One of the reasons the Bee Gees had such longevity and were so successful is that they didn't stagnate, they tried to keep their sound contemporary and in touch with current trends. They often blended elements of what made them successful into their newer works as time went on. Robin never abandoned his soulful ballads, Barry never abandoned his falsetto, Maurice never abandon his mastery of high harmony and instrumentation. They kept reinventing themselves but never threw out the things that made them unique.
The Bee Gees started there professional careers in 1958 as boys and ended in 2003 when Maurice died. They didn't want to sing without him. But they still wrote music for other singers.
That’s Robyn, one of the twins. They were around 16-18, and Barry was 3 yrs older. They wrote amazing music for kids that young. I was around for Elvis in the 50s and BeeGees in the 60s.
The first singer here is Robin, I love his voice. He isnt the one who sings the high falsetto songs but I prefer his voice. The Bee Gees have a very unique style which became very popular. Incidentally they'd never been to Massachusetts, not when they wrote the song. It was just a good fit, lyrically.
Love the Bee Gees' early music especially 60's-70's. You are hearing Robin Gibb's voice in this song "Massachusetts" from 1968. He also sang lead on "I Started A Joke", "I've Gotta Get A Message To You", "How Can You Mend A Broken Heart" etc. Some of their other early hits were "New York Mining Disaster 1941", "To Love Somebody", "Holiday", "World", "And The Sun Will Shine", "Really & Sincerely", "Words", "The Singer Sang His Song", ""Lonely Days", "Melody Fair", "First Of May", "Give Your Best", "Lamplight" etc.
Todos los temas de esa época fueron excelentes, y eran tan jovenes, quizás fue la edad o la época que influyeron en sus composiciones, pero siempre las escucharé, es más siempre veo recitales de ellos en vivo, y sus versiones eran cada vez mejor con el tiempo, la versión de 1989 en Melbourne Australia, fue una obra de arte, la versión de Started a Jock es para llorar, y Ka respuesta del público, notable.! También compusieron muchos temas para otros artistas como Woman in Love, que canta Barbra Streissand, es una belleza
Never a huge fan of this particular song, but his voice was unmistakable. Loved a few you mentioned. "I Started a Joke" and "..Mend a Broken Heart" two of their best ever.
My favorite band was The Bee Gees. Then the Beatles, Temptations (although I would say they were a group instead of a band cause they didn’t play instruments). 🤷🏾♀️. But The Bee Gees have always been #1 in my book. They adapted their styles to fit the eras from the 60’s all the way through the 2,000’s…so you’re likely to get a different vibe from them based on what decade you’re listening to! They were great at keeping up with the time.
I know most of you are being introduced to The Bee Gees (The Brothers Gibb) from their disco era, but those of us who are purists know there is So Much More! to them than Staying Alive and Too Much Heaven. They actually began performing as kids in England then after moving to Australia as teenagers got a record label and became regulars on a tv show called Australian Bandstand performing covers and their own original music. Just as their very first number one song was topping the charts there, they went home to England and made the rounds at the different recording studios. Finally auditioning for Robert Stigwood a partner of Brian Epstein the manager of the Beatles. This song Massachusetts was the first hit for them on the British Charts. This is a later performance but sounds just as good. Need to check out more 60’s,early 70’s they mostly wrote for others in the 1980’s. 90’s and early 2000’s. You are missing out on more than you will ever know if you get stuck on just one era.
If you want early Bee Gees, check out their first hit called Spicks And Specks. It is different than this, but then, they reinvented themselves and their sound a LOT. I love it all.
Exacto, y todos sus temas desde 1960 hasta los setenta, de la música disco solo compusieron los temas de Fiebre de Sábado a la Noche, producida por Robert Stigwood que era el manager de los Bee Gees!
The biggest Bee Gees smasher of all time alone from the Brothers Gibb - this song was 12 weeks in Germany on #1 and sold unbelievable appr. 3 million units and was No. 1 until Candle in the Wind 1996 with Elton John massive 10 times Gold 🏅and 5 times platinum 💍
They are the greatest of all time. Three brothers, three great songwriters, three great singers. Three geniuses. Tremendous success. Unique phenomenon❤❤❤
The Bee Gees actually started performing together in the late 1950's when they were like 8 and 12 years old. They have gone/evolved through several styles over the years. In the late 60's they came to America for the first time and were doing a sort of British Invasion style. In the very early 70's they were doing a tortured soul style (How Can You Mend a Broken Heart, I Started a Joke). By the mid 70's they had started doing the disco dance music style. They evolved into other styles in the years following disco. It's interesting to note that their most famous and most covered song came out in the mid to late 60's. Of course this is the incredible song "To Love Somebody!" This was a big hit for them, and a big hit for many others since then.
I'm going to be 61years old next month. I started very early on as a kid listening to to their records with my babysitter. Probably more than any other group they were the soundtrack of my life. To be honest, the disco days were not my favorite. But I loved the early stuff and what came after. "I Started A Joke" is probably my favorite song, although now when I hear it I shed a few tears. Robin was always my favorite, and his voice so distinctive. Their talent was amazing.
Opino lo mismo, Started a Jock es mi preferida, y ahí venís la excelente voz que tenía Robin, era único y el mejor de los hermanos, mi favorito también! Muy merecido lo tiene, podría un gran talento musical, vocal y compositor!
You are so right. I cried so hard when we lost him. I think I wore black for a week. But he was so unique I've never heard anyone that can imitate him. No matter how blended their harmonies got, I was always searching to hear him.❤
The Brothers Gibb were very popular early on. They had a heavy handful of top ten hits. This video didn't include Maurice for some reason. Their sound was different later because they sold out to (gulp) disco and became sensationally popular.
Watch the three of them performing this song from Johnny Carson's Tonight Show sofa. Maurice is brilliantly hilarious waiting to sing his parts. I saw him another time go back and get the TV camera and walk around recording the crowd while he waved to everyone between parts. He was the best.
Hello my young friend, the guy singing is Robin Gibb, Robin and Maurice are twins, Barry is the oldest, the youngest was Andy Gibb, he was also a singer. Granny
the Bee Gees were soulful R&B before disco and after disco. There are tons of songs with that sound. The disco era was pretty short and only accounts for a drop in the ocean of their songs. My top artists of all time... hmm... Bee Gees, Beatles are both up there. U2 is as well. Like most really big fans of U2, I prefer Achtung Baby songs over The Joshua Tree songs while most casual U2 fans go for The Joshua Tree songs most. I also love ELO, Elvis Costello, and, well, too many to name, really. :D
This is a few years later ruclips.net/video/NMZESDL4t0Q/видео.html This is 1997 ruclips.net/video/z59Qlu40TzE/видео.html Their early years were largely ballads. AFTER their disco era, they had dance songs,ballads and other styles. Their last release was 2001, 2 years before Maurice died.
Love the early pre-disco Bee Gees & so many wonderful songs they wrote & performed. There are videos of them performing in Australia when the twins weren't even in their teens.
I feel they were to some degree, quite wrongly in my opinion, blamed for the disco sound. Almost all artists were coming out with disco songs. But the Bee Gees were so good that they were able to take it to the highest level. They became almost the symbol in a way. That was due to their talent being so great. But people got tired of disco and started to bad mouth it. Because the guys were so associated with it they bore the brunt of the backlash and it was not fair. They should have been recognized way earlier than they were for their achievements. It is a testament to them that they did fantastic music, kept it contemporary, and were able to span generations. I have a brother in law who absolutely loved all the disco. I was never a fan of disco. But we both appreciate them so much and we both own EVERYTHING they ever released. He and I can debate the merits of disco, but at the end of the day those brothers brought us together and we love all their 🎵.
There was a popular song from Scott Mackenzie that would become the hippie anthem, If You’re Going to SanFrancisco , Robin came up with this melody and an idea about someone going back home after going to San Francisco.
This was before they sold out to disco. The first song I remember hearing from them was "New York Mining Disaster" that was released in 1967 and many thought it was the Beatles.
I didn't think they "sold out to disco." They had some great songs during that period, as they did every decade they performed. The radio magnates unfairly turned on them.
You should watch the 1960 video when they were really little kids. Song is Time is passing by (written by Barry who is about 13/14 at time and twins were about 10/11). They did go back into R&B with the album main course and after.
Enjoyed your reaction, as always! Thanks! First featured here is Robin, then Barry the oldest comes in at 0:50-51 to stand beside Robin. We get to see the third Gibb brother Maurice at 2:23-5-- just a flash playing bass guitar next to lead guitarist Vince Melouney. LOL! Drummer is Colin Petersen. The original international(1967-69) Bee Gees band were five guys.
Yes it's a shame the agents thought Barry was more appealing, and pushed him to the front.Caused a rift between them. Imo Robin had the better voice. RIP
@@KK-qd6ro totalmente de acuerdo, y esa figura duro toda su vida y trayectoria, me encanta la voz de Robin, es indiscutible que era el que cantaba mejor, su voz es única, grandiosa y conmovedora, fue una pena que no hubiera sido la figura principal! Me preguntó su representante no lo vio?
I always believed Robin had the strongest voice with his amazing vibrato. Combined with Barry's falsetto (sometimes) and Maurice's smooth voice, their harmonies were magic.
You really should check them out singing on Australian TV as children! An embarrassment of cuteness... Disco came a lot later in their career, almost accidentally, after they were given the opportunity to write and perform most of the music for a little dance movie called Saturday Night Fever, starring a young and athletic John Travolta... turned out to be a massive hit which pretty much kick-started that 70s disco craze, and revived the BeeGees flagging career, with a vengeance!
They did many genres throughout their career the "disco" era was only a short time in their long career. My top 5 bands of all time are : 1. Bee Gees - early to mid 70's era, 2. Bee Gees - post fever era (80's -00's), 3. Bee Gees - 60's Era, 4. Bee Gees - late 70's era, 5. Bee Gees - all other eras & tangental (late 58's, songs written for other artists, solo albums, kids' music, etc.). I'm only sort of joking - really though they are sort of like 5 bands in one. Try something like "Kiss of LIfe" or "For Whom The Bell Tolls" for some later songs. Try something like "NIghts on Broadway" or "Wind of Change" for some mid-70s vibe. For some softer ballads try "And the Sun Will Shine", "Lost in Your Love". Or maybe "Come on Over" for a touch of country.
You kept saying Beatles instead of Bee Gees. But that's okay. Barry was the primary lead singer for pretty much the group's whole career. But in the late '60s, Robin was lead or co-lead on several of their songs. He had a unique vibrato voice. For his solo leads, check out And the Sun Will Shine, I Started a Joke, Odessa, Black Diamond, Lamplight.
One of the reasons the Bee Gees had such longevity and were so successful is that they didn't stagnate, they tried to keep their sound contemporary and in touch with current trends. They often blended elements of what made them successful into their newer works as time went on. Robin never abandoned his soulful ballads, Barry never abandoned his falsetto, Maurice never abandon his mastery of high harmony and instrumentation. They kept reinventing themselves but never threw out the things that made them unique.
Totalmente de acuerdo, fueron únicos, la voz de Robin,única, conmovedora, excelente!
The Bee Gees started there professional careers in 1958 as boys and ended in 2003 when Maurice died. They didn't want to sing without him. But they still wrote music for other singers.
That’s Robyn, one of the twins. They were around 16-18, and Barry was 3 yrs older. They wrote amazing music for kids that young. I was around for Elvis in the 50s and BeeGees in the 60s.
@aletmartins6940 it's Robin not Robyn.
I heard The Bee Gees in the 60s on the radio; bought their albums. I prefer their early songs much more than their disco.
I agree. My favorite are their songs is Holiday.
I love early Bee Gees. But then they were great always.
They were child stars in Australia. You can find them real young singing the Beatles "Please Please Me"
…and Bob Dylan’s Blowin In the Wind!!
@@dp3396 And Lonnie Donegan's 'My Old Man's a Dustman'! 🙂
The first singer here is Robin, I love his voice. He isnt the one who sings the high falsetto songs but I prefer his voice. The Bee Gees have a very unique style which became very popular. Incidentally they'd never been to Massachusetts, not when they wrote the song. It was just a good fit, lyrically.
Love the Bee Gees' early music especially 60's-70's. You are hearing Robin Gibb's voice in this song "Massachusetts" from 1968. He also sang lead on "I Started A Joke", "I've Gotta Get A Message To You", "How Can You Mend A Broken Heart" etc. Some of their other early hits were "New York Mining Disaster 1941", "To Love Somebody", "Holiday", "World", "And The Sun Will Shine", "Really & Sincerely", "Words", "The Singer Sang His Song", ""Lonely Days", "Melody Fair", "First Of May", "Give Your Best", "Lamplight" etc.
Todos los temas de esa época fueron excelentes, y eran tan jovenes, quizás fue la edad o la época que influyeron en sus composiciones, pero siempre las escucharé, es más siempre veo recitales de ellos en vivo, y sus versiones eran cada vez mejor con el tiempo, la versión de 1989 en Melbourne Australia, fue una obra de arte, la versión de Started a Jock es para llorar, y Ka respuesta del público, notable.! También compusieron muchos temas para otros artistas como Woman in Love, que canta Barbra Streissand, es una belleza
Never a huge fan of this particular song, but his voice was unmistakable. Loved a few you mentioned. "I Started a Joke" and "..Mend a Broken Heart" two of their best ever.
Robin's my favorite. They considered themselves balladeers.
My favorite band was The Bee Gees. Then the Beatles, Temptations (although I would say they were a group instead of a band cause they didn’t play instruments). 🤷🏾♀️. But The Bee Gees have always been #1 in my book. They adapted their styles to fit the eras from the 60’s all the way through the 2,000’s…so you’re likely to get a different vibe from them based on what decade you’re listening to! They were great at keeping up with the time.
I know most of you are being introduced to The Bee Gees (The Brothers Gibb) from their disco era, but those of us who are purists know there is So Much More! to them than Staying Alive and Too Much Heaven. They actually began performing as kids in England then after moving to Australia as teenagers got a record label and became regulars on a tv show called Australian Bandstand performing covers and their own original music. Just as their very first number one song was topping the charts there, they went home to England and made the rounds at the different recording studios. Finally auditioning for Robert Stigwood a partner of Brian Epstein the manager of the Beatles. This song Massachusetts was the first hit for them on the British Charts. This is a later performance but sounds just as good. Need to check out more 60’s,early 70’s they mostly wrote for others in the 1980’s. 90’s and early 2000’s. You are missing out on more than you will ever know if you get stuck on just one era.
Loved this song. It’s amazing all the songs they wrote. Amazing Group
If you want early Bee Gees, check out their first hit called Spicks And Specks. It is different than this, but then, they reinvented themselves and their sound a LOT. I love it all.
Great suggestion. From 1966. Even has an official video.
Exacto, y todos sus temas desde 1960 hasta los setenta, de la música disco solo compusieron los temas de Fiebre de Sábado a la Noche, producida por Robert Stigwood que era el manager de los Bee Gees!
The biggest Bee Gees smasher of all time alone from the Brothers Gibb - this song was 12 weeks in Germany on #1 and sold unbelievable appr. 3 million units and was No. 1 until Candle in the Wind 1996 with Elton John massive 10 times Gold 🏅and 5 times platinum 💍
Yes! Alone is a great suggestion!!
They grew and developed over time.
More Beegees❤❤❤
Living Together
Let there be love
You stepped into my life
Beautifull band
Beautifull brothers
Beautifull Beegees
❤❤❤
They are the greatest of all time. Three brothers, three great songwriters, three great singers. Three geniuses. Tremendous success. Unique phenomenon❤❤❤
The one leading on this is the one who had on the sunglasses in their “ I don’t want to be alone”…
They said that the only reason they recorded it was because they liked the word “Massachusetts”
I like their older music the best!
You should check out their earliest tv shows in AU, they were just young kids. They were the best, I miss them.
The Bee Gees actually started performing together in the late 1950's when they were like 8 and 12 years old. They have gone/evolved through several styles over the years. In the late 60's they came to America for the first time and were doing a sort of British Invasion style. In the very early 70's they were doing a tortured soul style (How Can You Mend a Broken Heart, I Started a Joke). By the mid 70's they had started doing the disco dance music style. They evolved into other styles in the years following disco. It's interesting to note that their most famous and most covered song came out in the mid to late 60's. Of course this is the incredible song "To Love Somebody!" This was a big hit for them, and a big hit for many others since then.
once and for finally The beatles were broken up by Spring 1970. I so love the Bee Gees when Robin sings lead.
Thats wy I love the Bee Gees. Every Song is a surprice ❤❤❤
I'm going to be 61years old next month. I started very early on as a kid listening to to their records with my babysitter. Probably more than any other group they were the soundtrack of my life. To be honest, the disco days were not my favorite. But I loved the early stuff and what came after. "I Started A Joke" is probably my favorite song, although now when I hear it I shed a few tears. Robin was always my favorite, and his voice so distinctive. Their talent was amazing.
Opino lo mismo, Started a Jock es mi preferida, y ahí venís la excelente voz que tenía Robin, era único y el mejor de los hermanos, mi favorito también! Muy merecido lo tiene, podría un gran talento musical, vocal y compositor!
You are so right. I cried so hard when we lost him. I think I wore black for a week. But he was so unique I've never heard anyone that can imitate him. No matter how blended their harmonies got, I was always searching to hear him.❤
The Brothers Gibb were very popular early on. They had a heavy handful of top ten hits. This video didn't include Maurice for some reason. Their sound was different later because they sold out to (gulp) disco and became sensationally popular.
Maurice was there, playing bass.
Vince Melouney on lead guitar and Colin Petersen on drums.
@@DougRayPhillips Thank you. I guess dementia is starting to set in.😏
I believe that is Maurice in the white shirt and black pants on the right, behind Robin.
Watch the three of them performing this song from Johnny Carson's Tonight Show sofa. Maurice is brilliantly hilarious waiting to sing his parts. I saw him another time go back and get the TV camera and walk around recording the crowd while he waved to everyone between parts. He was the best.
@@MS-zv4bf Yeah I saw that. I thought about mentioning it. I laughed my butt off plus their vocals were outstanding.😊🤟
Hello my young friend, the guy singing is Robin Gibb, Robin and Maurice are twins, Barry is the oldest, the youngest was Andy Gibb, he was also a singer.
Granny
Barry was 21, and the fraternal twins 17 when they left aussie. They were born on the isle of mann. Ended up in the USA mostly.
The twins were the same age as me.This was recorded where I worked. In concert they were tremendous saw them twice.
the Bee Gees were soulful R&B before disco and after disco. There are tons of songs with that sound. The disco era was pretty short and only accounts for a drop in the ocean of their songs.
My top artists of all time... hmm... Bee Gees, Beatles are both up there. U2 is as well. Like most really big fans of U2, I prefer Achtung Baby songs over The Joshua Tree songs while most casual U2 fans go for The Joshua Tree songs most. I also love ELO, Elvis Costello, and, well, too many to name, really. :D
Please react to HOW CAN YOU MEND A BROKEN HEART.
You asked, so my top 5 bands of all time #1 Heart #2 Journey #3 Boston #4 Bon Jovi #5 Def Lepard 🙂
Always loved this song
This is a few years later ruclips.net/video/NMZESDL4t0Q/видео.html This is 1997 ruclips.net/video/z59Qlu40TzE/видео.html Their early years were largely ballads. AFTER their disco era, they had dance songs,ballads and other styles. Their last release was 2001, 2 years before Maurice died.
Love the early pre-disco Bee Gees & so many wonderful songs they wrote & performed. There are videos of them performing in Australia when the twins weren't even in their teens.
They were rejuvenated with the intro of disco.
I feel they were to some degree, quite wrongly in my opinion, blamed for the disco sound. Almost all artists were coming out with disco songs. But the Bee Gees were so good that they were able to take it to the highest level. They became almost the symbol in a way. That was due to their talent being so great. But people got tired of disco and started to bad mouth it. Because the guys were so associated with it they bore the brunt of the backlash and it was not fair. They should have been recognized way earlier than they were for their achievements. It is a testament to them that they did fantastic music, kept it contemporary, and were able to span generations. I have a brother in law who absolutely loved all the disco. I was never a fan of disco. But we both appreciate them so much and we both own EVERYTHING they ever released. He and I can debate the merits of disco, but at the end of the day those brothers brought us together and we love all their 🎵.
@@kathleenblankenship1880 I agree totally. I was of the “ death before disco “ camp. Truthfully because I couldn’t dance.
1. Moody Blues. 2. Pink Floyd. 3. The Beatles. 4. Jethro Tull. 5. ELP.
There was a popular song from Scott Mackenzie that would become the hippie anthem, If You’re Going to SanFrancisco , Robin came up with this melody and an idea about someone going back home after going to San Francisco.
This was before they sold out to disco. The first song I remember hearing from them was "New York Mining Disaster" that was released in 1967 and many thought it was the Beatles.
I didn't think they "sold out to disco." They had some great songs during that period, as they did every decade they performed. The radio magnates unfairly turned on them.
great song, was all over the radio back then, odd the film was in B/W though
You should watch the 1960 video when they were really little kids. Song is Time is passing by (written by Barry who is about 13/14 at time and twins were about 10/11). They did go back into R&B with the album main course and after.
Top five bands...in no order! The Who, The Beatles, the Bee Gees, Grand Funk Railroad, the Rolling Stones. Really like your reactions, well done sir.
Fleetwood Mac
The Beatles were around in the late 50s. They blew up in the early 60's.
The Beatles, The Bee Gees, and The Temptations for me.
My top 5 bands are the Beatles, Led Zeppelin, Cream, Jimi Hendrix Experience and Bread.
Actually in 1977 Barry was 31 and twins Robin and Maurice were 28
This was '67 though....
@@lauraallen55 I know he was mentioned how he thought they were a late 70’s band
@@elizabethfranco1284 Oh, okay, got it! :)
Enjoyed your reaction, as always! Thanks! First featured here is Robin, then Barry the oldest comes in at 0:50-51 to stand beside Robin. We get to see the third Gibb brother Maurice at 2:23-5-- just a flash playing bass guitar next to lead guitarist Vince Melouney. LOL! Drummer is Colin Petersen. The original international(1967-69) Bee Gees band were five guys.
Thanks for the info!😁
At the start of their career, Robin was the lead singer.
Yes it's a shame the agents thought Barry was more appealing, and pushed him to the front.Caused a rift between them. Imo Robin had the better voice. RIP
@@KK-qd6ro totalmente de acuerdo, y esa figura duro toda su vida y trayectoria, me encanta la voz de Robin, es indiscutible que era el que cantaba mejor, su voz es única, grandiosa y conmovedora, fue una pena que no hubiera sido la figura principal! Me preguntó su representante no lo vio?
I always believed Robin had the strongest voice with his amazing vibrato. Combined with Barry's falsetto (sometimes) and Maurice's smooth voice, their harmonies were magic.
Another early song 🎵 worth listening to is "World"
Es grandiosa!
They grew up near me in Brisbane Australia. They started playing at a very young age
You really should check them out singing on Australian TV as children! An embarrassment of cuteness...
Disco came a lot later in their career, almost accidentally, after they were given the opportunity to write and perform most of the music for a little dance movie called Saturday Night Fever, starring a young and athletic John Travolta... turned out to be a massive hit which pretty much kick-started that 70s disco craze, and revived the BeeGees flagging career, with a vengeance!
They did many genres throughout their career the "disco" era was only a short time in their long career. My top 5 bands of all time are : 1. Bee Gees - early to mid 70's era, 2. Bee Gees - post fever era (80's -00's), 3. Bee Gees - 60's Era, 4. Bee Gees - late 70's era, 5. Bee Gees - all other eras & tangental (late 58's, songs written for other artists, solo albums, kids' music, etc.). I'm only sort of joking - really though they are sort of like 5 bands in one. Try something like "Kiss of LIfe" or "For Whom The Bell Tolls" for some later songs. Try something like "NIghts on Broadway" or "Wind of Change" for some mid-70s vibe. For some softer ballads try "And the Sun Will Shine", "Lost in Your Love". Or maybe "Come on Over" for a touch of country.
Awesome singing
My top 5 are...
Bee Fees
The Eagles
Queen
Tears for Fears
Styx
Honorable mention...
Damn Yankees
💪👌👌
Top 5 bands: Bee Gees, maneskin, supertramp, queen, guns n roses.
I’ve never heard you say why the Mayo is on the sofa. Will you tell us why?
Try I Started A Joke.
Top 5 bands?
1. Bee Gees
2. Cold Chisel
3. Queen
4. Beach Boys
5. Wings
Check out the BeeGees doing a Beatles song medley on The Midnight Special on RUclips
Check out Wine and Women which they did even earlier than this one, there is a live video out there.
You keep saying Beatles!!! 🤣
My bad hahaha keep mixing them up 🤣
Why is a jar of mayo ways part of your decor?
Not Beatles! BEEGEES is my top group of all time. 50 years of music can't be beat.
You kept saying Beatles instead of Bee Gees. But that's okay.
Barry was the primary lead singer for pretty much the group's whole career. But in the late '60s, Robin was lead or co-lead on several of their songs. He had a unique vibrato voice. For his solo leads, check out And the Sun Will Shine, I Started a Joke, Odessa, Black Diamond, Lamplight.
This is The Bee Gees not The Beatles!
Wish you would have picked a better video, Michael 4/1/24
Any video in particular?
@@michaelwduffy BeeGees Massachusetts One For All Tour In Australia 1989. Michael I love your feed back to me!
I’m glad he saw the early footage, but agree that he needs to react to the 1989 live performance!!!
@@janetbarker1216 Hard agree! That one is amazing.
@@lauraallen55 Thanks Laura, love your name
bee gees ordinary livesruclips.net/video/wCjr0lRiFgw/видео.htmlsi=nGp7QQgziItRHjDk