What if Apollo had crashed on the Moon ?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 мар 2017
  • For all of the celebrations surrounding the first manned lunar landing of Apollo 11 in 1969, what is forgotten today is just how close they and the other Apollo missions flew to the edge of disaster.
    Patreon : / curiousdroid
    Paypal.me : www.paypal.me/curiousdroid
    You can now translate this and other curious droid videos, see my video about it here • Curious Droid RUclips ...
    Apollo 11 came within seconds of aborting the landing because they had over shot the landing area and were running low on fuel.
    This was only one of several issues with the Apollo missions that arose that could have led to the loss of the mission and crew, though as it turned out only Apollo 13 came close to this happening. This excludes the Apollo 1 accident where the crew died because of a fire as they rehearsed a launch on January 27th, 1967.
    Apollo 12 was struck by lightning twice a during the launch and although it knocked several electrical systems, the main navigation system continued to work and the rest of the mission proceeded successfully.
    On Apollo 16 the engine back up system malfunctioned on the command module as it orbited the moon which resulted in the flight being 1 day shorter but mission control determined that they could work around the fault instead of aborting the mission.
    Even Apollo 11 was a test flight, with it building upon the previous mission’s results and achievements. It was to be the first attempt at a manned landing and was driven as much by the desire to achieve President Kennedys directive to put a man on the moon before the end of the decade as it was to beat the perceived threat from the Soviets getting there first, US national pride was at stake if either of these failed.
    As Apollo 11 was to be the first landing, NASA wanted to make sure that it would be as event free as possible, so they chose to land on the largest flattest part of the moon that they could find, officially known as site 2, it was a 10 mile long elliptical area in the northern sea of tranquillity.
    The idea was that the flight computer on board the lander would guide it down to from 50,000 feet to 500 feet above the surface where Neil Armstrong would take over the controls for the final landing.
    However, Armstrong became aware early on that things were not going to plan and that they had already flown over the landing site and were heading to a boulder strewn area now known as west crater which about the size of a football field.
    He assumed control from the flight computer and manually flew over West crater and another smaller crater before landing at the outer edge of site 2 about 4 miles from its intended target, and uttering the immortal words, "Houston, Tranquillity Base here - the Eagle has landed."
    As he was making the final descent, mission control estimated that they had just 25 seconds of fuel left at the time they landed, although this was later revised to 45 seconds after the mission.
    Fluidscape by Kevin MacLeod is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution licence (creativecommons.org/licenses/...)
    Source: incompetech.com/music/royalty-...
    Artist: incompetech.com/
  • НаукаНаука

Комментарии • 6 тыс.

  • @zudemaster
    @zudemaster 6 лет назад +882

    Imagine being Mike Collins and having to take that lonely trip home alone without Aldrin and Armstrong.

    • @arbigdog73
      @arbigdog73 4 года назад +68

      I've always wondered that too. I also wonder what his solo training was?

    • @WesleyG8857
      @WesleyG8857 4 года назад +86

      Couldn't imagine a 3 day trek home wondering if the men you'd just gone there with were dead or not, yet...

    • @lengyel
      @lengyel 4 года назад +174

      If you read his excellent book "Carrying the Fire", in which Collins himself tells the story of his career from test pilot to Command Module Pilot, the prospect of leaving his friends on the moon and returning alone was the only thing that ever really gave him nightmares. He was never in his life happier than when Armstrong and Aldrin successfully returned to the CM.

    • @WesleyG8857
      @WesleyG8857 4 года назад +23

      @@lengyel It's a scary thought!

    • @Bankable2790
      @Bankable2790 4 года назад +85

      I watched a documentary called “Far Side of the Moon” or something like that. In it, they had Collins talking about how it dawned on him while orbiting the far side of the moon that he was the most distance person from all the rest of humanity had ever been alone, and the overwhelming peace he felt with God in that moment. Truly spiritual

  • @Andrew-ep4kw
    @Andrew-ep4kw 3 года назад +37

    In a book I read about the astronauts, one of them said there were no "suicide pills". According to the book he said the easiest and quickest way to end it all on the moon was to vent the air in the LEM to the outside. He also said if there was a survivable crash, most likely they would continue to report on conditions and observations until their oxygen ran out.

    • @IgnobleKin
      @IgnobleKin 6 месяцев назад +2

      Dutiful to the end.

  • @mrloop1530
    @mrloop1530 4 года назад +657

    "Houston, we are out of fuel!"
    - Flight control: "Hello, who is this?"

    • @MaynardGKrebs-gv4vy
      @MaynardGKrebs-gv4vy 4 года назад +39

      LMAO !! Another scenario:
      Apollo: "Houston, we are out of fuel".
      Flight control: "Well, good buddy, there's gas at the next exit. What's your 20?

    • @MaynardGKrebs-gv4vy
      @MaynardGKrebs-gv4vy 4 года назад +16

      Reminds me also of a Rodney Dangerfield joke:
      "I tell ya, my wife doesn't love me. I called her yesterday and asked her if she wanted to have a romantic evening at home. She said "Who is this?" I get no respect...

    • @eamesaerospace2805
      @eamesaerospace2805 4 года назад +11

      New phone who dis?

    • @yogeshkoranga2323
      @yogeshkoranga2323 4 года назад +3

      @@eamesaerospace2805 lmao

    • @obhuicoksetyaetse1
      @obhuicoksetyaetse1 4 года назад +3

      you peeopl think your funny but youre really just ASSHOLES

  • @wfjhDUI
    @wfjhDUI 5 лет назад +241

    "We have good news and bad news Michael. The good news is that you're promoted to captain of the mission and it's your time to shine! The bad news is that your buddies are dead or dying and you need to snap a few pics."

    • @JonatasAdoM
      @JonatasAdoM 4 года назад +24

      "Congratulations, you're now the first man to go to the moon... and come back."

    • @bennybau123
      @bennybau123 4 года назад +15

      @@JonatasAdoM not exactly, since Apollo 8, the crew has been orbiting the moon, so the first would be the crew of Apollo 8 ;)

    • @ashgreninja7521
      @ashgreninja7521 4 года назад +4

      @@bennybau123
      Borman Lovell Anders (Apollo 8) orbited moon
      Apollo 9 performed lm redocking in earth orbit only
      Apollo 10(Jim mcdivvit) almost reached the moon as dress rehearsal for Apollo 11

    • @alexanderleeart
      @alexanderleeart 4 года назад +1

      @@ashgreninja7521 apollo 10 wasn't jim mcdivvit

    • @ashgreninja7521
      @ashgreninja7521 4 года назад +2

      @@alexanderleeart Apollo 9 was mcdivvit, Apollo 10 was Stafford
      Sorry my bad

  • @jimthompson939
    @jimthompson939 5 лет назад +37

    The thumbnail for this video cracks me up! It is like Neil Armstrong jumped out of the lander 50 feet from the surface and landed face first, THUNK! "Houston we have a belly flop."

  • @MichaelClark-uw7ex
    @MichaelClark-uw7ex 2 года назад +11

    I think that Apollo 8 was at least as monumental as Apollo 11.
    It was the first time anyone had ever left the Earth for another body in space.

  • @gemizu4874
    @gemizu4874 4 года назад +196

    now i feel bad for leaving my kerbals in space :(

    • @hakont.4960
      @hakont.4960 4 года назад +21

      I always start a new save if any of my Kerbals die, I also try to keep them somewhat comfortable during long trips. This results in me having to build huge and complex space crafts lifted by obscenely big boosters for longer trips.

    • @Keinerboy
      @Keinerboy 4 года назад +2

      Go rescue them, I did !!

    • @JonatasAdoM
      @JonatasAdoM 4 года назад +10

      I can't stand watching someone just leaving them years in space on fast forward. I imagine their lives being miserable inside of the craft.

    • @uplinkx1126
      @uplinkx1126 4 года назад +4

      This is why you send the rescue team first.

    • @thegamingmatin575
      @thegamingmatin575 4 года назад +1

      I understaf a second ship to save them

  • @tonydevault3844
    @tonydevault3844 5 лет назад +18

    Growing up the Mercury, Gemini, and Apollo Astronauts were my Heroes. I always wanted to be an Astronaut. Most people cannot fathom the skill and courage these men put forth to achieve putting a man on the moon.

    • @mcfcguvnors
      @mcfcguvnors 5 лет назад +1

      n you ended up on you tube - where people are more famous than astronauts :/

    • @TheGecko213
      @TheGecko213 2 года назад +1

      Tony, that Moon was on a movie studio in Nevada desert 🌵

    • @raptorwhite6468
      @raptorwhite6468 Год назад

      ​@@TheGecko213 No it wasn't

  • @edwardvanleppard2774
    @edwardvanleppard2774 7 лет назад +1426

    Cutting communications, that's cold.

    • @stevehoward3049
      @stevehoward3049 6 лет назад +176

      That s the Government for you

    • @zarion1181
      @zarion1181 6 лет назад +182

      These astronauts were well aware of the risks they were taking.

    • @majormissile5596
      @majormissile5596 6 лет назад +123

      Honestly though, what would you tell your crew if they got stuck on the surface on the moon and there is no way you can bring them back?

    • @tovrobi5097
      @tovrobi5097 6 лет назад +92

      Major Missile At least something.

    • @huupper
      @huupper 6 лет назад +208

      Yeah you'd hope to be able to talk to your loved ones one last time

  • @donjaksa4071
    @donjaksa4071 5 лет назад +393

    History could have gone like this
    1. Apollo 11 crashes on moon after running out of fuel - crew lost
    2. Apollo 12 blows up on launch when struck by lightening - crew lost
    3. Apollo 13 lost on way to moon - crew lost
    4. Program canceled

    • @almostfm
      @almostfm 5 лет назад +46

      Actually, 11 wasn't close to running out of fuel. The times that you hear Charlie Duke call out are the "bingo fuel" times-the point at which, if they couldn't make an immediate landing, they'd have to abort. That gave them enough fuel to fire the descent engine full thrust to give them some altitude, jettison the descent stage, and fire the ascent stage engine. The needed the altitude because once they cut the descent engine so they could jettison the stage, they'd be falling back toward the surface until the ascent engine could fire. I saw a quote from Cernan one time who said that you needed to get at least 200 feet above the surface to give yourself enough time to jettison, pressurize the ascent tanks, and fire the ascent engine, and arrest your descent.

    • @CPS2
      @CPS2 5 лет назад +6

      lightning*

    • @jmswms53
      @jmswms53 5 лет назад +12

      And yet We ROCKETED!!! LITERALLY!!!! Awesome age of Aquarius Soooo Adauatious! Proud to be an America citizen of Earth!!

    • @OompaL0ompa
      @OompaL0ompa 5 лет назад +37

      Reality:
      1.it worked
      2. it worked again
      3. had a problem but still worked
      4. Program canceled because the miltary industrial took over control of the whole country.

    • @epiendless1128
      @epiendless1128 5 лет назад +6

      Don't forget Apollo 10 - LM lost control due to one astronaut flipping a switch when the other astronaut had already flipped it. LM came within seconds of its roll becoming unrecoverable.
      It would have hit the Moon.

  • @collegeman1988
    @collegeman1988 5 лет назад +4

    What’s amazing is that Apollo 7, 8, 9, 10 and 11 were all missions where NASA had performed mission objectives that had never, ever been done before without any serious problems happening and all astronauts safely returning to earth. That was truly an amazing time in space exploration for both the United States and for NASA.

    • @collegeman1988
      @collegeman1988 5 лет назад +1

      jimmyfly Yes. I know that each Apollo mission from 7 through 11 built off of what had been completed in previous missions. However, each successive Apollo mission did something that had never been done before in the history of space flight without any problems, which to anyone should be considered amazing.

    • @collegeman1988
      @collegeman1988 5 лет назад +1

      jimmyfly All of the astronauts on those missions safely returned to Earth, and that’s what counts.

    • @johnvrabec9747
      @johnvrabec9747 3 месяца назад

      The Saturn V launches that were unmanned were a first for NASA, as prior launch vehicles tested each stage as its own launch. The Saturn V was the first multistage rocket tested as a single vehicle, or as they called it "all up".

  • @frankie65th
    @frankie65th 5 лет назад +52

    I am watching this video 2 years later, not realizing i have already like it lol!

    • @claireboden9081
      @claireboden9081 5 лет назад

      Buzz watched it too. He never knew they were talking about him.

  • @Geographus666
    @Geographus666 5 лет назад +118

    Five Word Horror Stories: "Goodbye Houston, thanks for trying!"

    • @prolinelectricful
      @prolinelectricful 5 лет назад

      Ya thanks for trying to get nowhere! They couldnt talk to anyone on the moon. That is bullshit, wishful thinking tho.

  • @nethercraft1671
    @nethercraft1671 5 лет назад +209

    Mission control we are out of fuel
    NASA mission control = we don't know you

    • @AlexReiter1988
      @AlexReiter1988 5 лет назад +1

      Cold huh

    • @almostfm
      @almostfm 5 лет назад +7

      "Out of fuel" wasn't the scenario. The concern was that the ascent engine (which had it's own propellant tanks) wouldn't fire for some reason.

    • @charlesvan13
      @charlesvan13 4 года назад

      If they ran out of fuel before landing, they would just fire the ascent engine and return home. There was no doubt a good chance that they would crash rather than abort being so close to their goal.

    • @charlesvan13
      @charlesvan13 4 года назад +1

      @jimmyfly
      They would rather die rather than making a false abort. And it's not always clear when they're out of options.

    • @charlesvan13
      @charlesvan13 4 года назад +5

      @jimmyfly
      Frank Borman (Commander of Apollo 8)
      "I would rather die than make a false abort."
      I'm sure that attitude is common among astronauts making a first attempt at a Moon shot, and knowing there are serious risks.

  • @AMadScientist
    @AMadScientist 5 лет назад +2

    I saw an interview somewhere with Buzz Aldrin. They asked him about being stuck on the moon or if the rocket didn't fire to bring them back up. They asked him what would you do. He said they would keep troubleshooting until they ran out of oxygen.

  • @deeppurple883
    @deeppurple883 3 года назад +5

    The most nail biting part of the mission for me was the take of from the moon. That's the part that would give me nightmares, just imagin the last release mechanism not detaching . You only get one go at leaving the moon . That goes for every moon mission, just thinking about it gives me the shivers, that's all it takes . It's always the little things that catch you 😱

  • @jematheny
    @jematheny 5 лет назад +6

    On the descent, Buzz Aldrin decided to enable the ascent rendezvous radar. He reasoned, if there were a problem during descent, it would be much easier--since the ascent radar was active--to acquire and dock with the lunar orbiter. This procedure was never previously agreed upon or rehearsed--it was just Buzz's helpful idea at the time. Therefore, with both ascent and descent radars simultaneously providing data to the lander's computer, the computer became overloaded, issued periodic error codes and frequently reset. The descent calculations were therefor inaccurate and resulted in the lander flying past its intended primary target. My information comes from recalling bits of past information, and hopefully I am correct. NASA took many risks and there were other potential disasters. (I need to catch up on these videos and hopefully have not repeated a previous topic.)

    • @willoughbykrenzteinburg
      @willoughbykrenzteinburg 5 лет назад +1

      I'm going to have to refresh my recollection. I do not recall two parts of this story you mention. 1) I do not remember hearing that the activation of the ascent rendezvous radar was deliberate. I thought it was either left on or turned on by accident. 2) I do not remember hearing that the overload caused them to overshoot the landing. I've always understood that the computer was putting them down in the correct place; it was just covered with boulders, so Armstrong took over and deliberately overshot the landing.

    • @johnvrabec9747
      @johnvrabec9747 3 месяца назад

      They landed long because the docking tunnel was not 100% vented prior to undocking and that minute amount of residual pressure released at undocking pushed them off course a wee bit and it caused them to land beyond the targeted landing spot.

    • @johnvrabec9747
      @johnvrabec9747 3 месяца назад

      All insertions and injections are based on mission timelines, so, that little extra kick meant PDI started on time, but further west than nominal, therefore a long landing. When they were flying windows down to verify visual landmarks to reaffirm correct tracking, Armstrong noted they were hitting those landmarks early.

  • @iamismeallright
    @iamismeallright 6 лет назад +39

    Please make videos about all of the specific apollo missions. The differences in mission profiles, specifics and mission objectives.

  • @suchiboy
    @suchiboy 5 лет назад +21

    Hi, quite like your videos. Found them to be well researched, informative and out of the ordinary. Keep up the good work!

  • @aliensoup2420
    @aliensoup2420 4 года назад +2

    One thing I find interesting in this regard, is that immediately upon setting foot on the Moon - apart from his famous "One small step.." pronouncement - Armstrong began describing the geology of the surface. This was probably one of the scientific responsibilities of the mission, and they had to take every opportunity they had to relay as much information as possible back to Earth in the event they might not return.

  • @montylc2001
    @montylc2001 6 лет назад +708

    The tragedy is that we stopped going.

    • @pim1943
      @pim1943 6 лет назад +64

      It's extremely expensive for seemingly little gain. Back then, there was the cold war, the head to head with the Sovjet Union. Spaceflight was perfect for this competition. Nowadays, it's different. I don't think the scientific data alone gathered from the Apollo missions would have justified its cost. It was 'beating the other side' that was the driving force behind the space race.

    • @CurtisLittlechild92
      @CurtisLittlechild92 6 лет назад +14

      ugh! Not another one.

    • @CurtisLittlechild92
      @CurtisLittlechild92 6 лет назад +27

      jam biggest Another twat who thinks the moon landings didn’t happen.

    • @CurtisLittlechild92
      @CurtisLittlechild92 5 лет назад +14

      Haven't you got bs conspiracy theories to spread or something?

    • @MrDaiseymay
      @MrDaiseymay 5 лет назад +20

      THE REAL TRAGEDY IS PRICKS LIKE YOU, STILL BELIEVING THIS CRUD, AFTER YEARS OF PROVING IT'S ALL FAKERY

  • @peterdeacon4085
    @peterdeacon4085 7 лет назад +4

    Thanks once again for a fascinating and thought provoking video. The quality of these just gets better and better and you are rapidly becoming my favourite YT channel. Long may your curiosity continue.

  • @coreyfellows9420
    @coreyfellows9420 5 лет назад +15

    What balls those cats had.....

  • @PatrickMcAsey
    @PatrickMcAsey 5 лет назад +5

    I watched in wonder as Apollo 11 landed on the Moon, and with no less wonder as the other Apollo missions landed. But in all that time - or in the 50 years that have passed since - did | ever wonder what would have happened if these brave men hadn't returned. Thank you for this really enlightening video.

  • @londonspade5896
    @londonspade5896 7 лет назад +61

    If they were stranded on the Moon they could have survived on the endless supply of cheese

    • @BubbafromSapperton
      @BubbafromSapperton 5 лет назад +7

      Excellent-point...

    • @bilbobigbollix7318
      @bilbobigbollix7318 5 лет назад +10

      And Wallace and Gromit would have come to rescue them anyway. Sorted.

    • @sethsuosisbacc6559
      @sethsuosisbacc6559 3 года назад +1

      The moon is expensive cheese and in space they can’t age they would be immortal

    • @jonhatanblaise1659
      @jonhatanblaise1659 2 года назад

      And hung out with the DreamWorks fishing kid

  • @conalcochran8271
    @conalcochran8271 7 лет назад +3

    This is a very well researched and put-together video. Thank you for this. I really enjoyed it.

  • @nyeaglesfootballgarbagemen8346
    @nyeaglesfootballgarbagemen8346 5 месяцев назад +1

    Love how that model rocket lifts off the set so effortlessly

  • @workonesabs
    @workonesabs 4 года назад +4

    The guys in the module are not stupid - they knew, even before training began that there would be no rescue, and still would had no hesitation of going, anyway.

    • @IgnobleKin
      @IgnobleKin 6 месяцев назад

      They choose test pilots for a reason.

  • @metalhedd
    @metalhedd 6 лет назад +61

    Always double check Mechjeb

  • @mizzmaddieUTube
    @mizzmaddieUTube 6 лет назад +3

    Whoa...! Thanks CD for putting this out there. I was born in 1965 and never once considered this scenario, at least not in the level of detail you've provided. Wow. (Thank you, again.)

  • @Notoriousnipple
    @Notoriousnipple 4 года назад +2

    So much could have gone wrong during the entire trip. Truly a miracles. Saturn v being the insane giant that it was. And those lunar landing modules. Low tech and in reliable it it worked.

  • @ninoletigre
    @ninoletigre 5 лет назад +1

    I've been watching your videos all week. I love this channel.

  • @Disasterina
    @Disasterina 7 лет назад +5

    This is my new favorite channel! I'm obsessed! Oh, and the shirts!

  • @RedHotMessResell
    @RedHotMessResell 4 года назад +82

    Holy crap. “The crew had no knowledge of this during the mission.” Oh my goodness. I would have felt kinda slighted by NASA and distrusting after finding that out. Like oh thanks guys. Glad you had a backup plan in mind. 😂

    • @cantthinkofnameyeah7249
      @cantthinkofnameyeah7249 4 года назад +6

      Nasa is nothing but polished shit. Every disaster that has cost lifes were easy avoidable and due to sociopaths that run the program.

    • @mickolesmana5899
      @mickolesmana5899 4 года назад +3

      it is sad, but they have no other choices. Just like in exploration age, you sent some sailor, hope everything will alright.

    • @cantthinkofnameyeah7249
      @cantthinkofnameyeah7249 4 года назад +1

      @@mickolesmana5899 They had no other choices wow you are dead wrong

    • @BBSHOCKZ
      @BBSHOCKZ 4 года назад +7

      @@cantthinkofnameyeah7249 everyone knows the risks

    • @cantthinkofnameyeah7249
      @cantthinkofnameyeah7249 4 года назад +1

      @@BBSHOCKZ Your statement is so broad it carries literally no point

  • @LC-cd1yt
    @LC-cd1yt 5 лет назад +1

    Hi Paul just want to say good job on the videos :) can't stop watching

  • @Shadow77999
    @Shadow77999 3 года назад +7

    5:20 Jesus, that speed tho is terrifying lol

  • @jordanturner8496
    @jordanturner8496 3 года назад +3

    50 years later its still the greatest human achievement

    • @dijoxx
      @dijoxx Год назад

      Not really though

  • @911gpd
    @911gpd 6 лет назад +358

    Greatest engineering achievement in History.
    (in my opinion)

    • @deanharmse5126
      @deanharmse5126 5 лет назад +11

      Agree. Hopefully our children will say the same thing about the next great achievememt.

    • @jshepard152
      @jshepard152 5 лет назад +13

      Absolutely. And if you had to narrow it down further, the Saturn V is probably the most remarkable part of the equation.

    • @revolutionarycomrade
      @revolutionarycomrade 5 лет назад +10

      @@jshepard152 no kidding! I mean, the F1 engines alone are basically miraculous!

    • @CONTACTLIGHTTOMMY
      @CONTACTLIGHTTOMMY 5 лет назад +1

      Indeed.

    • @bobl78
      @bobl78 5 лет назад +2

      about what ? The IPhone ? Skype that never works ? Facebook ?

  • @1133saginaw
    @1133saginaw 5 лет назад +1

    Armstrong said he wasn't concerned about running out of fuel. He said he was prepared to let the LEM drop if they were within 20 ft. He also said he was prepared to land in the crater full of boulders.

  • @Dan10811
    @Dan10811 5 лет назад +2

    Wonderful video. Extremely informative and great atmosphere. Thank you

  • @freemanlevack6556
    @freemanlevack6556 3 года назад +3

    I don't think that NASA would have actually turned the radios off. I found a new article that said the official protocol was to declare 'deliberately closed down communications' as a euphemism for suicide. I doubt that the most professional scientists and engineers in the world would think that leaving their astronauts alone and confused while they died would ever be appropriate.

  • @scottfw7169
    @scottfw7169 5 лет назад +11

    Q: What if Apollo had crashed on the Moon?
    A: The next cake delivered to mission control would have been decorated a bit differently.

  • @darrensmith6999
    @darrensmith6999 5 лет назад +1

    Great Video as always . Thank you.

  • @AdvancedMarketingGro
    @AdvancedMarketingGro 6 лет назад

    Great video, keep up the good work. Very much appreciated.

  • @nickjeffrey8050
    @nickjeffrey8050 5 лет назад +10

    They would cut communication, DAMN SON!
    That’s some cold hearted shit right there

    • @wallasaurus_9241
      @wallasaurus_9241 3 года назад

      They’d actually cut communication to give the two astronauts privacy in their final moments, though, I think that would’ve been a few minutes later ‘cause I heard from somewhere that Mission Control would’ve stayed on the line for a while

  • @Stonehawk
    @Stonehawk 5 лет назад +11

    Death by hypoxia is actually one of the least painful ways to go. You get lightheaded and giddy, filled with a euphoric "I CAN DO IT!" feeling... which is ironic, because you really, _really_ *can't* "do it", no matter what "it" was, except pass out and ...
    ... yeah.

    • @TJDrumsRHCP
      @TJDrumsRHCP 5 лет назад

      @Denis Franks That wouldn't happen unless they would voluntarily shed their suits, right?

    • @annbeth6730
      @annbeth6730 5 лет назад

      and you know this how?

  • @jamesrindley6215
    @jamesrindley6215 6 лет назад +2

    Jim Lovell said the missions didn't carry suicide pills. Buzz Aldrin said that if the ascent stage didn't work for any reason they would have just carried on trying everything they could think of until they ran out of oxygen and lost consciousness. That is after all what one would expect an astronaut and test pilot to do.

  • @Mrbfgray
    @Mrbfgray 5 лет назад +1

    Fascinating, even more so then most of your excellent productions.

  • @pacosiquot9625
    @pacosiquot9625 5 лет назад +3

    I dont usually comment, but I really need to say your videos are fabulous. Thanks.

  • @bluesquare23
    @bluesquare23 7 лет назад +113

    It's still so amazing that it ever worked. There were so many points of failure and yet it still worked!

    • @jamesneilsongrahamloveinth1301
      @jamesneilsongrahamloveinth1301 6 лет назад +3

      Yes, I think Neil Armstrong too expressed surprise that all the links in this 'daisy-chain' (as he called it) of events held together . . .

    • @philliberatore4265
      @philliberatore4265 6 лет назад +7

      Blue Square
      Alan Shepard mentioned he was sitting on top of the collective efforts of thousands of low-bid contractors.

    • @MagicRoosterBluesBand
      @MagicRoosterBluesBand 6 лет назад +12

      Hahahaha! Of course it worked! It was in the script. Hahaha!

    • @counterfit5
      @counterfit5 6 лет назад +5

      Magic Rooster yeah, I bet they scripted Apollos 1 and 13 too

    • @phlodel
      @phlodel 5 лет назад

      They developed the technology that made it work as they made incremental progress to the moon landings. Sometimes a little after it was needed.

  • @Theineluctable_SOME_CANT
    @Theineluctable_SOME_CANT 2 года назад +1

    Great content,as usual.

  • @mesonparticle
    @mesonparticle 4 года назад

    Thanks Mr Droid. Love your stuff

  • @basantathapa7027
    @basantathapa7027 7 лет назад +8

    i like the way he narrates.

  • @truthpopup
    @truthpopup 7 лет назад +16

    Thanks for the video. No matter how you slice it, it took courage to get into that capsule and embark for the moon.

  • @donswope9111
    @donswope9111 4 года назад +1

    I really enjoy your videos.

  • @RobCLynch
    @RobCLynch 5 лет назад +1

    I don't think that such chances would be taken today. One engine to blast off from the lunar surface - with 50:50 odds and one engine to blast out of lunar orbit - another 50:50. The astronauts were test pilots and saw 50:50 as good odds. It's a miracle that these missions were as successful as they were. Also, the fault on Apollo 13 had been on all of the previous missions, so that was a miracle in itself. Thanks for the work put in to your videos.

  • @inquiringmindswanttoknow8749
    @inquiringmindswanttoknow8749 7 лет назад +8

    Thanks for sharing that. I worked on all the Apollo Block II CSM's during the fire abatement modification program after the Apollo I fire. I worked on Apollo 13 when the oxygen shelf was changed from three small tanks to one larger tank which was what blew up on 13. There were many things we Space Mechanics never knew, and something new is always being brought to public view.

    • @tristanband4003
      @tristanband4003 5 лет назад

      That memo...none of you knew about it Earthside? Assume that the worst happened and they did just cut off communication like that...how would you have felt about that? Not even allowing families to say goodbye?

    • @religioniscancer6859
      @religioniscancer6859 5 лет назад

      R/thathappened

  • @jonecp1
    @jonecp1 7 лет назад +5

    Thank you. A very professional video. I look forward to future videos!

  • @Hugging_Cactus
    @Hugging_Cactus 2 года назад +2

    when you see an Apollo capsule up close, you see how tight and tiny everything is/was.
    brave people.

    • @SaxonSuccess
      @SaxonSuccess Год назад

      Yes. So where did they put the moon buggy?

    • @kalez963
      @kalez963 Год назад

      @@SaxonSuccess Lander

  • @jessicateeters5497
    @jessicateeters5497 5 лет назад +32

    Apollo 11 (2019) shows this well. See it in imax

  • @robertsuhrer5604
    @robertsuhrer5604 6 лет назад +4

    Just found your channel. So refreshing. Keep up the great work!!

  • @dasroteeichhornchen411
    @dasroteeichhornchen411 5 лет назад +2

    Your commentary is always excellent! I watched the first moon landing as a 9 years old boy. It was T H E TV event. Nothing in the TV could reach this sensation! Greatings from Vienna

  • @mr171719
    @mr171719 2 года назад

    Love YOUR videos!

  • @antony5365
    @antony5365 6 лет назад +219

    That's hilarious. "Houston, we have a problem..." Quick, turn off the radio! *CLICK* Ok, who wants to go to happy hour?

    • @vivelafrance6314
      @vivelafrance6314 5 лет назад +15

      Um, so Houston, we failed to ge toff the moon, what do we do? Houston? You there? Um guys, they cut communications. Do we have pills? No? Um.

    • @OompaL0ompa
      @OompaL0ompa 5 лет назад +43

      Imagine they turned off com but those guys still managed to come back

    • @BOLOYOO
      @BOLOYOO 5 лет назад +5

      @@OompaL0ompa Im afraid they would kill them anyway.

    • @OompaL0ompa
      @OompaL0ompa 5 лет назад +7

      @boloyoo yeah someone would have killed someone for sure

    • @jellogibson4167
      @jellogibson4167 4 года назад +3

      thamonkaface999 that would be so legendary

  • @moonboy5851
    @moonboy5851 4 года назад +3

    Why was NASA’s plan to cut communications? To save everyone the trauma of listening to the astronauts plea for help? And the astronauts had no idea that this was the plan? Cold!

  • @Reginald-rr1gh
    @Reginald-rr1gh 2 года назад +2

    It may well be that NASA admin and the astronauts didn’t discuss any contingency plans in the event they were stranded, but the astronauts no doubt knew the risk they were taking.

  • @occhamite
    @occhamite 5 лет назад +1

    I read somewhere, I think it might have been in one of Aldrin's books, that the "suicide pill" never existed.
    If a crew wanted to do themselves in, all that was necessary was to reduce the cabin pressure until they passed out.
    Armstrong said in an interview that during the final portion of the lunar descent, he wasn't particularly concerned about the fuel level: he'd flown the LLRV/LLTV many times, both in development and then in training, and that craft was ALWAYS nearly out of fuel as touch neared.

  • @brennencox516
    @brennencox516 4 года назад +7

    "What if Apollo had crashed on the Moon ?"
    they'd try again
    or
    that would be it

  • @GodBreathedOnMe
    @GodBreathedOnMe 7 лет назад +214

    It's crazy how it got struck by lightning. & still able to proceed.

    • @dcwhitworth
      @dcwhitworth 7 лет назад +11

      Some quick thinking from some people at mission control saved the day and help to reactivate some systems.

    • @martinc3918
      @martinc3918 7 лет назад +19

      dcwhitworth A guy called John Aaron was the controller who recognised the issue and made the call to toggle a switch which restored systems. Apollo 12 was very close to abort when that call was made.

    • @nickrulercreator
      @nickrulercreator 7 лет назад +18

      Jake Pughh 60's tech, man. Built for life

    • @trumfit
      @trumfit 7 лет назад +10

      and thus began the phrase "steely-eyed missile man"

    • @zemzem8323
      @zemzem8323 7 лет назад +3

      Jake Pughh - power of film production

  • @futureworks6116
    @futureworks6116 5 лет назад

    well done as always

  • @SlightReturn666
    @SlightReturn666 5 лет назад

    Thoroughly enjoy your videos sir. Utterly clear, thoughtful, and delivered in a kindly and professional manner.

    • @claireboden9081
      @claireboden9081 5 лет назад

      pity the the VAB one is full of massive errors.

    • @SlightReturn666
      @SlightReturn666 5 лет назад

      @@claireboden9081 what's VAB?

    • @claireboden9081
      @claireboden9081 5 лет назад

      @@SlightReturn666 He did one one regarding the Van Allen Radiation Belt (VAB). Since Proven to be full of inaccurate data and fraudulent lies basically. This guy is a liar.

    • @SlightReturn666
      @SlightReturn666 5 лет назад

      @@claireboden9081 Oh! I thought you meant Vehicle Assembly Building -- didn't seem like there would be much controversy about that!

    • @claireboden9081
      @claireboden9081 5 лет назад

      @@SlightReturn666 lol...no I don't think there is.

  • @josephupton3601
    @josephupton3601 5 лет назад +12

    I believe that Neil Armstrong would have landed the Eagle even IF they had gotten below the "abort" point. If they fired him later...so what? He knew he was getting so close to landing. He was NOT going to abort because of some arbitrary rule about how much reserve fuel he might need. Running out of fuel was a small risk compared to what they had already gone thru.

  • @indianapatsfan
    @indianapatsfan 7 лет назад +877

    After browsing through this comment section, I've decided to invest heavily in the Acme Tin Foil Hat Corporation.

    • @Yukivee
      @Yukivee 7 лет назад +22

      10/10

    • @terrypussypower
      @terrypussypower 7 лет назад +30

      ALCAN shares are constantly rising! Ever since the internet became a thing and gave these science denying cretins a platform, in fact.

    • @yves3560
      @yves3560 7 лет назад +7

      It would only sell in the US, not worth investing in it ;)

    • @mylesms48
      @mylesms48 7 лет назад +1

      Nice one

    • @MaskedVengeanceTV
      @MaskedVengeanceTV 7 лет назад

      and ham radios.

  • @benthejrporter
    @benthejrporter 6 лет назад +1

    What a nightmare! Thanks goodness all the Apollo missions took place without such a fatality. We were very lucky!

  • @Narrowgaugefilms
    @Narrowgaugefilms 3 года назад

    There's that classic quote that has been used to define the Right Stuff:
    Reporter: "In the instance where the ascent engine wouldn't start and you only had six hours to live, how would you spend that time?"
    Astronaut: "Fixing the ascent engine."

  • @Trinayraj
    @Trinayraj 6 лет назад +7

    I always knew Lord Varys could have been an interesting RUclipsr . 😂

  • @Clenched.Cheeks
    @Clenched.Cheeks 7 лет назад +327

    I started scrolling comments and ended up falling into a conspiracy theory troll hole.

    • @ljdean1956
      @ljdean1956 7 лет назад +19

      It's unfortunate that the moon landings will be remembered as "Cost too much" or "Did we actually go". One can only hope privatization of spaceflight will result in laying the moon landing question to rest for good. But even then, there will be deniers.

    • @ashbrauw
      @ashbrauw 7 лет назад +9

      "swear on the bible that we went to the moon"

    • @WarthDader74
      @WarthDader74 6 лет назад +6

      The "moonlandings" is THE conspiracy theory itself. Some people actually believe that mankind traveled to the moon 6 times.

    • @mrobvious8598
      @mrobvious8598 6 лет назад +22

      WarthDader74 Dumbass

    • @almostfm
      @almostfm 6 лет назад +21

      And when you say "some people", that includes every scientist who has ever looked at the samples and or the data.
      Funny how experts don't have a problem with it, but you do.

  • @hooligan9794
    @hooligan9794 6 лет назад

    Love the channel! 👍

  • @johntanner3659
    @johntanner3659 Год назад +2

    One question that goes through my mind is what was in the CMP's procedures for a solo return to earth, for example, when would he be told to fire up to come home, what about navigational changes that would be necessary, what coverage would there be of the splash down etc? An interesting follow up I think

  • @gdhammr8113
    @gdhammr8113 4 года назад +12

    I’m entering the newest comments to find idiots who think the moon landing never happened.
    Wish me luck
    Ok, I’m literally not even 10 comments deep and I already found 4

  • @black5f
    @black5f 5 лет назад +7

    Everything was planned, both success and failure. The management of the mission was exemplary. This combined with the "Right Stuff" made it a success. Of course HR stepped in paid them an extra $8 a day for being off base ;-) I watched it live with my Dad, I was 5 and I remember it well.

  • @jaydaniels1790
    @jaydaniels1790 5 лет назад +1

    Thank you for doing this video thank you sir

  • @stavros693000
    @stavros693000 3 года назад +2

    young people 2020 most dont realise just how dangerous and experimental these 60s missions were.....i for one wouldnt board a gemini or apollo mission for a million dollars.......i recommend "first man" it gives a true sense of how claustrophobic and dangerous these early space missions were......they were basically suicide missions......i commend these pioneers for their bravery and have the upmost respect for them.........moon landing deniers piss me off and do a great disservice to these great men.

  • @dumitrumitu
    @dumitrumitu 7 лет назад +3

    you are great! i enjoy your videos.

  • @graycloud057
    @graycloud057 5 лет назад +9

    For a while I didn’t believe they really went to the moon. I reckon I believe it now. Tired of people think I was nuts.

    • @robertmarino7139
      @robertmarino7139 5 лет назад +1

      We never really went

    • @foximacentauri7891
      @foximacentauri7891 4 года назад +1

      @Mase Mason because our instinct brought us to where we are now, right?

    • @GraemePryce1978
      @GraemePryce1978 4 года назад +4

      @Mase Mason Congratulations. You have shown the world that you are an idiot.

    • @_charliezard_7218
      @_charliezard_7218 4 года назад

      Milt Farrow yea in the prehistoric era

  • @roachtoasties
    @roachtoasties 5 лет назад +2

    One thing I've thought about is if the two astronauts were stuck on the moon because of a mechanical or technical failure. They would have known they only had a few days to live. Air, fuel/power, water and food would all soon run out, and it wouldn't matter what would run out first. Being stuck in such a predicament would be horrible. Then there is Mike Collins, who would have to travel back to earth alone. Depending on the timing, he might have left moon orbit when they were alive and arrived back to earth when they were dead.

  • @lucasdeaver9192
    @lucasdeaver9192 5 лет назад

    Nice shirt this episode! Always engaging to watch your show.

  • @BlackEpyon
    @BlackEpyon 7 лет назад +4

    Personally, in the event of not being able to ascend , I would have requested (had I knowledge of that contingency) that NASA not cut off communication. If the ascent stage could not be fixed, I would wish to continue to feed back as much scientific data as possible before my life support gave out.
    "Let me not seem to have died in vain... Let me not seem to have died in vain."
    -- Tycho Brahe

    • @naumen6508
      @naumen6508 6 лет назад

      These people are heroes. I wish I could see our mother Earth fade away in the distance, as I'm thrown away towards Mars, one day.

  • @JonatasAdoM
    @JonatasAdoM 4 года назад +5

    So every time they tell they've "lost communication" means they're just ignoring the lost project?

    • @IgnobleKin
      @IgnobleKin 6 месяцев назад

      Pretty much. There are a lot of probes still flying that just have dead electronics.

  • @Jacen13
    @Jacen13 5 лет назад

    Proud to subscribe to this awesome channel! 🌍🚀🌚

  • @konrad3958
    @konrad3958 6 лет назад

    Love to watch Your videos. Best regards from Poland :)

  • @KEVMAN7987
    @KEVMAN7987 7 лет назад +726

    I really want to introduce the moon landing deniers here to Buzz Aldrin's fist.

    • @simonruszczak5563
      @simonruszczak5563 7 лет назад +21

      I'd take the Bible with me.

    • @declamatory
      @declamatory 7 лет назад +1

      Simon Ruszczak - "Buzz" Aldrin [the man who never blinks] is a Bible-denier.

    • @BryanPopRobson
      @BryanPopRobson 7 лет назад +54

      + Kevin Gomolchak, It was Ed Fendell at mission control, he had control of the camera on the Rover which was parked up to observe the liftoff. It took him 3 attempts (Apollo 15 he missed it, 16 he got it a bit better) he finally nailed it on the 3rd attempt Apollo 17.

    • @adrinathegreat3095
      @adrinathegreat3095 7 лет назад +12

      Kevin Gomolchak The old classic caught in a lie, blind panic launch a violent attack scenario.
      That buzz Aldrin punch showed he was caught unaware and in a blind panic punched the guy

    • @Bendc1970A1
      @Bendc1970A1 7 лет назад +37

      If Buzz had put his hand on the Bible and swore that he did land on the moon the guy would have kept on believing his conspiracy theories. People just don't let go of those things. Like when Obama showed his birth certificate. It then became a forgery.

  • @skubahitler5438
    @skubahitler5438 6 лет назад +3

    Man that shirt is great!

  • @respectdawildo_danjones508
    @respectdawildo_danjones508 2 года назад +1

    I didn’t know about the “cutting the communications” part. Learn something new everyday, the rest I did, not that. Collins did write in his book he was prepared to come back alone if necessary and that he wasn’t going to take any S pills or anything like that. He also stated he had dozens of rescue attempt checklists at certain points prior PDI burn

  • @carbon_no6
    @carbon_no6 Год назад +1

    The “loss of life” address speech was written with a very large focus on the grandiose scale!

  • @RodCornholio
    @RodCornholio 6 лет назад +3

    I'd love to know the thinking that went into the "cut comms" memo.

  • @adamclarke7394
    @adamclarke7394 4 года назад +8

    Given the complexities surrounding the return flight from the moon, I have sometimes wondered whether it would actually have been physically possible for one person to return successfully. I'd appreciate any thoughts on that question.

    • @IgnobleKin
      @IgnobleKin 6 месяцев назад +1

      The craft was piloted by a single man most of the time. With help from NASA checking over math it seems completely possible to return singlehandedly.

  • @Will-Parr
    @Will-Parr 5 лет назад

    Excellent video. Thanks

  • @julienvautrin9817
    @julienvautrin9817 5 лет назад +1

    Excellente vidéo, très instructive. Merci beaucoup

  • @pepengmahapon
    @pepengmahapon 5 лет назад +3

    Fortunately, the mission succeeded. Otherwise, we'll be seeing corpses the next time we visit the moon.