FINAL FANTASY VII REBIRTH - Piano Minigame - Let the Battles Begin ⭐️Rank
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 5 мар 2024
- This is the easier one of two optional piano pieces in the game, unlocked by getting at least A ranks on each of the other songs. The other, much harder song, which took me 148 hours to unlock, can be found here:
• FINAL FANTASY VII REBI... 
Игры
I genuinely feel this would be much easier if it had more notes. The amount of times i anticipate a note that isn't there and therefore messup drives me crazy. A couple of sections of the song only has you play 4-5 notes of like 20. I still find this one easier than 2 legs... that songs drives me crazy
Maybe I'll make a 2 legs video. I agree, it's tricky
Happened to me with Tifa's and Barrett's themes. It's complete nonsense...
I think that Two Legs is a harder song because it splits the rhythms between both hands, whereas every other song in the game (at least up to this one) uses the Left/Chord hand simply for emphasis at the beginning of rhythm patterns.
Exactly what I was thinking.
Square should of had a difficulty setting that actually makes you play all the notes instead of 4 at a time
Tifa: Something about this feels oddly familiar...
Cloud: Eh give it a couple of years maybe it will come to you by then.
Guy playing a piano with THAT sword on his back.
"Boo" me, I dare you. 😂
@@alexchou1984Hahahaha😂
😂😂😂😂😂😂
The odd note being thrown in and a note or two missing when humming along really throws me off, but still awesome playing.
54 sec to 1 min just absolutely melt my brain. I am having a very hard time deciphering exactly which notes those inputs are supposed to match
It just occurred to me that I didn't play these notes correctly. The left stick at 54 seconds is supposed to be a half beat earlier than the right stick. The timing window is big enough that I just barely got greats on them both but you can clearly see that I tried to hit them at the same time 😬
IVE BEEN TRYING FOR 3 FUCKDIKDJ HOURS IM GONNA KILL MYSELF I ALWAYS MISS A RANDOM ONE
I was pleased just starring Tifa's theme. This just blows my mind. Genuinely impressive. Well done.
I'm not a Musican but even i can hear that the Song isn't synchronized well with the Inputs. And that's what's putting me off... 😓
My best Score for this Piece so far: 24150
Well..if i managed to get S-Rank in "Two Legs? Nothin to it." then i'll someday get it in "Let the Battles begin!" too.
Edit #2: Best Score-Update: 24670
It's getting better but there are some Parts where you have to slow down and those always make me miss some Notes 😩
The audio is definitely synced a little off, the real problem is that they're coordinating the timing of the sounds with the timing of the inputs. As far as rhythm games go, this game has an extremely lenient great window. The problem could be solved one of two ways: 1.) make the songs like Guitar Hero where the correct sounds play as long as you keep your combo, or 2.)reduce the size of the great window, so if your timing makes it sound off, you get a worse judgement. Because right now, we can hit notes extremely early and still get greats.
Mute the sound, you do much better
@@Candyman5OSI tried that a few times. I did consistently worse, so it doesn't really work for me on this song.
might be the devs trying to make it easier on a controller
This might be late, is your sound output connected via Bluetooth? There’s latency. After I plug in headphones through the controller, easily perfect in a few tries.
Nice. Used this to decipher those doubles toward the end and got the Star myself.
Finally got the S-class rating! Had to speed it up a couple of ticks to get it right. When I first saw this song I said to myself “well I guess I won’t be getting S ratings on all of them after all” but turns out it can be done!!
Just wait til you find out about the Forbidden Eighth Sheet Music (I mean, the One Winged Angel exists to ruin the Lucky Harmony of Seven, so it should come as no surprise that the forbidden Eighth Sheet Music sealed away by Johnny, that needs Eighty-Eight Knickknacks to open, that causes the tracklist to not equate to seven, is none other than "One-Winged Angel"
0:54 to 1:00 is the part that throws me off. No matter how many times I attempt it, I always manage to miss a note or two. The rest of the song feels fine to play though.
It’s those two notes close together at 0:54 that got me forever.
I just can't handle when it goes from the white to black backgrounds. It plays tricks on my eyes to much.
Sidereading this for A rank was the coolest thing I’ve did in this game probably. As a rhythm and card game casual fan, the minigames were amazing in ff7r
Not sure but I hope this helps someone: THIS SONG IS NOT NEEDED FOR THE COLLECTIBLE FOR THE PLATINUM TROPHY
Thank you
Omg thank you. Bye!!
You rocks, i'm impressed.
Funnily enough, Two Legs took way more time to get down than this. Two legs I had to use a video and slow it down to 50% and practice like I do my trumpet playing (slow as all hell). First attempt afterwards, nailed it. Instant star rank. But it’s way too hard to do over and over and expect a different result. They should have added a practice mode for EVERY piece.
Agreed. Especially when there’s only a section you’re having a hard time with. I’d love to just be able to practice that section without having to do the whole song.
This is more doable that it looks! Best I've gotten is a 24680 score, it looks daunting and not worth trying but if you really want to you can do it if you practice a couple times
Honestly, if we could use buttons instead of the thumbsticks, I feel like this mini-game would be a hell of a lot easier.
Sometimes the sticks don't register the right direction. And the fast movement, I find myself accidentally hitting notes when switching to the correct one.
Oh, absolutely. Buttons would make the game a joke. The timing window is pretty big, just stick accuracy makes your mean error a bit bigger.
Which imo is fine, as long as you try to play early. You can hit the notes so early that it sounds like a beginner pianist, and still get greats. The secret is that hitting on time makes you prone to accidentally triggering the next note if you are even slightly inaccurate, but if you play early you'll never have that specific problem. It's easier to time early if you disable soundbars and external audio hardware.
For real and i played rock band and Guitar hero heavily. The analog stick is complete ass and should have been bumper and buttons.
@@xXElement I would get so lost with that control scheme, it would be 3d battle brawler all over again but this time I can't pause buffer between inputs, analogs are fine assuming you don't have any stick drift issues and the input windows are insanely forgiving, probably because of how an analog stick functions. Either way, skill issue, git gud.
@@RenoReborn sure
@@aethertruck " It's easier to time early if you disable soundbars and external audio hardware."
Thank you so much for sharing! I switched to external music (this youtube) so that even if I hit the wrong button, the music would remain complete, which greatly reduced distractions
Tifa: you play the piano?
Cloud: went to town on it
For anyone struggling, try turning off the sound on your TV and just doing it by visuals. Might seem weird but this was much easier for me
The piano is the hard mode off ff7 rebirth and that shinra manager lol
Impressive
This is crazy
Came hear to see if it was actually possible there is no way I am doing that!
awesome sauce
I'm tired boss... I did it, but I'm tired
Crazy
This song showed me how Im getting old, I used to do DDR on expert so I could do timing, but its too fast and its hard for me to keep eyes on both circles for simultaneous notes, the best I can get is a mid B
Keeping your eyes on both circles is probably a mistake. I suggest keeping your eyes on the right circle and 100% allowing peripheral vision to see the left. There's way fewer notes on the left. You could probably get an A while almost completely ignoring the left stick if you are good enough on the right
Theres almost 50 notes on the left, it is alot less but I will need to hit a fair amount of them to get an A @aethertruck
@@AC-mt9mg hmmm yes, the max value of a note is 100 and the minimum is -30. The difference between a great and a good is 70 point, the difference between a good and a miss is only 60. Better to get a great and a miss, than two goods. If you practice I know you can achieve your A
This song is killing me just to get the A rank, i swear half of the notes in the middle the radials show that i pressed it in thay direction and it just keeps carring the note to the end, doesnt even get me a bad or anything just pretends I didnt do anything
Exactly the same i cant even get a b rank
Its the worst game in trophy collection i mean who a damn for the mini games
The problem is already finished all the challenges except this i cant do it and because of it no platinum there
I experienced the same problem. It’ll go on a chain of the radials lighting up that I pressed it but not actually registering
I’ve noticed that the faster you set the speed, the less this problem occurs. I got it to A by playing it on speed difficulty 5, so the hardest one, it is was easier than on 1, just because my inputs actually registered correctly this way. It’s weird and annoying, that’s for sure. I wish I could play this one glitch free
There’s a ~30 second part of the song where the left note comes slightly faster than the right one, so practice leading with the left joystick for those quick two-step notes.
Does the metronome sound even help anyways? I always felt like it was just disturbing but not related to the song speed in any way
Song speed has nothing to do with how fast the song goes, it only has to do with how fast the notes scroll. As for the metronome, it can help get you back on time. Some of these songs have vanishingly quiet sections and I can really only tell, visually, the timing sometimes.
@@aethertruck I know about the song speed, but got annoyed by the metronome as it doesn't feel like a help to me. I also just rely visually on when to play the notes - anything else doesn't work since any of these songs contains notes that you just hear but not play for yourself - hope you get what I mean 🫣
I feel like the notes are so off key for this one its super frustrating
This isn’t dreadfully hard. Biggest struggle is the bridge cus it randomly has you play on the off beats/keys
Advent children
My ps5 and controller updated yesterday and there is a lag, I’m having some difficulty with this one
That's an interesting problem, do you have another controller? Mine updated also but I have no issues.
just curious,how much attempts you needed?for me it looks almost impossible to reach s rank here.
This took me about a half hour. What some people don't know about me though is that rhythm games are my most played genre. A lot of the same skills absolutely translate from game to game. People who have never played a rhythm game in their lives are probably not going to be able to do this even if they had several days of practice. They didn't expect non rhythm gaming standard FF game players to be able to do it so they didn't give any rewards for it. It's just there for fun and the game doesn't record your accomplishments anywhere except for the song menu in the piano minigame.
25080 on my second try, the part at 1:26 always screws me
I just learned that this one is not needed for any trophies! Great job, but man this one is just awful... A lot of inputs have absolutely no relation to the music being played and the piano version is just god-awful...
For this piece (even for chocobo song) the game ignore my inputs for some notes !
He says me « miss » whereas i spam the joystick 😅
For chocobo song the lvl 3 corrected the problem and i got the s rank but for this one always the same bug.
Does anyone know how to fix this ?
Ps : sorry for my english i’m french
I think you're probably misunderstanding the timing of the note you are missing. Some of these notes have tricky and deceptive timing. Increasing the speed makes it easier to tell exactly when the note is.
Thanks for your quick reply bro
Thank you for your advice
Got S rank for let the battles begin and one winged-angel 👍
I think most of this just takes practice.
The hard part, like in Cinco de Chocobo, is the variation.
After 0:53 you'll notice the notes aren't simultaneous, they're ever so slightly staggered, just for that one part. Noticing it is hard though; had to watch this youtube video to notice it. The game does you no favours, what with the aggressive metronome coming back in if you make a mistake, and the split second pause on the button prompts despite the music continuing at its own pace.
It's really badly designed in that it doesn't really offer you a proper practice mode; getting things right means you sail smoothly along, but one mistake and you're back to square one.
Eh, the game places no expectation on you to get a perfect score. Songs are very short and players can use the video save function on the ps5 to review the details. This may be a final fantasy game but practice mode isn't something you'll find in a lot of rhythm games. I don't know how much effort it would take to incorporate a practice mode, but there are only 8 songs. It would feel like a waste on that basis alone, especially since they're all so easy compared to anything that calls itself a rhythm game, even the two completely optional ones but especially the 6 main ones required for rewards.
What I would like to see is an explanation of what note speed does. People think it makes it harder to increase the speed and they don't wanna try it, if they did they'd discover it makes reading a lot easier. Also maybe give a prompt to this song and One Winged Angel that tells you something like "this song is optional, and will not have associated data included in the play log". Something like that so people don't get too bent out of shape about how hard they are. Because they give literally no rewards and you need to access a piano to even see your records.
Is there anything obtained when achieving all stars in the piano songs?
There isn't a reward for getting a star on any song at all, period. Stars are just there for the fun of it. You only need A ranks, and only on the first 6 songs. You can ignore this song entirely.
I don’t know why true chocobo song was the most difficult one for me. 😅
Probably the 5/4 time signature, it gets 5 beats per measure instead of 4, which can sometimes make players feel rhythmically off balance
@@aethertruck yes. This rhythm is difficult for me to handle :D Even the battle song was (for me) easier.
Best game of the year for me and worst trophy collection
This theme is hard for me i cant pass which i know someone would help on this
Already finished all the other challenges except the last side mission there seems a bug need to be fixed
How in the world going to finish this stupid note already spent hours for nothing
Hey I just made it to chapter 9, how do you get the sword? Did I miss it? If it’s something I’ve yet to encounter please say that only I don’t want anything spoiled. I’ve been doing everything extra in the game. I love it
It's in chapter 11
@@aethertruck okay cool lmao thanks bro
@@aethertruck also nice playing! I subbed
Where do you get this song from??
I believe you need to get an A on the first 6 songs, then talking to Dorian unlocks it.
@aethertruck took me 30 minutes to get As on the last 3 tracks but i did it thanks bro lol
Is this song required for the trophy?
I don’t believe so. This and One Winged Angel are prizes for doing the minigames to completion (except you don’t need to do this one for One Winged Angel).
@@hyperstargaming6150 how do you get the one winged angel sheet?
@@TheMaxinR complete Johnny’s display collection. It’ll be in the previously locked treasure chest in front of his hotel.
Is there literally no reward for getting an A rank or higher on this song?
Because i tried it and its tough EVEN WITH THE SLOW SPEED
No reward whatsoever, but slow speed doesn't make it easier to execute. On the contrary, most rhythm games have variable scroll speed options and most find that there's more clarity when you speed up the notes, ensuring there are never too many notes on the display at once. Try again with speed 2 or 3, and I'll bet you have an easier time.
Its part of the platinum trophy
@@Ch0pperized i know that but I wanna know if the AP up plus Chocobo armband effects all the materia that's NOT attached to it
@@Ch0pperizedyou do not need to interact with this song at all for the platinum. It's just here for the fun of it.
@@aethertruck Menos mal por qué entonces se puede meter el platino por el culo estos japones sadicos
How are people doing this? I swear it'd be easier to just learn the piano in real life and just play the songs. I can't seem to manipulate the joysticks in the manner this minigame is demanding me.
Part of it is definitely me already being a music game main. Already honed skills translate pretty well. The timing window for greats is ginormous in this game compared to virtually every other judgement based rhythm game, so when I sightread these songs I usually get all greats except for the 6-10 misses til I learn it lol
@@aethertruck Nice work either way. thanks for the video.
I did it with 2 people hahaha one on each joystick 😂
0:55 This song is flawed. Even when played perfectly, the melody and timing seem off. It needs fix.
The judgment system allows you to get the best rating for every note, even if your timing is off a little. The minigame also features a timing based music playback, meaning that the piano sound is played relative to your stick inputs. These two features combined means you can still get a perfect rating even if your timing is off, but the reason it sounds off is because I was off, not because of the game. An even more skilled player could make it sound perfect
Bruh this is not easier, over an hour later and my best is 24750
Whats the reward for this song ?
Unfortunately, nothing, as far as I can tell. Dorian gives you this sheet music after getting A ranks on every other song, and he stops tracking your scores after that. Which imo is the right thing to do because this minigame asks far too much of the average non-rhythm gamer. I'm just happy they gave us a song hard enough to feel like a real rhythm game.
@@aethertruck I've heard there is one more song to unlock - haven't seen it myself yet though
@@ryanodonnell9106 There is I wont spoil what it is but you have to get every collectable in the game basically every top reward for every mini game and fill up Johnny hotel wall thne his chest unlocks and u get the final sheet music
M@@aethertruckI have played all 6 and I'm glad I don't have to play the piano anymore 😂😭
@@aethertruckthere is one harder song with 7 star or 8 hardest song, but dont wanna spoiler it where to get
I swear, if there was a way to connect my piano to the PS5 this shit would be a joke, who tf thought analogs were a good idea
People praise this game, but the reality is far from what it looks like. The story is horrible and ruined, side quests are horribles, mini games are too hard and don’t get me started with the piano either. Whoever came out with the idea of using the stick as the piano notes, there’s a special place in hell for him
If he deserves a place in hell then I'll give him my ticket to Heaven because I loved it. I've played dozens of music games over the decades and I think this was a very fun design