THE THIN RED LINE Clip - "Captured" (1998) Terrence Malick

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 июн 2023
  • THE THIN RED LINE Clip - "Captured" (1998) Terrence Malick
    In 1942, Private Witt (Jim Caviezel) is a U.S. Army absconder living peacefully with the locals of a small South Pacific island. Discovered by his commanding officer, Sgt. Welsh (Sean Penn), Witt is forced to resume his active duty training for the Battle of Guadalcanal. As Witt and his unit land on the island, and the American troops mount an assault on entrenched Japanese positions, the story explores their various fates and attitudes towards life-or-death situations.
    Release date: December 23, 1998 (USA)
    Director: Terrence Malick
    Buy the film here!
    www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/AS...
    SUBSCRIBE for more all the latest Movie Clips here: bit.ly/31ByDAf
    #TheThinRedLine
  • КиноКино

Комментарии • 429

  • @bobbyricigliano2799
    @bobbyricigliano2799 11 месяцев назад +213

    This film really needs to be seen more than once to appreciated. I saw it in the theater, and didn't really appreciate what I thought would be a typical war movie, which it isn't. In fact, I don't really know what it is, except that it is a masterpiece.

    • @WielkaStopa-qh1rr
      @WielkaStopa-qh1rr 8 месяцев назад +2

      the book was one of very first which was about single man (and a group of single men) thoughts and hard experiences not just about unit's glory and fearless heroes so there was so many descriptions and the big book so war is hell etc.

    • @kimloy8019
      @kimloy8019 6 месяцев назад +3

      I saw it in the theater as well, I was also allot younger than I am now and I didn't appreciate what a great movie it was then.

    • @loganstroganoff1284
      @loganstroganoff1284 4 месяца назад +3

      I saw it with a friend in theaters when I was 13. My dad had to buy the tickets and give his permission to the theater manager lol. We thought it was going to be saving private ryan in the pacific. Both had a profound impact on me but we left saving private ryan excitedly chattering about how cool it was, despite the tragic parts. We walked out of TRL silent as did the rest of the crowd. It was stuck in my head for weeks. I didn't get it at all at that age and still don't completely but Jesus did it move me then and it still does today.

    • @markwebster5749
      @markwebster5749 3 месяца назад

      Shame it come out same year as Savin private Ryan

    • @nj2526
      @nj2526 3 месяца назад

      The Thin Red Line and The Pacific are both heavily underrated, the psychological difference jungle warfare has on a man is portrayed exceptionally well in both productions.

  • @glordit2035
    @glordit2035 Год назад +512

    The Japanese solider at 5:56 basically says "Surrender, you killed my comrades, but I don't want to kill you.... You are surrounded... Please surrender"

    • @Camel-from-Arabia
      @Camel-from-Arabia Год назад +98

      Well considering how Japanese officers treating they own soldiers - this dude preserve much humanity inside him...

    • @ccrider3435
      @ccrider3435 Год назад +4

      @@chetarmlin1196 Try to cope.

    • @andrewwebb-trezzi2422
      @andrewwebb-trezzi2422 Год назад +80

      They just wanted to torture him.

    • @nomarvillegas2694
      @nomarvillegas2694 Год назад +64

      @@Camel-from-Arabiano doubt, they were going to torture him for intel. He took the smart way out.

    • @spudpud-T67
      @spudpud-T67 Год назад +10

      @@andrewwebb-trezzi2422 Not something they teach in Japan today.

  • @ssalerno9200
    @ssalerno9200 2 месяца назад +17

    This is one of the most beautiful movies ever made. The light, the music, the chaos--just stunning, Pure poetry. It's the wind blowing through the tall grass. It's the devastating uncertainty of the soldiers trying to find a reason for their presence in this horror. This movie is a sublime meditation of everything that is wrong with us. And yet that it was made is our hope, Thank you, Terrence Malick and all who had a hand in this gorgeous masterpiece of cinema. Just breathtaking.

  • @DestinyAwaits19
    @DestinyAwaits19 Год назад +332

    This was more than just a movie. It was a spiritual experience.

    • @juhakernel8099
      @juhakernel8099 Год назад +7

      No - it was just a movie.

    • @DestinyAwaits19
      @DestinyAwaits19 Год назад +8

      @@juhakernel8099 That touched me spiritually.

    • @user-it3ex5nw5f
      @user-it3ex5nw5f Год назад +3

      @@DestinyAwaits19 transgender maybe?

    • @patrickmchenry2217
      @patrickmchenry2217 Год назад +6

      Very quietly you can hear a prisoner recite the Nembutsu in one scene. The movie is full of Buddhist references.

    • @richardstokes3625
      @richardstokes3625 Год назад

      It is if you are smoking something damned good.

  • @alienblog4717
    @alienblog4717 Год назад +316

    Jim Caviezel is a hell of an actor!!

    • @blabber1975
      @blabber1975 Год назад

      Shame he is a total lunatic

    • @ManfromJapan12
      @ManfromJapan12 Год назад +6

      Absolutely he is. Well said

    • @waynedurning8717
      @waynedurning8717 Год назад +4

      The whole cast is excellent.

    • @tomterific390
      @tomterific390 Год назад +33

      Too bad he went off the deep end into la la conspiracy land.

    • @waynedurning8717
      @waynedurning8717 Год назад +45

      @@tomterific390 that’s awfully naive of you. And you’re naïveté and willingness to dismiss some people while parroting others is how evil is allowed to flourish.

  • @Schuck.
    @Schuck. Год назад +140

    To call the film a masterpiece, is actually and understatement....... the score alone deserves that title...

    • @waynedurning8717
      @waynedurning8717 Год назад

      😂 masterpiece is pretty good. I’m not sure it’s understating it.

  • @stoke101
    @stoke101 10 месяцев назад +85

    This film is a absolutely fantastic piece of cinematography. I remember when I was in basic training it was put on for us to watch one evening during down time at a weekend. I was 20 years old and wet between the ears but thought I knew everything of the world. This film changed my whole perception of war, in that it’s not something to revel in and glorify but brings about the realisation that conflict is madness and has the ability to turn men in to beasts. It answered a lot of questions I needed answers to, and one week later at week 18 of basic I signed off. Why would I want to give my life for nonsense wars, initiated by inept corrupt politicians. I could quite easily have been involved in the Iraq and Afghan conflicts but can hold my head high in the knowledge that I made the right decision to not become involved in what I believe to be unjust illegal wars orchestrated by powerful men for monetary gain. I’m now 40 years old with a beautiful daughter and partner and from time to time I think about this film and what it meant to me at that time. Whilst I truly respect all those involved in war and all of it’s horrors I’m glad I saw the light for what it truly is.

    • @sid2112
      @sid2112 6 месяцев назад +1

      I did something similar, except I watched it before I went to join and decided that DoD contract pay for playing with computer networks was a LOT more profitable.
      If my butt is gonna get shot at then I'm gonna get well paid for their privilege.

    • @iraniansuperhacker4382
      @iraniansuperhacker4382 2 месяца назад +3

      I have damn near no hope for anything in life but every once in a while I will interact with someone like you and I think to myself that maybe we do have a future worth caring about.

    • @TimothyReilly-tu3uj
      @TimothyReilly-tu3uj Месяц назад +2

      Glad you got value from the thin red line, we had an educational experience making it. 5 military technical advisors and two historians were on set full-time to ensure historic accuracy.

    • @stoke101
      @stoke101 Месяц назад

      @@TimothyReilly-tu3uj is this John Reilly?

    • @OfficerNutcracker-ku1dl
      @OfficerNutcracker-ku1dl 21 час назад

      @@stoke101oh cmon you really think John c. Reilly is out on RUclips with a no profile pic account?

  • @drkresearch2945
    @drkresearch2945 5 месяцев назад +13

    One of those films that needs a few viewings to truly appreciate.

  • @nps6566
    @nps6566 Год назад +112

    5:18 Surrender!
    5:24 Surrender!
    5:43 Surrender...!
    5:48 Did you kill my comrade-in-arms?
    5:55 Do you understand? (slightly nervous)
    5:58 I don't want to kill you
    6:02 Do you understand? (slightly nervous)
    6:10 i don't want to kill you
    6:15 already surrounded
    6:15 Surrender obediently
    6:20 Was it you... (sigh)
    6:22 The man who killed my comrade-in-arms...
    6:30 I...
    6:32 Don't move!
    6:39 Stop!
    6:40 surrender!

    • @prabowosubianto8024
      @prabowosubianto8024 11 месяцев назад +6

      when google translate doesn't exist yet. If there was at that time perhaps the story would have changed.😂

    • @maxflares8888
      @maxflares8888 3 месяца назад +2

      thanks for the translation

    • @cheloruiz7640
      @cheloruiz7640 2 месяца назад +2

      Thank you

    • @motoprofessor3546
      @motoprofessor3546 Месяц назад +2

      Thank you for the translation.

    • @nps6566
      @nps6566 24 дня назад

      I was left with a memorable scene in which a Japanese soldier feels murderous after his comrades are killed, but he has mixed feelings about not wanting to shoot and kill the American soldier in front of him.
      But it's also a scene where if you don't understand Japanese, you won't be able to convey anything.
      Thanks for watching.

  • @stuartbennett7614
    @stuartbennett7614 Год назад +211

    I've been to war and this film hits home on so many levels it's a triumph

    • @jusnuts1443
      @jusnuts1443 Год назад +37

      In a war, nobody wins. Desert Storm vet here. The bravado wears off with age and you realize that nobody really wins. We are all just slaves to money and greed. Defend your family and your home. That's all you can do. Hope for the best but expect the worst. Godspeed to you all!

    • @marcbelisle5685
      @marcbelisle5685 Год назад +4

      How does it hit home for you as a veteran? I’m curious.

    • @stuartbennett7614
      @stuartbennett7614 Год назад +12

      The moments of beauty and horror and how man's spirit can rise and face it

    • @jusnuts1443
      @jusnuts1443 Год назад +14

      @@marcbelisle5685 We are simple pawns. A material. We are expendable. American citizens care, but our government does not.

    • @jusnuts1443
      @jusnuts1443 Год назад +3

      @@stuartbennett7614 And endure it or perish in the moment. We are only mortal beings.

  • @user-cx2mu5gw7f
    @user-cx2mu5gw7f Год назад +33

    この戦争で亡くなられた方々が来世で幸せになられている事を願います🍀
    気づいてもらいたいです。生かされた方々には。

  • @datvik7187
    @datvik7187 Год назад +101

    4:46 Malick's portrayal of the Japanese troops almost as ominous beasts of the jungle, is so cool and fitting.

    • @OutnBacker
      @OutnBacker Год назад +57

      Except they weren't. The Japanese troops on Guadalcanal were first rate veterans of other campaigns, but were down to the last of their rations by the time the Americans landed. They were sick from malaria and had no quinine because of American interference with their supply convoys. Eventually, the Japanese tried to evac all the troops they could, but basically, the jungle ate them alive, and the Americans were able to keep enough supplies coming to defeat every attack on the airfield. It was no picnic for the Americans but it was a nightmare for the Japanese.
      It is a myth that the Japanese thrived in the jungles. They hated and feared the jungle as much as anyone and were subject to the same diseases, animal bites, fevers, and starvation as any other army. There are no jungles in Japan, which had a very civilized and manicured urban system from which most of their soldiers were from.

    • @JohnWick-nn2cu
      @JohnWick-nn2cu Год назад +2

      @@OutnBackerthere are jungles in Okinawa

    • @OutnBacker
      @OutnBacker Год назад +11

      @@JohnWick-nn2cu Um, yeah. That's what I said. The Japanese were not "ominous beasts of the jungle" in reality. They feared the jungle because it was killing them. Go back. Re-read.

    • @CrazySC833
      @CrazySC833 Год назад +4

      I was thinking the same thing. The attire that they are wearing is incredible. If you ever watch any black and white film from the Japanese prospective, they seem to all be wearing that same kit. In particular that foliage stuck to the uniform is what sticks out in my mind.

    • @OutnBacker
      @OutnBacker Год назад +10

      @@CrazySC833 Almost all film footage from the Japanese perspective was propaganda designed to show the folks back home how professional and well equiped thier army was.
      Quadalcanal was a cesspool island, ridden with tropical diseases like denge fever and malaria. No American or Japanese troops were immune to this, and both sides suffered badly, but the Japanese had no quinine, a drug made from sources in the veyr islands they were fighting for. The Americans did, and could be treated. Dysentery was rampant among both sides, but again, the Americans had better medical care because they contolled the buildings and facilities around the airfield, while the Japanese were out in the jungle withering away.
      The well turned out Japanese depicted in the film COULD have been just arrived - otherwise, a typical cotton uniform would begin to rot within a couple weeks. Illness was all but imedeate to Japanese soldiers on the Canal.
      They lost about 36,000 men there as opposed to 7100 Americans in the six month ordeal. This figure includes Navy casualties because th ecampaign was both a land and sea battle. Actual Marine and Army casualties on the island were about 2800. When the Japanese bombed Pearl they sealed their fate.

  • @snowwalker9999
    @snowwalker9999 Год назад +39

    The saddest clip of the entire film. When he saw at the bats staring at him, he knew this was the end.

  • @StephenBrown-nx2gd
    @StephenBrown-nx2gd 5 месяцев назад +9

    I've never seen the beauty of nature juxtaposed with war in such a way. This film is beyond me.

    • @reddiver7293
      @reddiver7293 4 месяца назад +1

      The scenes and screenplay and cinematography all do a stunning job of creating a dreamlike quality. As in a living nightmare set in visually gorgeous locales.

  • @user-vg5fq7gu9e
    @user-vg5fq7gu9e 7 месяцев назад +8

    I'm a fan of Jim Caviazel since i saw this movie over and over again. My favorite war movie!

  • @mariovillanueva833
    @mariovillanueva833 Год назад +27

    La primera vez que vi a Jim Caviezel fue en esta película y pensé "Este tipo es mágico....", tremenda actuación,un carisma incomparable!!!

  • @tatata1543
    @tatata1543 Год назад +28

    Fun fact, Adrian Brody was meant to be the star of this movie and only found out just before the premiere that his role had been reduced to a bit part.

    • @dmayres
      @dmayres Год назад +8

      I was surprised when reading the book how much more Fife's character was involved. Knowing Terrance Mallick, he probably filmed 6 hours of footage, I'd love to see a director's cut one day.

    • @tatata1543
      @tatata1543 Год назад +1

      @@dmayres The version you see is the director’s cut.

    • @user-eo5ju9fg6m
      @user-eo5ju9fg6m 10 месяцев назад

      Probably more like hours. I'd watch every minute. This is truly art. @@dmayres

    • @radioactivehands
      @radioactivehands 8 месяцев назад +2

      There is the 5 hours director cut with more footage of Brody

    • @DirectedbyRon
      @DirectedbyRon 3 месяца назад +1

      ​​@@dmayresfirst cut was 8 hours long, they could easily do a mini series with all that cut content, and i would be so down for it.

  • @randallf.4646
    @randallf.4646 Год назад +23

    The Japanese drum beat at that certain point is an awesome attention to detail and just adds to the epic sequence of this great epic film.

  • @bierdlll
    @bierdlll 9 месяцев назад +15

    Witt is the enlightened liberated mind in the midst of war. Surrounded, there was no fear or sense of self, only love and compassion at encountering fellow humans trapped in war. The Japanese soldier felt this and was bewildered and unsure as to how to respond.

    • @Dougie-ex1ov
      @Dougie-ex1ov 9 месяцев назад +1

      interesting take. Maybe that individual sensed it in him. Interesting how some ppl have this ability.

    • @bobmn5702
      @bobmn5702 8 месяцев назад +4

      How do you explain him raising is weapon at the end instead of just surrendering?

    • @bierdlll
      @bierdlll 8 месяцев назад +5

      @@bobmn5702 Surrendering is a poor choice, they may torture him for information on the rest of the platoon he is trying to protect. Raising his weapon is a quick and sure way for him to meet his death.

    • @outgreen2911
      @outgreen2911 6 месяцев назад +2

      .@@bobmn5702 i also asked myself why he didnt surrender. would have been more fitting imo.

    • @sid2112
      @sid2112 6 месяцев назад

      @@outgreen2911 Because he was the decoy. He led them away. If he surrendered and they forced it out of him, well. A bullet is a lot less painful.

  • @johnbennett3269
    @johnbennett3269 6 месяцев назад +5

    A cinematic masterpiece of a scene... period

  • @np494609
    @np494609 Год назад +9

    I was literally remembering this movie in my head last night and it shows up in my RUclips recommended feed

    • @xxdmoneyxx4968
      @xxdmoneyxx4968 Год назад +2

      Thts how you know they’ve hooked our Brains to our phones lol

    • @waynedurning8717
      @waynedurning8717 Год назад

      @@xxdmoneyxx4968eh you beat me to it lol. Get out of my head Alexa!

  • @TimothyReilly-tu3uj
    @TimothyReilly-tu3uj 4 месяца назад +11

    I was an extra in this for about 5.5 months. We filmed in the upper Daintree area for 3.5 months alone. All the grass scenes were filmed on a property owned by a man called Harold Lee.

  • @4700_Dk
    @4700_Dk Год назад +27

    The battle for Guadalcanal should never be forgotten. So many stories never told, so many lives cut short on all sides. No more WAR !

    • @TheHigherVoltage
      @TheHigherVoltage Год назад

      As long as there is religion...as long as there are people willing to demonize others to take their stuff...there will always be war.

  • @Mrbuckaroonie..
    @Mrbuckaroonie.. 10 месяцев назад +8

    Filmed where I live in Far North Queensland Australia. One of the scenes only 30 minutes away.

  • @delrey874
    @delrey874 Год назад +31

    Terrence Malick is a genius.

  • @nicholasbartonlaw341
    @nicholasbartonlaw341 11 месяцев назад +7

    He defied a universe that let's someone chooses who dies out of hate and callousness, and instead forces it to take the most worthy of all. He's on that thin red line, astonishingly aware, his senses attuned, and understanding everything, but seconds away from the oblivion of death...an immensely spiritual place. He knows every second he stalls his comrades will have time to escape, and if he surrenders there will be no shot heard to warn them. The Japanese soldier is saying nothing to him, has no power over him, because he is far beyond the madness and antipathy of war, far above the madness. A great moment in film.

  • @cschamby8545
    @cschamby8545 9 месяцев назад +2

    So many 'Heroes' that did not make it back. So many necessary stories untold.

  • @cookeatliverepeat8815
    @cookeatliverepeat8815 Год назад +15

    This movie is one of a kind and i dont even like movies about WW2 . This guy is a hero thats for sure and a Person of Interest 😉😉

    • @user-it3ex5nw5f
      @user-it3ex5nw5f Год назад

      movies heros like americans are!!! i!n real life you are cowards!!!!

  • @user-pm2ly2lq1j
    @user-pm2ly2lq1j Год назад +34

    John 15;13 theres no greater love have no man then this to lay down his life for his friends

    • @errickflesch5565
      @errickflesch5565 Год назад +8

      Yes, you have heard it said that there is no greater love than this.........until Jesus said, "hold my holy water".......He then died for His enemies. While we were yet sinners, Christ died for us. That is the greater love. It's a lot easier to die for a friend, family member or even a child...........who would for an enemy. Nobody but Jesus.

  • @josephkunath4173
    @josephkunath4173 4 месяца назад +4

    Saving Private Ryan and this movie came out the same year. 2 amazing movies.

  • @aspiringnormie9499
    @aspiringnormie9499 3 месяца назад +1

    He is such a good actor. A coocoo for sure, but so are most of the greats in this film.
    Expect elias koteus. He genuinely seems like a normal dude.

  • @KeprikMasafri-h2e
    @KeprikMasafri-h2e День назад +1

    Kisah nyata THE THIN RED LINE

  • @peacemen6460
    @peacemen6460 Год назад +5

    Sound of Freedom brought me here!

  • @MovieBuffReal
    @MovieBuffReal Год назад +38

    This movie never got enough appreciation simply because it's a war movie NOT directed by Spielberg.

    • @Akasacarafilm
      @Akasacarafilm Год назад

      ..and not enough NAZI apparently..

    • @mashek331
      @mashek331 Год назад +7

      It's less mainstream and a lot more thoughtful and ponderous, which I find people will either love or hate.

    • @07foxmulder
      @07foxmulder Год назад

      Right. Because making 100 million at the box office, being nominated for countless awards and being critically praised really proves it wasn’t appreciated. Genius.

    • @MovieBuffReal
      @MovieBuffReal Год назад +1

      @@07foxmulder Mr. Professor Weed, did you write that after your daily dose or you haven't CONSUMED it?

    • @kittycatcat6962
      @kittycatcat6962 10 месяцев назад

      ​@@MovieBuffRealhe's not wrong, this is one of the most critically acclaimed war movies ever released, sorry not trying to pile on or sound like an ass

  • @jasperangel
    @jasperangel Год назад +3

    Fan here in the Philippines 🌴

  • @zigzag2510
    @zigzag2510 Год назад +4

    Absolutely masterpiece❤

  • @riptheripper9060
    @riptheripper9060 Год назад +9

    Not the ending I wanted to see, but a fantastic movie nonetheless.

  • @williamschwartz3918
    @williamschwartz3918 11 месяцев назад +4

    What was helpful for me was viewing a clip of the movie's interpretation of some of the actor's roles representing different philosophies. This hero is a Stoic in this clip. Another is a Nihilist and others are other points of view. This is consistent with James Jones's intention that is to show all the behavior of U.S. soldiers in the Pacific war and not just a black and white whitewash of this war. The Japanese are portrayed as any soldier in any war without the politics. I like how the general war is portrayed as a machine where human beings are pawns in the bloody horrible route to it's end.

  • @claudioquiroga521
    @claudioquiroga521 3 месяца назад +2

    La mejor película bélica ,para mí gusto ..

  • @connorcolebrook9800
    @connorcolebrook9800 Год назад +3

    If I ever make a movie a fraction this good I'll be a happy man.

  • @TellySavalas-or5hf
    @TellySavalas-or5hf Год назад +2

    This Nature jungle setting is nice!

  • @nev707
    @nev707 Год назад +12

    Even if the Japanese soldier had honourable intentions he would’ve been overruled by someone senior.
    Individual Allied soldiers captured by the Japanese didn’t fare well.

  • @DubVinC
    @DubVinC Год назад +37

    I saw this in the theatre when it was released. I remember very clearly thinking Jim Caviezel would play Christ very well as I watched this particular scene. True story.

    • @waynedurning8717
      @waynedurning8717 Год назад +1

      You and Mel both.

    • @johnscott9979
      @johnscott9979 Год назад +2

      I remember really admiring Malick's eerie soundscapes & the poetry of the narration, and similarly being greatly impressed by Caviezal's depiction of a spiritual, almost otherworldly character.

    • @DubVinC
      @DubVinC Год назад +2

      It really is mesmerising.

  • @mokooh3280
    @mokooh3280 Год назад +5

    im a combat vet the strikes many notes with me, it scares me ,, so much is accurate that many hate it

  • @ik1lbl
    @ik1lbl 10 месяцев назад +6

    Best war movie ever! A masterpiece! Much better than a typical Hollywood propaganda...this movie it's a pure Art! Not for everyone... and yes.. it's a movie that we need to see multiple time on different time of our lives...

  • @ManuelShuhmelian-ox4ci
    @ManuelShuhmelian-ox4ci Год назад +37

    Beautiful scene of a man who led the enemy in the wrong direction while trying to help his brothers escape. In the end he got trapped, and surrounded by a merciless enemy. None the less he stood his ground and refused to surrender the only things he still possessed in this life. His honor, and dignity. I think his enemies even realized this before they let him exit this life with some sort of mercy only another soldier can appreciate.

    • @sillytrooper
      @sillytrooper 11 месяцев назад +5

      "merciless enemy" my man look up what the japanese guy says :)

    • @SeraphinOM
      @SeraphinOM 10 месяцев назад

      @@sillytrooper I'm eager to hear! Please tell me!

    • @1337billybob
      @1337billybob 10 месяцев назад +1

      Don’t even need to look it up. They literally didn’t shoot him till he raised his firearm. It’s like OP person doesn’t understand the word merciless.

    • @sillytrooper
      @sillytrooper 10 месяцев назад +1

      @@1337billybob maybe, i just didnt wanna be a dickhead in the internet about it and instead show him a new perspective :)

  • @peacefrog5193
    @peacefrog5193 10 месяцев назад +1

    Reading the book atm, is excellent

  • @caesarlol1
    @caesarlol1 7 месяцев назад

    amazing movie

  • @aclarkedesign
    @aclarkedesign 2 месяца назад

    What a great film.

  • @horuslupercal9936
    @horuslupercal9936 Год назад +24

    Overall a disjointed movie that still had some wonderful individual moments.

    • @johnny7s1
      @johnny7s1 Год назад +3

      Yeah I agree, it all came together in its own way but for a casual film goer this is prob a tough watch, some of the best combat scenes in film tho

    • @horuslupercal9936
      @horuslupercal9936 Год назад +1

      @@johnny7s1 Exactly!

    • @jiveassturkey8849
      @jiveassturkey8849 Год назад +1

      That's a Terrence Malick movie in a nutshell.

    • @gregwebb7530
      @gregwebb7530 4 месяца назад +1

      Nominated for an Academy Award for Best Picture. Probably would have gotten more fanfare if it had not been released the same year as Saving Private Ryan.

  • @wreccen
    @wreccen 4 месяца назад +3

    Bats knew what was up

  • @TrackMonkey327
    @TrackMonkey327 2 месяца назад

    Such a great war film.

  • @scarlet_squadron
    @scarlet_squadron 10 месяцев назад +5

    They are most likely the Yano Battalion.
    They were a temporary force of 750 men formed to support the withdrawal from Guadalcanal.

  • @hannotn
    @hannotn Год назад +5

    Don't know that I'd be keen on floating down the river too far. Crocs must have had an endless buffet during the combat on Guadalcanal.

    • @serviceadvisormaxbyservice916
      @serviceadvisormaxbyservice916 5 месяцев назад +1

      It's either that, or you get killed by the enemy. Take your chances down river.

    • @hannotn
      @hannotn 5 месяцев назад +3

      @@serviceadvisormaxbyservice916 There's a very rough estimate that about 500 Japanese soldiers were killed by crocodiles on Ramree Island in Burma. Indian troops landed on a Japanese held island and forced the Japanese back into swamps where they died of malnutrition, tropical diseases and large, unfriendly reptiles. I've worked around crocs. I'd take my chances with the Japanese.

    • @serviceadvisormaxbyservice916
      @serviceadvisormaxbyservice916 5 месяцев назад +1

      @@hannotn I know that wild animals maimed a lot of soldiers on both sides.

  • @thomasogrodnik3233
    @thomasogrodnik3233 7 месяцев назад

    One of the best ever made in dynamic levels; emotional, graphical, metaphorical, historical...
    I really enjoyed this..

  • @cliffordrammadamba2859
    @cliffordrammadamba2859 Год назад +1

    Yeah

  • @behiye5688
    @behiye5688 5 месяцев назад +1

    Her gün bir savaş veriyoruz her savaşta duygularımızı güvenimizi umutlarımızı daha bir çok hislerimizi kaybediyoruz silahın olmasına gerek yok😔

    • @dansecor8753
      @dansecor8753 5 месяцев назад +1

      So just governments should have them? And criminals? As an American I oppose your statement.

  • @Dmog97
    @Dmog97 6 месяцев назад

    5:49 swear the Japanese soldier says “will you look at me when I’m asking you a question”

    • @truthquest
      @truthquest 2 месяца назад

      Actually, he said,
      Is that you, who killed my bro?

  • @michaelwong6050
    @michaelwong6050 7 месяцев назад +1

    The first time I saw this I was wondering who Adrien Brody's character was and why this character who was mostly an extra is suddenly getting more screen time. Then I read about the stuff that happened behind the scenes and how Adrien Brody's character was supposed to be an important character. Makes you wonder what a director's cut of this film would actually be like.

    • @CyrilSneer123
      @CyrilSneer123 6 месяцев назад

      Apparently Brody went to the first screening expecting his character to be the main character only to find most of his scenes were cut from the movie. Knowing Terence Malick the original cut would've been 5 hours long lol

  • @KeprikMasafri-h2e
    @KeprikMasafri-h2e День назад +1

    Inget waktu vcd

  • @mindeloman
    @mindeloman Год назад +30

    While the Japanese soldier was emploring him to give up, the reality is, he had only one option. We have too many accounts to not know that he would've been mercilessly tortured - to scream out into the night- to strike fear into the hearts of his comrades, as they hear echoes of agony through the night. The Japanes gave no quarter and did not respect those that surrendered. At some point, he would've had his manhood cut from his body and shoved into his mouth. Finger nails and toe nails slowly pulled from their roots one by one. Tied to a tree and used as bayonet practice. Every GI and Marine knew, they had better off themselves verses getting captured. "War is cruelty. You cannot refine it." - Sherman

    • @jakefreedomfighterjosohqajds
      @jakefreedomfighterjosohqajds Год назад +2

      Even Bowe Bergdahl us soldier who was taken captive by the Taliban he says they tortured him so yeah this soldier witt took the smart move

    • @chikntaco141
      @chikntaco141 Год назад +4

      ​@@jakefreedomfighterjosohqajdsdon't believe anything that traitor says bro please. He is a liar

    • @jakefreedomfighterjosohqajds
      @jakefreedomfighterjosohqajds Год назад +1

      @@chikntaco141 yeah your right He is a traitor and at best a deserter atleast witt didn't betray his brothers

    • @tntvsouy
      @tntvsouy 11 месяцев назад +3

      Did you know that Japanese soldiers were stuffed with men's things in their mouths on Makin Island?

    • @CorettaJG
      @CorettaJG 11 месяцев назад

      Americans did that torture and murder to fellow Americans in extra judicial lynchings. Then took photos and momentos from the bodies and sent images as postcards.

  • @Emdee5632
    @Emdee5632 11 месяцев назад

    In the original novel he doesn't get shot, but survives. At least til the end of the book.

  • @welberlau
    @welberlau Месяц назад

    Melhor cena de filme de guerrw de todos os tempos

  • @shaunscowcroft9
    @shaunscowcroft9 8 месяцев назад

    Epic war movie!

  • @ThatsMrMoronToYou
    @ThatsMrMoronToYou 11 месяцев назад

    Jon Cryer was born in New York City, NY in 1965.

  • @setsaimu
    @setsaimu 11 месяцев назад +5

    The Japanese soldier at the end told him, “Please drop your weapon. I don’t want to kill you.” If only there was some common way to communicate that, he could have been spared

    • @TheSemperac
      @TheSemperac 11 месяцев назад +2

      he said we have orders to no take prisionaires, defend youreslf

    • @RommelsAsparagus
      @RommelsAsparagus 9 месяцев назад +6

      Witt fully expected to die and basically sacrificed himself for his company. This is basically Jesus as a WV coal miner who is an American Transcendentalist.
      He calmed himself, knowing this was the last breath he was going to take.
      BTW, this is a philosophy film, not a war film. It's actually pretty ahistorical. It is supposed to be Guadalcanal, but it's a melting pot of PTO battles.

  • @charliecen9025
    @charliecen9025 6 месяцев назад

    they were filming this movie in the actual battleground, i remember when they were setting of their explosives, that the actual bombs that were buried underground are going off as well, that they have to seek cover.

  • @davidrace1050
    @davidrace1050 Год назад +1

    Mouse from the Matrix can't catch a brake.

  • @saint52vvs
    @saint52vvs 2 месяца назад

    Adrian Brody’s role was huge and almost completely cut out

  • @daniellap.stewart6839
    @daniellap.stewart6839 Год назад +2

    Rip witt you are in peace now

  • @EsotericCelt
    @EsotericCelt Год назад +15

    The Japanese solider was saying "Surrender, I won't kill you. So surrender, I will not kill you."

    • @spidos1000
      @spidos1000 Год назад +4

      I doubt a Japanese soldier would ever have said that though.

    • @captainsharpeNEL
      @captainsharpeNEL Год назад +7

      @@spidos1000 They can say what ever they want, even in English. by then no US forces soldier was dumb enough to do it. most would rather this ending. it looks in the movie scene like he had a choice but for sure they would have killed him slowly and painfully.

    • @reynaldoflores4522
      @reynaldoflores4522 Год назад +4

      Actually, the Japanese soldier was saying " I don't WANT to kill you. Please surrender. "

    • @patnor7354
      @patnor7354 Год назад +1

      @@spidos1000 They were not all monsters.

    • @anglingpassion5039
      @anglingpassion5039 Год назад

      They would only probably torture him to death anyway

  • @debbiecurtis4021
    @debbiecurtis4021 6 месяцев назад +1

    At the end the Japanese soldier is telling him he doesn't want to kill him.

  • @sandeeppoojary7586
    @sandeeppoojary7586 Год назад +1

    Whatever movie i watch i see our big nose guy...and always he looks tensed..😅

    • @mikeike2177
      @mikeike2177 Год назад

      he was getting flashbacks from kongs island

  • @MaxMinXX
    @MaxMinXX Год назад +4

    Those bolt action Arisakas are kind of funny when you make it go head to head with a semi auto M1 Garand.

    • @OutnBacker
      @OutnBacker Год назад +9

      Those were excellent early Arisaka rifles at that point in the war, which were strong modified Mauser actions, and one of many very good bolt rifles in the war. All other countries but the US had bolt action rifles until the last two years. When the Marines first went ashore on Guadalcanal, they were armed with Springfield bolt actions, which were also modified Mausers. The only rifle that I know of that was not a modified Mauser was the British SMLE Enfield, which was smoother and faster than the Mauser, and could stand on its own compared to the US-M1 Garand in aimed rapid fire.
      The only advantage of a semi auto rifle is that it can lay down covering fire and is harder to detect by the enemy because there is no arm movement when chambering the next round. Semi auto fire from the shoulder is not that effective in getting hits. The .30 cal cartridge was just too powerful to control with any precision. Soldiers were trained in single action fire only, unless covering movement or suppressing the enemy.
      Also, I know from experience with the US-M1 Garand and US-M14. Both are superbly accurate in single shot use, but dismal when fired from the shoulder unless rested on a sandbag. For this reason, almost ALL us snipers in WW2 and Korea, and even up into Viet-Nam, used the bolt action Springfield 03-A3

    • @reynaldoflores4522
      @reynaldoflores4522 Год назад

      I fail to see what makes the Arisaka rifle " funny " compared to the Garand.
      You must have a twisted sense of humor.

    • @OutnBacker
      @OutnBacker Год назад +1

      @@reynaldoflores4522 I rather think he meant "odd" as in out of place in terms of modernity.

    • @brianflynn5355
      @brianflynn5355 Год назад +1

      Still lethal though.

  • @81forever50
    @81forever50 9 месяцев назад

    If some of them have to pass out.

  • @fliprblx_yt9609
    @fliprblx_yt9609 Год назад +5

    Im japanese so ill translate this.
    5:25 Surrender!
    5:44 Surrender
    5:50 Are you the one that killed our comrades?
    5:55 Do you understand?
    6:00 I don't want to kill you. Do you understand?
    6:12 I don't want to kill you. If you understand, surrender now.
    6:24 you're the one that killed our comrades. isn't it?
    6:33 Dont move
    6:40 SURRENDER!
    Pin this if you can so others will understand this.

    • @tntvsouy
      @tntvsouy 11 месяцев назад

      司令官と戦友はニュアンス違うくない?

    • @fliprblx_yt9609
      @fliprblx_yt9609 10 месяцев назад +1

      @@tntvsouy ほんまやヘッドホン使って聞いたら確かに「戦友」って言ってるね。ありがとう。

  • @radioactivehands
    @radioactivehands 8 месяцев назад

    This film made me fall in love with Terrence Malick and Jim Caviezel. Then Malick didn't make a film until 20 years later and Caviezel, a fantastic and powerful actor, played Jesus in Passion and pretty much ended his Holywood career

    • @codymoe4986
      @codymoe4986 Месяц назад

      Pretty sure the majority of his films took place after 2004...
      How did Passion end his career?

  • @toddytoddy9165
    @toddytoddy9165 10 месяцев назад

    como é o nome desse filme e aonde encontrar

  • @HowieFeltersnatchMD
    @HowieFeltersnatchMD 2 месяца назад

    I’d put this, platoon, Full metal jacket and black hawk down as the most realistic war movies ever..followed by Savjng private Ryan, deer hunter, apocalypse now, we were soldiers, dunkirk etc

  • @fleuger99
    @fleuger99 Год назад +5

    All the Japanese soldiers are in a circle, if they open fire en-mass they will hit one another. Great movie though.

    • @spudpud-T67
      @spudpud-T67 Год назад +1

      very monty python

    • @reynaldoflores4522
      @reynaldoflores4522 Год назад

      Astute observation, Captain Obvious !

    • @tntvsouy
      @tntvsouy 11 месяцев назад

      ​@yuusukeDid you know that Japanese soldiers were stuffed with men's things in their mouths on Makin Island?

  • @rickgodley1018
    @rickgodley1018 Год назад

    Remember, this is a movie.

  • @jordanmartin7596
    @jordanmartin7596 Год назад

    @0:57 Holy crap! Is that a young Jon Bernthal? lol

    • @GillD03
      @GillD03 10 месяцев назад

      no......

    • @stretchedout6600
      @stretchedout6600 6 месяцев назад

      He was getting his foreskin removed around this time so no.

  • @kolbaruch9912
    @kolbaruch9912 Месяц назад

    6:50 He knows what will happen if he surrenders.😇✌

  • @elmapaxe
    @elmapaxe Месяц назад

    This clip spoiled me the entire movie

    • @codymoe4986
      @codymoe4986 Месяц назад

      Sounds like a personal problem...
      P.S. Why would you watch clips of a movie that you haven't watched yet?

  • @user-de8xw5mh4d
    @user-de8xw5mh4d 6 месяцев назад

    😔

  • @CrazySC833
    @CrazySC833 Год назад +1

    Does anyone actually speak Japanese? Would LOVE to know what the officer is saying to Whit just before they kill him.

    • @mameloff_video
      @mameloff_video Год назад

      Is that you? Did you kill my comrades-in-arms? Do you understand Japanese? I don't want to kill you. Do you know what this means? I don't want to kill you. You are already surrounded. Surrender now. You killed my comrade-in-arms. I'm... don't move. Stop! Surrender!
      This sentiment is also portrayed in Clint Eastwood's Letters from Iwo Jima.

    • @brianflynn5355
      @brianflynn5355 Год назад +10

      First, he asks "Are you the one who killed my friend?". Then he tells him "Surrender. I don't want to kill you." He repeats this a few times. Since he doesn't respond, he tells him "You're surrounded, just give up & surrender". But instead of surrendering, he raises his rifle & gets shot.

    • @waynedurning8717
      @waynedurning8717 Год назад

      I’m pretty sure he’s asking if he wants a la cart or bento box. A la cart or bento box! Choose! Or I kill you. Along those lines.

  • @kushsmokesam1379
    @kushsmokesam1379 Год назад +2

    What it Japanese saying at the end when he died fighting back

  • @charliep5139
    @charliep5139 Год назад +17

    He's lucky the Japanese just killed him and didn't take him prisoner and torture to death...

  • @taylor77724
    @taylor77724 Год назад +1

    Knowing japanese makes this hurt

  • @jbstorey7223
    @jbstorey7223 8 месяцев назад

    Read up on the character he portrayed. Actually, read up on all of them. Malick's approach to filmmaking is a little unusual. He does not strictly stick to a script. For example, Adrien Brody assumed he was the main character with all the VO work he had done. Turned out to be Jim. He represents a man in search of truth and meaning but removed from connection. He finds a meaning toward the end, and that is how those in his company care for each other. They want to live. He's at peace with dying. They are not. So, sacrifice is probably what he finds meaning in. Contemplative serenity. This isn't a typical 'hero'. It wasn't a deliberate heroic act, as the character doesnt care about heroism. He just sees that the men he is around do care. So, he's fine with sacrificing himself, not as a hero, but as a disposable decoy. In fact, his ending is one of the most profoundly sad things about this movie. In a world full of people who loathe, despise, cling to tribalism - there is no room for compassion or peace. As there is always the 'other' to find fault with. He finds fault in nothing. He looks at the animals, the water, the forest, and probably realizes that in the end, whether you're a wombat, a tree, or a person, we're all the same. That where he finds his inner peace and reconciliation with meaning.

  • @TedBackus
    @TedBackus 11 месяцев назад +1

    originally the title was meant to be 'The Smelly Brown line' but it was changed after 1yr of shooting due to conflicts with the production company

  • @BullToTheShit
    @BullToTheShit Год назад

    Can someone please translate what the Japanese soldier is saying starting at 5:48?

    • @williammcneill2753
      @williammcneill2753 Год назад +1

      "Buy one , get one free at Benihana's"

    • @ALLROY240
      @ALLROY240 Год назад

      5:25 Surrender!
      5:44 Surrender
      5:50 Are you the one that killed our commanders?
      5:55 Do you understand?
      6:00 I don't want to kill you. Do you understand?
      6:12 I don't want to kill you. If you understand, surrender now.
      6:24 you're the one that killed our commanders. isn't it?
      6:33 Don't move
      6:40 SURRENDER!

    • @BullToTheShit
      @BullToTheShit Год назад

      @@ALLROY240 Thank you.

    • @ALLROY240
      @ALLROY240 Год назад

      @@BullToTheShit I copied it from a Japanese person's translation that was submitted some time after your query.

  • @gameram6382
    @gameram6382 Год назад +6

    They us to tie you up to a tree and us you as bayonet practice, only stabbing you in guts, that way you live for longer and the whole platoon would stick you once

    • @mameloff_video
      @mameloff_video Год назад +1

      Yes. But what did Americans do in the Vietnam War about 20 years later? Great justice.

  • @maciej5281
    @maciej5281 11 месяцев назад

    Witts is this guY!!!!!!!

  • @hannotn
    @hannotn Год назад +2

    The endless pauses become funny after a while. Just so predictable. Visually beautiful, but endlessly repetitive in technique.

  • @iberianoutsider3287
    @iberianoutsider3287 9 месяцев назад

    They could not capture him, really 😊

  • @biyahenibryan3051
    @biyahenibryan3051 Год назад +2

    Jesus Christ and the Pianist together

  • @thegael791
    @thegael791 Год назад +1

    My favourite war movie of all time

  • @Daimo83
    @Daimo83 Месяц назад

    "I don't want to kill you. You have been surrounded by Japanese soldiers. You should give in. You, you killed my fellow soldier, didn't you. I don't want to kill you."

  • @WhiteStar762
    @WhiteStar762 2 месяца назад

    Fife, where's Whitt?