I love China's tone the most. However when it comes to upper belts I think Dove takes it. China with these mid belts though. Sofia definitely is awesome but Dove and China take the cake.
Dove voice is so light she is my least favorite tone of the three she takes off in upper belting Sofia voice is distinctive I think she is the perfect middle between the two China was my favorite she also has my favorite tone and has the strongest lows and mid belts
Actually, technically speaking, Dove's lows are the best. But I agree, China outdoes Dove and Sofia in mid-belting (I never expected her to be this good though, considering that very few vocalists from Disney can actually compete with Dove)
@@varunravi27 I will have to respectfully disagree on dove having the better lows. I think people also forget china was/is a singer before this movie. She also sings the middle notes in her group with her sisters.
@@Jhearn93 I agree that people do forget that China became a singer at a very young age. In terms of consistency and vocal freedom, Dove's low notes are a teensy bit better (China's darker tone allows her to project her low notes better than Dove so China wins for projection)
what do you think these girls' voice types are? Dove is a soprano for sure, but what about Sofia and China? And yes I agree, the last Disney trinity was Miley-Demi-Selena oh how fast time flies. It's crazy that these three are from the same movie franchise tho. That's like putting Demi, Selena and Miley in a movie 😂
@@justinbraylock757 Dove's is the only correct one. China is also a soprano (her voice is evidently high-placed and her lows are far too weak for her to be a mezzo)... most people just don't know which subclassification (I would say she's an underdeveloped full-lyric because she has that womanly grit in her voice, but her voice, despite being powerful, is not powerful enough for her to be a spinto-soprano or a dramatic). As for Sofia, I would classify her as a soubrette because she has a lower tessitura than the other two, but not low enough for her to be a mezzo-soprano. She lacks that darkness in her voice (it's rather bright and has a youthful quality; and, like the usual soubrette's, her voice lacks flexibility/agility)
Honestly this is one of my favorite RUclips vídeos ever, is so funny how China seems to have the lowest voice but Dove and Sofia actually went lower then her, and she went higher then them (on belting) when seems like they both have higher voices (specially Dove). Tone wise I'll say China is my fav, but between all the notes I'll say my favorite high notes are by Dove (specially her E5 on Better in Stereo and the F5 on Ways To Be Wicked
This is my opinion: Low notes (I didn't include D3 because China can't hit a D3, and also not Eb3 because Dove, despite possibly being able to hit the note, has never sung it live, or even in studio, for that matter): E3: Dove = China (+3) > Sofia (+2) F3: Dove = Sofia (+3) > China (+2) F#3: Dove (+3) > China (+2) > Sofia (+1) G3: Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2) > China (+1) Belts (I didn't include anything above F#5 because that's Sofia's highest belt) Bb4: China = Dove = Sofia (+3) Bb4: Dove (+3) > China = Sofia (+2) B4: China = Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2) B4: Sofia (+3) > Dove = China (+2) C5: China = Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2) C5: Dove (+3) > China (+2) > Sofia (+1) C#5: China = Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2) C#5: China (+3) > Dove (+2) > Sofia (+1) D5: China (+3) > Dove (+2) > Sofia (+1) Eb5: China (+3) > Dove = Sofia (+2) Eb5: China = Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2) E5: Dove (+3) > China (+2) > Sofia (+1) E5: Dove (+3) > China (+2) > Sofia (+1) F5: Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2) > China (+1) F#5: China (+3) > Dove (+2) > Sofia (+1) Upper register (Dove and China use head voice while Sofia uses falsetto; I didn't include F5 as Sofia doesn't have an F5 in the upper register as far as this video is concerned, and also nothing above A5 because Dove and China don't have Bb5, Sofia and China don't have B5 and Sofia doesn't have C6 in the upper register as far as this video is concerned): D5: Dove = Sofia (+3) > China (+2) Eb5: China = Dove = Sofia (+3) E5: China = Sofia (+3) > Dove (+2) G5: Sofia (+3) > China (+2) > Dove (+1) A5: Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2) > China (+1) Low notes: Dove > China = Sofia Belts: Dove > China > Sofia Upper register: Sofia > Dove > China Sofia - 48 Dove - 64 China - 57 ✨Dove ✨wins (China isn't far behind though! She's a really good vocalist... she's on the same level as Miley Cyrus, and Dove is on the same level as Jessie J or Demi Lovato)
Tone: China>Sofía>Dove
Technique: Dove>China>Sophia
Style: Sofía>China>Dove
Love chinas tone best
I love China's tone the most. However when it comes to upper belts I think Dove takes it. China with these mid belts though. Sofia definitely is awesome but Dove and China take the cake.
Dove voice is so light she is my least favorite tone of the three she takes off in upper belting
Sofia voice is distinctive I think she is the perfect middle between the two
China was my favorite she also has my favorite tone and has the strongest lows and mid belts
Actually, technically speaking, Dove's lows are the best. But I agree, China outdoes Dove and Sofia in mid-belting (I never expected her to be this good though, considering that very few vocalists from Disney can actually compete with Dove)
@@varunravi27 I will have to respectfully disagree on dove having the better lows. I think people also forget china was/is a singer before this movie. She also sings the middle notes in her group with her sisters.
@@Jhearn93 I agree that people do forget that China became a singer at a very young age. In terms of consistency and vocal freedom, Dove's low notes are a teensy bit better (China's darker tone allows her to project her low notes better than Dove so China wins for projection)
Sofia is of course the best lower register
China for me! 4:37 I’m speechless
what do you think these girls' voice types are? Dove is a soprano for sure, but what about Sofia and China? And yes I agree, the last Disney trinity was Miley-Demi-Selena oh how fast time flies. It's crazy that these three are from the same movie franchise tho. That's like putting Demi, Selena and Miley in a movie 😂
Dove- Light-Lyric Soprano
Sofia- Mezzo-Soprano (?)
China- Mezzo-Soprano
@@justinbraylock757 Sofia's hard to pinpoint hahah
@@fiveh3340 she really is 😂 i said the same thing about Kehlani’s voice
@@justinbraylock757 i think it's crazy how a mezzo can have more upper range than a soprano. Cause Dove goes to G#5 but China can go up to A5.
@@justinbraylock757 Dove's is the only correct one. China is also a soprano (her voice is evidently high-placed and her lows are far too weak for her to be a mezzo)... most people just don't know which subclassification (I would say she's an underdeveloped full-lyric because she has that womanly grit in her voice, but her voice, despite being powerful, is not powerful enough for her to be a spinto-soprano or a dramatic).
As for Sofia, I would classify her as a soubrette because she has a lower tessitura than the other two, but not low enough for her to be a mezzo-soprano. She lacks that darkness in her voice (it's rather bright and has a youthful quality; and, like the usual soubrette's, her voice lacks flexibility/agility)
Honestly this is one of my favorite RUclips vídeos ever, is so funny how China seems to have the lowest voice but Dove and Sofia actually went lower then her, and she went higher then them (on belting) when seems like they both have higher voices (specially Dove). Tone wise I'll say China is my fav, but between all the notes I'll say my favorite high notes are by Dove (specially her E5 on Better in Stereo and the F5 on Ways To Be Wicked
China Sofia dove all has great voices
sofia for mee! she has a rlly unique voice!
I LOVE Sofia's and China's voices the BEST/MOST!!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️ l LOVE the movies 🎥
This is my opinion:
Low notes (I didn't include D3 because China can't hit a D3, and also not Eb3 because Dove, despite possibly being able to hit the note, has never sung it live, or even in studio, for that matter):
E3: Dove = China (+3) > Sofia (+2)
F3: Dove = Sofia (+3) > China (+2)
F#3: Dove (+3) > China (+2) > Sofia (+1)
G3: Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2) > China (+1)
Belts (I didn't include anything above F#5 because that's Sofia's highest belt)
Bb4: China = Dove = Sofia (+3)
Bb4: Dove (+3) > China = Sofia (+2)
B4: China = Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2)
B4: Sofia (+3) > Dove = China (+2)
C5: China = Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2)
C5: Dove (+3) > China (+2) > Sofia (+1)
C#5: China = Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2)
C#5: China (+3) > Dove (+2) > Sofia (+1)
D5: China (+3) > Dove (+2) > Sofia (+1)
Eb5: China (+3) > Dove = Sofia (+2)
Eb5: China = Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2)
E5: Dove (+3) > China (+2) > Sofia (+1)
E5: Dove (+3) > China (+2) > Sofia (+1)
F5: Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2) > China (+1)
F#5: China (+3) > Dove (+2) > Sofia (+1)
Upper register (Dove and China use head voice while Sofia uses falsetto; I didn't include F5 as Sofia doesn't have an F5 in the upper register as far as this video is concerned, and also nothing above A5 because Dove and China don't have Bb5, Sofia and China don't have B5 and Sofia doesn't have C6 in the upper register as far as this video is concerned):
D5: Dove = Sofia (+3) > China (+2)
Eb5: China = Dove = Sofia (+3)
E5: China = Sofia (+3) > Dove (+2)
G5: Sofia (+3) > China (+2) > Dove (+1)
A5: Dove (+3) > Sofia (+2) > China (+1)
Low notes: Dove > China = Sofia
Belts: Dove > China > Sofia
Upper register: Sofia > Dove > China
Sofia - 48
Dove - 64
China - 57
✨Dove ✨wins (China isn't far behind though! She's a really good vocalist... she's on the same level as Miley Cyrus, and Dove is on the same level as Jessie J or Demi Lovato)
Love these girls 😍😍😍
What a coincidence their upper range (falsetto/head voice) all end at G6
I know right. I shouldve included it
@@ruanfourie6436 it was a great vid nonetheless! thank you for this
All i love them all💗💛💜💙
Where was china G#5 from
ANTfarm episode Fraudulant
@@ruanfourie6436 whaaat i watch ant farm all the time and i never heard of that episode
I want list of the songs so bad :(
Dove is the best vocalist technically but Sofia has the best lower register
China eats both of them vocally and easily stands out more tbh
@@littemixwillsurvive1871 perioddd
Muito massa ❤️❤️
❤️❤️❤️
🤩👌🏻
Sofia has the best vocal tier
agreee
Where is China F5 from
It's from her song Young Guns from Black Lightning
ruclips.net/video/YfkA4-gn0G8/видео.html