seeing him playing various wrong notes and following like nothing happened is still so impressive for me. the self control this man has is insane i wish i was like him.
Ritmo perfecto, tremdnda musicalidad y carácter, estilo impecablemente logrado, articulación clarísima. Me transmite un mensaje único. Para mí, la mejor versión que escuché.
People who added comments should have asked questions to the owner of this video instead.questions like what was the background? Who were the intended audiences? Based on the condition it wasn’t a professional setting. Perhaps a charity event, guest appearance at a local competition? He is a world renowned pianist surely he knew what he was doing there.
I can't see how he finished playing without losing his temper or concentration, given that throughout I kept hearing some people coughing with unfailing regularity. I also got a jolt hearing a very LOUD thud of a falling object. The incessant coughing was unforgivable , in all probability prompted by sheer boredom. If classical music bores you, don't go to a concert and cough your way through it, spoiling it for the rest of us.
because he is disengaged from pretty much everything in the world except the piano and the piece. it's visible on his face, and probably the only way to perform with such a passion.
Definitely not one of Yundi's top performances. Apart from the wrong notes, the piece at times feels like it does not even hold together, making you wonder if he simply forgot how to play? Also missing are the textured tone and beautiful color Yundi is loved for. The third movement is simply a disaster. The recording and the tuning are bad too. Still love him though, hoping to see him returning to his old self!
Agreed ... His Adagio Cantabile is one of the most heartbreakingly beautiful renditions I've ever heard, but this particular performance almost had the sound of having practiced something 10000x and just playing on autopilot without pouring the emotion into it. Also that piano is unforgivably out of tune ... Seriously, it's an insult to that Steinway.
I agree, I’ve listened to the album recording dozens of times and this in comparison is not good (to be fair though that piano is also very out of tune) but the amount of wrong notes is absurd for the yundi we know and love
Yundi's Beethoven does not sound German at all. It lacks the structure and precision that Germans are all about. It also lacks masculinity and maestoso often heard in Beethoven and Wagner. And too much rubato.
Beethoven may not be like the steotype of German. From the nature of Music, Beethoven could be very romantic, otherwise he couldn't create the music like this. Because we never hear how Beethoven and Chopin played, how can we say its more Chopin than Beethoven??????
이 연주가 정말 쇼팽콩쿨 우승자 yundi의 연주가 맞습니까..? 1악장에서 하도 기가막혀서 피아노 조율상태가 안좋나 했습니다. 2악장 들어보니 그냥 미스터치였네요. 3악장에서는 완전히 무너지네요. 꾸밈음 무너지는 것은 물론이고 이 연주는 그냥 연습부족 이라고 밖에 안보여 대단히 실망입니다. 아마 컨디션이 매우 대단히 안좋았다고 믿고싶네요.. 서울 예술의전당 내한공연 2번(두번 모두 쇼팽 피아 협주곡 1번)도 가봤는데 한번은 실수해서 연주를 멈추지를 않나.. 번번히 음반과 달라 실망하네요. 쇼팽 그 자체였던 00년 윤디리는 어디갔나요..
The people who liked this video should really get their hearing checked. No only does the piano sound broken, the playing was full of VERY obvious mistakes. I've already seen plenty of videos of Yundi making a fool of himself performing on stage, but this one is by far the most shocking, because this looks like a more serious setting. Also looks like this took place before he became a full-time "celebrity" personality in China.
This is shockingly poor. I teach and this is unbelievably bad for a professional. I'd be ashamed if any of my students played this as he does here. The last movement is utter destruction of the piece there's hardly a right note, clumps of chords just smashed up, missing bars. God knows what was going on in his head and fingers! Wow I've heard him before and he's been fantastic but this !?....well maybe it's a lesson that no matter how good you might be you can have a seriously OFF day ....!
seeing him playing various wrong notes and following like nothing happened is still so impressive for me. the self control this man has is insane i wish i was like him.
中國少有的鋼琴家，把作曲家的意思演繹得很到位，實在比另一些光賣弄技巧的好得多👍🏻
Ritmo perfecto, tremdnda musicalidad y carácter, estilo impecablemente logrado, articulación clarísima. Me transmite un mensaje único. Para mí, la mejor versión que escuché.
are you kidding，its full of wrong voice
対鋼琴演奏不大了解，但這次雲迪的被「虛偽的道德」窩害感到震驚、所以就試着傾聽他的演奏，第一次就整個人被吸引進入他的演奏中，那真是無法形容的天籟之音，這麼一個天賦異稟的年輕人怎麼會被中國人所拋棄？這樣的國家永遠不可能產生改變世界的微軟的畢爾蓋次、蘋果的史蒂芬喬伯以及現在的伊龍馬斯克。請索尋所有歐美西方音樂大師們的生平吧！
不了解你还屌屌赖赖，这一堆错音乱七八糟的车祸现场你都能夸
好棒.....好喜歡.......多謝你 !!
Great performance I love Beethoven and Yundi Li illustrates well the caracter within this Sonata!😁
People who added comments should have asked questions to the owner of this video instead.questions like what was the background? Who were the intended audiences? Based on the condition it wasn’t a professional setting. Perhaps a charity event, guest appearance at a local competition? He is a world renowned pianist surely he knew what he was doing there.
I can't see how he finished playing without losing his temper or concentration, given that throughout I kept hearing some people coughing with unfailing regularity. I also got a jolt hearing a very LOUD thud of a falling object. The incessant coughing was unforgivable , in all probability prompted by sheer boredom. If classical music bores you, don't go to a concert and cough your way through it, spoiling it for the rest of us.
Also can people stop clapping between movements in a classical music concert. Just don't do it people.
He could have put that anger into his playing since it is a rather angry piece
at a concert held in china, you always hesr tons of coughs and whispers, sometimes loud talkings.
because he is disengaged from pretty much everything in the world except the piano and the piece.
it's visible on his face, and probably the only way to perform with such a passion.
Yes, very noisy audience! Criminy! 🙄
The grave is full of pain.
the tune of C5 of that piano was amazing... 😅
Una pena que se haya desafinado groseramente el piano. Este pianista posee una concentración digna de un profesional.
👏👏👏
The piano tuner needs to be fired. Ugh.
But brilliant playing.
Definitely not one of Yundi's top performances. Apart from the wrong notes, the piece at times feels like it does not even hold together, making you wonder if he simply forgot how to play? Also missing are the textured tone and beautiful color Yundi is loved for. The third movement is simply a disaster. The recording and the tuning are bad too. Still love him though, hoping to see him returning to his old self!
Agreed ... His Adagio Cantabile is one of the most heartbreakingly beautiful renditions I've ever heard, but this particular performance almost had the sound of having practiced something 10000x and just playing on autopilot without pouring the emotion into it. Also that piano is unforgivably out of tune ... Seriously, it's an insult to that Steinway.
I think he doesn't like Beethoven that much compared to Chopin, and didn't work enough on this Sonata. + was maybe young ?
How can he concentrate with all these fucking coughs lol but I aggree with you ahah
Agreed , also what score is he using ?!?
I agree, I’ve listened to the album recording dozens of times and this in comparison is not good (to be fair though that piano is also very out of tune) but the amount of wrong notes is absurd for the yundi we know and love
Damn piano.
調律がおかしい…？素敵な動画ありがとうございます！
彼の演奏を好きなのに特に2楽章を好きです ライブ演奏の時はすごく不安ですね。 アルバムを録音した時は、 一体どのように演奏したのか疑問ですね。
0:39 0:56 2:09 2:17
Some tones even split… awful tuning but great performance!
The piano was tuned fine, he was making some mistakes
@@nshk9737 I feel sorry for you mate you cannot tell what the fine tuning is
@@jordan7080 I change my mind, listened again and I definitely hear the faulty tuning
stupid tuned piano in spire of 275 full size piano ? toy piano sounds ~ !
사람들 기침 졸라 하네 이렇게 멋진 곡을 연주하는데 ㅠ
This piano no good
Yundi’ s Beethoven is always Chopin.
Shut up
oh darn Henry you beat me to it! haha yeah +1 here!
Yundi's Beethoven does not sound German at all. It lacks the structure and precision that Germans are all about. It also lacks masculinity and maestoso often heard in Beethoven and Wagner. And too much rubato.
@@ShanshanZheng agreed
Beethoven may not be like the steotype of German. From the nature of Music, Beethoven could be very romantic, otherwise he couldn't create the music like this. Because we never hear how Beethoven and Chopin played, how can we say its more Chopin than Beethoven??????
this sonata is deceptively difficult especially when the piano is garbage
이 연주가 정말 쇼팽콩쿨 우승자 yundi의 연주가 맞습니까..? 1악장에서 하도 기가막혀서 피아노 조율상태가 안좋나 했습니다. 2악장 들어보니 그냥 미스터치였네요. 3악장에서는 완전히 무너지네요. 꾸밈음 무너지는 것은 물론이고 이 연주는 그냥 연습부족 이라고 밖에 안보여 대단히 실망입니다. 아마 컨디션이 매우 대단히 안좋았다고 믿고싶네요.. 서울 예술의전당 내한공연 2번(두번 모두 쇼팽 피아 협주곡 1번)도 가봤는데 한번은 실수해서 연주를 멈추지를 않나.. 번번히 음반과 달라 실망하네요. 쇼팽 그 자체였던 00년 윤디리는 어디갔나요..
He’s obviously lack of practice.
The piano is AWFUL!
钢琴的好几个音不准，走音了。 Several notes of the piano are out of tune.
Not a huge fan of the coughing in this video.
H
拜託，要當盲粉也顧一下耳朵吧？這鋼琴聽起來都走音了，李雲迪彈的也是錯誤百出，這樣還有人能按讚？
有程度一點，去聽一下像Zimmerman那種大師是怎麼彈的，來訓練自己的耳朵，不要把聽鋼琴演奏當作是在看耍猴戲特技(雖然某人好像的確就是擅長這種招)🙄
錯音錯到起雞皮疙瘩
況且他是不是反覆錯地方了...
有些人听不出不能怪他们，而且每个人都有错误，只是李云迪后来自大所以错误比其他人多
钢琴的确走音，但是音乐是要听整体的。给你这样的钢琴，你能弹到这样吗？演奏多多少少会出错，我们是人不是神
Keyboard man.
Piano not well tuned !
He looks tired ..
The people who liked this video should really get their hearing checked. No only does the piano sound broken, the playing was full of VERY obvious mistakes.
I've already seen plenty of videos of Yundi making a fool of himself performing on stage, but this one is by far the most shocking, because this looks like a more serious setting. Also looks like this took place before he became a full-time "celebrity" personality in China.
I prefer Freddy Kempf’s version…
This is shockingly poor. I teach and this is unbelievably bad for a professional. I'd be ashamed if any of my students played this as he does here. The last movement is utter destruction of the piece there's hardly a right note, clumps of chords just smashed up, missing bars. God knows what was going on in his head and fingers! Wow I've heard him before and he's been fantastic but this !?....well maybe it's a lesson that no matter how good you might be you can have a seriously OFF day ....!
Hard to listen to all around
Seems he tried his best, but the piano was way out of tune, imagine mowing for a farmland with a 20-year old John Deer.
Terrible..
李云迪有几场音乐会不是车祸现场的？肖赛就是他的人生高光了，之后一直走下坡路。
让你们听听这个柯蒂斯音乐学院的学生弹的，你们就知道李云迪有多差。ruclips.net/video/w--SfVE2A3c/видео.htmlsi=4WjDgy0aGrPYcPii