Comparing Quantizers in VCV Rack

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 1 янв 2025

Комментарии • 54

  • @OmriCohen-Music
    @OmriCohen-Music  5 лет назад +6

    About the Midi map mode in Scala Quantizer, it maps each pitch of the current scale onto the 12-tone-per-octave pitches that you'd get by default from a midi controller. So, if you're using a midi keyboard and sending it through the quantizer, instead of tuning each key to the nearest pitch of your selected scale, each key, as you go up, will be returned to the next pitch in the scale. If you wish to use, for example, a scale with 24 pitches in an octave, then two octaves on your keyboard will correspond with one octave of your scale.

  • @animatrix1490
    @animatrix1490 5 лет назад +15

    I always love it when Omri says "Oh yeah." :)

  • @CBusschaert
    @CBusschaert Год назад +1

    Quantizers covered and timestamps, for convenience, with availability notes as of Jan 2023:
    0:26 - QNT by VCV (included. now has an octave shift knob and a keyboard-like arrangement)
    2:45 - Quantizer from JW (Free)
    3:45 - Quantizer from XOR (Not available for Rack 2)
    6:00 - Quantum from ML (Free)
    9:30 - Quantum Multiverse from ML Pro ($15 in Library)
    12:05 - Re-win from Repelzen (Free) + Re-trig at 14:30
    15:07 - Lazy Suzan from Holonic Systems (Free)
    17:35 - Scala Quantizer from NYSTHI (Free)
    19:15 - Scalar by VCV ($20 in Library)
    21:07 - Scale Quantizer Mk II from Amalgamated Harmonics (Free)
    23:06 - Customscaler from Noobhour (Free)
    26:00 - Probably NOTe from Frozen Wasteland (Free, there are modules with alternative tuning systems in the collection)

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  Год назад +2

      Oh wow, thank you so much! I should really record a new video about this...

  • @sh0ckvalue989
    @sh0ckvalue989 4 года назад +2

    Was watching your latest video "Permutation Overview and Tutorial" and wanted to know more about the quantizer you were using. Doing a search - what do you know? A different tutorial from Omri explaining exactly what I was looking for. Hats off to you, sir!

  • @RubenSainiuc
    @RubenSainiuc 2 года назад

    Useful comparison, you are a very good teacher. The only thing that didn't work for me is when I try the double-Quantum at 8:33, because the VCV Rack keeps crashing. Other than that, I learned a lot from you. Thanks again!

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  2 года назад +1

      Oh, that's weird... I wonder why it crahses. But I'm happy you enjoyed the video :)

    • @RubenSainiuc
      @RubenSainiuc 2 года назад

      @@OmriCohen-Music I opened a bug report on Quantum's source code page, hoping that it can be solved.

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  2 года назад +1

      @@RubenSainiuc thanks so much. I hope so too

    • @RubenSainiuc
      @RubenSainiuc 2 года назад

      ​@@OmriCohen-Music ​It seems like Martin already fixed the bug in 2.0.1. I tested it and it works for me now. Cheers!

  • @rafaelgarcia1906
    @rafaelgarcia1906 4 года назад +3

    Hello Omri!
    I wondered if you know how to create a scalar file.
    Thank you very much for everything you do!

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  4 года назад +2

      I'm not so sure actually but have a look here - www.huygens-fokker.org/scala/
      Cheers!

  • @MuslimShortanov
    @MuslimShortanov 3 года назад

    Super useful. I wanted to explore myself today. But you did all work ! Thanks.

  • @Audhentik
    @Audhentik 5 лет назад

    very nice! my fav is the rewin quantizer at the moment:)

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  5 лет назад +1

      Yes, it looks nice also and the scenes are very useful.

  • @RecordingOfMind
    @RecordingOfMind 5 лет назад +1

    Thanks a lot Omri, there's certainly some interesting functionality some of them have that i missed :o

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  5 лет назад +1

      Cheers! Yeah, there are some really interesting tools out there.

  • @LarsBjerregaard
    @LarsBjerregaard 5 лет назад +4

    Great overview of all those quantizers Omri, very useful, thanks! That will be $3000 in hardware modules please.... 😬

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  5 лет назад +1

      Thanks, Lars! I wonder what quantizers are available in Eurorack. I can think of a couple but I never really got into this since VCV is taking care of everything like this.

    • @WalmikDeshpande
      @WalmikDeshpande 3 года назад

      @@OmriCohen-Music Mob of emus has a nice quantizer mode for internal as well as external input for each of it s 6 oscillators.

  • @dataphreak
    @dataphreak 4 года назад

    Kind of in the same neighborhood, SouthPole Riemann is a neat way to get quantized notes. It's actually a sequencer, but built to sequence chords based on perfect 5hs and minor 3rds. I guess it's kind of an algorythmic sequencer, like Grids/Topograph. Would love to see a rundown of all the modules like this.

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  4 года назад

      Well, the Sounthpole collection is not available in the library anymore, but I remember this sequencer, it was a fun one.

  • @aaronrogers8328
    @aaronrogers8328 7 месяцев назад

    Bit late to the party, but I guess the midi mode on the poly scala would allow you to map an external keyboard to something like 10 tone equal temperament.

  • @thimkthimk
    @thimkthimk 5 лет назад +1

    I really love Utility by dBiz. 3 inputs and 3 outputs. The 2nd and 3rd inputs can be treated as offsets of the first.
    For some reason it's currently tagged under "Utility" and not "Quantizer".

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  5 лет назад +1

      Oh yeah, I missed this one... I will have a look, thanks!

  • @wimwijn1
    @wimwijn1 5 лет назад +4

    lot's of quantizers, lot's of thanks :-)

  • @KNHSynths
    @KNHSynths 5 лет назад

    My preferred one is the Amalgamated Harmonics. Clear, offers the common scales and before the polyphonic option of VCV it was super handy with its 8 individual voices (and it is more handy today with polyphonic I/O). The second one is the Quantum because you can create your own scales from a readable keyboard. For all the others I can't understand how such things can be proposed, there is no keyboard displayed, nor any note information, you must count in your head to know if this button is F or F#, it is a hell. So just 2 quantizers are enough for all needs (excluding micro tuning). The AH, simple and efficient and the Quantum to create special scales. You can forget all the others :-)

    • @ablaut
      @ablaut 5 лет назад +1

      repelzen re-win and holonic lazy susan also have vertical keyboard layouts similar to quantum for selecting notes in a scale. they also have some interesting features, as omri explains in the video, that are different from quantum. personally i find re-win's scenes super useful.

    • @denistercier
      @denistercier 5 лет назад +1

      Lazy susan devrait donc également avoir tes faveurs je pense.... ;-) bon week-en à toi!

    • @KNHSynths
      @KNHSynths 5 лет назад +1

      @@ablaut When you look at the details they are some cool features here and there that are not in the AH or the Quantum you're right.
      It's cool to have this choice and to be able to select the ones you're the best confortable with.
      But there are so much modules now for VCV that's it is merely impossible to load them all and study each one. I did it but I stopped when we reached about 1000 modules. I also published a view videos (in French) about how to pick the right modules, how they work and using them the right way to create music not just beeps and blips.
      The quantizers I named were among the first ones and they always make the job. I think it is enough for must people apart very exotic needs like micro tuning. I believe it is a good advice for the vast majority of users. Knowing to get the most from a limited number of modules is more efficient for creativity than loading thousand ones and just scratching their surface while loosing time in secondary interest things.
      Omri is doing a great job helping to make the right choices. The real lesson is in this ability to make a selection, the goal is not to make you using all these modules in a patch of course.

    • @KNHSynths
      @KNHSynths 5 лет назад

      @@denistercier Oui c'est un module sympa avec un mini clavier aussi . Ce que j'aime bien c'est l'idée du trigger d'échantillonnage. Le AH ou le Quantum ne savent pas le faire. C'est un point à considérer si on sait utiliser cette feature et en tirer partie (ce qui n'est pas le cas de tout le monde à mon avis). Bon weekend à toi aussi !

  • @LazarethPrime
    @LazarethPrime 2 года назад

    Really loved the look of the Repelzen modules only to find out they aren't available for Rack2 and haven't been updated in 3 years 😭

  • @reasOneMusic
    @reasOneMusic 4 года назад +1

    great video! i’ve been using quantum to quantize notes ( i’m a noob) and since it has a gate out it’s been great, the jw quantizer does not have a gate, and i’ve been using CLOCKED into entropia to sequence , so i can figure out with that set up how to use jw quantizer, would i route something from CLOCKED into say interzones gate?

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  4 года назад +2

      Thanks! Well, I guess that the easiest will be to use Quantum or a different quantizer that has a gate output, but you can also try ReTrig from Repelzen that is designed for this.

    • @reasOneMusic
      @reasOneMusic 4 года назад +1

      Omri Cohen thank you man, i will have to give that a try, i’m still learning how to string everything together but every day is getting a bit better, i really do like the jw quantizer but i might have to just use quantum for a while since my patch didn’t have any clock in it besides clocked, i love that thing

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  4 года назад +3

      Yes, Clocked is a must, totally. By the way, also Mother from Orange Line has the option to choose a predetermined scale. It's in the right click menu. It also has a gate output like the one on Quantum.

    • @reasOneMusic
      @reasOneMusic 4 года назад +1

      Omri Cohen excellent!! really appreciate all your videos man!

  • @macronencer
    @macronencer 3 года назад

    Now I know why I struggled when I tried to use the VCV quantiser... it's upside down, with the low notes at the top. Why didn't I realise that? :D

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  3 года назад

      Yeah, I don't know why but it's upside down :)

  • @ldlework
    @ldlework 5 лет назад

    This video was so freaking helpful.

  • @luiscanela1321
    @luiscanela1321 5 лет назад

    I loved it thank you :)

  • @Kid_Placo
    @Kid_Placo 5 лет назад

    Indispensable pour la musique générative contrôlée, par exemple. Merci, Omri Cohen 🙂

  • @SlashnKashmir
    @SlashnKashmir 5 лет назад

    Hello Omri. I want to use VSTs in VCV like plogue. And i found Host module. Do you think this is worth to buy it. Do you know any technique to use VSTs in VCV
    Thanks.

    • @roland4507
      @roland4507 5 лет назад +1

      Host is the thing if you want to use VST in VCV. But be careful. VCV is already demanding on the CPU. So it's depending to your Computer which VST'S work fine. Some of them crackle very easy. I use it and i like Host very much. And its supporting the Makers of VCV if you buy some Stuff from them.

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  5 лет назад +1

      Hi! Yeah, like Roland said, Host is the thing for you if you want to use VSTs in VCV.. I have it and it's great, but I have to be honest I don't use it that often. I find that I have enough to play with in VCV and I don't have so many VSTs actually. Although, running Kontakt in VCV can be lots of fun, but I do get crackles here and there. Don't forget also that now Host is polyphonic so you can also program drums and such (pssttt, video coming soon ;) )

    • @SlashnKashmir
      @SlashnKashmir 5 лет назад +1

      @@OmriCohen-Music Thank you both. Actually I want to use Eventide's plugins in VCV

    • @OmriCohen-Music
      @OmriCohen-Music  5 лет назад +1

      Well, with host you get also the effects version so you can load effect VSTs also and use them in VCV