I think that comparatively kai's skin IS slightly tanner, but imo he's also the hottest exo member and im glad kai has learned to embrace his skin tone
(Im Asian) My skin color isn’t even dark I get made fun of or being “black” and I’m not even fat (I weigh 100 lbs and I’m 5’ 1) well at least my friends say I’m not but I get call black, fat, ugly, etc by my family. I know when some are joking or when they’re not but either way I’ve been told this ever since I was 7 up until now. Honestly I have pretty bad confidence, I just wish Asians don’t have HIGH HIGH standards for beauty. Most of the time when people tell me this stuff now I go to my room and cry. Now I think that beauty is not defined with femininity, masculinity, weight, height, etc. 💗 edit: Well i forgot i commented this- I dont have to say what i do weigh now but its more than 100 now lol. Anyways still going on but i dont give a sh what they say now so :]
it sucks because in Korea, they seem to associate darker skin with more sexy and chic concepts and lighter skin with more beautiful and cute concepts, when in reality it doesn’t matter on the shade of your skin.
@Mariah Palmer Of course it’s not, because it’s rude and disrespectful no matter if your pale or dark. I’m just stating the fact that just because someone doesn’t fit a beauty standard doesn’t give you a right to make fun of the color of their skin or to tell them they’re not pretty just because they don’t match the standards and to be more open minded of others. I’m not saying that people with pale skin don’t get bullied also.
@@reemtsuki795 u not seeing it from all perspectives just because they have a beauty standard dont mean everyone has to follow them and it doesn't make it right to shame something thats different from it either they literally bully and make fun of darker members or the ones with more weight and thats not right so yea ur literally defending them😐
When kai said "i dont have any plans to become paler" it was the best thing i hope people who look up to him and have been teased for their skin tone learn to love themselves. Also what exo was doing was not racist but was colourist
@@illusion743 I m sick of such people sometimes when I go to the Beach a my skin gets tanned in summer people be like gurl what happened to your face? Why do u look like that u should not stay too much in the sun! And u look burned I feel offended tbh these kind of people don't make me comfortable coz I know their standards are so fucked up and need to be educated
i'm an asian and it's very common here that "the paler you are, the more beautiful you are" kinda thing and it is sickening, i myself have tan skin and my skin is darker than most of my friends and i often got teased about it since i was so young and i was always insecure about it. but the more i grew up the more i love my skin color, just like kai said : i don't have any plans to become paler
My eldest sister was also teased about her dark skin from when she was just a kid to now when she's married. She also felt insecure about it and used to buy whitening products till this day. She also been called ugly and 'not that pretty' bc of her skin colour. The most annoying thing is that half of my own family members and all our reletives are the ones always making remarks about her skin and they don't know what they're doing is not right(idk how but...). Plus, I'm also from asia.
@@Cocotubeline sameee me too, mostly are from relatives istg idk what’s wrong with asian’s family are sometimes toxic and soooo close minded. i got teased by my grandma’s sisters bc i use a darker toned foundation than all of my cousins and kept on telling me to use whitening products more, i remember it was thanksgiving and i couldn’t handle the bullshits so i went home by uber all by myself lol
I'm a very pale European with a lot of Chinese colleagues, and pretty much all of them have commented on my skin tone being 'ideal' or 'pretty', it's so weird to me. One girl didn't want to go out in the sun to picknick cause she was scared of getting a tan, while here that's literally the beauty standard :/
I think a lot of people in general wouldn’t hold another race to their beauty standards like they would for someone from that same ethnicity/race (I’m excluding racists from this).
@@letyv9071 still it's just really bothersome and extremely petty human behaviour which belongs to junior school. sadly alot of young koreans doesn't seem to grow up as quickly as in other cultures.
@@sneakerjuice1856 I agree that this seems immature but its not really that that lets them get away with these types of comments. It seems more of a lack of caring and empathy for others when making these types of comments. I really dont want to contribute colorist comments to immaturity. They know what they are doing.
literally in all the videos theyre all the same color💀 and the fact they make fun of him for being "tan" when they all bleach their skin like... you'd be that color too if u didnt whiten urself
They still comfort kai When everyone made fun of kai (not exo ones) Baekhyun praised Him Said he loves kai’s skin so they are friends like super close like family
Ikr. except namjoon tho. He always apologizes for it before any American concert. I mean not all of them are bad 🥺 Edit: My Comment sounded a bit bad. I meant that a lot of them have apologized and was using namjoon as an example.
I'm sorry to say this but from MY EXPERIENCE Canadians(Yellowknife) were racist as HELL to me and almost every other black person I knew there. Like seriously wow... they were just straight up racist... like not even tryna hide it... they were more racist to me than the locals in Texas... like darn!!! ( again from experience they are racist too)I just came for a short visit and it was almost ruined because of the strangers passing by and saying " yo yo what's up girl" " I play basketball and eat watermelon" They acted like I was the only black person in the entire city... and they even do the same to ther random black ppl too!!!! But obviously I'm not saying ALL Canadians in Yellowknife are racist. They were a few nice ppl. I just dont think slave history is taught as much in Canada and they have less education on it, although they're parents shoulda taught them better...
Because Wendy lived in Canada for most of her childhood, she was asked to show how people (black + white) behave there. It was a stereotype based on what she experienced there.
@@koyakream key words, NOT ALL. Don't get me wrong, I'm mixed (native american+black+german) and I've been discriminated a lot but rlly, not all of this is racist, but rather colourist and/or ignorant.
@@neocrackheadtechnology3395 If this isn't racism then can you explain why exo kept picking on Kai's tan skin color? If they think he's that dark then they would hate black people's skin color...
@@emaleigh7812 it’s more commonly referred to as AAVE (African American Vernacular English) she was mostly copying the stereotypical mannerisms that black women do. which was yes, very wrong,
@@millieart9638 no there literally is😭 it’s called aave which is African American vernacular and it can be considered a dialect. That term is also more commonly referred to as “black english” which consists of words like “chile” “sis” “lit” “woke” “i feel you” etc. There’s also a term called ebonics that is considered a language in its own that most black people use and talk like.
@@kimm9086 hmmm. i get that you're trying to be nice, and that it's a compliment, but i feel like there's a better way to word it(?) like. maybe like saying smth like 'personally, i really like [certain ethnicity/race]'s [something, eg. traditional music, style of traditional clothing, etc.] like yeah. i feel like that's a lot better than just saying a whole race/ethnicity is cool if u get me
@@Sana-jc9xc It doesn’t matter WHEN they did it. They still did it. The only thing that matters now is whether or not they’ve educated themselves and grown as a normal human being.
@@jazaiofficial1167 I'm sure that they talked with each other and educated themselves. all the videos is an old clip, and actually in the last clip (6:38) they compliment his skin colour.
@@Sana-jc9xc These weren't all the clips and these colorist comments extended well past 2013 (those radio clips were Call me Baby era); and I didn't even see some of the worst ones in this video. There was even a pretty bad one just last year. Its shocking to think that EXO barely did any interviews/variety shows, and still every other one there was a colorist comment towards Kai's skin. Imagine what was said when the cameras weren't on. And the footage from EXO Showtime esp was horrible; all of those comments were approved by editors/producers to release to the public, like wtf. The first and only time I watched it I was horrified. The way Kai's face fell after every comment about his skin made me want to cry. Baek and Chan were always the ones to take it too far. Asking if Kai wanted to go in for skin whitening??? Even Sehun looked disgusted with that comment (btw its interesting that the members closest to Kai then never made a peep about his skin. Kyungsoo and Sehun knew how much it bothered him.) The members never apologized nor expressed remorse for how they treated him, and I can and will hold that against those who made those comments until they address it. They were in their twenties, and Kai was one of their maknaes who couldn't really fight back.; there's no excuse.
@@Sana-jc9xc Whoa that was rambling (spacing would be helpful with such a long reply btw). Youre assuming a lot with no evidence at all. We dont know what goes on behind the scenes, which is why addressing this topic would be beneficial to fans who are uncomfortable with the members basically bullying Kai for so long, way before pre-debut. EXO is still gaining fans and they are going back to watch all those interviews and shows, and that in itself makes it relevant today. And the name Chan saved Kai's name as in his phone? Inexcusable. I don't care if they finally started to reel back the comments after seeing Kai looking so hurt. Why tf say those things in the first place? Because they actually thought it was funny. And you are defending that.........gross. I dont believe for one second you are a Kai bias lmao. Making fun of teenager much younger than them, since pre-debut, over something he can't control, then saying now its not a big deal. Pls. And yes, many fans would like to see the members apologize. What does how long ago matter? This was only 5 or so years ago that this was happening; which says a lot about their opinion of dark skinned Asians. It doesnt have to be a public statement, just a couple words on a live or even just Jongin saying he received an apology or talked to them about it.
@@Sana-jc9xc So you're saying the members don't want to apologize....that's even worse 😭 We all know SM won't address situations until they absolutely have to. Unfortunately this issue has been ignored and buried by both the company and, even more disappointedly, fans themselves. Holding idols accountable for their actions is not a bad thing; some statements/actions come to light that were years and years ago and just bc time has passed doesn't negate how hurtful or damaging they were. I really don't understand where you're coming from at all. And Exols asking others to ignore or forget these colorist statements and even outright bullying are part of the problem.
exactly that’s what made it hard to get over wendy’s stereotyping because i’m pretty sure she was in canada long enough to know what’s right from wrong
@knockoff chanel yea certain parts of Canada are racist as hell(from experience) But I'm not gonna say it isnt their fault or it is. I dont really care but they all know its wrong. Canadian social media isnt too different from American social media. They know what they are doing. (Certain Canadians) Anyway who body shamed Wendy?
knockoff chanel i agree bullying is wrong but people always use situations like this to publicly release their pent up animosity against members which is a whole other issue. idk so many people have spoke about this apology but i’ve still never seen it or heard what she said to apologise. obviously sm don’t so i understand that maybe wendy could have felt regretful but idk.
lolo pari what she said was definitely bad but lowkey I feel like her company may have had her to do? Considering it happened 2 times and a lot of these questions are staged. And like I know she could’ve said no but like SM entertainment has been know to be more controlling compare to others. But that’s just a thought idk the truth.
@bts army well ur friend is certainly different... But honestly I dont think it matters how you treat someone if you make fun of them behind their backs...
@bts army yes of course It depends on where you live. It's just that most of these stars are from the WEST where slavery is taught most. That's what makes it hit different. I'm from a different country as well but we still know about slavery. Well you're right tho, some ppl dont know. But someone like wendy shoulda known. I mean she lived in Canada. Oh and ur from south Asia right? That's cool. Had a lotta friends from there Although I know colourism is prominent around there and white skin is more favoured. But this was due to colonization from the British not African slavery so it must be different there. And for the jihyo one, I dont think the dressing was racist. I could dress up as a local cowgirl and no one would say crap. But for the Indian cry, that was racist.
bts army i agree! i think it’s more ignorance than anything. (although there may be some idols that are actually racist, but let’s hope that’s not true) especially with the n word, that’s a word that is from american history and people outside of ameerica might not know what it means other than hearing african american people use it. i had that experience with a german friend of mine, and once it was explained to him he felt horrible. the costumes tho? and the comments about tan skin and such? i will say those really don’t sit well with me.
only wendy and hwasa get dragged for this, even if hwasa apologized ? idk i dont stan mamamoo lol but if you say something about bts past racism they'll tell you you're weaponizing racism and "they apologized/learn from their mistakes" when only one member apologized the others didnt say sht...but they defend them only bcz they're men
momo didn't deserve anything. she said "when I was 6, I started to dance" the subtitles were based off the song lyrics. this is coming from an actual black person btw
you can tell how uncomfortable kai is feeling when they're bringing up and joking about how "dark" his skin color is, and i feel bad but makes me happy that he loves his skin color just the way it is
Actually the members love his skin tone too. Chanyeol said he envy kai’s skin tone caise he looks more masculin and hot. Even in one video, sehun’s makeup is one shade below his true skin tone (cause he’s pale af) to look a lil bit tan to add hot and sexy look.
that's the one thing that triggered me the most in this video, like if my white american friends don't know ab roots and kunta kinte but they do...they know ab racism and they knew what they were doing smh
Not even trying to make excuses for him, because I was real pissed off when the accurate translation came out for what he said, since I'm a black exo-l. But apparently "kunta kinte" is a derogatory/slang term used in SK for people that have full lips. Which is still messed up.
I love the fact that despite how toxic society and its critics are, Kai has learned to love his skin color. I feel really sad about the comments that her members made to him, but it comforts me a little that they are old clips and that their way of thinking has evolved over time.
As far as I know they've apologised and haven't said those things in years, they do look close and tell Kai that he's handsome often and care about him, but I agree that what they said about his skin wasn't right and that they shouldn't have done it.
not everyone outside from the US takes skin color jokes as seriously. i’m from a foreign country and people joke about skin color and how pale/tan you are all the time. it’s not meant to be racist either so please think about that. the world doesn’t revolve around american mindsets
@@picapicaculo just because its not meant to be racist, IT STILL IS. Racism is a global issue, not just an American one. People die everyday because they are a little darker.
I don't think it was racist. I mean u listen to kpop (i think) and u know the Korean beauty standards with being pale are considered as beautiful and Kai was tanned so they weren't saying u are black that's disgusting they were saying u are dark, darker than the beauty standard in Korea. It wasn't racist at all just from watching and thinking about it for a second.
honestly , like i get it . racism in korea isnt taught much , but they are all grown men and woman . im pretty sure they can educate themselves with the internet . if i can understand “hyung , annyeonghaseyo , dongsaeng , gamhamsamnida , ect” and learn hangul they can simply google if something is racist or not
hyunjinnie True. Yeah I’m moreso just confused why they can’t apologize and then educate themselves afterwards. What’s with the silence? .. The thing that upsets me the most are the fans though. Like they’re really out here defending and babying grown ass men and women. It’s ridiculous.
@Jour Den agreed , and its worst because the fans know its wrong but force themselves to think its okay and defend them , wouldnt it be better if they just apologized and addressed the situation ?? normalize holding your faves accountable and normalize them apologizing
The kai thing is actually so sad and the fact that I experience this on a daily bases with my family makes me upset even more cuz I know what he’s going thru
As far as I know they've apologised and haven't said those things in years, they do look close, especially Kyungsoo, Sehun and Kai, and tell Kai that he's handsome often and care about him a lot, but I agree that what they said about his skin wasn't right and that they shouldn't have done it and I'm really sorry about what you have to go through with your family, no one deserves that. You look beautiful no matter what and the colour or tone of someone's skin doesn't change that at all, all colours are beautiful!
@@Kalakeiko ofc I know sometimes ppl are ignorant but change or they rlly don’t mean it in a bad way and that’s just their way of joking 🙃 so no hard feeling but in those clips I genuinely felt bad
And then you got kpop idols who are from America using the n word acting like they dont know the meaning behind it🙄 Edit: i think i found who i was talking about. Her name is Julie Han and she was rapping to a song for YG and said the N word. She was singing the same song Jennie (black pink) rapped to for one of her auditions as a trainee, and there controversy over if Jennie also said the N word (i think she did).
@Tiger Bear can't remember her name but she was singing a cover to a song and didn't skip over the n word. I watched it a while ago so sry for not remembering who she is exactly.
true cause if they’re from america there’s a high chance they’ve heard it and know the meaning but since in korea african culture and black history isn’t really taught it the possibility is very low i guess
Agreed! As far as I know they've apologised and haven't said those things in years, they do look close and tell Kai that he's handsome often and care about him, but I agree that what they said about his skin wasn't right and that they shouldn't have done it.
and a lot of kpop stans use ‘but namjoon’ as an excuse for their faves actions. atleast namjoon has actually said an apology and learned from his mistakes
@@m1sh743 yeah and sometimes even when idols make mistakes and apologize, they end up making the same mistake again, or they don't really learn from it. while I don't know about the other idols in the video, ik tht namjoon has grown, you can tell from the lyrics he writes, the way he talks and whatnot
I am a Korean and to be honest when idols are celebrities stereotype other cultures I feel offended because it's really rude. But some Koreans say that its fine since other white and black people make racist jokes about Asians. But no! People need to know that racism is a global thing and it's not just for one race and you should respect all races. In kpop there have been many racist things but when that group does something racist the fandom always defends their idol but when another group are racist they attack them for being racist. The fact you are doing is just sad. Your idol and someone else's idol did the same mistake but you attack them. You should never defend your idol and educate them. But other fandoms shouldn't send hate and actually help educate them. Canceling the idols, sending death threats, and defending your idols is not educating. But please remember that not all Koreans are racist. Also, sometimes the entertainment does not let the idols apologize for their mistakes.
Oh, what a beautiful comment, thank you Sometimes we as international fans have a bad image about Koreans , but I'm really surprised that there is people like you
Also as a Korean (well actually White- Korean) when my Asian friends make jokes about other cultures I feel offended because of the lack of respect they are showing.
@@wilsonsele9096 you’re right! I’ve had many come at me for saying something similar. I wasn’t disrespectful about it either, they’re just insensitive 😳
I’m tired of these non black people in these comments trying to tell us how to feel about these situations. It’s not your place to tell us to get over it because you will never understand it. It’s not your place to determine what you feel is racist or not.
I'm half black. Koreans have next to no exposure to people of other races/backgrounds. This isn't unique to Korea, it's like that almost everywhere. In this sense, we can safely assume their mocking or stereotyping of black people is as malicious as they might stereotype Americans as fat or Europeans as feminine. I'm not saying what they're doing is right, I'm saying they didn't grow up in the environments we did, where the danger and consequences of racism are real. And so taking it personally only inflicts pointless self harm.
Carth Canten growing up in the same environments mean nothing. People all over the world know about the racism towards black people that goes on. You don’t have to grow up in a certain environment to know. There’s the internet, the news, and plus racism towards black people is so heavy in Asia. So “taking it personally” does NOT inflict any type of pointless self harm. They’re not dumb at all and they know what they are doing. It’s far from pointless too. VERY FAR from personal self harm or hurt. I have the right to feel the way I feel about the situation. The way I feel shouldn’t hurt anybody cause it’s my history and past.
Your words sound good , it's very hard to see that he is mocked by his own members , mainly chen Who insulted him the most 🤬...ugh !!!! . But Kai's reply was so beautiful 😀
Kai really suffered with EXO. It seems EXO’s learned from all the times Kai’s been so distraught over it... Lately they’ve been saying sweeter things, like how Kai’s tan skin looks better in crop tops and etc . Hopefully exo have learned, because no matter how strong and confident Kai is, a human can only handle so much... I’m glad exo is being nicer to him these days. They’ve always been so cruel to him and Tao..
yes,really even myself i dont like people or my friends doing jokes like bodyshaming,faceshaming or say whatever might be offended,,ughh they think thats cool,thats funny huh🤡🤡 but at the same time i dont know how should i say/defend myself/people being joked bcs i think it's just me who think it's really wrong and not funny at all😔🤠👌🏻
"I have no intention of getting paler," YES, pls we love your skin tone Kai. Honestly, he isn't even considered tan! The rest are just too pale and fair. I think his skin tone really adds to his masculinity visually, especially when he's surrounded by the "pure, innocent" pale toned ppl
As far as I know they've apologised and haven't said those things in years, they do look close, especially Kyungsoo, Sehun and Kai, and tell Kai that he's handsome often and care about him a lot, but I agree that what they said about his skin wasn't right and that they shouldn't have done it. Let's not be toxic and let people learn from their mistakes.
I understand that Korea isn’t a very diverse country and some Koreans may not be as knowledgeable about racism, appropriation, and insensitivity, but these are idols. They trained for years, and are in a global market with diverse fans. Somewhere in their training, they should have to be educated about this kind of stuff
I mean I guess a lot of the clips in here did happen a bit before Kpop was a huge thing so there wasn’t as many diverse fans but yes they should still be informed about things like these even more now since there are now more fans from different places. They should definitely be held accountable for their actions.
Lowkey tho, the kpop industry already isn’t the best at treating its idols, so I would assume compared to making them more profitable, diversity isn’t really valued as much
I once covered for him. I played the song “Bae Bae” by BigBang in the car, we’re black btw, and in his rap he says the word “naega(i/me)” FAST. she asked if he actually said the n word and i ofc said no. little did i know he would say it somewhere else 💀😃
Ya'll forgot Snsd, Snsd tease and make fun of Yuri's skin colour. They call her black pearl which I don't mind but when they call her mud.....I feel uncomfortable. I have seen a lot of idols who are uneducated or just straight up racist. I am not black but it hurts me, ppl getting judged by their race, religion or sexual orientation. And using a culture as a concept is not cool. Some ppl still say their idol didn't know it was wrong, gurl I am 14 if I know about this why don't those adults know.
I agree with everything apart from the last statement. I just want to point out that (assuming that you are from the West, I apologise for assuming if you're not) as you said a lot of idols are genuinely uneducated which is less of a kpop problem than it is a Korean society problem.
@@Thebananamoster So in where ever you are from in Asia are people actually taught about different cultures and racism? (Sorry if this comes off rude, I don't mean to be, I am just curious since I'm from the UK. It's fine if you don't want to answer.)
@@lkisnothere Honestly most ppl only know about their culture and most of the time ppl are taught that their culture are the only important thing not other cultures which is why many Asian or just ppl in general mock others culture since they think there culture is superior. And about racism even my family members mock ppl on their skin tone which I feel uncomfortable about but I can't rise my opinions because for them it's like me disrespecting them. Most ppl around me think that if u are fair u are beautiful but if u are tan they will always point this out "You are beautiful but you are a little brown, use fair & lovely."
I never understood the Kai one. He wasn't even that much (if really any) darker than the other members. What would be the point of teasing him continuously? The viewer can see him so you don't really have to point it out and on top of that, what do you want him to do about it? bleach his skin or something??
his skin has always been really tan to me but??? Also it’s not teasing at first maybe it might’ve been but now it’s just called being plain ignorant they know he gets uncomfortable by that yet they continue as if nothing is wrong about it that I will never get
I can say that as an exo-l it didn’t really look like he was never really bothered by the comments but he has acknowledged his dark skin color before and on multiple occasions after that. Also when xiumin was talking about it he just basically said that it made him look sexy and cute and kai seemed like he was happy about it even though people at the time of exo’s debut weren’t so happy with it and this was at a time when racism wasn’t even taken too lightly in kpop but still. They don’t talk about it anymore but I don’t think they meant any harm by it. Also the comments that Chen made back then were not funny and I have to say this since he’s my bias in exo and what he did was wrong but Chen was never really the type of person to make such ignorant comments like that and you can tell that he regrets saying something like that but it’s not the first time that someone has made comments about it but still
I really feel bad for Kai The pain in his eyes you can tell that he’s not liking it but can’t do anything as he has to stay with his members until the contract ends
@@user-ud2on4hb1g pretty sure he did apologize back in like 2015 and then again in 2016-2017..? the whole love yourself campaign and the un speech wasnt done for nothing, so for me i wont forget what he did, but i'll hope he continues to spread this message of loving yourself and learning to know when you are right/wrong ; sorry for this long paragraph lol i just wanted to share my thoughts about it
@@user-ud2on4hb1g www.allkpop.com/forum/threads/bts-rm-and-owning-up-to-his-past-mistakes.133940/ here's an article about this if you want to know more👍
i agree, but most of the time its just ignorance, not really racism, so i think we should try to educate idols about why what they say or do is racially insensitive instead of just 'cancelling' all of them without giving them a chance to learn
i’ll just say it sucks... 😔it hurts finding out that they use your culture but they low key hate your race. it hurts when people tell you not to get offended when they’re not a part of your race and don’t feel and go through the same thing. neither them or their ancestors have ever been treated like aliens from another planet. they’ve never felt the pain of being generalized and looked as criminals, thugs, loud or aggressive. they don’t ever have to look at videos like this and realize that practically the whole world is against you and thinks this of you and your race.
It sucks and many get bullied at a young age (me) and when i say young i mean 5ish. Dont get me wrong i love to embrace my south african side but it truly does suck going outside with your dad(whos white making me mixed) and getting looks bc people think im adopted. Also finding out that pretty much every one on my mums side is a bunch of raging racists. Also seeing the people that i look up to do blackface really hurts .
As a black 12 yr old I can say that it makes me feel very hurt, I know that this was a while ago but yknow it still makes me feel uncomfortable and stuff😞
mostly in Europe it's being said by edgy people who wants to provoke anger from others, and they know none who is black is near so they will have no consequences for saying it. A white dude won't beat you up for saying the n-word, he will just look at you with dissappointment and less respect.
Apparently Jaehyun didn't even apologize for the lipsync. Meanwhile Giselle apologized for the lip-sync and ppl still give her hate...female idols always having harder time
Okay, I actually agree with that. When jae hyun lip synced the n word people literally tried contacting the company and waited for an apology. Its literally been years and no apology till this day. But keep in mind that incident happened a few years ago when a lot of black kpop stans didn’t like kpop and it was mostly Asian people and white,Indians whatever. When Giselle said the n word, it was when kpop was extremely popular with lots of international fans and people were more aware of what the n word was.
@@lizachu5344 You are right as well, ppl are now more aware of the n word and black kpop fans have increased. It's sad they still need to hear it and because ppl aren't educated enough
As a fellow Asian I'm also dissapointed that a lot of us are insensitive to racial topics and don't think our actions through. There is no excuse for what they've done and that's final.✋👺
I really don’t like it when people make fun of kai’s skin tone, it hurts even more that it is own group. Exo will always be sooo talented and hold a place in my heart, but this ain’t it.
yes... it hurt me too but let's give them some credit as it looks like they have grown out of it... i have not seen specially after i started following them, repeat this... it was all in the past
Honestly, I like his tanner skin, I feel like it would suit him much better than the “standard light skin”. (Please let me know if anything came off as offensive)
@@JesusChrist-3301 idols make mistakes too, you didn't think he was perfect did you? he's also apologised and I'm sure he's grown since then, but you can feel what u wanna feel :)
@Grace Isaako I think another reason why he didn't know that it was controversial word is because he learned english from Friends Edit: Nah I take back what I said, you literally don't even need to know english to know that you can't say the n word
honestly i’m suprised soyeon and the rest of (g)-idle aren’t here, no hate to any of the girls cause i don’t know much about them, but from what i’ve heard they have said some pretty problematic shit over the years
@@arundhatisharma5743 there's no if.. Gidle was in fact educated on certain aspects of ca. You're probably referring to something that happened before that. If you feel by offended by the act of culture appropriation then I think you should know that not everyone has the same though process as you and what they see as appreciation you may see it as appropriation aka cultural and social context. If you think that they're "raging racists" for wearing a piece of clothing that's inspired by other cultures then I would recommend you to educate yourself on the idols that have actually said / done extremely offensive things, you might be surprised lol.
for real, when people bring it up their fans are like "its the past, he apologized" but when they bring up female idols doing that and we tell them its the past they be like "racism doesnt expire" the double standards.
@@quainntrelle no matter what gender, ALL problematic idols should be held accountable. +if you're not apart of the group they're offending yourself, you shouldn't say "they apologized get over it". It's not your place to forgive them
she mocked black americans and white americans on their mannerism. In this video it says only "black people" but on the original she says she's "gonna mimick how white girls and black girls talk like". But only black people are getting offended
effwutade yes I’m not sure about the white fans because I feel like they should get offended too but I feel like people stereotype black people way to much and it saddens me because she had black and white classmates
Everyone around Kai said the most colorist things and Kai just had to listen and take the criticism while doing his best to keep saying how it’s ok and there’s nothing wrong with his skin tone. It’s sad.
just a reminder : if you are white you CANNOT invalidate black kpop stans opinions on this , defend the idols or say “they apologized get over it” . okay now keep watching the video and have a good day
people act like idols don’t have sense and are completely clueless. out of all the idols in the world you can’t tell me that none of them know about racial issues. some of them know what they’re doing. (i’m black)
@@elle244 Exactly. The whole "Oh they didn't know excuse" is really fucking old. They can reference Kunta Kinte, an obscure pop culture reference to some white americans and even some black people, but somehow not know the origins of the n-word and why not to say it? Make it make sense.
Peoples ONLY complaining about namjoon when he is one of the ONLY idol that apologized LOL Edit: I didnt know my comment would blow up like this lol. The comments are full of people fighting over who's right and who's wrong. I apologize if my comment sound ignorant because i didnt know there are some idols apologized too. My main point is to say Namjoon is the only one that got so much hates until today for what he did even when he apologized and educated himself since then. Even when you go to twitter of youtube you will see people cancelling him because of that i didnt see the same hates for other idols. Comments like saying 'doesnt matter if he apologize or not it is still CA' 'You are not black it is not for you to say this' 'idc he apologize or not he still did it' etc just doesnt make sense to me. Everyone makes mistake but that makes you become a better person. You LEARN from that mistake. Sometimes good people make a bad choice. But that doesnt mean they are BAD PERSON. Doesnt care if he apologized? Then what you want him to do? Beg and ask for every people for forgiveness? I dont think you people hating him know they (BigHit and BTS) donate to BLM movement. That was enough for me to know they care for every people in this world. I bet you all make mistakes too (well me too) but bcs you are not artists or idols OR you dont have people around you care about every little things you did OR you dont have any haters to come at you everytime you did something, you didnt realize what you did is wrong. I'll ignore the replies on my comment. Everyone has their own opinion so do i. I cant forced HATERS to like him because when you hate someone all you see is their bad sides. 🤷♀
@@elaela6892 sorry if my words offended you. Im not a fan of got7 so i dont know they did apologize but my point is although RM apologized longggg time ago people keep bringing it up until now just because they want to hate on RM. But when it comes to other idols they turn a blind eye (not hating on other idols though) and act like their idols did nothing wrong...
The fact that namjoon went out to the point that performing in America they change naega( because of the n word)to something else shows how mature and outgrown he is.
Where as the group they covered (who sang the original song with the n word in it) performed it in America AFTER Namjoon got hate for it without changing the lyrics and have never apologised 🤦♀️ here’s the link ruclips.net/video/nXw4LdS0rTM/видео.html
Tbh I didn’t see a point in changing it, it’s a word in korean it’s not the N word, him changing it was stupid in my opinion. But I won’t disregard why he did it, which I am proud of him for, and I’m glad he’s grown as a person.
Saniyia Howard did u just say “Karen ok boomer” oh my god lmfaooo it would’ve been more effective if u only used one of those but thanks for the laugh ig. anyways like I said, 내가 and 니가 are KOREAN words like I said. They are NOT racist, they literally mean I and you. They do NOT sound the same, they are pronounced very differently. If you heard 5 korean sentences with the words mixed in the middle, guaranteed you would miss it AT LEAST 3 times, if not more. And as I said, I’m proud of joon for changing it but it was completely unneeded, as it shouldn’t have to be changed because those words are very common and used all the time everyday. If you’re going to stan a korean group you can’t get butthurt over something that doesn’t even exist.
There’s also another situation I wanted to address. Lee Hyori had used the Gayatri Mantra in her song White Snake in a sensual manner. The Gayatri Mantra is a sacred hymn that we Hindus ONLY use for serious worship. It’s meant to cleanse the soul but she has sexualized it in such a a way that is highly inappropriate. It’s downright disrespectful and rude to Indians
I want to like Blackpink but I'm reminded of the How You Like That MV and how they quietly covered up the Ganesha idol lying on the floor with other things (just for the aesthetic) beside Lisa on a throne after it caused outrage. I get that Blackpink members didn't make the set, but considering the disrespect to Hindus, the company should have owned up and apologised, and at the end of the day, it comes to Blackpink, not YG, because I'm sure they knew what happened and should've been aware, if not then, atleast after seeing the reaction, how that scene hurt the sentiments of so many of their fans. If they cared enough, they'd have apologized and said they'd do better. The Hindu religion is not their aesthetic or a costume they can put on and conveniently forget about it.
Adding to my previous comment, everything else they've previously done to disrespect Black and Indian cultures has still not been apologised for. I wonder how long they can go on pretending they never know what they're doing...
@@shiwangi3803 YG is definitely to be blamed, but Blackpink members cannot go on being oblivious to everything, you know. I'm sure they never brought it up with YG; had they done that, the video wouldn't turn out the way it did. Cultural awareness is important, and so is accountability, and unfortunately Blackpink lacks both at present.
Please do not bring up the gayatri mantra here, it is honestly embarrassing. You guys criticize these people for racisim while ignoring that the gayatri mantra is Brahmin supremacist thing, related so deeply to the janeu, another symbol of oppression for the majority human beings of the Indian subcontinent.
As an Exo-L I can't hide how bad I felt when they made those comments to kai, I think they were overconfident and didn't ask if those comments bothered him, it seems that they mention it to create a funny atmosphere but there is always a limit, obviously I know that EXO has grown and learned all together, now they love and accept each other as they are, a family. We don't know for sure what Kai thought but I love that he says that despite everything he loves himself, a clear example of self-love.
The kunta kinte thing is still one of the more sinister things. How can you watch something so traumatizing and evil like Roots and find it in yourself as a grown man to joke like that? To see someone's physical features as a joke? Not to mention the endless amount of black producers that work hard on their music , making them all that money and yet SM couldn't force him to apologize.
Wendy’s moments are still so shocking to me . You can’t even say she is ‘uneducated’ as she has lived abroad so how could she!!! and it’s happened more than once with no apologies 💀💀
Park Jihyo “haven’t seen any artists under SM apologize for any scandals” maybe you haven’t heard about the ‘97 line Itaewon scandal? Jaehyun posted an apology in his insagram feed, even after SM themself had already posted an apology on behalf of him. What I’m saying is that Jaehyun didn’t really have to apologize himself, but he did anyway. I’m a big reveluv myself, but seeing wendy did those things really confused me, since wendy herself is from canada, so she should’ve known better.
to all my black, indigenous, south asian, hispanic stans, i would like to apologize on behaf on all the actual educated koreans. cultures should be appreciated and never used as a trend or costume and slurs should be reclaimed for only the culture that it was used against.
There is no need for your apology. As part of the hispanic community, I can safely say that there is no ill-intention in 99% of the examples given. Furthermore, I found the whole "culture appropiation" subject as borderline idiotic. Nothing would make me more happy than seeing my fav Idol paying attention and exposing my culture for the world to see, as long as they are not actively ridiculing or insulting one's ethnicity/culture, It should be perfectly fine.
@@matrixlel6056 hey, that’s mean. this is a person trying to apologise as part of the Kpop idols for their actions- yes, they as a person didn’t do anything wrong, but they are helping them with starting the apology.
@@lll.24601 When you try to apologize on behalf of an entire demographic about a subject that doesn't really require an apology to begin with, then it can come across as pretencious. Just don't make bold claims about what YOU might deem as offensive and project that on everyone else.
I feel bad for Kai. No matter how strong he is (mentally), he's a human and he must get hurt whenever someone makes fun of his skin color. He looked sad when the other members made fun of his skin color. I have tan skin too and it hurts seeing tanned people being treated like this. :(
To the white people saying we shouldn’t be mad this, you’re not even part of the discussion to begin with. If any poc says “IM A POC AND THIS IS NOT RASIST” you cant speak for your entire community cause I’m pretty sure someone else who looks just like you may be mad at this. This video does prove that korea has a big racism problem and it basically comes from the lack of diversity in their country. The sad part is we dont ever know when its going to end unless we start educating people more and more.
i agree on everything that you just said, but most importantly on the poc part. some people really have the nerve to say "i'm poc and this doesn't offend me" when the thing mentioned doesn't even concern their own racial background. yes, you are poc. but that doesn't mean everyone else will share the same feelings as you. now, i can't say this on behalf of all of asia. but i as an asian myself, i can say that racist shit that we do is so normalized that we're even racist to ourselves. mocking others for their dark skin, monolids, or even language and way of speech, the list goes on and it's disgusting. i'm glad you pointed out that korea has a big racism problem. because like every other asian country, they definitely do. and it's another problem that it's normalized, which should definitely be changed
Dud, white people can also suffer of racism, not only afros and other cultures...In this case white people werent disrespected but dont act like white people cant suffer racism and they dont know what it feels like.
ponnzel 3 i think i’m going to cry. that or remain very confused. and while i would usually hate myself for asking this, i feel like the situation calls for it to answer some personal questions that i have: how old are you? are you at least 16? i don’t think you actually get what i’m saying here. by whites, i meant european whites. “my ancestors were from scotland” whites. Karen whites. not “i’m a light skin latino” white. and if i’m reading this right, you’re not even White (with the capital w, to help better understand what i’m getting at). you’re a light skinned latino, which is a completely different thing. and what you explained (hebrews being slaves, like, thousands of years ago to the egyptians, other whites killing other whites which doesn’t even apply to the topic of racism because that’s more about antisemitism?? and albinism. which..isn’t a racial thing because that’s more of a rare genetic disorder that people thought was a curse from the gods) doesn’t apply to, well, now. (and notice how 2/3 of your examples aren’t even european whites? they’re either middle eastern or african. none of which are the whites that everyone thinks about when someone says “white people”) and hun, white people (european whites. “blonde hair blue eyes” whites. american whites. not light skinned latinos) are as privileged as they can get. have you seen usa? that place reeks of privilege. i don’t think i need to even explain too much on that part to you (social media and google does exist for this part). lighter sentences? the fact that the police would easily let them slide with most things?? again, racism does not apply to White people (and i will repeat this, european whites. american whites. blonde hair blue eyes white. not light skinned koreans, latinos, middle easterns, etc) only racial prejudice does. both are similar in terms. the difference is the fact that racial prejudice (hate against other race) is a global term that ALL race can experience, while racism (also hate against other race) is a hate hierarchy with whites on top (which makes them literally untouchable, so they won’t be able to experience it)
ponnzel 3 and here’s a slight note to the video you mentioned and your own experiences -the video one? those people are joking. it’s called sarcasm. and if it wasn’t sarcasm, then they probably have racial prejudice against white people. but again, still not racism. -to your experiences, i’m incredibly sorry that happened to you. racism can happen amongst ourselves too (african americans that are racist towards asians and vice versa, indigenas that are racist towards latinos and vice versa) humans invented racial prejudice. but racism and it’s ladder of power was built and introduced by White people (europeans. definitely europeans.) with them on top (so they would be untouchable. so they can’t experience racism themselves. get it? bc-)
@@hyukaexplosion I'm sure that's the answer, every country have their own beauty standards, in a country that has white skin beauty standards you will often be ridiculed by people in that country if you have darker skintone, and if you go to a country that have dark skin for beauty standards, you will also be ridiculed by them if you have white skintone Sorry for my bad English, I use Google translate :'
@@hyukaexplosion Yeah, and that's a bad habit, are they a God to justify what color should they have to be born with just to fit with their so called "korean standard" fuck this shit, hope to get rid of this stereotypes thay are normalized in each of the country
purple revearmy I was so shocked to find out recently that it was actually a cover of a Korean song not a Western one like I had originally thought, as you often just see the clip of RM saying it but I actually found out that the original group Shinwha performed the song at KCON LA AFTER Namjoon got all the hate for it and still outright just said the n word.. I was seriously speechless a whole grown Korean man saying the n word in America 🤦♀️ (also just wanted to add I am in no way trying to justify RM for saying it I’m just saying that it literally did happen in America in front of loads of fans)
Early Birdie Shinwha knew better. They can’t use the excuse that they didn’t know. Sometimes Kpop fans need to wake up and realize that they don’t know their idols as well as they thought they did, and that idols aren’t always the going to be the angels that they’re marketed as
qqqa2sophia ricks to see the full story? A lot of the time people want to see these situations for themselves so they can have their own opinion on it. Sorry my intention wasn’t to glorify it but to shed light on a bad situation
I don’t Stan BTS simply because their music isn’t my taste, but after watching this and watching their parts I noticed how much they have changed and I am very happy to see that. I don’t understand why I still see many people hating on them for this shit. I mean I get it, it was wrong but with the whole LY campaign thing and the UNICEF speech, you cant tell me they aren’t better people now. Major respect for them✊🏾
Just wanna say i forgave them too so im not tryna sound like a hater. Yes i can see how they have changed but i don't like idols preaching about loving yourself when they can't love themselves. Im glad there starting to love themselves more but don't preach about it if u dont love your self bc that's just hypocritical.
@@derive8251 yeah I never liked mamamoo bc there group wasn't my taste but i like the fact moomoos scolded hwsa (unlike some fandoms who just defend there idols) and hwsa actually learned and got informed. So i feel like she sould be forgave I feel like for most idols who sing or rap the n word wasnt intentionally but u can tell hwsa didn't really know. But doing black face and wearing braids after is sketchy.
@@haodite_ you guys are annoyed when you bias is aplogized for done so many racist things in the past but people still drag that but you guys done the same to other group. Such a doulbe standard.
I feel so dissapointed. I used to be ashamed to be black when I was younger and the people kept insulting me. They told me "We can't see you in the dark" or "you're the colour of poop" which made upset. I used to wish that i could be white because of it. The people from a class next to me also recently said the n word to me, i have no idea on why they do that like do they want me to be ashamed? What the fuck is their problem? I'm now really proud to be black but i still feel very insecure when they insult me. Being black in germany (or atleast in my city) is very hard.
ughh i live in dumb america and when i was younger my sister took me to this playground with mostly white kids there and i asked if i could play some game with them but they said “no we have enough people” but when they finished this other little girl asked to play (she’s white) and they immediately let her join them and i was confused at first but then i later understood and told my sister i wanted to go home after that and we did. i still remember that day like it’s yesterday, sad.
Damn same girl same! Auch wenn der Lehrer über dunkelhäutige redet gucken mich alle aufeinmal und machen weird faces. That makes me so uncomfortable ughhh in Deutschland gibt es kein education abt Black people deswegen sind sie so ignorant:/
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
at 3:02 i mistook jihyo’s dress for indian when it was actually native american/indigenous. i apologize to anyone that was offended
@jared ok
Jimin did the same thing it is disrespectful! There is no way to get away with it
Kira Forbes which Jimin?
I'm a weird bts Fan lol: BTS Jimin
Kira Forbes how?
The fact that Kai's skin colour isn't even that dark
Its pale imo
I think that comparatively kai's skin IS slightly tanner, but imo he's also the hottest exo member and im glad kai has learned to embrace his skin tone
@@moon.937 agreed
@@moon.937 I've meet exo in a fansign his skin isn't even that dark exo are just making a big deal cause his skin isn't pale like...
(Im Asian) My skin color isn’t even dark I get made fun of or being “black” and I’m not even fat (I weigh 100 lbs and I’m 5’ 1) well at least my friends say I’m not but I get call black, fat, ugly, etc by my family. I know when some are joking or when they’re not but either way I’ve been told this ever since I was 7 up until now. Honestly I have pretty bad confidence, I just wish Asians don’t have HIGH HIGH standards for beauty. Most of the time when people tell me this stuff now I go to my room and cry. Now I think that beauty is not defined with femininity, masculinity, weight, height, etc. 💗
edit: Well i forgot i commented this- I dont have to say what i do weigh now but its more than 100 now lol. Anyways still going on but i dont give a sh what they say now so :]
it sucks because in Korea, they seem to associate darker skin with more sexy and chic concepts and lighter skin with more beautiful and cute concepts, when in reality it doesn’t matter on the shade of your skin.
preach
reem tsuki bye
reem tsuki Asians with dark skin have been bullied and made fun of for having a darker complexion
@Mariah Palmer Of course it’s not, because it’s rude and disrespectful no matter if your pale or dark. I’m just stating the fact that just because someone doesn’t fit a beauty standard doesn’t give you a right to make fun of the color of their skin or to tell them they’re not pretty just because they don’t match the standards and to be more open minded of others. I’m not saying that people with pale skin don’t get bullied also.
@@reemtsuki795 u not seeing it from all perspectives just because they have a beauty standard dont mean everyone has to follow them and it doesn't make it right to shame something thats different from it either they literally bully and make fun of darker members or the ones with more weight and thats not right so yea ur literally defending them😐
When kai said "i dont have any plans to become paler" it was the best thing i hope people who look up to him and have been teased for their skin tone learn to love themselves.
Also what exo was doing was not racist but was colourist
What makes me sad is when i see girls saying "I wish my skin was paler"
They literally all have the same skin colour tho🤔
that still doesn’t make it right
@@illusion743 I m sick of such people sometimes when I go to the Beach a my skin gets tanned in summer people be like gurl what happened to your face? Why do u look like that u should not stay too much in the sun! And u look burned I feel offended tbh these kind of people don't make me comfortable coz I know their standards are so fucked up and need to be educated
And white people wonder why people have a problem with them tanning their skin 5 shades darker. It's both messed up
i'm an asian and it's very common here that "the paler you are, the more beautiful you are" kinda thing and it is sickening, i myself have tan skin and my skin is darker than most of my friends and i often got teased about it since i was so young and i was always insecure about it. but the more i grew up the more i love my skin color, just like kai said : i don't have any plans to become paler
My eldest sister was also teased about her dark skin from when she was just a kid to now when she's married. She also felt insecure about it and used to buy whitening products till this day. She also been called ugly and 'not that pretty' bc of her skin colour. The most annoying thing is that half of my own family members and all our reletives are the ones always making remarks about her skin and they don't know what they're doing is not right(idk how but...). Plus, I'm also from asia.
@@Cocotubeline sameee me too, mostly are from relatives istg idk what’s wrong with asian’s family are sometimes toxic and soooo close minded. i got teased by my grandma’s sisters bc i use a darker toned foundation than all of my cousins and kept on telling me to use whitening products more, i remember it was thanksgiving and i couldn’t handle the bullshits so i went home by uber all by myself lol
@@ama200 I stopped attending get-togethers between relatives.✊😌
@@Cocotubeline MEE TOO, covid have been a great excuse for not seeing them the last 2-3 years
I'm a very pale European with a lot of Chinese colleagues, and pretty much all of them have commented on my skin tone being 'ideal' or 'pretty', it's so weird to me. One girl didn't want to go out in the sun to picknick cause she was scared of getting a tan, while here that's literally the beauty standard :/
I love how despite Kai being bullied for his skin color, he still loves it no matter what💕
Sophie Bobb because he is more tanned than the others, and in Korea (and most East Asian countries) having fair skin is part of their beauty standards
I honestly can’t comprehend how they don’t envy his honey skin lol. It’s GLOWING.
@@user-ud2on4hb1g exactly...HONEY SKIN
Well guess what he is one of the most popular in exo overall and most popular internationaly
And the gag is i think he's the most popular member 😭
I cringed throughout the video because they were all laughing at the jokes
HELLO!!!!!!!
Well... it sure didn’t make me laugh.
let me guess. You are from america?
"Jokes"
They are Koreans, you can't force your cringe American sensibility
The way they dragged kai’s skin 😭😭 imagine them meeting a black person now 💀
I think a lot of people in general wouldn’t hold another race to their beauty standards like they would for someone from that same ethnicity/race (I’m excluding racists from this).
@@letyv9071 still it's just really bothersome and extremely petty human behaviour which belongs to junior school. sadly alot of young koreans doesn't seem to grow up as quickly as in other cultures.
@@sneakerjuice1856 I agree that this seems immature but its not really that that lets them get away with these types of comments. It seems more of a lack of caring and empathy for others when making these types of comments. I really dont want to contribute colorist comments to immaturity. They know what they are doing.
Yea and he's ✨a t t r a c t i v e ✨
@@ruwaidaanshur8077 ikr like I find dark or tanned skin soooo attractive
its so funny how exo members make fun of kai's skin colour when he's the most handsome out of all of them 💀
Also he's not even that dark and their skin tones are the same 💀
literally in all the videos theyre all the same color💀 and the fact they make fun of him for being "tan" when they all bleach their skin like... you'd be that color too if u didnt whiten urself
They still comfort kai When everyone made fun of kai (not exo ones) Baekhyun praised Him Said he loves kai’s skin so they are friends like super close like family
the fact that half of these people didnt even apologize- yikesss.
Ikr.
except namjoon tho.
He always apologizes for it before any American concert.
I mean not all of them are bad 🥺
Edit: My Comment sounded a bit bad.
I meant that a lot of them have apologized and was using namjoon as an example.
Yikesss lmao
@@ye6090 and Mamamoo
@@vikirios3624 yep
Viki Rios Wait Mamamoo apologized?
Wendy lived in Canda for most of her childhood, she should've known better.
I'm sorry to say this but from MY EXPERIENCE
Canadians(Yellowknife) were racist as HELL to me and almost every other black person I knew there. Like seriously wow... they were just straight up racist... like not even tryna hide it... they were more racist to me than the locals in Texas... like darn!!! ( again from experience they are racist too)I just came for a short visit and it was almost ruined because of the strangers passing by and saying " yo yo what's up girl" " I play basketball and eat watermelon"
They acted like I was the only black person in the entire city... and they even do the same to ther random black ppl too!!!!
But obviously I'm not saying ALL Canadians in Yellowknife are racist. They were a few nice ppl. I just dont think slave history is taught as much in Canada and they have less education on it, although they're parents shoulda taught them better...
Ms A wendy lived in an area that was mostly white and wealthy as well. Explains her racist thoughts
Because Wendy lived in Canada for most of her childhood, she was asked to show how people (black + white) behave there. It was a stereotype based on what she experienced there.
@@layloo5244 wow... no wonder...
@@emitsun8664 true
SMH! Being a black kpop stan sucks sometimes....
Yes bc they love they shit out of hip hop but not black ppl
The exact words that kept repeating in my head throughout this video :/
It does
Cheryl D for real 😔😔
Mhm...
Wendy thought she ate😭
Right like 🤚🏼
Fr😭
@@JuniperGal-ek2pui literally got second hand embarrassment
as a black kpop stan i am kinda disappointed that they stereotype us like that. not all black people act like that :(
True 🥺
Maybe that’s what goes around a lot on the internet and not all of this was Racism but Ignorance
@@neocrackheadtechnology3395 bro stop saying the video isnt racist. it is
@@koyakream key words, NOT ALL. Don't get me wrong, I'm mixed (native american+black+german) and I've been discriminated a lot but rlly, not all of this is racist, but rather colourist and/or ignorant.
@@neocrackheadtechnology3395 If this isn't racism then can you explain why exo kept picking on Kai's tan skin color? If they think he's that dark then they would hate black people's skin color...
"Black english". WTF IS WRONG WITH THEM.
i mean black english is a thing, but yeah they shouldn’t have tried to recreate it
@@emaleigh7812 it’s more commonly referred to as AAVE (African American Vernacular English) she was mostly copying the stereotypical mannerisms that black women do. which was yes, very wrong,
What is “black English “ ? Sorry I don’t know what I means
@@millieart9638 no there literally is😭 it’s called aave which is African American vernacular and it can be considered a dialect. That term is also more commonly referred to as “black english” which consists of words like “chile” “sis” “lit” “woke” “i feel you” etc. There’s also a term called ebonics that is considered a language in its own that most black people use and talk like.
What is black English?
Wendy, girl... that's fricking cringy don't do that
@@shiwangi3803 um no im pretty sure people can learn from racism
yeah and the hand movement was embarrassing to watch
Tae Tae I hate her, she needs to apologise
@@hihigh1017 they asked her to make it first
@@jude-si8rj yeah and she did it. TWICE.
funny how we’re mocked but continuously have our culture used and or stolen
Its because you guys are cool
@@kimm9086 ….. get a life.
@@kimm9086 if you thought that was a compliment, it’s not..
@@kimm9086 hmmm. i get that you're trying to be nice, and that it's a compliment, but i feel like there's a better way to word it(?) like. maybe like saying smth like 'personally, i really like [certain ethnicity/race]'s [something, eg. traditional music, style of traditional clothing, etc.] like yeah. i feel like that's a lot better than just saying a whole race/ethnicity is cool if u get me
preach sis
kai's made me sad. imagine ur band members being colourist towards u. that must've hurt a lot.
@@Sana-jc9xc It doesn’t matter WHEN they did it. They still did it. The only thing that matters now is whether or not they’ve educated themselves and grown as a normal human being.
@@jazaiofficial1167 I'm sure that they talked with each other and educated themselves. all the videos is an old clip, and actually in the last clip (6:38) they compliment his skin colour.
@@Sana-jc9xc These weren't all the clips and these colorist comments extended well past 2013 (those radio clips were Call me Baby era); and I didn't even see some of the worst ones in this video. There was even a pretty bad one just last year. Its shocking to think that EXO barely did any interviews/variety shows, and still every other one there was a colorist comment towards Kai's skin. Imagine what was said when the cameras weren't on. And the footage from EXO Showtime esp was horrible; all of those comments were approved by editors/producers to release to the public, like wtf. The first and only time I watched it I was horrified. The way Kai's face fell after every comment about his skin made me want to cry. Baek and Chan were always the ones to take it too far. Asking if Kai wanted to go in for skin whitening??? Even Sehun looked disgusted with that comment (btw its interesting that the members closest to Kai then never made a peep about his skin. Kyungsoo and Sehun knew how much it bothered him.) The members never apologized nor expressed remorse for how they treated him, and I can and will hold that against those who made those comments until they address it. They were in their twenties, and Kai was one of their maknaes who couldn't really fight back.; there's no excuse.
@@Sana-jc9xc Whoa that was rambling (spacing would be helpful with such a long reply btw). Youre assuming a lot with no evidence at all. We dont know what goes on behind the scenes, which is why addressing this topic would be beneficial to fans who are uncomfortable with the members basically bullying Kai for so long, way before pre-debut. EXO is still gaining fans and they are going back to watch all those interviews and shows, and that in itself makes it relevant today.
And the name Chan saved Kai's name as in his phone? Inexcusable. I don't care if they finally started to reel back the comments after seeing Kai looking so hurt. Why tf say those things in the first place? Because they actually thought it was funny. And you are defending that.........gross. I dont believe for one second you are a Kai bias lmao. Making fun of teenager much younger than them, since pre-debut, over something he can't control, then saying now its not a big deal. Pls.
And yes, many fans would like to see the members apologize. What does how long ago matter? This was only 5 or so years ago that this was happening; which says a lot about their opinion of dark skinned Asians. It doesnt have to be a public statement, just a couple words on a live or even just Jongin saying he received an apology or talked to them about it.
@@Sana-jc9xc So you're saying the members don't want to apologize....that's even worse 😭 We all know SM won't address situations until they absolutely have to. Unfortunately this issue has been ignored and buried by both the company and, even more disappointedly, fans themselves. Holding idols accountable for their actions is not a bad thing; some statements/actions come to light that were years and years ago and just bc time has passed doesn't negate how hurtful or damaging they were. I really don't understand where you're coming from at all. And Exols asking others to ignore or forget these colorist statements and even outright bullying are part of the problem.
as a black kpop fan this makes me so ashamed ngl, they’re grown ffs...
Sorry your profile pic is killling me🤣🤣🤣🤣😭😭
@@shannonobeng JK
Dude... it was triggering to watch this as I was screaming at my phone at how ignorant most of the idols were.
i sometimes literally feel wrong for liking kpop knowing that some idols don’t like/respect me or my culture
the way everyone laughs and claps afterwards is so disturbing
and disgusting too
so true
It’s like watching a fucking black minstrel show
no one know back then
In korea, it's actually common to shame on foreigners
funny how kpop would not exist without black people yet we're often the victim of idol's racist ignorance, the world is an interesting place
That whole black English thing is just cringe 😬
Honestly I had to fucking skip
I KNOWWWW like is there a certain WAY black people are supposed to talk? Like I don’t get that. It was rude and the topic shouldn’t have came up-
Nini Jone i think they should have changed it to “ghetto accent”
Stream you calling My name i agree but either way people would still think it’s insensitive..
The Life Of Jurney! Yeah, maybe ignorant, but I’m pretty sure they would receive less backlash.
the fact that most of these people are from or have studied outside of korea hurts more tbh
exactly that’s what made it hard to get over wendy’s stereotyping because i’m pretty sure she was in canada long enough to know what’s right from wrong
RUclipsr !! yes
@knockoff chanel yea certain parts of Canada are racist as hell(from experience) But I'm not gonna say it isnt their fault or it is. I dont really care but they all know its wrong. Canadian social media isnt too different from American social media. They know what they are doing. (Certain Canadians)
Anyway who body shamed Wendy?
knockoff chanel i agree bullying is wrong but people always use situations like this to publicly release their pent up animosity against members which is a whole other issue.
idk so many people have spoke about this apology but i’ve still never seen it or heard what she said to apologise. obviously sm don’t so i understand that maybe wendy could have felt regretful but idk.
lolo pari what she said was definitely bad but lowkey I feel like her company may have had her to do? Considering it happened 2 times and a lot of these questions are staged. And like I know she could’ve said no but like SM entertainment has been know to be more controlling compare to others. But that’s just a thought idk the truth.
Kpop idols are old enough to know how NOT to be racist, right? Or am I delusional? This honestly makes me so sad😭
No you aren't delusional, you just speak facts
bts army that is interesting, thanks for telling me that☺️
@bts army well ur friend is certainly different...
But honestly I dont think it matters how you treat someone if you make fun of them behind their backs...
@bts army yes of course
It depends on where you live. It's just that most of these stars are from the WEST where slavery is taught most. That's what makes it hit different. I'm from a different country as well but we still know about slavery. Well you're right tho, some ppl dont know. But someone like wendy shoulda known. I mean she lived in Canada.
Oh and ur from south Asia right? That's cool. Had a lotta friends from there
Although I know colourism is prominent around there and white skin is more favoured. But this was due to colonization from the British not African slavery so it must be different there.
And for the jihyo one, I dont think the dressing was racist. I could dress up as a local cowgirl and no one would say crap. But for the Indian cry, that was racist.
bts army i agree! i think it’s more ignorance than anything. (although there may be some idols that are actually racist, but let’s hope that’s not true) especially with the n word, that’s a word that is from american history and people outside of ameerica might not know what it means other than hearing african american people use it. i had that experience with a german friend of mine, and once it was explained to him he felt horrible. the costumes tho? and the comments about tan skin and such? i will say those really don’t sit well with me.
the weird part, is that i've never seen them get canceled for this.
bc Kpop Stan’s are too obsessed with them and don’t care☠️
only wendy and hwasa get dragged for this, even if hwasa apologized ? idk i dont stan mamamoo lol but if you say something about bts past racism they'll tell you you're weaponizing racism and "they apologized/learn from their mistakes" when only one member apologized the others didnt say sht...but they defend them only bcz they're men
@@user-yo4dz5np7g chen also
@@chuu_guevara RM was the only one who mostly did that... Suga and jhope apologized too for their own mistakes...
momo didn't deserve anything.
she said "when I was 6, I started to dance"
the subtitles were based off the song lyrics.
this is coming from an actual black person btw
you can tell how uncomfortable kai is feeling when they're bringing up and joking about how "dark" his skin color is, and i feel bad but makes me happy that he loves his skin color just the way it is
Actually the members love his skin tone too. Chanyeol said he envy kai’s skin tone caise he looks more masculin and hot. Even in one video, sehun’s makeup is one shade below his true skin tone (cause he’s pale af) to look a lil bit tan to add hot and sexy look.
@@gigit8234 ok and? They are still colorist. Stop tryna defend them
@@yoongiarmy3144 i agree but come on you stan bts they are the kings of racism in k-pop lol
@@triplej8666 no they're not lmao pipe down. Bts are innocent compared to these idols so stfu
@@triplej8666 just say you don't like bts and go 🤦🏾♀️
If they’re not educated how do they know about “Kunte kinte” .. y’all need to stop making up excuses for these idols.
Omg I am late but Yes! You hit it right on the nail💯
THANK YOU. FINALLY SOMEONE SAID IT. I'm sick of people trying to excuse these actions.
Yujinie So he’s a fictional character in the Novel/ movie Roots made in America about slavery back in 1700 and the 1800’s.
that's the one thing that triggered me the most in this video, like if my white american friends don't know ab roots and kunta kinte but they do...they know ab racism and they knew what they were doing smh
Not even trying to make excuses for him, because I was real pissed off when the accurate translation came out for what he said, since I'm a black exo-l. But apparently "kunta kinte" is a derogatory/slang term used in SK for people that have full lips. Which is still messed up.
I really feel bad for kai as a brown girl. You don't have to point out him you can see it.
Dude if u look at the clip of them all at the table...YOU CANT EVEN TELL THE FUCKING DIFFERENCE.
HIS NOT EVEN BROWN OR AM BLIND TF ?
@@livinlikelarry8788 he actually has way darker skin the lighting just made it look that way
I love the fact that despite how toxic society and its critics are, Kai has learned to love his skin color. I feel really sad about the comments that her members made to him, but it comforts me a little that they are old clips and that their way of thinking has evolved over time.
As far as I know they've apologised and haven't said those things in years, they do look close and tell Kai that he's handsome often and care about him, but I agree that what they said about his skin wasn't right and that they shouldn't have done it.
@@Kalakeikosó estão fingindo,e o Kai também é racista ele é hipócrita todos os coreanos são racistas sem excessão.
Okay, there are a thousand things to joke about but skin color?
... doesn't mean it's funny or acceptable
Amaya Jiselle i think she's saying you could joke about anything else so why joke about skin color.❤
not everyone outside from the US takes skin color jokes as seriously. i’m from a foreign country and people joke about skin color and how pale/tan you are all the time. it’s not meant to be racist either so please think about that. the world doesn’t revolve around american mindsets
@@picapicaculo just because its not meant to be racist, IT STILL IS. Racism is a global issue, not just an American one. People die everyday because they are a little darker.
I don't think it was racist. I mean u listen to kpop (i think) and u know the Korean beauty standards with being pale are considered as beautiful and Kai was tanned so they weren't saying u are black that's disgusting they were saying u are dark, darker than the beauty standard in Korea. It wasn't racist at all just from watching and thinking about it for a second.
It’s the fact that the whole kpop industry is based off of black culture ...
!!!! Kpop would be nothing without black culture!!!!!
@@monique4525 exactly
@@shiwangi3803 exactly I feel as if they think we don't know what there doing like we're not stupid
Kpop is just a trend that will soon fade
@@bassiebarbz3889 lol okay it isn't a trend. Its music. So ur telling us that music is just a trend and will fade away....ok
The amount of “unnie/oppar didn’t mean it” in the comments is.. something else.
honestly , like i get it . racism in korea isnt taught much , but they are all grown men and woman . im pretty sure they can educate themselves with the internet . if i can understand “hyung , annyeonghaseyo , dongsaeng , gamhamsamnida , ect” and learn hangul they can simply google if something is racist or not
hyunjinnie True. Yeah I’m moreso just confused why they can’t apologize and then educate themselves afterwards. What’s with the silence? .. The thing that upsets me the most are the fans though. Like they’re really out here defending and babying grown ass men and women. It’s ridiculous.
@Jour Den agreed , and its worst because the fans know its wrong but force themselves to think its okay and defend them , wouldnt it be better if they just apologized and addressed the situation ?? normalize holding your faves accountable and normalize them apologizing
In it these idols are grown ass adults 😒
ruclips.net/video/C069GSUzSz0/видео.html I hope this video will help you to Understand how ignorant they are, no excuse
The kai thing is actually so sad and the fact that I experience this on a daily bases with my family makes me upset even more cuz I know what he’s going thru
As far as I know they've apologised and haven't said those things in years, they do look close, especially Kyungsoo, Sehun and Kai, and tell Kai that he's handsome often and care about him a lot, but I agree that what they said about his skin wasn't right and that they shouldn't have done it and I'm really sorry about what you have to go through with your family, no one deserves that. You look beautiful no matter what and the colour or tone of someone's skin doesn't change that at all, all colours are beautiful!
@@Kalakeiko ofc I know sometimes ppl are ignorant but change or they rlly don’t mean it in a bad way and that’s just their way of joking 🙃 so no hard feeling but in those clips I genuinely felt bad
@@NiNi_trolls Same here, I'm glad that they aren't like this anymore, but I'm still sad that happened at all, so I totally understand how you feel.
I sometimes hate being a black kpop stan
Amen to that 🤦🏾♀️
Same
honestly
It's love-hate relationship with me
@@wisteriabloom9412 same
And then you got kpop idols who are from America using the n word acting like they dont know the meaning behind it🙄
Edit: i think i found who i was talking about. Her name is Julie Han and she was rapping to a song for YG and said the N word. She was singing the same song Jennie (black pink) rapped to for one of her auditions as a trainee, and there controversy over if Jennie also said the N word (i think she did).
@Tiger Bear can't remember her name but she was singing a cover to a song and didn't skip over the n word. I watched it a while ago so sry for not remembering who she is exactly.
true cause if they’re from america there’s a high chance they’ve heard it and know the meaning but since in korea african culture and black history isn’t really taught it the possibility is very low i guess
@@justchillin2999 I think it was Hwasa!
@@vyentro29 hwa sa is not from America and doesn't speak English lol
i was shocked when Jennie said it, especially considering she grew up in new zealand (i believe)
Kai looks so pissed like you can tell he is so over it
im really happy how Kai managed to love his self. that's why i love him sm
agreed
same
@Justagirlwholikeyoutube no he’s not black
@Justagirlwholikeyoutube Yea
Agreed! As far as I know they've apologised and haven't said those things in years, they do look close and tell Kai that he's handsome often and care about him, but I agree that what they said about his skin wasn't right and that they shouldn't have done it.
I am glad that namjoon has educated himself since then
I'm glad too 😌
yeah, It's nice to see people grow and learn from their mistakes
and a lot of kpop stans use ‘but namjoon’ as an excuse for their faves actions. atleast namjoon has actually said an apology and learned from his mistakes
@@m1sh743 yeah and sometimes even when idols make mistakes and apologize, they end up making the same mistake again, or they don't really learn from it. while I don't know about the other idols in the video, ik tht namjoon has grown, you can tell from the lyrics he writes, the way he talks and whatnot
Same
I am a Korean and to be honest when idols are celebrities stereotype other cultures I feel offended because it's really rude. But some Koreans say that its fine since other white and black people make racist jokes about Asians. But no! People need to know that racism is a global thing and it's not just for one race and you should respect all races. In kpop there have been many racist things but when that group does something racist the fandom always defends their idol but when another group are racist they attack them for being racist. The fact you are doing is just sad. Your idol and someone else's idol did the same mistake but you attack them. You should never defend your idol and educate them. But other fandoms shouldn't send hate and actually help educate them. Canceling the idols, sending death threats, and defending your idols is not educating. But please remember that not all Koreans are
racist. Also, sometimes the entertainment does not let the idols apologize for their mistakes.
Oh, what a beautiful comment, thank you
Sometimes we as international fans have a bad image about Koreans , but I'm really surprised that there is people like you
Thank you!
I'm from the bahamas and Thank you for saying this! You're so sweet..
Don’t worry I don’t think all Koreans are racists cause at the same time not all humans are racist so thank you🥺❤️
Also as a Korean (well actually White- Korean) when my Asian friends make jokes about other cultures I feel offended because of the lack of respect they are showing.
Most of these incidents can’t be blamed on the ignorance of not knowing, but the ignorance of no one holding them accountable 😐
Your right. But if anyone tries doing so then the toxic stans will come after them
@@wilsonsele9096 you’re right! I’ve had many come at me for saying something similar. I wasn’t disrespectful about it either, they’re just insensitive 😳
Tbh I only found out about Namjoon today. 🤷🏻♀️ I can’t help that bud. Not many know. I also only know a few of the people mentioned in this video
@@serenitynalu-lover5474 not many people because they are tone deaf to what's happening 😃👍
@@wilsonsele9096 or because it isn’t told much? It’s a bit of both deffo. But it just isn’t circulating as much.
I’m tired of these non black people in these comments trying to tell us how to feel about these situations. It’s not your place to tell us to get over it because you will never understand it. It’s not your place to determine what you feel is racist or not.
We all need to hold idols accountable instead of blindly defending our favs. 😔😔😔 I’m so sorry y’all have gone through this so much
Preach👏🏽
Fr 👏🏾
I'm half black. Koreans have next to no exposure to people of other races/backgrounds. This isn't unique to Korea, it's like that almost everywhere. In this sense, we can safely assume their mocking or stereotyping of black people is as malicious as they might stereotype Americans as fat or Europeans as feminine.
I'm not saying what they're doing is right, I'm saying they didn't grow up in the environments we did, where the danger and consequences of racism are real. And so taking it personally only inflicts pointless self harm.
Carth Canten growing up in the same environments mean nothing. People all over the world know about the racism towards black people that goes on. You don’t have to grow up in a certain environment to know. There’s the internet, the news, and plus racism towards black people is so heavy in Asia. So “taking it personally” does NOT inflict any type of pointless self harm. They’re not dumb at all and they know what they are doing. It’s far from pointless too. VERY FAR from personal self harm or hurt. I have the right to feel the way I feel about the situation. The way I feel shouldn’t hurt anybody cause it’s my history and past.
Kai’s skin is gorgeous I don’t care what anyone says
yes
It’s so beauty’s
Your words sound good , it's very hard to see that he is mocked by his own members , mainly chen Who insulted him the most 🤬...ugh !!!! .
But Kai's reply was so beautiful 😀
AMEN
Right he so cute
Kai really suffered with EXO. It seems EXO’s learned from all the times Kai’s been so distraught over it... Lately they’ve been saying sweeter things, like how Kai’s tan skin looks better in crop tops and etc . Hopefully exo have learned, because no matter how strong and confident Kai is, a human can only handle so much... I’m glad exo is being nicer to him these days. They’ve always been so cruel to him and Tao..
it's literally so sick to watch
yes,really even myself i dont like people or my friends doing jokes like bodyshaming,faceshaming or say whatever might be offended,,ughh they think thats cool,thats funny huh🤡🤡 but at the same time i dont know how should i say/defend myself/people being joked bcs i think it's just me who think it's really wrong and not funny at all😔🤠👌🏻
Right he’s just a little tan
@ Your exacted words was what I want everyone to hear cause some people don’t understand that others aren’t raised like us.
@ 🙌
"I have no intention of getting paler," YES, pls we love your skin tone Kai. Honestly, he isn't even considered tan! The rest are just too pale and fair. I think his skin tone really adds to his masculinity visually, especially when he's surrounded by the "pure, innocent" pale toned ppl
Having dark skin doesn't make you more masculine
@@tata8495 yea op's comment is weird
As far as I know they've apologised and haven't said those things in years, they do look close, especially Kyungsoo, Sehun and Kai, and tell Kai that he's handsome often and care about him a lot, but I agree that what they said about his skin wasn't right and that they shouldn't have done it.
Let's not be toxic and let people learn from their mistakes.
I didn't know there was something called "black English " until i got into k-pop. Nah my ancestors did not die just for this.
Same 🤚🏾
It’s also called aave! People call it “stan Twitter” or “gen z language” which is wrong.
best comment
@@bri4442 Stan Twitter is a bit different, it’s a mixture of aave and gay manners, it’s way too cringy
@@levitatingstan6526 I know that’s why I said that
I understand that Korea isn’t a very diverse country and some Koreans may not be as knowledgeable about racism, appropriation, and insensitivity, but these are idols. They trained for years, and are in a global market with diverse fans. Somewhere in their training, they should have to be educated about this kind of stuff
Periodt
Periodt 🍵
I mean I guess a lot of the clips in here did happen a bit before Kpop was a huge thing so there wasn’t as many diverse fans but yes they should still be informed about things like these even more now since there are now more fans from different places. They should definitely be held accountable for their actions.
Lowkey tho, the kpop industry already isn’t the best at treating its idols, so I would assume compared to making them more profitable, diversity isn’t really valued as much
I agree
"Idk who this is but he said the n word " 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 it's G-dragon
Oof
Yes it's him and I didn't even know that he says the n word 😭
I- I didn’t even know
Yooooo they just be throwing that shit around on BROADCAST TELEVISION?! Jesus 🤦🏽♀️
I once covered for him. I played the song “Bae Bae” by BigBang in the car, we’re black btw, and in his rap he says the word “naega(i/me)” FAST. she asked if he actually said the n word and i ofc said no. little did i know he would say it somewhere else 💀😃
Julie Han: I was born in Hawai'i and lived there for 13 years.
Also Julie Han: managed to say the n-word.
Literally nobody can defend her ass🗣️
she literally could have changed it from the nword to people
First time seeing an idol who was born here 🤝
Well yeah that was wrong but it was so long ago & she apologised
Ya'll forgot Snsd, Snsd tease and make fun of Yuri's skin colour. They call her black pearl which I don't mind but when they call her mud.....I feel uncomfortable. I have seen a lot of idols who are uneducated or just straight up racist. I am not black but it hurts me, ppl getting judged by their race, religion or sexual orientation. And using a culture as a concept is not cool. Some ppl still say their idol didn't know it was wrong, gurl I am 14 if I know about this why don't those adults know.
I agree with everything apart from the last statement. I just want to point out that (assuming that you are from the West, I apologise for assuming if you're not) as you said a lot of idols are genuinely uneducated which is less of a kpop problem than it is a Korean society problem.
@@lkisnothere Oh true I am Asian
@@Thebananamoster So in where ever you are from in Asia are people actually taught about different cultures and racism? (Sorry if this comes off rude, I don't mean to be, I am just curious since I'm from the UK. It's fine if you don't want to answer.)
@@lkisnothere Honestly most ppl only know about their culture and most of the time ppl are taught that their culture are the only important thing not other cultures which is why many Asian or just ppl in general mock others culture since they think there culture is superior. And about racism even my family members mock ppl on their skin tone which I feel uncomfortable about but I can't rise my opinions because for them it's like me disrespecting them. Most ppl around me think that if u are fair u are beautiful but if u are tan they will always point this out "You are beautiful but you are a little brown, use fair & lovely."
@@Thebananamoster Thanks for the insight. It's interesting to see how different Western and Asian cultures are.
I never understood the Kai one. He wasn't even that much (if really any) darker than the other members. What would be the point of teasing him continuously? The viewer can see him so you don't really have to point it out and on top of that, what do you want him to do about it? bleach his skin or something??
his skin has always been really tan to me but??? Also it’s not teasing at first maybe it might’ve been but now it’s just called being plain ignorant they know he gets uncomfortable by that yet they continue as if nothing is wrong about it that I will never get
I can say that as an exo-l it didn’t really look like he was never really bothered by the comments but he has acknowledged his dark skin color before and on multiple occasions after that. Also when xiumin was talking about it he just basically said that it made him look sexy and cute and kai seemed like he was happy about it even though people at the time of exo’s debut weren’t so happy with it and this was at a time when racism wasn’t even taken too lightly in kpop but still. They don’t talk about it anymore but I don’t think they meant any harm by it. Also the comments that Chen made back then were not funny and I have to say this since he’s my bias in exo and what he did was wrong but Chen was never really the type of person to make such ignorant comments like that and you can tell that he regrets saying something like that but it’s not the first time that someone has made comments about it but still
Sara Collins Do you remember the time xiumin saved jongin as blackie on his phone??
@@millisvlogs1898 It wasnt Xiumin tho
Kokista Nam it was xiumin tho lmaooo just stop frontin and kissing exo’s ass especially xiumin
This proves that anyone can be racist. You don’t have to be white, black, etc.
PREACHH
Exactly, some of these idols talk about how they’re discriminated but they’re racist, the hypocrisy is...
Latino is not a race lol
I'm latino and I'm white
true but latino isn't a race
@@keziaannamammen4068 Hispanic?
I really feel bad for Kai
The pain in his eyes you can tell that he’s not liking it but can’t do anything as he has to stay with his members until the contract ends
namjoon really said the n word with his whole chest oh my
femaleskater1185 I’m deceased....I need an apology. Just saying. I knew they weren’t saints but DANG.
@@user-ud2on4hb1g pretty sure he did apologize back in like 2015 and then again in 2016-2017..? the whole love yourself campaign and the un speech wasnt done for nothing, so for me i wont forget what he did, but i'll hope he continues to spread this message of loving yourself and learning to know when you are right/wrong ; sorry for this long paragraph lol i just wanted to share my thoughts about it
@@user-ud2on4hb1g www.allkpop.com/forum/threads/bts-rm-and-owning-up-to-his-past-mistakes.133940/ here's an article about this if you want to know more👍
Zuri Got jams he already apologized u dimwit
Zuri Got jams he’s apologized countless times and has said “yesterday’s me is still me so i’ll try harder to become a better person”
Stop trying to defend them..bc u know exactly what they said. ..
Exactly
I don’t see anyone defending them
@@susu-gq9cp there's a lot of fans defending them tho and always saying that the idols didn't mean it lol
Pfp...
i agree, but most of the time its just ignorance, not really racism, so i think we should try to educate idols about why what they say or do is racially insensitive instead of just 'cancelling' all of them without giving them a chance to learn
I'm white and this made me extremely uncomfortable, I can't imagine how it must feel to be a person of one of these cultures or races
i’ll just say it sucks... 😔it hurts finding out that they use your culture but they low key hate your race. it hurts when people tell you not to get offended when they’re not a part of your race and don’t feel and go through the same thing. neither them or their ancestors have ever been treated like aliens from another planet. they’ve never felt the pain of being generalized and looked as criminals, thugs, loud or aggressive. they don’t ever have to look at videos like this and realize that practically the whole world is against you and thinks this of you and your race.
It sucks and many get bullied at a young age (me) and when i say young i mean 5ish. Dont get me wrong i love to embrace my south african side but it truly does suck going outside with your dad(whos white making me mixed) and getting looks bc people think im adopted. Also finding out that pretty much every one on my mums side is a bunch of raging racists. Also seeing the people that i look up to do blackface really hurts .
Same I'm not black but I can't even continue this video after the second clip it's very uncomfortable
As a black 12 yr old I can say that it makes me feel very hurt, I know that this was a while ago but yknow it still makes me feel uncomfortable and stuff😞
Human races don't exist, go to study some biology
i seen more racism in k-pop than western media 😭
Because in western media racism isnt accepted, in korean media people dont care
Why are they so obsessed with the n word
People want what they can’t have
I think because some people think is "cool" I'm from Mexico and some people use it too, and is just too cringy and can't believe people think is cool.
@@angelanavarro2581 Same. I’m from Norway and people use it all the time to seem “edgy”.
Same. I lived in Pakistan for 18 years and people just didn't care. They used the N Word so casually. It makes me so sad how ignorant people can be.
mostly in Europe it's being said by edgy people who wants to provoke anger from others, and they know none who is black is near so they will have no consequences for saying it. A white dude won't beat you up for saying the n-word, he will just look at you with dissappointment and less respect.
When Wendy mocked the black community and the way they laughed takes me back to elementary where ppl would say hurtful things about me
Im so sorry for that things happened to you
@@karenvcala1748 Thank you ❤️❤️ ik how to stand up for myself now so I’m happy :)
I’m so sorry that happened 🥺
sending luv and hugs to you girl ❤️
Ikr
8:02 okay so how the hell was this girl born in america, lived there for most of her life and doesn’t know that it’s not okay to say the N word?
Just like Sixnine, I'm sure she thought that she would sound cool
a lot of yg trainees say the n word to sound cool. it’s like how in blackpink songs there’s random aave that makes no sens e
@@Jj-qp6gl what
@@leighannalawrence2399 what did i say that confused you?
@@Jj-qp6gl literally your entire comment is confusing
Apparently Jaehyun didn't even apologize for the lipsync. Meanwhile Giselle apologized for the lip-sync and ppl still give her hate...female idols always having harder time
Okay, I actually agree with that. When jae hyun lip synced the n word people literally tried contacting the company and waited for an apology. Its literally been years and no apology till this day. But keep in mind that incident happened a few years ago when a lot of black kpop stans didn’t like kpop and it was mostly Asian people and white,Indians whatever. When Giselle said the n word, it was when kpop was extremely popular with lots of international fans and people were more aware of what the n word was.
@@lizachu5344 You are right as well, ppl are now more aware of the n word and black kpop fans have increased. It's sad they still need to hear it and because ppl aren't educated enough
I think he says “killa” bc the clean version says killa
As a Chinese person 🇨🇳 I am embarrassed by my fellow Asians doing this stuff
Thanks for being a decent person!!
same ong
Same
I would like to be chinese ;-; im hispanic 💖✨
Edit: GUYS! Stop freaking out like im not being for real omg! 👹👁👄👁
As a fellow Asian I'm also dissapointed that a lot of us are insensitive to racial topics and don't think our actions through. There is no excuse for what they've done and that's final.✋👺
I really don’t like it when people make fun of kai’s skin tone, it hurts even more that it is own group. Exo will always be sooo talented and hold a place in my heart, but this ain’t it.
yes... it hurt me too but let's give them some credit as it looks like they have grown out of it... i have not seen specially after i started following them, repeat this... it was all in the past
Kai skin is 10/10 I don’t know who’s delusional mind try to convince that poor kid his skin is not beautiful.
Honestly, I like his tanner skin, I feel like it would suit him much better than the “standard light skin”.
(Please let me know if anything came off as offensive)
An apology doesn't have to be forgiven. For some all it takes is one time.
I'm a huge exo fan but i always find them mocking kai's skin color very toxic.
yea, sad kai:(
It makes me upset as well, Kai's skin color is gorgeous.
It happened a long time ago and they've stopped and praise Kai's skin instead- hope you can find it in you to forgive them 🙏
@@moccisimo Do you have video proof where they praise his skin tone?
@@chetna3963 you can see in their interviews from loveshot era
I have never felt so disappointed in Namjoon-
but good thing he apologized :( damn
@Grace Isaako yeah as I disappointed as I was in him, he did grow since than, you can tell from the lyrics he writes and the way he talk and stuff
I wasn't expecting Namjoon to be here... i kind of feel different about him now:(
@@JesusChrist-3301 idols make mistakes too, you didn't think he was perfect did you? he's also apologised and I'm sure he's grown since then, but you can feel what u wanna feel :)
@Grace Isaako apologizing and saying sorry is the same thing?
@Grace Isaako I think another reason why he didn't know that it was controversial word is because he learned english from Friends
Edit: Nah I take back what I said, you literally don't even need to know english to know that you can't say the n word
Me: DONT CRY DONT CRY DONT CRY DONT CRYYYYY
Same✌🏾😗
STAY STRONG WOMEN ✊🏾
That Revy I-
Honeslty im just disgusted ✊🏽
i am immune to this at this point.
9:00 the fact that she said shes from america and still said it 🤡
Fr. That’s a huge yikes…
K-Pop is literally inspired by black people and their music, the least they could do is respect black people and their culture and not mock them.
FACTS!!!! 👏👏
Ummmmm
Yeah, you're right
Its COMPLETELY INSPIRED by BLACK PEOPLE
@@bottatto yes
@@bottatto it is lol ion know why you tryna be sarcastic but Kpop is black people pop just singed in Korean
@##sana!¡ sorry but i mean that thats thoe whole point
honestly i’m suprised soyeon and the rest of (g)-idle aren’t here, no hate to any of the girls cause i don’t know much about them, but from what i’ve heard they have said some pretty problematic shit over the years
This video was made 1 year ago-
Wait they have ? Time to go investigate
arundhati that’s not racist tho
Racism is not culture appropriation, please get that into your heads.
They were educated.
AAAAAAAA
@@arundhatisharma5743 there's no if..
Gidle was in fact educated on certain aspects of ca.
You're probably referring to something that happened before that.
If you feel by offended by the act of culture appropriation then I think you should know that not everyone has the same though process as you and what they see as appreciation you may see it as appropriation aka cultural and social context.
If you think that they're "raging racists" for wearing a piece of clothing that's inspired by other cultures then I would recommend you to educate yourself on the idols that have actually said / done extremely offensive things, you might be surprised lol.
How are people so quick to apologize Male idols but can't seem to forget the Female idols mistakes?
It's called ✨internalized misogyny✨
for real, when people bring it up their fans are like "its the past, he apologized" but when they bring up female idols doing that and we tell them its the past they be like "racism doesnt expire" the double standards.
@@quainntrelle When did most of the female idols apologize?
@@quainntrelle either way it’s still wrong, no matter gender they still did racist things
@@quainntrelle no matter what gender, ALL problematic idols should be held accountable. +if you're not apart of the group they're offending yourself, you shouldn't say "they apologized get over it". It's not your place to forgive them
Still tryna process how the actual hell people really BELIEVE Kai has a dark skin tone
Dark skin is beautiful
You're right✨
so true
Agreed i feel sad for black people rn
THE FACT THAT WENDY EVEN SAID “BLACK WOMEN “ “BLACK MEN” NO APOLOGY
she mocked black americans and white americans on their mannerism. In this video it says only "black people" but on the original she says she's "gonna mimick how white girls and black girls talk like". But only black people are getting offended
effwutade yes I’m not sure about the white fans because I feel like they should get offended too but I feel like people stereotype black people way to much and it saddens me because she had black and white classmates
Bangpink forever Kpop never said it was racist but she did it twice bro 🤦🏾♀️ she had to know that it was offending people
@@idonthavethink9695 How is it a "misunderstanding" ???
Ok but it’s in the past
This is painful to watch.
Ikr sis
@Maria Eduarda Rocha Isidorio how funny haha let's forget that our favs had racist behaviours and act like there's nothing wrong about it, yeah
@キティ it's a question or an affirmation? lol
cope.
@@hshroyalnloyal2058 wdym "cope"?
Everyone around Kai said the most colorist things and Kai just had to listen and take the criticism while doing his best to keep saying how it’s ok and there’s nothing wrong with his skin tone. It’s sad.
just a reminder :
if you are white you CANNOT invalidate black kpop stans opinions on this , defend the idols or say “they apologized get over it” .
okay now keep watching the video and have a good day
And all the other NON BLACK kpop stans
@Roffin then leave :)
@Roffin I can't believe you write down the word. You are being disrespectful delete the comment
i reported you and youtube deleted your comment you don't have to bother to delete it now
@Roffin you is a child. Do your homework
i just KNOW that the only people defending these idols’ actions are NOT POC/minorities
@@derive8251 A lot of people defended them
@Cruceable Yikes, bit of an escalation there, disowned by race for a youtube comment.
@Cruceable we don't claim you as a black person, if you don't know how to forgive, wjere are you gonna get in life? He clearly changed ffs
people act like idols don’t have sense and are completely clueless. out of all the idols in the world you can’t tell me that none of them know about racial issues. some of them know what they’re doing. (i’m black)
@@elle244 Exactly. The whole "Oh they didn't know excuse" is really fucking old. They can reference Kunta Kinte, an obscure pop culture reference to some white americans and even some black people, but somehow not know the origins of the n-word and why not to say it? Make it make sense.
I really see teens defending adults and their actions
Smh😔
literally
Uff yess sis, like seriously an adult doesn't need pretty teens to protect them Lmfao
that kunte kinte line was crazy
fr
Peoples ONLY complaining about namjoon when he is one of the ONLY idol that apologized LOL
Edit: I didnt know my comment would blow up like this lol. The comments are full of people fighting over who's right and who's wrong. I apologize if my comment sound ignorant because i didnt know there are some idols apologized too. My main point is to say Namjoon is the only one that got so much hates until today for what he did even when he apologized and educated himself since then. Even when you go to twitter of youtube you will see people cancelling him because of that i didnt see the same hates for other idols. Comments like saying 'doesnt matter if he apologize or not it is still CA' 'You are not black it is not for you to say this' 'idc he apologize or not he still did it' etc just doesnt make sense to me.
Everyone makes mistake but that makes you become a better person. You LEARN from that mistake. Sometimes good people make a bad choice. But that doesnt mean they are BAD PERSON. Doesnt care if he apologized? Then what you want him to do? Beg and ask for every people for forgiveness? I dont think you people hating him know they (BigHit and BTS) donate to BLM movement. That was enough for me to know they care for every people in this world. I bet you all make mistakes too (well me too) but bcs you are not artists or idols OR you dont have people around you care about every little things you did OR you dont have any haters to come at you everytime you did something, you didnt realize what you did is wrong.
I'll ignore the replies on my comment. Everyone has their own opinion so do i. I cant forced HATERS to like him because when you hate someone all you see is their bad sides. 🤷♀
for real though
Ikr
sorry girl but
got7 also apologized and since then they have grown up without these kinds of issues so please don't
generalize.
@@elaela6892 sorry if my words offended you. Im not a fan of got7 so i dont know they did apologize but my point is although RM apologized longggg time ago people keep bringing it up until now just because they want to hate on RM. But when it comes to other idols they turn a blind eye (not hating on other idols though) and act like their idols did nothing wrong...
@@mxssnini yeah and when their idols do something like this, they're going to bring back what happened to rm and use it as an excuse
The fact that namjoon went out to the point that performing in America they change naega( because of the n word)to something else shows how mature and outgrown he is.
I feel like he's one of the 4% of Idols that actually sincearly apologize for their mistakes and actually learned from them
Where as the group they covered (who sang the original song with the n word in it) performed it in America AFTER Namjoon got hate for it without changing the lyrics and have never apologised 🤦♀️ here’s the link ruclips.net/video/nXw4LdS0rTM/видео.html
Neon Kyle 😂😂😂
Tbh I didn’t see a point in changing it, it’s a word in korean it’s not the N word, him changing it was stupid in my opinion. But I won’t disregard why he did it, which I am proud of him for, and I’m glad he’s grown as a person.
Saniyia Howard did u just say “Karen ok boomer” oh my god lmfaooo it would’ve been more effective if u only used one of those but thanks for the laugh ig. anyways like I said, 내가 and 니가 are KOREAN words like I said. They are NOT racist, they literally mean I and you. They do NOT sound the same, they are pronounced very differently. If you heard 5 korean sentences with the words mixed in the middle, guaranteed you would miss it AT LEAST 3 times, if not more. And as I said, I’m proud of joon for changing it but it was completely unneeded, as it shouldn’t have to be changed because those words are very common and used all the time everyday. If you’re going to stan a korean group you can’t get butthurt over something that doesn’t even exist.
There’s also another situation I wanted to address. Lee Hyori had used the Gayatri Mantra in her song White Snake in a sensual manner. The Gayatri Mantra is a sacred hymn that we Hindus ONLY use for serious worship. It’s meant to cleanse the soul but she has sexualized it in such a a way that is highly inappropriate. It’s downright disrespectful and rude to Indians
I want to like Blackpink but I'm reminded of the How You Like That MV and how they quietly covered up the Ganesha idol lying on the floor with other things (just for the aesthetic) beside Lisa on a throne after it caused outrage. I get that Blackpink members didn't make the set, but considering the disrespect to Hindus, the company should have owned up and apologised, and at the end of the day, it comes to Blackpink, not YG, because I'm sure they knew what happened and should've been aware, if not then, atleast after seeing the reaction, how that scene hurt the sentiments of so many of their fans. If they cared enough, they'd have apologized and said they'd do better. The Hindu religion is not their aesthetic or a costume they can put on and conveniently forget about it.
Adding to my previous comment, everything else they've previously done to disrespect Black and Indian cultures has still not been apologised for. I wonder how long they can go on pretending they never know what they're doing...
@@shiwangi3803 YG is definitely to be blamed, but Blackpink members cannot go on being oblivious to everything, you know. I'm sure they never brought it up with YG; had they done that, the video wouldn't turn out the way it did. Cultural awareness is important, and so is accountability, and unfortunately Blackpink lacks both at present.
Please do not bring up the gayatri mantra here, it is honestly embarrassing. You guys criticize these people for racisim while ignoring that the gayatri mantra is Brahmin supremacist thing, related so deeply to the janeu, another symbol of oppression for the majority human beings of the Indian subcontinent.
What the actual hell how did she not get cancelled for that this is so humiliating and annoying
As an Exo-L I can't hide how bad I felt when they made those comments to kai, I think they were overconfident and didn't ask if those comments bothered him, it seems that they mention it to create a funny atmosphere but there is always a limit, obviously I know that EXO has grown and learned all together, now they love and accept each other as they are, a family.
We don't know for sure what Kai thought but I love that he says that despite everything he loves himself, a clear example of self-love.
You know what's more offensive? The mcs of the programs laughing.
And the 'fans' defending them
@@foziahmatzain5703 lol fuck this society
Kai isnt even THAT dark
But i love how he is satisfied with his skin color because its beautiful
Same
Same
and personally i think he is the most attractive one in the group
Girlll he's beautiful isn't he 💖🤗
Kai skin tone is ver pretty, i feel disappointed about other Exo members as an Exo-l
Kai; “I have the darkest skin in the Team.”
Me: Well, if he’s dark, am I burnt?? Cause I-
no we r coal 🙃
“in the team”
@@dattebayo1656 ok?
@Kayra Andalussia I know that? That doesn’t make what I say any different
@@cooknala1721 no but it doesn't have any connection. if he said "i have a dark skin." then what you said make sense👍
The kunta kinte thing is still one of the more sinister things. How can you watch something so traumatizing and evil like Roots and find it in yourself as a grown man to joke like that? To see someone's physical features as a joke? Not to mention the endless amount of black producers that work hard on their music , making them all that money and yet SM couldn't force him to apologize.
Wendy’s moments are still so shocking to me . You can’t even say she is ‘uneducated’ as she has lived abroad so how could she!!! and it’s happened more than once with no apologies 💀💀
You notice when she was showing white girls it was simple stereotype but when she showed how black people she did very negative stereotypes
I love red velvet but this is one thing i will always be dissapointed about. She didnt even apologize.
@Park Jihyo kimda same with other companies and i hate this tbh. Let them apologize...
@Park Jihyo i understand if they dont let them apologize for small and stupid things. But in this case it isnt small and stupid.
Park Jihyo “haven’t seen any artists under SM apologize for any scandals” maybe you haven’t heard about the ‘97 line Itaewon scandal? Jaehyun posted an apology in his insagram feed, even after SM themself had already posted an apology on behalf of him. What I’m saying is that Jaehyun didn’t really have to apologize himself, but he did anyway. I’m a big reveluv myself, but seeing wendy did those things really confused me, since wendy herself is from canada, so she should’ve known better.
to all my black, indigenous, south asian, hispanic stans, i would like to apologize on behaf on all the actual educated koreans. cultures should be appreciated and never used as a trend or costume and slurs should be reclaimed for only the culture that it was used against.
Where Southeast Asian
There is no need for your apology. As part of the hispanic community, I can safely say that there is no ill-intention in 99% of the examples given. Furthermore, I found the whole "culture appropiation" subject as borderline idiotic. Nothing would make me more happy than seeing my fav Idol paying attention and exposing my culture for the world to see, as long as they are not actively ridiculing or insulting one's ethnicity/culture, It should be perfectly fine.
@@matrixlel6056 hey, that’s mean. this is a person trying to apologise as part of the Kpop idols for their actions- yes, they as a person didn’t do anything wrong, but they are helping them with starting the apology.
@@lll.24601 When you try to apologize on behalf of an entire demographic about a subject that doesn't really require an apology to begin with, then it can come across as pretencious. Just don't make bold claims about what YOU might deem as offensive and project that on everyone else.
@@matrixlel6056 But Jihyo was mocking you can rewatch and see
If I was Kai I would’ve been whooped some ass 🏃🏽♀️💨
Same and then I would've gotten cancelled for being rude.. 😂😭
@Did someone say DRACO MALFOY ur everywhere lol
sameeee
I feel bad for Kai. No matter how strong he is (mentally), he's a human and he must get hurt whenever someone makes fun of his skin color. He looked sad when the other members made fun of his skin color. I have tan skin too and it hurts seeing tanned people being treated like this. :(
To the white people saying we shouldn’t be mad this, you’re not even part of the discussion to begin with. If any poc says “IM A POC AND THIS IS NOT RASIST” you cant speak for your entire community cause I’m pretty sure someone else who looks just like you may be mad at this. This video does prove that korea has a big racism problem and it basically comes from the lack of diversity in their country. The sad part is we dont ever know when its going to end unless we start educating people more and more.
i agree on everything that you just said, but most importantly on the poc part. some people really have the nerve to say "i'm poc and this doesn't offend me" when the thing mentioned doesn't even concern their own racial background. yes, you are poc. but that doesn't mean everyone else will share the same feelings as you.
now, i can't say this on behalf of all of asia. but i as an asian myself, i can say that racist shit that we do is so normalized that we're even racist to ourselves. mocking others for their dark skin, monolids, or even language and way of speech, the list goes on and it's disgusting. i'm glad you pointed out that korea has a big racism problem. because like every other asian country, they definitely do. and it's another problem that it's normalized, which should definitely be changed
Dud, white people can also suffer of racism, not only afros and other cultures...In this case white people werent disrespected but dont act like white people cant suffer racism and they dont know what it feels like.
And yes, korea has a big problem with racism that they have to improve.
ponnzel 3 i think i’m going to cry. that or remain very confused. and while i would usually hate myself for asking this, i feel like the situation calls for it to answer some personal questions that i have: how old are you? are you at least 16?
i don’t think you actually get what i’m saying here. by whites, i meant european whites. “my ancestors were from scotland” whites. Karen whites. not “i’m a light skin latino” white. and if i’m reading this right, you’re not even White (with the capital w, to help better understand what i’m getting at). you’re a light skinned latino, which is a completely different thing.
and what you explained (hebrews being slaves, like, thousands of years ago to the egyptians, other whites killing other whites which doesn’t even apply to the topic of racism because that’s more about antisemitism?? and albinism. which..isn’t a racial thing because that’s more of a rare genetic disorder that people thought was a curse from the gods) doesn’t apply to, well, now.
(and notice how 2/3 of your examples aren’t even european whites? they’re either middle eastern or african. none of which are the whites that everyone thinks about when someone says “white people”)
and hun, white people (european whites. “blonde hair blue eyes” whites. american whites. not light skinned latinos) are as privileged as they can get. have you seen usa? that place reeks of privilege. i don’t think i need to even explain too much on that part to you (social media and google does exist for this part). lighter sentences? the fact that the police would easily let them slide with most things??
again, racism does not apply to White people (and i will repeat this, european whites. american whites. blonde hair blue eyes white. not light skinned koreans, latinos, middle easterns, etc) only racial prejudice does. both are similar in terms. the difference is the fact that racial prejudice (hate against other race) is a global term that ALL race can experience, while racism (also hate against other race) is a hate hierarchy with whites on top (which makes them literally untouchable, so they won’t be able to experience it)
ponnzel 3 and here’s a slight note to the video you mentioned and your own experiences
-the video one? those people are joking. it’s called sarcasm. and if it wasn’t sarcasm, then they probably have racial prejudice against white people. but again, still not racism.
-to your experiences, i’m incredibly sorry that happened to you. racism can happen amongst ourselves too (african americans that are racist towards asians and vice versa, indigenas that are racist towards latinos and vice versa)
humans invented racial prejudice. but racism and it’s ladder of power was built and introduced by White people (europeans. definitely europeans.) with them on top (so they would be untouchable. so they can’t experience racism themselves. get it? bc-)
I do not understand why Kai is getting mocked by his own group members. I mean, is being tan a bad thing or a sin? I guess not!
@@hyukaexplosion I'm sure that's the answer, every country have their own beauty standards, in a country that has white skin beauty standards you will often be ridiculed by people in that country if you have darker skintone, and if you go to a country that have dark skin for beauty standards, you will also be ridiculed by them if you have white skintone
Sorry for my bad English, I use Google translate :'
@@hyukaexplosion Yeah, and that's a bad habit, are they a God to justify what color should they have to be born with just to fit with their so called "korean standard" fuck this shit, hope to get rid of this stereotypes thay are normalized in each of the country
@@howayu1648 What country has a dark skin beauty standard? LOL.
@@meikoluvv in Saudi Arabia if a man skin was so pale they will get bullied or laughed at *yes toxic behavior*
@@meikoluvv not even African countries
I'm so glad namjoon changed imagine if he tried that shit nowadays with their huge international fandom or on an American show sksksks
purple revearmy I was so shocked to find out recently that it was actually a cover of a Korean song not a Western one like I had originally thought, as you often just see the clip of RM saying it but I actually found out that the original group Shinwha performed the song at KCON LA AFTER Namjoon got all the hate for it and still outright just said the n word.. I was seriously speechless a whole grown Korean man saying the n word in America 🤦♀️ (also just wanted to add I am in no way trying to justify RM for saying it I’m just saying that it literally did happen in America in front of loads of fans)
ruclips.net/video/nXw4LdS0rTM/видео.html this is the link if anyone wants to check it out 🤦♀️
Early Birdie Shinwha knew better. They can’t use the excuse that they didn’t know. Sometimes Kpop fans need to wake up and realize that they don’t know their idols as well as they thought they did, and that idols aren’t always the going to be the angels that they’re marketed as
Early Birdie, why would somebody want to check this out!?
qqqa2sophia ricks to see the full story? A lot of the time people want to see these situations for themselves so they can have their own opinion on it. Sorry my intention wasn’t to glorify it but to shed light on a bad situation
Do they really think that imitating stereotypically other races is entertaining??? Or a damn talent??
Right it's like a joke or a game to them
I don’t Stan BTS simply because their music isn’t my taste, but after watching this and watching their parts I noticed how much they have changed and I am very happy to see that. I don’t understand why I still see many people hating on them for this shit. I mean I get it, it was wrong but with the whole LY campaign thing and the UNICEF speech, you cant tell me they aren’t better people now. Major respect for them✊🏾
Damn bruh chill same
Just wanna say i forgave them too so im not tryna sound like a hater. Yes i can see how they have changed but i don't like idols preaching about loving yourself when they can't love themselves. Im glad there starting to love themselves more but don't preach about it if u dont love your self bc that's just hypocritical.
@@derive8251 yeah I never liked mamamoo bc there group wasn't my taste but i like the fact moomoos scolded hwsa (unlike some fandoms who just defend there idols) and hwsa actually learned and got informed. So i feel like she sould be forgave I feel like for most idols who sing or rap the n word wasnt intentionally but u can tell hwsa didn't really know. But doing black face and wearing braids after is sketchy.
@BL Only but it was the braids she wore people take it too offense with there cultural now just respect it
RIGHT?!
When Namjoon did his impression the guy said “suddenly your skin tone just got darker” & called it black English wtfffffff 😤
Yeah whatever umm look at ur user than ur idol no place to talk namjoon grown and apologized
@@alyssaevans325 wait he apologized ? when ??
@@snoopyssister bighit apologized and released his statement and apology in twitter go search it up damn, ya'll are so annoying
@@haodite_ you guys are annoyed when you bias is aplogized for done so many racist things in the past but people still drag that but you guys done the same to other group. Such a doulbe standard.
@@haodite_ I'M JUST ASKING, I'M VERY SORRY :(
I feel so dissapointed. I used to be ashamed to be black when I was younger and the people kept insulting me. They told me "We can't see you in the dark" or "you're the colour of poop" which made upset. I used to wish that i could be white because of it. The people from a class next to me also recently said the n word to me, i have no idea on why they do that like do they want me to be ashamed? What the fuck is their problem? I'm now really proud to be black but i still feel very insecure when they insult me. Being black in germany (or atleast in my city) is very hard.
ughh i live in dumb america and when i was younger my sister took me to this playground with mostly white kids there and i asked if i could play some game with them but they said “no we have enough people” but when they finished this other little girl asked to play (she’s white) and they immediately let her join them and i was confused at first but then i later understood and told my sister i wanted to go home after that and we did. i still remember that day like it’s yesterday, sad.
ah wo wohnst du in Deutschland? ja die Leute hier sind echt rassistisch , tut mir leid :)
@@aboyisagun117 Alles gut du musst dich nicht entschuldigten dafür haha :) Ich hab mich schon etwas daran gewöhnt
Damn same girl same! Auch wenn der Lehrer über dunkelhäutige redet gucken mich alle aufeinmal und machen weird faces. That makes me so uncomfortable ughhh in Deutschland gibt es kein education abt Black people deswegen sind sie so ignorant:/
Aus welcher Stadt kommst du? Hier in Köln hab ich sowas noch nie erlebt
2:59 WILD. JUST WILD. No idea how some armys keep defending him with all that confidence he had when saying it.