Music Snob's Rock Subgenre Tier List

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 окт 2024

Комментарии • 410

  • @GNVS300
    @GNVS300 2 года назад +176

    Never thought I'd see Mike rank Pop Rock above Prog Rock

    • @pchavez8833
      @pchavez8833 2 года назад +26

      Surprising at first but the more I think about it the more it makes sense. Pop Rock encompasses bands like The Beatles, The Beach Boys, Weezer, Green Day, etc and when you see it through that lens it makes a lot more sense.

    • @ToveriJuri
      @ToveriJuri 2 года назад +8

      @@pchavez8833
      If anything the latter two bring it down a lot.

    • @Rowjimmyguitar
      @Rowjimmyguitar 2 года назад +26

      @@pchavez8833 I highly doubt Green Day and weezer are what made him want to rank it above prog rock

    • @pchavez8833
      @pchavez8833 2 года назад +16

      @@Rowjimmyguitar Maybe, I was just throwing out examples. Weezer and Green Day do legitimately have good stuff though, The Blue Album, Dookie, etc.

    • @emperortrevornorton3119
      @emperortrevornorton3119 2 года назад +1

      Yes but you have to include some of each with the title of the video or it would not seem like a accurate title for the video

  • @fourseasons4105
    @fourseasons4105 2 года назад +99

    Jazz fusion is easily an A tier genere to me, at least. Return to forever, Brand X, Miles Davis's 70's records, Weather report, Allan Holdsworth, UK...
    So many amazing artists

    • @AllMediaReviewsPodcast
      @AllMediaReviewsPodcast 2 года назад +6

      Pat Metheny as well.

    • @spenserphoenix
      @spenserphoenix 2 года назад +6

      Casiopea, Takanaka the list goes on

    • @090nj2
      @090nj2 Год назад +1

      1000%

    • @Cobalt985
      @Cobalt985 Год назад

      @@spenserphoenix Hiromi Uehara!

    • @ezra340
      @ezra340 11 месяцев назад +1

      Absolutely! Not to mention arguably one of the greatest guitarists of all time Allan Holdsworth.

  • @Vivi_9
    @Vivi_9 2 года назад +38

    "Sounds like it sucks to me"
    That made me laugh my ass off, not triggered or anything but knowing you said that about one of the most iconic rock songs of the 80s/90s in such a blasé fashion was quite hilarious

  • @CollinLake
    @CollinLake 2 года назад +55

    Hey Mike I know your not huge on Radiohead, however I’d love to see a Radiohead video that’s in the same vain of The Pink Floyd video. (Great video btw) it would be great to see your perspective on the whole discography. 🤘🏻

  • @Glasshexagon
    @Glasshexagon 2 года назад +71

    90's Depeche Mode is legitimately electronic rock

  • @MatttheWitcher
    @MatttheWitcher 2 года назад +35

    Despite what people think of your opinions I watch because of your personality. You balance the humor with actual in depth criticism.

  • @STiLLiLLPRODUCTiONS
    @STiLLiLLPRODUCTiONS 2 года назад +52

    I’d love to see more of these tiers lists on other genres.

  • @iliketrains3495
    @iliketrains3495 2 года назад +57

    Become The Knight: "Dance Rock is in A tier"
    Finn McKenty: *screams into Falling in Reverse hoodie*

    • @superstarthomas
      @superstarthomas 2 года назад +1

      And cries

    • @scottbulinski5450
      @scottbulinski5450 2 года назад +5

      Dance rock isn't real

    • @laurisaarinen1126
      @laurisaarinen1126 Год назад +4

      I just thought it would be beyond interesting to see Mike and Finn do this kind of ranking TOGETHER 🤣
      Both have takes i don't agree with but they sometimes seem as polar opposites... But i'm always more in agreement with Mike's takes. Finn is super entertaining to watch but he often seems to put too much emphasis on looks, fashion and culture instead of the actual music.

    • @utopianeconomics5814
      @utopianeconomics5814 Год назад

      @@scottbulinski5450 I agree. Dance punk, like Death from Above, LCD Soundsystem, Test Icicles, and Late of the Pier, is definitely a thing, albeit, niche, but dance rock, like STRFKR, Luna Luna, and Ghostland Observatory, are more likely to be classified as electronic rock/pop rather than dance rock. The example he gave was poor too in my opinion.

    • @ANT96-x8d
      @ANT96-x8d Год назад

      He forgot Goth Rock

  • @Werner4voss
    @Werner4voss 2 года назад +42

    The Stone Roses shouldnt be mocked, they are one of the most important British bands ever

    • @SpiralDream
      @SpiralDream Год назад +15

      Dude has poor taste, which is typical of modern prog metal fans

    • @Volvith
      @Volvith Год назад +6

      @@SpiralDream Taste IS subjective, but i do think mike presents it too much as 'this is how it is and any other opinion is dogshit'.
      But yeah, a healthy fist full of salt over the shoulder, as per usually with these kinds of videos, never hurts. ;)

    • @kylem.9525
      @kylem.9525 Год назад +8

      @@Volvith When he really goes in depth, I can understand and respect his arguments, but outside of that he's not very good at saying he doesn't like something without sounding like a bit of an asshole.

    • @barry1369
      @barry1369 Год назад +1

      Ever? Really? They’re one hit wonder

    • @trtorbelfort
      @trtorbelfort Год назад +5

      @@barry1369one album wonder but that one album is so fucking good

  • @TheBlackQueen
    @TheBlackQueen 2 года назад +13

    It sounds like you're talking more about Glam Metal than Glam Rock. The latter is much more the lines of David Bowie, T. Rex, Sweet, Queen, Sparks, and Roxy Music. To me, that is one of the best genres of Rock because of its creativity and experimentation. It could be as glamourous as David Bowie and Roxy Music, as good-time-feeling as 10cc and T. Rex, as empowering as Sweet and Queen, as experimental as Sparks, and as Punky as The New York Dolls. There's so much ground covered in Glam Rock, and all of it just screams creativity!

    • @MGdelOeste
      @MGdelOeste 2 года назад +1

      And in fact, 70s glam rock didn't exactly brought back virtuosity (the guitar heroes thing and so on) to pop. It did pretty much the contrary, it brought back 50s good time rock n roll philosophy. Queen doesn't really applies as proper 70s glam in my book because they covered many other areas, some of them quite different to glam, like prog rock or the more virtuosistic side of heavy metal (Brian May was always closer to Blackmore or Eddie Van Halen than to Marc Bolan and the like). Curiously the Sweet were also a bit of a proto-metal band, but they didnt go as far.

    • @TheBlackQueen
      @TheBlackQueen 2 года назад +2

      @@MGdelOeste I agree with most of this, but Queen represented the more Artsy side of Glam Rock in their early years, in the same light as a band like Sparks. But yes, they covered a lot of ground including Heavy Metal, Progressive Rock, Glam Rock, Pop Rock, and numerous fusion genres too. When I say Glam Rock in terms of Queen, I mean Killer Queen, Seven Seas Of Rhye, Fat Bottomed Girls, Brighton Rock, Keep Yourself Alive, et cetera. You might say that none of these songs sound similar, and you'd be right! Queen were that varied in styles that even the songs in the same genre would sound very different from each other.

    • @MGdelOeste
      @MGdelOeste 2 года назад

      @@TheBlackQueen Yeeeah, I was also thinking on those songs as Glam Rock in terms of Queen. They all are catchy, relatively simpler takes on their hard rock sound (except perhaps for tunes line Killer Queen).

    • @TheBlackQueen
      @TheBlackQueen 2 года назад +2

      @@MGdelOeste Killer Queen is an example of the more artsy style of Glam Rock that was less Proto-Punky (though Queen did have some Proto-Punk elements on their debut) than their peers.

    • @americanliberal09
      @americanliberal09 Год назад

      @@MGdelOeste *like prog rock or the more virtuosistic side of heavy metal (Brian May was always closer to Blackmore or Eddie Van Halen than to Marc Bolan and the like*
      ummm......Van halen as metal? I personally think that they're more like hard rock than anything else.
      *Curiously the Sweet were also a bit of a proto-metal band, but they didnt go as far.*
      Dude. Seriously? What makes you even think that sweet are a proto-metal band?

  • @ryanshinermusic
    @ryanshinermusic 2 года назад +14

    Industrial is definitely a genre within rock.
    Nine Inch Nails has always been considered rock. Usually alternative rock or industrial.
    Usually most industrial sounds like Powerman 5000. Nowadays, it’s mostly dudes trying to be like Powerman 5000 despite the fact they only play like 100-cap rooms. I’ve met a few local people who play it and it’s usually a demo who’s sort of rural but also likes raves.

    • @greatdude7279
      @greatdude7279 Год назад

      Really?
      Maybe because I am European but Industrial here sounds more like EDM people combining metal with DnB or Dub.
      Like its still rock/metal but the focus also heavy in EDM.
      I mean local bands here sound more like Mick Gordon or Blue Stahli basically making industrial video game music. I mean I know that people would label them as "electronic rock/metal" but I mean if you look definition for electronic rock/metal its literally "industrial mixed with rock" and industrial is already a mixture between rock and electronica music so... electronic rock is "rock/electronica fusion mixed with rock music" kinda stupid definition.

  • @darkwarrior1253
    @darkwarrior1253 2 года назад +8

    Skinny Puppy was actually a heavy fire starter for Industrial music as a whole, balancing their older albums with more dark synth pop and their later albums being a mix of Industrial metal/rock. Actually a little known fact, some of the fellas from Skinny Puppy were helping with the band Ministry in their older album "Land of Rape and Honey."

  • @nemesis8626
    @nemesis8626 2 года назад +19

    Wow, who in there right mind would ever class can't get you out of my head by Kylie Minogue as Rock in any sense of the meaning, its a straight up pop song.

    • @stevierv22
      @stevierv22 2 года назад

      A Nick Cave fan, maybe 😋

    • @iliketrains3495
      @iliketrains3495 2 года назад +2

      All of the electronic rock results were bullshit except Sail

    • @laurachiriac1336
      @laurachiriac1336 Год назад

      Yeah, definitely wikipedia doesnt know what electronic rock is.

  • @vulkanofnocturne
    @vulkanofnocturne 2 года назад +9

    The trifecta of music (maybe all art/media) Fun, Authenticity, Originality. The closer to one you get you move away from the others.

  • @jhardyrules
    @jhardyrules 2 года назад +20

    This reminds me of a story I heard about High Hefner back in the day. So there was a monk that snuck into the Playboy Mansion and tried to sell flowers to all the girls that were staying there to fundraise for the US Forest Service and Hefner got upset about it. After he kicked him off the property, one of the girls started crying and asked him why he did that. He said, “Sweetheart, only Hugh can prevent florist friars!”

  • @acanofvancampsbeaneeweenee2037
    @acanofvancampsbeaneeweenee2037 2 года назад +6

    Jazz fusion & jazz rock are different, but it’s understandable to lump them together. Bands like Chicago & Steely Dan are jazz-rock, while Mahavishnu or Weather Report are fusion.

  • @Rosario_Verano
    @Rosario_Verano 2 года назад +15

    Today I learned that ' Can't get you out of my head ' is considered Electro-Rock by Google. What the actual fuck.

  • @alexdownfeet882
    @alexdownfeet882 2 года назад +24

    the stone roses are really cool man you should check them out

    • @iliketrains3495
      @iliketrains3495 2 года назад +4

      Apparently he's heard them before on Song Suggestion streams, but in that case I'm surprised he's never heard I Wanna Be Adored, one of their most famous songs

    • @alexdownfeet882
      @alexdownfeet882 2 года назад

      @@iliketrains3495 i get though why he wouldnt like them that much, their slow psychedelic vibe is not really his thing

  • @MGdelOeste
    @MGdelOeste 2 года назад +6

    I've always understood "glam rock" refers to the 70s glam movement (T Rex, Sweet, Slade, Bowie, New York Dolls, Gary Glitter, Transformer era Lou Reed, probably even Kiss and Alice Cooper...) instead of 80s "glam metal". There were 80s bands clearly influenced by proper 70s glam bands (Twisted Sister started out basically as one, Def Leppard were very influenced by them, Too Fast for Love era Motley Crue, Poison...) but there were also lots of 80s bands that were straight out hard rock, heavy metal or "AOR" groups. That doesn't mean 70s glam wasn't also a kind of catch-all term based mostly on looks, but underneath it there was a philosophy, and I think this is important. It is because in the description of the genre you said it brought back virtuosity to pop mainstream. But, actually, proper glam rock in the 70s did just the opposite: they brought back the poppy, carefree and amateur-ish side of rock n roll after the pshychedelic, prog explosion.

    • @lukeizabelle2131
      @lukeizabelle2131 Год назад

      It is evident from what you are saying that he has little idea of what Glam Rock actually is

    • @MGdelOeste
      @MGdelOeste Год назад +3

      @@lukeizabelle2131 Well, it would suprise me he didn't know about 70s glam rock, really. Perhaps he's just more familiar with the 80s version.

    • @lukeizabelle2131
      @lukeizabelle2131 Год назад +2

      jfmg95 Well, it is fair to say that Glam Rock and Glam Metal are different separated things so I don’t know how could he confuse the two things

    • @MGdelOeste
      @MGdelOeste Год назад +1

      @@lukeizabelle2131 Yeah, but I have the feeling that specially in America (where 70s glam rock wasn't as big as in the UK) this division isn't as clear cut

    • @lukeizabelle2131
      @lukeizabelle2131 Год назад

      @@MGdelOeste You think so? Interesting🙂

  • @blackhaze8233
    @blackhaze8233 2 года назад +108

    I always thought emo as pop punk garbage that was inspired by The Goth culture... Which is quite sickening and annoying being that i like Goth culture... Every time somebody sees a goth person or hears goth music the first thing they always yell is emo emo emo emo...🤦🏻

    • @no1defleppardfan101
      @no1defleppardfan101 2 года назад +22

      I feel this on so many levels. I’m not goth but a full on metalhead and people still call me emo. It’s so annoying man😭😭

    • @loweffortproductions1985
      @loweffortproductions1985 2 года назад +12

      I think South Park did an excellent episode about Goth and Emo culture 🤣

    • @blackhaze8233
      @blackhaze8233 2 года назад

      @@loweffortproductions1985 never seen it...was it funny

    • @loweffortproductions1985
      @loweffortproductions1985 2 года назад +3

      @@blackhaze8233 yes. Very funny

    • @robertparker6280
      @robertparker6280 2 года назад +9

      "We're not Emo, we're Goth!"

  • @BIGxBOSSxx1
    @BIGxBOSSxx1 2 года назад +18

    We need to get this guy on to some industrial rock

    • @domri4203
      @domri4203 2 года назад

      I'm sure Mike has heard NIN.

    • @BIGxBOSSxx1
      @BIGxBOSSxx1 2 года назад +1

      @@domri4203 Yeah but he said he thinks they’re more electronic then rock which makes me feel like he hasn’t listened to a whole lot of NIN. Downward Spiral has some straight up rock songs like March of the Pigs for example

    • @hastyhawkeye
      @hastyhawkeye Год назад +1

      Nin is industrial metal

    • @BIGxBOSSxx1
      @BIGxBOSSxx1 Год назад +1

      @@hastyhawkeye tomato tomato

    • @NILEGOD.777
      @NILEGOD.777 Месяц назад

      @@hastyhawkeye ministry and manson are more industrial metal, nin is easily industrial rock

  • @Wyocaster
    @Wyocaster 2 года назад +18

    Mike I actually really like your tier lists. Can you rank the maiden albums?

  • @loubadabin420
    @loubadabin420 2 года назад +4

    I really needed that, haven't laughed this hard during lunch break in a bit.....

  • @sirgreg7124
    @sirgreg7124 2 года назад +5

    Industrial is a genre that has a ton of influences so whether it’s industrial Metal, rock, or “electro industrial” (which is the definition of redundant) to me it’s all industrial music. And stuff like Fear Factory is really just Thrash Metal with some industrial influences.

  • @Tsudkyk
    @Tsudkyk Год назад +2

    Thank you for not shitting on blues rock, I was surprised with your ranking. I play a lot of heavy music but I enjoy playing improve blues rock or jazz on my looper pedal to “shift gears” mentally when I have writers block or want to just jam for a few minutes.

  • @carlosfer461
    @carlosfer461 2 года назад +6

    Jazz fusion is S tier tome because of bands like The Aristocrats, Other proyects from Guthrie like The Fellowship, Greg howe, Al Di Meola, Thundercat, Allan Holdsworth, Shawn Lane, Chick Corea or japanese bands like Casiopea and Masayoshi Takanaka and mouse on the keys. And no math rock on the list? another S tier for sure to me

  • @markustjelta5894
    @markustjelta5894 2 года назад +21

    I got genuinely upset when you said The Stone Roses suck

  • @iliketrains3495
    @iliketrains3495 2 года назад +7

    While electronic rock does feel like more of a description of instruments used than an overall style of music, I feel it's legitimate, although I prefer the term 'synthrock'. I think Kasabian is a good example of an electronic rock band, although they're pretty hard to categorise; they usually get tagged 'indie rock' as a result (which I'm surprised wasn't on this tier list, although it would probably end up in the bottom two tiers). Shock rock on the other hand, hell no, that just feels like a pure aesthetic label and I can only think of like 3 artists who qualify.
    Also for symphonic rock I can think of more specific songs than artists; only artists I can think of are ELO and Muse from 2009-2012. And yeah, I've never understood the difference between heartland and roots, and especially 'swamp pop/rock'.

    • @iliketrains3495
      @iliketrains3495 2 года назад

      That being said, almost all of the Google results for 'electronic rock' were straight up bullshit. Can't Get You Out of My Head is a pop and nu-disco song, the FURTHEST thing from rock, I Wanna Be Adored is indie rock and Madchester (another that could qualify for 'redundant' tier) with elements of psychedelic and dance-rock, don't know All My Friends; the only one of those that is accurate is Sail by Awolnation, but I've also seen that song tagged as 'industrial rock', which I disagree with

  • @TheBlackQueen
    @TheBlackQueen 2 года назад +13

    I've always preferred to use the word Progressive in terms of Prog as being about the music itself Progressing on, as in changing moods and styles from one part of the song to the next. This is a big reason why Prog albums tend to connect the songs as if they were just one long song which is often interpreted as such. This way it doesn't have to stick to the idea of always pushing boundaries that have never been done before. Of course, this was both the case for older 60s and 70s Prog.

  • @Paool
    @Paool 2 года назад +10

    Haven't watched yet, but your wrong.
    -the internet

  • @johngekchyan703
    @johngekchyan703 Год назад +4

    I don't really understand how you have art rock and prog rock so far apart. They really go hand in hand and many bands cross into both at the same time.

  • @gabingston3430
    @gabingston3430 2 года назад +7

    Mike, have you heard Bo Burnham's parody of Country music? It was the first thing I thought of when you explained why Country Rock was going in the F tier.

    • @henryorsomething
      @henryorsomething 2 года назад +2

      🎶 No shirt, no shoes, no Jewwwws ʸᵒᵘ ᵈᶦᵈⁿ'ᵗ ʰᵉᵃʳ ᵗʰᵃᵗ 🎶

    • @gabingston3430
      @gabingston3430 2 года назад +2

      @@henryorsomething sort of a mental typo.

  • @capnfluff2428
    @capnfluff2428 2 года назад +18

    Please name a few bands for every genre so we know exactly what you're referring to.

  • @CallieCatGaming
    @CallieCatGaming 2 года назад +3

    Lmao seeing the electronic rock pop up with Kylie Minogue was hilarious. No that's like 2000s pop. No rock about it.

  • @ale.2p284
    @ale.2p284 2 года назад +10

    13:40 You are talking about glam metal, not about glam rock. They're different subgenres.

  • @PCamron90
    @PCamron90 2 года назад +19

    Bruh how is Nine Inch Nails not rock?

    • @thorndust5329
      @thorndust5329 2 года назад +2

      Aren't they just industrial music?

    • @PCamron90
      @PCamron90 2 года назад +4

      @@thorndust5329 industrial metal, industrial rock...

    • @brandenlucero
      @brandenlucero 2 года назад +2

      Agreed. If NIN isn't rock, or even alternative rock in some of their later releases, then that blows my fuckin mind on what they even are.

    • @silverg2862
      @silverg2862 Год назад +1

      @@thorndust5329 Bands like Throbbing Gristle are industrial. NIN is "industrial rock" which is really just electronic music fused with rock guitars.

    • @starsinmysky
      @starsinmysky Год назад +1

      They are most definitely a sub genre of rock

  • @AdrianBrth
    @AdrianBrth 2 года назад +9

    Mike criticizes Shock Rock, but is wearing this shirt.

  • @wadekemmsies7180
    @wadekemmsies7180 2 года назад +4

    I HIGHLY recommend that first stone roses album

  • @dbd4596
    @dbd4596 2 года назад +4

    Hey Mike, a tier list of classic prog rock bands would be interesting!

  • @Houlgravely
    @Houlgravely 2 года назад +2

    Jazz-fusion and Yacht Rock would be S-tier for me. Unparalleled genres in regards to crafting a certain feeling / atmosphere.
    Soft Rock isn't really a thing because it doesn't zero in enough as a term on what makes the good stuff actually good.

  • @veenoir1991
    @veenoir1991 2 года назад +7

    Steel panther is pretty good. Ben stiller is a great guitarist

    • @darkdudironaji
      @darkdudironaji 2 года назад +1

      I never noticed how much he looks like Ben Stiller until you said that.

  • @thekivster
    @thekivster 2 года назад +9

    Jazz rock and jazz fusion are sort of different

    • @marcocardia3960
      @marcocardia3960 2 года назад +1

      Yeah you see that in Zappa's discography when you lisen to Apostrophe and Hot Rats you see a clear difference

    • @JocaFus
      @JocaFus 2 года назад +3

      Yep. For example, the first albums of Chicago are jazz rock, but surely not jazz fusion

  • @rossmusic25
    @rossmusic25 2 года назад +15

    Post punk in D??????? Bro it’s A no question. So many extremely important bands

    • @starsinmysky
      @starsinmysky Год назад +1

      AGREED

    • @lugarespecial
      @lugarespecial 7 месяцев назад

      It's a F tier. Pop Punk bands took everything Punk had of interesting and throw it away.

    • @rossmusic25
      @rossmusic25 7 месяцев назад

      @@lugarespecial No it just made it different than it already was. I love both regular punk and pop punk when it’s good

    • @liamcragin
      @liamcragin 2 месяца назад

      @@lugarespecialyou guys are talking about two different things.

  • @AndromedaEleven
    @AndromedaEleven 2 года назад +3

    Experimental rock is Swans for example or some weird avant-garde bands.

  • @elpolitemexa2272
    @elpolitemexa2272 2 года назад +5

    Hard disagree on jazz rock being the same as fusion jazz; fusion jazz at its core is the electrification of modal jazz using rock, blues and funk mainly as references. Jazz rock would only be the fusion that mainly comes from rock, or uses rock as their main reference.
    I don't think something like duel of the jester and the tyrant is Jazz Rock for example, because it's so much more medieval, modal and funk than it is rock, but i can't say the same for don't make waves from Brand X on the other hand.
    TL;DR: every jazz rock is fusion jazz but not every fusion jazz is rock.

    • @GBsdclf01
      @GBsdclf01 2 года назад

      Jazz fusion comes from jazz, jazz-rock comes from rock.

  • @ArcticTyrion
    @ArcticTyrion Год назад +1

    personally i think post punk should be higher. talking heads, television, joy division, the smiths, the cure... so many important and influential bands to the indie/alt scene during that era

  • @trevorfernandez6886
    @trevorfernandez6886 2 года назад +2

    I only ever heard sail on rock stations and wondered how it was rock. Guess it was too "edgy" for the pop stations? But radio stations have been pretty abysmal with their set lists for awhile. it's had to have been a good decade now since I heard someone the radio and was like "man, who's that? What song is this?" Started using YT music and between the algorithm bringing decent stuff my way and a couple channels like this, I've been stoked to finally expand the shit I listen to. Too much of same good music has been getting stale for me over the years

  • @bluepinkman4785
    @bluepinkman4785 2 года назад +2

    Emo is really just a confusing genre. When I first listen to Sunny Day Real Estate, I really thought they were a grunge band. And then there are emo albums that are really different in terms of sound. Not to mention, there are waves of emo that I saw on tiktok. Personally, I love emo especially Midwest emo. It's just really a confusing genre because emo bands have really different sound compare to other emo bands.

  • @Zuub470
    @Zuub470 2 года назад +1

    CCR is blues rock, and the best argument for blues rock being higher.

  • @shanewalton8888
    @shanewalton8888 2 года назад +2

    "All bow down to the church of Acid Rock"

  • @fearfulstatic
    @fearfulstatic 2 года назад +4

    Forgot Goth Rock and Shoegaze.

    • @liamcragin
      @liamcragin 2 месяца назад

      They could fit under Post-Punk and Alt Rock.

  • @staceyfletcher9764
    @staceyfletcher9764 2 года назад +1

    Mike can you please do a tier list for Progressive rock band and by the way I love your videos keep up the good work❤

  • @mrlevinielsen
    @mrlevinielsen 2 года назад +3

    Electronic rock is awesome. 😂

  • @orlock20
    @orlock20 2 года назад +3

    Ska and ska rock are two different sounds. Ska is a type of jazz founded in Jamaica and is mixed with reggae. Ska rock is rock bands with a brass section and strive for a reggae beat. Streetlight Manifesto is one of these bands. There are fake ska rock bands such as No Doubt which lack the brass section.

    • @ryanshinermusic
      @ryanshinermusic 2 года назад +2

      “Ska rock” means ska punk.
      No Doubt was a real ska punk band. They just switched to pop real quick once they got picked up

    • @MGdelOeste
      @MGdelOeste 2 года назад

      @@ryanshinermusic Yeah, basically. Most ska-rock bands I know are really ska-punk. A quite popular rock genre in Spain and Italy for some reason, by the way. It is also often openly political.

  • @michaelrigney9682
    @michaelrigney9682 2 года назад +15

    aight so imma need to find out where I can get that shirt, Mike.

  • @christianmariolongo6395
    @christianmariolongo6395 2 года назад +1

    Excellent shirt, sir

  • @danbuckholz9228
    @danbuckholz9228 2 года назад +2

    There’s actually some really good Modern pop punk now that it’s not *the* mainstream genre

  • @LanceCorporalHawk30
    @LanceCorporalHawk30 2 года назад +2

    I love that shirt, dude XD

  • @Ruddline
    @Ruddline 2 года назад +3

    I'll do a list
    S TIER
    Hard Rock ya lets just make this default S
    Arena - I feel like this was the better or worse the highest peak of Rock (hell, maybe music itself?) history this is the truest form of Rock as its the one that united the world, such as Queen Live Aid performance, it was sad when Rock died and went exclusively to clubs and shows
    A TIER
    Alternative - has produced some of the best rock ever but got stale and died out with the "Core Scene"
    Psyche - I feel like its underrated its like Stoner but actually CAN trip you out without drugs and has a feel like none other, Beatles, Tame Impala, Jefferson Airplane, Foxygen, Animal Collective, Panda Bear and much more
    Prog - C'mon maybe the fans are annoying but that doesn't make it C its highs are some of the best music ever, I will put it at A because I will fold in subgenres not on the list like Math and Djent, Polyphia is the most relevant rock band in the world
    Soft - if I wrapped with Yacht Rock its my jam, something so aspirational about thinking about drinking on a beach, sailing, flying in a fighter jet, dancing romantically, Glory of the Power of Love, people have Lo Fi Beats, well I study to Soft Rock all day
    B TIER
    Blues - slaps agreed on Funk Glam Jazz Pop
    Emo - White blues lol I mean I think it has its moments its definitely memorable, this is also basically covering Goth Rock I guess
    Punk - Its extremely played out but... meh I think its above average music, its asskicking wake up to go to work music
    Southern - ya low B but this has the most soul
    New Wave - If you ever had a Doomer phase I can tell Mike is too manly man for this shit but I like it, give me Simple Minds any time
    Pop Punk - Its happy music and its something everyone likes/tolerates as driving music nothing wrong with it
    C TIER
    Art Rock - can be good or bad
    Britpop - It had its moments but didn't age well
    Heartland?
    Rockabilly - I always wanted a girlfriend who dresses in 50s clothes and has sexy kinks but the music is just bland
    Post Punk - ehh its the official Millennial Genre like Sum 41 and Blink 182, you gotta jam to All The Small Things as a 32 year old mom
    Industrial - Stuff like NIN, Rammstein, Kraftwerk has its moments its never going to be GREAT
    D TIER
    Folk Rock - Garfunkle, Dylan, Neal Young its disgusting but Sound of Silence keeps it away from F
    Stoner - I appreciate it and some of King Gizz more stonery stuff but feel like its a one note boring thing
    Ska - One note but Superman is still one of the GOAT songs
    Electronic - Muse, Radiohead, its all right don't see the dogshit
    Surf - Its just another one note genre
    F TIER
    Dance Rock - its just post disco its pretentious cheesier than Hair Metal somehow
    Country Rock - screw it
    Acid - boring just proto-psyche
    Roots - ya like Toots and the Maytals its like whatever

    • @SherlockHolmez
      @SherlockHolmez Год назад +1

      Post-punk is stuff like Joy Division, Bauhaus, Echo & The Bunnymen, and The Smiths, not Sum 41 and Blink 182 lol
      Unless I misunderstood you?

  • @joeturton6627
    @joeturton6627 2 года назад +4

    glam rock isnt what you were describing, I guess you were describing glam metal but there are so many subgenres its kind of redundant. Glam rock is more of a 70s thing such as bands like Slade, Wizzard and David Bowie

  • @rossmusic25
    @rossmusic25 2 года назад +4

    So you’re definitely dead wrong about industrial. It’s a mix of rock and electronic.

    • @iliketrains3495
      @iliketrains3495 2 года назад +3

      Industrial is a style in itself, there's also industrial pop, industrial hip-hop etc. I always interpreted it as having more aggressive electronics

    • @rossmusic25
      @rossmusic25 2 года назад +2

      @@iliketrains3495 that’s true but there’s plenty of guitar in it also. Plenty of Nine Inch Nails songs that have guitar, plenty of ministry songs that have guitar, skinny puppy, Marilyn Manson, so on and so forth

  • @AllMediaReviewsPodcast
    @AllMediaReviewsPodcast 2 года назад +1

    Michael Nesmith is Country Rock. At the same time, Michael Nesmith is progressive (see The Prison among a lot of his other work. Wax Minute as another example).

  • @delix787
    @delix787 2 года назад +1

    FUCKING LOVE THE BLUE MIKE!!!
    💙🖤💙

  • @vtr_monsterextremo5145
    @vtr_monsterextremo5145 2 года назад +2

    10:40 I think Emo is a mix between Pop Punk and Metalcore, an example is from Fall Out Boy with the song Saturday when bridge comes, there’s some growls from the bassist

    • @iliketrains3495
      @iliketrains3495 2 года назад

      Was metalcore even a thing at that point?

    • @vtr_monsterextremo5145
      @vtr_monsterextremo5145 2 года назад

      @@iliketrains3495 if I remember correctly, by that time when FOB released Take This to Your Grave, Killswitch Engage had already one or two albums

    • @vtr_monsterextremo5145
      @vtr_monsterextremo5145 2 года назад

      Btw, I’m using Killswitch as an example

    • @iliketrains3495
      @iliketrains3495 2 года назад

      @@vtr_monsterextremo5145 ah okay then, I was actually thinking of Killswitch but couldn't remember when they debuted

    • @thenoodledrop
      @thenoodledrop 2 года назад

      A lot of the core (metalcore, deathcore, post hardcore) subgenres have their roots in emo. A lot of it having roots in skramz (Orchid, Pg99) as well as emo (Sunny Day, Thursday). A lot of it splintered off into their own things by the mid 2000s, but I think At The Drive In were the penultimate culmination of the styles and inspired people to take it in various directions.

  • @KingofCogs1
    @KingofCogs1 Год назад

    I love Ska, but I knew you were going to put it there...lol. I could probably argue it up to a C, but that would require to have you listen to some 2nd wave ska. Go listen to some Scofflaws and/or The Toasters if interested. Thanks for the list!

  • @blackhaze8233
    @blackhaze8233 2 года назад +3

    Love the shirt lol....

  • @ringotango4883
    @ringotango4883 2 года назад +1

    love the shirt

  • @captainkthebassplayinpirate16
    @captainkthebassplayinpirate16 9 месяцев назад +1

    The Stone Roses are not Electronic Rock, they paved the way for The Smiths and Oasis did

  • @demetrisgalides
    @demetrisgalides 2 года назад +5

    This guy seriously said that radiohead is overrated

    • @trentonmcintyre5617
      @trentonmcintyre5617 2 года назад +6

      I guess it isn’t a become the knight video without hot takes

    • @cee_jay_mcc7914
      @cee_jay_mcc7914 2 года назад +3

      Cause it is

    • @youreokayboah2128
      @youreokayboah2128 Год назад +3

      Because they are.

    • @RevStickleback
      @RevStickleback 5 месяцев назад +1

      If you want music to fire you up, they are awful. If you want music to relax to, they are fantastic.

  • @ssawws1898
    @ssawws1898 2 года назад +2

    Tbh potatoes are the best vegetable, they’re so versatile, fries, mashed potatoes, boiled, roasted, raw, let alone all the possible dishes you can make with it, potato salad is horrible tho

  • @Xygor
    @Xygor 2 года назад

    Love the video man!

  • @hank35682
    @hank35682 Год назад

    Industrial rock and symphonic rock is just electronic rock, and I love it, A Tier

  • @RevStickleback
    @RevStickleback 5 месяцев назад +1

    I always found it odd to see Britpop classified as a genre, when really it was just referring to a set of bands with no connection at all, other than a period of time and a nationality. Blur and Oasis were the biggest two, and they are not remotely similar. I guess it might depend on what bands you think of. But, you should like it for one thing...an act of mercy if you will, because it stopped pop-punk gaining any kind of foothold in the UK.

  • @Schellnino1994
    @Schellnino1994 Год назад

    I was wondering your opinion on Will Yip?
    He has made some classics in the scene lately (Movements, Turnstile, Turnover, Citizen, Circa Survive) and his production feels very progressive (in a Pink Floyd kind of way) to me

  • @PeterPan-dz7mu
    @PeterPan-dz7mu 2 года назад

    Emo seems to be more an aesthetics/vibe kind of thing. People call all kinds of bands 'Emo'. You hear people say it about Evanescence, My Chemical Romance, Marilyn Manson, Sisters of Mercy and even Billie Eylish, which all make very different music.

  • @Kriegter
    @Kriegter Год назад +2

    Ay how can you forget Bob Rock

    • @ChrisStoneinator
      @ChrisStoneinator 5 месяцев назад

      Chris representative here to point out he also forgot Chris Rock. To save the kid representatives the effort of coming here I’ll also put in a word for Kid Rock.

  • @ryanshinermusic
    @ryanshinermusic 2 года назад +1

    Emo is a different genre than post-hardcore.
    Post-hardcore just became a name because had no idea how to label Refused.
    “Emo purists” on r/emo get mad at including “Mall Emo” like MCR just because they want to sound cooler by saying they listen to American Football.

  • @megamuerte6934
    @megamuerte6934 2 года назад

    9:12
    Lol i like it despiste the vocals
    It's crazy how i met one of my favs songs in this video by Mike saying "sounds like it sucks to me'

  • @Jordo246
    @Jordo246 2 года назад +5

    You just pissed off every single British person that watches you by instantly dismissing The Stone Roses. They are an incredible band, here in Britain they are absolutely legendary and were about 5 years ahead of everyone else for what would become the popular sound of British music in the 90s.
    Extremely disappointing to see you dismiss them based on the intro to their most famous song before it even starts.
    Your section on Britpop didn't make any sense to me either. I have literally never gotten the vibe you described from any Britpop band. Maybe it's just because you don't know what British culture is actually like but I think you were way off on that one.

    • @iliketrains3495
      @iliketrains3495 2 года назад

      I got the feeling he didn't like them from his Describe Bands in One Sentence #3 (in which I was surprised he even knew them), but couldn't tell if he was being serious or not

  • @allyourbasearebelongtous2191
    @allyourbasearebelongtous2191 2 года назад +1

    I got a Bourbon commercial for this video.... just wanted you to know.

  • @mintybadgerproductions
    @mintybadgerproductions 2 года назад +4

    Does Mike actually know what Britpop is? I have no idea who he's referring to when he says they're pretending to be awkward outcasts or emotional manipulators.

    • @liamcragin
      @liamcragin 2 месяца назад

      I feel like that’s the case for a lot of the genres honestly.

  • @Divig
    @Divig 2 года назад

    Love the shirt!

  • @KnapfordMaster98
    @KnapfordMaster98 11 месяцев назад

    I agree about New Wave BUT... listen to Til Tuesday and see if they get an exception. I love them.

  • @joniheumann2895
    @joniheumann2895 2 года назад +4

    Psychedelic Rock >>

  • @em0tionalpavu1on
    @em0tionalpavu1on 2 года назад +4

    seems like there are much more alt. rock bands than rock bands. Same goes to heavy metal vs other metal genres

    • @iliketrains3495
      @iliketrains3495 2 года назад +1

      Yeah, I can't think of a single rock band since the 90's who doesn't fall under 'alternative rock' in some way. Maybe Greta Van Zeppelin

    • @em0tionalpavu1on
      @em0tionalpavu1on 2 года назад +1

      @@iliketrains3495 exactly the same thing goes to "heavy metal" bands since 80s. Maybe aside from (just like Greta) some obvious 80s classic metal revival bands

    • @pchavez8833
      @pchavez8833 2 года назад +1

      @@iliketrains3495 I feel like alt rock is kind of a catch all term these days. Like according to Google Weezer and Radiohead are both alt rock and they’re both completely different bands.

  • @KilroyWasHere83
    @KilroyWasHere83 2 года назад +1

    I see that shirt. Love it

  • @1GuyGaming
    @1GuyGaming 2 года назад +1

    Those "Sail" type songs can probably be considered stomp rock, I've also seen it be called stomp clap.

    • @iliketrains3495
      @iliketrains3495 2 года назад +1

      Mike called them 'neo rock' in another video

  • @anthonystark5412
    @anthonystark5412 10 месяцев назад

    Mike is so effing entertaining that I was 18 minutes into this video before I figured out what was printed on his hoodie/top. 😆
    Apologies, bro. I just don't pay attention to your clothing.

  • @youareweirdforreadingthis
    @youareweirdforreadingthis 2 года назад +1

    Hi my name is J and I am glad foo fighters is on your team.

  • @carlpeterson8182
    @carlpeterson8182 2 года назад

    So many artists can be in multiple sub genres especially the good ones. The great ones are just themselves and often transcend these sub genres. Rush is one of them. Are they prog rock? I would say they are hard rock. Queen is probably another. As an 70’s and 80’s kid I like Nu Wave. It is simple but it is fun.

  • @jarhead98gaming
    @jarhead98gaming 2 года назад

    I actually love Pop-punk because of the catchiness of it and love the fast paced songs….. but I completely understand why you’d put it way down there because MOST of it is very similar to all other pop-punk if not copied by other bands!! There are actually very talented writers in the genre though, which is respectable

  • @deathsquadrec
    @deathsquadrec 2 года назад

    I would say about 60 percent of the time people say emo they mean post hardcore and scene. But the other 40% is split between Midwestern emo and DC emotional hardcore. Leaning heavier to Midwestern

  • @snowinaz
    @snowinaz 2 года назад +3

    Mike really hasn't listened to as much music as I used to think huh. No offense

  • @CedricsSpecialLP
    @CedricsSpecialLP 2 года назад

    After your Metal subgenres tier list, I was hoping for something I had a bit more knowledge about, and being more of a Rock fan, this was it. I see a lot of things differently, I would definitely put Progressive Rock in S Tier. Fight me! 😉 Many other genres you put in C Tier, I would put in S or A Tier, but everyone has a different view.

  • @Frip36
    @Frip36 Год назад

    I think the term Alt-Rock is great. It let's you know that it's the new version of classic rock. More modern. Alt rock is what happened to classic rock when classic took on influence from post punk, hip hop, electronic, new wave. It was a new term in the early 90's that let you know you weren't going to be hearing Bad Company for the billionth time. But a band named Pearl Jam who tweaked it a bit.

    • @bezoticallyyours83
      @bezoticallyyours83 Год назад

      Plus there's some bands that just can't fit into any particular category. Lookin at you Sublime and Butthole Surfers.

  • @theelvis654
    @theelvis654 2 года назад

    Great shirt!

  • @ryanshinermusic
    @ryanshinermusic 2 года назад

    I just skipped around this video for genres I liked.
    For emo being where it was, I’m surprised pop punk wasn’t around the same spot.
    The whole “not being genuine” thing just doesn’t make any sense to me. Pop punk has remained as a dominant genre long enough to be the new dad rock because a lot of those bands were genuine to their audiences.
    Like The Wonder Years are still selling out clubs and wrote real honest music years ago and now. Alkaline Trio, A Day To Remember, New Found Glory, Four Year Strong, etc. all influenced multiple genres and are generally considered having genuine feelings in their songs and towards the fans.
    And then obviously Green Day and Blink like you said were “honest” bands even if they never really liked the title of “pop punk.”
    There was just such a negative connotation about the music when you and I were younger because it was considered immature or “just a phase” or whatever. And also people took exception just to the name. Plus a lot of the flavor-of-the-week one-hit wonders from 2007 fell off pretty hard and got replaced by much better bands a few years later.

  • @TheRareVideosXL
    @TheRareVideosXL 2 года назад

    Great tier list.

  • @yourescum497
    @yourescum497 2 года назад +3

    My chemical romance is definitely not post hardcore. Hahah. They are pop music with dark themes and imagery! Bands like PG-99,Orchid and Rites of Springs are considered Emo/Post Hardcore. But good list! Enjoyed the tier list! Keep up the good content!

    • @thenoodledrop
      @thenoodledrop 2 года назад +4

      I think Bullets is pretty post hardcore, but most of their popular discography isn’t imo

    • @Azg105
      @Azg105 2 года назад +1

      Their first 2 albums has quite a lot of post hardcore elements to it., but yea they were nevert a pure posthardcore band.

  • @puttu_racing
    @puttu_racing 2 года назад +1

    16:58 The only industrial rock band that I can think of is "Emigrate" but other than that, the genre is completely redundant.

    • @orlock20
      @orlock20 2 года назад

      I can't think of NIN as metal. It's closer to hard rock than metal.

    • @puttu_racing
      @puttu_racing 2 года назад

      @@orlock20 I have never listened to Nine Inch Nails so I can't really comment on that.

    • @mr.echo24
      @mr.echo24 2 года назад

      @@orlock20 Rammstein is metal though I think?

    • @puttu_racing
      @puttu_racing Год назад +1

      @@mr.echo24 Yes, Rammstein is industrial metal/Neue Deutsche Härte