Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto and Balochistan -
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 июл 2024
- Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @thepakistanexperience
The Pakistan Experience is an independently produced podcast looking to tell stories about Pakistan through conversations.
Please consider supporting us on Patreon:a
/ thepakistanexperience
To support the channel:
Jazzcash/Easypaisa - 0325 -2982912
Patreon.com/thepakistanexperience
And Please stay in touch:
/ thepakistanexp1
/ thepakistanexperience
/ thepakistanexpeperience
The podcast is hosted by comedian and writer, Shehzad Ghias Shaikh. Shehzad is a Fulbright scholar with a Masters in Theatre from Brooklyn College. He is also one of the foremost Stand-up comedians in Pakistan and frequently writes for numerous publications.
shehzadghiasshaikh
Facebook.com/Shehzadghias/
shehzad89
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @thepakistanexperience 
Развлечения
Bhutto, Mujib and Yahya Khan - 1971 Bangladesh kee Sachayee kya hay? - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
ruclips.net/video/OWR8SLvRg4A/видео.html
This is what I appreciate about India. It acknowledged the various states and languages and brought them together under one banner of 'Bharat' or 'India.'
I have acquaintances here who are from Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, and they don't know a word of Hindi. To my surprise, I used to think Hindi was the national language of India, but in reality, it is the national language only of Maharashtra. The entire south portion (or West, North and East alike) have the liberty to impose their own national language.
This is why Indians are stronger in their communal aspect. Every language, custom and culture is respected without the imposition of the majority government
One correction. There is no national language of India. Yes there are many official languages. And Hindi is not from Maharashtra. Marathi is the language of Maharashtrian. ❤
No Hindi is not Maharashtras language.It is the language of North Indian states but all of us speak it. We also speak other languages .
Marathi is Maharashtra’s state language but there’s no imposition on which language to use in Maharashtra. Although it’s a compulsory to study Marathi besides English and Hindi in school till tenth grade
@@anuchugh31 It is not mandatory, it is only the case if you are in a state board school.
@@fakebatli friends son is studying in cbse school dude. Be receptive to other pov or search online
As a baloch I love you.
❤️
The main reason for the break up of Pakistan was that Mujibur Rahman was prevented from becoming the PM even though he won the majority in the election. Are you suggesting that Bhutto had no role in keeping Mujibur Rahman out and the blame should go only to the army?
Bhutto, Mujib and Yahya Khan - 1971 Bangladesh kee Sachayee kya hay? - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
ruclips.net/video/OWR8SLvRg4A/видео.html
Wali Khan fully supported Zia-ul-Haq, martial law he was the first politician who asked Zia to prosecute Bhutto instead of holding elections in 90 days. Nawab Marri, Sher Muhammad Marri aka General Sharro had told me that they were close to creating Balochistan after Bangladesh, but the Shah of Iran and Bhutto thwarted our plan.
This is a breath of fresh air. Atleast someone talking about our past the way it was
Sir you should also make a video on Jinnah's biggest blunder when he sent forces to invade Balochistan. And also a video on when a British General denied Jinnah's orders to send forces to Kashmir
Jhute bihari Jinnah Sahab ne Akbar bugti se milkar Balochistan join karaya
@IqbalBakht I am not Bihari by the way. Kalat was forced to become part of Pakistan. Read Taj Mohammad Breseeg book.
@@brassbaloch309 I am not Bihari by the way. Kalat was forced to become part of Pakistan. Read Taj Mohammad Breseeg book.
@@darthvader56 brahui propaganda hai ye baloch srf development chahta tha jisko brahui ne freedom movement bana diya or khud aram se balocho ko mar rhe hai brahui
I remember when I was university student, I used to argue with my Sindhi nationalist friends that if you are promoting nationalism, you are in fact promoting anti-Islamism. Now when I reconsider, I don’t understand how this idea was inculcated in my mind through the media with people like Zaid hamid and may be through some “islamic” influencers of that time. Now I realize how stupid was I to argue that.
Being anti-islam is also justified though, not all people want an outdated religion governing them
@@f.50 you see Islam is not all about governing. Islam allows people to have their own identity. People can maintain their identity and still practice Islam.
@@asad2880 Islam allows you to leave religion if you want to? Do you even know the punishment for apostates?
@@f.50 Having an identity and leaving religion are two very different things. I can be a Punjabi and a Muslim. Being punjabi won’t hurt my religious beliefs. Thats what I am saying.
@@asad2880 but you used to be against nationalism because it seemed anti-islam, not because it seemed anti Pakistan.
And it bothered you why someone was being anti-islam when it shouldn't have
Finally been asking for this one for a long time
🙌
Why is this Palestinian gentleman talking about Pakistan??? Few months back he was holding the Palestinian flag so dearly. He was posting videos after videos for Palestinian cause. As a Palestinian supporter am outraged. My identity being Palestinian and his being the same, and seeing him talk about a country ( neighbour of India) which has nothing to do with us, am disappointed.
Very informative and good analysis.. thanks.
🙌
Agree with u talked truth about Sindh Baloch
This was great Shezad
Sorry off topic request
Would be really great if you do a take on the judiciary's role historically and what are the gaps that should be fixed going forward to progress....I just feel their role in our failures or progress goes relatively unnoticed
🙌
Nice job explain everything so clear
🙌
Bro, I'm scared for your life. This is an important conversation to be had but I'm worried for you. Always watch your 6 man.
❤️
Shahzad bhai apki ki Pakistan political history playlist ka link to dena
Why Bhutto launched a military operation in Baluchistan?
1- Background:
Zulfiquar Ali Bhutto became President in December 1971, shortly after the “East Pakistan Debacle.” In 1972-73, the Communist Afghan regime restarted it’s support for the “Pashtunistan” & “Azad Balochistan” (Chakkar movement) movements. They intensified the Radio Kabul propaganda & sheltered NAP (an anti-state political party of Pakistan) activists inside Balochistan & KPK.
The NAP activists were led by Ajmal Khattak. In July 1973, Sardar Doud led a bloodless military coup to overthrow King Zahir Shah & declared himself the President of Afghanistan. One of the reasons he quoted for the coup was Zahir Shah’s supposedly soft approach on “Pashtunistan” issue.
Afghan official gazette published the Pashtunistan flag & also ran inflammatory reports about terrorist activities of Pashtunistan miscreants. Radio Kabul’s propaganda reached its peak. Bhutto arrested several leaders of NAP on the charges of treason & launched military operation in Balochistan and intelligence based operations in KPK, to crush the separatists.
2- The Pakhtunistan Issue:
In February 1974, Afghan animosity to Pakistan was so great that Afghan President Doud didn’t participate in the ‘OIC Leaders Summit’ held in Lahore. Abdul Rahman Pazhwak, the Afghan delegate at the summit, tried to raise “Pashtunistan issue” on this Unity forum too but got snubbed as no Muslim country’s leader paid any heed.
From 1973-78, soon after Doud assumed power, Afghan government started supporting the Baloch insurgents fighting against Pakistan. Afghanistan sheltered thousands of Marri tribesmen & gave them training+weapons for militant activities inside Pakistan. In the same period of time, Afghan government (under Doud) continued to support the “Pashtunistan proxies.”
3- NAP’s terrorism in Pakistan:
NAP’s militant wing “Pakhtun Zalmi” was funded/trained/armed by Kabul for terrorist attacks in Pakistan. These facts have been confirmed by Jumma Khan Sufi, a close aide of Ajmal Khattak, in his memoirs “Faraib-e-Na Tamam.” Sufi remained in exile for 20 years in Afghanistan & was involved in the Afghan proxy activities inside Pakistan. Not only was Afghanistan supporting NAP terrorism in Pakistan itself, it also became a hub for Indian interference into Pakistan via Pashtunistan & Balochistan proxies.
NAP leaders were paid monthly stipends & other funds by Indian government as admitted by Jumma Khan Sufi in his memoirs. In February 1975, Hayat Sherpao, (Senior PPP minister & ex-Governor NWFP) was killed in a bomb blast. The assassination was carried out by NAP militant wing operating out of Afghanistan (as confirmed by Jumma Khan Sufi some three decades later).
4- Conclusion:
In April 1978, Afghan President Doud & his whole family were massacred in the Soviet-sponsored “Saur Revolution.” The new pro-Communist regime announced an all-out support for “Pashtunistan.” Later in December 1979, Soviet secret service (KGB) assassinated Afghanistan’s President Hafizullah Amin & nearly 100,000 Soviet forces entered Afghanistan.
Babrak Karmal was installed as President by Soviets who pledged to free the “holy land of Pashtunistan” (from Pakistan). You may disagree with me but Bhutto took a right decision of launching a military operation in Balochistan because that operation was against the insurgents-not against the Baloch people. This great strategy of Bhutto saved Pakistan from another debacle like 1971.
Thanks for this detailed background & context - I did not know much about this issue & was confused watching this video (as some background knowledge was presumed on this matter).
You’re welcome brother. Btw I appreciate this quality of you “Indians.” You people love book reading & you guys are always eager to get knowledge. Love from Pakistan. ❤️❤️❤️
Bhutto is responsible for the creation of Bangladesh and bringing mullahs into politics. He was a power hungry wadera.
What? 😂
Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto and Balochistan - #TPE
ruclips.net/video/UIAw1oB0XNg/видео.html
History sees bhutto as a villian
Anyone with a brain does as well. This idiot doesn't.
But far better than Zia
Yes@@Udhayanidhi.stalin.fans.club2
@@Udhayanidhi.stalin.fans.club2zia saved Balochistan
@@Udhayanidhi.stalin.fans.club2Yes
Great analysis
Appreciate and love your work
❤️
Awesome man ! brutally honest. Amazing root cause analysis ❤
❤️
Shahzad the reality in Pakistan is this no civilian had or have power greater than it's military, if ZAB would resist and not send military in Balochistan he would have been out or thrown away at that very moment😮, regretfully he was highly smart and intelligent leader but there was a human weakness in him to cling to the power no matter what will be the end consequences. He did an other blunder to protect his premier ship by listening to religious parties
Which brought him down not only from his PM chair but took his life too, that was so unfortunate because that was not his agenda to become dictator or religious bigot.😢😢
You know nothing about Balochistan, come and experience the backwardness of our land and people, then you will know that who germinated the terrorism in Balochistan😢
Balochs won't leave their 9k old culture, language and identity for only 75 old enforced identify culture and so-called Urdo language.
Stay healthy bro❤
We are on the same page bro ❤️
so u are suppoting terrorim... pakistani is a nationalitynot ethnicity u still are a baloch no onw get this identity from u
9k old history😂😂. you people were under persian rule for 3k years. that's what we know. And plz don't sell kot DG and mohanjodaro they were punjabis.
@@AbdulRehman-il7wv I'm not even Punjabi and don't even live in Punjab... I'm a Rajput and live in Karachi... Mohenjo-Daro and ivc were Sindhi civilization... Pakistan ≠ Punjabi....
@@AbdulRehman-il7wv you should read the history of mehr gadh civilization.
Listening ..... Keep on.
🙌
Shahzad looking HANDSOME today 😅
Breaking news- Shahzad going on DATE as soon as video ends 😂😂
🤣
Nahi aaj bhai naha ke aaya hai😂
Nahi aaj bhai naha ke aaya hai😂
@13:00 buhat khoob
Heavy
It’s such a stark contrast between you and some of our other desi “intellectuals”. You tackle hard-hitting topics which have the potential to endanger your life, meanwhile they are content with dunking on already oppressed minorities like Ahmadis and transgender individuals to keep their homes running. Would love to meet you in person one day.
🙌
First time i see any Pakistani talk sensible ❤ hats of to you shehzad...and please take care
❤️
Came here after seeing your community post about the unfair shadow ban
No one can ever accuse you of favoring Sindhis now
Well done
I hope other intellectuals from other ethnicities in Pakistan are also self critical of the short comings of their own communities
They will continue doing it. They are idiots
Pyary lag raha hu Bhai ❤u
❤️
One question Shahzad what do you think who send military to provinces, is it Shahbaz, Imran Khan, Nawaz Sharif, Benazir? Do they have power enough to make decision about military deployment I don't think so than how can you blame Bhutto solely about Balochistan debacle, he had to get share of blame because he was the PM at that time but not his fault 💯.
They don’t
You can call it ZAB 's fault,but no one in his better senses could ever say that #Balochistan military operation was the brainchild of PM.Bhutto.
Aaj tu new style😮😮😮!!!
😎
Shehzad bhai. The next video should be about the tapping of calls by agencies.
I made a post about it. Video mai kya hee boloon aur
Ya aap ke agli video ni dekhna chahta
For me he was equally responsible for 1971 because he was much more power politician as compare to nawaz imran and other politicians, actually he was more than just a politician he was an active member of ayubs cabinet and he had the oppirtunity to revive democracy but he prefered personal vengeance over it
{correct me if i am wrong} i think he had left ayub after tashkent declarent
after this decleration he was ver much against ayub
@@hammadabbasi5941he left Ayub because he had no other option, he was part of the campaign against the Iron Lady Fatima Jinnah in the first presidential election, the election was rigged blatantly and they stole people's mandates plus he initiated the war with Ayub if I say ''he convinced Ayub to take on India'' would not be wrong by saying that India would not start the full-scale war against Pakistan and apparently what India did, Pak was not ready or prepared for it.
ruclips.net/video/OWR8SLvRg4A/видео.htmlsi=XiO91oAGkEzdAuxc
@@talha5171 yeah pretty much facts
but half a loaf is better than no bread
and {a/c to me} if we had to choose one politician {who had came into power} it would be Mr. Z.A {undoubtly}
@@hammadabbasi5941 this can be debated but the question is what we have learnt from history. aren't we repeating it again?
Here to boost the video
❤️
Bro groomed specially for this video.
saj dhaj key aye hen bhai is dfa. Looking gorgeous 🤩
Bravo shehzad....carry on the good work
🙌
It's not "Jabaal" it's jabal (جبل) means Mountain in Balochi
My bad
Sindhi❤baloch hazaro salo se bhai hai sab hamare bhai hai par Sindhi sabse ziyadah balocho k sath rahe hain proud of you guyz
Getting pop up of your video is unbayanable...♥
❤️
Unbayanable❤
is there any film exists about Z A Bhutto's lifestory ?
it is quality of leaders that they take responsablity of their wrongs
Bhutto is rightly also blamed for what happened in 1971. He supported and encouraged the military operation in East Pakistan (he said Shukar hai Pakistan Bach gaya)- and he refused to sit in opposition after losing the election to Sheikh Mujeeb. These are incontestable facts.
Even if Bhutto did not utter the exact words idher hum udher tum, his above actions led to a situation that clearly conveyed the very sentiments of that misquoted phrase.
Had Bhutto agreed to sit in opposition and accepted the mandate of the Pakistani people instead of resorting to manufacturing this political crisis , there would not have been violence in East Pakistan and it would not have led to Operation Searchlight. As stated above, Bhutto endorsed Operation Searchlight
Yes the army is to blame but you can’t whitewash Bhutto of an equally great responsibility for what happened in 1971.
I expected better from you.
You changed your seat to the left side and its kinda bothering me 😂
Just for a couple of videos 🙈
Love you God bless you
❤️
Pakistan Army is doing best i am from Rawalpindi and we live in a peace 🙏 nothing happened bad since i born
Tearing a paper in UN and leaving the conference with attitude.
Then surrendering after 2 days😂😂
That is funniest moment in Pakistan history.
Bhutto, Mujib and Yahya Khan - 1971 Bangladesh kee Sachayee kya hay? - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
ruclips.net/video/OWR8SLvRg4A/видео.html
@@ThePakistanExperienceShehzad Bhai , I remember your mimicry of Zulfikar Bhutto tearing the paper 😂
Your new hairstyle reminds me of the zam zam electronics walay brothers
I didn't get notifications of channel now a days even i have subscribed with bell icon on. I think it is due to copyright issue and if it is, how can we help you. Love from Balochistan
❤️
Shahzad bhai. The next video should be about ongoing insurgency in balochistan which is started from 2000s till continue
To my opinion based on studies, Z Bhutto was sole responsible for 1971 episode , he was also responsible for 1965 war as he encouraged military for aggression, also he should have focused on water management, promote education, health and industries he goes foe atom bomb which was unnecessary for Pakistani.
Bhutto, Mujib and Yahya Khan - 1971 Bangladesh kee Sachayee kya hay? - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
ruclips.net/video/OWR8SLvRg4A/видео.html
You need to study more bro
Studio ki setting change kr li ap ne bhai.😂
The focus should have been on the facts n national development but for Pakistani political players it was personal interest. Aur nateeje aapke saamne hai. Despite the indicators, the political players are still on with their game plunging the country into a deeper sinkhole. And of course with the blanket cover of religion everything gets eventually justified.
بڑے لیڈروں سے غلطیاں بھی بڑی ہی سر زد ہوتی ہیں ظاہر ہے وہ کونسے پیغمبر ہوتے ہیں جو غلطیاں نہ کریں۔بلوچستان کے بارے میں حقیقت یہ ہے کہ بھٹو کے پاکستانی سیاست میں آنے سے پہلے بھی بلوچستان پر فوج آپریشن ہوچکے تھے اور بھٹو کی شہادت کے بعد آج تک حالات نہیں بدلے بلکہ زیادہ خراب ہوچکے ہیں۔ کیوں؟ یہ پوائنٹ ہے سوچنے کا
Bhai wo stage recording aaj bhi hai jis mn Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto "idhar hum, udhar tum" wala slogan lagaya
Bhejo mujhay phir
Shahzad bhai ajj to Bal Shal bana key bethey hay.. ❤
Beg to differ on Bhutto not being responsible for partition.
Bhutto is villain because he was lapdog of Daddy, when Daddy was crushing political parties left right and center he was part of the club.
Bhutto lost East on political front, rather enabled it. Bhutto played the same role as Chruchill played when there was a famine in Bengal and Chuchill called them rats.
Such a massive human tragedy of regions biggest cyclone in its history and West Pakistan was interested in protecting their seats and military control. Such a shame.
Both Balochistan and East Pakistan are Bhutto's doing, East Pakistan is a performance of a Band of Establishment and Bhutto.
Bhutto, Mujib and Yahya Khan - 1971 Bangladesh kee Sachayee kya hay? - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
ruclips.net/video/OWR8SLvRg4A/видео.html
Liking and Commenting just to give a push to your Video.
🙌
21:54 Wrong. If that was true, if Pakistan was a nation of nation states, it would not have gone through the messy history, the coups, terrorism and conflicts with Divided India, the Afghan war etc.
In fact, if Jinnah had used such an argument for his movement, it would not have come to exist on the map of world either. But the idea is nice. The problem is that such a narrative can't be promoted. If Pakistan begins to celebrate pluralism-diversity, the civilians will hold the power. If that happens, the military would lose its power and relations with India will soon patch up. Also the US and allies will lose a significant pawn in the region so they would also not let it happen easy. It's easy to purchase and dictate or use a nation under thumb of a few men in uniform than thousands of politicians. It will not happen. More than the Pakistani military it's the White man that won't allow it. You can also count China in it.
Nice hairstyle tho :O
Also u talked truth about zulfi bhutio his hands are involve murder of lot of Sindhi people also bloch aslo banagli
There is a video regarding Malala on SHAHOOR RUclips channel; can you make a video about it, thanks.
You can't add someone to gc and start asking those question like " what is BLA and what are your thoughts" when you don't even know the guy. We don't understand what they are facing and as you said we should condemn terrorism but if we don't address their problems they will reach out to the other side for the solution.
Major Blunder was making True Muslim Qadiyani as kafir - else, Pakistan would have implemented Riyasat e Qadiyani in Pakistan and would have become number 1 power in the world.
I understand you saying that them killing regular innocents is wrong, when you're talking about the Baloch organizations. But then you also say attacking CPEC is wrong because it's a state project. The state took their land by force, treated them like second class citizens, forcibly kidnap and make them disappear. Why is it wrong for them to try and harm the state which has harmed them? I'm genuinely curious.
Genuine point...hope he answers.....
please make a video about how electricity bills have gotten so expensive and why salary class is being burden with tax over tax
Will do
Ajj Makeup kdre behtr h
I'm an Indian and I have met 5 Pakistanis in UK recently, 3 of them claimed to be Indian at first, out of those 3, 2 started arguing with me over Kashmir for no apparent reason. 1 was normal but it was very awkward afterwards as he explained why he claimed to be an Indian, among the remaining 2, 1 admitted to being a Pakistani and later on confessed to be an atheist but asked me to keep it a secret since his Pakistani girl friend thinks he is a muslim and it would causes problem back home if news reaches there and 1 was very decent.
And all of this is relevant to this video, how ?
@@MrHhhaaassspsyche of a average pakistanis
@@MrHhhaaasss because laandyas have identity crisis now 😂
@@MrHhhaaasss It shows most foreign Pakistanis feel humiliation in accepting their nationality, I think the commentor wanted to show Pakistan's real aukad.
So true same here in US. Few Pakistani friends I have they are the same way. 😅😂
Balochistan is middle eastern region quite different from sub continent India
Why Bhutto didn't accept the election results of the 70's election and let Mujeb rule the country? why did Bhutto support military operation in East Pakistan? Pakistan has been saved that was Bhutto's statement on the start of military operation in east Pakistan (Operation Searchlight). this statement was not published in the daily Lihaf but it was published in the most credible newspaper in Pakistan which is daily Dawn. Bhutto was not a democratic politician at all. He was a fascist dictator and a mediocre politician.
Bhutto, Mujib and Yahya Khan - 1971 Bangladesh kee Sachayee kya hay? - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
ruclips.net/video/OWR8SLvRg4A/видео.html
Sarfraz bugti got less than 600 votes in form 45 and 58000+ votes in form 47. How can a puppit CM be accepted by people of Balochistan. A rootless mushroom man.
BHai karty raho upload ham sath hain apkay sath
bhai jan nice hair style
Against the punjabi generals.... this was also the thought of bengali people
Pictures b add krty jaayen
Nice video
🙌
Some of your presumptions are incorrect. Balochistan total budget for this year is about 990 billion. Punjab has a budget of 4.4 trillion. Balochistan has a population of about 15 million, while Punjab has a population of about 130 million. Clearly, enough funds are being earmarked for Balochistan- much more per person than in Punjab. Not to say that injustices do not exist. They do, but the main problem lies in its geographical location, which has made it a tool for regional and global geopolitics. Look around, outside your borders, and you will know what is happening in Balochistan, and why. You are trying very hard to attribute everything to internal reasons. You need to modify your narrative with the inclusion of who is lighting the blowtorch, and why.
Marathi nation literally named Maharashtra (great nation😂) in India
Aaj to naha kay aaye ho 😂
Bhutto ki baaari your criticism becomes meeetha meetha hola hola pyaar se.
Bro woh koi roti ko chochhi nae kehta tha.
Rajja va rami greedy for power tha.
You cannot ignore that he was a civil politician with the military and was the FM for ayub khan.
Full time jholli mein betha va tha woh bhi, just for his own power gains.
Please analyse the Muslim Person Law in India..... Pakistan has tackled it much better than India...
Let's have an analysis of the same
India mein to aap terrorism as a Pakistani state policy dhadalle se support karte hai , also masquerade it as some nonsense freedom struggle. Just moral relativism at play here.
Wth man. Why’d you delete my comment! I wasn’t trolling but genuinely asking the thought process behind it. Anyway ✌🏼
I didn’t?
@@ThePakistanExperience Ohh, then i guess youtube deleted it coz it had the word ‘Pal*****e*
New hairstyle.. looking cool
❤️
Shahzad, please call Manzoor Pashteen on your upcomming podcast!
Shahzad hi gum hojayega!
Paxtan Should not put so much Pressure on the Common Man Through High Electricity and Grocery Prices
Even as a Hindu BJP Supporter, I am Against it.
Don't Do this to your people, it is very immoral.
And People like you Shehzad, and Others who have some resources, plz try to help at least 1 poor family in these times.
I mean yeah, but govt be like tax bhi to Lena ha na😂😂....ab ye batein govt ko kon samjhai....
@@legendaryhound5261 So they should Tax the Elite.
They should impose Tax on Properties with Value over 3 Crores PKR, and Agriculture Land Beyond 10 Acres.
They Should Also Increase Tax on Luxury Goods, And Decrease Tax on Essentials.
They should cut Defence Spending.
They should start trade with India so the Paxtanis can get cheaper and better quality vegetables, Aata, sugar, etc.
Later they could even allow India cars to be sold in Paxtani Market and charge 40 % Import Duty on the cars and Raise tax for Paxtan.
They can do a lot to raise taxes, but Paxtan has become a Kleptocratic Nation
I hope may be u read or no books name
Mujeeb and Zulfqar, wrote Abdul wahid araisar very truth Sindhi people know about.....
Bhai very impressive but urdu to impose k gai he bikul shi kha he apne to ab hme chnge karna chahye khud to ab apna broadcast all local languages me karen like Pashto, punjabi,Balochi, Sindhi bs urdu me nh karen q k ye start ap len ge to logo me awareness aye gi to ab jo galti 75y se ho rahi he wo sahi karne ka wakt he.
Bhai budget pr aik podcast ho jae.❤
Trying
Hum Ghaas khayenge lekin bam banayenge. Aaj baat sach hui. Inke paas aaj bam bhi hai aur log ghaas bhi khaa rahe hai 😂
Shehzad in a sadarri.
3:37 indian sea ????😂😂😂 ye kaunsi geography sikhate hai pak me ? History ke saath saath geography ka bhi problem hai.
Walikhan received Gandhi Peace from India.
I agree with almost all of your points except that elite is only from Punjab. In your own video you said waderas in sindh and sardars of Balochistan are colonial legacies then i want to tell fuedal lords of Punjab are also from that same family tree who were granted lands by bristishers and they all collectively form the elite of Pakistan.
These waderas receive their patronage from Pindi and Islamabad too. Toh Pakistan kee elite toh Wahan hee hay jis nay Pakistan kee resources par qabza Kia hua sa hay
@@ThePakistanExperience those who are sitting in islamabad and pindi donot necessarily from Punjab for example first dictator Ayub Khan was not from Punjabi but he was from KP. Similarly Musharraf and many other generals like Abdul Waheed Kakar they all didnot beling to Punjab. Therefore elites in Pakistan have a joint venture they are not centered in a specific area or ethnicity.
Ayub Khan was a colonial subject. Musharaf was from Karachi, I include Karachi.
@@ThePakistanExperience All the elite of today's Pakistan is an offspring of colonial subjects. A very few numbers post partition have joined elite club mostly are from those 22 families.
I know you love to read books when you get a chance just read Oriana Fallci's interview with history and your eyes will open. Bhutto was just a mediocre politician.
"Agr koi Dhaka gaya to mai uski tangey tod dunga"
"Uss (East pakistan) taraf tum (Bengali) Iss taraf (West Pakistan) hum"
-Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto-
Bhutto, Mujib and Yahya Khan - 1971 Bangladesh kee Sachayee kya hay? - Pakistan Lost - #TPE
ruclips.net/video/OWR8SLvRg4A/видео.html
❤❤❤❤❤
❤️