Dr. Muqtedar Khan: Pakistan has no grand strategy. It has only one policy: obsession with Kashmir.
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 авг 2024
- Prof. Muqtedar Khan was born in 1966 in Hyderabad Deccan, India. He is a professor in the Department of Political Science and International Relations at the University of Delaware. He is the founding director of the Islamic Studies Program there. He was a senior non-resident fellow at the Brookings Institution from 2003 to 2008. He earned his Ph.D. in international relations, political philosophy and Islamic political thought from Georgetown University in May 2000.
He advocates independent thinking, and says that it is the inability of Muslims to sustain a dialogue with time and text which sometimes makes Islamic teachings appear anachronistic or intolerant. He has testified at hearings hosted by the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee and the US House Armed Forces Committee. A fellow of the Institute for Social Policy and Understanding, he has been the president, vice-president and general secretary of the Association of Muslim Social Scientists. In October 2008, Khan received the Sir Syed Ahmed Khan Award for service to Islam from Aligarh Muslim University.
He runs a RUclips channel ( / profmuqtedar , which hosts his lectures, sermons and commentary on Islam and global affairs. He is critical of radicalism and conservatism in Islamic thought and of Western foreign policies, racism and Islamophobia in the U.S. and the West.
According to him, "America is without doubt one of the greatest countries in the world. Because it assumes we are moral beings and capable of doing good -- we are free. And because America assumes we are mature and capable of self governance -- we have democracy." "When I look at Islamic sources, I find in them unprecedented examples of religious tolerance and inclusiveness. They make me want to become a better person. I think the capacity to seek good and do good inheres in all of us. When we subdue this predisposition towards the good, we deny our fundamental humanity".
In a Washington Post article entitled "Islam Says Otherwise", he told Bin Laden to "go to hell": "Before we rush to condemn America we must remember that even today millions of poor and miserable people all across the world are lining up outside US embassies eager to come to America, not just to live here but to become an American. No Muslim country today, can claim that people of other nations and other faiths see it as a promise of hope, equality, dignity and prosperity." He has written, "I remember telling my wife; maybe I will be our Henry Kissinger, the first Muslim to become the Secretary of State. Then came Bin Laden and his bloody men and along with the World Trade Center, American Muslim dreams and aspirations came crashing down."
Unlike the present-day Islamists, when the prophet of Islam established the first Islamic state, actually a Jewish-Muslim federation extended to religious minorities the rights that are guaranteed to them in the Quran. It was based on the covenant of Medina, a real and actual social contract agreed upon by Muslims, Jews and others that treated them as equal citizens of Medina. They enjoyed the freedom to choose the legal system they wished to live under. Jews could live under Islamic law, or Jewish law or pre-Islamic Arab tribal traditions. There was no compulsion in religion even though Medina was an Islamic state. The difference between Medina and today's Islamic states is profound.
According to him, Muslim theology is undergoing a subtle change in the United States. About 57% of American Muslims are OK with gay marriages, but those who are vehemently opposed to it, voted for Trump for this reason. They were 33% of the Muslim community.
Religious identity trumped ethnicity in India in 1947. Islam is the fastest spreading religion in the whole world, including Israel and India.
Hegemony is not such a bad concept, he says. It happens with the consent of the other party.
**************************
Shakil Chaudhary is an alumnus of Government College, Lahore. Subsequently, he studied international relations at Quaid-i-Azam University Islamabad and media at the London School of Economics. He has worked for several English-language newspapers. He has written a critically acclaimed book, Handbook of Functional English (Ferozsons), to help those who wish to improve their English skills. He has conducted many workshops on communication, writing and critical thinking skills. He is a former president of the Progressive Writers Association, Islamabad (2021-2022).
If you want to see his most popular videos, here are the links to them.
• Why didn't Jinnah impl...
• Prof. Hoodbhoy: Pakist...
• Shahid Siddiqui: The p...
• Muslims started the 19...
You are welcome to follow him on Facebook and Twitter.
/ shakil.chaudary
/ shakchaudhary
Dear Friends,
If you like my find my videos worthwhile, please share them with your friends and subscribe to the channel.
I welcome your comments, but please use civil language. Uncivil langue does not make you more convincing. There is no problem if you want to disagree with me or the guest, but please do so without being disagreeable. If you wish to give an opposing view, please send me your contact details.
If you want to see my most popular videos, here are the links to them.
ruclips.net/video/hWJugbilQd8/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/hRDiEe90z6Y/видео.html
ruclips.net/video/sqHGMhJkygc/видео.html
You are welcome to follow me on Facebook and Twitter.
facebook.com/shakil.chaudary
twitter.com/ShakChaudhary
Ok sir !
Shaki Sahib I am so happy that you have called Dr Muqtadir Khan on your show. He is my favourite person from whom I have learnt lot of valuable lessons on interpersonal skills because of his ideas of international relations he talks about. I have immense respect for him. IMO he is a scholar par excellence and we all will greatly benefit from his intellectual capital. Once again Thank you!
*_SIR, DID YOU GET ANY CHANGE TO READ THIS BOOK BY ASRA NOMANI -> "Woke Army"_*
*_1 Question Sir_*
*_A Mafia Named As "Vikash Dubey" Was Encountered By UP Police. Then, It Was Accepted By Hìndù Community Despite Of The Fact That He Was A Brahmin._*
*_When Mafia Atìq Ahmèd Was Kìllèd. A Large Mùslìm Community In UP, Bihar & Bengal Officially Hold Candle March._*
*_Why The Mùślìm Community Favored Such Mafia?_*
The Worthy Guest spoke well and gave us new dimensions of thinking 🙏
1😊
I am 75 years old from meerut ,from where 1857 independence war started. My elders told me that before partition, muslim league was terrorising hindus with the slogan
Hans ke liya hai pakistan
Lad ke lege hindustan.
Pakistan attacked kashmir immediately after independence as a first step towards this slogan.
Indian should never forget this slogan and never believe in words like khitta, padosi,peace and so on.
India should focus on strong growtj so that wedtern border is sevured.
right ... patience of indians have already exhausted....
Thank you, Sir.
Your words of wisdom are badly needed for our young generation, who are easily swayed by propaganda of 'Aman ki Asha'.
We need to live and discuss reality.
how were hindus terrorised ? you should be laughing at them all the way until now 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@Pankaj A no laughing matter this. the same slogan is reverberating even today, somedays on your primetime TV screen.
Muqtedar Khan is real zihadi of chuslam
Muqtedar Khan cant face ex muslim adam seeker.
p6Iam is fake religion : prooved by adam seeker...
Shakil Bhai, you never impose your views on your guest and give full space to them to speak their mind. You are too good 👌👍👏👏👏👏
Shakil, I love the way you address Dr. Khan, a personal friend, much, much younger than me. Others say "daktar saab" all the time. "Sir" is a very Indian way of addressing and showing respect. I like the American way of simply showing respect and a kind of egalitarianism, even in academia.
Sir dr. Rizwan Ahmed sir ko bhi invite kijiye....
मजा आ जाएगा डॉ रिजवान को बुलाया तो
Gratitude Dr Khan, your explanation is at bull's eye....yes we are sad and angry that "India ko Tod Diya"....my forefathers had to leave from Bangladesh and start from the scratch.....we lost our motherland in East Pakistan....but Pakistan should also understand that in present time the new feeling is...we don't want them in any form because that again will retard the growth of india
Dr Khan will take another 100 years to understand the concept of India and its Sanatani culture. India has never invaded another country in its existential History. India believes in the Concept of 'Vasudev Kutumbakam' ; we want to take along with us the entire humanity. India's hard power is not any country specific. Sanatani culture is beyond the concept of any subjugation of people or culture. Dr Khan is trying to compare India through the Western Civilization perspective which is wrong.
👍👍👍🙏🏼
Shakil sahib. Kudos to your objectivity, honesty, integrity, and courage to conduct these interviews and confront hypocrisy and bigotry
Mr khan really don’t know anything about Srilanka 😂😂😂 he is good only expressing view about Islamic country
India bailed out Sri Lanka with 3.9 billion dollars aid and helped it get an IMF loan. Japan and India are together developing infrastructure in Bangladesh and connecting it with India's NE and South East Asia. Bangladesh has offered India two deep sea ports.
Khan is a Indian born with Pakistani heart
i agree
Bro, don’t think so, his thinking is pro Indian
@@ananthravi328 not always!!!
Pakistan is not a territory , rather it is state of mind. That state of mind is also called Global Jehadism .
Your own Zaahil Maulana Azad was one . Read his Khutbaas of 1916 to 1930 .
Know your enemy ,it's antecedents it's past and then extrapolate .
Jinnah was honest in his confessions while British Agents Nehrou and Ghandy were nincompoops.
@@ananthravi328 Plz ...grow up
Indeed, India has progressed far and has become a leading economy and power while We have very weak economy..and our bad relationship with India is mainly due to Anti Hindu mindset_Kashmir obsession will continue damaging Pakistan 🙏🌹🇵🇰
Pakistan going to self distraction...
Its high time the intelligentsia start some dialogue on the same
Dr sahab why Pakistani hate Hindu any reason for that plz mention
What will be the result if Indian hindus(80%) start hating our Muslim and seven other minority community brothers and sis. Answer is "TABAHI" the total disaster of a country. Pakistan is facing that. Even 10-15% out of 99% muslims shias are not feeling safe in Pakistan.
@@YashGaikwad-xb6fp reason is "Laillaha illialh" of Qur'an and Gazwa e Hind of Hadees.. so their hatred stems from their religious books.. their Kalma itself is a hatred towards all other religions and their corresponding Gods" .. that's how Islam is designed and that's how it destroys the basic value of any creature"live and let live"..
Shakilji, it’s unfortunate that fewer Pakistanis see ur vlogs. No bakwaas in your programs.
I agree.
It is unfortunate our people do not like Shakil Chaudhary and others who speak the truth; we don't want to accept the reality.
Pakistani born in India is back. Al Taquia!!
SHAKIL BHAI, lots of respect to you from AMERICAN. I watch your show regularly. I wish some day 100 millions like you live in PAKISTAN. HINDUS ARE DOING WELL WORLD OVER, HINDUSTAN IS LAND OF HINDUS, Hindus are secular by heart. Muslim did to zoharstrians in in iran, Buddhist in Afghanistan; and Hindu and Sikh in Pakistan? NO Shia sect and zoharstrian would be alive if Hindu have accepted them as lord’s children.
This was a great discussion. I find that Dr. Shakil always asks incisive questions and brings out the best of his guests. Dr. Khan was firing on all sixes today, off the mark on some I felt, but was really holding up the mirror on many others. Thank you!
In the very beginning Dr. Shakil Sahib asked 3 questions but Dr. Khan elaborated on only one question of Hegemony . Rest of two Dr.Khan evaded..
The other two questions were better avoided, from Prof Khan's POV.
Shakil sahab, main apka program dekhta raheta hu, magar is aadmi se saqt nafrat karta hu, jyadatar bhartiya bhi isko pasand nahi karta hain, iska tweet dekhe Hindu ke against bolta reheta hain, bada hi ghatiya kism ka insaan hain yeh, bharat virodhi hain, isko na bulaya kare apki show main.
Shakil Saheb, this man is anti-India with a typical Pakistani mindset.A good many Muslims in India ;while living in India, fantasize about Pakistan being their dreamland. This is due to many factors viz-illiteracy, madarsa education, living in ghettos & Hindu hatred ingrained in Muslim society and so on, as you, yourself must have found out in your endeavor. This is to remind you again that I love your videos & wish to meet you someday. My greetings !
What nonsense. Khan saahab sometimes laughs at Pakistanis
How you arrive at this conclusion. Give me 2 example Dr. sahab is hindu hater
Well said 🙏🏼
Very cleverly Dr Khan criticize India and putting China in front. People if you checked his conversation with other channels he is always doing that putting China first. Ind never put pressure our neighbors like China however he is always trying to hitting India. Shakillji always salute ur thoughts n apericiate ur words
I agree
I don't think, we pressurize Nepal, he meet people who has like minded, which are anti india just like him,
India is friends with all neighbors except pakistan.
He wants india to fight stupid wars like US, just because they have money. Even if india has US gdp we won't go to war like them
Guy is an educated Islamist, period..
How you deny miraculous rise of china in short period of 30 yrs plus how can you deny achievement of chinese economy,education, science,technology, medicine, business, space programme, hard power. This ostrich behaviour remind me of pakistani who knowingly or unknowingly have developed the habit of belittling india achievement. Like make toilet instead of Mars orbiter programme. This cheap habits of pakistan will always make india small vis china. China has already emerged as great power of 21st century or perhaps millennium where as india catching up with china. So what is wrong in accepting rise of china!
Thanks!
Dr Khan is limited by his religious affiliation and western influence on his discourse. Yes, he doesn't seem to have much love for the country of his birth.
Shakil sir...what i can summise...for every move of chess that india makes....Pak throws the dice and hopes for a six....😂
F You. I fell off my chair laughing off.
Indians are not Only Hindu muslims christians jews all religions exist in INDIA and They are great And They r Pride of the nation … and valuable for Hindusstan 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
What a terrific team for discussion on an interesting subject. Dr khan explains in the simplest way with interesting analogies.
Love from Mumbai.Always treat to watch your vidros
Prof was brutally candid today. He isn't this candid with Qamar Cheema and other Pakistani bloggers.
Because Shakil will question his response!! QC is anti India, so Dr Khan will say what he is actually thinking!!
Where is Qamar Cheema?
Shakilji, request you to get Dr. Kusumlata Kedia on your channel for understanding Akhand Bharat as Dr. Khan understanding of power or super power is from a western perspective and not Indian / sanatani perspective.
Good suggestion 🙏🏼
Dear Sri Khan ,
Dear Mr Shakil ,
When I heard this dialogue I was reminded of a situation in my city in India where Large number of Iranian students were studying.
Majority of them were leading epicurean life style, enjoying life with wine, women and regularly present in cabaret shows etc.
Then this thing happened called Iranian revolution led By Imam Khomeini and Shah had to flee the country.
Most of these types then on I saw them growing beards, Rosary in the hand chanting Ali, Ali all the time.
Some of them gave a Halo around Khomeini stating my grand father saw Khomeini in the night sky blessing Iran etc.
I could not understand this sudden transformation and divine stories being created and asked few liberals among them what exactly has happened ??
They answered me.
* They were all feeling terribly guilty that when other Iranian Muslims were struggling , they were having a whale of a time in India and did not do anything for the islamic revolution cause.
* Many were afraid if they do not appear religeous enough, may have to face ostracism from community and agencies.
* They all believed the best in this world and there after can be had only in an ideal Islamic country.
It is another matter most of them went back and migrated to westren countries giving a slip to Khomein's Shangrila
It is the same with Pakisthani Muslims.
Feeling guilty that they left and made good for themselves elsewhere forsaking the brothers.
After enjoying prosperity, good life, liberty in West or USA still curse it , not proud of it as somewhere westren values are clashing with Brain washed sub concious Islamic value system they learnt till impressionable age.The sense of belonging they are capable of feeling only with Umma.
They get solace when others clap and appreciate their unwavering loyalty to Pakisthan in turn Islam.
They also feel the Creation of Pak itself was an Islamic revolution and its progress thrawted by USA, Jewish, Westren conspiracy
Can you find more ungrateful people on this earth than this Variety ??
Using Pak adage simply putting it as a case of
"Namak Haraam" after enjoying westren comforts, Prosperity, liberty and equality( as par law) & not being loyal to the adopted country fully ??
Then they always have an explanation " A muslim will be only loyal to the umma and not to the land and in any case all land belongs to Allah etc"
Perhaps this is the root cause of the problem of Muslims wherever they are in Minority in any country.
That's how their loyalty is called to Question by the public in these countries.
Brilliantly put together, excellent explanation 👍
Verry good discussion 👍
Just asking out of curiousity: Who in the present times is seeking annexation of areas beyond India as a part of the putative 'Akhand Bharat' project? Are any authentic speeches, documents, statements to that effect available for reference?
Dr. Khan had some good points and perspective for viewers to ponder 🌷
You must be really dumb to think that Madrass chap India hater has point. You must be India hater too...
Pakistan's main problem is to survive as a nation, if they can do it then offcourse think about fight for their demands, doesn't matter valid or not.
Pakistan is fighting for survival. Can they save their economy. Is it viable? Whats their achievement
Not possible. Eventually it will collapse.
@@AF-yq9es it will get waiver from US but they want it to collapse first so Muslims get into their senses and learn a lesson. Imrand showed them Pakistan can be not trusted as they are with China.
Good discussion ❤from California 🙏🙏
Wonderful
Maxwell's wife is Indian
Discussion between highly learned peoples.
The wisest thing that should be on everyone's mind currently should be to invest in different streams of income that doesn't depend on the govt. Especially with the current economic crisis around the world. This is still a good time to invest in Gold, Silver and digital currencies (BTC,ETH...)
There are lots of investors out there, but getting the right one and expert who is skilled has been a problem for most people, I was lucky to have come across this expert Mrs Evelyn Ruth Reis , she's the number 1 when it comes to stock/bitcoin and real estate investment.
Wow this is a refreshing coincidence I invested with Mrs Evelyn too my first investment with her gave me profit of over € 25,000 and ever since she never failed to deliver, I can even say she's the most sincere broker I've ever seen. Cheers from Australia 🇦🇺
I've seen reviews about her on Bloomberg news.
Chaudhary saheb, what was the topic and objective of this discussion? You started with three pertinent points or questions. Were these questions answered to your satisfaction? As I understood from the three root causes of conflict, as you outlined, were Kashmir, hate towards India and hegemony. No doubt, it was good a 101 course on hegemony, but none of the issues identified were addressed candidly. Hope we have it better next time. Best regards, 🙏🏻
Prof khan has selective hearing. He latches on to questions he can answer glibly while kicking India on the shins ever so slightly. He is popular among pakistani youtubers of all hues.
Hegemony is what Punjab does with Balochistan, Sind, NWFP not what India in relation with Sri Lanka, Bangladesh, Bhutan , Nepal
Many Pakistani Ahmedis escape to Srilanka to find Refuge.
Choudhury saheb. Such guests are a degradation of analysts you invite. The last vitriolic guest was not pretending to be an analyst.
Wonderful answers.
Iam. Hardline Hindu society... But.... Original Islamic person ko dekta hu. Dil khush ho jata hi,,,,,Sakhil chodary sahab. @. Dr. Khan. Saheb.....real Islamic person very very highly educated. Person...... IND 🇮🇳 me. Ye. Numbers. Bhot hi kaam hi.
Many online hosts and guests will soon imitate Prof Sahib's spiffy fashion sense. 😛
Sir why it is called South Asia not Indian subcontinent,is it because other countries than India feel shame to be identified as Indian ethnicity. Though nationality is different but ethnically people are Indian na?
Good question. It is indeed the INDIAN SUBCONTINENT 🙏🏼🇮🇳🙏🏼
Brilliant analysis by Professor Muqtedar Khan. Awesome. Please invite him for more thought provoking discussions. Hearing this episode is a learning experience.
What brilliant analysis by Khan ???? He is sick person uski mentality wahi islam ke gulam jaise he ha
Prof khan is a kattar professor of islamiat; and a muslim supremacist. Please listen to discussions by him on other channels.
Good going. A mirror can be the best remedy at the worst of times.
Dr. Khan....Hegemony is also "power" which is consented to by a lesser country without coercion from the bigger country. So...when a dominant group/country has overwhelming power and exerts that power on other countries in political, economic, cultural, or ideological forms, it is called Hegemony. LETS NOT CONFUSE & COMPLICATE THE WORD 'HEGEMONY'. Secondly...let's admit....In 2023 modern Pakistanis admit India's hegemony indirectly in their heads (& partially some Pakistanis do publicly) but do not accept/admit it a 100% openly due to their senior citizens/Army/politicians..... but that will change after 2024. CHECK THAT OUT !!! Lastly Dr. Khan...YOU ARE WRONG... India has no issues of borders with neighbours like Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Bhutan, Bangladesh, Maldives or even Nepal till 5-6 years back when China prompted a Marxist govt. after overthrow of Monarchy. SO CONCLUSION..India has NO issues with neighbours' borders except wherever China gets itself involved (that includes Pakistan).
Excellent explanation. Well done Kumar🙏🏼
@@gopalramanathan7062 Thank you 😊 🙏
Dr Khan has still not resolved his fundamental identity - whether his ‘ Muslim ‘ is more than his ‘ Indian ‘ ,… therefore the confusion
मुक़दर खान में और आम पाकिस्तानी में फर्क नहीं है. न चाहते हुए भी ये अपनी सोच बता देता है. अंदर से उतना ही बुरा है बस अंधे देख नहीं पाते.
Pakistani foreign ministers so far talk only about dost mubaliq for support on Kashmir that they express as "Masha Allah dost mubaliq ka support milega, insha Allah Kashmir banega Pakistan"
Kashmir is legally indias only.
Very nice conversation
I have a question while Pakistan built on ideology that muslims can't live with other religion how they migrate to the other religious country?
Dr Muktedar khan has very prudently defined and explained hegemony.
Akhand Bharath is nostalgic way of remembering the cultural integrity of India which streched from Afghanistan and central Asia all the way to south east asia. We Indians don't even have any dream of making akhand Bharath, unlike bikhari mulk pakistan which thinks of "gazwa-e-hind". Pakistani mentality is 7th century mentality such country should not exist peacefully and should be dismembered.
Indian foreign policy under modi is so soft, we need radical change like very actively supporting and internationalising demand for separate sindhudesh, Balochistan, Pakhtunistan etc .
Namaskar Shakil Sir 🙏
It's pleasure, learning, eye-opening to listen Dr Muqtedar khan, I like his conversation because he always breaks the egg shell and looks beyond it to the core. That's rare.
We try to think that vast but its impossible unless there is an exposure to that level like he meets people across globe and talks their reality.
Also, the questions that Shakil asks is root level to any issue, which makes this platform important. So, thanks for this analysis.🙌
Eid Mubarak to Shakil Sahab and Muktedar Sahab.💐💐
Shakil Saab, please invite Dr.Rizwan Ahmed and avoid such confused and boring personality.
Dr Khan is not boring. Your assessment is incorrect.
I think some of his views are predetermined.
Indians are happy that Jinnah created Pakistan. All jahils went across the border!!!🤣
Quite a few points to ponder.
Khansaheb, I agree about all Pakistanis wanting to leave Pakistan and settle outside in western countries to escape some form of extremism or injustice. Yet when their numbers increase to a certain point they want to replicate the same surroundings and conditions even in the chosen country of migration. The hatred for non-Muslims is absolutely unforgivable and will not be tolerated anywhere in the world. I hope one day the rest of the non-Muslims in Pakistan also have the sense and get opportunity to leave this place and migrate for a better future. India has CAA for them hopefully it will be welcomed and taken advantage of. Thank you Chaudary sab for the video.
True 😅😂❤
When people with matching sincerity talk with each other. It's a treat to listen, simply. Though, topic is not my cup of tea, but i enjoyed.
डॉ खान आपके बोली में हैदराबादी लहजे से ज्यादा लखनऊ की बोली लगती हैं 🙏🏻
Dr khan sahab to knowledge ke samudr hain, poora bhandar hai aapke andr gyan ka
Loved discussion ❤️🙏
India aur hindus jitni liberty dete hain apne females ko usko saari duniya follow karti hai.. hinfu men know even if an indian woman might seem wrong but she will be doing something good for her family and kids
Sir Ji, I am a very simple person from India and a simple graduate from Delhi University.. and what I understand is that Pakistanis are 1000 years behind our minds.. SAD..
Precisely 1462 years
Beautiful discussion.
Excellent discussion, always a pleasure to listen to Professor Khan.
Patel r u suicidal. You feel India hater has point. As Hindu u still have inferiority complex thanks to Khangess education..
A well thought out analysis indeed...!!! Pakistanis also have zero understanding about Hinduism and almost no knowledge of India beyond Punjab, Delhi, Agra and a smattering of UP, Bihar... !! They don't realize the depth and grassroots level democracy and institutions in India... It's not a great leader or a party that leads a country to success, it's the structures! Here, the administration of our Apartment common facilities, the house owners associations on every street, Panchayats, Taluks, Municipality.. are based on elected, democratic principles right upto our Legislative Assembly and Parliament. Even our Temple, Masjid and Church commities are democratic with own by-laws!!
Khan sir, is always giving cricket
Analogies.
Shakeel Chaudhari Sahab kis ghatiya aadami ko bula liya
Always Good to listen to both of u guys… Gyan to gyan hota h
China has antagonistic relation with Taiwan.s Korea,Japan,india,Vietnam and Philippines. But still is super power. So why different standard for India muktedar Saab..
His analysis are also like Pakistan.. anything that is not in favour of india.. if same condition applies to any other country than india it becomes favourable for that nation..
Damn ... he didn,t hold back this time
Dr. Khan, do you have a deep personal understanding of the nuances that exist in Nepal, or Bangladesh, in terms of language, dialect, cultural affiliations, and many more? Of your Nepali interlocutors, kindly ask how many of them are Newari, and how many of other groups? Do Nepali /Newari understand the niances of the Sherpa language vs. ""Nepali"" language as it plays out amongst the Sherpa communities of North Bengal? Or the Newari attitudes towards the Hindus of Nepali origin kicked out of Bhutan with nary a voice raised for them especially within the so-called Vajrayana community, including Dzongsar Ruinpoche, a Bhutanese?
What about the immigration from Bangladesh to Nepal, and the resultant, sharp change i demographics, at least of eastern and central Nepal? What do your newari students say about this? And please do ask them about what percentage of the NEPALI population, especially young men, and women to a lesser degree, work in India, free from visa or other official restrictions?
What is the population of Nepal? What percentage of this is comprised of men aged 15-50? What percentage of these work in India, and what percentage outside India? What tid the Newaris do to Nepal during the so-called marxist 'revolution'' and what the Newari brahmans, ever the treacherous element, just like Bangali brahmans, done to their land?
Why not ask Enam Khan, what he really understands of Bangladesh society, gieb his very ignroant spouting of the propaganda of the BSF shooting bangladeshis for fun? HOw stupidly mischeivous is he? I am happy to prove to his face the ugliness of his stupidity, biases, and sheer ignorance of the land he and Biru Pakkho claim to 'rule'? Ask him who the latter luminary is.
Sadly, despite their education and undoubted mental capacities, why and how were the US academics so ignorant of the coming storm in Iran, re: Khomeini, that they and even the Shah's secret servies were unaware of the depth of anger, and among specific segments of that society, against the Shah, and against the USA?
I feel troubled and sad at the sheer levels of hubris that occlude the nalysis of US based academics of every sort. ntive-born or foreign, to clearly understand the areas of their expertise? For example, please inquirw of your State Department, festering in the bowels of the Omphalos, just how many experts in Urdu they have, and what that level of expertise might be? How many 'analysts' speak bangla with native fluency? How many are comfortable in the bangla dialects, many of which are also segregated by gender and class? Bangla is among the 7 languages most used in the world, but what is the expertise of the US, or indeed Indian official circles, in understanding the mqany undercurrents of fury that are very very visible to someone who has grown up in the trenches, to use a metaphor?
Obviously, familaiarity at this level of detail is not feasible for any group of academics who choose to think about particular regions. But the extraordinary absence of knowledge in depth re: various crucial areas of the world, is most dismaying, to say the least. To date, one has never found many or any US based academics possessing a very 'organic'' [ for the lack of a better term] comprehension of various strands of subcontinental history and society. This includes academics like yaqoob Bangash, who may impress 'analysts' like Shakil Chaudhuri, but who excite only outrage and fury within many others.
Unlike the very aggressive Christine Fair, many Indian students of the history of the subcontinent will not so brashly express their opinions, but opinions do indeed persist beneath the surface. Those who have been savagely burned by social circumstances, will tend to hew to very harsh and inflexible positions. Many such individuals will not feel the urge to confront the ''errors'' in many academics, which are a matter opf the greatest concern for them, and never in public. Nor are all of them the dunces who prance about in the public eye, aka, the media with its idiotsprache.
"Ashani sanket'' is a tatsama phrase used to indicate the lightning bolts that signal from a distance, the coming of a terrible storm. The subcontinent is waiting for such. Please wait until 2032, and then re-evaluate your thoughts on many issues. Sad lack in core competencies, quite like that afflicting the brilliant and thoughtful Ali Shariati, who met with a very tragic end.
Lahore ki dukaano per likha hai
Jab tak Kashmir ka masla hal nahi hoga udhar nahi diya jaega😂😂😂🤩🤩😜😜😜
Invite ahmedia face to face on RUclips, he is proud Indian, let see you where you stand for humanity.
he is depressed because bjp was removed reservations in his state. He completed his education in a reserved seat
Mr. Shakil Chaudhary this guest is anti India.
N O N S E N S E..............just because he crticizes the govt doesn't mean he is 'anti India'..........I LOVE India but criticize the andhbhakts, the rightwing xtremist govt.............as it should be in a PROPERLY functioning democracy......not BJP RSS Shiv Sena type daakugiri
What makes ypu think he is anti India?
Yes I totally agree with you. I use to listen to his views before. He is in US. He praises India for views only.
This is a true statement
SC Sir, Dr. Khan is most important and valuable and most respected and most knowledgeable guest on your channel. Many thanks for bringing him on your channel. His views are most relevant for all indians. He is a unparallel guru in foreign affairs. And fortunately he is from my city Hyderabad. I used to study in a school just 1 or 2 km from his school.
People who are completely unaware about current affairs find even mediocre as greatest.
@@abodeofangelariel4932 Indian Media is not maligning Sikhs. It is the Macaurthy fake Sikhs who are maligning Sikhs.
@@ravikumar1975ind A Muslim analyst, come what may can never understand the Spirit of India. His understanding of "hegemony" is completely bookish. India has dominated Whole of South Asia without ruling them. Send this guy some good history books as he thinks INDIA is born after 1000 CE. 😄
@@tseeker7622 don't forget Muslim's have ruled Telangana for 400 years. I tried to tell him that islam is a fake deen and no one has seen Allah except fake prophet Muhammad. Being a political science professor he does not understand lies of prophet Muhammad. Even uneducated people are becoming exmuslims. But a very educated professor believes in fake stories about Allah living on 7 heavens. But we should not worry about his religious beliefs. Let us hope his children will become exmuslims and live a happy life. We should respect him at a individual level and must not comment of his religious beliefs. Let us love our professor as is and forget about his fake deen.
@@ravikumar1975ind thank you earth 2.0 for your valuable comment.
Brilliant analysis 👍
Only chutiya dumb like u will like India hater muku
A good analysis basis discussion which makes you aware of other point of view. In fact is worth putting as a class room project in any higher education Institution.
Pakistan works against its interests without any inducement or enforcement by another power.
Because it is at war with itself from its birth, and will be so till it dies - disintegration and dissolution is the only solution to this disaster.
Dr. Khan was trying to say that he left India because some Muslims wanted Pakista!? That was the reason India was not a livable place for him! No, Sir,,, you left India to get a better life. Like others do. I also live iin USA, lots of Non Mulslim NRIs are living in USA and other first world countries, for their own interest. . And, please do not try to be the voice of NRIs. Yes, you have been polished in USA,,, and there is no doubt that it was your hard work and talent,,,, but it was India who gave you the base of your education, on which you made your successfull Gharonada.
Sri Lanka inflation is going down as they are using Indian rupee locally, India will provide support for $1 billion currency swap support to Sri Lanka this month. India per capital income ending march 2023, is $ 2690. Highest in South Asia. India rupee will gain strength it will be 75 vs $ in 2 years. Mr. khan needs to catch up on economic principles.
Best debate i have seen ever
Excellent discussion 👏👏
Shakil saab ...we r 15 years behind china in infrastructure...10 years behind china in manufacturing....much ahead of China in digital transformation
yeah india is ahead of china in digital transformation but not much ahead....
Well articulated! 👍🏻
Pakistan illusion well explained.
Dear Shakilji you are always logical. I always love to watch your videos. keep it up.
I'm not a fan or supporter of Dr. Khan, but I love him as a good human being. As a congress supporter, I started working for congress while I was a child(I attended the virtual janaza of Indira Gandhi at my 10 later Rajiv Gandhi too), I elected as a Treasurer of a Block(Panchayat) at my 15 years of age(1990) 15 lakhs of INR. The reason why I'm describing it is "HOW POLITICS IS ENROUTED IN INDIAN SCHOOLS AND COLLEGES". You can't find it in Pakistan. I joined the Indian Navy at my 18(1993)
Now I'm a supporter of Modi(not BJP)
@@sreekantcp So you are just 48 now.. right?
@@dramjad1712 Yes, I born 25 Dec 1975 on a Christmas day during emergency imposed by Indira Gandhi. I started my schooling in a Govt school with free mid day meals for all students. Now that school is at the International School level. Both my children studied there. Elder son is studying in Canada with scholarship, younger one is awaiting results for his 10th(matric)
Excellent interview
Indian foreign policy kisi Desh mein dakhal Dene ki nahin hai. India Duniya mein Shanti aur development aur pura world 1 family hai ya India ki policy hai.
Thank you Sir that you explained hegemony so nicely.
Ye sab US ki views and terms hai . India believe in Vasudev Kutumbakam world is one family.something these Pakistanis and Americans will never understand. But great respect for u both good intellectual Level.
Shakeelji, ye discussion bilkul *why P@kistan is in a problem* ko discuss karta hai* Khan sahab is very frank on his views to which nobody in Pxtn wants to introspect.
Pakistan has not accepted India’s hegemony so they can’t be termed as regional power but in the same note China is a regional power even though India has not accepted Chinese hegemony, isn’t that conflicting?
Concept of Akhand Bharat not an ideal situation for present India. If Akhand Bharat happened then Hindu community will automatically become minor community and leadership automatically will be hand of muslim community. Then we will be in the era of Aurangjeb. Who like worse. Who like that their worship places to be demolished. Please accept reality of SAR TAN SE JUDA. Present is very challenging why we should think about Akhand Bharat. Pok also captured by pakistani punjabi muslim. Nobody speaking there kashmiri language. Hence India never take dead snake on his neck. Please accept hamara Kashmir tumhara Kashmir. If India become develop country then pok automatically will merged with India. Then there is no need to WAR. Great India🇮🇳
I disagree dr khan. India wants to get better financially. I think dr khan lost it today when he was talking about hegemony. Like for Ambani it doesn't matter to him if someone thinks he is below poverty line.