CookieRepairProjects no this is real. There’s an actual bootleg which is 25 mins long and features various takes (without solos), until the last 8-ish minutes of that bootleg during which there is a full band rehearsal which is exactly the same as this video. In otherwise, the audio for this video was taken from a bootleg release of led Zeppelin’s stairway to heaven rehearsals. The other rehearsal and solo can be found on RUclips (that one has no outro vocals)
yeah, some people - even on the bootleg index sites - say its fake But how would you fake Plants voice like that? Impossible, unless you have the isolated vocal track and enough talent to imitate JP, JB & JPJ. Almost impossible. Maybe someone stole a copy of the multitrack and made a diy mixdown?
I’ve listened to Led Zeppelin for over 15 years. This song became background for me. I was drunk coming home from a night out and let it play for the first time in a long time and it just hit me in a new way. Like a child. Wowee. I hope I can let that happen for all of the beautiful things in life I take for granted. Love.
I actually love this version, feels old and like you’re not supposed to hear it, which it is but also like, hard to explain. It feels decrepit and darker, a fuller meaning, but also more earthy
I'm glad I found and that this is here. I love this version. I hope it stays here forever. The other upload from someone else got taken down and blocked.
You guys would also appreciate in the Light (alternative take) by Zeppelin. It's like the opening scene to the classic it movie with the rain and George. Creepy sounding
A lot of people not buying this as Jimmy Page playing. The more I listen to it the more it makes sense. At first listen it sounded pretty fractured and not in time, but after several listens it makes more sense. I do believe its Jimmy playing, but the mix is simply horrible so the question is how did this get leaked out. I've heard a lot of people try and imitate page's playing and very few, I mean extremely few can capture the nuances of his playing. This sounds like him. It's just that the mix doesn't make sense. So hell, I dont know, other than I do believe that is JP playing.
This is definitely not a fake... the solo is mixed into Plant’s vocals... and on account there where multiple different takes of the solo, this is one of the 3. The rest I think, however, is the first take of the entire song... after recorded, mixed, Page decided it needed to be re-recorded... so this is probably the original first take with an alternate solo take
1. There is no farm called Hampshire. Well ... there probably is one somewhere, but Led Zeppelin never recorded there. The place where they recorded SOME of Led Zeppelin IV is called Headley Grange, which is a HOUSE located IN Hampshire. 2. All of the album was NOT recorded there. SOME of it was recorded there and some of it was recorded at Island Studios.
I believe it's an early play through before being refined into what was on the fourth album surely people realise the effort required to produce a song like stairway I bet there would have been numerous takes
They REALLY got it right in the end; the solo here is horrid by comparison, and other unnecessary guitars. As with great novel writing and film, knowing what to leave out is just as important as knowing what to put in.
The solo is not very good. It almost sounds like something he would have played when he was deep into his heroin years. Where did this come from, and how do we know it's authentic? I've heard another version that featured one of the 3 solos, and it was much better than this.
Sounds nothing like his heroin years at all…… here his playing is at least fluid and consistent. It’s just the note choices are not as powerful as in the final version. Underwhelming.
CookieRepairProjects It tells us it’s just panned like that. This sounds like a lot of Page’s rough stuff. He was always a studio artist first and when he’s improvising something out of thin air he tends to be pretty disjointed. Listen to other studio sessions and you notice he’s often pretty rough.
@The Fine Black Harm ummm... yes it is. 1. This guy wouldnt fake it. 2. His voice cracks a lot more from repeated singing of the song. 3. They try to make it sound as similar as what they rehearse, because, that's what they want it to sound like. I don't think any of you guys saying it's fake know what you're talking about.
The Fine Black Harm its real and and plant’s voice is very off and it’s just another take which sounded off. Page’s solo isnt good either he missed a couple of notes too.
I have exceptional perception of musical nuances, and yes, this is the recorded vocal take that made it on the original album version. Perhaps Robert did double his vocal after this, but it's exactly the same BEFORE the guitar solo. After? It is not the vocal take that made it to the final version.
Googoo101 The solo may be the ultimate result of many different improvisations, but in the end it's clearly a well rehearsed and scripted solo that we hear on the final version. It has very few hallmarks of being improvised. No inconvenient pauses, every space filled and rhythmically perfect, not to mention perfectly in tune. A solo like that does not come together by accident and may actually be several takes spliced together, just like the rest of the song!
Pretty sure it's Jimmy Page. He once admitted there were 4 different solos he tried for this song. This might be one of them. It still sounds like his playing...just not as epic as the album solo.
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Jimmy Page recorded 3 different guitar solos, the third one is the one on the studio album... this has one of the other two... love it
Where is the last one i wonder?
@@zanesadler4033 pretty easy to find on RUclips, this one here however I think is a fake
CookieRepairProjects no this is real. There’s an actual bootleg which is 25 mins long and features various takes (without solos), until the last 8-ish minutes of that bootleg during which there is a full band rehearsal which is exactly the same as this video. In otherwise, the audio for this video was taken from a bootleg release of led Zeppelin’s stairway to heaven rehearsals. The other rehearsal and solo can be found on RUclips (that one has no outro vocals)
Best version of this incredible song is the one from Paris theatre .
yeah, some people - even on the bootleg index sites - say its fake
But how would you fake Plants voice like that? Impossible, unless you have the isolated vocal track and enough talent to imitate JP, JB & JPJ. Almost impossible.
Maybe someone stole a copy of the multitrack and made a diy mixdown?
I’ve listened to Led Zeppelin for over 15 years. This song became background for me. I was drunk coming home from a night out and let it play for the first time in a long time and it just hit me in a new way. Like a child. Wowee. I hope I can let that happen for all of the beautiful things in life I take for granted. Love.
I actually love this version, feels old and like you’re not supposed to hear it, which it is but also like, hard to explain. It feels decrepit and darker, a fuller meaning, but also more earthy
You stoned ??? Cause I am and this made sense to me lmao
@@NEO_RKX yes
@Wilt Chamberlain im glad
@@NEO_RKX made sense to my sober mind
@@NEO_RKXno I’m just tired. I did the wash
…in case this is my mom
Every version of a song he plays he never plays the same that's his word👍👍👏👏
I'm glad I found and that this is here. I love this version. I hope it stays here forever. The other upload from someone else got taken down and blocked.
I hope it stays here forever to
I love the organ sounds before the solo!
Hermosa
Jimmy listens to it and rebuilds his guitar, John always composes changes
5:54 - 8:03
love the guitar...
absolutley perfect.. I love this version better.
Also love this part
6:56 - 7:46
Thank you for the guitar parts!
Samantha Mahawan
You're welcome
I see you got this by the Stairway to Heaven purge of RUclips.. I had the same thing uploaded but it got blocked twice for copyright.
Led Zeppelin Rarities good luck?
I prefer the pipes or flutes being used here as opposed to the recorders in the original version.. adds a more mystical feel
For sure. This is so sick
This is not Fake....This is Stairway still in the making....💯
This is f*cking incredible. Thanks for uploading!
God bless you for posting this
Wow...like hearing another song.
You have great playlists!
Gemma...♥️
Love the solo!
You guys would also appreciate in the Light (alternative take) by Zeppelin. It's like the opening scene to the classic it movie with the rain and George. Creepy sounding
8:03 wow...chills
A lot of people not buying this as Jimmy Page playing. The more I listen to it the more it makes sense. At first listen it sounded pretty fractured and not in time, but after several listens it makes more sense. I do believe its Jimmy playing, but the mix is simply horrible so the question is how did this get leaked out. I've heard a lot of people try and imitate page's playing and very few, I mean extremely few can capture the nuances of his playing. This sounds like him. It's just that the mix doesn't make sense. So hell, I dont know, other than I do believe that is JP playing.
Yeah this is definitely Jimmy playing. The some of the licks in this solo i’ve heard in other live versions of the song.
I believe that the part when the guitar descends around 6:22 to that low note, it is a very underrated part.
I keep replaying that part!
The thing that started it all and will end it all. I will not be the last person who comes here and so I wish you all a good end.
This is definitely not a fake... the solo is mixed into Plant’s vocals... and on account there where multiple different takes of the solo, this is one of the 3. The rest I think, however, is the first take of the entire song... after recorded, mixed, Page decided it needed to be re-recorded... so this is probably the original first take with an alternate solo take
1. There is no farm called Hampshire. Well ... there probably is one somewhere, but Led Zeppelin never recorded there. The place where they recorded SOME of Led Zeppelin IV is called Headley Grange, which is a HOUSE located IN Hampshire.
2. All of the album was NOT recorded there. SOME of it was recorded there and some of it was recorded at Island Studios.
The solo was recorded at Island Studios, as well as all the overdubs
There is a strange panning. I think it's to throw off YT's music signature algorithm.
I believe it's an early play through before being refined into what was on the fourth album surely people realise the effort required to produce a song like stairway I bet there would have been numerous takes
1:00
is it live aid or this rehearsal i can't tell which one.
Alex L.A. probably a rehearsal. Definitely sounds like they are in a studio or rehearsal space
u guys prob didnt get what i meant :D
@@AlexGray19 Damn, that ain't fair. It's a really nice version, the audio isn't as good because it's not on record but that doesn't make it bad.
Fiabescha cuasi surreale mitica😅❤
I don't like the solo , very simple, without the classic part . But good versión in general
They REALLY got it right in the end; the solo here is horrid by comparison, and other unnecessary guitars. As with great novel writing and film, knowing what to leave out is just as important as knowing what to put in.
while i like how after the solo plant gets a moment to shine, i really like the chaotic finish where the guitar solo extends into the final verse
Cidden efsane abartıldığı kadar var
it sounds like someone played over the album version during the solo and recorded the whole thing on an old boombox
Im not sure, not sound like page
The solo is not very good. It almost sounds like something he would have played when he was deep into his heroin years. Where did this come from, and how do we know it's authentic? I've heard another version that featured one of the 3 solos, and it was much better than this.
Sounds nothing like his heroin years at all…… here his playing is at least fluid and consistent. It’s just the note choices are not as powerful as in the final version. Underwhelming.
Тот случай, когда комментаторы знают больше самого Джимми Пейджа...
Georgi boulder
Sorry this is not Jimmy Page playing the solo. Doesn't sound like him.
My thoughts exactly if you listen on headphones you can hear the audio shifting left to right if that tells anybody anything
CookieRepairProjects It tells us it’s just panned like that. This sounds like a lot of Page’s rough stuff. He was always a studio artist first and when he’s improvising something out of thin air he tends to be pretty disjointed. Listen to other studio sessions and you notice he’s often pretty rough.
it’s one of the 3 recorded solos before the final one
Exactly
So fake. Plants voice EXACTLY the same as the official song. You goof
It's not exactly same man listen carefully
@The Fine Black Harm This is unedited version
Compare to the studio version
@The Fine Black Harm ummm... yes it is. 1. This guy wouldnt fake it. 2. His voice cracks a lot more from repeated singing of the song. 3. They try to make it sound as similar as what they rehearse, because, that's what they want it to sound like. I don't think any of you guys saying it's fake know what you're talking about.
The Fine Black Harm its real and and plant’s voice is very off and it’s just another take which sounded off. Page’s solo isnt good either he missed a couple of notes too.
I have exceptional perception of musical nuances, and yes, this is the recorded vocal take that made it on the original album version. Perhaps Robert did double his vocal after this, but it's exactly the same BEFORE the guitar solo. After? It is not the vocal take that made it to the final version.
You get all excited for the solo and it's just..... meh.
Yeah, Led Zeppelin is the only band that can give this solo justice. This band shouldn't even try.
You're meh.
It’s literally how the studio solo came together... improvisation
@@googoes I know, I'm just saying that it's not as good as the one they went with.
Googoo101 The solo may be the ultimate result of many different improvisations, but in the end it's clearly a well rehearsed and scripted solo that we hear on the final version. It has very few hallmarks of being improvised. No inconvenient pauses, every space filled and rhythmically perfect, not to mention perfectly in tune. A solo like that does not come together by accident and may actually be several takes spliced together, just like the rest of the song!
Nice solo..who ever. Really nice. Not jimmy page.
for my opinion its better
THIS IS FAKE not Page
+alex ciardi Not Fake, This is a shot of the multiple solos recorded
Ye, it aint fake .-.
oh yes ! it s a fake !! very poor fake
Pretty sure it's Jimmy Page. He once admitted there were 4 different solos he tried for this song. This might be one of them. It still sounds like his playing...just not as epic as the album solo.
Parc Matériel L'Yonne en Scène bud this is real
Can I get my 8 minutes and 24 seconds back now?
Nope