@@muhammadfarhans66let's be real, no one thought Jess would've been singing the final adlibs of the songs and most people till this day had issues with the "we are, girls" post chorus since apparently Jess does nothing during said parts in performances
this video now proves that jessica has never been last in an snsd song now and joins taeyeon as the only members who were never last or were in the bottom 3 (lead vocals)
Here in America, it's Thanksgiving Day. One of the things I'm thankful for is this channel. Thanks for keeping SNSD songs alive and presenting them in a new way with new information. Happy Thanksgiving Everyone!
@@abc_jv_xyz personally their "analysis" didn't lead me to believe that Jessica is in the chorus and other parts because I already knew they're super biased
agreed, it's so rare and out of place compared to the rest of their ld's cus even at their fare ld's at least 1/2 of the vocal line is at the top 3 and at least two dance line members at the bottom 3
One of my favorite songs of SNSD, seeing all the members having lots of lines and different layers and harmonies is so refreshing and rare to see, Thank You!
@@muhammadfarhans66 do you have a link to it? because the only Gossip Girls performance I see when I search is the one uploaded by Vitu and Tiffany was the one shown lifting her arm and slightly mouthing it
making the time meter speed up when it's a layered vocal makes absolutely no sense because the member doesn't actually sing twice it's literally the same line with layered vocals, this counting is not wise to say the least
Logically is not singing twice but said harmonies are still recorded by the same member but with a different tone and pitch, so that's why is counted multiple times
the layers are sang (and recorded) not in the same way as the melody of the said line so it makes sense that they are counted separately. the better argument is if it is wise to recount the same line and its layers when it shows up again in the song (for example, the chorus) when the singing's only recorded once 😅 but i'm not here to argue about that, i agree with how everything's counted here.
![Girls' Generation (SNSD) • All Songs Line Distribution [CORRECTED]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vr-xWMEP1VA/mqdefault.jpg)
![Girls' Generation ~ All Songs Line Distribution [from Into the New World to FOREVER 1]](/img/1.gif)
if you tried to tell me that yoona would have twice jessicas lines in a song i wouldnt believe you..
The revenge of dance lines and possibly Jessica as she is always counted as 7s in other ld video.
Bcs it was based on color coded lyrics, which hasn't been updated since 2013. Ccl really need to update their page.
@@muhammadfarhans66let's be real, no one thought Jess would've been singing the final adlibs of the songs and most people till this day had issues with the "we are, girls" post chorus since apparently Jess does nothing during said parts in performances
also Taeyeon, who's always put 5/6th when she's actually 4th
@@abc_jv_xyz she's 4th
@@Oliver-uz1fs fixed it
Seeing Jessica with over 20 seconds in this song is insane
Seohyun really went from 8th to 2nd in All Vocals
this video now proves that jessica has never been last in an snsd song now and joins taeyeon as the only members who were never last or were in the bottom 3 (lead vocals)
I mean, the main vocals
Also this means that Tae is 1st on the album distribution and that Jess is 3rd
@@Oliver-uz1fs yup, this proves TiTaeSeo are not the top 3
Dance line having decent hidden vocals is so surprising
Here in America, it's Thanksgiving Day. One of the things I'm thankful for is this channel. Thanks for keeping SNSD songs alive and presenting them in a new way with new information. Happy Thanksgiving Everyone!
seohyun jumping from 8th in lead vocals to 1st in background vocals 😭
i don't know if it's the combination of voices or the production but Sooyoung is so clear in the chorus
Remember when we all thought it was due to a mix of JeTiSeo? Yeah
@@Oliver-uz1fs divadream fooled us all
@@abc_jv_xyz personally their "analysis" didn't lead me to believe that Jessica is in the chorus and other parts because I already knew they're super biased
@@Kom26Music for me it was easier to believe Jessica was on the chorus than to believe Sooyoung was
@@abc_jv_xyzsame here, I also heard Soo a while but SeoFany where so clear to me as well so I thought those where some effects or layers
The way I overlooked this song for so long but omg, I’m obsessed now
dance line outdid vocal line by a pretty big margin there lol
This is possibly one of the weirdest snsd rankings
1 - 3: YoonYulHyo
4 - 6: TaeTiJess
7 - 9: SooSeoSun
I think the bottom 3 is normal, SunSeo rarely get as many lines in japanese songs as TaeJeTi and Sooyoung is part of the dance line
@@abc_jv_xyz all 3 of them have never been on the bottom 3 together
agreed, it's so rare and out of place compared to the rest of their ld's cus even at their fare ld's at least 1/2 of the vocal line is at the top 3 and at least two dance line members at the bottom 3
Haha it's weird and rare but i love it💕 guess this song is special for our Dance Line😌
Our Dance Line YoonYulHyo definitely our Gossip Girls🤭💕💕💕
This distribution is something you don't see every day.
Yoona is the first and only dance line member to get 1st place in a song to this day, even if we count Oh!GG
@@BstansforB didn’t Yuri also get a first? Can’t remember what song it was
@@shrugemoji7476 It was the wrong version of FOREVER 1, but Tiffany is first
@@BstansforB Ah I see
@@BstansforBNo, Tiffany not 1st. LOL
Taeyeon is 1st technically
Dance Line ate this song
Jessica OUTDID that 7s
Jessica belting that F5 is still co crazy
Jessica lines didn't show much on this song, but let's agree these F5 adlibs is crazy af
So it is Sunny who is last all this time not Sica, Poor Sunny mistreatment
Gossip Girls had a unique combo!!👏🏼✨️
without "Gossip Gossip~," Hyoyeon would have 0.9 second of line.
One of my favorite songs of SNSD, seeing all the members having lots of lines and different layers and harmonies is so refreshing and rare to see, Thank You!
Since those ad-libs are not done by Tiffany, Taeyeon's probably 1st on this album
Interesting line distribution
Wow, I thougt Seohyun would be 4th or 5th, didn't expect to be 2nd
Poor SunSic
Also, I have some song suggestions
(Motorcycle, Do The Catwalk, Karma Butterfly & Blue Jeans)
Jess is on every single song in the rest of the album so I'm nor concerned about her
Poor Sunny though
@@Oliver-uz1fstrue
Okay my comment aged really bad and glad for it
2:51 isn't Tiffany?
In L&P tour, the video shows that Taeyeon was in the center and mouthing that part.
@@muhammadfarhans66 do you have a link to it? because the only Gossip Girls performance I see when I search is the one uploaded by Vitu and Tiffany was the one shown lifting her arm and slightly mouthing it
@@girlsgenerationtaylorsversionruclips.net/video/PWnQj9MhGXs/видео.htmlsi=OAoEdtraEW3_GiOr Idk, but maybe this could help
I’m a Sica bias but honestly I never listen her voice in her shared parts in here :/
Wow, 2h sáng cô còn chưa ngủ
Up nhanh để đổi qua bài khác đóooo
@@thedoradora ủa cô ơi, bài Summer Night đâu rồi á cô
@@anhmaingo tui private để check lại background ùi .-.
making the time meter speed up when it's a layered vocal makes absolutely no sense because the member doesn't actually sing twice it's literally the same line with layered vocals, this counting is not wise to say the least
Logically is not singing twice but said harmonies are still recorded by the same member but with a different tone and pitch, so that's why is counted multiple times
the layers are sang (and recorded) not in the same way as the melody of the said line so it makes sense that they are counted separately. the better argument is if it is wise to recount the same line and its layers when it shows up again in the song (for example, the chorus) when the singing's only recorded once 😅 but i'm not here to argue about that, i agree with how everything's counted here.
Go Sunny, give us NOTHING 🤩