So Proud of her. She's come so far. 💕
people saying carly tries too hard? man if you have an audition and youre battling against someone else, you HAVE to outdo the other and perform your hardest. show them what you've got, no wonder she "over did" that performance. Bea actually shoulda tried harder in that sense to outshine her competition.
Bea even said in a video that they both got a verse and a chorus. They just showed Carly's chorus so it sounded like she was better and had a stronger voice for the song. Its just apart of television.
I like both of them. But I like Bea's tone better than Carly's. But Carly has more of a range and her higher register is insane. I can't choose. But I didn't like how Carly stopped right in front of Bea trying to show off. That was a low.
I honestly love them both, this was such a hard season to watch because I love Beatrice Miller's voice as well, I mean they are completely different but both very talented extremely talented!!!!
For people who don't know, they each got to sing a verse and chorus but they just aired this part. Beatrice posted a video talking about X-factor. The red mark on her forehead is from a straightener burn.
Nothing to do with which section of the song either got. It is about the strength of the vocals. Beatrice didn't have to do anything fancy...she just had to sing it, which she did and done very well.
Carly has the perfect vocal technique but lack a personality, so Bea has a free kind soul, when she sings can really touch your hearth and make u feel electrified. Bea it’s such an amazing artist and Carly just another perfect voice
I like Bea more because she has a softer and easier voice than Carly because Carly wouldn't be able to do that kind of things in a song that's today unless it's like shakira. Bea's voice is more natural:) Carly does have an amazing voice tho no hate.
I think Carly had the upper hand in this competition because she got the better sounding part of the song. They should've at least sang the same thing and adjust it accordingly themselves. This seems pretty biased and unfair to Beatrice.
Carly sang better (because she had a better part sing?) but Bea was the better, more connected and electric entertainer. During that competition I remember writing that Carly will have a great career, but Bea will end up in the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame.
You knows, the most of winner of xFactor don't continue into Music, look, Beatrice Miller and Carly Rose Sonenclar didn't won, but they will make an album. Tates won and ? Tates who ? xD
10 лет назад
Yeah, It's good for Bea, 'cause She have really good friends, Carly start her career too, It take a more time but She have one, you know that Bea is the best friend of Demi's little sister ?
Carly you have a beautiful voice that showers over Beatrice's voice. What a powerful voice you have. I'm inspired you will have very bright future I wish all the best.
They tried to make it look like carly could sing high and was so much better because they both had 1 verse and 1 chorus they showed carly singing the chorus at the end where the high notes are and they didnt show were Beatrice doing the same....
and so what? Beatrice has more personality... one of the main reasons Beatirce is where she is now. Who has a hit single?Beatrice. Who's gone on two tours around the world?Beatrice. Who's more known?Beatrice. It doesn't matter who can hold a note look at Britney Spears, she super famous and she can't sing even Shakira!
Who cares who is more famous? Lol just because your famous does not make you a better singer, and I get no one likes Carly for whatever reason but what "personality" did bea have? Absolutely none. Apparently, Carly wanted to finish and focus on school. Bea went the other way good for her, not even my point she still will never be a better singer than Carly. Period.
Bea does have personality, and I never said I didn't like Carly. You've obviously never seen her RUclips videos... Don't be so quick to judge when you haven't seen that side of her before. My first comment in the first place had nothing to do with who can sing better. S
Everyone all hate aside both girls are amazing and will go far in life no matter who is in the music business right now both will be in the music business in 5-10 years time. Good job to both of you girls
ces deux petite la se passage je le repasse en boucle sa fait la 10000 ieme fois elle son cute leurs prestation est juste oufe les deux ensemble la comme sa c'est un pure plaisir
So the first time I watched this I was all rooting for Carly but I found it again after my Bea obsession hit and I don't even know what to do any more. 😫
That's because she chooses to focus on school. At least she has a back up career if Carly's musical career doesn't go well. Carly's voice is way better than Bea, she just chooses to live a normal life.
Where? Cause I haven't seen Bea anywhere in the top whatever, since just after the show. Carly chose to focus on school, but I'm absolutely positive that when she decides to pursue music professionally, she will blow Bea out of the water.
carly does have the better voice but in this competition you have to have "it" nobody knows what "it" is but to become famous you have to have IT. thats why bea is more known at the moment and having her song on the radio rather then carly.
![Carly Rose Sonenclar and Tate Stevens - The Climb (The X-Factor USA 2012) [Final]](/img/1.gif)
Bea has more of a raspy voice and Carly's is more powerful
spoopy jim true but both have powerful voices and both have good voice control but Carlys range is just a bit higher
spoopy jim I agree
Just incase you guys forgot, this is a reality show, things get cut out all the time so you can't say they gave Carly the best bit to sing when Bea also sang the chorus while Carly also sang another verse, they just cut it out.
Truth.
MeMyself&Cam and Bea Miller did a video explaining that they got an even share of a verse and a chorus.
Kath&Ash this is true
a voz da carly é mais forte, ou seja, o justo foi dar o refrão para ela. É o mais obvio para ficar bom
Kath&Ash who cares? Bea is famous now so yhea
Bea did a chorus but they cut it out and Carly did a verse but they cut it out which was unfair
Angelica Schuyler yea! I didn't show that bea’s most awesome singing!
Exactly what I was thinking about
It don’t matter because this is the judges who are deciding not America. And they made their decision from hearing north of their full live performances
And they both made it through…. What’s unfair about it🥱
Just watched Bea's video about the X Factor. She said that they both had a verse and a chorus but they didn't show it. She also said she burned her forehead, not a pimple lol.
So If They Show The Whole Freaking Songs, These People Sing, You'll Not Watch It.
because it would be so freaking long.
editing is a necessity . kids just cry .
i don't know the reality, but you just can't say that.
I have felt the system was rigged on competing myself but you just can't use that to your advantage like this .
sue them, if you are so sure , that they are rigged and shit.
it's a reality show x{ they do take good looking people with not so good voices but that is because the people want to see that !! SHOW BUSINESS DARLING.
and about your heatstroke and all , you can sue them like shit, if you are speaking the truth.
no hatred. it's a cute little girl for god's sake xP i feel sad myself but thats is just the way it is.
p.s kids do make up stories. and a lot of shows ARE RIGGED.
chivalry dead
She burnt her for head with a curling iron I believe. Nothing to be sued over lmfao.
isabunny101 but why would it matter if it were a pimple
I just don't feel like Bea had the voice power to go up against Carly. Bea has a beautiful voice but there was really no way for her to overpower Carly. That being said, I also think that it is incredibly unfair to blame Carly for trying hard. She is there to showcase her talent, not to hold back for her competition.
well said
yep well said !
This competition is all about covers and doing something different than how the song was originally sung is what makes the song stand out.
Anon Whoops You're so dumb, this is a competition you can't expect to win if you just copy the vocals of the original song. You NEED to have your own voice and style to appeal to the judges. Idiot.
mrsinvincible3000 exactly
Carly knows how to make everything her own...she adds these crazy runs and harmonies and it's amazing. That's what makes her stand out.
I'm reading these comments and some petty people are saying that Carly was seeking attention and how she hogged the stage and how Bea is more famous now and stuff and I just want you all to know that 1, it is a competition. 2, when it was Bea's turn she walked up front too. 3, it was not Carly being disrespectful, it was Carly singing her heart out like she always has. 4, Carly is trying to finish school before she goes for the music business. And 4, all you people can hate all day but at the end of the day, both those girls have more talent in their finger nail than you have in your body so if you don't have anything nice to say, dont say it at all. Point Blank.
5*
If they hate they hate but doesn't mean the haters don't have talent. Everyone is talented at some just some haven't found it yet. I don't really have a talent but I can pick up any intrument and learn how to play it rather quickly
Actually bea carly and diamond are best friends so nobody was seeking attention
The whole thing about them having more talent then people in this comment section a really stupid assumption bruh...dont be a dick.
Well said avery!
I prefer this cover instead of the original one
Games Lover me too
Games Lover what's the name of the song
Abdouxcx Pumped up kicks
i need a full version
Yeees, rhey should have to retake it and put it out as a cover.
They each got a verse and a chorus. They just edited out stuff to make it seem more of a rival thing. First Bea did hers and then Carly. That's why Carly was in front at the end.
Beatrice had an amazing voice, but honestly Carly made this song her own and OWNED it :0
I love Carly's voice and Beatrice is good too, but Carly deserved to win.
anitabreakone yup
anitabreakone Carly was so much better
U didn’t get to see the full thing so I wouldn’t give an opinion tbh. Some things were obviously cut out to make one look better than the other...
Idk where Carly is rn but I know that Bea has a hit
Whos.ashley Carly has a day named after her in her town, and I think she's doing covers online.
+Whos.ashley I read in one of the comments that she's finishing school. And she worked with Timeflies on their song called Runaway. She's also working on music, I hear.
She dropped a song named birds and the bees.. It's good 😍
@@ssrob wow that’s cool
in case you guys didn't know, they both get a verse and a chorus they just don't show the whole song. so we don't know how bea sounded because we didn't get the chance to listen.
bahree Is so sad how they dont give us carly rose all sing, probably the best version of this song.
I can't believe Carly lost over some country guy no offence but she's waaaaaaaaaaaaay more better than the country guy whom somehow won the X factor 201w
Mawadah Alkibsy 9
I know right?
You guys American love shitty country singer right? Take that !!
I bet it was all predetermined, and the multiple rounds are just for entertainment. I don’t think many sane people would actually vote for the cowboy guy over Carly or even Beatrice.
Yep, still can't believe it 🤧
Carly is the better singer, but if I was choosing someone to record this song it would be Beatrice all day long; her voice and interpretation is just perfect for the song.
Eh what?
Carly's voice is so much more powerful.
Its 2017 now, and queen Bea is on top of her game. She had a debut album, and she's going to release another one very soon. So Proud of her. She's come so far. 💕
people saying carly tries too hard? man if you have an audition and youre battling against someone else, you HAVE to outdo the other and perform your hardest. show them what you've got, no wonder she "over did" that performance. Bea actually shoulda tried harder in that sense to outshine her competition.
Carly's voice is too powerful for this song. When I think of this song I think raspy like Beas voice.
Best season of X Factor USA
Carly's made me cry, I'm serious😭😭she is really good
Bea even said in a video that they both got a verse and a chorus. They just showed Carly's chorus so it sounded like she was better and had a stronger voice for the song. Its just apart of television.
I like both of them. But I like Bea's tone better than Carly's. But Carly has more of a range and her higher register is insane. I can't choose. But I didn't like how Carly stopped right in front of Bea trying to show off. That was a low.
Bea did have a Chorus part but they cut it off and put Carly's instead. Carly did sing a verse, but they cut that out too.
I believe she didn't mean to do that on purpose
Sabrina Laskey carlys voice is better buy tone wise bea
But it’s fine if Beatrice does it?
Bea did the exact same thing though lmao
both have such talent, the way bea said why I was so impressed it was so nice, carly is a natural
I love Carly Rose Sonenclar
She was the best
I honestly love them both, this was such a hard season to watch because I love Beatrice Miller's voice as well, I mean they are completely different but both very talented extremely talented!!!!
Carly ❤
Always team carly, also if she isn't more famous tan bea
Beatrice was cute......but then Carly stepped in like, hmmmmmm. I'm about to do this right chea. When it was her turn, she DELIVERED.
Shai's Time bea got a chorus too and Carly got a verse but the show didn't show it so you can't really say that
Spot on sis.. Carly was like yeah yeah that shit was cute now back up give me some space.. I'm bout to kill this shit lil cutie
For people who don't know, they each got to sing a verse and chorus but they just aired this part. Beatrice posted a video talking about X-factor. The red mark on her forehead is from a straightener burn.
I'm just proud of how far Bea has become since the x factor days to her amazing work of Chapter 1-3 💙❤💛
Look at where Bea is now!!! Compared to Carly!! But Carly still almost won the X factor!
+Diya Bains I believe Carly had temporarily stopped singing for schooling that's why.
Carly got the chorus which is known more than the first verse, Bea got the first verce and you can't really do anythung to fancy with that.
Nothing to do with which section of the song either got. It is about the strength of the vocals. Beatrice didn't have to do anything fancy...she just had to sing it, which she did and done very well.
bea actually sang the chorus too but they didn't show it
I haven't seen that one. How did Beatrice do with it?
Carly has some major pipes and there is something about Bea that seems really cool
Carly has the perfect vocal technique but lack a personality, so Bea has a free kind soul, when she sings can really touch your hearth and make u feel electrified. Bea it’s such an amazing artist and Carly just another perfect voice
Carly rose is better
Carly came in too fast at first.
***** Yeah, that's why I was here
Both of these women need to sing together...I recently listened to both of these women latest songs and their voices would harmonize perfectly...
I like Bea more because she has a softer and easier voice than Carly because Carly wouldn't be able to do that kind of things in a song that's today unless it's like shakira. Bea's voice is more natural:) Carly does have an amazing voice tho no hate.
ruclips.net/video/4Fy6qT3QJJ0t/видео.htmlhat solves your question about carly's voice, can and more than that
I think Carly had the upper hand in this competition because she got the better sounding part of the song. They should've at least sang the same thing and adjust it accordingly themselves. This seems pretty biased and unfair to Beatrice.
Carly sang better (because she had a better part sing?) but Bea was the better, more connected and electric entertainer. During that competition I remember writing that Carly will have a great career, but Bea will end up in the Rock n Roll Hall of Fame.
They're both amazing in different ways you can't compare them to each other
Carly should've won :/ my opinion.
The fact that Carly did not win completely destroys that show's credibility.
saumerez I agree. Truly talented and she made each song her own. Really amazing.
I know
You knows, the most of winner of xFactor don't continue into Music, look, Beatrice Miller and Carly Rose Sonenclar didn't won, but they will make an album. Tates won and ? Tates who ? xD
Yeah, It's good for Bea, 'cause She have really good friends, Carly start her career too, It take a more time but She have one, you know that Bea is the best friend of Demi's little sister ?
Carly you have a beautiful voice that showers over Beatrice's voice. What a powerful voice you have. I'm inspired you will have very bright future I wish all the best.
bea's voice is SO good
This song suits Beatrice better
True but I still adore Carly more.Just my opinion...
Why so cute! And 13 and your singing like that. WOW!! God Bless them
i personally loved each part they sang
Great song choice
They didn't show Beatrice's chorus
They tried to make it look like carly could sing high and was so much better because they both had 1 verse and 1 chorus they showed carly singing the chorus at the end where the high notes are and they didnt show were Beatrice doing the same....
ThatBeautyGal and even still beatrice voice wouldn't have out powered Carly's.
and so what? Beatrice has more personality... one of the main reasons Beatirce is where she is now. Who has a hit single?Beatrice. Who's gone on two tours around the world?Beatrice. Who's more known?Beatrice. It doesn't matter who can hold a note look at Britney Spears, she super famous and she can't sing even Shakira!
Who cares who is more famous? Lol just because your famous does not make you a better singer, and I get no one likes Carly for whatever reason but what "personality" did bea have? Absolutely none. Apparently, Carly wanted to finish and focus on school. Bea went the other way good for her, not even my point she still will never be a better singer than Carly. Period.
Bea does have personality, and I never said I didn't like Carly. You've obviously never seen her RUclips videos... Don't be so quick to judge when you haven't seen that side of her before. My first comment in the first place had nothing to do with who can sing better. S
So I'm putting you on mute, because you're not gonna waste my time.
i seen beatrice explain o she also sang a chorus...they should have shown that as well...not fair
aww my baby Bea
this is funny bc Bea's more succesful than Carly nowadays
So true !!!!
But fame is not equivalent to talent...
😂 true
+Navya TheAwesome Bea is good though so... it's all a matter of opinion
+YoItsClo i guess
i can’t believe the producers thought it was okay for 13 year old girls to be singing this song on television 😭 then again it was 2012
Everyone all hate aside both girls are amazing and will go far in life no matter who is in the music business right now both will be in the music business in 5-10 years time. Good job to both of you girls
2018 and still here x)
Love you carly rose 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍
their both amazing love fire and gold
Both are AWESOME
Carly ALWAYS steals the stage away hahaha... I love it.
ces deux petite la se passage je le repasse en boucle sa fait la 10000 ieme fois elle son cute leurs prestation est juste oufe les deux ensemble la comme sa c'est un pure plaisir
I love Carly's voice but she got the chorus advantage
Carly is such a performer
So the first time I watched this I was all rooting for Carly but I found it again after my Bea obsession hit and I don't even know what to do any more. 😫
y’all need to stop comparing them, they are two different types of singers with different voices, they are both good in their own ways.
Britany k. this was like 3 years ago😂but you should hmu on instagram- brikal.c 😂😂
I've watched this video multiple times over several months and idek why
good job you guys!!!!!!
Carly should have won even tho shes was just a child. Her stage maturity and voice were unbelievable for her age.
now in *2018* *Bea* Is a *singer*
and *Carly* still at the X factor
Still my fav. 😍 Bea and Carly. Who's watching this in 2018? 😊😍
i miss this
Carlyrose sing with more soul than anybody
I love it you r awesome
Bea killed it.🔥❤️
Love this video
oh, i miss this so much. i'm really bad at moving on, i guess
Love them both so much 💕
they both had a verse and a chorus but they cut off bea's chorus and Carly's verse
I love this song
I love it
carly is just too good😍😍
Demi is so cute
Loved them singing this song:)
Now no one knows who Carly is and Bea is slaying the game lmao
That's because she chooses to focus on school. At least she has a back up career if Carly's musical career doesn't go well. Carly's voice is way better than Bea, she just chooses to live a normal life.
Where? Cause I haven't seen Bea anywhere in the top whatever, since just after the show. Carly chose to focus on school, but I'm absolutely positive that when she decides to pursue music professionally, she will blow Bea out of the water.
Who is Bea? 🤔
I will always know Carly as Gilda Flip from Electric Company.
Guys, stop talking about how Bea is more famous than Carly now and all that. Both of them have tons of talent.
who has a hit song called fire and gold? Bea! haha love this
Carly sang the high notes, they've should listen to Bea's.
They did, it just wasn't shown neither was Carly singing the verse.
carly does have the better voice
but in this competition you have to have "it"
nobody knows what "it" is but to become famous you have to have IT. thats why bea is more known at the moment and having her song on the radio rather then carly.
These two are absolute powerhouses
#talented #carly 💖
Carly, omg ! she is fantastic ♥
Beatrice this should be your song errthing on point reolace song now
These girls are so good singers Johnthielberg
Carly I pick Carly
I still cant believe she sounds so good
Carly is badass, she has real talent.
Ummm, yea Carly was meant to be a star!
I like them both