22:04 Anwar Maqsood and Ashfaq Ahmad were the most prolific writers/broadcasters during the Zia era when the real intellectuals were banned, exiled and even received lashes. This shows you how revolutionary they really were.
@@mariamtbutt you have very little knowledge of Zia era, Anwar Maqsood outwitted the Zia regime, they tried to ban him multiple times, could not find a solid reason, probably you were born after 2000
@@akhilkumarchoudhury6363 He is proving his 🆔 @commonsense612 as oxymoron...Common sense is not common... certainly not among the fundamentalist in Pakistan. ☺️
@@umairshah6358 Bhai sachme mai chota tha mujhe lagta tha Sindhi saare ameer hi hote hai. And when I grew up and came to know Pakistan me sindhi hai boht , I wondered how Pakistan is suffering economically.
Its largely because of the difference in system and power hierarchy in 2 countries. India abolished the feudalism (introduced by British to reward their loyalist), whereas in Pakistan these same feudals became part of the ruling class. Sindh in Pakistan is in the claws of same feudal lords for last 78 years and this is the main reason for the condition of the ordinary Sindhis anywhere in Sindh (apart of Karachi, which had an influx of educated and professional population from India.) Ironic is that after all this suffering the Feudal Bhutto is still alive in minds of these Sindhis. Yet some are trying to find a reason to blame others for their dire state.
Thank you, Shahzad. It was a much-awaited video. I'm Urdu-speaking but I was so disappointed with the comments against Sindhis. Sindh gave us a place to live and Sindhis welcomed us wholeheartedly. I don't consider these people intellectuals who spread hate.
Please watch and debang the Exmuslim Sajid Faizalam Ahamed Sameer Adam seeker Quranwala Zafar Hartic Salim and famous Exmuslim Sahil to understand the book 23yrs by ALIDASTI on Kooran
Welcomed us so wholeheartedly that they still refer to us as 'Hindustanis' and say things like "Bhookay nangay aaye thay". They imposed quota system on us and have systematically pushed us to the sidelines, we live like second grade citizens in our own city. And nobody ''welcomed" us to Pakistan. Urdu speaking/Mahajir community is the biggest reason why Pakistan won independence in the first place. If it weren't for us, these people would still be living like savages and burying their new born girls alive.
Hi Shahzad. I just saw the whole video. I am Urdu-speaking. I appreciate the logic and depth with which you explained step by step. As I've grown older and seen your videos more, ive realized not to take your videos personally as an Urdu-speaker and see it from a holistic perspective. I appreciate the effort you put in to this and I after seeing the full video, I won't take it personally as I may have done at an earlier age. I do feel that it would still be good if you have a session with him on your podcast though regarding this. Kind regards, an Urdu-speaker and Sindh lover in peace
@@mugheesurrehman626 more older n popular lol.....ur comparing a seasoned comedian to a young vlogger ....u youther log sure do get butt hurt a lot.....
May "God" save a country or community which is hell bent on destroying itself. The quality of discourse, both in India and Pakistan, is exceptionally below par. The idea of criticism is quite foreign to us. I absolutely adore you, Shehzad Bhai. You rock.
Although not defending flaws in Indian society but after watching numerous videos on RUclips on both the countries, Discourses in India is far more critical and rational from both left and right wing. In Pakistan their criticism is all about the wrong history and their identity crisis which they observed after reading books but in India we talk more about the subjects for which these people may get blaspheme cases against them. Fundamentalist exists everywhere but intensity matters...
Thankyou shehzad for speaking on mdcat. This year Mdcat taken by Iba was 100% fair and it was a big achievement. The other thing is that people from tharparkar and mithi are very hardworking and academically intelligent. I have came to give university entrance exams in Karachi many times and I have seen more thari/ dhatki people there than urdu speaking giving competitive exams. So this scenario against sindhis is just racist. But Karachi also had good number of mdcat toppers as 10 out of 100 is very good according to population ratio. Also Karachi has alot of other opportunities. It has many universities so many people consider studying in those universities. Nowadays I think urban people have started taking IT and Computer science path more than mbbs.
Its unfortunate that we are full of racism and hate. Every ethnicity hates other and considers them inferior. Its not only against sindhis but for punjabis pushtoons everyone. I am glad you brought up this issue. Keep on educating people. We need massive education
as a Sindhi from a small village we always knew that Anwar Maqsood and Ashfaq Ahmed, and Banu Qudsia were part of state intelligentsia, it was a common knowledge in our sociopolitical discourse. However, when i went to university and came to Karachi, i realized people here don't think this way. and if i point out some problematic works of them then people use to get offended. i felt bad about the backlash you got last time, but I'm glad you still made this video. Hopefully, this will make the privilaged class who are beneficiaries of the state think critically and reevaluate the works of their "legends"
Excellent podcast Shehzad. I am an ethnic pushtoon and living abroad but have brain to make analysis. However, I had no idea that he is actually a wolf in sheep's skin. When I look back at his works, I realize that yeh to asal me certified youthia hee tha.
Shehzad, I am really impressed by your editing. I’ve noticed that you and your team are shifting from a typical Pakistani channel style to compete with larger channels like Vox or Johnny Harris in terms of editing. Please don’t change your editing style; it looks fantastic!
Shehzad, as a Sindhi I commend you for bringing up sensitive issues and educating the masses. Also I would appreciate your book recommendations about topics like ethnic fault lines here in Pakistan. I bought "Political conflict in Pakistan" on your recommendation. God speed!
Shahzad Bhai, You never fell short to surprise me. Every time when a notification of your video pops, I overwhelmingly say to myself that I will learn something new today. Shahzad will enlighten my mind with another good piece. Thnk uh for chipping in. 🎉
I appreciate your work and fully agree with the basic idea of this video. Having said that, we can not deny that the culture and values in Sindh are not the same as it were before PPP. I am talking about the corruption in governance and lack of awareness among the masses. This culture suits Sindhi elite.
what about the corruption of MQM and our Business tycoons in Sindh??? what about the corruption in Punjab and KPK and Baluchistan???? everybody knows these MQM ldrs stories from rags to riches. during Musharaf era MQM walo ny andhi machayee huyee thi.... it is in law no audit will be conducted of funds provided to MQM during that tenure and MQM recieved 100s of billions of rupees from Federal govt without any check and balance. but to our friends only corruption is done by PPP. your so callled honest party PTI and and its Leader IK have done mega corruptions in KPK but na ji na udher na dekho just few examples here BRT project and Tree Tusnami
@ThePakistanExperience It's true that Sindh is not PPP, and politics has shaped our perception. But we must address the prevailing corruption in Sindh and work together to resolve it. I usually avoid commenting on RUclips, but this issue is very close to my heart. I recently encountered yet another systematic normalization of corruption and bribery in a very important government department/organization. If someone wants a shortcut and pays a bribe, I don't mind (though I should). But the real tragedy is that if someone tries to follow a transparent and formal process, their case/file simply doesn't move past certain desks.
His "blackface" video mocking Bengalis/Bangladeshis was watched with great joy by my Bengali friends a few years ago - they thought it was some harmless satire. While I am a north Indian brought up in Bengal (and obviously wouldn't instruct an ethnic Bengali on what to laugh at), I personally found a lot of it wildly offensive and insensitive.
As much as it's insensitive, he was a man of his times. Black faces were fairly common in the US in 1980/1990's inspite of being a far more liberal country
@@blackmamba9950I don't necessarily disagree, but my problem was more with the material than the "blackface". I only used that term to refer to the exact episodes.
As a Bengali, I don't find it offensive all. It's absolutely hilarious. Let's not be oversensitive and you don't have to be outraged on behalf of others.
@@anuragdas9400it was targeting Bangladeshis and played up racial prejudices and stereotypes faced by Bangladeshis/east Pakistanis. Having not faced that being from West Bengal (I assume) you don’t recognise the problems with the skit. Same issue with the op’s Bengali friends - Bengalis in India haven’t been discriminated against for being “dark, uncivilised”, so would not see what the issues with that deeply problematic skit is.
@@choudhury9265 other than the blackface, if you look at the contents of that episode, it mocks Pakistan as much as it mocks Bangladesh. The host tries to mock Bangladeshi cricket, while the guest mocks Pakistan's economy. The whole episode was quite witty and fun to watch.
Commenting after a very long time on your videos Shehzad, and absolutely loved the way you explained it. I myself was and still am a fan of loose talk, but i understand where you are coming from. Guys, the criticism isnt about the art, i can understand this as worldover we have this issue. Bhai we have the right for 'agreeing to disagree'. Comments mein gaaliyan dena is not on. Aap zaroor disagree karein, lekin zubaan ki shahista ko na chodein. Bhai more power to you!
Your well researched foundation based opinions make complete sense.. tu bohat bolta hai, 43 minutes to be exact, magar khoob bolta hai.. much love from Lahore.. keep doing what you're doing, you're amazing, best of luck.
Please watch and debang the Exmuslim Sajid Faizalam Ahamed Sameer Adam seeker Quranwala Zafar Hartic Salim and famous Exmuslim Sahil to understand the book 23yrs by ALIDASTI on Kooran
Bhai Sindhi people a mesage to you guys!! I am from India Agra and have been recently following Sindhi culture etc videos om you tube !! You people are soul of Pakistan 🇵🇰!! God bless best wishes ! Mighty impressed with your rustic colorful humble and inclusive culture Loads of love amd Support from 🇮🇳
Please watch and debang the Exmuslim Sajid Faizalam Ahamed Sameer Adam seeker Quranwala Zafar Hartic Salim and famous Exmuslim Sahil to understand the book 23yrs by ALIDASTI on Kooran
Shehzad, you're brilliant. I always felt you've said everything in this video. Yes, Anwar Maqsood's writings about Sindhis are problematic. I'm an Urdu-speaking Sindhi and I agree with you 100%.
So you think peoples party is doing wonders in sindh? I m from Sindh what they have done except bhutto zinda ha But l agree with your remarks fir sindhi community l respect them
Here's a rewritten version: Love the analysis! It's eye-opening to realize how we've normalized harmful stereotypes in our society, like the casual use of Sindhi or Pathan jokes.
Shehzad, I always get a whole new lens Every time I listen to you on different issues. I won't say I changed my opinions to what you say, but it gives me a whole new perspective-the lens I think I lacked. Thank you for broadening my perspectives!!!
Well I have been listening to you! And I’m happy to see day by day people are agreeing with your opinions or ab wo galiyan nhn de jarhen apko. People are evolving mentally it’s a relief
Disappointing video. You advocating for political correctness in comedy / advocating for boundaries in comedy is a bit shocking. AM’s political views can be refuted using other arguments.
@@ThePakistanExperience not exactly, but it is implicitly present in your entire argument. jokes are just jokes. no one has the right not to be offended. i like your podcast, your content, but here i disagree with you. respectfully.
Assalam o Alaikum Shehzad bhai. Loved this one. Highlighted a very least talked topic in Pakistan.. cuz its easy to say anything to someone weaker than you but same people keep their mouths shut when it us the higher class. Zahir he roti kaha he aayegi phir. I am myself a Sindhi in Karachi, my father faces these kinds of jokes and disgusting comments in his workplace about the *gair maqami afrad* and all kinds of things.. He does agree that most of these people are involved in such things but to point out whole community like people do is not the right thing you should do. That Anwar Maqsood's video on the sindhis was a good example of a mishandling, cuz some of the jokes were avoidable and they all came in one after another, Again love your work, keep it up. ❤ Love u Shehzad bhai u have done a great job in awakening me up.
It has been heartening to see you reclaiming your own identity and great to see you become a defender of the marginalized by exposing "intellectuals " like AM. This phenomenon unfortunately is not limited to last 16 years. People like AM are architects of disharmony and hatred especially against Sindhis which I have witnessed for past 50 years. Thank you for showing a mirror to people like AM
Keep up the great work Shehzad. Today's discourse is to understand how discourse works. But we, as society, lack understanding of ideas such as "punching up", "entities beyond criticism" aka Demi-Gods, or standing against the cult/powerful. Although there is a possibility that Anwar Maqsood was only referring to the Sindhi community within PPP (targeting a political structure of a political party), but these topics should be discussed in perpetuity, since we are in extreme deficit when it comes to this
You and people like you have absolutely no idea, of the pain it takes to realize, write and express the anguish which is upon us as a nation. In such an environment I am only respectful of Anwar Maqsood as a senior artist at such a high level of his career. He is doing it for us to realize the factual reality despite the life risk.
Shehzad is completely wrong that Charlie Hebdo was punching down. In hindsight, we can see that the people at Charlie Hebdo lost their life for that joke. What can be a bigger example of punching up than risking your life to make fun of something or somebody?
Hello! I am a huge fan of yours and your work against extremism, discrimination, caste issues, genocide, religious intolerance, and honor killings. It is truly inspiring, and I have learned a lot from it. Regarding today’s topic, as Anwar Maqsood showing some points about Sindh, I don't think they are wrong, because I don't know much about Sindhi people. However, I do know a person whose business was connected to corruption where government jobs and bribes were involved. Their Friend who involve in false appointments on Govt Posts keep the black money in their accounts and they run business with that money. A few years ago, cases were filed against them, and now they have nothing left. I am not saying everything is wrong, but if you look closely, what has been done for Sindhi people in Sindh? I believe the poor Sindhis are also victims, and many of them have never been given the opportunity to progress. I really admire your work, and may Allah give you the strength to continue raising your voice against wrongdoings, because this strength is a blessing that only fortunate people possess.
No, sir, I am a big believer that we should provide rights to Baloch, Sindhis, and Pashtuns. I’m just talking about the upper class of Sindh, the landlords. If we focus on them, Anwar Maqsood is right. However, if we look at the real middle and lower-class Sindhis, they are truly oppressed. I personally wish to do something against all this, but Allah has given you the strength, and I really appreciate that. May Allah give you more strength to do good work.
You are right Shehzad. Anwar Maqsoob sb, with all due respect, should focus on writing subtle satire only. He is loosing his loyal fans because of these cheap antics. And irony is that he has no need to do this. His stature is way above this.
It sounds more of a straw man fallacy as he also made jokes on urdu speaking people such as bihari or indian Hyderabadi etc. Even though that should be condemned in totality but not of your lens. And being mohajir is superior or being urdu is superior has world of difference in Pakistan or Sindh. Urdu is used to get powe at national level by non Urdu speakers whereas a mohajir has never been a CM in its own province of Sindh in last 75 years, all government jobs in Sindh belong to Sindhi speakers and on top of it there is regressive job quota system to support who rule Sindh. It is somehow underneath real racism which is being pointed out by Anwar Maqsood in a wrong way.
Why should some muhajirs who are cowards from India be allowed to be cm, agar cm banana tha toh India mai rehna tha, ya sindh hai air sindhi ki power rahegi, zayda problem hai go back to India
Paiyyan quota system was introduced by your lord Liaqat Ali Khan and why do you guys never mention how many seats NED has for rest of the Sindh other than Karachi? Wahan quota nazar nai ata
@f.50 In world mostly quota allocates on the basis of population or who are suffering more. Liaqat Ali introduced quota is true but for mohajirs (REFUGEES) who left everything. NED quota is of population based ie city/province/country formula which is same across Pakistan. Whereas in Sindh quota is exclusively designed on Urban/Rural divide which is problematic. And Liaqat Ali was killed within 4 years and everything finished. While Bhuuto introduced quota that still exists after 45 years of his hanging.
Day by day, you are proving yourself more than just a LUMS burger. Bro you cant imagine what kind of impact your work is creating. I was not fan of him, but enjoyed his jokes. From now on, I'll never enjoy and promote his narratives. Thank u for exposing their true intensions against indigenous people. Keep exposing more, keep going ❤
Sindhio k uthane se ager pesay bana rhy ho to lgy rho bhai..dont deny the facts the elite who exploited and misuse the rights of other communities in same province. Just see the results od SPSC once u will get to know how much intellignce is found among sindhis
2 kitaben parh k khud ko intellectual dikhaa k cool bnny se bhter apni gireban m jhaank ly bhai ..faida hoga tjhe. The hatred u have for some communities clearly shows sick mindset ....
Bhai mai nay agar 2 bhi parhi hain toh that’s 2 more than you’ve ever read. Tumharay jaisa nafrat say barha insaan kabhi taleem hasil nahee karsakta. Enjoy jahalat
@@ThePakistanExperience hahaha tu bhai apni halat dekhly phly kisi ko nafrat ya jahalat bhara bolney se phly.. kher i recommnd u to read more than 2 books tmhri jahalat or penduism p kafi fark prega... try this landay k scholar
"Sindhis' intelligence" jesa carpet assumptions use krkey tu khud ko okha samaj Raha hai, purely racist. Sindhis dumb hain lekin they can speak more languages than you somehow. Saalon Anwar Maqsood jese establishment ki goudon main beth kr, ethic stereotypes perpetuate krkey apney aap ko intellectual samajtey rahey. Dude's a pawn, nowhere near being a real intellectual.
I have words for Anwar Maqsood sahab with lots of respect and regard that God has bestowed him to speak and write so he must utilise this characteristic with intellect and intellectualy as being a muslim we believe that we are accountable to God what God has bestowed us
To all those criticizing Anwar Maqsood, you have right to criticize anyone at anytime and anywhere, nobody should be above criticism, but doing by ethnic angle is a racism, this what Shahzad has done, most of the Sindhis I have met have been racist unfortunately, PPP always plays a Sindh card, despite pathetic performance in government, they have been in power for last many decades, PPP along with waderas, exploiting common Sindhis but beside this they have remained in power and it’s growing, this basically tells you out loud that who is racist ! This is a fact nobody can deny ! Why they get votes ?? Sindhis instead of looking inwards, try to find an enemy and they find Urdu speaker and blame them for all their inadequacies!
Your racism is not a “fact” Phichlay comment Kay reply mai aap nay gaaliyan Dena shoro kardi thee ab wapis comment kardia so people can’t see your previous meltdown?
@ I want people to read my comments, I never used any obscene words, Shahzad please don’t stoop so low, I understand your inner is racism against Urdu speaker is kicking and alive! You basically hates Urdu speakers, I have never seen you criticizing PPP government or Sindhi Waderas, so do not mix facts. I understand you can’t stand my comments!
I’ve been following Shehzad’s work for a couple of years, and his videos have been incredibly insightful, especially in addressing societal biases in our history and culture. He has consistently advocated for freedom of expression and respectful discourse, which I 100% agree with. That said, I feel there’s a fundamental issue with the timing of his recent content. It appears to align with the establishment’s narrative, which is concerning. Drawing a parallel from history, it feels akin to someone in the 80s criticizing Bhutto for nepotism and economic policies (nationalization, etc) while overlooking the oppressive impact of Zia’s regime and its lasting damage to society. Context matters, and I believe timing and balance are crucial in such discussions.
Boss agar aap 2 saal say dekh rahay hain mai yehi baatain consistently kar raha hoon so how is the timing relevant when I’ve been saying the same thing for 5 years? Aap in 2 saal say pehley kay bhi meray 3 saal Kay podcasts dekh lai
Apriciated work Im surprised wachting this kind of vedios and hatttt offff you and your team.. brother...keep making these kind of stuff for coming artist and people to reduce the heated behviors against any bad thoughts against anyone..
Karachi is in the province called SINDH 😅. I have only heard good things about my grandfathers when our family welcomed them after migration. Tahasub tuh hum nay MqM k baad dekha. Before that hyderabad was such a peaceful city 😢
For current (non) liberal class like Nadeem F Paracha and yourself, who would loud the role of current establishment because you hate few and love others. The work of Anwar Masood sahab is definitely a problem for you guys on "moral grounds" but what are your own values? just Love and hate. No rationality, no political values. Make a video on "why Bhutism is problematic" instead of answar masood.
@@UsamaKhan-kz2ln learn Sind Hind historical books, orient the facts of Karachi ? how it's actually part of Sindh, check actual historian books. English, Indian, writers historian. At last, if the city is metropolitan it doesn't mean that it's not part of constitutional unit. And If its dream of any person that it's gonna be separate someday, then remember it will never come true. It's a heart of Sindh. Long live Sindh
Thank you for this Shehzad. A very important and tough conversation we need to do. I am an Indian-Pakistani who came to Pakistan after getting married in 1990. First visited Pakistan with my family as a kid in 1977. My parents were shocked how even Marhoom Moin Akhter making fun of Bengalis in video which was such a shock. But Pakistanis thought it was funny. Then when married to a decent Pakistani, I saw how people were classed into Bihari, Bengali, Sindhi, Paindu etc. in derogatory terms. For the first time I was stereotyped as a Dilliwali ( because I came from Delhi) and hence I wore deep necks. LOL. This mindset my father identified with Aligarians who had in India this tendency to mock all other muslims except those who were educated in AMU. Then in Pakistan I saw people calling West Indians as Kaali Andhi. However, this antiblack racism is far worse in Indian side of the subcontinent. Indians now make a mockery of Pakistanis as badly as Pakistanis mocked Bengalis. Its not just mockery, they bully too. The mockery that Punjabi stage dramas make on women, or the marginalized is as pathetic. Another important FALSE stereotyping is that all Sindhis are PPP, all Urdu speaking are MQM loyals, all Punjabis are PMLN and all Pathans are PTI. I can go on and on.... Bottomline: All of us in the subcontinent are racist and we think we are the best culture. LOL.
Flawed argument about satire qualifying as satire only if it is about the majority because majority is synonymous to power. With that argument, pre - independence, British jokes about Hindu or Muslim practices would be just satire. The British were never a majority in India during their 200 year rule. Satire is speaking truth to power. Charlie Hebdo was satire because they knew that islamic extremists will get to them. In India, making jokes about muslims will be satire because it's done putting aside the 'Sar Tan se Juda' (beheading) consequences. Did you miss the All India Bakchod Roast where they had to take it all down because Christian minority made life threats to all the comedians even though there were plenty of Hindu jokes too? The definition of satire is the ability to make jokes regardless of the threats or the violent repercussions that try to silence you. It doesn't matter if they come from a majority or a violent minority.
Well, interesting thought. That's why I support all kinds of Satire especially in religious point of view. If religions in India by default get violent just by jokes, then it means that satire is triggering that religious powerful community regardless of any religion.
@@ThePakistanExperience But you did say making Hindu jokes is India is brave which is farther from the truth. In reality its the easiest thing ever. Making jokes on Christians is very bad here and even worse is making jokes muslims which no one does due to fear of dying.
Thank you very much for the descriptive explanation. Sindh and it's civilization are more than 7000 year old. There have been world-class lietratis and intellectuals in Sindh.
Anwar Maqsood is a legend, particularly renowned for his sharp and witty satires. If you have any beef with him, then invite him to your podcst, I am sure he’ll dispel any misconceptions you hold agaist him. It’s also true that Sindhis as a group, are often perceived as less industrious compared to other Pakistanis. If you were to subtract the wealth generated by Karachi from Sindh’s GDP, the remaining figure would be essentially zero. I have nothing against Sindhis, actually I admire them for their tolerance and secular outlook qualities that stand in contrast to their northern counterparts. The contributions of the Bohra, Memon, and Khoja Muslims from Karachi and Gujarat to the creation of Pakistan and the economic development of the newly established country are unparalleled. Don't belittle their efforts or distort by half-backed theories. These communities played a vital role in both creation of Pakistan and in laying the economic foundations of the nation in the 50s.
History parh lo rather than just holding racist worldviews How the Elite continues getting rich in Pakistan - Dr. Rosita Armytage - #TPE 249 ruclips.net/video/SCgueX5TGGM/видео.html
@@ThePakistanExperience I’m simply responding to your views which seems to reflect a prejudiced perspective you have towards certain communities particularly those who came from India after Partition. These Memon/Gujarat communities were in fact instrumental in financing the All-India Muslim League before the creation of Pakistan. They were already rich and brought their wealth to Pak and invested here. Who doesn't know that some people get rich because of their connections with the right people in power? It seems like your understanding of the situation is rather narrow.
@@ThePakistanExperience Plz don't reply them ye log India se behes hi krne aaye thy Kuch aata jaTa hai nh behas krty hain bal k Sindhion ki zid me Sirf issi zid me M Bin Qasim ko hero bnaaty hain ye level hai inkay racism ka
Men sone ja rha tha mgr in ke video dekh kr neend frr hogye And thank you so much Pyara I really appreciate your work and critical analysis and different perspectives.
@Workhard-jo5pz my father worked in HBL for 38 years. His experience taught him that PUNJABIS will favour other PUNJABIS even if a Sindhi is deserving and talented. He was passed over for promotion because his ethnicity did not match his punjabi boss and the guy who got promotion over my dad was punjabi as well. That behaviour based on racist discrimination is called UNJUST PUNJABI. same could be said about any other ethnicity if the basis for injustice is race.
I have bagladeshi friends who watched that Bengali video and they loved it. Woke brigade loves to get offended on everything. Its episodes like these that mark the downfall of TPE and the rise of platforms like Eon podcast which are purely intellectual instead of attacking and cancelling people.
What ever Anwar Sahab said is 100% true, majority ka yahi haal hai it's a reality... Interior sindh ka haal dekh lo appke saamne hai.. I'm not favouring urdu speaking, un mein bhi burayian hein.. hum sab mein burayian hein but interior sindh k logo ka bahut bura haal hai.. ghalti unki nh govt ki hai but Ghalti ko ghalti manogey tu sudharoge naa... Govt offices Karachi mein jaa k dekh lein kitne sindhi hein aur unki kia haal hai
Sahi baat hai, They earned this level of respect over the period of time, Haal dekh lein ap Sindh ka or iski awam ka aur compare karein ap Punjab, KP se aur wahan k logo se!! I'm not either from these cast.
What about your Racist joke on SZABIST University "Aby Mai To Sindhi Houn Mujhe to Ghar Per Admission Mil Jae Ga". Sir eyse na karein na, yeh kia hypocrisy hai.
Bhai, you missed the point. Shahzad is saying that Anwar Masood is part of the establishment's agenda, playing the role of a spokesperson who shows the right hand while striking with the left foot. Vese b ab apna kaam pirate kar k vo irrelevant ho hi China he
1:15 bhai kyu nhi tha yay problematics joke? They literally leave their families to protect you, and this Anwar Maqsood can only crack these jokes because the navy , and the entire army is there to protect you
Shahbaz bahi, I love the way you explained the social construct of identities and opinions about other classes, races, ethnicities and communities in Pakistan. I hope that people will gradually become aware of how state authorities use its machinery to influence or propagate its narrative by utilizing these marionettes. More power to you.
Thanks shazad , to begin this awareness, how the writers spread hatred against different nationalities in the cover of being an intellectual , long time ago we watched this episode of bengali character moeen akhtar played 😢with black faced makeup it makes me cringed now not at that time but i remember it was not funny either to make me laugh. I watched Anwer Maqsood programs for last many many years you are right he has built in hatred for sindhi nation and their language may be the backlash of PPP government which had highly educated sindhi in the cabinet as well some less educated influential rich people but that doesn't give him right to humiliate the entire nation. Keep up the good effort to rise awareness against demagoguery.❤
I LOVE your humour you're the BEST critic ❤❤ I want to spill some of my opinions... Yes, it is necessary to call out our elders on what they have messed up but at the same time do not forget they didn't get the amount of exposure we've they've seen poverty and hunger and so many other things which we can't even imagine... The more I grow the more I feel less hate towards people every one had their own story... One day some one might criticise your opinions on this platform life goes on... 😊😊 I feel light after watching all of you syed muzamil or Junaid akram
If It is not possible for a student from Tharparker to top in MDCAT, then please check how many student from Tharparker secured international scholarships in last few years. I hope PPP is not supporting them to secure these scholarship.
This is why I think Rangeela is a far superior comedian, in addition to his super talents in direction, singing, scriptwriting, and production. He made fun of himself instead of poking fun at others.
What about the stereotypes against Urdu-speaking? "Gutke khanay wale", "Altaf Hussain supporter" and that "paipsi" accent. Aren't you biased Sindhi Supermacist?
Love you Shehzad Gias for making video on such much-needed topic that could potentially reduce your fan following. Hats off You Bro. Sindhis are made abuse mainly because of PPP. This was a propaganda against PPP by Establishment after 80s to bring down PPP mass support. For this Urdu Intelligencia and Urdu media were Used. Though Sindhi Supported PPP till 2000 But that PPP was secular, democrat and leftist. It deserved that support. Now the scenario is different Sindhis as majority don't Support PPP, PPP wins due to someother factor. It is Establishment primarily responsible for PPP Victory in Sindh, then weak Opposition also helps PPP, alongside Bureaucracy also favours PPP. However, On public level there is strong criticism and opposition to PPP bad governance. Kindly inform Urdu speaking community about Political history and Activism from 1900 to 2000. Be it struggle against Ayub khan, be it anti one unit movement, MRD, resistance against Military rule or resistance against Extremism Sindhis have played crucial role. Don't make abuse of whole ethnicity keeping PPP bad governance in mind. This is racism. Long Shehzad❤
We have been divided and collided with each other systematically since Pakistan came into being. Read Surkh Feetay from Qudratullah Shahab. It is only serve the agenda of hegemonic/establishment. Hats off to you for explaining the real issue in a very simple and easy way, may people would ponder and understand.
22:04 Anwar Maqsood and Ashfaq Ahmad were the most prolific writers/broadcasters during the Zia era when the real intellectuals were banned, exiled and even received lashes. This shows you how revolutionary they really were.
Yes!
@@mariamtbutt you have very little knowledge of Zia era, Anwar Maqsood outwitted the Zia regime, they tried to ban him multiple times, could not find a solid reason, probably you were born after 2000
@@Commonsense612A dictator needs a reason to ban a writer if he really wants to ? You can outwit the whole world with your IQ 😂 ~ from India
@@akhilkumarchoudhury6363
He is proving his 🆔 @commonsense612 as oxymoron...Common sense is not common... certainly not among the fundamentalist in Pakistan. ☺️
Anwar maqsood always played on the safe side !
Hindu Sindhis who migrated empty handed to India are one of the richest community in India
Aur yahan Pakistani Sindhis ki halat dekho. I wonder why??
@@umairshah6358 Bhai sachme mai chota tha mujhe lagta tha Sindhi saare ameer hi hote hai. And when I grew up and came to know Pakistan me sindhi hai boht , I wondered how Pakistan is suffering economically.
Its largely because of the difference in system and power hierarchy in 2 countries. India abolished the feudalism (introduced by British to reward their loyalist), whereas in Pakistan these same feudals became part of the ruling class. Sindh in Pakistan is in the claws of same feudal lords for last 78 years and this is the main reason for the condition of the ordinary Sindhis anywhere in Sindh (apart of Karachi, which had an influx of educated and professional population from India.)
Ironic is that after all this suffering the Feudal Bhutto is still alive in minds of these Sindhis. Yet some are trying to find a reason to blame others for their dire state.
@@umairshah6358 Yaha ke sindhis ke halat deko, Jaahil , chor daket zaalim
In which book have you read it lol😂
Thank you, Shahzad. It was a much-awaited video. I'm Urdu-speaking but I was so disappointed with the comments against Sindhis. Sindh gave us a place to live and Sindhis welcomed us wholeheartedly. I don't consider these people intellectuals who spread hate.
❤️🙌
Bro you are not urdu-speaking 😂😂 No urdu-speaking would ever say something like you said you probably are a sindhi stop lying for validation
love you bro❤❤
Please watch and debang the Exmuslim Sajid Faizalam Ahamed Sameer Adam seeker Quranwala Zafar Hartic Salim and famous Exmuslim Sahil to understand the book 23yrs by ALIDASTI on Kooran
Welcomed us so wholeheartedly that they still refer to us as 'Hindustanis' and say things like "Bhookay nangay aaye thay". They imposed quota system on us and have systematically pushed us to the sidelines, we live like second grade citizens in our own city.
And nobody ''welcomed" us to Pakistan. Urdu speaking/Mahajir community is the biggest reason why Pakistan won independence in the first place. If it weren't for us, these people would still be living like savages and burying their new born girls alive.
Hi Shahzad. I just saw the whole video. I am Urdu-speaking. I appreciate the logic and depth with which you explained step by step. As I've grown older and seen your videos more, ive realized not to take your videos personally as an Urdu-speaker and see it from a holistic perspective. I appreciate the effort you put in to this and I after seeing the full video, I won't take it personally as I may have done at an earlier age. I do feel that it would still be good if you have a session with him on your podcast though regarding this.
Kind regards, an Urdu-speaker and Sindh lover in peace
❤️❤️🙌🙌
He’s welcome to come on the podcast anytime
@@ThePakistanExperience
Bro you should ask him to come on your podcast. He is more older and popular than you.
@@mugheesurrehman626 more older n popular lol.....ur comparing a seasoned comedian to a young vlogger ....u youther log sure do get butt hurt a lot.....
What’s Urdu-speaking, isn’t Urdu spoken in whole Pakistan ? If not why is Urdu being read in all schools of pak ? Confusing
May "God" save a country or community which is hell bent on destroying itself. The quality of discourse, both in India and Pakistan, is exceptionally below par. The idea of criticism is quite foreign to us. I absolutely adore you, Shehzad Bhai. You rock.
❤️🙌
Although not defending flaws in Indian society but after watching numerous videos on RUclips on both the countries, Discourses in India is far more critical and rational from both left and right wing. In Pakistan their criticism is all about the wrong history and their identity crisis which they observed after reading books but in India we talk more about the subjects for which these people may get blaspheme cases against them. Fundamentalist exists everywhere but intensity matters...
Thankyou shehzad for speaking on mdcat. This year Mdcat taken by Iba was 100% fair and it was a big achievement. The other thing is that people from tharparkar and mithi are very hardworking and academically intelligent. I have came to give university entrance exams in Karachi many times and I have seen more thari/ dhatki people there than urdu speaking giving competitive exams. So this scenario against sindhis is just racist. But Karachi also had good number of mdcat toppers as 10 out of 100 is very good according to population ratio. Also Karachi has alot of other opportunities. It has many universities so many people consider studying in those universities. Nowadays I think urban people have started taking IT and Computer science path more than mbbs.
🙌
Its unfortunate that we are full of racism and hate. Every ethnicity hates other and considers them inferior. Its not only against sindhis but for punjabis pushtoons everyone.
I am glad you brought up this issue. Keep on educating people. We need massive education
🙌
as a Sindhi from a small village we always knew that Anwar Maqsood and Ashfaq Ahmed, and Banu Qudsia were part of state intelligentsia, it was a common knowledge in our sociopolitical discourse. However, when i went to university and came to Karachi, i realized people here don't think this way. and if i point out some problematic works of them then people use to get offended. i felt bad about the backlash you got last time, but I'm glad you still made this video. Hopefully, this will make the privilaged class who are beneficiaries of the state think critically and reevaluate the works of their "legends"
🙌
Tum sindhi sach me jahil hote ho muhammd bin Kasim inventor ko abbu maante ho😂
Excellent podcast Shehzad. I am an ethnic pushtoon and living abroad but have brain to make analysis. However, I had no idea that he is actually a wolf in sheep's skin. When I look back at his works, I realize that yeh to asal me certified youthia hee tha.
🙌
Love it the way you explained ❤❤❤ 💯 agreed
And u people are perfect chey wao pesh
Shehzad, I am really impressed by your editing. I’ve noticed that you and your team are shifting from a typical Pakistani channel style to compete with larger channels like Vox or Johnny Harris in terms of editing. Please don’t change your editing style; it looks fantastic!
❤️🙌
Shehzad, as a Sindhi I commend you for bringing up sensitive issues and educating the masses. Also I would appreciate your book recommendations about topics like ethnic fault lines here in Pakistan. I bought "Political conflict in Pakistan" on your recommendation. God speed!
🙌
Shahzad Bhai,
You never fell short to surprise me.
Every time when a notification of your video pops, I overwhelmingly say to myself that I will learn something new today. Shahzad will enlighten my mind with another good piece.
Thnk uh for chipping in. 🎉
❤️❤️🙌🙌
💯👍
We always learn from him
Being urdu speaking i totally support your opinions in this podcast. This is the first time i am watching your podcast and couldn't agree more. ❤
❤️
This episode was brilliant. I never realized that comedy needs to be evaluated in the context of socioeconomic realities of a society
🙌
YOU ARE 200 PERCENT RIGHT, I REMEMBER MY CHILDHOOD AND AGONY OF MY COUSINS "OUR ACCENT WAS NOT ACCORDING TO URDU SPEAKERS".
🙌
I appreciate your work and fully agree with the basic idea of this video. Having said that, we can not deny that the culture and values in Sindh are not the same as it were before PPP. I am talking about the corruption in governance and lack of awareness among the masses. This culture suits Sindhi elite.
Thanks but we can’t use PPP and Sindh interchangeably. Read about Ayub khans corruption to know what he did before PPP. Read about his son
what about the corruption of MQM and our Business tycoons in Sindh??? what about the corruption in Punjab and KPK and Baluchistan???? everybody knows these MQM ldrs stories from rags to riches. during Musharaf era MQM walo ny andhi machayee huyee thi.... it is in law no audit will be conducted of funds provided to MQM during that tenure and MQM recieved 100s of billions of rupees from Federal govt without any check and balance.
but to our friends only corruption is done by PPP. your so callled honest party PTI and and its Leader IK have done mega corruptions in KPK but na ji na udher na dekho just few examples here BRT project and Tree Tusnami
@ThePakistanExperience It's true that Sindh is not PPP, and politics has shaped our perception. But we must address the prevailing corruption in Sindh and work together to resolve it. I usually avoid commenting on RUclips, but this issue is very close to my heart. I recently encountered yet another systematic normalization of corruption and bribery in a very important government department/organization. If someone wants a shortcut and pays a bribe, I don't mind (though I should). But the real tragedy is that if someone tries to follow a transparent and formal process, their case/file simply doesn't move past certain desks.
18:00 - The way you explained comedy, its impact, and how it should be used in sociopolitical culture is something new I’ve learned. Much appreciated.
🙌
His "blackface" video mocking Bengalis/Bangladeshis was watched with great joy by my Bengali friends a few years ago - they thought it was some harmless satire. While I am a north Indian brought up in Bengal (and obviously wouldn't instruct an ethnic Bengali on what to laugh at), I personally found a lot of it wildly offensive and insensitive.
As much as it's insensitive, he was a man of his times. Black faces were fairly common in the US in 1980/1990's inspite of being a far more liberal country
@@blackmamba9950I don't necessarily disagree, but my problem was more with the material than the "blackface". I only used that term to refer to the exact episodes.
As a Bengali, I don't find it offensive all. It's absolutely hilarious. Let's not be oversensitive and you don't have to be outraged on behalf of others.
@@anuragdas9400it was targeting Bangladeshis and played up racial prejudices and stereotypes faced by Bangladeshis/east Pakistanis. Having not faced that being from West Bengal (I assume) you don’t recognise the problems with the skit. Same issue with the op’s Bengali friends - Bengalis in India haven’t been discriminated against for being “dark, uncivilised”, so would not see what the issues with that deeply problematic skit is.
@@choudhury9265 other than the blackface, if you look at the contents of that episode, it mocks Pakistan as much as it mocks Bangladesh. The host tries to mock Bangladeshi cricket, while the guest mocks Pakistan's economy. The whole episode was quite witty and fun to watch.
Commenting after a very long time on your videos Shehzad, and absolutely loved the way you explained it. I myself was and still am a fan of loose talk, but i understand where you are coming from. Guys, the criticism isnt about the art, i can understand this as worldover we have this issue. Bhai we have the right for 'agreeing to disagree'. Comments mein gaaliyan dena is not on. Aap zaroor disagree karein, lekin zubaan ki shahista ko na chodein. Bhai more power to you!
🙌❤️
Great articulation of the arguments, Shehzad. Superb. Brilliant 👌🏾👍🏾👍🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Thank you ❤️❤️🙌🙌
Your well researched foundation based opinions make complete sense.. tu bohat bolta hai, 43 minutes to be exact, magar khoob bolta hai.. much love from Lahore.. keep doing what you're doing, you're amazing, best of luck.
🙌
This video, as always, is a testament to your intellectual perspective. All ethnicities in Pakistan deserve equal respect.
Please watch and debang the Exmuslim Sajid Faizalam Ahamed Sameer Adam seeker Quranwala Zafar Hartic Salim and famous Exmuslim Sahil to understand the book 23yrs by ALIDASTI on Kooran
🙌
Bhai Sindhi people a mesage to you guys!!
I am from India Agra and have been recently following Sindhi culture etc videos om you tube !!
You people are soul of Pakistan 🇵🇰!!
God bless best wishes !
Mighty impressed with your rustic colorful humble and inclusive culture
Loads of love amd Support from 🇮🇳
❤️
I look forward to your videos for a detailed overview on these topics. Big ups!
🙌
Please watch and debang the Exmuslim Sajid Faizalam Ahamed Sameer Adam seeker Quranwala Zafar Hartic Salim and famous Exmuslim Sahil to understand the book 23yrs by ALIDASTI on Kooran
Shehzad, you're brilliant. I always felt you've said everything in this video. Yes, Anwar Maqsood's writings about Sindhis are problematic. I'm an Urdu-speaking Sindhi and I agree with you 100%.
❤️
So you think peoples party is doing wonders in sindh? I m from Sindh what they have done except bhutto zinda ha
But l agree with your remarks fir sindhi community l respect them
Here's a rewritten version:
Love the analysis! It's eye-opening to realize how we've normalized harmful stereotypes in our society, like the casual use of Sindhi or Pathan jokes.
I agree with you on the points you made on this video. We need some Punjabi Equivalent people for Punjabi Culture.
🙌
Shehzad, I always get a whole new lens Every time I listen to you on different issues. I won't say I changed my opinions to what you say, but it gives me a whole new perspective-the lens I think I lacked. Thank you for broadening my perspectives!!!
❤️❤️🙌🙌
I fully agree with you Shahzad that a satirist should have the guts and intellectual heft to satire the majority in a nation or region...
🙌
Well I have been listening to you! And I’m happy to see day by day people are agreeing with your opinions or ab wo galiyan nhn de jarhen apko. People are evolving mentally it’s a relief
❤️🙌
I block those who abuse toh woh phir nazar nahee aaatay 😂
@@ThePakistanExperience
This is your way to communicate. Jo thora sa ap k nazariye k ilawa comment main likhay usay block kr dooo. Waooooooo
Abuse ka matlab google karleyte before commenting
@@mugheesurrehman626 sahi hai shehzade khush reh 👍
Disappointing video. You advocating for political correctness in comedy / advocating for boundaries in comedy is a bit shocking. AM’s political views can be refuted using other arguments.
I am not
Mai nay kab political correctness kee baat ker
@@ThePakistanExperience not exactly, but it is implicitly present in your entire argument. jokes are just jokes. no one has the right not to be offended. i like your podcast, your content, but here i disagree with you. respectfully.
Assalam o Alaikum Shehzad bhai. Loved this one. Highlighted a very least talked topic in Pakistan.. cuz its easy to say anything to someone weaker than you but same people keep their mouths shut when it us the higher class.
Zahir he roti kaha he aayegi phir.
I am myself a Sindhi in Karachi, my father faces these kinds of jokes and disgusting comments in his workplace about the *gair maqami afrad* and all kinds of things..
He does agree that most of these people are involved in such things but to point out whole community like people do is not the right thing you should do.
That Anwar Maqsood's video on the sindhis was a good example of a mishandling, cuz some of the jokes were avoidable and they all came in one after another,
Again love your work, keep it up. ❤
Love u Shehzad bhai u have done a great job in awakening me up.
❤️
Soo proud of you
You are our young intellectual generation
It has been heartening to see you reclaiming your own identity and great to see you become a defender of the marginalized by exposing "intellectuals " like AM. This phenomenon unfortunately is not limited to last 16 years. People like AM are architects of disharmony and hatred especially against Sindhis which I have witnessed for past 50 years. Thank you for showing a mirror to people like AM
❤️
🙌
What a powerful Podcast and point of view. Never thought about that perspective that actual hate is towards common and poor people!
🙌
Anwer Maqsood has made skids about Memon, Punjabis, Mohajirs , Pathans and other ethnicities also.
yes they were all terrible equally terrible
@@aunthegeek5788 Han, aur tmhare apne sindhi comedians sindhiyion ka mazak urayein unhe jism par baalon wala bolein, Tmhara Sindhi leader GM syed hindus ke khilaf baatein krrhe, to koi baat nhi kiunke apne hain.
Love the analysis! It's eye-opening to realize how we've normalized harmful stereotypes in our society, like the casual use of Sindhi or Pathan jokes.
Anwar Maqsood ♥️ pride of Pakistan 💚🇵🇰
@jazahmed old psychopath anwar
@mansabmemon3665 Ghar layja Anwar Bhai ko apne
@@JazAhmed-n4u aap lejao aap ko Pasand hai humare liye psychopath hai aapki tarah
Keep up the great work Shehzad.
Today's discourse is to understand how discourse works.
But we, as society, lack understanding of ideas such as "punching up", "entities beyond criticism" aka Demi-Gods, or standing against the cult/powerful.
Although there is a possibility that Anwar Maqsood was only referring to the Sindhi community within PPP (targeting a political structure of a political party), but these topics should be discussed in perpetuity, since we are in extreme deficit when it comes to this
🙌
Thank you so much Shehzad.
🙌
You and people like you have absolutely no idea, of the pain it takes to realize, write and express the anguish which is upon us as a nation. In such an environment I am only respectful of Anwar Maqsood as a senior artist at such a high level of his career. He is doing it for us to realize the factual reality despite the life risk.
Allah mujhay bhi ARY ka director banay ka pain aur paisa day 😂
Actually to thar ka joke PPP pa tha you took that too personally
Finally, someone has the guts to talk logically about this so-called intellectual. well done Shahzad bhai
🙌
Shehzad is completely wrong that Charlie Hebdo was punching down. In hindsight, we can see that the people at Charlie Hebdo lost their life for that joke. What can be a bigger example of punching up than risking your life to make fun of something or somebody?
Hello! I am a huge fan of yours and your work against extremism, discrimination, caste issues, genocide, religious intolerance, and honor killings. It is truly inspiring, and I have learned a lot from it. Regarding today’s topic, as Anwar Maqsood showing some points about Sindh, I don't think they are wrong, because I don't know much about Sindhi people. However, I do know a person whose business was connected to corruption where government jobs and bribes were involved. Their Friend who involve in false appointments on Govt Posts keep the black money in their accounts and they run business with that money. A few years ago, cases were filed against them, and now they have nothing left. I am not saying everything is wrong, but if you look closely, what has been done for Sindhi people in Sindh? I believe the poor Sindhis are also victims, and many of them have never been given the opportunity to progress.
I really admire your work, and may Allah give you the strength to continue raising your voice against wrongdoings, because this strength is a blessing that only fortunate people possess.
Thank you sir but it is unfair to take some personal experiences and say all Sindhis are like this.
No, sir, I am a big believer that we should provide rights to Baloch, Sindhis, and Pashtuns. I’m just talking about the upper class of Sindh, the landlords. If we focus on them, Anwar Maqsood is right. However, if we look at the real middle and lower-class Sindhis, they are truly oppressed. I personally wish to do something against all this, but Allah has given you the strength, and I really appreciate that.
May Allah give you more strength to do good work.
Aap jo shugal lagate (Army or PTI) & jo jo ghlt krta ka usi ki wjh se app LOVE ho, SIR.
You are right Shehzad. Anwar Maqsoob sb, with all due respect, should focus on writing subtle satire only. He is loosing his loyal fans because of these cheap antics. And irony is that he has no need to do this. His stature is way above this.
🙌
Being from India, I used to think Sindhi ameer hi hote hai..
It sounds more of a straw man fallacy as he also made jokes on urdu speaking people such as bihari or indian Hyderabadi etc. Even though that should be condemned in totality but not of your lens. And being mohajir is superior or being urdu is superior has world of difference in Pakistan or Sindh. Urdu is used to get powe at national level by non Urdu speakers whereas a mohajir has never been a CM in its own province of Sindh in last 75 years, all government jobs in Sindh belong to Sindhi speakers and on top of it there is regressive job quota system to support who rule Sindh. It is somehow underneath real racism which is being pointed out by Anwar Maqsood in a wrong way.
Why should some muhajirs who are cowards from India be allowed to be cm, agar cm banana tha toh India mai rehna tha, ya sindh hai air sindhi ki power rahegi, zayda problem hai go back to India
Paiyyan quota system was introduced by your lord Liaqat Ali Khan and why do you guys never mention how many seats NED has for rest of the Sindh other than Karachi? Wahan quota nazar nai ata
@f.50 In world mostly quota allocates on the basis of population or who are suffering more. Liaqat Ali introduced quota is true but for mohajirs (REFUGEES) who left everything. NED quota is of population based ie city/province/country formula which is same across Pakistan. Whereas in Sindh quota is exclusively designed on Urban/Rural divide which is problematic. And Liaqat Ali was killed within 4 years and everything finished. While Bhuuto introduced quota that still exists after 45 years of his hanging.
Thank you Shahzad! For raising voice against the criticism on Saraikis and Sindhis.... ❤
❤️
Day by day, you are proving yourself more than just a LUMS burger. Bro you cant imagine what kind of impact your work is creating. I was not fan of him, but enjoyed his jokes. From now on, I'll never enjoy and promote his narratives. Thank u for exposing their true intensions against indigenous people. Keep exposing more, keep going ❤
🙌
Sindhio k uthane se ager pesay bana rhy ho to lgy rho bhai..dont deny the facts the elite who exploited and misuse the rights of other communities in same province. Just see the results od SPSC once u will get to know how much intellignce is found among sindhis
Chor dai jigar ye videos dekhna. Ek racist mind ka knowledge say koi taluq nahee
2 kitaben parh k khud ko intellectual dikhaa k cool bnny se bhter apni gireban m jhaank ly bhai ..faida hoga tjhe. The hatred u have for some communities clearly shows sick mindset ....
Bhai mai nay agar 2 bhi parhi hain toh that’s 2 more than you’ve ever read. Tumharay jaisa nafrat say barha insaan kabhi taleem hasil nahee karsakta. Enjoy jahalat
@@ThePakistanExperience hahaha tu bhai apni halat dekhly phly kisi ko nafrat ya jahalat bhara bolney se phly.. kher i recommnd u to read more than 2 books tmhri jahalat or penduism p kafi fark prega... try this landay k scholar
"Sindhis' intelligence" jesa carpet assumptions use krkey tu khud ko okha samaj Raha hai, purely racist. Sindhis dumb hain lekin they can speak more languages than you somehow.
Saalon Anwar Maqsood jese establishment ki goudon main beth kr, ethic stereotypes perpetuate krkey apney aap ko intellectual samajtey rahey. Dude's a pawn, nowhere near being a real intellectual.
I have words for Anwar Maqsood sahab with lots of respect and regard that God has bestowed him to speak and write so he must utilise this characteristic with intellect and intellectualy as being a muslim we believe that we are accountable to God what God has bestowed us
To all those criticizing Anwar Maqsood, you have right to criticize anyone at anytime and anywhere, nobody should be above criticism, but doing by ethnic angle is a racism, this what Shahzad has done, most of the Sindhis I have met have been racist unfortunately, PPP always plays a Sindh card, despite pathetic performance in government, they have been in power for last many decades, PPP along with waderas, exploiting common Sindhis but beside this they have remained in power and it’s growing, this basically tells you out loud that who is racist ! This is a fact nobody can deny ! Why they get votes ?? Sindhis instead of looking inwards, try to find an enemy and they find Urdu speaker and blame them for all their inadequacies!
Your racism is not a “fact”
Phichlay comment Kay reply mai aap nay gaaliyan Dena shoro kardi thee ab wapis comment kardia so people can’t see your previous meltdown?
@ I want people to read my comments, I never used any obscene words, Shahzad please don’t stoop so low, I understand your inner is racism against Urdu speaker is kicking and alive! You basically hates Urdu speakers, I have never seen you criticizing PPP government or Sindhi Waderas, so do not mix facts. I understand you can’t stand my comments!
Wapis auqaat par aah kar jhoot bolna shoro kardia. Lagay raho apnay agenda par
@@Commonsense612 100% Agreed
@@Commonsense612
You are a big liar mjy bh yaad hai Tum apni parwarish Jo ki Gai wahi kr rhy thy zahir hai Jahan se aaye ho
I’ve been following Shehzad’s work for a couple of years, and his videos have been incredibly insightful, especially in addressing societal biases in our history and culture. He has consistently advocated for freedom of expression and respectful discourse, which I 100% agree with. That said, I feel there’s a fundamental issue with the timing of his recent content. It appears to align with the establishment’s narrative, which is concerning. Drawing a parallel from history, it feels akin to someone in the 80s criticizing Bhutto for nepotism and economic policies (nationalization, etc) while overlooking the oppressive impact of Zia’s regime and its lasting damage to society. Context matters, and I believe timing and balance are crucial in such discussions.
Boss agar aap 2 saal say dekh rahay hain mai yehi baatain consistently kar raha hoon so how is the timing relevant when I’ve been saying the same thing for 5 years? Aap in 2 saal say pehley kay bhi meray 3 saal Kay podcasts dekh lai
You are a joke to think bhutto is a hero
So glad to listen to someone voice the realities of Sindh and the long-lived stereotypes against Sindh.
🙌
I wonder how many Pakistanis would find something like Southpark funny.
Me.. and about 7 - 8 other Pakistanis who don't spend the entirety of their lives looking for things to get offended by.
@@Zebness990 Haha, well said. Imagine one of your or my conservative uncle listen to something like Uncle Fuc*er.
I do
@@ahmedrazamughal Nice, I love Southpark as well.
INDIAN spotted
Apriciated work Im surprised wachting this kind of vedios and hatttt offff you and your team.. brother...keep making these kind of stuff for coming artist and people to reduce the heated behviors against any bad thoughts against anyone..
🙌
Karachi is in the province called SINDH 😅. I have only heard good things about my grandfathers when our family welcomed them after migration. Tahasub tuh hum nay MqM k baad dekha. Before that hyderabad was such a peaceful city 😢
❤️
Insightful & New Perspective ❤
❤️
For current (non) liberal class like Nadeem F Paracha and yourself, who would loud the role of current establishment because you hate few and love others. The work of Anwar Masood sahab is definitely a problem for you guys on "moral grounds" but what are your own values? just Love and hate. No rationality, no political values. Make a video on "why Bhutism is problematic" instead of answar masood.
Karachi has been a metropolitan. It doesn't identify as a sindhi city 😂
Long Live Sindh. Karachi is the Jugular vein of Sindh. learn the metropolitan meaning first. 🤣🤣
@mansabmemon3665 its means a big city tf are you on about?
@@UsamaKhan-kz2ln learn Sind Hind historical books, orient the facts of Karachi ? how it's actually part of Sindh, check actual historian books. English, Indian, writers historian. At last, if the city is metropolitan it doesn't mean that it's not part of constitutional unit. And If its dream of any person that it's gonna be separate someday, then remember it will never come true. It's a heart of Sindh. Long live Sindh
@mansabmemon3665 wow that was a transgender joke and y'all can't take a joke at all.
@@mansabmemon3665 rakh lo yar.
Thank you for this Shehzad. A very important and tough conversation we need to do.
I am an Indian-Pakistani who came to Pakistan after getting married in 1990. First visited Pakistan with my family as a kid in 1977. My parents were shocked how even Marhoom Moin Akhter making fun of Bengalis in video which was such a shock. But Pakistanis thought it was funny. Then when married to a decent Pakistani, I saw how people were classed into Bihari, Bengali, Sindhi, Paindu etc. in derogatory terms. For the first time I was stereotyped as a Dilliwali ( because I came from Delhi) and hence I wore deep necks. LOL.
This mindset my father identified with Aligarians who had in India this tendency to mock all other muslims except those who were educated in AMU.
Then in Pakistan I saw people calling West Indians as Kaali Andhi. However, this antiblack racism is far worse in Indian side of the subcontinent. Indians now make a mockery of Pakistanis as badly as Pakistanis mocked Bengalis. Its not just mockery, they bully too.
The mockery that Punjabi stage dramas make on women, or the marginalized is as pathetic.
Another important FALSE stereotyping is that all Sindhis are PPP, all Urdu speaking are MQM loyals, all Punjabis are PMLN and all Pathans are PTI.
I can go on and on....
Bottomline: All of us in the subcontinent are racist and we think we are the best culture. LOL.
🙌
Flawed argument about satire qualifying as satire only if it is about the majority because majority is synonymous to power.
With that argument, pre - independence, British jokes about Hindu or Muslim practices would be just satire. The British were never a majority in India during their 200 year rule.
Satire is speaking truth to power. Charlie Hebdo was satire because they knew that islamic extremists will get to them. In India, making jokes about muslims will be satire because it's done putting aside the 'Sar Tan se Juda' (beheading) consequences.
Did you miss the All India Bakchod Roast where they had to take it all down because Christian minority made life threats to all the comedians even though there were plenty of Hindu jokes too?
The definition of satire is the ability to make jokes regardless of the threats or the violent repercussions that try to silence you. It doesn't matter if they come from a majority or a violent minority.
Did I say majority?
Well, interesting thought. That's why I support all kinds of Satire especially in religious point of view. If religions in India by default get violent just by jokes, then it means that satire is triggering that religious powerful community regardless of any religion.
@@ThePakistanExperience But you did say making Hindu jokes is India is brave which is farther from the truth. In reality its the easiest thing ever. Making jokes on Christians is very bad here and even worse is making jokes muslims which no one does due to fear of dying.
Well said.
Yes you said majority@@ThePakistanExperience
Thank you very much for the descriptive explanation. Sindh and it's civilization are more than 7000 year old. There have been world-class lietratis and intellectuals in Sindh.
🙌
You cannot criticize anyone without getting cancelled here or anywhere.
Toxic fan bases everywhere
Anwar Maqsood is a legend, particularly renowned for his sharp and witty satires. If you have any beef with him, then invite him to your podcst, I am sure he’ll dispel any misconceptions you hold agaist him.
It’s also true that Sindhis as a group, are often perceived as less industrious compared to other Pakistanis. If you were to subtract the wealth generated by Karachi from Sindh’s GDP, the remaining figure would be essentially zero. I have nothing against Sindhis, actually I admire them for their tolerance and secular outlook qualities that stand in contrast to their northern counterparts.
The contributions of the Bohra, Memon, and Khoja Muslims from Karachi and Gujarat to the creation of Pakistan and the economic development of the newly established country are unparalleled. Don't belittle their efforts or distort by half-backed theories. These communities played a vital role in both creation of Pakistan and in laying the economic foundations of the nation in the 50s.
Your racism isn’t “true”
History parh lo rather than just holding racist worldviews
How the Elite continues getting rich in Pakistan - Dr. Rosita Armytage - #TPE 249
ruclips.net/video/SCgueX5TGGM/видео.html
@@ThePakistanExperience I’m simply responding to your views which seems to reflect a prejudiced perspective you have towards certain communities particularly those who came from India after Partition.
These Memon/Gujarat communities were in fact instrumental in financing the All-India Muslim League before the creation of Pakistan. They were already rich and brought their wealth to Pak and invested here.
Who doesn't know that some people get rich because of their connections with the right people in power? It seems like your understanding of the situation is rather narrow.
I gave you evidence but instead of watching or reading the book you started abusing me.
Please unlearn racism.
@@ThePakistanExperience
Plz don't reply them ye log India se behes hi krne aaye thy Kuch aata jaTa hai nh behas krty hain bal k Sindhion ki zid me Sirf issi zid me M Bin Qasim ko hero bnaaty hain ye level hai inkay racism ka
Men sone ja rha tha mgr in ke video dekh kr neend frr hogye
And thank you so much Pyara I really appreciate your work and critical analysis and different perspectives.
❤️🙌
Excellent! Appreciate your effort. You are doing great work.
🙌
A Punjabiphobe is suddenly concerned about Sindhiphobia. Woww
I somewhat agree with you.
Calling out an UNJUST PUNJABI is not punjabiphobe
@@almemon3691 who is an unjust Punjabi?
@Workhard-jo5pz my father worked in HBL for 38 years. His experience taught him that PUNJABIS will favour other PUNJABIS even if a Sindhi is deserving and talented. He was passed over for promotion because his ethnicity did not match his punjabi boss and the guy who got promotion over my dad was punjabi as well. That behaviour based on racist discrimination is called UNJUST PUNJABI. same could be said about any other ethnicity if the basis for injustice is race.
@@almemon3691 in Karachi, I have seen SINDHIS supporting SINDHIS while muhajirs aren't even faithful to their own people
Absolutely loved your analysis. Great job shehzad❤
❤️
I have bagladeshi friends who watched that Bengali video and they loved it. Woke brigade loves to get offended on everything. Its episodes like these that mark the downfall of TPE and the rise of platforms like Eon podcast which are purely intellectual instead of attacking and cancelling people.
@ismail that why eon has started to sell courses bcz everyone loves them. My wishes are that they keep rising and have to sell many more courses.
TPE should also sell courses but I can only think of one course. How to cancel someone 😂
True. Just watched "mazakraat" where sakhawat naaz made joke about "baloch" pointing Abdul Wali Baloch and i was shocked!
🙌
q nhi ho rahi comedy .
Excellent...a new perspective... eye opener. Well done 👍
🙌
What ever Anwar Sahab said is 100% true, majority ka yahi haal hai it's a reality... Interior sindh ka haal dekh lo appke saamne hai.. I'm not favouring urdu speaking, un mein bhi burayian hein.. hum sab mein burayian hein but interior sindh k logo ka bahut bura haal hai.. ghalti unki nh govt ki hai but Ghalti ko ghalti manogey tu sudharoge naa... Govt offices Karachi mein jaa k dekh lein kitne sindhi hein aur unki kia haal hai
Isko racism boltay hain
Mohajiron ka bhi bura haal hai Jo KORANGI mein rehtey hain, Anwar Maqsood ne kabhi us par mazaaq kia hai?
Govt offices mein mohajiron ki PAAN KI PEEKEN bhi hoti hain, wo bhi mention karo naa
Sahi baat hai, They earned this level of respect over the period of time, Haal dekh lein ap Sindh ka or iski awam ka aur compare karein ap Punjab, KP se aur wahan k logo se!! I'm not either from these cast.
The only community you belong to is the racist community.
@ThePakistanExperience Haha this hate comes from both sides about those you're talking about. This is not a one sided story.
What about your Racist joke on SZABIST University "Aby Mai To Sindhi Houn Mujhe to Ghar Per Admission Mil Jae Ga".
Sir eyse na karein na, yeh kia hypocrisy hai.
You're making him relevant by making these videos 😅 I think Anwar Maqsood is not relevant anymore.
Mujhse toh zyada hee hain
Mai nay kya kisee ko relevant karna hay
I don't agree...
Bhai, you missed the point. Shahzad is saying that Anwar Masood is part of the establishment's agenda, playing the role of a spokesperson who shows the right hand while striking with the left foot.
Vese b ab apna kaam pirate kar k vo irrelevant ho hi China he
Pirate* pura
He is resist. He hates Sindi,Punjabi, Hindu
1:15 bhai kyu nhi tha yay problematics joke?
They literally leave their families to protect you, and this Anwar Maqsood can only crack these jokes because the navy , and the entire army is there to protect you
Bakwass, just a vlog for criticism to get viewership
wanna say a few things but pta Nhi kaun offend ho jaye for being safe grateful for ur content on a side note Omar sherif is also a legend in India
🙌
Last hope TLP
A terrorist organization= tlp
Sorry
Tera TLP charhe saday lul ta. Pen yakkey dehshatgard 😂
Can you relocate to Afghanistan to taste TLP
No it's not
Shahbaz bahi, I love the way you explained the social construct of identities and opinions about other classes, races, ethnicities and communities in Pakistan. I hope that people will gradually become aware of how state authorities use its machinery to influence or propagate its narrative by utilizing these marionettes. More power to you.
🙌
Hey can you suggest some book and video to better understand comedy or satire
Thank you Shahzad for talking about this and Karachi is sindh everyone should know that.
🙌
Thanks shazad , to begin this awareness, how the writers spread hatred against different nationalities in the cover of being an intellectual , long time ago we watched this episode of bengali character moeen akhtar played 😢with black faced makeup it makes me cringed now not at that time but i remember it was not funny either to make me laugh. I watched Anwer Maqsood programs for last many many years you are right he has built in hatred for sindhi nation and their language may be the backlash of PPP government which had highly educated sindhi in the cabinet as well some less educated influential rich people but that doesn't give him right to humiliate the entire nation. Keep up the good effort to rise awareness against demagoguery.❤
🙌
I LOVE your humour you're the BEST critic ❤❤ I want to spill some of my opinions... Yes, it is necessary to call out our elders on what they have messed up but at the same time do not forget they didn't get the amount of exposure we've they've seen poverty and hunger and so many other things which we can't even imagine... The more I grow the more I feel less hate towards people every one had their own story...
One day some one might criticise your opinions on this platform life goes on... 😊😊 I feel light after watching all of you syed muzamil or Junaid akram
❤️
If It is not possible for a student from Tharparker to top in MDCAT, then please check how many student from Tharparker secured international scholarships in last few years. I hope PPP is not supporting them to secure these scholarship.
You should go to umerkot and see how hard those students work
@ThePakistanExperience I am from Umerkot bro
Then you know how much med students there srudy
@@ThePakistanExperience Kachi hogai 😆
Excellent episode once again!!👍🏽
🙌
As a sindhi, i faced many problems you mentioned here in Karachi 😢
Thank you Bhai shehzad ❤
❤️
This is why I think Rangeela is a far superior comedian, in addition to his super talents in direction, singing, scriptwriting, and production. He made fun of himself instead of poking fun at others.
Yes
Precise and succinct analysis. Absolutely insightful, thought provoking. Good job young sir.
🙌
After a long time i liked your video.
Who remembers Moin Akhter's joke on bangali when he says " Janwar hum ko dekh ke hansta hai"
Moin Akhter was problematic just like Anwer Maqsood.
Thanks for fixing the audio bro. Love you
❤️
What about the stereotypes against Urdu-speaking? "Gutke khanay wale", "Altaf Hussain supporter" and that "paipsi" accent. Aren't you biased Sindhi Supermacist?
Thank you so much for this Bold program,more Power to you ❤
❤️
Love you Shehzad Gias for making video on such much-needed topic that could potentially reduce your fan following. Hats off You Bro.
Sindhis are made abuse mainly because of PPP. This was a propaganda against PPP by Establishment after 80s to bring down PPP mass support. For this Urdu Intelligencia and Urdu media were Used.
Though Sindhi Supported PPP till 2000 But that PPP was secular, democrat and leftist. It deserved that support.
Now the scenario is different Sindhis as majority don't Support PPP, PPP wins due to someother factor. It is Establishment primarily responsible for PPP Victory in Sindh, then weak Opposition also helps PPP, alongside Bureaucracy also favours PPP. However, On public level there is strong criticism and opposition to PPP bad governance.
Kindly inform Urdu speaking community about Political history and Activism from 1900 to 2000. Be it struggle against Ayub khan, be it anti one unit movement, MRD, resistance against Military rule or resistance against Extremism Sindhis have played crucial role. Don't make abuse of whole ethnicity keeping PPP bad governance in mind. This is racism.
Long Shehzad❤
🙌❤️
We have been divided and collided with each other systematically since Pakistan came into being. Read Surkh Feetay from Qudratullah Shahab. It is only serve the agenda of hegemonic/establishment. Hats off to you for explaining the real issue in a very simple and easy way, may people would ponder and understand.
🙌