Hands touch, eyes meet Sudden silence, sudden heat Hearts leap in a giddy whirl He could be that boy But I'm not that girl Don't dream too far Don't lose sight of who you are Don't remember that rush of joy He could be that boy I'm not that girl Ev'ry so often we long to steal To the land of what-might-have-been But that doesn't soften the ache we feel When reality sets back in Blithe smile, lithe limb She who's winsome, she wins him Gold hair with a gentle curl That's the girl he chose And Heaven knows I'm not that girl Don't wish, don't start Wishing only wounds the heart I wasn't born for the rose and the pearl There's a girl I know He loves her so I'm not that girl...
Ms Mojo sent me here. Playing Elphaba in New York and London May have done something to Idina’s vocals. But she’s still got it! Because if she still can’t sing beautifully as she did when she was younger, Idina would have never been Elsa.
It really is. It highlights the insecurity and longing for more that she outwardly hides and only admits secretly to herself in her fantasies. The most tragic line of the show to me is after finally getting with Fiyero she shyly admits to him she wishes she was prettier for his sake. It’s just heartbreaking
Abby Vdl My favorite songs in the show are Wizard & I, What is this Feeling, Dancing Through Life, Popular, One Short Day, Defying Gravity, As Long As You’re Mine and For Good
This song relates to me because ever since I was in elementary school wanted to be a broadway star. I feel it every day in my gut. Everyday, all day, that’s all I think about. The problem is is that people have so much more talent than me, and I’m a soprano in my head voice but an alto/mezzo in chest voice so singing musical theater has always been tough for me. These components together make me relate so much to this song.
she has the most beautiful voice that I have ever heard and I also get the message in the song who has not felt this way at some point in their lives thinking about what might have been if this person had cosen them instead of the person they are with.
I love Idina so much. She has such a wonderful true feeling with really nice cute pop quality of singing. Singer with big S for me! I wish I could hear you live one day! :)
Idina, I sang your piece in Voice class in college about 19 years ago 😮❤❤❤❤ I made a fellow classmate weep tears of emotion, singing “I’m Not That Girl”! What a compliment. My compliments to Mr. Schwartz and you 😊❤😊❤🎉
Only your opinion but I think her doppelganger, Jackie Burns, arguably sang it better than her. And Cynthia Erivo sang it better than both, an even more softer mournful version which I think is what the song is supposed to be.
My favorite version is not even her version, is this performance. Her acting makes it ten thousand times better. She understands Elphaba's character so well💚
When she pauses and bows he head in the end, I truly believe that she is personnally feeling the hurt and rejection in the song. Could that girl have been Amanza Smith Brown?
I love her so much. I found a bunch of ten year olds on a RUclips video saying she can’t sing, belt, or do anything live. I was like, “oK KiDS LiStEN uP-“
Comparing Cynthia and Idina’s performance is a crime. Hahhaha. Both of them sang it beautifully. Its a matter of what generation you are in. What’s your musical preference. ❤❤❤
?? Hands touch, eyes meet Sudden silence, sudden heat Hearts leap in a giddy whirl He could be that boy But I'm not that girl Don't dream too far Don't lose sight of who you are Don't remember that rush of joy He could be that boy I'm not that girl Ev'ry so often we long to steal To the land of what-might-have-been But that doesn't soften the ache we feel When reality sets back in Blithe smile, lithe limb She who's winsome, she wins him Gold hair with a gentle curl That's the girl he chose And Heaven knows I'm not that girl Don't wish, don't start Wishing only wounds the heart I wasn't born for the rose and the pearl There's a girl I know He loves her so I'm not that girl...
I prefer cynthia version over ever one. Its so emotional idina is good but when i hear her singing i automatic go to animation movies. She just just sounds like she belong there. Disney princess movies.
omg legIT HALF THE REASON WHY IM SO EMOTIONAL RN *no, i havent gotten over that episode, i dont think i ever will **the other half is because i've been star after bbtbc since 2015 woop
I was not expecting to find a comment like this.... But I'm still not over the season 2 finale, and now after the season 3 teaser trailer/sneak peak I'm freaking out even more. How is this show so good at suspense and cliffhangers? It's painful.
Can you please send me a message when you’re on break and we could chat on my cell phone I have a question about the new job I have a couple questions about my new job and I need to ask you a couple questions about the position I would appreciate your business thank you so much for all of your business
I saw the Play, WICKED on Broadway in 2019. I would L💚ve to go see it again. This is my Favorite Broadway Play. This was my Favorite Song in the Play. I'm looking forward to seeing the Movie. 💚🩷💚🩷💚
Hands touch, eyes meet Sudden silence, sudden heat Hearts leap in a giddy whirl He could be that boy But I'm not that girl Don't dream too far Don't lose sight of who you are Don't remember that rush of joy He could be that boy I'm not that girl Every so often we long to steal To the land of what-might-have-been But that doesn't soften the ache we feel When reality sets back in Blithe smile, lithe limb She who's winsome, she wins him Gold hair with a gentle curl That's the girl he chose And heaven knows I'm not that girl Don't wish don't start Wishing only wounds the heart I wasn't born for the rose and pearl There's a girl I know He loves her so I'm not that girl
This is the most underrated songs in wicked
I always forget about this song... but it always takes my breath away💚
Yes it really is
It was the first time I cried while watching the musical
Lou Marit i also cried during west side story
Agreed
she doesn't just sing the songs she lives them and that's what makes her so special
novlincess amen sister!! She is one of the few best singers that sings songs AND lives them every day
novlincess she's one of my fav. musical actresses
novlincess Idina is no Celine Dion but I can tell within her emotions and breathing.
Yes that is what makes musical numbers musical numbers.
Cynthia really did this song justice. I never heard it until watching the movie and fell in love with it.
Idina was amazing too....
Both are absolutely amazing with it!❤
@@melo3427 Both were amazing with very different interpretations that match the type of portrayal of the character.
@melo3427 one is in a studio one is live..I know which I prefer
I love Cynthia but Idina was the OG and her voice just melts me everytime
This hits too close to my current situation
😭
Sorry 😞
😞
gender confusion?
Always be true to yourself just the same and realize your worth is not measured by anyone except God Himself!
"Don't dream, too far. Don't lose sight of...who you are..."
That's so sad 😢😥😫😩😞😔
Wazowski's Apprentice that never fails to get me emitonal
Its like "dont you dare for a second think you're the gurl who gets the boy" and I feel that
Good lyric
Those last lines where she says “Don’t wish, don’t start, wishing only wound the heart” damn I felt that
No one sings this more beautifully and in a more heart-wrenching way! Idina, you are perfection!
Cynthia's version is heart-wrenching as well. :) Hello from the future.
Cynthia version is way better n emotional
Not until cynthia's version... This song became my favorite after cynthia's version
Hands touch, eyes meet
Sudden silence, sudden heat
Hearts leap in a giddy whirl
He could be that boy
But I'm not that girl
Don't dream too far
Don't lose sight of who you are
Don't remember that rush of joy
He could be that boy
I'm not that girl
Ev'ry so often we long to steal
To the land of what-might-have-been
But that doesn't soften the ache we feel
When reality sets back in
Blithe smile, lithe limb
She who's winsome, she wins him
Gold hair with a gentle curl
That's the girl he chose
And Heaven knows
I'm not that girl
Don't wish, don't start
Wishing only wounds the heart
I wasn't born for the rose and the pearl
There's a girl I know
He loves her so
I'm not that girl...
campanulac thanks
*I wasn't born for the rose and pearl* there's not the between and pearl
Also it's every not ev'ry I have a copy of it and it's every
This song always makes me cry. It’s such a sad and touchy song
And heaven knows i'm not that girl 😢😔💔
Saul Carrillo
You can tell she really connects to the lyrics of this song.
God, I adore her voice. Let's find our fellow Elphabas!
Yassss!
scgtlp Someday I hope to my Elphaba to her Fieryo
Ms Mojo sent me here. Playing Elphaba in New York and London May have done something to Idina’s vocals. But she’s still got it! Because if she still can’t sing beautifully as she did when she was younger, Idina would have never been Elsa.
This is definitely the saddest song in the wicked song set.
This is sad. I personally think For Good is 10x sadder though.
It really is. It highlights the insecurity and longing for more that she outwardly hides and only admits secretly to herself in her fantasies. The most tragic line of the show to me is after finally getting with Fiyero she shyly admits to him she wishes she was prettier for his sake. It’s just heartbreaking
why didn't they put it in the CD????????? She is so emotional, beautiful voice and lyrics equals PERFECTION!!!
One of my favorite songs from Wicked 😭
Abby Vdl My favorite songs in the show are Wizard & I, What is this Feeling, Dancing Through Life, Popular, One Short Day, Defying Gravity, As Long As You’re Mine and For Good
I love her Barefoot at the Symphony concert. She is so real here.
Colleen Marsh This is actually the second portion of the concert I’ve watched.
This song relates to me because ever since I was in elementary school wanted to be a broadway star. I feel it every day in my gut. Everyday, all day, that’s all I think about. The problem is is that people have so much more talent than me, and I’m a soprano in my head voice but an alto/mezzo in chest voice so singing musical theater has always been tough for me. These components together make me relate so much to this song.
Never give up hope!! You can do anything you set your mind to. If you want to go for it, go for it
All of it aside tho. Bedroom performances to ourselves 🤜
That feeling tho 😊😌
The sadness you can see in her eyes... And the way she sings "She wins him" .... My heart 😢
I just watched the movie. Never listened to the full musical but I heard this song today. Wish I had heard it before today. It’s beautiful.
8 dislikes? Who hurt you guys?
I love Idina so much ❤️❤️❤️
Beautiful performance!
The main song of the playlist of my life
Her voice is like silk
this is so much more perfect than it already is live
she has the most beautiful voice that I have ever heard and I also get the message in the song who has not felt this way at some point in their lives thinking about what might have been if this person had cosen them instead of the person they are with.
I cry when I hear this song
Such a good singer
After so many years, it's still the most emotion touched song of all. Tears!
I love Idina so much. She has such a wonderful true feeling with really nice cute pop quality of singing. Singer with big S for me! I wish I could hear you live one day! :)
I love her swallowing! The true emotion! :O
@@daliborburanda9626 You love her what?
One of the greatest show tunes ever sung by one of the best.
Idina, I sang your piece in Voice class in college about 19 years ago 😮❤❤❤❤ I made a fellow classmate weep tears of emotion, singing “I’m Not That Girl”! What a compliment. My compliments to Mr. Schwartz and you 😊❤😊❤🎉
The truth is, no one can sing this song better than her
No one
And many have tried
Only your opinion but I think her doppelganger, Jackie Burns, arguably sang it better than her. And Cynthia Erivo sang it better than both, an even more softer mournful version which I think is what the song is supposed to be.
This is hard to face Reality the song is like this
This is magical
My favorite wicked song.
Breaks my Heart...
omg im crying this is my fave song
Idina has played 2 Disney queens Elsa of arendale and queen Nancy of adalasia
I love Idina and her voice. 😍 she's perfect! ❤️
The song that makes me cry with no one mourns the wicked
She needs to get back on Broadway!
Or do a live TV musical
My favorite version is not even her version, is this performance. Her acting makes it ten thousand times better. She understands Elphaba's character so well💚
Thank you for this music. ❤❤❤❤❤⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐🍀🍀🍀🍀🍀
When she pauses and bows he head in the end, I truly believe that she is personnally feeling the hurt and rejection in the song. Could that girl have been Amanza Smith Brown?
Sueseajoy it's acting. If you believe it, that means she's a good actor.
Carl Eric Pean of course she is a good actor, watch the remake of beaches haha
Amanza smith brown
Oh this song is sang by Angelica Schuyler in Hamilton.
Wait, wrong song.
Wait I thought this was Satisfied from the show Hamilton
Oh this song is sang by Eponine in Les Miserables as well.
No.
She's such a great singer...love hearing her.
My favorite song from movie!!
The best song from Wicked
I love her so much. I found a bunch of ten year olds on a RUclips video saying she can’t sing, belt, or do anything live. I was like, “oK KiDS LiStEN uP-“
Wow this performance was FKDUP!!!!😭😭😭 absolutely stunning
Comparing Cynthia and Idina’s performance is a crime. Hahhaha. Both of them sang it beautifully. Its a matter of what generation you are in. What’s your musical preference. ❤❤❤
She sold that to the back row 💯✨💜✨
IDC Cynthia ate this cover
Heart-wrenching
Esta canción expresa perfectamente cómo me siento... La mejor canción de mi musical favorito 💚
Sooooo goood😢
She wa great. She sang that like it was her
YOU SUCH AN INSPIRATION XOX
Who’s watching here 2024? After watching the Wicked the movie 🙋🏻♀️
🙋🏻♀️
🙋🏽
??
Hands touch, eyes meet
Sudden silence, sudden heat
Hearts leap in a giddy whirl
He could be that boy
But I'm not that girl
Don't dream too far
Don't lose sight of who you are
Don't remember that rush of joy
He could be that boy
I'm not that girl
Ev'ry so often we long to steal
To the land of what-might-have-been
But that doesn't soften the ache we feel
When reality sets back in
Blithe smile, lithe limb
She who's winsome, she wins him
Gold hair with a gentle curl
That's the girl he chose
And Heaven knows
I'm not that girl
Don't wish, don't start
Wishing only wounds the heart
I wasn't born for the rose and the pearl
There's a girl I know
He loves her so
I'm not that girl...
the only girl that can sing this perfectly
I never could be that girl even if I wanted to 😢
I love idina meanzel so very much she is so good at singing
Too bad they didn't put it on the Barefoot at the Symphony album
'Lat's the girl he chose'? o.o 1:55
😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
I wish this song wasn’t my theme song
" im not that girl" at 2:58 😭
De fato um hino pra quem faz papel de trouxa
She could be that girl...but I not that girl
I just have to come to terms that he is that boy but I’m not that girl! 😢💔
The Cynthia version be on repeeeeeat for me. If it shows up on my 2025 wrap I wouldn’t be surprised lol
It's Elsa
shaylen sanders I’ve been a fan of this women long before Frozen sent her stardom to the stratosphere of showbiz.
You cant top the OG Elphaba
Who are these 17 terrible people who disliked
Oh no 😟
ha!
I prefer cynthia version over ever one. Its so emotional idina is good but when i hear her singing i automatic go to animation movies. She just just sounds like she belong there. Disney princess movies.
*Typically Star Butterfly after BBTBC
ha i caught you singing im not a girl
omg legIT HALF THE REASON WHY IM SO EMOTIONAL RN
*no, i havent gotten over that episode, i dont think i ever will
**the other half is because i've been star after bbtbc since 2015 woop
Antrivictrianne Gamboa yesssss
*Typically Star Butterfly after Just Friends
I was not expecting to find a comment like this....
But I'm still not over the season 2 finale, and now after the season 3 teaser trailer/sneak peak I'm freaking out even more. How is this show so good at suspense and cliffhangers? It's painful.
This is every gay man’s anthem for every time he falls for a straight guy. Lol
My brother is gay I’m straight
Or every lesbian women’s anthem
Frrrr 😢
her bone structure is divine LOL😭
Can you please send me a message when you’re on break and we could chat on my cell phone I have a question about the new job I have a couple questions about my new job and I need to ask you a couple questions about the position I would appreciate your business thank you so much for all of your business
I saw the Play, WICKED on Broadway in 2019. I would L💚ve to go see it again. This is my Favorite Broadway Play. This was my Favorite Song in the Play. I'm looking forward to seeing the Movie. 💚🩷💚🩷💚
Hands touch, eyes meet
Sudden silence, sudden heat
Hearts leap in a giddy whirl
He could be that boy
But I'm not that girl
Don't dream too far
Don't lose sight of who you are
Don't remember that rush of joy
He could be that boy
I'm not that girl
Every so often we long to steal
To the land of what-might-have-been
But that doesn't soften the ache we feel
When reality sets back in
Blithe smile, lithe limb
She who's winsome, she wins him
Gold hair with a gentle curl
That's the girl he chose
And heaven knows
I'm not that girl
Don't wish don't start
Wishing only wounds the heart
I wasn't born for the rose and pearl
There's a girl I know
He loves her so
I'm not that girl