I kind of figured it was a joke or a dare knowing he'd be kicked off anyway....it was too clever and creative to be creepy. Very funny. "I'd Peter Faulk her" was genius
Exactly he cud hav had a weapon or anything i wudnt take mo chances if I was her I wud get up fast as he got closer . .Plus he seemed to b growing larger as he got closer strange🤔
It’s got nothing to do with protection. There were hundreds of security people. She was in no danger. Simon was always on record saying people like this, somehow, ruined the “integrity” of the show. A singing competition which produced very few long lasting talents (Carrie Underwood, most notably). You younger people never saw or clearly forgot what Simon was ACTUALLY like.
I love how Simon just sits there with a straight face. If it was me, I'd be laughing for ages. That song was so disturbing, creepy and weird😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Randy laughing through the whole thing Paula is smiling thrugh the whole thing Simon is thinking wtf is wrong with this dude and having other thought through the whole thing
Still, even if it was a comedic prank, people still shouldn't be joking like that because it's creepy, and it could make people uncomfortable. So, him being a comedian is not an excuse.
I love how we starts singing before Simon even ends his sentance, when he see's her laughing, like he's watching her, and that was queue for him to sing
I find it funny that people fail to see the completely obvious (and somewhat brilliant) humour in this. By far the best thing to ever be shown on that show.
Lol, this is HILARIOUS! It's extremely creepy but when I was watching this 2 nights ago I was laughing SO DAMN HARD! This guy is probably just a comedian... not serious, but either way... HILARIOUS!
Randy’s reaction makes this so enjoyable. The fact he was cracking up is contagious. The guy knew he wasn’t getting on TV so he took a chance to make people laugh. I appreciate that more than most singers who were on here.
Finally someone said something! I was like why the hell are they letting him continue? I didn't think his song was funny at all and why the hell were they laughing? Not everything is funny. Maybe now after what happened to that girl Paula... American Idol will screen people better not just pass every freak through for a boost in ratings. Paula is such a sweet person cuz I would not have been nice to him at all.
I know I’m late but yeah and this always reminds me of that time the guy song for Britney Spears and he even bought her flowers. And Brittany was such a jerk to him and she was incredibly rude she didn’t even say thank you she just acted disgusted. Paula on the other hand is able to keep her cool and she even thinks the guy even though he talked about sneaking in their house and wearing her underwear😂.
I gotta agree with asionzionson on this one. If it was all a stunt, this is on a level with Borat. It almost seems obvious that it's fake, how else do you come up with stuff like "If I was Columbo, I'd Peter Faulk her/If she was a bathtub, I would caulk her?" Seems too over-the-top creepy to actually be real, But if it is....holy crap.
OMG, I feel soo bad for Paula, that would be soo creepy! he can't even sing! Who would do that? Paula must have been really freaked out. (obviously) It's such a good thing that Simon shut him up!!
They know about these contestants ahead of time, they obviously put him on the show for entertainment value. Randy was laughing the entire time, too. Cut Paul a break.
I'm pretty sure he did it just to be funny. I think Simon's reaction was a little more creepy. He responded like he was saying, "Stop looking at my girl." The other two seemed to find it slightly more humorous then Simon.
the minute he said he would take off his clothes,and put on paula's underwear. That was really crossing the line i'm surprised he wasn't thrown out at that moment.
I don’t know why some people are creeped out. It’s hilarious. It’s all a joke. Real stalkers wouldn’t call themselves stalkers. Real stalkers don’t know that what they’re doing is wrong.
that's so flipping CREEEEEEEPY!!!! If I were Paula I'd...I don't know what I'd do, but I'd be VERY afraid. It's pretty hilarious to watch again though.
You can tell the judges are genuinely scared as they constantly glance at the producers/bodyguards on the side probably wondering if they're going to need security lol. Fortunately and Unfortunately, the guy's a scripted comedian/actor.
The dude is getting closer and Simons like: whoa! Whoa! Whoa! Lol his face was gradually getting dArker throughout that song. Jelous much Simon? Poor Paula lol atthe end she was like hyperventilating.
Paul: "I broke into her house..."
Randy: "Huh?"
😂😂😂
Alyson J. I love Randy's little huhs
I love that was his reaction and not "What the fuck?"
That sounds like me and I'll stalk people
BEST PART
Oh . . . My . . . . . . .Goodness!!!!
Randy's reactions are underrated
No, he's practically used as a Facebook react emogi.
“Paul have you been drinking?” is my favorite lol
Can you rat kids stop with that stupid UNDERRATED comment in every fuckin video? Get your own brain for fuck sake, braindead sheeps
They are 😂
Sh your ruining the moment Simon 😂😂😂
COCK BLOCK 100.
I need blood
You're
I think he should have ended this going...
"To bad I'm gay, but instead I'll go with the English man to the right!"
🤭
What are you doing here?
I love u
Shut up Charles
"I broke into her house, when she wasn't theeeeeerre"WTF!!😂😂😂😂
“Took off all my clothes and tried on her underwear” 😂😂😂😂😂 and Randy’s like WWUUUUTTT
“If I were calambo I will Peter fuck her.” 😂😂😂
0:47 Simons face gave me LIFE.
"Paul have you been drinking?" omfg haha
Paul: "I BROKE INTO HER HOUSE"
Randy: "😮 Huh!!?!"
Randy's reactions are so relatable 😂😂😂
LMFAO this guy is hilarious but Simon getting protective is really cute
This was very clever.Btw this guy isn't a stalker,he's actually a comedian who did this as a joke.
he can be both a stalker and comedian at the same time
It certainly comes natural to him.
Most of the crazy people are comedians who do it for ratings. It's still funny though.
Pretty clear lol
I kind of figured it was a joke or a dare knowing he'd be kicked off anyway....it was too clever and creative to be creepy. Very funny. "I'd Peter Faulk her" was genius
That's so freaking creepy omg when he got closer and went up to the table i was honestly scared that he would grab at her
Exactly he cud hav had a weapon or anything i wudnt take mo chances if I was her I wud get up fast as he got closer . .Plus he seemed to b growing larger as he got closer strange🤔
The contestants go through like 3 auditions, This is clearly a bit lol
@@majesticallymade6177 you just gave me a stroke
I agree but I died laughing he said “if she were bathtub….(pause) I WOULD CALK HER 😂” literally I just died laughing hysterical
This guy is a clever comedic performer. He got exposure and didn't sing anything truly offensive. It's also cool that Paula was such a good sport.
Yeah, Britney would have been just there staring at him
she was a "good sport" because she was fucking terrified.
The whole Brittany thing was different. That guy was really creepy for real. This guy was a comedian and Paula knew it.
He said I'd fuck her.
@@anitadiaz733 he did?
Simon actually got pissed off lol
Your ruining the moment Simon 😂😂😂😂
COCK BLOCK 100.
You're
@@Neo2266.stfu
@@DivineAdmire lol no, dipshit
@@DivineAdmirewhat's wrong with having half decent grammar
oh how cute simon was scared for paula
Simon: PAUL! PAUL! PAUL!
Paul: shhhhhh you're ruining the moment Simon
lol one of the funniest vid on youtube
I heart how protective Simon was of Paula. He was not laughing from the beginning. He was creepy.
It’s got nothing to do with protection. There were hundreds of security people. She was in no danger.
Simon was always on record saying people like this, somehow, ruined the “integrity” of the show.
A singing competition which produced very few long lasting talents (Carrie Underwood, most notably).
You younger people never saw or clearly forgot what Simon was ACTUALLY like.
You can tell it's a joke when he tells Simon that he's ruining the moment. It made me laugh insanely hard the first time I saw it.
I love this guy seriously in tears from laughter omg...omg
Even after all of these years, this never fails to kill me LMFAO
The look on simon's face was priceless
Simon cracks me up "Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul, Paul" Lmao! 😂😂😂
"Ssshh simon ur ruining the moment!!" I see no connection. That poor lady is hiding 😂😂👋
Yes
This guy is a great comedian.
Omg hi Charles I Watch ur vids
He actually has a nice voice.
He’s not that bad.
99% of American Idol viewers had no idea what the Peter Faulk line meant.
He was the guy with the glass eye on Colombo, make that 98%.
+5burowz can you tell me what that means?
smallie210 Peter Faulk played Colombo, a detective show your grandmother probably watched.
+Purple Jamz yes I know he played Colombo but what does he mean by saying he would "Peter Falk her"?
smallie210 Peter is slang for Penis and Falk sounds like fuck.
I love how Simon just sits there with a straight face. If it was me, I'd be laughing for ages. That song was so disturbing, creepy and weird😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Paula is flattered. Even Randy gets the humor of the song. Simon, way too serious. XD
This is so hilarious it made me cry from laughter
Lmao I love Simon, he was pissed..he was all trying to push Paula away from the guy when he got closer lol
Randy laughing through the whole thing
Paula is smiling thrugh the whole thing
Simon is thinking wtf is wrong with this dude and having other thought through the whole thing
Wow he actually sounds pretty good! He is a good singer.
This guy is actually a comedian; this song is a prank. :-p
Still, even if it was a comedic prank, people still shouldn't be joking like that because it's creepy, and it could make people uncomfortable. So, him being a comedian is not an excuse.
Singing was good. Poetry was GREAT. I'd pay to hear more from this guy.
I love how people are taking this guy seriously. It's an incredibly awesome but obvious prank.
Randy's reactions throughout the whole song had me dyyyiiing oh my goshhhh hahahaha. XD
Simon: “Have you really had any-“
Paul: *Cuts him off and starts his creepy song*
😂
I love randys reaction to this he was just laughing the whole time lol :) I miss him
I'd love to see this done on Simon.
Yes lol
Yess lol
Hats off to Paula, she handled that so well, and with a sense of humour! :)
I love how we starts singing before Simon even ends his sentance, when he see's her laughing, like he's watching her, and that was queue for him to sing
0:17 Look at his face 😂😂
Its Rebekah lmaoooooo
Creepy lol
ewwww
I find it funny that people fail to see the completely obvious (and somewhat brilliant) humour in this.
By far the best thing to ever be shown on that show.
Lol, this is HILARIOUS! It's extremely creepy but when I was watching this 2 nights ago I was laughing SO DAMN HARD!
This guy is probably just a comedian... not serious, but either way... HILARIOUS!
this cracks me up every time haha
Awe!Simon is very protective I think!❤️😍Saula
Ashley Cariño same here
Imagine if he sang that nowadays… he’d get cancelled. Also he’s actually not a bad singer, he just chose a wrong approach
Obviously if this guy wasn't a comedian doing a bit, they would never have put this on tv.
it was clearly a bit. People nowadays can't really take a joke huh. smh
I laughing so hard whem I saw this video “I broke into her house when she wasn't there" lmfao
Randy’s reaction makes this so enjoyable. The fact he was cracking up is contagious.
The guy knew he wasn’t getting on TV so he took a chance to make people laugh. I appreciate that more than most singers who were on here.
Finally someone said something! I was like why the hell are they letting him continue? I didn't think his song was funny at all and why the hell were they laughing? Not everything is funny. Maybe now after what happened to that girl Paula... American Idol will screen people better not just pass every freak through for a boost in ratings. Paula is such a sweet person cuz I would not have been nice to him at all.
paula is so nice, she's like thank you so much....and it's so adorable how simon is so protective of her, someone's jealous!!
I know I’m late but yeah and this always reminds me of that time the guy song for Britney Spears and he even bought her flowers. And Brittany was such a jerk to him and she was incredibly rude she didn’t even say thank you she just acted disgusted. Paula on the other hand is able to keep her cool and she even thinks the guy even though he talked about sneaking in their house and wearing her underwear😂.
I gotta agree with asionzionson on this one. If it was all a stunt, this is on a level with Borat. It almost seems obvious that it's fake, how else do you come up with stuff like "If I was Columbo, I'd Peter Faulk her/If she was a bathtub, I would caulk her?"
Seems too over-the-top creepy to actually be real, But if it is....holy crap.
He started in mid-questioning xD he prolly only heard the voices in his head
he is so creepy.........they should have arrested him whether he was acting or not.ugh he gives me the creeps
I actually think this was a joke
theheadlessguitarist yup the guys an online comedian
It was. He's a comedian and has his own website.
Yeah I mean he was 32 years old,too old for the competition anyway.
SITHMAN how is that too old for competition haha. You serious??? Paul Potts, Susan Boyle etc.
It wasn't funny. Especially when she had to deal with a stalker who killed himself in front of her home.
OMG, I feel soo bad for Paula, that would be soo creepy! he can't even sing! Who would do that? Paula must have been really freaked out. (obviously) It's such a good thing that Simon shut him up!!
I feel like he lost a bet with middle school boys and the middle school boys wrote the lyrics.
hahahahah that was so creeeeeeepy!! but i couldnt help but laugh when he said "If she was a bathtub, I would caulk her."
They know about these contestants ahead of time, they obviously put him on the show for entertainment value. Randy was laughing the entire time, too. Cut Paul a break.
that guy wasnt creepy, he was only acting...
look at his face at the end of it, he's all smiling and looking like a normal guy.
omg its shocking they didn't call security....lol. Paula is so brave she kept smiling rofl
He should've sang "The More you Ignore me, the Closer I Get" from Morrisey! >:}
Omg Simon was so protective. Miss saula :;
I'm pretty sure he did it just to be funny.
I think Simon's reaction was a little more creepy. He responded like he was saying, "Stop looking at my girl." The other two seemed to find it slightly more humorous then Simon.
the minute he said he would take off his clothes,and put on paula's underwear. That was really crossing the line i'm surprised he wasn't thrown out at that moment.
One thing I did discover about Paul Marhurano he is an excellent Songwriter and Singer,you will be pleasantly surprised.
this brings tears to me eyes every single time :')
Paula looked like she was put in front of the blockhead effect of a Mac computer
This is so funny but if I were her I would be so uncomfortable whilst still laughing 😂
"If I were Columbo, I'd Peter Falk her!"
That's it, I'm dead! lol
She was a little bit hyperventilating at the end, but she was trying to brush it off and stay composed, so she pretended to be laughing.
LOL!!
Paul: I broke into her house..."
Randy: HUH!???
Oh my God... there are no words to describe how creepy this is.....
loool i love randys little noises and when he keeps goin huh
Brilliantly funny.
I knew he looked familiar, like I saw him on Premium Blend or something.
pause at 1:41 for a surprise
how'd you catch that haha glitch
LMFAO
creeped me out so much that i couldn't fall asleep until i looked out of my window for 30 minutes i did this for 5 days...
I don’t know why some people are creeped out. It’s hilarious. It’s all a joke. Real stalkers wouldn’t call themselves stalkers. Real stalkers don’t know that what they’re doing is wrong.
LOL
"if she were a bathtub i would caulk her"
what a creepy man...
I've never felt so sorry for someone in my life
The Peter Falk line was pretty funny though.
I love simon cowell for being protective to paula oh shit😂kinikilig ako..SIMON LOVE'S PAULA VERY MUCH☺SAULA FOREVER
ItsMe Jashlie same same 😍😘😂😅
that's so flipping CREEEEEEEPY!!!! If I were Paula I'd...I don't know what I'd do, but I'd be VERY afraid. It's pretty hilarious to watch again though.
simon was so ready to knock the shit out of him
Ilike to she that happen lol
"shhhh your ruining the moment simon" omg lol
No stalker would act like this. Obvious comedic genius.
"your ruining the moment simon"
You can tell the judges are genuinely scared as they constantly glance at the producers/bodyguards on the side probably wondering if they're going to need security lol. Fortunately and Unfortunately, the guy's a scripted comedian/actor.
that guy has a sense of humor
The dude is getting closer and Simons like: whoa! Whoa! Whoa! Lol his face was gradually getting dArker throughout that song. Jelous much Simon? Poor Paula lol atthe end she was like hyperventilating.
Did Paula say he was "scarinading" her? She was right. Scary as hell.
i think Simon was jealous. lol
" If I was Columbo,
I'd Peter Falk her"
LOL! This is great!
@mydaddyatemyeyes
We'll agree to disagree on this one. Certain jokes can go too far.
ROFLMAO @ CAULKING HER!
that is the NASSTIEST line ever,
but i died when i heard it!
HAHAHAHA.
paul have you been drinking😂😂😂
LMAO randy's liek HUH? like ten times. priceless audition