Yes especially in Xenoverse 2. It literally just sounds like Ichigo being pissed at Goku. Johnnys an S tier VA. It just doesn’t work for a bigger guy like Broly
Yeah no contest, Vic legit sounds like a murderous psychopath who revels in destruction and havoc. Johnny....Sounds like Johnny putting on a tough guy voice. He sadly doesn't have the range to pull off a big bruiser like Broly.
Vic's Broly sounds intimidating while Johnny's Broly sounds like he's trying to be intimidating. In my opinion, Johnny just doesn't have the voice for a 7foot sadist
Johnny is fine as timid broly in dbs, but kinda sucks at dbz broly. He's trying to hard to sound like Vic so he just sounds like Ichigo if he was slightly more angsty teen. If he is doing psychotic broly then he should do it like how he did White from Bleach. If you know you know
I like JYB as a person. He's a good VA. No disrespect to JYB. But I do REALLY miss Vic. I think JYB confused the voice he should use for THIS Broly with DBS. He does a good DBS Broly, but Z Broly had a more maniacal sound to him, like the Joker had a baby with steroids.
As much as I love JYB I REALLY don’t think he was the right replacement for broly, if casting a new actor for broly to be the “canon event” as Miguel would put it I feel someone like Matthew mercer would be a better successor
It doesn't work at all. Johnny has a cool, smooth voice hero/anti hero voice. He doesn't sound heartless like a villian, especially someone as sadistic as Broly who loves being evil
Vic type casted Broly. When Broly speaks, Vic is exactly the voice you expect to come out of him. The thing is that JYB sounds like he's pushing the limit of his lower voice while Vic sounds like Broly's voice is confortably within his vocal range. It causes JYB to sound like he's trying too hard to having a booming voice instead of just having a booming voice.
I like JYB as a voice actor but this comparison makes me so sad. He’s not Broly. Sucks that they booted Vic Mignona. One of the greatest anime English VA’s ever but more importantly nobody gets or does Broly like him.
Johnny has a distinct voice that works for younger looking characters. His laugh is great but the voice coming out of that body just misses the mark. Vic I think is a little silly but its juust right for a perfect fit for this Broly
Not having Vic voice Broly in Sparking Zero wich fans have been wanting for almost 2 decades is one of the biggest Ls in gaming/anime the man is irreplaceable
As much as I love JYB, I’ve heard abridged voice actors do a better job of capturing brolys voice. See dragon ball deliverance, it might feel a bit over acted but it captures that raspy psycho voice from Vic better than JYB
The problem with Johnny's take on this it's that he doesn't make Broly sound crazy enough. He almost sounds like he is calm in a way. Broly is supose to be a psycho, and for me Vic's take is much better. I still perfer the original JP one tho haha
Vic is definitely better, there's a rough and raspiness that captures the essence of a psychopath. Johnny doesn't have that, he can do psychotic, his white ichigo is awesome, but the problem is, that it's too contained, it doesn't have that edge to it. That's why he's good for super broly even if I still prefer Vic. His performance here would be good for super broly especially when he says "i'll destroy this planet"
Can someone create a petition like broly is my top three fav characters nothing again JYB but I need Vic M there’s just no comparison. JYB is good for Super Broly just doesn’t have that menacing voice for Z broly maybe if they give him better dialogues it might help better
Johnny's broly has definitely improved ngl, starting out though I do have to give it to Vic. If only he didn't do what he did, we could've had peak dokkan.
They could not have picked a worse replacement. Could they not actually find a guy who actually sounds like an adult with bass in his voice? The Japanese voice is a force of fucking nature. This is a complete joke in comparison.
That's exactly the issue. JYB sounds like he's pushing the limit of his lower vocal range while Vic sounds like he's comfortably within his vocal range.
Vic wins by a landslide he's voice actually sounds pure evil while Johnny all i hear is ichigo and nero pretending to be evil z broly isn't a voice that JYB can do z broly character is too evil and sadistic for him
vic is 100% the better z broly, johnny is a really good super broly and could probably even do a decent untransformed z broly. but lssj z broly has such a unique voice
JYB deserves zero hate, I don’t understand why some people treat him like trash. I agree, he does a much better Super Broly than Z Broly, but it’s hardly his fault that Vic got caught up in all that bs.
@@SpedeVesku He was never convicted of anything, majority of the accusations came from several years ago with slim to none evidence that support these accusations. A bunch of he said, she said bull💩 yes he was fired for accusations but the intention wasn’t pure or justified. Clearly ulterior motive was involved base on how well orchestrated Vic’s termination was.
@@RichDXtreme247 Sure, I'm certain there's a global conspiracy formed by unrelated women, anime con staff and voice actors to discredit an anime dub actor. Definitely more believable than an anime dub actor being a creep.
@@SpedeVesku I’m gonna assume that’s sarcasm, right? Cause it’s having me believe that you are in the perspective that Vic IS a sexual predator and everyone else is in deep denial. Kinda hard to tell in text.
It’s such a miscast man. I always find myself listening to Sub nowadays, cause at least they have their shit together over in Japan. What happened to Vic wasn’t right, and he should be given his role as Broly back.
Respectfully I do not even think it is good It sounds amature And i have hard this voice before in other things and have never been a fan However he was decent as super broly But it sounds like he does not care.
Vic wins by a landslide ofcourse, his evil laugh is also unmatched
Agree 100%
All i get from Johnny's Broly is angry Ichigo.
😂
I just hear Nero from DMC
@@angelbleach8392 Same thing
@angelbleach8392 I just hear Zero from MegamanX😭
Yes especially in Xenoverse 2. It literally just sounds like Ichigo being pissed at Goku. Johnnys an S tier VA. It just doesn’t work for a bigger guy like Broly
Bro those corny English va really fucked things up kicking Vic out
Fr man😔
Blame dumbass Monica Rial.
He’s a grapist dude
Ong they trash
Vic is one of the best voice actors in entire db cast
TRUTH! 🤌
Facts
Yeah no contest, Vic legit sounds like a murderous psychopath who revels in destruction and havoc.
Johnny....Sounds like Johnny putting on a tough guy voice. He sadly doesn't have the range to pull off a big bruiser like Broly.
Vic is the man
Only good fit for Johnny is definitely Broly BR The Super Ver.
Fr they need to bring vic back for broly johnny just isn't right for z broly
@@whitetspider82whitetspider78nah vic is still better for that one too
Johnny is cool but Vic's actually make Brolly sound like a maniac
Vic's Broly sounds intimidating while Johnny's Broly sounds like he's trying to be intimidating. In my opinion, Johnny just doesn't have the voice for a 7foot sadist
Thought he was nine feet 💀
@@kalloyD. I'm assuming he's close to there
I thought he was ten feet tall?
Broly is not 7 foot he’s like 9’10 😂
@@kalloyD.7'10 in base i think
Johnny is cool and all, but we need someone who can pull off the same menace and evilness z broly had that vic made iconic
Nah we just need Vic back. That case was Bs & we all know it.
I voice zbroly like Vic but I know that other people will get mad at me if I did
@@Berserk_erguts bro just do it. Screw the haters
@@marcelousneal4641 fine I’ll try and see if I can get some footage and voice it
@@Berserk_erguts go for it let us know when you drop
Broly sounds like that kid in the back of the class who hates making friends and listen to the newest album of green day xd
Johnny is fine as timid broly in dbs, but kinda sucks at dbz broly. He's trying to hard to sound like Vic so he just sounds like Ichigo if he was slightly more angsty teen. If he is doing psychotic broly then he should do it like how he did White from Bleach. If you know you know
Facts that would be perfect imagine z broly sounding like white
Johnny makes Broly sound like a younger and reckless version of Vergil, which is ironic since Johnny already voices Vergil's deadweight son
Vic is Broly. Both of them. Nobody else can do good or evil Broly justice..
Fr
I wish there was a way to mute Broly if Vic isn't voicing him anything that isn't him ruins Broly as a character for me personally
Fr hearing z broly in sparking zero doesn't fit right with me z broly is vic and no one else
gosh johhny yong sounds like an emo teen from anime not an evil villain #istandwithvic
Johnny Broly needs to speak the hell up
JVB is too soft spoken for Broly...
Vic has a more rough voice...
I like JYB as a person. He's a good VA. No disrespect to JYB. But I do REALLY miss Vic. I think JYB confused the voice he should use for THIS Broly with DBS. He does a good DBS Broly, but Z Broly had a more maniacal sound to him, like the Joker had a baby with steroids.
We all love Johnny Yong Bosch, I mean he voiced Lelouch from Code Geass and Ichigo from Bleach.
But he simply can’t replace Vic, Vic IS Broly.
Fr replacing him was the stupidest thing ever all because of bulma's voice actor bitch ass
Vics' sheer range as a VA is insaiyan 😉
He can pull of DBZ/DBS Broly in their calm and enraged modes with absolute ease.
Johnny's voice is for protagonists, not antagonists.
Vic for the win.
Vic but jonny is a goated voice actor as well
thank you dokkan worldwide celebration 2024 for showing us just how much better JYB has gotten as Z broly since INT Broly’s release
Goku: No, you won't! *transforms into Super Saiyan*
As much as I love JYB I REALLY don’t think he was the right replacement for broly, if casting a new actor for broly to be the “canon event” as Miguel would put it I feel someone like Matthew mercer would be a better successor
It doesn't work at all. Johnny has a cool, smooth voice hero/anti hero voice. He doesn't sound heartless like a villian, especially someone as sadistic as Broly who loves being evil
Vic type casted Broly. When Broly speaks, Vic is exactly the voice you expect to come out of him.
The thing is that JYB sounds like he's pushing the limit of his lower voice while Vic sounds like Broly's voice is confortably within his vocal range.
It causes JYB to sound like he's trying too hard to having a booming voice instead of just having a booming voice.
PLEAAASE BRING BACK VIC
They wont unfortunately.
Nah, let the scum rot
Sadly they won't
Johnny sounds like ichigo and Nero entering an emo phase
Vic just fits better. Johnny still great
I love johnny but bro sounds like Ichigo or Yu Narukami telling a horror story to their friends 💀
Vic wins this can’t wait to meet him in the Uk at the Oxford Card show in March !!’
Nice!! I'm Jealous!
Winner : Vic Mignogna
Almost every character that vic plays, u cant imagine anyone else playing him. Thats why its kinda hard hearing Junpei talk in persona 3 reload…
I like JYB as a voice actor but this comparison makes me so sad. He’s not Broly. Sucks that they booted Vic Mignona. One of the greatest anime English VA’s ever but more importantly nobody gets or does Broly like him.
Went from evil Tamaki to Evil Ichigo 😂
Weird how they’re basically saying the opposite thing with their voicelines
Johnny has a distinct voice that works for younger looking characters. His laugh is great but the voice coming out of that body just misses the mark. Vic I think is a little silly but its juust right for a perfect fit for this Broly
Johnny's voice is starting to grow on me, but Vic's will always be superior. The dude's acting was ahead of his time.
Not having Vic voice Broly in Sparking Zero wich fans have been wanting for almost 2 decades is one of the biggest Ls in gaming/anime the man is irreplaceable
Fr
Johnny couldnt even dream of holding up to Vic
They should use him for Frieza.
Vic all day
As much as I love JYB, I’ve heard abridged voice actors do a better job of capturing brolys voice. See dragon ball deliverance, it might feel a bit over acted but it captures that raspy psycho voice from Vic better than JYB
The problem with Johnny's take on this it's that he doesn't make Broly sound crazy enough. He almost sounds like he is calm in a way. Broly is supose to be a psycho, and for me Vic's take is much better.
I still perfer the original JP one tho haha
I still hear Ichigo man fml..
😂😂
Ikr😂
johnny doesnt sound evil enough for broly his voice doesnt really fit him but hes a good voice actor nevertheless
The anime won no hate to dokkan fans its still cool
Johnny is super broly, vic is Z broly.
I actually really enjoy Johnny as Broly. More so Super Broly than Z Broly, but I don’t hate his Z Broly either. I think it still suits the design.
Vic is definitely better, there's a rough and raspiness that captures the essence of a psychopath.
Johnny doesn't have that, he can do psychotic, his white ichigo is awesome, but the problem is, that it's too contained, it doesn't have that edge to it. That's why he's good for super broly even if I still prefer Vic. His performance here would be good for super broly especially when he says "i'll destroy this planet"
Vic nailed it!
Vic's Broly is my Broly, Johnny's is good, but its not Broly
i feel bad for johnny, but he sounds like a ocean dubbed version of broly....
Can someone create a petition like broly is my top three fav characters nothing again JYB but I need Vic M there’s just no comparison. JYB is good for Super Broly just doesn’t have that menacing voice for Z broly maybe if they give him better dialogues it might help better
I like Shimada’s Broly more than both anyway, only voice actor in JPN I mostly prefer over ENG
Vic. It's not even close.
John does the laugh pretty well but doesn't seem to put a lot of effort into dbzs brolys actually voice. He does super broly really well though.
Johnny's broly has definitely improved ngl, starting out though I do have to give it to Vic.
If only he didn't do what he did, we could've had peak dokkan.
They really messed up big time by kicking Vic out. his voice is unmatched and really sounds like a bloodthirsty super sayian!
LOL I don't even know why people are saying Johnny's Interpretation is even "good" cause it is definitely not.
They could not have picked a worse replacement. Could they not actually find a guy who actually sounds like an adult with bass in his voice? The Japanese voice is a force of fucking nature. This is a complete joke in comparison.
Fr man like all I hear is Ichigo and Nero in broly 🤦♂️
That's exactly the issue. JYB sounds like he's pushing the limit of his lower vocal range while Vic sounds like he's comfortably within his vocal range.
Wait, he did BOTH Brolys??
Vic goated cuz you can’t even tell it’s him. Cant hear a hint of Edward’s. But with Johnny… ICHIGOOOOOOO
Kirk thorton would've been a good Z Broly
JYB is a talented actor, but he fits Super Broly better. Vic Mignonga suits Z Broly way better.
Vic wins by a landslide he's voice actually sounds pure evil while Johnny all i hear is ichigo and nero pretending to be evil z broly isn't a voice that JYB can do z broly character is too evil and sadistic for him
Vic = Z Broly
Johnny = Super Broly
No
@@BrolyContent Yes
@@OhFrittata Never
@@BrolyContent Sometimes
@@OhFrittata No, never
JY is solid for Super Broly, but VM is the perfect Z Broly.
Vic Wins by a landslide Vic will always be the Z Broly voice no matter what Johnny is good as DBS Broly but he doesn't fit what Z Broly was
This is weird. Johnny can voice sadistic bastards. I mean, look at White and the guy from P4. What happened?
Vic is a lot more natural
I do miss Vic as Broly, but, out of pure respect for Yu Narukami's English VA, and some external things that happened with Vic, Bosch wins.
Yu Narukami from Broly is cursed
vic is 100% the better z broly, johnny is a really good super broly and could probably even do a decent untransformed z broly. but lssj z broly has such a unique voice
Gosh man, all I hear is ichigo with Johnny, his voice is not vicious
Vic *IS* Broly
All I can here is nero
JYB deserves zero hate, I don’t understand why some people treat him like trash. I agree, he does a much better Super Broly than Z Broly, but it’s hardly his fault that Vic got caught up in all that bs.
Vic was hated for spreading his faith.
Frick that man.
God bless.
No, pretty sure he was hated for being a sexual predator.
@@SpedeVesku He was never convicted of anything, majority of the accusations came from several years ago with slim to none evidence that support these accusations. A bunch of he said, she said bull💩 yes he was fired for accusations but the intention wasn’t pure or justified. Clearly ulterior motive was involved base on how well orchestrated Vic’s termination was.
@@SpedeVeskuA falsely accused one.
@@RichDXtreme247 Sure, I'm certain there's a global conspiracy formed by unrelated women, anime con staff and voice actors to discredit an anime dub actor.
Definitely more believable than an anime dub actor being a creep.
@@SpedeVesku I’m gonna assume that’s sarcasm, right? Cause it’s having me believe that you are in the perspective that Vic IS a sexual predator and everyone else is in deep denial. Kinda hard to tell in text.
All I hear is nero or ichigo
I think super broly fits jyb better.
Johnny you ain’t it.🤦🏻♂️
It’s such a miscast man. I always find myself listening to Sub nowadays, cause at least they have their shit together over in Japan. What happened to Vic wasn’t right, and he should be given his role as Broly back.
For some reason I feel like Johnny fits reboot broly but is awful as z broly. Idk why.
Vic is the best, sucks after everything that's happened
Yeah not close
Jyb is better at super broly imo
johnny got better but still doesn't match the GOAT vic
Respectfully
I do not even think it is good
It sounds amature
And i have hard this voice before in other things and have never been a fan
However he was decent as super broly
But it sounds like he does not care.
yea that new voice is terrible
Not even close
I could voice a better broly than that
Yea bullshit. Keep dreaming
Prove it