For everyone who complains about chord mistakes at the beginning, here are the answers: 1. Because he closed his EYES 2. He closed his eyes because he wanted to FEEL the music 3. He felt the music because he is A GREAT COMPOSER 4. He is a great composer because he put his HEART on it 5. He put his heart on it because it is a MASTERPIECE 6. It is a masterpiece because HE IS A GODDAMN JOE HISAISHI
Nope, music would not be music if it was nothing but feeling. It's of no value to play shit with all the world's feeling. The right version of your comment would be that it is given that you have already done your hard work and almost guarantee yourself that you won't do any "mistake", so that you can focus your mental capacity on "feeling". And that is possible only to a variable degree in each case. Also a mistake is not a mistake only if you could play it "right" and chose to not do so (so as to not justify one's laziness as "innovativeness" or "artistry"). If music had been just feeling, everyone would have been a musician.
For the non musicians - there is no mistake! If you watch the full concert, the previous piece ends on a C major chord with a very prominent E note that can’t be ignored :) But this piece is in a different key (G minor). So for a smooth transition he starts on a different chord than the original, one that is related to C major and includes that E note (A minor). Basically he adds a link between the two pieces. With the next chord (the one that people perceive as “mistake”) he actually returns to the original key. The entire concert is perfection ❤️
well this should put the debate to rest. most people commenting here including myself didnt know the beginning context. but this is absolutely what happened.
@@Gruskinator I mean honestly, what are the chance of him actually making a mistake? I mean possible but low because they trained for this and pianists with years if not decades of practice have almost absolute control of their instrument
Look at him, he's not just conducting, he's humble enough to participate with his fellow musicians as a pianist to play one of his masterpieces. He is no doubt a humble master of symphony
Joe Hisaishi is in my opinion the best film composer so far, his music is so emotional and melancholic beautiful. Hollywood composers are great but their music is music just doesn't have the same emotional appeal.
I agree with you about Hisaishi being one of the best film composers EVER, but there are plenty of Western and Hollywood film composers who's music really kicks you in the feels and connects with you on a raw emotional level. Michael Giacchino works wonders with his music for Pixar, especially Married Life from Up (which never fails to make me cry 😂). James Newton Howard is a god in the feels department, and Hans Zimmer can sway off of his general 'punch-in-the-face epicness' factor in his music to make some really emotional pieces, like Corynorhinus from Batman Begins. Nicholas Hooper did the soundtrack for Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, and the Dumbledore's Farewell score and scene is, in my opinion, one of the most breathtaking film moments ever. So what you said may have been a bit too much of a generalisation, and I see what you mean, but there are plenty of badass Hollywood and Western composers out there 😁
i get most chill when listening to japanese composser rather than western composser, idk why. japanese intrustment just get me more emotional feeling. -just my opinion.
This is the first time in 13 days of fighting here in Israel. I could escape in my thoughts to another place, and not think about the many losses and the kidnapped in Gaza. Thanks Ghibli, my heart calmed down a bit. 💙🇮🇱
You guys, that was not a mistake. I even much prefer this version because of the surreal unearthly and that mystic feeling you get when he started off. It was like his very own soul translated the original into the next level of depth in the contemplation and interpretation of the song itself. He's the composer of the song. No such thing as a mistake!
Aeezen Tester I watched a video (don’t remember what it was called) but it basically explained that Joe uses a mixture of the Classic Western scale and the traditional Japanese scale. The Japanese scale sounds a bit off to us making it feel ‘unnatural’ or ‘surreal’ but because it is mixed with the Western scale, it sounds amazing.
The chord change in the beginning isn't a mistake Why is everyone saying it is? This whole song is a variation Some of the notes are placed differently And it's not like since he closed his eyes he hit the wrong notes A good pianist is able to hit the correct notes even with eyes closed And it's not like the crowd didn't “notice” his “mistake” (everyone noticed the chord change) I think the crowd knew exactly what was going on
it's not a mistake, he just started in Am instead of Gm and modulated downwards. It was 100% intentional, even if the result was less than pleasing. I would venture to say that he probably wanted to change things up a bit and add it to see what it would sound like. You do not compose and perform on the piano for years and start in the wrong key. That would be like getting into the wrong side of the car... and realizing that there is no steering wheel 😄
I recently listened to this and the recorded version again and have concluded that I don’t know what I was talking about? I was listening to it a lot back then, I guess I imagined it?
For everyone who complains about chord mistakes at the beginning, here are the answers:
1. Because he closed his EYES
2. He closed his eyes because he wanted to FEEL the music
3. He felt the music because he is A GREAT COMPOSER
4. He is a great composer because he put his HEART on it
5. He put his heart on it because it is a MASTERPIECE
6. It is a masterpiece because HE IS A GODDAMN JOE HISAISHI
Light Yagami Well put bro.
Light Yagami it sounds good so maby he just wanted to do something new with it, change it up a little
plus you have a death note...
world would be dark place without you.
LOL
This makes me cry, don't forget: music is just feeling, music is not maths,doesn't matter the ''mistakes''
Music is math and even mistakes are a part of music, because music is art.
+yorza gallegos tamayo what mistakes ??
Damn this is the best comment ever
WHERE IS THE MISTAKES
Nope, music would not be music if it was nothing but feeling. It's of no value to play shit with all the world's feeling.
The right version of your comment would be that it is given that you have already done your hard work and almost guarantee yourself that you won't do any "mistake", so that you can focus your mental capacity on "feeling". And that is possible only to a variable degree in each case. Also a mistake is not a mistake only if you could play it "right" and chose to not do so (so as to not justify one's laziness as "innovativeness" or "artistry").
If music had been just feeling, everyone would have been a musician.
For the non musicians - there is no mistake! If you watch the full concert, the previous piece ends on a C major chord with a very prominent E note that can’t be ignored :) But this piece is in a different key (G minor). So for a smooth transition he starts on a different chord than the original, one that is related to C major and includes that E note (A minor). Basically he adds a link between the two pieces. With the next chord (the one that people perceive as “mistake”) he actually returns to the original key. The entire concert is perfection ❤️
well this should put the debate to rest. most people commenting here including myself didnt know the beginning context. but this is absolutely what happened.
@@Gruskinator I mean honestly, what are the chance of him actually making a mistake? I mean possible but low because they trained for this and pianists with years if not decades of practice have almost absolute control of their instrument
where can i watch the full concert
@@letskilliceagebaby291 ruclips.net/video/qg-g2DH8GZw/видео.html Read the description for specific chapters. x
I dont understand C major E G minor, whatever it is but i agree this concert is perfection 💕
he wrote the song. he can't make mistakes, only variations.
exactly
david chen well put
I like the way you think :D
I cant even heard he wrong the chord
@@이찬우-p9p i suppose it was in the very beginning, but hey, he did actually created a great variation of the beginning tho
やはり、久石譲さんの演奏が一番好き。
変にアレンジ入れて力強く弾いたり、テンポ早くしたりするのも良いのかもしれないけれど、落ち着いて豊かに壮大に弾く方が私は好きです。
あなたの世界に私は生まれてみたい。
とうもろこしたぬき めっちゃ共感
no entendí ni verga, no se inglés
En efecto
まあ、洒脱なコメントだこと
通報しました
I would spend all my money just to watch this live
Forreal, I am over here deciding which body parts I don't need
Simplycoconut Same.
200 Dollars!!?? WOW
I did, it was amazing, but sadly we can’t record or take pictures, but still one of the best performance I watched
@@sophist2485 200 dólares easiest money of my life spent I would spend 400 or more to watch this
10年前の高校生の頃、みんなにおすすめしたい受験応援ソングをクラスメート全員が書いていく企画で、人生のメリーゴーランドをあげた元彼を思い出します。その独特な感性が大好きでした。
この曲に「人生のメリーゴーランド」ってタイトルつけるなんてどんな神センスなんだろう⭐️
ん？
いろいろな人に演奏されている人生のメリーゴーランドですが、久石譲さんの演奏するピアノがやっぱり一番好きです。
久石さんも凄いけどやっぱり
演奏してる方達も凄い……
技術がすごい、美しすぎる
ワルツなのに哀愁があって不思議。何か懐かしくなってそこには決して戻れない悲しさみたいな感情。
この曲聞いてると人生は悲しくとも美しいって感じがして大好き
転調する所本当にやばい。鳥肌が止まらん。なんて素敵なんだろうか
何故か分からないけど、壮大なのに胸が締め付けられるような寂しさもあってほんとに良い曲です。
ジブリの音楽を聴くたび、あの世界にほんとに行きたくなってしまう…ほんとに素敵です。ジブリは
私は完全に同意し、あなたと関係があります！
ほんとにそれなです（ ; ; ）
毎回見たくて見るのに見終わったあとには叫びたくなるくらい現実逃避しちゃいます。あのジブリの世界に行きたすぎて！
私は特にハウルの動く城と千と千尋の神隠しが大好きなんですよね〜
ジブリを作る方々の感性は物凄いですよね。
僕は久石譲さんが奏でる音楽の世界に入りたいです。
倒置法
久石譲さんって本当に天才だと思う、沢山の曲が生まれてる中でこんなに素晴らしい曲を作ってしまうのだから、ジブリの世界観に忠実に、ハウルの人生を曲にしたみたい
1:53 this is where Howl and Sophie started their air walk when they just first met. Best part ever 😩👌
I thought it was just me! the background music sounds in that part it's just beautiful, it gives me goseebumps, best part ever!
@@mafum4fu Ikr? Man, If I was there watching the orchestra, I would cry from how just amazing it is
LITERALLY MADE ME CRY THE FIRST TIME I WATCHED THAT PART
2:00 THIS PART IS WONDERFUL
IKR IT GAVE ME GOOSEBUMPS
He can make mistakes if he wants to, it's his god damn composition!! :D
Natalya Plays Piano
Yeah I mean,he can't really make a mistake just a variation :3
Damn! you're totally right!!!
i mean that wasn't even a mistake
@@cecilevalerie7541 it is improvisation
where's the mistake
久石さんはあっさり弾くのではなく凄く繊細に弾くので本当に胸が締め付けられますね
本当に感動する
2:00 から動きが綺麗に揃ってて、舞踏会を2階から覗いてる気分になる
まるで映画の世界ですよね(*´･ω･｀
その表現..あ～"いっすねぇ～"()
マスカレードホテルみたい
その表現めっちゃすこ
同じこと思ってる人いた！！めっちゃわかる
ジブリで一番好きな曲、一番好きな映画。他の作品にはない優雅さ、壮大さ。ハウルが最高なのはストーリーの面白さだけじゃない。世界観が本当に好き
ruclips.net/video/w86rotpPU1Q/видео.html
1:53こっから急に元気になる鳥肌を誰か止めて……永遠に止まない……!!
Look at him, he's not just conducting, he's humble enough to participate with his fellow musicians as a pianist to play one of his masterpieces. He is no doubt a humble master of symphony
🕶
譲さんと同じ世界線に産まれてこれてよかった
宮崎監督と久石さんに
はよ！国民栄誉賞与えてくれよ！！
それよ！
スポーツとかどうでもエエから
日本は芸術に全然ダメ
素晴らしい人
皆海外行っちゃう
国民栄誉賞じゃなくて紫綬褒章のが良いよ
@@ぱんびーる運動できないからって嫉妬んすなよ😂
誰かに助けてもらいたいわけじゃない
同情してほしいわけでもない
ただ自分の人生の途中で迷っているだけ
この音楽の様に広く壮大に生きたい。
自分の迷いに笑える。
それが人生ですから
はい🙌
@@みよちゃん-x2b
人生は面白いよ。今まで25くらいの仕事をして、同じ回数程引っ越し、外国を含む様々な場所に住んだ。
自分で自分の映画を楽しんで来たような人生だったな。
もう駄目だ、と思った時もあったけど、不思議と切り抜けてきた。
最近、コロナで解雇になってしまった。
しかし、金はないけど、また面白いことが起きそうだ。
人生なるべくポジティブに生きましょう。
This was the first waltz at my wedding.
AbsentWithoutLeaving I'm so sorry.
pingasblobfish97 how come
Also mine ✨
@@poisonrozzie dope
That seems nice
埋もれちゃったのかもしれないけど、「2:00あたり舞踏会を上から眺めてるみたい」ってコメント好きだったな。ほんとにそう見える
時間指定押して2分のところ行けばありますよ
@@黒魔導-b6gそのコメントの事だと思う
@@lu-lu0796埋もれちゃったって言ってるのでどこにあるのか教えてるんだと思いますよ
The shot at 2:01 coupled with the music feels like you’re watching the orchestra itself waltz. It’s mesmerizing. What a masterpiece.
素晴らしい
涙が出るほど感動
世界に誇れる音楽家
Nostalgic... It's like an intense explosion of beautiful colours spiraling through my existance. BRAVO!
What a wonderful way to put it! I feel the same :)
Lorena Pimenta thats exactly how i feel
Omg, 7 years later and Howl answers me!!!!! Hahahahah 🤣
I think it is the build up to the chorus at 2:00
曲や演奏はもちろんなんやけど、カメラワークが完璧なの。曲に合わせて個々の楽器隊の良さを魅せる部分とオーケストラ全体の一体感を魅せる部分の使い方が完璧。
Joe Hisaishi is in my opinion the best film composer so far, his music is so emotional and melancholic beautiful. Hollywood composers are great but their music is music just doesn't have the same emotional appeal.
I agree with you about Hisaishi being one of the best film composers EVER, but there are plenty of Western and Hollywood film composers who's music really kicks you in the feels and connects with you on a raw emotional level. Michael Giacchino works wonders with his music for Pixar, especially Married Life from Up (which never fails to make me cry 😂). James Newton Howard is a god in the feels department, and Hans Zimmer can sway off of his general 'punch-in-the-face epicness' factor in his music to make some really emotional pieces, like Corynorhinus from Batman Begins. Nicholas Hooper did the soundtrack for Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, and the Dumbledore's Farewell score and scene is, in my opinion, one of the most breathtaking film moments ever. So what you said may have been a bit too much of a generalisation, and I see what you mean, but there are plenty of badass Hollywood and Western composers out there 😁
But joe hashini can make me simultaneously dance and cry
Pre114 Hans Zimmer does. Him and Joe are the jewels of the century
I love joe hisaishi and john williams. They're both great
i get most chill when listening to japanese composser rather than western composser, idk why. japanese intrustment just get me more emotional feeling.
-just my opinion.
いつ聞いても壮大かつ楽しいようでどこか切ない曲です。また終盤の場面ではまるで舞踏会を連想させるようなモダンな曲調で、それを理解しているカメラの視点、どれも素晴らしい関係性であり、引き込まれる作品です。
My god almost cried hearing on here what if i was actually there? I would be balling my eyes out.
Me too:((
Sammy Alarcon I WOULD FUCKING MOSH
Got myself a goosebump tho...╮(╯▽╰)╭
I literally did just bawl my eyes out over a YT clip. Absolutely no chance live. Like at all.
1:40
のホルン好きすぎる💗さりげなくグリッサンド入ってんのがもう…😭
金ローから来ました！人生のメリーゴーランドは本当に名曲です😭
金ローめっちゃ良かった、、
冒頭の、ピアノがメロディに入るところからもう全然世界が変わるのがすごい。本当にすごい。
自然と涙が出ちゃうのは何ででしょうね。
13年前からRUclipsてあるんだ。あと曲が素晴らしい！
言葉に表せないなんとも言えない感情が湧いてきます。間違いなく後に残したい曲ですね。
上から見た時みんな動きが揃ってんのめちゃくちゃいい
いい音楽は時代を造る
鳥肌が立ち涙が出て喜ぶ
人生は…
何度聴いても感動が訪れる。心が躍る。ジブリの世界に引き込まれそう。本当に素晴らしい。日本の誇りです。APPALE！
今までもこれからもずっと好きです。この曲を聴いてると子供の頃や受験勉強で聞いてたことを思い出します。
辛いときに聴くとなぜか涙が出てきます。
人生の色々なページに現れすぎて、もはやこの曲が私の人生のメリーゴーランド…
この演奏を肴にもう一杯。
明日は休日、あと一杯だけ…
本当にこの曲は聴くたびに胸が締め付けられる。
人生の辛さ愛しさ、出逢いに別れ、喜びに悲しみ….。
その全てが押し寄せてくるように感じる。
fun fact: you searched for this
i did. again and again
Yes, indeed i did,
Called out
true
nope
本当に落ち着く音色
ジブリはまじで不思議な世界と良い孤独を味わせてくれるよね
1:53 always makes me so damn emotional Studio Ghibli movies mean so much to me they were my childhood so beautiful
上のアングルから撮ってくれた人に感謝
あなたのせいで夢を諦めました
絶対一生をかけても敵わないって肌で感じた、そのくらい圧倒的で素敵
1:53 absolute chills from here on out.. amazing
なんてうっとりする音だろう。ピアノの音の重さがはんばない
ディズニーにアランメンケン！ジブリに久石譲あり！！！！！
今まで優雅なワルツのイメージの曲だったけど、この動画では久石さんが原動力となって城(オーケストラ)を動かしている感じがすごいする。
本当に大好きな曲です！
この人の演奏もそうだしほんとに輝いてて鮮やかで10年後でもずっと聞きににくると思う
他の「人生のメリーゴーランド」と久石さんの演奏を聴いて思うこと。他の人の演奏って、ただ単に流麗に間違わずに演奏しているだけ、という気がします。私たちの人生って、この演奏のように何事もうまく美しく過ぎていくのでしょうか。時には障害にぶつかったり、失意もある。危機さえある。逆に本当にうれしい時も生きていてよかった、というときもある。人生にはいろいろな局面がある。決して流麗に過ぎていくのではない。久石さんの演奏、テンポが変わったり、転調があって曲調が変わったりします。そこに私は人間の人生の有為転変が非常に巧みに表現されているように思います。
時間が経った今でも、いつ聴いても、良曲すぎる。最高…
何回聞いても凄く綺麗で聴き惚れてしまう 1番初めて聞いた時は強い風がいきなり吹いた感じで新しい世界が見えたのと同時に懐かしさも感じてボロボロ泣いた 語彙力は無いけど凄く好き
やっぱり日本のオーケストラが最高です。
1:52-2:30 favorite part ^-^
My favorite part 0:00-2:44 :)
Redsparrow633 Same
This part makes me cryyyy
Gives me chills
Same!
You HAVE to listen to the orchestral version because it sounds a whole lot better than just a piano.
This is the first time in 13 days of fighting here in Israel. I could escape in my thoughts to another place, and not think about the many losses and the kidnapped in Gaza. Thanks Ghibli, my heart calmed down a bit.
💙🇮🇱
😢
ここにいる演者、観客、そして映像を見てる自分たち、この曲が流れてる間だけ全ての人間の人生が渦巻いて流れ出してるように思える。
I love dancing the waltz with this piece of music especially the loud parts you have to turn around.☺️
i agree with you 😊
役割の一つ一つが紡がれて全てが美しい……
You guys, that was not a mistake. I even much prefer this version because of the surreal unearthly and that mystic feeling you get when he started off. It was like his very own soul translated the original into the next level of depth in the contemplation and interpretation of the song itself. He's the composer of the song. No such thing as a mistake!
Aeezen Tester I watched a video (don’t remember what it was called) but it basically explained that Joe uses a mixture of the Classic Western scale and the traditional Japanese scale. The Japanese scale sounds a bit off to us making it feel ‘unnatural’ or ‘surreal’ but because it is mixed with the Western scale, it sounds amazing.
That's amazing
間の取り方が絶妙です。
His intervals are exquisite.
oh my god. i'm crying. so beautiful
本当にこの曲大好き
この曲聴いてると、過去とか未来も含めて自分の人生が遠巻きに観察できてる気がして楽しい。
こんなにも華やかで美しい音楽が他にあるだろうか。
初っ端の音を間違えて「あっ！やべ」って顔する久石さんの表情がなんか可愛いw
おそらく、マエストロ・久石はこの曲の前の曲（Cave of Wind）の最後の和音を考慮して、最初1音高く始めたのだと思います。ぜひ前の曲と一緒にご覧になってみてください。
金曜ロードショーでジブリやるたびに聞きに来てる ほんとに好き
The chord change in the beginning isn't a mistake
Why is everyone saying it is? This whole song is a variation
Some of the notes are placed differently
And it's not like since he closed his eyes he hit the wrong notes
A good pianist is able to hit the correct notes even with eyes closed
And it's not like the crowd didn't “notice” his “mistake” (everyone noticed the chord change)
I think the crowd knew exactly what was going on
Chromatic thirds is neither a chord change nor a mistake.
it's not a mistake, he just started in Am instead of Gm and modulated downwards. It was 100% intentional, even if the result was less than pleasing. I would venture to say that he probably wanted to change things up a bit and add it to see what it would sound like. You do not compose and perform on the piano for years and start in the wrong key. That would be like getting into the wrong side of the car... and realizing that there is no steering wheel 😄
WHERE IS DA MISTAKEEEE
@@Gruskinator is the mistake in the first 30 seconds, i notice it is higher notes, but i think it sounds better (?)
@@masyarakatcerdas6963 the “”mistake”” is the first few notes even though it isnt a mistake
1:39 ホルンマジでかっこええ
昼間に聴くのも好きだけど一日をやり遂げた夜に聴くのも好き
死ぬまでにやりたいことリストに久石さんの生演奏を聴いてみたい。という贅沢な願いを入れてもいいでしょうか
私も同感
んで久石譲先生の生演奏聞いて、思いっきり号泣したい
Im crying. This song has always been my lullaby before sleep. Thanks Joe Hisashi for the wonderful music :) Im glad I fell in love with Ghibli
1:50から好きで2:00の上から撮ってる感じがなんか好き。手の動き統一で🫶
Its so beautiful hearing and even watching everyone play in sync! One of my all time favorites btw!
2:00 このときに上からのカメラワークになるところが最高だと思う
指揮を中心に円になっていて、まるでメリーゴーランドみたい
1:58
Call me cheesy, but when the camera goes for the top-down view, the musicians all look like dancers on a ballroom floor, and i love it❤
Listening to this feels like heaven. I'll never get bored of this.
I love this piece and one summer's day
1:55 のところ鳥肌たった
皆んな上手く引いたりしてるけど0から1を創り上げる人はやっぱすごい
I'm happy, sad and I've got goosebumps all at the same time while listening to this.
1:52 this part and beyond NEVER fail to give me chills. so gorgeous and still hasn’t (and prob never will) lose its magic
余りにも美しくて泣いちゃった
天才 天才 素晴らしいなにも言う事無し ありがとうだ
Hisaishi-starts out in wrong key-recovers like a BOSS. Audience doesn't even notice... *applause*.
Um um um this is own piece soooo
Pretty sure that wasn't a mistake lol
RiverGirl how do you know that audience didn't notice?
where is thr wrong key actually?
I recently listened to this and the recorded version again and have concluded that I don’t know what I was talking about? I was listening to it a lot back then, I guess I imagined it?
He’s so passionate when he plays! It’s beautiful!
やっぱり日本のオーケストラが最高だ。外国のオーケストラより繊細に感じる。
聴くと思わず涙ぐむ曲。
ハウルも、理由を上手く説明できないけれど涙が出てしまう映画。
아주아주 오랜만에 좋아했던 하울을 다시보고. 나이들고 보니 영화도 ost도 너무 울리네. 왜이리 눈물이 나지
生で聴いてみたい。多分鳥肌立ちすぎて鳥になるわ。
2023寒くなる中この神曲には今もうたれています
深呼吸しながら聴かないと押し潰れてしまいそう
大袈裟だけどわかる。いつのまにか息荒くなってる
表現の仕方小説家
ジブリの作品って使われてる音楽の素晴らしさで価値があがってると思う