‪@jacobcollier‬

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
  • Shot in Jussieu, Paris, July 2022
    Directed by Hugo Jouxtel
    Sound direction by Alban Lejeune & Oscar Ferran
    Assisted by Nicolas Defeudis
    Produced by Christophe 'Chryde' Abric and Anousonne Savanchomkeo
    Coordination by Caroline Fauvel
    Production assistants: Elsa Benichou & Simon Delange
    Production administration: Tatiana Fouque & Mia El Rakka
    Post-production: Axel Verbruggen, Audry Elisa Duparc & Eloïse Therond
    Voice & guitar: Jacob Collier
    Voice: Alita Moses
    Melodica & backing vocals: Bryn Bliska
    Guitar & backing vocals: Emily Elbert
    Management: Fran Haincourt & Michael Peha
    Label Managers: Charlotte Kindred & Katie Watts
    Thanks to Le Nouvel Institut
    Stream 'Never Gonna Be Alone' by ‪@jacobcollier‬ feat ‪@LizzyMcAlpine‬ & ‪@johnmayer‬: jacobcollier.l...
    Follow Jacob:
    www.JacobCollie...
    / jacobcollier
    / jacobcollier
    / jcolliermusic
    / jacobcollier
    / jcolliermusic
    - Want to see more ? Subscribe :
    bit.ly/SubBlogo
    - Follow La Blogothèque :
    blogotheque.net
    / blogotheque
    / blogotheque
    / blogotheque
    - Stay a while :
    Take Away Show, the Very Best : bit.ly/TASBest
    Take Away Show 2021 : bit.ly/TakeAwayShow2021
    Take Away Show 2020 : bit.ly/BlogoReprise
    Reprise : bit.ly/BlogoReprise
    Pocket Parties : bit.ly/PocketParties
    For more than ten years, La Blogotheque has changed the way people experience music videos. We film beautiful, rare and intimate sessions with your favorite artists, and the ones you are soon to fall in love with. Come, stay a while, and be taken away.

Комментарии • 346

  • @jacobcollier
    @jacobcollier 2 года назад +1423

    This was a dream come true!!! Thank you so much for having me :)

    • @maximepotier
      @maximepotier 2 года назад +6

      Thank you for your show at Olympia. The dream come true

    • @juliencarnevale2712
      @juliencarnevale2712 2 года назад +9

      This was incredible, as always! Those harmonies.. such a vibe :)

    • @maximepotier
      @maximepotier 2 года назад +4

      @@juliencarnevale2712 can’t wait next tour/dates

    • @uckaIlolo
      @uckaIlolo 2 года назад +5

      Of course !! You had to be in la Blogothèque !! :))) Thank you for the present you are to music .

    • @iconnoclass5342
      @iconnoclass5342 2 года назад +6

      《 💙 》So very special to hear this treasure trove of a new gem in this setting and those harmonies! Thank you Jacob. Hope your Birthday was the happiest!! 🎶🎁✨ Xx

  • @MrKA129
    @MrKA129 2 года назад +144

    That capo slide at 3:13 was toooo smooth

  • @marnessteyn5659
    @marnessteyn5659 Год назад +47

    HE MOVED THE DAMN CAPO WITHOUT MISSING HALF A BEAT!! SORCERER!!!

  • @leoporto
    @leoporto 2 года назад +95

    That modulation at 3:10 took me with my guard down. Instantaneous tears.

    • @nmamano
      @nmamano 2 года назад +19

      Jacob sneakily slides the capo up one fret

    • @Issamtheboss
      @Issamtheboss Год назад +1

      But the transition though... I’m still trying to get the good chords out of it !!

    • @gwgwgwgw1854
      @gwgwgwgw1854 Год назад

      Mtoo too, tears!

    • @daveydeboer2542
      @daveydeboer2542 Год назад +3

      @@Issamtheboss Im assuming its the same capo change on the album version as he is doing here. Theres this story about one of Chet Atkins song where he transposes in the solo and for years no one could transcribe how he played the notes until he revealed he secretly switched guitars (another tuning) during the solo. Sometimes even the greatest artist will take the easy road because why not. :)

  • @planetgrazia
    @planetgrazia 2 года назад +54

    This was so relaxing and fresh to listen to! Love this channel! Wish I could´ve heard Alita Moses´ harmony at 3:25 even more because it was so ridicolously beautiful! So talented!

  • @MB-ib9zv
    @MB-ib9zv 2 года назад +121

    I love how different this version feels compared to original! But I still love it just as much! :) This feels less sombre, but you can still feel how much love is between the two singing..
    It's amazing how he makes the same songs feel so different for every version. I love it!

    • @SimonJefferis
      @SimonJefferis 2 года назад +3

      The sign of a truly good song, strip it back and it's still beautiful

  • @Merlincat007
    @Merlincat007 2 года назад +313

    Jacob Collier has a tendency toward overproduction and spectacle so it's nice to hear him in a very simple band setting! He's obviously amazingly talented, and so is the rest of the band :)

    • @skinblanketed
      @skinblanketed 2 года назад +48

      This is the biggest barrier for me getting into his studio recordings. I'm so glad there are recordings like this and the Tiny Desk sets to put his raw brilliance on display. Can't wait to hear how his sound and approach progresses as he ages.

    • @keithklassen5320
      @keithklassen5320 2 года назад +59

      His maximalism is a big part of his appeal for many of us, but this is lovely.

    • @WalterKimaro
      @WalterKimaro 2 года назад +29

      @@keithklassen5320 Exactly, going overboard and pushing vocal and instrumental harmonic edges and then taming it all to create a beautiful sound takes a lot of skill, a keen ear and perfectionism of the highest order.

    • @MB-ib9zv
      @MB-ib9zv 2 года назад +15

      I think what's great is he can both do simple performances and over produced performances and versions so beautifully, in my opinion. It's a bonus that every version feels so different the other.. :)

    • @kaisersozen
      @kaisersozen 2 года назад +22

      He puts out a lot of intimate, stripped down performances… I think he intentionally explores boundaries with studio recordings and saves the acoustic versions for shows like this

  • @em-zr8bi
    @em-zr8bi 2 года назад +54

    This version seriously needs to be on streaming services!! 😍

  • @JXter_
    @JXter_ 2 года назад +44

    The camera perspective and minimalist production pulls you right in to this flea market in Paris, it feels as if I'm actually right there living in the beauty of this song. It's a reminder of where we come from, what music is truly meant to be. This is easily one of Jacob's best works yet, showcasing exactly who he is and what he's about - he lives and breathes music, and is a beacon of shining light in dark times. Jacob, thank you for the positivity and excellence you bring to the world, you truly are a genius and an inspiration to us all.
    edit: I have watched this probably over 30 times in the past two days and I have to add, both women at the beginning and end are integral to the warm and welcoming vibes this video has. Their down-to-earth spirits are rare qualities these days.

    • @SolarMumuns
      @SolarMumuns 2 года назад +2

      Well said - I share those sentiments

    • @DanLiveOnUTube
      @DanLiveOnUTube 5 месяцев назад

      minimalist production involves extensive planning and lav placement and post. But yes. This IS the new standard of a live performance.

  • @lincolnrossmusic
    @lincolnrossmusic 2 года назад +44

    Jacob, Alita, Bryn & Emily ... you guys sound so good together ... also mad props to Christophe, Anousonne and the whole production crew ... magnificent !!!

  • @chayanka_kaushik
    @chayanka_kaushik 2 года назад +10

    A Grammy award-winning musician singing on the streets and people thinking he's just normal street singers looking for tips along the way 🤣

  • @luxrose7613
    @luxrose7613 2 года назад +29

    I lived in Paris for a year and it felt like a dream. Jacob’s concert and meeting him after, getting a closer glimpse of his quiet kindness still feels so special. This video is such a cozy place for my heart, the memory of Jacob in Paris during that time I was 22, living in my childhood dreams.

  • @acecarlo11
    @acecarlo11 Год назад +19

    Who the heck is this Alita Moses and why is she criminally underrated? Stunning!

    • @misterbadcock
      @misterbadcock 3 месяца назад

      She slays "Box of Stars pt 1" on Jacob's current tour

  • @tdoc
    @tdoc 2 года назад +29

    Blogotheque x Jacob Collier = perfect combination

  • @JAZZTONRODRIGUEZ
    @JAZZTONRODRIGUEZ 2 года назад +14

    don’t know if i’ve ever seen a mid song key/capo change like that before! @3:12

  • @Zimmar
    @Zimmar 2 года назад +33

    Jacob always excells in those minimalistic settings.

  • @JAZZTONRODRIGUEZ
    @JAZZTONRODRIGUEZ 2 года назад +95

    is that a five string guitar?! man Jacob is great.

    • @raphaelbermudes2339
      @raphaelbermudes2339 2 года назад +4

      Yeah it is

    • @SamGoldfarb
      @SamGoldfarb 2 года назад

      I noticed that too! What’s the tuning on that?

    • @absoledge
      @absoledge 2 года назад +1

      @@SamGoldfarb looks like it just doesn't have the high e, eadgb basically

    • @KKoakOOakoAA
      @KKoakOOakoAA 2 года назад +13

      i think he mentioned once that his tuning for his custom 5-string is DAEAD so he can play specifically in 4ths and 5ths

    • @jas_bataille
      @jas_bataille 2 года назад +1

      It's an acoustic 5 string bass guitar, to be exact. His fingers are just otherworldly...!

  • @lelilu1
    @lelilu1 Год назад +17

    Parisians crack me up. So oblivious when being serenaded by greatness. Magical. ❤

    • @anonymous38741
      @anonymous38741 Год назад +5

      the acoustics might have been poor in person

  • @modalmixture
    @modalmixture 2 года назад +29

    Love Jacob’s new band, they sound wonderful in this little quartet arrangement

  • @asoaresjr
    @asoaresjr 2 года назад +6

    And at 2:08 we're reminded that even Jacob Collier is human

  • @TheRollingStone11
    @TheRollingStone11 Год назад +9

    There's a patch of sunlight in my room
    On the carpet where I held you for a moment in June
    There was something so sweet about it, never been so unguarded
    And it made me fall for you
    There's a tree that looks up at the moon
    In the garden, where I held you for a moment in the gloom
    There was something so sweet about it, I'm holding onto this moment
    'Cause it made me fall for you
    Made me fall for you
    Take me back to the window, take me back to the door
    You'll be right where I left you sittin' on the floor
    Now I'm never gonna be alone, mm, mm
    Take me back to the window, take me back to the door
    You'll be right where I left you sittin' on the floor
    Now I'm never gonna be alone
    And I know, I know
    There's so much I want to say to you
    Even though I know
    Nothing's gonna change
    But I'll always find my way back here to you
    Take me back to the window, take me back to the door
    You'll be right where I left you sittin' on the floor
    Now I'm never gonna be alone
    (Never gonna be alone, never gonna be alone, be alone, be alone)
    Take me back to the window, take me back to the door
    You'll be right where I left you sittin' on the floor
    Now I'm never gonna be alone (be alone)
    There's a patch of sunlight in my room
    On the carpet where I held you for a moment

  • @bobm1485
    @bobm1485 Год назад +12

    2:08 Thank God 🙌 Jacob’s also a human 😊

  • @jackquentin1950
    @jackquentin1950 2 года назад +4

    Relay button
    0:41

  • @nerygavarrete
    @nerygavarrete 2 года назад +51

    Is it possible to know how the audio gets recorded? I'm always amazed by the audio quality from these videos. Does anyone have a clue about how the miking works for these videos?

    • @oscar.ferran
      @oscar.ferran 2 года назад +12

      Boom + lavalier microphones
      Like in cinema :)

    • @nerygavarrete
      @nerygavarrete 2 года назад +1

      ​@@oscar.ferran Well, yes i can imagine but what is the placement? That's the trick I would like to see revealed

    • @oscar.ferran
      @oscar.ferran 2 года назад +38

      @@nerygavarrete 2 lavaliers on the vocal (1 cardio and 1 omni), so I can use together in perfect phase, or one of them, I’m doing this choice on each phrase. And an other lavalier in guitar, and on each backing vocal. The combination with the boom does the rest.

    • @nerygavarrete
      @nerygavarrete 2 года назад +8

      @@oscar.ferranthank you! I appreciate you sharing this. That was a hell of a job you guys did!

    • @oscar.ferran
      @oscar.ferran 2 года назад +17

      @@nerygavarrete thanks to you !
      Alban Lejeune who did the recording is an expert for mike placement ! ;)
      It becomes easy for mixing

  • @1971stratocaster
    @1971stratocaster 2 года назад +14

    This is beautiful Jacob bro, Makes me so overwhelmed to see how far you've come since we did music when we were 15 in your room. Love you brother

    • @SolarMumuns
      @SolarMumuns Год назад +1

      Wow, what a privilege to have played music with him! He must have already been amazing then, was he?

  • @derekauth157
    @derekauth157 2 года назад +12

    Outside of the phenomenal live performance in ONE TAKE, this is an honest masterpiece in audio quality & production. Mind blown, guys…

  • @Chewbacca0702
    @Chewbacca0702 2 года назад +7

    It's nice when angels don street clothes and hang out with the mortals for a while

    • @pattyblevins2765
      @pattyblevins2765 3 месяца назад

      There is a Christian man on RUclips - he has a channel and one time after an event they had he asked God if angels had been there? God answered and I remember the number was over 10. He meant in human form. We can entertain angels unawares. There are also the angels we don’t see in their spiritual body. Yeah they can be in a crowd disguised as humans.

  • @countolaf9930
    @countolaf9930 2 года назад +12

    When you put a new pair of socks on, and feel how soft it is, this sounds like that feels; pure bliss

  • @moomatre
    @moomatre 2 года назад +21

    Fantastique comme toujours !
    Merci beaucoup La Blogothèque, Jacob Collier et participants

  • @paulie4450
    @paulie4450 2 года назад +28

    Love how they keep the tiny little mistakes that comes with single takes.
    Makes it more wholesome and beautiful, like a moment captured in time.

  • @daradipatar2655
    @daradipatar2655 2 года назад +15

    The most beautiful composition I've heard in a while ❤️. Oh, the blend of the melodies 🌿

  • @WilsonRidge
    @WilsonRidge 2 года назад +10

    Lovvvvved this. Thank you to Jacob and friends for sharing and to all the audio and visual people who put us in the market there for a second!

  • @cwielander9709
    @cwielander9709 2 года назад +12

    So heartwarming! 🥰

  • @alexanderbe7287
    @alexanderbe7287 2 года назад +6

    Beautiful sound, beautiful rendition! Sittin’ here in my signed, yellow crocs havin’ a good ol’ time watching this over and over!

  • @JordanOverstreet
    @JordanOverstreet 2 года назад +4

    Jacob come back to Denver once you rested and are able!! It was absolutely wonderful to see you live and I would really love to do it again sometime:))

  • @TheGuacamoleXplosion
    @TheGuacamoleXplosion Год назад +2

    Alita

  • @ryanmoore4130
    @ryanmoore4130 6 месяцев назад +3

    how tf did they mic this up??

  • @huburgalula4031
    @huburgalula4031 2 года назад +5

    Im gonna cry

  • @AngeloBrillante
    @AngeloBrillante 2 года назад +3

    This is amazing!!! If the sound engineers read this, could you please tell me how you recorded it? I can't figure it out for the life of me. Where are the mics? How does it sound so good and balanced as the camera moves around and they move around? Do you have it hanging in the middle of them above their heads? What kind of mic is it?

    • @oscar.ferran
      @oscar.ferran Год назад

      Boom + lavalier microphones under their clothes
      Like in cinema :)
      And mixed to match as much as possible with the movie

  • @corey8760
    @corey8760 Год назад +1

    Since several people asked, Jacob's tuning is: DEEAAC#. Capo on 3rd then on 4th at 3:14. You're welcome

  • @전인호-x7j
    @전인호-x7j 2 года назад +2

    Ah……. How this situation could made?! How how this beautiful Scene is made!!!!! Happy happy happppppy coincidence!

  • @chinmoysarma4101
    @chinmoysarma4101 2 года назад +1

    Think bout this ; John Mayer comes to play the solo out of nowhere ; READ THAT AGAIN !

  • @skinblanketed
    @skinblanketed 2 года назад +2

    This song is about a dog and you can't change my mind.

  • @jakecox3107
    @jakecox3107 Год назад +2

    This performance I come back to when I need soothing peaceful vibes. So so wholesome - and we need more of those blowy piano things (melodica I believe the proper name is 😅)

  • @christianefleurant7089
    @christianefleurant7089 2 года назад +4

    Merci Blogothèque. C'est super de les voir chanter "live" en gros plan. De Montréal.

  • @Rafaelfo.
    @Rafaelfo. Год назад +4

    That melodica solo! 2:16

  • @anjarahari2232
    @anjarahari2232 2 года назад +1

    3:25 naaah y'all need to chill...

  • @philippequesnel
    @philippequesnel 2 года назад +3

    oh my ! the purety of this is only equaled by its beauty .. so much beauty in such 'simplicity', thank you very much

  • @veryclaro
    @veryclaro Год назад +2

    This is precious. Can't believe this only has 140k+ views???

  • @matthewwakefield3750
    @matthewwakefield3750 2 года назад +14

    I cannot stop listening to this, I heard it on radio 4 and then needed to hear it again, I actually am not overly fussed for the fully produced version, this has so much more soul acoustically and live! This is soul food!

    • @davidhandelman5131
      @davidhandelman5131 2 года назад +1

      I heard it too on Front Row. A gorgeous song.

    • @Tommy-TwigFan
      @Tommy-TwigFan Год назад +1

      His songs are very overproduced, this is the proof!

  • @alamdaaliartes
    @alamdaaliartes Год назад +2

    3:19 that made me cry. no music ever made me cry... wow

  • @masonroberts3461
    @masonroberts3461 2 года назад +4

    Awesome, love the vibe of this :)

  • @ET-pj6rx
    @ET-pj6rx 2 года назад +1

    waouu, comment la prise de son a été faite ?

  • @JumpydeerbobHD
    @JumpydeerbobHD 2 года назад +2

    The colors and feel of this video are incredible. The first person on looker feel really did a great job of building atmosphere. Fantastic! :)

  • @JorgeLopez-bh7hk
    @JorgeLopez-bh7hk 2 года назад +2

    Those last two chords are simply unbelievable, Thank you Jacob for making me love music every day a little more

  • @JamesRone
    @JamesRone 2 года назад +3

    That melodica solo is absolutely gorgeous. I don't know the first thing about how to do that.

    • @JamesRone
      @JamesRone 2 года назад

      @peter g lol

    • @JamesRone
      @JamesRone Год назад

      Back for another (another) listen. I just realized that she picks up the adlibbed vocal harmony run that was sung moments before as her opening phrase. Wwowowowwowowow.

  • @emilianomarquez1629
    @emilianomarquez1629 2 года назад +1

    Perfect ending, can't belive I'm so early. Merci blogotheque, je les manque !

  • @ShakiraJasmineOfficial
    @ShakiraJasmineOfficial 2 года назад

    Thankyou jacob for making this masterpiece

  • @vigneshs9949
    @vigneshs9949 Год назад +2

    This should have more views. So soothing and calm.🥰

  • @hexalyte
    @hexalyte 2 года назад +2

    Y'all got me sobbing in public with this performance...

  • @mikecole4489
    @mikecole4489 2 года назад

    This is the most beautiful thing I've seen in a minute

  • @tobychung6163
    @tobychung6163 2 года назад +1

    anybody know what model Taylor guitar Jacob's playing here? sounds amazing!

  • @evedotcom
    @evedotcom 2 года назад +2

    Just glorious. That woman was right, it is very soothing. I love the simplicity of this performance.

  • @nyleah411
    @nyleah411 6 месяцев назад

    This song sounds like the beginning rhythm of “Dreams” by Fleetwood Mac…I thought it sounded familiar!

  • @ohcanada7838
    @ohcanada7838 4 месяца назад +1

    magical!!!

  • @nicebluejay
    @nicebluejay Год назад +1

    how could people just walk by this?

  • @hannahspangenberg7748
    @hannahspangenberg7748 2 года назад +3

    This version, this setting… it’s everything

  • @sitjar
    @sitjar 2 года назад +1

    Cheeky capo adjustment at 3:13.....i had to rewind it to see how it had changed key so seemlessly

  • @kfree21
    @kfree21 10 месяцев назад

    watched this so many times since it was released, only just realized he's playing a 5-string acoustic. WTF

  • @ENSOTAVES
    @ENSOTAVES Год назад +1

    this is freakin beautiful 😻

  • @adachan7589
    @adachan7589 2 года назад +1

    I like this version much better than the studio version. Please put it out on the music platforms!! Please!

  • @Ferenz111
    @Ferenz111 2 года назад +1

    THis song is super divine ... tears of emotions. I would love to play violin with you !

  • @jas_bataille
    @jas_bataille 2 года назад +1

    Gosh do I miss France :( ... but I love this!

  • @RashleyY
    @RashleyY 2 года назад +1

    Holy crap, I had the privilege of watching Alita live in Buffalo with her band opening for Lawrence. She’s so soulful and knows how to energize the crowed

  • @keithmccabe4040
    @keithmccabe4040 Год назад

    Handing him a child's toy is so appropriate, something for his toy box in mommy's basement.

  • @josilmalibu2595
    @josilmalibu2595 Год назад

    Anyone know what melodica Bryn Blizka used in this vid?

  • @kentbyron7608
    @kentbyron7608 2 года назад +1

    Wow, this is a dream. Jacob Collier and his supremely talented crew slowly meandering around a Parisian flea Market, with attentive art lovers like the French welcoming the sounds… this video is deeper than it first appears. Unique! Gratitude! Wow! You made my day. ❤️🙏🏼

  • @bc5127
    @bc5127 2 года назад +1

    Had me smiling all the way thru. Thank you, just great👍💙 B U.K.

  • @wa7pP986
    @wa7pP986 2 года назад +8

    Thank you Jacob, for everything you give to us. it is hard to put into words (I guess that's what music if for). You, and your friends, are like a light, a small candle in a dark world. That flame, at any moment, can become an illumination, a blaze of understanding, of love, of support; A reminder of who we are and were we actually come from. It is up to us to take that flame and make it something more. But you help us peak through those clouds of darkness and remember there is a sun back there.

  • @pauminsu91
    @pauminsu91 2 года назад +2

    Another take away concert that I'll be repeating for the day 💗

  • @zgjfinance2796
    @zgjfinance2796 2 года назад +1

    The girl in the white pants is 😍🥰

    • @kirsten7152
      @kirsten7152 2 года назад

      Alita Moses, one of the best singers in the world.

  • @sedwarg
    @sedwarg Год назад

    Most of these are innocuous, modest. Of course Jacob has to do it in a busy market, being the unwanted centre of attention.

  • @ferryrahman2465
    @ferryrahman2465 Год назад

    pleasee what microphone are you guys using?

  • @lafinestracatalana8340
    @lafinestracatalana8340 2 года назад

    Bonjour, est possible registrer un video a la Finlande?
    Merci becaoup.

  • @tedakem1812
    @tedakem1812 Год назад

    Jacob is easily the most diverse interesting and natural bad ass talent of the last 2 years, get your laurels my nigga, get yours

  • @vashappeninlainey
    @vashappeninlainey 2 года назад +1

    ALITA MOSES WOWWWW

  • @VeryGoodDrinks
    @VeryGoodDrinks 2 года назад +2

    an absolutely supreme vibe

  • @LucasBrenelliG
    @LucasBrenelliG 2 года назад +1

    Ah...Jacob ♥️⚘ (kisses from brazilian musician)

  • @nicholasmoyer3275
    @nicholasmoyer3275 Год назад

    now do a jacob collier epic big orchestra thing in the dolomites or something

  • @Jack1Jack2Jack3Jack4
    @Jack1Jack2Jack3Jack4 2 года назад +1

    the capo shift at 3:13?! Absolutely seamless

  • @andre3434
    @andre3434 2 года назад +1

    Beautiful chords, is this an open tuning?

  • @efeakpofure
    @efeakpofure Год назад

    Girl at 1:51 looks so much like a young @dodie

  • @siphovice
    @siphovice 2 года назад +1

    It sounds so relaxing and comforting 😌

  • @forkkio1
    @forkkio1 25 дней назад

    The key change at the end was smooth af

  • @sheltondsouza4189
    @sheltondsouza4189 11 дней назад

    What is the tuning of his guitar

  • @MarlonSena
    @MarlonSena 2 года назад +2

    Ready to love it.

  • @Tommy-TwigFan
    @Tommy-TwigFan 2 года назад +2

    This is amazing

  • @KeshuvHuriaMusic
    @KeshuvHuriaMusic Год назад

    oh that scale change ... ufff

  • @dannywarnock8822
    @dannywarnock8822 2 года назад +1

    Best capo changer in the biz!

  • @tzmathew
    @tzmathew Год назад

    What model of Taylor is that ?