History of China and neighbor (18000BC - 2024) Countryballs Best version

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 19 янв 2024
  • Thanks for watching

Комментарии • 3,7 тыс.

  • @iron_8453
    @iron_8453  3 месяца назад +581

    For who don't understand timeline of China 👇👇
    - Xia
    - Shang
    - Zhou
    🔴 Warring states of China
    - Qin
    🔴Chu Han war
    - Han
    🔴Three kingdoms
    - Jin
    🔴16 kingdoms 5 Tribals
    - Sui
    - Tang
    🔴10 kingdoms 5 dynasties
    - Song
    - Yuan(mongol)
    - Ming
    - Qing
    🔴Opium war
    🔴Taiping rebellion
    🔴Boxer reble
    - Republic🇹🇼
    🔴World War 1 and 2
    - Communist🇨🇳(present)

    • @BrazilMapping
      @BrazilMapping 3 месяца назад +15

      9 likes and 0 replies? Let me change that

    • @Mongolia1991
      @Mongolia1991 3 месяца назад +14

      Yuan (mongol)

    • @LLENN0420
      @LLENN0420 3 месяца назад +1

      Republic:Republic of China 🇹🇼
      1912 ~ 1945 “China”
      1945 ~ 1949 “China and Taiwan”
      1949 ~ Now “Taiwan”
      Policy:Democracy、Freedom and Human rights
      Communist:People's Republic of China 🇨🇳
      1949 ~ Now
      Policy:Communism、Totalitarianism and Dictatorship

    • @RaulDIOS
      @RaulDIOS 3 месяца назад +4

      14:41

    • @Malayballs69
      @Malayballs69 3 месяца назад

      These are correct orders:
      Xia
      Shang
      Zhou
      Sui
      Qin
      Han
      Tang
      Jin(three kingdoms)
      Song
      Yuan(mongol puppet)
      Ming
      Qing
      Republic china
      中国 china

  • @mikeli9812
    @mikeli9812 3 месяца назад +149

    This is a video with a very obvious Western view of history. There are many errors. During the Qin Dynasty, China had already acquired the land in Lingnan. China first had territory in Xinjiang in the Western Han Dynasty, and continued to control it in the subsequent Tang and Ming dynasties. The Yuan Dynasty is not represented in the video. Taiwan has been under actual control by China since the Ming Dynasty.

    • @user-pj1xd2wt6z
      @user-pj1xd2wt6z Месяц назад +4

      xd是国人吗,这么懂历史😂

    • @join-711
      @join-711 Месяц назад

      8:49 Yuan

    • @user-jv8gz2xm1x
      @user-jv8gz2xm1x 25 дней назад +5

      出现了啊,因为元朝不到一甲子就没了。当然是一闪而过。

    • @Jack-vs4pf
      @Jack-vs4pf 25 дней назад +7

      是的,汉朝的时候设立西域都护府,走出丝绸之路,没有在视频里体现出来。

    • @user-vr3qs7sz7g
      @user-vr3qs7sz7g 23 дня назад

      @@Jack-vs4pf所谓都护府就一个军事据点而已😂 地图里有反映啊,汉代实际控制的河西走廊不是有么。唐代不就把新疆标出来了。

  • @ritedw
    @ritedw 3 месяца назад +835

    It is also a miracle that Chinese civilization has survived so far

    • @PlasmaBlast1108
      @PlasmaBlast1108 3 месяца назад +6

      *thumbs up*

    • @echolee4509
      @echolee4509 3 месяца назад +170

      @@PlasmaBlast1108 In fact, the Chinese began to record their history in writing 4,000 years ago. Every dynasty in ancient China had special historians to record their history, and there was also a great deal of writing that people in ancient China usually wrote that was passed down to later generations. Every later dynasty knew the history of the past very well.

    • @bg9280
      @bg9280 3 месяца назад +196

      中国人可以阅读三千年前的中国文字,中国文化一直都在。你们可以吗。​@@PlasmaBlast1108

    • @georgelee1962
      @georgelee1962 3 месяца назад +77

      为什么要对牛弹琴😂​@@bg9280

    • @bg9280
      @bg9280 3 месяца назад +11

      @@georgelee1962 😄

  • @phyolayphyolay2238
    @phyolayphyolay2238 3 месяца назад +29

    12:43 I love how you add Burmese getting three shots from British because Myanmar and British have three Major wars and after that Burma lost and plotted something else but Anyway Qing Dynasty and Taungoo Empire are still standing after getting shot. They didn't surrender even to the end.

  • @user-wq3zq8pb3j
    @user-wq3zq8pb3j Месяц назад +19

    Thank you for your video of the history of china That’s meaningful

    • @user-wr1tw6ey5o
      @user-wr1tw6ey5o 7 дней назад

      That's not true,too many mistakes the video made

  • @jeffrey20
    @jeffrey20 3 месяца назад +203

    Thank you for made a video about Chinese History man,i appreciated it

    • @SuperChaoGG
      @SuperChaoGG 3 месяца назад +5

      there are many many mistakes

    • @jeffrey20
      @jeffrey20 3 месяца назад +13

      @@SuperChaoGG Creating a video requires a significant amount of time and effort, as well as the gathering of a vast amount of information. Especially when it comes to producing videos about complex subjects like Chinese history, there is a possibility of some inaccuracies, but overall, I think it's acceptable.

    • @tingjunlee6279
      @tingjunlee6279 3 месяца назад +4

      中華民國萬歲🇹🇼💥

    • @theremoon92
      @theremoon92 3 месяца назад

      @@tingjunlee6279 没有毛泽东扫平中国1840年以来的一切不公,今天的中国还活着黑暗分裂之中

    • @user-by5no5zz2n
      @user-by5no5zz2n 3 месяца назад

      ​@@tingjunlee6279中华民国和中国人民共和国都是我们的一部分,可惜中华人民共和国被西方黑的太惨了,因为它使这个国家恢复了以前的强大,这威胁了西方的地位,而你们被洗脑了难以认同它,当然论中华民国在台湾也取得了非常厉害的成绩,只是迟早我们会兵戎相见并统一为一个真正完整的中国,并不仅仅是因为我们认为台湾是我们的领土,而更是因为你们是美国爸爸阻止中国大陆地区崛起的第一轮炮灰。

  • @user-cs2mx4lt3q
    @user-cs2mx4lt3q 3 месяца назад +148

    wow can't believe how criminally underrated this is keep up the awesome content bro

    • @Conor.Mcnuggets
      @Conor.Mcnuggets 3 месяца назад +6

      so many inaccuracies...

    • @neois3
      @neois3 2 месяца назад

      The north of the Great Wall is not Chinese territory. It was ruled by Mongols, Manchurians, and Koreans. Qin Shi Huang built the Great Wall to block the so-called Northern Orangkai. Later, China was conquered by the Mongolia and also Kim(金) Dynasty founded by descendants of korean Kim Ham-bo.
      Manjuwonryugo (滿洲源流考), compiled during the Qianlong Emperor of the Qing Dynasty, also reveals that the national name 金(kim) Dynasty is also derived from the family name 金(kim)of King of Silla(ancient korea).
      Also china was ruled by the Manchurians for 300 years(Qing dynasty)
      Sugihara, a professor who published "Japan's Bronze Age from Korea," said, "The Bronze Age came to Japan from 100 BC to AD50, the end of Korean Bronze Age society. In Japan, the Iron Age and the Bronze Age were handed down at the same time during the Yayoi period, and the Bronze Age was only used for ancestral rites, so it seems that it went straight to the Iron Age without going through the Bronze Age."
      Around 100 BC - Ancient civilization began in Japan when Koreans landed with iron weapons in Japan, where primitive people in the Stone Age lived. Japanese history is the history of the Korean people
      "High-tech science has proven historical truths that no one has ever told you. In other words, Koreans moved to Japan and founded the ancient civilization of Japan. Although traces of the Yayoi civilization, which ended Japan's primitive era and opened up an ancient society, appear throughout the Japanese mainland, it is widely accepted as orthodox that it originated in the northern part of Kyushu by the descendants. The study made it clear that the Yayoi people are descendants of people from the southern part of the Korean Peninsula."
      The Han Chinese along with Vietnam, were grouped in a different lineage, showing genetic differences from Koreans.
      O2b: This type can be said to be the core of Koreans' unique Y chromosome. It accounts for 37.3 percent of Koreans, but is rarely found in China. O2b is mainly distributed in Japan (31.9 percent) and Manchu (3.8 percent) outside of the Korean Peninsula, so O2b can be said to be a unique gene of Koreans and Japanese people
      "direct ancestors of korean are members of the ancient Asian and Tungus ethnic group that migrated from Siberia in the Neolithic Age, and linguistically belong to the Altai ethnic group." "In addition to the Yayoi (Yamato people) of the Doraein line who crossed from the Korean Peninsula, there are also the Ainu lineal descendants of the Jomon people of the indigenous people of the Japanese archipelago."
      Japanese civic group claims, "It is the same as the annexation of Korea and Japan, reunification of East and West Germany." 2018-11-2008:30 A report was sent to the U.N. Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination in Korea to demand "correct the fabrication of facts in Korea."
      At the time of the annexation of Korea and Japan, the Japanese ruling class thought that they were unified.they granted equal rights to Koreans through "Korea and Japan are One" policy(內鮮一體). In addition, a huge amount of 30 percent of Japan's total budget was poured every year for the modernization of Joseon.
      The lives of Koreans have become so abundant that the population, which had remained at the level of 10 million without population growth for 600 years during the Joseon Dynasty, doubled during the Japanese colonial era.
      "During the colonial period, Joseon's population grew by 12.6 million people, about 69 percent of whom, 8.7 million, were within the Korean Peninsula and 31 percent were flown to Manchuria and Japan"

    • @user-cs2mx4lt3q
      @user-cs2mx4lt3q 2 месяца назад +1

      @@neois3 i mean yeah mistakes were made but that's only like 1 minute out of the 16 minutes that were historically accurate i mean no offense but you can't do any better (respectfully)

    • @freeworldtankman
      @freeworldtankman 2 месяца назад +2

      So true. Actually, one of the USA founders was a Korean too.​@@neois3

    • @octavianxu
      @octavianxu 2 месяца назад

      @@neois3 where did you get the ridiculous theory that Manchurian Dynasty was associated with Korean?

  • @user-un1jb2qz3w
    @user-un1jb2qz3w 3 месяца назад +66

    It's a very good vedio if you are interested in Chinese history. However, I have to say that there are lots of mistakes and could be a little confusing sometimes. For example, after the collapse of Tang empire, there are successors that claims themselves to be "Tang", which didn't have much relationship with Tang empire. But they are using the same ball in this vedio. I don't think that it is correct. And the "Tang" in north (which is known as "Hou Tang" 后唐) is actually founded by the kingdom of Jin, instead of annexing it. And this kingdom of Jin is totally different from the latter Jin (known as "Hou Jin"后晋), which is one of "the Five Dynasties".

    • @user-yh4zw4mu6x
      @user-yh4zw4mu6x 2 месяца назад +2

      🤓

    • @user-dy1xe6xf8e
      @user-dy1xe6xf8e 2 месяца назад +1

      @@user-gf7eu5ys5c in fact they are the same character, because those who use 唐 as their name thought they are the heir of the first 唐. in historian's view, they might be named in後唐、南唐or something else, but formally they all named the same word at their time. btw, the last name of leaders of these dynasty is 李(Lee).

    • @user-gf7eu5ys5c
      @user-gf7eu5ys5c 2 месяца назад

      @@user-dy1xe6xf8e I disagree with your idea. The ancient Chinese history I have studied does not propose a direct relationship between the rulers of the Later Tang and Southern Tang dynasties and the rulers of the Tang dynasty. As for surnames, they can be changed. Of course, the father and son of Li Cunxu and Li Keyong in the Later Tang Dynasty may have a blood relationship with the rulers of the Tang Dynasty

    • @user-dy1xe6xf8e
      @user-dy1xe6xf8e 2 месяца назад

      @@user-gf7eu5ys5c hmm, u can keep your opinion, but after all, they are same character.

    • @user-oj2yo8pn7e
      @user-oj2yo8pn7e 2 месяца назад

      Oh this is correct, I was waiting for this explanation!

  • @fdgfgb6918
    @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +10

    15:48 ก่อตั้ง จากพรรคคอมมิวยิสต์ ให้ขี้นเป็น people repubilc of china ขี้น ค.ศ.1949

  • @ItzThaiAnimations
    @ItzThaiAnimations 3 месяца назад +49

    อนิเมชั่นเเละเรื่องราวประวัติศาสตร์ตัดต่อ ออกมาได้ดีมากครับ เป็นกำลังใจให้ทำคลิปต่อไปนะครับ🤩

    • @iron_8453
      @iron_8453  3 месяца назад +4

      ขอบคุณครับผม

    • @Gabo_Koopa
      @Gabo_Koopa 3 месяца назад

      a question :C @@iron_8453

  • @ALCGCG
    @ALCGCG 3 месяца назад +100

    作為一個外國人能把時間線搞明白已經很厲害了

    • @user-xo9dl9fz3y
      @user-xo9dl9fz3y 3 месяца назад +10

      作为中国人,就我也搞不懂时间线,但大概内容我是了解的

    • @user-gq6dy7os5n
      @user-gq6dy7os5n 3 месяца назад +5

      确实 很少看到这种科普中国历史的视频🎉

    • @YLHaoShuai
      @YLHaoShuai 3 месяца назад +2

      蛮厉害吗

    • @user-ue5ph6qw2q
      @user-ue5ph6qw2q 3 месяца назад +6

      有的朝代例如五代十国,真的很难搞懂😓

    • @user-ir6qw8cn7z
      @user-ir6qw8cn7z 3 месяца назад

      汉到魏晋南北朝然后到隋,唐到五代十国然后到宋@@user-ue5ph6qw2q

  • @mcheng7190
    @mcheng7190 2 месяца назад +3

    I'll give the Jasmine soundtrack at the beginning of the video a favorable review
    good👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

    • @user-pv7xb8wg7i
      @user-pv7xb8wg7i 15 дней назад

      Reminds me of the days when I played Civilization 6

    • @alptekin6299
      @alptekin6299 День назад

      @mcheng7190 where can i find the soundtrack?

  • @Ocro555
    @Ocro555 3 месяца назад +89

    Haven't started watching the video yet but I randomly clicked into the middle parts of the video and got to say it looks promising! As a Chinese, I'm hyped to see how well this video actually is. Just expressing my awe beforehand!

    • @BBoxB
      @BBoxB 3 месяца назад +3

      《作为一个中国人》,用英语😅

    • @xudongpeng
      @xudongpeng 3 месяца назад +12

      @@BBoxB 这又不是中国网站

    • @bg9280
      @bg9280 3 месяца назад +8

      @@BBoxB 怕你看不懂🤣

    • @cristallee
      @cristallee 3 месяца назад +2

      Ming Dynasty needs to be added the Tibet.

    • @aeawel
      @aeawel 2 месяца назад +2

      明朝的库页岛😅硬是被他吃了

  • @user-ze6gw2oc9z
    @user-ze6gw2oc9z Месяц назад

    It's good that the Battle of Sekigahara is properly written down.

  • @kritsadachanthes4325
    @kritsadachanthes4325 3 месяца назад +7

    How long have you produced this video. I appreciate your patience.

  • @qmyt2678
    @qmyt2678 Месяц назад +16

    Thank you! This is a very detailed and accurate visualization of Chinese history. You must have done a lot of research!

  • @KeniclesTheEpic
    @KeniclesTheEpic 3 месяца назад +46

    this is very detailed and deserves more recognition!

  • @user-by5no5zz2n
    @user-by5no5zz2n 3 месяца назад +2

    这小动画非常有趣,观看过程就像是在复习高中所学历史知识。

  • @yugeeyx8196
    @yugeeyx8196 2 месяца назад +5

    感谢你的分享,非常喜欢

  • @user-gz8xb9pr6c
    @user-gz8xb9pr6c 3 месяца назад +69

    夏朝分兩段,前半段都城在陝西省沒錯,但是是在陝西北部。後半段都城在河南,也就是二裡頭遺址。商朝是在夏朝後半段都城(二裡頭遺址)東北部的一個領主推翻國王發展來的。秦朝以前,夏、商、周是分封制的,全國的土地都是國王的,但國王把全國土地劃分成許多塊,分封給公爵、侯爵、伯爵、男爵、子爵等領主,秦朝以前中國朝代和歐洲中世紀的行政管理方式類似。視頻中秦朝以前的朝代僅顯示國王直接管理的區域,那些效忠國王的領主的領土沒有顯示。請問你們劃神聖羅馬帝國的領土範圍你們會只劃出神聖羅馬帝國皇帝直接管理的領土嗎?或者選帝侯直接管轄的領土嗎?😂秦朝之後,秦始皇開始把國家所有權利集中到他自己手中,到漢景帝平定七國之亂,最終完成中央集權制,一直延續到現代。所以秦朝以前和秦朝以後是不同的行政制度。如果在夏、商、周三個王朝,當時的中國領主跟中國國王稟報遭到外族入侵,估計這場入侵是發生在距離你劃的所謂夏、商、周領土非常遠非常遠的地方,而且當時的中國軍隊是要到視頻所顯示的國王直接管理的區域非常遠非常遠的地方戰鬥。

    • @user-ke2ir2zt1v
      @user-ke2ir2zt1v 3 месяца назад +6

      它给夏商周位置还画偏了

    • @user-cy4kw2vr3m
      @user-cy4kw2vr3m 3 месяца назад

      毕竟是白皮做的,不过战国倒是让人眼前一亮,竟然把魏国划成两块了,要知道国内很多做历史的都是胡乱画的

    • @user-lk9nt5wg5q
      @user-lk9nt5wg5q 3 месяца назад

      看来在国外都不承认台湾是中国的啊,只有大陆人认为是。(本人大陆人但非粉红)

    • @kaishao2035
      @kaishao2035 3 месяца назад

      夏朝始于启,何来陕西之说

    • @_Nobita_0143
      @_Nobita_0143 2 месяца назад

      I appreciate that.

  • @user-vn8py2tl1n
    @user-vn8py2tl1n 3 месяца назад +6

    พี่ครับเล่นเกม great conqueror 2 shogun หน่อยครับ อยากเห็นพี่เล่นเป็นEPจัง

  • @tiro_taiwan
    @tiro_taiwan 3 месяца назад +1

    Nice work

  • @tommywang8752
    @tommywang8752 3 месяца назад +2

    The most important message showed in the end of this video is Covid also is a war😊

  • @anonymuswere
    @anonymuswere 3 месяца назад +15

    this is one of the better ones of these I've seen.

  • @user-bg6km7kx5h
    @user-bg6km7kx5h 2 месяца назад +1

    I am so happy because you have make the Hong Kong and Macao

  • @luskySS
    @luskySS 2 месяца назад +4

    In fact, the Communist Party's acquisition of the Northeastern region during the civil war was not as easy as shown in the video. It seemed that it was simply obtained from the Soviet Union. In fact, the Soviet Union seemed to be more supportive of ROC during the civil war. After Japan surrendered, almost all the major cities in Northeast China were handed over to KMT.

    • @dimushka383
      @dimushka383 2 месяца назад +2

      You are wrong about this.
      The support from the USSR was very serious. Everything was given to the Chinese Communists. More than a thousand people with USSR citizenship died in the first year of the civil war in China.
      Yes, there were disagreements with Mao, but not with the party itself. There was training, weapons and political support.

    • @onerainhsia6659
      @onerainhsia6659 13 дней назад

      两头压注

  • @user-hj8ph6nw9p
    @user-hj8ph6nw9p 3 месяца назад +42

    this is a china history video , however lost many details about its neighbors, thats a pity but understandable, they are not the main character in this video

  • @Anthony-hh3dl
    @Anthony-hh3dl 3 месяца назад +62

    很多錯誤,但是總體來講還算ok. 比如漢代是有西域的,還有中華民國時期沒有人承認西藏,外蒙古於1946年正式獨立,蘇聯1944年吞併唐努烏梁海(圖瓦共和國)
    Btw, 高句麗是真能苟,從東漢一直到唐朝

    • @user-mg1og3gi3z
      @user-mg1og3gi3z 3 месяца назад

      😂😂是的

    • @SleepyTiger8
      @SleepyTiger8 3 месяца назад

      西康不就是西藏嗎?

    • @jusheng345
      @jusheng345 3 месяца назад +5

      @@SleepyTiger8 是分開的喔!西藏是地方、西康是省,如青康藏高原就是指青海省、西康省跟西藏地方。

    • @SleepyTiger8
      @SleepyTiger8 3 месяца назад

      @@jusheng345謝謝指正👌

    • @RuijinBags
      @RuijinBags 3 месяца назад +3

      两晋后的乱世没写,辽没写。

  • @withmilkwalnut-rz4jj
    @withmilkwalnut-rz4jj Месяц назад

    The bgm is China Jiangnan famous song "Jasmine".

  • @user-ks1en7hd2h
    @user-ks1en7hd2h 27 дней назад +8

    你做的太棒了,真的做了很多功课吧,辛苦了

  • @Andy_yyR
    @Andy_yyR 3 месяца назад +116

    Ojalá pudiera aprender Chino para visitar ese maravilloso país.
    La historia y cultura de China me encantan ❤

    • @user-zc1gc6qe1n
      @user-zc1gc6qe1n 3 месяца назад +10

      My friend, welcome to China.

    • @TheCubeWelcome
      @TheCubeWelcome 3 месяца назад

      @@user-zc1gc6qe1nFree Hong Kong Xi jin ping from india

    • @user-ic6ne3pr5t
      @user-ic6ne3pr5t 3 месяца назад +8

      我们中国🇨🇳很安全,人也很热情❤

    • @hughy6189
      @hughy6189 3 месяца назад +4

      welcome

    • @xwisp1942
      @xwisp1942 3 месяца назад +4

      欢迎你哦😄

  • @Pacan1609
    @Pacan1609 3 месяца назад +31

    Я из России, и российский народ уважает Китай. Мы братья❤🇨🇳❤🇷🇺❤🇨🇳♥️🇷🇺♥️🇨🇳♥️🇷🇺♥️🇨🇳

    • @argynqazaq7360
      @argynqazaq7360 3 месяца назад +2

      Да вы Младший саттелит китая

    • @cuongnguyen-cq5qh
      @cuongnguyen-cq5qh 3 месяца назад +1

      Không có anh em nào đi cướp đất của chính anh em mình 😂😂😂, hãy trả vùng viễn đông mà đế quốc nga đã chiếm của trung quốc

    • @EzequiasRosson
      @EzequiasRosson 3 месяца назад +1

      @@argynqazaq7360 哈哈!你是对的!

    • @user-fg1jm2sn9o
      @user-fg1jm2sn9o 3 месяца назад +5

      YES!!👍Brother! from China Harbin

    • @KellyPhiladelphia535
      @KellyPhiladelphia535 3 месяца назад +5

      ​@@argynqazaq7360на данный момент в мире есть три суверенных государства это Америка, Китай, Россия все остальные подшконарные

  • @Caraful
    @Caraful 3 месяца назад +2

    i love the face expressions on these circle faces

  • @Anonymous-mh1vs
    @Anonymous-mh1vs 2 месяца назад +2

    Pretty good video. Good job! The only thing I noticed, which isn't even an error, but maybe it would deserve something like a written clarification, is that the Xia Dynasty, still as of today, isn't clear if it really existed or was only a legend born during the Zhou Dynasty. The research is still ongoing but for now we still haven't a clear answer, differently from the Shang Dynasty and Zhou Dynasty which were proven archeologically and even with some written documents contemporary from their periods.

    • @MS_XIONGbao
      @MS_XIONGbao 2 месяца назад

      how could?xia's site been found already

    • @Anonymous-mh1vs
      @Anonymous-mh1vs 2 месяца назад

      @@MS_XIONGbao there is indeed the possibility, as I said. The zone was obviously already inhabitated during that period and there were also cities from that period. On that there is no doubt. One of the problems for example is to show without any doubt that these urban findings really do represent a single polity or not and instead at the time there were various Chinese polities and not a single Xia Dynasty. Or another problem is why not only there also no written record or mention found from oracle writing from the period of the Shang Dynasty, or anything which makes them consider a successor to the Xia, and it's only mentioned later, during the Zhou Dynasty such a dynasty. But again, these are only doubts. Maybe the sites are indeed a representation of the Xia Dynasty and not of early separate polities. Or also, at least the last period of that phase represented by the archeological findings, was already the beginning of the Shang Dynasty. Or also maybe during a part of this period there were separate polities and later emerged a single Xia Dynasty. And regarding the problem of lacking documentation from the Shang, maybe there are other reasons as of why there isn't written documentation about the Xia during the Shang Dynasty. Maybe they were trying to erase it or at least hide it for some reason. Or maybe simply there are written sources abou the Xia from the Shang Dynasty period but simply were not able to find, as of now. Maybe in the next years it will be found a more exaustive proof to link the archeological sites found at Erlitou with the Xia Dynasty.

    • @MS_XIONGbao
      @MS_XIONGbao 2 месяца назад +1

      ​@@Anonymous-mh1vshardly figuring out. But i heard there was a solar eclipse which been recorded occurred in Xia dynasty

  • @user-um8eo7kf8t
    @user-um8eo7kf8t 3 месяца назад +13

    有些地方错得很明显,有些细节又把握得很准,挺有意思的😮

    • @8910H
      @8910H 2 месяца назад

      同意

  • @fdgfgb6918
    @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +5

    13:20 ก่อตั้ง empire of china ขี้น ค.ศ.1915

  • @qingque520
    @qingque520 3 месяца назад +16

    China's website has a video of the same type, and it is very sophisticated.

    • @aczbdk
      @aczbdk 3 месяца назад

      Ignore any info provided by the Communist PRC, they are full of lies. Communism originated from Germany, they occupied China by force and call it PRC.

    • @iron-fx7xc
      @iron-fx7xc 2 месяца назад

      from bilibili“史图馆”or“一团小红球”

  • @CodeZero587
    @CodeZero587 3 месяца назад +6

    Hey what's the name of the Chinese theme? Nice video btw

    • @user-rq9ri2nx4c
      @user-rq9ri2nx4c 3 месяца назад

      这个视频错误百出,有的历史事件颠倒,有的地理位置错误,有的细节错误,只能看个大概。

    • @yfayf597
      @yfayf597 3 месяца назад +1

      its names “茉莉花”You can try searching for 《China (The Industrial Era)》

    • @thesuninmyheartismaozedong
      @thesuninmyheartismaozedong 3 месяца назад +1

      @@user-rq9ri2nx4c有稍微讀過中華文化的就知道

    • @hellosurvivor97
      @hellosurvivor97 Месяц назад

      Jasmine flower

  • @fdgfgb6918
    @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +4

    2:09 สงครามราชวงค์ฮั่น กับ ฉู่ 206 BC

    • @fdgfgb6918
      @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +1

      2:45 จบสงครามด้วยชัยะชนะของฮั่น และกลายเป็นราชวงค์ฮั่น

  • @rodrigoh1025
    @rodrigoh1025 3 месяца назад +3

    Very good greetings from Brazil

  • @fengwu8256
    @fengwu8256 3 месяца назад +15

    The area of the Qin Dynasty was too small, but the Qin Dynasty had already conquered the Western Region (now Xinjiang)

    • @user-oy1dn8zt9p
      @user-oy1dn8zt9p 14 дней назад +1

      S'B一眼反串,上过初中都知道是西汉时建立的西域都护府

    • @felixcruis
      @felixcruis 13 дней назад

      是汉朝
      但是图中没有画

    • @user-lg4wm9nq6r
      @user-lg4wm9nq6r 10 дней назад

      byd是汉朝

  • @LeoNath...8753
    @LeoNath...8753 3 месяца назад +43

    The only apparent mistake is that Tajikistan is misplaced (too west compared to China, making it looks like China annexed Tajikistan), but the rest is perfect! Nice vid.

    • @Conor.Mcnuggets
      @Conor.Mcnuggets 3 месяца назад +4

      way more mistakes...

    • @chundh99
      @chundh99 3 месяца назад +4

      How can you be sure it’s perfect tho? It’s far from perfect but still very accurate most of the part.
      I assume you think it’s perfect because you know detailed history about a certain place. That doesn’t mean everything else is perfect. I’m Korean, and I can see many errors in the video regarding the Korean Peninsula. But I don’t say “it’s perfect except this or that” because first of all it’s not true since I don’t know about other areas, and second you are spreading misinformation by commenting this.

    • @orangecitrus8056
      @orangecitrus8056 Месяц назад +2

      @@chundh99 do you have plastic surgery

    • @user-lv3xr4wj3i
      @user-lv3xr4wj3i Месяц назад

      Tajikistan is not chija 🤢.

    • @hecongzhang8515
      @hecongzhang8515 21 день назад

      @@chundh99 is not about perfect or not, if you just read a liitle bit of chinese history you'll see that this is all wrong bro read more books bruh.

  • @Eksksmshcywywug
    @Eksksmshcywywug 3 месяца назад +5

    Amazing video! Thank you ❤

  • @hao-xn1pd
    @hao-xn1pd Месяц назад +5

    视频做的非常好,谢谢你

  • @patricialeites2129
    @patricialeites2129 2 месяца назад +1

    También me harías un vídeo de las dinastías Sui Tang Song Ming y Han juntas???

  • @jie0330
    @jie0330 3 месяца назад +18

    I'm chinese and i would say There are many things wrong.😂 Thank you for the video.

  • @alangxu5680
    @alangxu5680 29 дней назад +10

    做的很棒,而且大致方向和历史发展没有太大差异!作为中国人,我给您送上祝福。🎉

    • @hecongzhang8515
      @hecongzhang8515 21 день назад

      老弟,你是真不懂历史啊。稍微看一下就知道全都是错的,像是收复河套,南匈奴,大理国还有女真部落都没有啊。

    • @user-dt4yn4ik4g
      @user-dt4yn4ik4g 20 дней назад +3

      汉代那个北击匈奴没了,西域也没征服,到现在他们还在意图分裂新疆

    • @hecongzhang8515
      @hecongzhang8515 15 дней назад

      老弟学学历史吧

    • @alangxu5680
      @alangxu5680 10 дней назад

      @@hecongzhang8515 好的,哥哥!推荐几本书

  • @8nabaluh
    @8nabaluh 3 месяца назад +70

    Love china and Thailand from Myanmar ❤🇹🇭🇨🇳🤝🇲🇲

    • @1june204
      @1june204 3 месяца назад +5

      🇨🇳❤🇲🇲

    • @ydh3606
      @ydh3606 3 месяца назад +2

      Love

    • @tianlingchen5523
      @tianlingchen5523 3 месяца назад +6

      希望缅甸早日恢复和平❤❤🎉

    • @muje2511
      @muje2511 3 месяца назад

      How can you, a Myanmar person, support China when the reason the Myanmar military kills thousands of innocent citizens and stays in power is because the Chinese Communist Party supports them? I'm really curious.

    • @user-yo5sv9tz3l
      @user-yo5sv9tz3l Месяц назад +1

      中缅友好🤝

  • @artificialanimeuniverse5063
    @artificialanimeuniverse5063 10 дней назад

    12:57
    The way all of them came in boat and started shooting simultaneously is hilarious.
    This might look nothing from the outside but we must dig deep.
    Even though it dosen't say so we can pretend this creator has good sence of humour and can understand Psychology. It has been scientifically proven that a bit of humour is good for mental health.

  • @user-kn2is2et8q
    @user-kn2is2et8q 3 месяца назад +6

    这是我看到过的最棒的中国历史相关的视频。可能地图不够准确,但已经相当不错了。

  • @kevincano2299
    @kevincano2299 2 месяца назад +1

    This is amazing

  • @fdgfgb6918
    @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +5

    1:53 หลังจากชนะแล้ว แล้วสถาปนาตนเอง ซื่อว่า ราชวงค์ฉิน 221 BC

    • @fdgfgb6918
      @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +1

      ราชวงค์ที่ 4 ของจีนคือ

    • @fdgfgb6918
      @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +2

      Qin dynasty

  • @PaektuMountain
    @PaektuMountain 3 месяца назад +37

    10:34 You misunderstand the map for Korea. The Qing Dynasty attacked Korea not for absorption or annexation.
    It was an attack to establish relations because Korea interfered with the Qing Dynasty's occupation of Ming.
    During the Qing Dynasty, The Qing government was in charge of Mongolia, Tibet, and Uyghur-related affairs by the Ministry of Home Affairs, while the Ministry of Foreign Affairs was in charge of affairs such as Korea, Ryukyu, and Thailand.
    As a result, Qing's treatment of Korea was no different than it was during the Ming Dynasty, after the Qing Dynasty had complete control over China.

    • @user-jw9be1gs1f
      @user-jw9be1gs1f 3 месяца назад +8

      I completely agree with you

    • @pokmandeng5650
      @pokmandeng5650 3 месяца назад +1

      korea is a satilite state of china. Korea belongs to china.

    • @pokmandeng5650
      @pokmandeng5650 3 месяца назад +6

      north korea was apart of china, korea and japan are satilite state. Their food, language, culture and way of managing their country are all from china. Even the korean flag was made by china then edited by british. Korea's capital used to called han, referring to the chinese ethlinicty.
      What is today modern-day Seoul was first occupied in 554 and called "Hanyang" -- a name used for Seoul ever since. In 1068, King Munjong made Hanyang one of several regional sub-capitals, and when the Yi Dynasty overthrew the Koryo ruling house in 1392, Hanyang was renamed and became the capital two years later.

    • @pokmandeng5650
      @pokmandeng5650 3 месяца назад +7

      by the way, sushi, kimchi, are from china. Even the langage, in the korean war, koreans fled to china. Now they have 2 million decendents in china, they speak korean and use the original korean with chinese characters, south korea stoped using chinese only recently. And the 2 million chinese who speaks korean their korean is 30% with chinese characters.

    • @pokmandeng5650
      @pokmandeng5650 3 месяца назад

      large portion of modern day North Korea was under direct rule of the Chinese empire during the Han and Yuan administration

  • @Reiwa18
    @Reiwa18 3 месяца назад +35

    Next time, I would like to see the history from the year 2024 to 10,000.

    • @user-rp5mb6rw1k
      @user-rp5mb6rw1k 2 месяца назад +5

      I want to see the history in year 114514

    • @gopiraj6733
      @gopiraj6733 2 месяца назад

      ​@@user-rp5mb6rw1k
      What a childish fake content😅😅😅 I want to see stupid chinese imagination till year 20 458 217, 😂😂😂😂

    • @user-mj4zz9yd4k
      @user-mj4zz9yd4k Месяц назад +1

      Нету ищо такого года 😂

    • @user-pp5sk5lt3x
      @user-pp5sk5lt3x 10 дней назад

      我去看过了,一片焦土,上面没有大型生命

  • @user-ix4mo7kg6y
    @user-ix4mo7kg6y Месяц назад +2

    I really liked the background music starting from 13:24. Could you please tell me the name of the song? It seems like It's not included in the summary section for the music.

  • @fdgfgb6918
    @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +4

    10:50 ก่อตั้ง ราชวงค์ชิง ขี้น หลังจากที่แยกตัวเป็นอิสรจากราชวงค์หมิง

    • @fdgfgb6918
      @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +1

      ราชวงค์ ที่ 12 ราชวงค์สุดท้ายของจีนคือ

    • @fdgfgb6918
      @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +1

      Qing dynasty

  • @fdgfgb6918
    @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +3

    13:15 ก่อตั้ง เป็น Repubilc of china ขี้น ค.ศ.1912

  • @yarcowang
    @yarcowang 3 месяца назад +1

    You are a genius~~

    • @hecongzhang8515
      @hecongzhang8515 21 день назад

      老弟,你是真不懂历史啊。稍微看一下就知道全都是错的,像是收复河套,南匈奴,大理国还有女真部落都没有啊。

  • @ssssssss11146
    @ssssssss11146 3 месяца назад +11

    わかりやすくて面白かった。
    大きくなっても、分裂してしまうのですね。

    • @zihaojiang9143
      @zihaojiang9143 3 месяца назад +6

      天下大势,分久必合

    • @jevonjiang
      @jevonjiang 6 дней назад

      其實不是分裂,視頻中有些錯誤,周朝末期,其實就一個周朝,剩下的小國家是分封的諸侯國,仍然屬於周朝。漢末分三國,其實也都屬於中國,但是他們都認為自己是中國的合法政府,出現了三個政權。

  • @user-mi3km6qt6e
    @user-mi3km6qt6e 3 месяца назад +14

    What sources did you refer to for China's eastern border? completely wrong.

    • @Best-gb4rc
      @Best-gb4rc 3 месяца назад +7

      Western border also wrong

  • @yongjunliu1898
    @yongjunliu1898 3 месяца назад +78

    Very good video. As a Chinese, I can say that it reflects the history I know.

    • @atlas_x150
      @atlas_x150 3 месяца назад +8

      just completely inaccurate, although it's overall correct

    • @gameworld1488
      @gameworld1488 3 месяца назад

      看不出来么?反华分子岁月史书。错误点包括:中共实控地区,伪满洲国这种傀儡,古代很不用说了,到处都是问题。

    • @watchman835
      @watchman835 3 месяца назад

      @@atlas_x150So are Chinese just a bunch of colours balls stabbing each other for growth?

    • @RossoAegis-oj7om
      @RossoAegis-oj7om 3 месяца назад +19

      你这中国人怕是个假的😅上学没学历史么?错成这样

    • @watchman835
      @watchman835 3 месяца назад +2

      @@RossoAegis-oj7om 还行吧。卡通片科普外国人,已经很复杂了。

  • @patricialeites2129
    @patricialeites2129 2 месяца назад

    Me harías un vídeo de la historia de la Dinastía Sui por favor ???🙏🙏🙏

  • @__shunn
    @__shunn 3 месяца назад +2

    Countries in close proximity to each other has been squabble over territory, origins, culture, character, etc...
    Each country will say that its neighbors are the worst.

    • @user-zo5yb9bv5s
      @user-zo5yb9bv5s 13 дней назад +1

      하지만 중국을 좋아하는 나라는 단 한개도없다

    • @user-xb1ug5kt3h
      @user-xb1ug5kt3h 8 дней назад

      @@user-zo5yb9bv5s喜不喜欢我都是你爸爸,尽管你不承认

    • @user-zo5yb9bv5s
      @user-zo5yb9bv5s 8 дней назад

      @@user-xb1ug5kt3h 응 머라는지 하나도 이해못했엉 영어로써

    • @Xkaala_07X
      @Xkaala_07X 2 дня назад

      @@user-zo5yb9bv5s

  • @cqjstm7332
    @cqjstm7332 Месяц назад +3

    This video is a distorted video that knows nothing about the previous history of the Korean Peninsula.

  • @user-cu9jz6qs1r
    @user-cu9jz6qs1r 3 месяца назад +97

    It's a video with countless errors

    • @akaneqi_2009
      @akaneqi_2009 3 месяца назад +5

      大致吧Roughly

    • @f35alightning
      @f35alightning 3 месяца назад +16

      lots of errors about Korea

    • @user-qb6pl3le9k
      @user-qb6pl3le9k 3 месяца назад

      别再宣扬你们韩国的假历史了,全世界都知道你们喜欢制造假历史。

    • @jchen4365
      @jchen4365 3 месяца назад +10

      maybe if you know Chinese and read the history book before Korea character was made and wrote by CHINESE, you will find what you learn now is wrong

    • @user-nz2rn6ku2f
      @user-nz2rn6ku2f 3 месяца назад +2

      相对的,对比历史专业的人,可能很多错误。对比普通人,还是有很多学习的。

  • @Garettteh
    @Garettteh 2 месяца назад

    @1:36 Sequence is wrong. Chu was 2nd last to be destroyed by Qin.

  • @svart3917
    @svart3917 3 месяца назад +2

    What's the first theme please?

    • @em_658
      @em_658 2 месяца назад

      茉莉花

  • @user-fu4ig5dz8q
    @user-fu4ig5dz8q 3 месяца назад +4

    ❤优秀的动画,下载了。不知道B站有没有类似的波兰球古代历史动画。

    • @user-qr7ql3cz1t
      @user-qr7ql3cz1t 3 месяца назад +2

      笑死,B站能转这视频我直播倒立吃SHIT

    • @rongrong-ki3yi
      @rongrong-ki3yi 3 месяца назад

      ​@@user-qr7ql3cz1t把臺灣上面的改成五星紅球就可以了😂😂

    • @user-qr7ql3cz1t
      @user-qr7ql3cz1t 3 месяца назад

      还有雪山狮子旗和东突呢😝@@rongrong-ki3yi

    • @user-jn3ho2bf6g
      @user-jn3ho2bf6g 3 месяца назад

      這中共ㄧ定不給人知道
      這中國地方有5000年歷史
      但中共沒有
      中華民國還存在
      人民其實可以選擇
      中共給人民欺騙
      不讓他們思考選擇

    • @user-qt6qd7oi9s
      @user-qt6qd7oi9s 3 месяца назад +1

      破案了,真转载了,但是大清之后的就没了

  • @user-ie9lm4lp4k
    @user-ie9lm4lp4k 3 месяца назад +17

    From a long time ago, most of the world's population was in China. China's civil war history, almost half of EQUIV.'s civil war history.

    • @ritedw
      @ritedw 2 месяца назад

      还有一部分在印度

    • @Jacky-so2gm
      @Jacky-so2gm Месяц назад +1

      @@ritedw 最早的时候两河流域和埃及也很多人口

    • @J.Wolf90
      @J.Wolf90 Месяц назад

      India has always been heavily populated too. I wonder how humanity grew so quickly in that area in such early human infancy..

  • @SherlockSherry
    @SherlockSherry 2 месяца назад +10

    As a teenager from China, I am delighted to see this video.Hope people all over the world get a better understanding of China.But I still need to note that there are some small mistakes in the video.Advise finding books to read if you want to learn more.😊😊😊

    • @yty1941
      @yty1941 2 месяца назад

      As a young adult from China, this video delights me.Hopefully people all over the world who watched this video would get a better understanding of China. However, I should still note that minor mistakes were made in the video. I advise reading some books if you want to learn more about Chinese history.😊😊😊

  • @user-le7yt6xj8y
    @user-le7yt6xj8y 3 месяца назад +58

    16:19 北朝鮮だけマスクをつけていない😂

    • @zjt110
      @zjt110 3 месяца назад +2

      是这样的😅

    • @peisi-bv9yd
      @peisi-bv9yd 3 месяца назад +9

      因为朝鲜发现一例,直接枪毙了😅

    • @IleneMcvicker
      @IleneMcvicker 3 месяца назад +3

      会被枪毙的 哈哈哈哈哈哈哈

    • @Weeping-Angel
      @Weeping-Angel 2 месяца назад +1

      lol I didn’t even realize it 😂

    • @36661
      @36661 2 месяца назад

      太细节了

  • @LeAOWAviation
    @LeAOWAviation 3 месяца назад +2

    Nepal: *fought ww2 and had a civil war in 1996*
    Bhutan: *Had an operation called Operation All Clear in 2003*
    You forgot the 2 landlocked nations as they also had wars and operations

    • @CatfoodChronicles6737
      @CatfoodChronicles6737 3 месяца назад

      Give him a chill pill I highly doubt that he thought about those two countries and they are South Asia after all

    • @candyneige6609
      @candyneige6609 3 месяца назад +1

      And also the recent invasion (or "special military operation") of Taiwan by China.

  • @quackcake91651
    @quackcake91651 2 месяца назад +1

    0:01 who made that music? Could you please give credit to who ever made it cause I wanna find the original

    • @liudi3047
      @liudi3047 2 месяца назад

      好一朵美丽的茉莉花

  • @pu3nurmaisara127
    @pu3nurmaisara127 3 месяца назад +45

    Im in malaysia,love china from malaysia.🇨🇳❤🇲🇾

    • @1june204
      @1june204 3 месяца назад +3

      🇨🇳❤️🇲🇾

    • @tianlingchen5523
      @tianlingchen5523 3 месяца назад +1

      馬來華人朋友你好

    • @daniel-mf4sb
      @daniel-mf4sb День назад

      I,m indonesian love china🇨🇳🇲🇨 friend🤝

  • @fdgfgb6918
    @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +11

    15:13 ค.ศ.1945-ค.ศ.1949 สงครามกลางเมืองจีน จีน กับ พรรคคอมมิวนิสต์แห่งประเทศจีน

    • @user-vw3lv2hk5d
      @user-vw3lv2hk5d 3 месяца назад

      内战是对的,但你说的内战双方是中国和中国共产党这是错误的,

    • @123-dt8ef
      @123-dt8ef 3 месяца назад

      ​@@user-vw3lv2hk5d应该是机翻,翻译有问题

  • @felixcruis
    @felixcruis 13 дней назад +2

    你没有画汉朝的西域部分o(╥﹏╥)o

  • @user-zt8iz8om1s
    @user-zt8iz8om1s 3 месяца назад +9

    As we all know,China had already ruled Guangdong during the Qin Dynasty. During the Han Dynasty, the Han army actually controlled Sichuan, Guizhou, Guangdong, Guangxi and now Xinjiang. This video has obvious Europeanism. Why can Europe and America regard the colonies as their own territory, and China cannot regard the areas where they set up ruling departments as their own territory?

    • @commentorsilensor3734
      @commentorsilensor3734 3 месяца назад +1

      Han did not really control XinJiang. Those countries were not even colonies. Those countries did not even have one country two systems. They had their own systems.
      So long they didn't declare emperors n paid their tributes, they had their own autonomy. Japan created a puppet regime in Manchukuo. Japan had more to say about Manchukuo. Japan did plan to annex Manchuria. Since Japan never officially annexed Manchukuo, Japan never officially claimed Manchuria. Those Xinjiang kingdoms had more autonomy than Manchuria, if Manchuria was not part of Japan, so were Xinjiang were not part of Han or Tang

    • @ezj1694
      @ezj1694 3 месяца назад

      Fucking Chinazi
      One China = One Germania
      Do you think France is Germany's history and lost territory?

    • @user-es8yf8tr8b
      @user-es8yf8tr8b 3 месяца назад +2

      @@commentorsilensor3734典型的欧洲历史傲慢

    • @commentorsilensor3734
      @commentorsilensor3734 3 месяца назад

      @@user-es8yf8tr8b typical Chinese arrogance without perfect logic.

    • @user-rl3et3go6s
      @user-rl3et3go6s 3 месяца назад

      @@commentorsilensor3734 日本犬🤣

  • @andrewyuyoungearn2799
    @andrewyuyoungearn2799 2 месяца назад +5

    My favourite dynasties of all time are The Ming, The Traditional Version of The Qing Dynasty aka The Qing Dynasty, and The Modern Version of The Qing Dynasty aka The Republic of China 🇹🇼. I am a Malaysian Chinese who was born on 8th December 1997 in Brunei 🇧🇳. I am a Pentecostal and Charismatic Christian

  • @tj7543
    @tj7543 21 день назад

    what is the name of the first song? may i ask. can not find it on the internet

  • @user-yo5sv9tz3l
    @user-yo5sv9tz3l Месяц назад

    感谢你们这么了解中国历史❤

  • @aligarh6351
    @aligarh6351 3 месяца назад +50

    Я из России и я очень люблю Китай :)🇷🇺❤️🇨🇳

    • @aligarh6351
      @aligarh6351 3 месяца назад +7

      Это не важно! Главное что мне нравится Китай.

    • @GamerzC0rner
      @GamerzC0rner 3 месяца назад +4

      Yeah me too 😊❤

    • @berekebg7168
      @berekebg7168 3 месяца назад +1

      Дай Сибирь Китаю

    • @coverlun9369
      @coverlun9369 3 месяца назад +8

      ​@@berekebg7168历史上,中国没有占领过西伯利亚

    • @robovano_gaming
      @robovano_gaming 3 месяца назад

      @@berekebg7168are u drunn

  • @TehCapcutSpartaRemixer
    @TehCapcutSpartaRemixer 3 месяца назад +6

    Here is a tip: Japanese empire actually fought against mongolia. At the very border of dornod and half of inner mongolia

    • @tianlingchen5523
      @tianlingchen5523 3 месяца назад +3

      On the contrary, the Japanese army did military operations against Mongolia and the Soviet Union, that is, the Battle of Nomenham, but the Japanese failed.

    • @lei3324
      @lei3324 3 месяца назад

      ​@@tianlingchen5523确实,当时苏联的坦克比较厉害

    • @Jacky-so2gm
      @Jacky-so2gm Месяц назад +1

      @@tianlingchen5523 When Yuan beat Song they forced Song's people to build war ships to atk Japan, but the ships sucked.

    • @tianlingchen5523
      @tianlingchen5523 Месяц назад

      @@Jacky-so2gm This is the origin of Kamikaze Special Forces in Baga kingdom.

    • @hellosurvivor97
      @hellosurvivor97 Месяц назад

      sunken

  • @user-dj8cy1jc7o
    @user-dj8cy1jc7o 19 дней назад +1

    The Tang Dynasty was the strongest country in the world at that time, with unparalleled military power.

  • @lifetellermr.5240
    @lifetellermr.5240 3 месяца назад +29

    This video contains serious errors.
    First of all, Manchuria, which was historically a puppet state of the Japanese Empire, was portrayed as an independent country, and Joseon, which historically only cooperated with the world order led by the Qing Dynasty (such as the East Asian United Nations), was portrayed as a vassal state.
    Next, Goryeo, which was expressed as being occupied by the Mongols, suffered from considerable interference and influence for about a hundred years, but maintained an independent sovereignty and army, and only pledged loyalty to the Mongols. Mongolia actually completely pulverized and occupied more than one country, but Goryeo maintained its independence, which was the reward for resisting and holding out for decades. In that respect, it is a clear error to portray Goryeo as if Mongolia had completely occupied it.
    The increasing number of media portraying Goryeo and Joseon as if they were colonies through incorrect information is the result of China and Japan's intentional distortion of history. China and Japan claim that the Korean Peninsula belongs to them for their own interests.
    However, although China has exercised influence for a considerable period of time, it has never actually occupied the entire Korean Peninsula and only briefly occupied parts of it for several decades. Just as the fact that the United States exerts global influence today does not mean that the entire world is a vassal state of the United States, the fact that East Asia at the time adapted to China's influence does not mean that it was a vassal state.
    Japan actually completely occupied the Korean Peninsula for 35 years, so its situation is actually better than China. (Of course, the terrible colonial rule and war crimes also better) Other than that, they only invaded a few times but never occupied the Korean Peninsula or had the same level of influence as China.
    In conclusion, as shown in the this video, if the Korean Peninsula had been occupied by another country for hundreds of years, it would be impossible for the Korean Peninsula to have complete linguistic and cultural independence as it exists today. Japan, which is less influenced by China than Korea, also uses more Chinese characters than Korea. However, Korean is linguistically treated as an isolated language, and Hangul is an independent language used only on the Korean Peninsula. Korean culture is also clearly distinct from China or Japan, except for the level of homogeneity shared by all East Asian countries. This is the result of strong independence and diplomatic negotiations that, with the exception of the Japanese Empire, have not been occupied even though they lost the war.
    I hope that when dealing with the Korean Peninsula, these historical facts will be based.

    • @LouisZy
      @LouisZy 3 месяца назад +15

      Your logic has too many loopholes, you should think about whether your government is teaching you real history,
      Having administrative power does not mean cultural and sovereign independence. You are vassal states and subjects in the tribute system
      Not conquering Korea is not because Korea is very strong, but because you do not pose any threat and are beyond reach, and the land is barren, so there is no need to invest too much
      There are also military factors, just like North Korea is just a military buffer zone now
      You are just chess pieces between great powers, you need to see your own historical status clearly
      As for cultural independence, it's like a joke. In ancient Korea, calendar etiquette and clothing followed China. It was not until the Ming Dynasty that Korean characters imitated the structure of Chinese characters and created block shaped phonetic characters to be used in conjunction with Chinese characters. It was not until 1948 that the policy of abolishing Chinese characters began.
      Using fake history to showcase your so-called national independence everywhere will only make you look like a clown
      Remember, the survival of your small country on the peninsula is not due to your strength, but precisely because your weakness does not constitute a threat to the great power and has value for utilization

    • @moony7144
      @moony7144 3 месяца назад +7

      Korea historically was vassal-tributary state of Great China. Yeah, currently only half of Korea is still Chinese vassal (northern part), when southern part is american vassal.
      There is nothing shameful, it is your history. Small and weak countries always are subjects of big and strong ones.

    • @nonename855
      @nonename855 3 месяца назад +5

      대댓글에 개소리가 2개 정도 있네

    • @Quasi-Zenith_Satellite_System
      @Quasi-Zenith_Satellite_System 3 месяца назад +1

      辛辣で草
      自国に誇りを持つのはええことやろ笑

    • @KnightWar8
      @KnightWar8 3 месяца назад +3

      지우지마라 동북공정 헛소리 댓글이나 지워라

  • @_stree2590
    @_stree2590 3 месяца назад +17

    You omitted half of the history of Chosun.

  • @fdgfgb6918
    @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +4

    3:29 โจโฉล่มสลายและสถาปนาตนเอง เป็น ราชวงค์จี้น ค.ศ.266

    • @fdgfgb6918
      @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +1

      ราชวงค์ที่ 6 ของจีนคือ

    • @fdgfgb6918
      @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +1

      Jin dynasty

  • @Soviet_Stalin
    @Soviet_Stalin Месяц назад

    This guy deserves RESPECT

  • @okayunekomata
    @okayunekomata 3 месяца назад +1

    10:14 徳川と言えば大砲のイメージがある(某ゲームの影響)

  • @MrRiversand
    @MrRiversand 3 месяца назад +7

    This video contains fatal historical distortions. The Great Wall of China does not extend to the Korean Peninsula. It extends only to Jinzhou City, the tip of the Liaodong Peninsula.
    The content of the video above includes the three-year mountain fortress built by Goguryeo, one of the ancient Korean states, in preparation for Chinese invasion due to China's distortion of history.
    Please correct it.

  • @Mjanja
    @Mjanja 3 месяца назад +3

    Why 730AD Japan dead and change his flags?
    There weren’t major political changes or something in Japan at that time

    • @user-tr3sl8jv4e
      @user-tr3sl8jv4e 3 месяца назад +1

      そうですね。というか2600年間ずっと菊の御紋でいいんですけどね。

    • @user-ku2cd1xi1b
      @user-ku2cd1xi1b 2 месяца назад

      この時期に、国号が倭から日本に変わったからだと思う。
      菊の御紋から日の丸に変わるのは、天皇家と豪族による私的な性格を持った連合政権が、古代中央集権国家に変貌したという扱いのつもりかもしれない。変な話だけど。

    • @gunsoviva1633
      @gunsoviva1633 Месяц назад

      ​@@user-tr3sl8jv4e平家が台頭して源氏が鎌倉幕府を起こした以降はなんの力もないただの飾り😂
      厳密には藤原氏の摂関政治が始まった時点で天皇なんてただのアイテムだけど🤣
      力無き権威に価値など無し

  • @jcloud842
    @jcloud842 3 месяца назад

    我觉得这个视频很棒,给你点赞

  • @user-yc3hu3qf9b
    @user-yc3hu3qf9b 3 месяца назад +10

    いい暇つぶしになりました、サッカーアジアカップ韓国VSサウジアラビア観よ🤓

  • @user-bo7nm9po4i
    @user-bo7nm9po4i 3 месяца назад +9

    If Goryeo is a vassal of Yuan,
    why is Joseon a vassal of Qing?

    • @yansgod3209
      @yansgod3209 3 месяца назад +5

      朝鲜不需要在意朝代,他只是跟着中国的统治者以获得庇护

    • @user-bo7nm9po4i
      @user-bo7nm9po4i 3 месяца назад +4

      @@yansgod3209 ㅈㄹㅇㅂ

    • @user-ss9nk1qu4q
      @user-ss9nk1qu4q 3 месяца назад +7

      事大主义
      况且清朝(中国)也继承了汉人王朝的不干涉主义

    • @lei3324
      @lei3324 3 месяца назад

      ​@@user-ss9nk1qu4q否则,朝鲜半岛上的人也要被强制留辫子了

    • @user-es8yf8tr8b
      @user-es8yf8tr8b 3 месяца назад

      朝鲜半岛的国家一直依附中国朝代而生

  • @Oui404
    @Oui404 2 месяца назад

    Obviously our ancestors really love peace🙏

  • @atlas_x150
    @atlas_x150 3 месяца назад +6

    Completely inaccurate, but overall correct

  • @user-hr6gw9xg2b
    @user-hr6gw9xg2b 10 дней назад +14

    Although Korea is not the main theme, I think the situation and map of Korea are a little wrong. In the early north of Korea, the state was Gojoseon. And the territory of Gojoseon was bordered by the Yan Dynasty of China, based on relics and dolmens from the Gojoseon period. Usually, Gojoseon's territory was bordered by the Yan Dynasty to the west and occupied about half of the Korean peninsula to the south. Gojoseon lost the war against the Yan Dynasty and lost the area of Liaodong, but succeeded in recapturing the Liaodong Peninsula again when the Qin Dynasty was destroyed and China was confused. However, before long, Gojoseon was destroyed by the Han Dynasty. And the map from AD268 shows that the Wei Dynasty occupied the northern part of the Korean peninsula, which is not true. The Wei Dynasty actually attacked and controlled the Liaodong Peninsula. That was the same with the Qin Dynasty in AD280. At that time, China didn't enter the northern part of the Korean peninsula. It's just the Liaodong Peninsula. On the AD475 map, Goguryeo, a country north of the Korean peninsula at that time, was in its heyday of expanding its largest territory and marched further north and south to pressure neighboring countries. The Korean peninsula is very strange in the AD562 map The green country in the south of the Korean Peninsula is Gaya. However, the green country on the previous map was originally Silla. Gaya had existed since around AD 200. However, only three countries are displayed on the map, and suddenly a gray country appears on the AD562 map. This may be seen as wrong. Originally, the Silla country in the southeastern gray country of the Korean Peninsula should be a green country. And since the heyday of the Silla country begins and destroys the Gaya country, there should be three countries on the Korean Peninsula instead of four. Also, after the heyday of the Silla Dynasty ended, Goguryeo moved back to the South and reclaimed its existing territory. Before the Tang Dynasty destroyed Goguryeo in AD668, an alliance of Silla and Tang Dynasty destroyed Baekje in 660. However, since it was 738 AD that Baekje disappeared from the map, this is wrong. Munron: While the alliance of Silla and Tang Dynasty attacked Baekje's capital and destroyed Baekje, the map was not wrong because Silla had not yet been able to subjugate all of its territory, it is officially said that Baekje was destroyed in AD660. And in 993, the Khitan (Yo Dynasty) invaded Goryeo, the state on the Korean Peninsula at the time. However, after being defeated in the war with Goryeo and losing its national power, the Yo Dynasty was destroyed by the newly emerged Yeojin people. And in AD1270, the Korean Peninsula was attacked by the Mongolian Empire, but the strange thing about the map is that Goryeo was never occupied by Mongolia or incorporated into its territory. After 50 years of resistance to the Mongol Empire, Goryeo exerted its diplomatic power on the succession to the Mongolian throne, forming a friendship with Mongolia and forming a marriage alliance with the Mongolian imperial family. Mongolia recognized the Goryeo royal family and guaranteed their autonomy, so it can be said that it is a little wrong for Mongolia to conquer Goryeo and mark Goryeo as Mongolia's territory.

  • @royuoko
    @royuoko 2 месяца назад

    We recently went through China in history :)

  • @mohammod.bin.Musa.ibrahim
    @mohammod.bin.Musa.ibrahim 12 дней назад +1

    Love China from Bangladesh 💝💝💝

  • @nirvana4165
    @nirvana4165 3 месяца назад +15

    百済は660年に唐新羅連合軍に滅亡され、旧百済の地で662-663年には大和王権を巻き込む大戦がおこり、668年に高句麗は唐新羅連合軍に滅亡させられました。

    • @lei3324
      @lei3324 3 месяца назад +2

      再后来,唐朝又与新罗交恶,我曾看到过相关的史料是在说,在双方交战期间,唐朝也有来自西部“吐谷浑”的压力,为了避免两线作战,唐朝与新罗在半岛的争夺方面做出了妥协……

    • @lei3324
      @lei3324 3 месяца назад +1

      在下也比较热爱历史,欢迎讨论😂

    • @user-es8yf8tr8b
      @user-es8yf8tr8b 3 месяца назад

      新罗就是韩国

    • @user-es8yf8tr8b
      @user-es8yf8tr8b 3 месяца назад

      @@lei3324唐朝帮新罗灭了高句丽 新罗统一朝鲜半岛!最后新罗全面唐化!所谓的妥协就是让新罗有更多的自主权 其实政治文化全面唐化

    • @iviingivia4158
      @iviingivia4158 3 месяца назад +3

      @@user-es8yf8tr8bit's hard to say though. From my point of view, the Korean peninsula doesn't have a continues history at all.

  • @fdgfgb6918
    @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +18

    5:17 ก่อตั้ง ราชวงค์ถัง ที่รบเก่งที่สุดฤในประวัติศาสตร์ ค.ศ.624

    • @fdgfgb6918
      @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +1

      ราชวงค์ที่ 8 ของจีนคือ

    • @fdgfgb6918
      @fdgfgb6918 3 месяца назад +1

      Tang dynasty

    • @myrrha7417
      @myrrha7417 3 месяца назад

      😂 we Chinese usually think the Mongolians are best soldiers in the ancient, which is Mongolia empire or Yuan dynasty

    • @CyrusZachary
      @CyrusZachary 3 месяца назад

      The Tang Dynasty is considered to be the peak of ancient China.

    • @user-fm2tw6bk8y
      @user-fm2tw6bk8y 3 месяца назад +2

      ​@@myrrha7417那是你认为的,我认为汉朝才是最强