Claire is A Theory, Twin of Bethany Young

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 дек 2024

Комментарии • 110

  • @AleynaSeymen
    @AleynaSeymen 9 лет назад +22

    ive forgotten all about claire before watching this vid. they've added so many too many storylines that i can't keep track of not even the characters now!

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад +1

      Only reason she's memorable for me is because me and my friend laughed about her line of 'I wished sara was dead before she went missing' because theres thing and it was like 'i texted my sister i hope you die in a car crash and then she died in a car crash' but now with Talia and Jonny like i just think its getting ridiculous, Leslie was good storyline to add but i dont know how they are going to end this storyline with sara harvey at all its annoying

  • @msnickelodeongirl
    @msnickelodeongirl 9 лет назад +31

    A is someone from season 1. Big A simply cannot be someone introduced in season 3, such as Cece, much less a character we haven't even seen (Bethany). Not being funny, but I'd be so disappointed if A wasn't from season 1. Maya's story cannot be at an end. We've still yet to find out how Noel and Maya were linked, and whether their relationship has any similarities to Noel helping Alison at the beginning of season 5. I still think there's so much, like Maya being in the DiLaurentis house, having all of Ali's stuff etc. In my opinion, a character not introduced in season 1 cannot be A, a character we've never seen cannot be A, and Alison does NOT have a twin because that's the book, not the show -_-

    • @TheVeridianalopes
      @TheVeridianalopes 9 лет назад +9

      Actually, it would make sense if Big A were from season 3 since someone stole the game from Mona.

    • @msnickelodeongirl
      @msnickelodeongirl 9 лет назад +2

      nah mate.

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад +7

      its going to be Wren / Hanna / Aria /Emily / Maya /Twin of any of those 5... if not ill be super surprised

    • @AleynaSeymen
      @AleynaSeymen 9 лет назад +2

      Pretty Little Liars i think mostly hanna. but ashley did speak to a little girl at a halloween episode which was creepy if you remember? so the twin story may be about ashley marin. there's something very shady about her

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад +1

      If it was hanna mom i think i'd be blown out of this world with joy nothing would be more satisfying than seeing that, but after todays ep im back to Emily being A I just felt like she was so evil and I really don't trust her.

  • @makingitpurple
    @makingitpurple 10 лет назад +5

    That is one hell of a catch. Either this is the murkiest of conspiracies in the -A world or they ran out of extras.

  • @Sara-tp7me
    @Sara-tp7me 4 года назад

    “If you ignore it it will go away” lmfao idk why that’s so funny to me

  • @chloemonroe.
    @chloemonroe. 9 лет назад +2

    I strongly believe Big A is Lucas. He's has the money to do it because of his gambling, he has a clear and obvious motive, and he's already been linked to the A-team. I'm betting that he was the one who took over while Mona was in Radley. Plus, as some awesome person from tumblr pointed out, Marlene likes to refer to Big A as Uber A, and if you didn't know, uber is a german word. The only person who has any connection to that is Lucas because his last name, Gottesman, which is also German. Also, another sidenote (if this wasn't enough already), Gottesman mean "man of god". And who likes playing god more than A?

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      Chloe Monroe except sara shepard named lucas therefore all the characters that pre-existed their meanings mean nothing to the show, it would make sense as lucas as the character to be A but i dont think they will do it because the actor's voice limits him to play a dark character.

    • @alex_is_shook
      @alex_is_shook 9 лет назад +1

      Pretty Little Liars Yeah but Sara Shepard named him Lucas Beatie in the books they changed his last name on the show for some reason!

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      I just think that in that process it was way too early to be throwing that in for a end game meaning when the writers never expected it to blow up like it did, I truly believe that the actor that plays Lucas could never pull off being A to me it would feel like Shana 'ill blow your head off' it just wasnt powerful enough.. I'd like to be wrong though I want them to actually explain why Alison always called him Hermy we never got the backstory.

  • @megan1950
    @megan1950 9 лет назад

    Did you notice the name next to hers in the mausoleum? (1:01) David Lazarius, so similar to Lazarus because people DO NOT stay buried in PLL! They tend to rise from the dead.

  • @amariharris2315
    @amariharris2315 9 лет назад

    Cool you actually took time to make this theory and it's decent since sara harvey is relevant again

  • @farahjackson10
    @farahjackson10 9 лет назад

    Mareline King stated that someone guessed A correctly after the Christmas episode so i think Claire is the orignal A. Aria will be revealed as Big A but Claire is the ultimate A

  • @diamondhot000
    @diamondhot000 9 лет назад +7

    What if Claire thinks Ali is Sara and that's why she's after her lol?

    • @mockingpink
      @mockingpink 6 лет назад

      Lewis Forest
      Alison is not Sara

  • @chiefsosa3171
    @chiefsosa3171 9 лет назад +1

    I don't know if you guys noticed but ..
    The girl who said "Avery couldn't be here today" LETS CALL HER KATIE
    K SO..
    Katie looks like - emily
    Avery(takes sleeping mess) -similar to Spencer.. (Her drug addiction)
    Claire- she kind of looks like Hanna.
    Who's left.. Aria!

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      yeah but there was only 4 of them tina claire sarah and avery

  • @firewoodcast7439
    @firewoodcast7439 9 лет назад

    How did you add the effect that rewinds it

  • @EgyptNile
    @EgyptNile 9 лет назад

    omg bethany is allison sister, she escape the night of allison went missing, and allison mother was on the phone with someone that night, and she was scared. like someone she knew escape from a mental hospital, and may hurt Allison she warn Allison to not go out but she did, bethany had to attack her and Allison mother cover up her so no one will find out bethany is her daugther, and bethany was crazy.

  • @Dllky_
    @Dllky_ 9 лет назад

    what is the song called on 2:05

  • @mindyourbusiness9917
    @mindyourbusiness9917 10 лет назад +2

    At The Ice Ball That Girl Looks Nothing Like Claire , Claire Has Bigger Lips And Her Jaw Is More Elongated , The "Girl" At The Ice Ball Has Small Lips And Her Jaw Is More Round

  • @firewoodcast7439
    @firewoodcast7439 9 лет назад

    How did you do that rewind thing??!

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      Firewood Cast i just reversed the clip and added an effect

  • @konigwolf1
    @konigwolf1 9 лет назад

    Could I have you're song list for this video???

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      sharon doorson -louder, civil twilight - letters from the sky, nylo - take it back

    • @konigwolf1
      @konigwolf1 9 лет назад

      Omg thankyou so much!!

  • @user-nm1hf8uu2i
    @user-nm1hf8uu2i 9 лет назад

    2:21 what ep was that?

  • @gozolavida
    @gozolavida 8 лет назад +1

    That Sara Claire describes doesn't match the robotic Sara we see

  • @shaunascott643
    @shaunascott643 Год назад

    Wait one minute maybe Avery looks like Aria and volunteered at radley and was also a patient there after when Sara Harvey went missing
    Maybe Clair Sara Tina and Avery went to ravenswood high school
    Maybe Avery was the one who kidnapped Alison and Avery dated Cyrus

  • @pyrincess54
    @pyrincess54 9 лет назад

    love the song tho.. thanks..

  • @katelouise4963
    @katelouise4963 9 лет назад

    Hanna was the only one who ever heard that twin thorey story on the halloween ep where alli and hanna were babysitting? and alli tells a story about the twins how one twin killed her sister and got sent away from being mentally disterbed.
    and then ashley ( hannas mom) sees the little blonde girl? only ashley and hanna have seen the twins. but maybe claire and beathany are twins or sarah and alli? i have no motive as to why both girls ended up in the grave.. and if Cece had the yellow top on to? maybe Sarah could have been the one in the grave? and bethany is the real -A?
    and maybe Sarah got sent away for trying to kill Alli? and claire and beathany some how new about it? and Sarah got jealous and told them to threaten all the girls? cause Sarah went missing around the same time as both bethany and alli?

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      I don't think they thought it through when they were writing it because it makes literally no sense... im preparing for a huge letdown... i hope its been mona all along and she tricked them all into thinking someone stole it from her when she was just using it as a cover... hopefully we find out who Bethany actually is in the finale but i doubt it UGH I don't even want to watch the finale it's going to be terrible hopefully im wrong and they surprise me.

    • @katelouise4963
      @katelouise4963 9 лет назад

      i know, its been way to long either way everyone will be dissapointed with who -A is my orignial thought was merdith for some reason

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      It's going to be so hard for them to please everyone... i hope its hanna's mom because no one would see that coming ever and it would be such a good storyline

  • @mayflower7811
    @mayflower7811 7 лет назад

    Bethany may not be A but either she or her twin is AD. BTW does anyone know the song that is playing in the background #PLLENDGAME

  • @daniahabd7603
    @daniahabd7603 9 лет назад

    BTW A is a girl and A is in Ali's funeral in the first episode

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      thats not true that was just a person in a black veil which is very common at funerals

    • @daniahabd7603
      @daniahabd7603 9 лет назад

      True but Marlene said that black viel is an end game! So it means she could be a but Bethany is deffently dead!!

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      yes but the original black veil in the pilot was nothing but an extra back then they didnt plan on bringing her onto the show, and yes bethany is dead unless which i highly doubt that the parents go public saying that they have twin girls like the books

  • @missserenelouise
    @missserenelouise 10 лет назад

    That's actually really clever cause the only two people that heard Claire's voice were Hanna & Emily & the only two people that really heard Bethany's voice were Spencer and Mona. Maybe they are twins. It also makes me suspicious that Aria is the only one that hasn't heard Bethany's/Claire's voice & Marlene King said something about A.M & B.Y being a family or something :/

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  10 лет назад +1

      im 90% sure that A.M B.Y tweet was fake

    • @0xxJulyxx0
      @0xxJulyxx0 10 лет назад +2

      How about A.M is actually Ashley Marin ? If she is mother of bethany, it would make sense why she sees that little girl on halloween. it would also mean that hanna has sister/twin.

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  10 лет назад

      ooooooh dam i never even thought about ashley marin i just thought it was aria, nice nice... i really hope this isnt hanna though its way too obvious for me

    • @Fv3lasquez
      @Fv3lasquez 9 лет назад

      In season one, there is a magnet picture of two blonde girls in the Marin's refrigerator... Every since I saw that I thought hanna had a twin. It would make sense with why Ashley saw the ghost blonde girl and why hanna kept seeing the two blonde girls in ravenswood

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      i honestly think that picture looks like hanna and her mom but i havent really zoomed in to see it exactly but it looks like them... im all for hanna being A /having the twin but its so obvious and i want to be shocked.. im so over pll they arent going to pull this off

  • @BattDrixLestrange
    @BattDrixLestrange 10 лет назад +1

    Amandyne's World - Mode & Beauté Théorie intéressante. Je ne me rappelé plus de ce personnage

    • @AmandynesWorld
      @AmandynesWorld 10 лет назад

      BattDrix Lestrange Oui c'est pas bète :)

    • @BattDrixLestrange
      @BattDrixLestrange 10 лет назад +1

      Je commence à croire à ta théorie de la mise en scène de la Team -A- (S5E14)

    • @97hanabi
      @97hanabi 9 лет назад +1

      Oui, moi aussi je l'avais totalement oubliée, mais je pense que cette théorie n'est pas bête du tout!

  • @blumachine
    @blumachine 9 лет назад

    Wren is A. He is the least expecting suspect. He stays in the shadows, somehow he is always here but not.

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      B🔺STILLE he is the most obvious suspect by far, if it is him its going to be super disappointing he hasn't even been on the show in over a whole season now, still trying to make him relevant by mentioning his name on the show and then have him never even turn up just makes him more suspicious

    • @blumachine
      @blumachine 9 лет назад

      True, we didn't even see him when Spencer went to London. Was he really even there? He made a reappearance when Mona went to Radley, he could be red coat. Mona could've been slowly putting it together that it was him. I think that when she comes back, she is still working for him but we don't know why. we never know why A does these things..

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      I just dont think they can afford him, hes a really successful actor now and it would be so expensive to pay him for such a minor role his character has played, Marlene has been hinting he will be coming back but she lies about everything so who knows anymore

    • @blumachine
      @blumachine 9 лет назад +1

      I guess when you look at it that way... it makes sense. But then again, A can be anyone. Now I'm leaning closer to Aria or Caleb. I don't know if you've heard this song but its called dollhouse and they use it on the 5x25 teaser. I feel like it describes a side of aria we haven't seen before. Listen to the lyrics

    • @LaurenKaminski
      @LaurenKaminski 7 лет назад

      coexist and ghost No he's the most expecting suspect!

  • @isacelliotlover
    @isacelliotlover 10 лет назад

    Great video

  • @BattDrixLestrange
    @BattDrixLestrange 10 лет назад +1

    I thought Meredith, it is present in the first episode

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  10 лет назад +2

      I actually had a dream the other day A took off the burnt alison mask and it was Meredith haha I hope not though she has been gone for too long.

    • @Tom911ization
      @Tom911ization 9 лет назад +1

      Pretty Little Liars id like meridith to be a

  • @commandercharmander8527
    @commandercharmander8527 9 лет назад

    Who is CLAIRE??

    • @AnthonyIvon
      @AnthonyIvon 9 лет назад +1

      She was roommate with Sarah wit another school

  • @dizhairstyles9539
    @dizhairstyles9539 9 лет назад +1

    Charles is A

  • @MP-ec9zb
    @MP-ec9zb 9 лет назад +2

    It 'a not possible.. I mean.. We' ve seen her just once

  • @chichiibegbu6223
    @chichiibegbu6223 7 лет назад

    Maya Is AD

  • @daniahabd7603
    @daniahabd7603 9 лет назад

    What if Claire is Bethany and she just using a different identity name what if Ali was Sara Harvey or the other way around btw I had a dream that Ali killed Spencer and Hanna LOL and buried them in my backyard. Lots of blood 👎

    • @theprincess857
      @theprincess857 9 лет назад

      Ali can't be Sara Harvey , we already saw a picture of Sara and they look nothing alike, but i have a theory that Bethany knew Sara and she lured her to rosewood so that she would be killed and people would think its bethany , btw i had a dream that Maya was alive and showed up and became friends with the liars and started helping them lol

    • @daniahabd7603
      @daniahabd7603 9 лет назад

      LOL that's a good theory
      Do I have any theories about a twin??

    • @daniahabd7603
      @daniahabd7603 9 лет назад

      But wait we already know that Alison lured bethany into rosewood on that night and even gave her a yellow top exactly like Ali's wearing

    • @phoenixfilmtv7322
      @phoenixfilmtv7322  9 лет назад

      Daniah Abd i mean technically we do but do we really? A could of planted that note in alisons basement, thats whats hard about this show because we dont really know anything because you give an answer and it just becomes another question

    • @daniahabd7603
      @daniahabd7603 9 лет назад

      That is show true PhoenixFilmTv but did you guys also catch on on that Marlene king tweeted that one of the girls is a but then she deleted I have a theory that either mike or Melissa or Marion cavanuag or hanna but aria is a big one also Emily LOL lots of questions

  • @alasaundrasilva1040
    @alasaundrasilva1040 9 лет назад

    Mmmmm not likely