I love this film. I've lost count the times I've watched it. My first time in 1959, that I remember. Excellent direction, acting, technique and sound for the time, 1934, when the international sound system in cinematography was in its infance. Being a socialist myself, needless to say, that I enjoy it even more. p.s.- Its preservation, fortunately, is superb. Long live the Russian Soviet Revolution !
@CAVKING19DELTA TEXAS Learn a difference between communism and socialism. Also seems like you don't understand the context pushed Mao into having to kill some people in cultural revolution, but it was kind of worth it. Also thats other topic than Gulags. Also, socialist countries was more successful than capitalism, say Cuba, USSR, SFRJ, Makhnovtchina, Manchuria, Zapatista, Aragon... Only their socialist period (some went capitalist afterwards), and results relative to point where they started, they became more developed relative to rest of world.
@CAVKING19DELTA TEXAS How were all of these places forced into conservatism? I've never heard the Anarchists in Aragon making homosexuality illegal or pushing conservative views.
Si on met de côté l'aspect idéologique ou propagande, ce film reste une magnifique illustration de certains aspects de la guerre civile russe et du quotidien russe des années 20 / 30 : les maisons, villages, les chants, les vêtements, les charges de cosaques, les postures tactiques de l'époque, les rapports entre individus dont les ambiguités ... Bref ce film parvient à saisir une "atmosphère" de l'époque, comme une carte postale.
@@veljko0864 Not much but there is : you find the good one (red), the bad one (white), the strenght of the army of peasants. Look at the famous charge by the "aristocrats" at 1,00,06, the tragic end of the 2 heroes at the end shot at the back by ine aristocrat : the message is clear But yes, it is not "Oktober " by Eisenstein ....
Красивая сказка. Мифы советской России о героях, необходимое условие пропагандистской машины. В реальности, с одной стороны всё было гораздо жёстче, грубее и бесчеловечнее, а с другой стороны Чапаев воевал не за большевиков, и не за коммунистов. И этот момент отлично обыгран в фильме. Так бывает. В куче непотребства блестит бриллиант.
@@user-wl9cn5kw1eГений , В РФ сносят памятники Ленину и большевикам , Ставят памятники Краснову , Колчаку , Маннергейму . Извратили смысл 9 мая , сколько антисоветских фильмов про ВОВ сняли (Утомленные Солнцем , На Париж , Штрафбат , Сволочи и т.д.) . В какой пропоганде можно обвинить РФ , так это в антикоммунистической ,а потом уже в антизападной политике , поскольку тот же Путин хотел и в НАТО и в Евросоюз . По антисоветским сказкам Путина можно книгу написать . И вообще что ты знаешь о чапаеве.Он участник Октябрьской революции и начальник дивизии красной армии ?
Последний бой Чапаева произошёл ранним утром 5 сентября 1919 года в селе Лбищенское, это было побоище. Фурманов Д. так описывал последствия катастрофы- там за Лбищенском есть старые кирпичные ямы они были доверху заполнены изувеченными и изрубленными трупами крассноармейцев. Но и у казаков это была последняя военная удача, атаман Толстов с войском после этого только отступал до Гурьева и дальше в Иран. Бессмысленная братоубийственная война. Я думаю что если бы Чапаев не погиб его бы обязательно расстреляли в 37 году. Так что своей славой и легендой он обязан казакам.
Зря думаешь - совсем не факт. Многие из тех, кто в белой армии служили, благополучно пережили 1937 год. Гугли генерал Шапкин например))) Ну или маршал Говоров.
Одной из первых жертв при узурпации власти Сталиным был как раз Фрунзе. Командир Чапаева. Никто из его окружения не поверил в его мнимую болезнь и быструю смерть.
Ottimo film, peccato che il nostro eroe di origine contadine, partecipò alla repressione delle rivolte contadine per togliere pane e cibo ai contadini stessi in nome dello Stato.
The movie is high qualited as many other soviet movies. But i would like to say to those who likes the USSR that you are happy because you didn't live there. It was a big prison.
Such a big prison, the Soviet scientists got sick of being trapped and built rockets that could reach space while the Americans enjoyed the freedom of banning evolution and other sciences in schools because it made Jesus mad.
@@UntrusiveThoughts The soviet government used scientists as slaves. I would tell about the death of Serhij Korolyov. I think it will be enough. The official version conceals certain details, which, in fact, were the cause of death. During one of the interrogations, an NKVD investigator struck Serhiy Korolyov in the face with a decanter, resulting in a large-scale fracture of the jaw. In the camps, the bones fused incorrectly, causing the Queen's jaws to no longer be able to fully open. Due to these consequences, during the operation Korolyov could not be intubated urgently - that is, to insert a tube into his trachea for artificial respiration and to maintain the level of oxygen in the blood. Most likely, this is what led to an increase in heart failure and subsequent death.
@@Tamara-yc8ho Wow, what kind of made up BS is this lol? Korolyov was already quite unhealthy towards the end of his life, having had a heart attack as well as abdominal cancer and hemorrhoids. There was no guarantee that even intubation would've saved somebody who was quite literally on the cusp of dying due to ill health. Spare the BS for people who aren't going to fact check your ranting. I'm more than familiar with the ineffectual "debating" methods folks like you think is clever.
@@UntrusiveThoughts Key words of my post are that he was prisoned and beaten there. Vavilov was shot. And many other facts... In addition read please works by A. Sakharov.
Reading Stephen Kotkin’s biography of Stalin. This film was mentioned because he realized after seeing this how cinema can be a useful propaganda tool. I figured it’d be on RUclips, a product of the awesomeness of capitalism!
Kotkins, Snyder, COnquest are propagandists or bad scientists. Read Grover Furr if you need the real history of USSR. Or watch his video lectures on youtube.
This movie is better than anything else I've seen from that time. It has soul, excitement, and witty lines.
From that time do you mean before ww2 or specifically the social realism post-montage years?
@@Reionder The 1930s
@@makita3680 Ah I agree
Друг. Рекомендую вам посмотреть: Путёвка в жизнь. И многие другие снятые при Сталине.
Good film, excellent portrayals, and direction. I particularly liked the lighting and the singing was superb.
I love this film. I've lost count the times I've watched it. My first time in 1959, that I remember. Excellent direction, acting, technique and sound for the time, 1934, when the international sound system in cinematography was in its infance. Being a socialist myself, needless to say, that I enjoy it even more. p.s.- Its preservation, fortunately, is superb. Long live the Russian Soviet Revolution !
yes and let's remember the tens of millions who died as slaves in the gulags
The amount barely exceed 1mil
i fully agree!!!
@CAVKING19DELTA TEXAS Learn a difference between communism and socialism. Also seems like you don't understand the context pushed Mao into having to kill some people in cultural revolution, but it was kind of worth it. Also thats other topic than Gulags. Also, socialist countries was more successful than capitalism, say Cuba, USSR, SFRJ, Makhnovtchina, Manchuria, Zapatista, Aragon... Only their socialist period (some went capitalist afterwards), and results relative to point where they started, they became more developed relative to rest of world.
@CAVKING19DELTA TEXAS How were all of these places forced into conservatism? I've never heard the Anarchists in Aragon making homosexuality illegal or pushing conservative views.
What a great movie I had to watch the for my Russian film class and wow its so good.
Such a movie... Watched it for the first time... Got here from Song about Chapaev
I am here, on a new account, and now I am watching it for the fourth time!
@@lesleyzore987 ნ
Same
Great movie. Thanks.
Si on met de côté l'aspect idéologique ou propagande, ce film reste une magnifique illustration de certains aspects de la guerre civile russe et du quotidien russe des années 20 / 30 : les maisons, villages, les chants, les vêtements, les charges de cosaques, les postures tactiques de l'époque, les rapports entre individus dont les ambiguités ... Bref ce film parvient à saisir une "atmosphère" de l'époque, comme une carte postale.
I'm surprised, there isn't as much propaganda as one would think
@@veljko0864 Not much but there is : you find the good one (red), the bad one (white), the strenght of the army of peasants. Look at the famous charge by the "aristocrats" at 1,00,06, the tragic end of the 2 heroes at the end shot at the back by ine aristocrat : the message is clear But yes, it is not "Oktober " by Eisenstein ....
Now its 7th november so i watch this
54:31 on 2x speed you wont regret it
With all that singing, I was beginning to think this was a musical!
Chapayev the hero!
Lenin lived. Lenin lives. Lenin will live.Da zdravstvuyet nasha krasnaya sovetskaya rodina! Hurrah!
на одном дыхании посмотрел.
Bravo ! Eu ouvi falarem muito bem deste filme, finalmente poderei assistir !
Banned in the Philippines in 1940
Por que?
@@nathanhiggers4606 Fears of communist uprising probably idk
how did that happen
puntin love this movie
hello wittenberg gang who didnt do the coursework until the last week
Stop I'm in this class right now lmaooo
Putin's favorite movie, not a joke
Красивая сказка. Мифы советской России о героях, необходимое условие пропагандистской машины.
В реальности, с одной стороны всё было гораздо жёстче, грубее и бесчеловечнее, а с другой стороны Чапаев воевал не за большевиков, и не за коммунистов. И этот момент отлично обыгран в фильме. Так бывает. В куче непотребства блестит бриллиант.
@@user-wl9cn5kw1eГений , В РФ сносят памятники Ленину и большевикам , Ставят памятники Краснову , Колчаку , Маннергейму . Извратили смысл 9 мая , сколько антисоветских фильмов про ВОВ сняли (Утомленные Солнцем , На Париж , Штрафбат , Сволочи и т.д.) . В какой пропоганде можно обвинить РФ , так это в антикоммунистической ,а потом уже в антизападной политике , поскольку тот же Путин хотел и в НАТО и в Евросоюз . По антисоветским сказкам Путина можно книгу написать . И вообще что ты знаешь о чапаеве.Он участник Октябрьской революции и начальник дивизии красной армии ?
No, Putin hates Lenin and the revolution. He likes the zarist period and the stalinist period, because he's nationalist.
Отличный фильм, и, по слухам, Иосиф Сталин смотрел его не менее 38 раз!
59:34
Your welcome
thank you
Hello Russian 10 friends...
Now i know why Putin loves this show
Fun fact: This is Vladimir putin favorite movie.
It sounds like they dubbed some new sound effects in to give it a more "Modern" sound.
Yes, and it sounds like they removed some of the music
@@Reionder A lot of 30s Soviet films sound like they were re-dubbed in the 60s or 70s.
@@antoniod that's sad.. I like the sound of the originals, it's very unique
That was an ending.
Супер
слава героям революции
Idź do diabła przeklęty bolszewiku i sługusie putina.
hello HI206 pals
Последний бой Чапаева произошёл ранним утром 5 сентября 1919 года в селе Лбищенское, это было побоище. Фурманов Д. так описывал последствия катастрофы- там за Лбищенском есть старые кирпичные ямы они были доверху заполнены изувеченными и изрубленными трупами крассноармейцев. Но и у казаков это была последняя военная удача, атаман Толстов с войском после этого только отступал до Гурьева и дальше в Иран. Бессмысленная братоубийственная война. Я думаю что если бы Чапаев не погиб его бы обязательно расстреляли в 37 году. Так что своей славой и легендой он обязан казакам.
Зря думаешь - совсем не факт. Многие из тех, кто в белой армии служили, благополучно пережили 1937 год. Гугли генерал Шапкин например))) Ну или маршал Говоров.
За что бы его расстреляли?
Одной из первых жертв при узурпации власти Сталиным был как раз Фрунзе. Командир Чапаева. Никто из его окружения не поверил в его мнимую болезнь и быструю смерть.
Who's here because this is Putin's fav movie?
А где вся музыка?
I wonder what Chapaev would think of Putin?
100% Negative
Pet'ka: Chapaev, what would you say about Putin?
Chapaev: Rasstrelyat'.
@@Andrey-Lyan Putin's hero is Tsar Alexander III, Chapaev's is, obviously like Stalin's, Lenin.
To shoot him on the spot
Stalin's favourite movie
So this is putins favorite movie
Stalin's favorite movie.
Лучший фильм о Путине.
4:30 and now try to hide the m 60 as well
Ottimo film, peccato che il nostro eroe di origine contadine, partecipò alla repressione delle rivolte contadine per togliere pane e cibo ai contadini stessi in nome dello Stato.
Chi le ha detto queste stronzate?
15:00
русские субтиры где мы что америке живем чтоли
А зачем вам субтитры?
В Ютуб можно и с русскими субтитрами найти и на этом канале тоже.
И свою культуру двигать нужно, в той же Америке.
make you're movies be collard
The movie is high qualited as many other soviet movies. But i would like to say to those who likes the USSR that you are happy because you didn't live there. It was a big prison.
Such a big prison, the Soviet scientists got sick of being trapped and built rockets that could reach space while the Americans enjoyed the freedom of banning evolution and other sciences in schools because it made Jesus mad.
@@UntrusiveThoughts The soviet government used scientists as slaves. I would tell about the death of Serhij Korolyov. I think it will be enough. The official version conceals certain details, which, in fact, were the cause of death. During one of the interrogations, an NKVD investigator struck Serhiy Korolyov in the face with a decanter, resulting in a large-scale fracture of the jaw. In the camps, the bones fused incorrectly, causing the Queen's jaws to no longer be able to fully open. Due to these consequences, during the operation Korolyov could not be intubated urgently - that is, to insert a tube into his trachea for artificial respiration and to maintain the level of oxygen in the blood. Most likely, this is what led to an increase in heart failure and subsequent death.
@@Tamara-yc8ho Wow, what kind of made up BS is this lol? Korolyov was already quite unhealthy towards the end of his life, having had a heart attack as well as abdominal cancer and hemorrhoids. There was no guarantee that even intubation would've saved somebody who was quite literally on the cusp of dying due to ill health.
Spare the BS for people who aren't going to fact check your ranting. I'm more than familiar with the ineffectual "debating" methods folks like you think is clever.
@@UntrusiveThoughts Key words of my post are that he was prisoned and beaten there. Vavilov was shot. And many other facts... In addition read please works by A. Sakharov.
Ты врёшь! Я жил в СССР. Тюрьма в твоей голове.
Reading Stephen Kotkin’s biography of Stalin. This film was mentioned because he realized after seeing this how cinema can be a useful propaganda tool. I figured it’d be on RUclips, a product of the awesomeness of capitalism!
Kotkins, Snyder, COnquest are propagandists or bad scientists. Read Grover Furr if you need the real history of USSR. Or watch his video lectures on youtube.
comparing to western propagandists soviets were a child.
Stephen Kotkin is not worth the attention. His lies are completely ridiculous. He's like a dwarf compared to titans like Dr. Goebbels or Solzhenitsyn.
Frunze is mentioned more than once in this flick.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mikhail_Frunze
Frunze commanded the front where Chapaev assigned (West Kazakhstan).