'Was this a one off strike?': Military analyst Sean Bell on aid worker strike | Israel-Hamas War
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 4 апр 2024
- The Israeli military has said a series of 'grave mistakes' led to a drone strike on an aid convoy that killed seven workers in Gaza.
Among those killed in the strike were three British nationals -- James Henderson, John Chapman and James Kirby.
They were all part of the World Central Kitchen's security team and were delivering aid to civilians in Gaza, according to the charity.
Military analyst Sean Bell discusses with Sky's Kamali Melbourne.
Read more: news.sky.com/story/grave-mist...
#skynews #aidworkers #airstrike
SUBSCRIBE to our RUclips channel for more videos: / skynews
Follow us on Twitter: / skynews
Like us on Facebook: / skynews
Follow us on Instagram: / skynews
Follow us on TikTok: / skynews
For more content go to news.sky.com and download our apps: Apple itunes.apple.com/gb/app/sky-n... Android play.google.com/store/apps/de...
Sky News Daily podcast is available for free here: podfollow.com/skynewsdaily/
Sky News videos are now available in Spanish here/Los video de Sky News están disponibles en español aquí: / @skynewsespanol
To enquire about licensing Sky News content, you can find more information here: news.sky.com/info/library-sales
![Minecraft but Players Can Upgrade [FULL MOVIE]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/QRRgLJs4ZPk/mqdefault.jpg)
It was 3 separate strikes
Deliberate to stop the Aid Convoys & starve the Palestinians....Pure Evil of Judah....Shalom...old Messianic Jew
Sky, give it a rest. Your Israeli paymasters are on the wrong side of history
Exactly. This is the second interview I’ve seen on sky trying to cover up for Israel. It pathetic
This network should call itself "Pie in the Sky News". What they say sounds good on the surface, but is implausible, wishful thinking, and absurd.
@@ejiroabraham fake Israel -1/12th - Judah -is the Beast 'out of the [Mediterranean] SEA' of Daniel 7- I Believe! ....Shalom...old Messianic Jew.
@@ChrisAlbertH47😆👏
Also remember how this tory government continues to support Netanyahu's genocide.
This was a deliberate. A message was that anyone who is willing to provide aid will be targeted. Also, it was successful . Aid got stopped.
Thats a potato IQ opinion, think about it for more than 5 seconds.
Isreal isnt trying to lose its remaining support it desperatly needs.
Aid will begin again soon and aid workers now know they will be safe as the Israelis will never be able to justify a second "mistake".
For this reason I am convinced that the attack was actually a mistake (or the result of the irresponsible decision of a commander on the battlefield) and was not decided by Israeli leaders.
@@slopermarco No the IDF clearly want to alienate themselves from the rest of the world, i guess they see Russias situation and want a piece of that. Besides, mistskes never happen in a war, right?
Nonsense.
How can did they kill 200 aid workers then? If this isn't deliberate? Hello? Wake the heck up. @@Polynuttery
grave mistake? how about the 200 palestine aid worker who were killed before??
They probably destroyed Gaza accidentally too
And the countless thousands buried under rubble.
They say its a mistake but why would someone (IDF) blow up cemetery when they already dead in there
Plus over 100 reporters
Deliberate strike stopping Food Aid convoys from Kittim [Cyprus-Dan11;30]....Biblical evil being done!....Shalom ....old Messianic Jew.
This clown always comes on to make excuses for the IDF.
Ex army / veterans have been murdered! Show some respect
They have no respect for us veterans we are dogs to the US/UK empire they would rather protect foreign war criminals who hate us
I remember went he said Russia is losing the war 😂, wad liar
they brought this clown to make excuses for a foreign army to kill britons...
surely this stooge needs to be arrested...to come on British media and ok why britons were murdered by q foreign army with made up boogie men as the excuse...who only they could see by the way but couldn't see the logo on the vehicles...
What were they doing there? and ITV reported they were there providing security= Guns for hire!
No mistakes made here, it's deliberate, shameless and unforgivable
But not coverable. It wil get covered up, lied about and then forgotten and later a different story will come out which will be lies but will be treated as the truth. The families will get nothing.
Just think what happened if aid workers were killed in Ukraine by the Russian strike.
🎯
His tone would have been different of course
But the Russians do not live their lives by a book which instructs them to kill all non Muslims do they .
Biden killed 10 Palestinians by throwing aid packages at their heads from airplanes? Has anyone demanded an investigation into this?
Spot on. Also, remember the shock and disgust in Bucha? The same happened but on a larger scale in Al Shifa but nothing on the main stations about it. The media is helping to provide cover for these crimes.
Israel doesnt make mistakes. It's strategic and targeted. World is blind
Nope. World sees clearly. Western governments are just occupied.
Bought.. not blind. Who owns the banks?
u r insane
we do many mistakes. many of our own soldiers were killed by friendly fire. its very common.
Yes, targeted to discourage aid workers from operating in Gaza, thereby systematically starving its people.
Every army makes mistakes in warfare. How many Americans and allied troops did the USA kill in Iraq in 1991 and 2003? Quite a lot. It happens with poor intel and poorly disciplined troops. Israel's targeting procedures in Gaza are pretty open - if they kill ten or twenty civilians to get one "suspected Hamas operative", that's a good result for them. If there were innocent, they just say "meh - they were only arabs, so who cares". They have killed at least 3 of their own hostages trying to be rescued, and probably many more through aerial bombardment. If that's the effort they put into saving their own people, then imagine how little they put into saving Palestinian civilians. Evidently, not very much!
They clearly told the world that they will cut off food water and electricity to gaza before all this and belive me if they could cut of the oxygen in the air they would😊
They are probably working on that already.
Why didn't they make their own food, water and electricity instead of building tunnels and making rockets?
@@leechristythey did… it’s been destroyed. The tunnels too, and they found next to no infrastructure that could cause any considerable damage to the Israeli state. One is funded with billions from genocide complicit western nations whilst the other is using tactics dating back to the early 20th century. Give it a rest
@@leechristy With enough land they could do all those things. They didn't seem to have any trouble until Israel started stealing it.
No mistake, just following through in that promise.
How can it be a 1 off strike, when several dozen others have happened previously...
Hundreds, not dozens. Hundreds.
Divide and conquer.
@@ChrisAlbertH47 Dozens of individual strikes and self confessed assassinations, just under 200 individuals killed, confirmed by at least 4 different independent non Hamas affiliated global agencies.
@@ChrisAlbertH47
I wonder how much they pay him
Corporate media is always on the side of where the money is.
Is he defending it by calling it a “technical error” ??
The f##k is this guy doing back? 2 days ago he assured us this was an accident.
that's what he said in this video too. It was an accident in identifying a valid target, not an accident in firing the weapon at a different target and accidentally hitting the wrong one. They hit the target correctly, but got the wrong target accidentally. Intention is important.
So the IDF did NOT fire on the northbound vehicle with visibly armed militants, but did fire on the southbound vehicles with no militants. Did this northbound vehicle even exist??
Journalists were shown at least some of the video footage, so yes, the fourth vehicle did exist apparently.
The northbound vehicle was also WCK apparently which then headed towards another area to do further drops of aid whereas the other 3 were headed back the way they came. But if THIS now differing from spokesperson to spokesperson story was to be believed, why after the 1st 3 targets did they not then go back for the 4th? The one full of gunmen, who they didn’t target as they may have destroyed some of the aid which was very close. These people are uncontrollable. They take and speak of lives they’ve taken as if it is just another day in the office!
200 aid workers? 200?
Any Israel’s military mistakes will be American’s mistake as well.
And Brits
Almost 40k people kild all was mistak
Sham
. They saw a handbag on a man but didn't see the sign on the van?
😂😂😂
It's much easier to see a silhouette or a shape on a thermal image than to read letters or logos on the roof of a moving vehicle. Bear in mind the strike was at night, so drone pilots would not have great visual fidelity with night-vision cameras.
Even then, the image quality was poor enough to not be able to differentiate between a shoulder bag and a weapon, so it's clearly not good enough to make a kill / no-kill decision. They were just trigger-happy and don't care enough about killing the wrong people.
@@johngwheeler 😂😂😂😂😂
@@johngwheeleryou give to much credit.The supposed gunman was on a truck that entered a Aid Depot known to the IDF. No effort was made to warn the depot or check if the gunman was part of the Aid security detail, the IDF would have been informed about the british security services employed by the Aid organisation. No gunman was identified two hours later, leaving the depot and getting in the van. Obviously the IDF new it was a Aid depot. It is unbelievable that the IDF did not knowingly target Aid workers.
If this was Russia 🪆 would Bell 🔔 be giving a similar explanation
😂😂😂
like f he would
@@rooksfoot1184 precisely because one can claim that Russia is destroying schools, hospitals and private homes in Ukraine because the Ukrainian have built miles of tunnels under them.
Hypocrites
Exactly.
Why idf don't release video with those gunmen ? until then just bs.
They have all major news journalists have seen it
@@marcust123 all major news journalists are monkeys who just repeat what they are told to say.
@@marcust123 Name one.
... Really, it took over three days to concoct a story.? 🤔
Prof Michael Clark dismisses the IDF reasoning and implies it was deliberate.
@@ONTHEHUNT119They dont deserve one
@@ONTHEHUNT119 Michael Clark has an antenna for BS.
was the mistake the nationality of the aid workers? the fact they were vets? or the fact everyone knows about it?
Remember when they killed 3 male hostages by mistake before realizing that they were Jews?
@@danielch6662 they killed them as they thought they were unarmed
palestinians
Rachell Allen Corrie (April 10, 1979 - March 16, 2003) They did it again
What they did to Rachell was utterly abhorrent, I don't remember much changing in the narrative.
🌹
King David Hotel 1946
USS Liberty 1967
It was 3 stikes, aprox 1.5km apart. And they attacked each vehicle as the survivors from the attakc made their way to the next vehicle.
Excuses excuses excuses. Long time since I tuned into sky news. lol won’t b back for a one sided news channel for a long time. Same old billshit propaganda
This was a assassination of witness that witnessed war crimes and they likely had evidences"
The only mistake was the victims weren't Palestinians.
stop your apologies fir criminality
I’m sorry, 😂 I don’t want to believe it, but it’s so clear, but it was clear that they were targeted. They changed vehicles thrice time! And they kept attacking these humanitarians
Lies lies lies…
How can an bomb that kills several people be a "grave mistake", an "accident", and a "one-off"?
Keep repeating the lies, they think we will believe this nonsense if they keep saying it was a mistake. ?
Idf is rouge army what can be expected from them
And here is Sean Bell to read the IDF briefing verbatim.
Anyone who believes this was a one-off strike doesn't deserve to be considered an expert.
Fix your thumbnail guys. I've already told off talkTV today for the same thing.
Quality, not quantity.
It’s a grave mistake
Making excuses for and promising unconditional support is the real mistake.
Cause the drone operators were teenagers on drugs thinking it's a video games
defund.
Interesting. It’s the first time I’ve heard that the aid workers were accompanied by gunmen. To keep crowds away. It could explain a lot.
That’s the most BS I’ve heard in my life. What a joke!
The Circus is in full swing!
Why didn't the windows break?
Two of the 3 vehicles were armoured and the warhead on the missile may have been small enough to blow open the doors but not shatter the armoured glass.
I did notice that one of the vehicles had the interior upholstery intact, implying there was no fire. This might indicate a Hellfire "flying Gyoza knife" missile that has no explosive, but opens up multiple blades to destroy a target with kinetic energy and penetrating wounds.
Either way, this is a pretty nasty way to die, albeit probably quite quick. I'm surprised that there were survivors in the first 2 strikes who were still able to run to the other vehicles in the convoy. It must have been a desperate situation.
It's tough to follow this!!!
Sean! Just dont bother.
They can't tell the truth. But Mr. Guterres did tell the World the truth.
Was this a one time strike ? The answer is simple NO
"Was this TRAGIC MISTAKE ONE OFF?"
IDF said no more aid to the north, the convoy was heading to the north so this was deliberate.
sean saber rattling bell
The most important thing to focus on is how to build a long-lasting peace in the area and hopefully 🙏 in the world.
Please end all wars as they benefit no one at all.
Mr Bell rings for the M.I.C. once more
Humans made a fkig big mistake by funding the bloody thing!!
It was an accident, they thought innocent Palestinians were in the cars
Three cars. Clearly a strategic and coordinated attack on unarmed civilians
Those 3 UK security staff would never have let any weapons or threats near that aid convoy. They would have been vigilant to that sort of that stuff. There needs to be an independent investigation and testimonies from staff in and around that warehouse.
Excellent reporting
they can identify Iranian nuclear scientist in another country but can't identify 3 large aid trucks coordinating with them, is this a joke
"Israel has declared war on aid organisations", in other words: it has declared war on humanity.
Listening to this makes me angry , arrogance , unforgivable shameful and merciless . When people die ANYWHERE we must show remorse and not disguise things as mistakes . If I kill somebody there must be repercussions- not just oopsie daiseee
If this man does not know that an artificial intelligence is being used to select targets then he does not know what he is talking about
Dead men tell no tales. I wonder what they saw before they were murdered?
He seems to be representing IDF.
They wouldn't travel in vehicles. They have tunnels. Remember? Plus they never leave the house because they are full-time 24/7 'human shields'. U. S. needs to be in the dock with them when it's done.
Yeah, it's not like they haven't attacked their allies before on purpose.
This is another special military operation without a winner
Russia and Israel will both win. Arguably, they already have.
Remember this is the same guy who said Russians are fighting with showels 😂😂😂
Is there drone footage that shows "gunmen on the roof of the vehicle"?
Where is the satelite or drone footage that shows armed gunmen anywhere naer the convoy.
Were any of the exservice volunteers armed themselves?
This guy is too pro Israel, his analysis is clouded
What a cover up story. We not stupid 🚫
This so called analyst from sky is talking nonsense why is he trying to cover for IDF
I’m not sure what he’s saying, no commitment
Not sure about that, targeting Palestinians did not stop the aid flowing. This did though, and the PR spin like this channel is allowing them to get away with it.
It was not misidentification. The WCK workers knew something that IDF wouldn’t want it to leak. Not something that has happened but rather something that will happen.
There's an incident before that they bombed ambulances carrying patients. There's a pattern here.
Nope, once ehh maybe but a stretch but thrice no way.
Rahfa must be cleared , this tragic incident does not change this fundamental fact .
Show some video that supports your story. Otherwise, total BS!
Sky give it a rest .... mistakes happen
Cocktail of lies and propaganga
Yes, it is really MIST KAKE on thumbnail 😂😂😂
Those who thought they will celebrate destruction of Israel sorry to u
They could always release the hostages.
A rare, good interview and content from Sky News. A quick question for all the media. Why is every picture of the Palestinian's standing around show healthy people and not a starving population. While I do not doubt that some are starving, it seems to be due to internal power struggles (Hamas, clan leaders) and greed of fellow Palestinian's.
Opened a can of worms. Will eventually lead to action by the ICJ and lots of grief for all involved. Refusal to take part will put Netanyahu in the naughty corner with putin.
wow
What a cocktail of lies. None of the gunmen footage has been provided to journalists. Absolutely deliberate by a bunch of arrogant soldiers who are above the law.
It was a huge mistkake
What's a Mistcake?
Anyone who says it was not a mistake is biased against Israel. Unfortunately, these things happen in all warzones.
Skynew desperately trying to restore some credibility to israel ,,,,this is hilarious at this point
A speck of dust in a desert surrounded by enemies who has started a three front war while in economic freefall has elected to insult all its allies as food rots on the vine and destroyed any care from international aid organizations because they kept killing the aid workers.
What does everyone think happens next?
So that they are using AI is what 😮😮😮
75 year long apartheid,16 year long blockade of Gaza and now committing genocide.
No he didn't.
A mistake? It was intentional... probably a decision made by Lavender (AI).
Galatians 6:7 KJV
7 Be not deceived; God is not mocked: for whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap.
typical sean ding dong bell ???
Remember when Macron was caught on hot mic saying to Obama "I can't stand that guy he's just a liar"?
Collateral damage