There's No Real You, No Special Substance, No Immortal Permanent Entity - Daniel Dennet

Поделиться
HTML-код

Комментарии • 17

  • @bobtarmac1828
    @bobtarmac1828 13 дней назад +2

    Miss him. 😢

  • @Amazology
    @Amazology 8 дней назад

    Says who ?

  • @chromakey84
    @chromakey84 13 дней назад +8

    This can be disproven with a direct experience.
    All these concepts fall away and words become stupid.
    All the words describing what is in this video are empty concepts.
    The truth is ineffable

    • @Noelsterrr
      @Noelsterrr 13 дней назад +4

      Your inability to grasp science is not a valid argument against it.

    • @shyman3000
      @shyman3000 13 дней назад

      @@Noelsterrr Actually it is. You would not have science today without philosophy and yet, modern scientists have no philosophical training or background. They have no relationship to the fundamental questions about human beings, ontology, epistemology or cosmology, just ask a PhD in the sciences and you will see what poor thinkers they are. In short, they no longer grasp the origins or the meanings or the madness behind their own methods. That's a pretty good argument against it.

    • @a.m.7438
      @a.m.7438 13 дней назад +2

      Direct experience is not the same as perfectly understanding something. It's just feeling. Feeling is how we experience things, it's how we translate experience. But we can and often do get them wrong. It's exactly like when you witness a magic trick. You're seeing a trick. You had direct experience with it. But you are still left with guessing how it happened when you don't practice/learn/study/are told and shown exactly how it happened.
      You can't trust your own experience, but it is the best we got. Still, take care with how you translate your experience.

    • @benjaminjoeBF3
      @benjaminjoeBF3 12 дней назад

      ​@@NoelsterrrScience do not exists.

    • @alexale5488
      @alexale5488 12 дней назад

      @@Noelsterrr
      Near Death Experiences
      Terminal Lucidity Cases
      Visual Binding Problem
      The Hard Problem of Consciousness
      +.....
      All point to an immaterial conscious independent entity.
      Before outright dismiss all above, document and research accordingly.

  • @percival1137
    @percival1137 11 дней назад

    When psycology, philosophy, science and spirituality are not unified as a whole, they become useless lies when broken into fragments. Its all the same damn thing. I would have enjoyed very much explaining, very simply, to these men how they are wrong.

    • @thenacregod
      @thenacregod  11 дней назад +3

      Spirituality is a scam and you are fooled.

    • @HumansAreShitFactories
      @HumansAreShitFactories 8 дней назад

      You can’t even spell psychology!!! Yet you talk about ‘science’ in a very broad sense. Strange. Science is a method. Also, psychology is a science, but you seem to be making a distinction.