Yeah, really old and ancient Chinese proverb, and China never used it until now. The developed countries already went past those 100 years. LKY also knew it lah. You think only the Chinese know it ah? Everybody can see what China is doing now.
@@peterk5981 “The majority of people…”. Au contraire, both the US and EU are on the other side of the world yet are, respectively, the 2nd and 3rd largest trading partners with ASEAN countries. The US runs a $200 bil deficit. Without those 2 blocs, South East Asian countries would be, not only considerably poorer, but subject to the whims of capricious CCP,
@@angusmckenzie9622wrong, without western country not holding gun to asean head to force sell raw resources with extremely cheap price, asean would have rise long ago. Btw asean countries had been colonize for centuries by western countries only around 1945 and up they had their countries back, and that is with neo colonisation.
@@intanpermata5115 "wrong, without western country not...How does what happed for a couple of hundred years and finished 80 years ago make current trade figures wrong ? If you make a victim of yourself, you'll aways be a victim.
@@intanpermata5115 If u have no weapons to defend yourself, then u can't blame ppl for colonising u... Resources are useless if there's no machine that uses them... Come on, without the invention of Engines, you think Saudi Arabia will be rich? They will have plenty of oil in the ground and no one will want to dig them up... we have to thank Europe for the Industrial Revolution...
But American goes to do the exact opposite, taking over its allies' market share of products that they sold to China... Who need enemies when you have "friends" like the US.
🍌THE GOSPEL OF THE WORD OF ALMIGHTY GOD "the last age in which God is saving man from the imminent destruction of this old world" (The transformation of a person's disposition is not a change of behavior, or a feigned external change or a temporary change produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a real transformation of disposition that brings about a change in behavior. The transformation of disposition means that you have understood and experienced the truth, and that truth has become your life. Now that your disposition has changed, you not only understand the truth, but you also act on it. You are able to let go of the things you felt like doing the other day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. This is a transformation of disposition, and it is also the process of transforming your disposition. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. Only after experiencing all this can a person partially understand his own nature. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. In this process, you will understand some things about yourself, and you will realize that you are very impure, harbor too many personal motives, and have too many desires while fulfilling your duties. Once you have understood the meaning of these things, you will be able to approach God in prayer and truly repent; in this way, you will be cleansed of impurities. The more one's corrupt disposition is refined, the more the disposition of their life will change.) Almighty God said The TRANSFORMATION of a PERSON'S DISPOSITION is NOT a CHANGE of BEHAVIOR, or a FELT EXTERNAL CHANGE or TEMPORARY DIFFERENCE produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a REAL CHANGE of DISPOSITION which CAUSES a CHANGE in BEHAVIOR. Such a change in behavior is not the same as changes manifested in a person's outward behaviors and actions. The TRANSFORMATION of the DISPOSITION MEANS that YOU have UNDERSTOOD and EXPERIENCED the TRUTH, and the TRUTH has BECOME YOUR LIFE.🌷 In the PAST, you UNDERSTOOD the TRUTH of this matter, BUT you did NOT put it into PRACTICE; the truth is only doctrine to you that is not practiced. NOW that your DISPOSITION has CHANGED, you not only UNDERSTAND the TRUTH, but you also ACT ACCORDING to IT. You are LETTING GO of the THINGS you LOVED to do back in the day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. 🙏🌷 You are now ABLE to GIVE UP THINGS that you COULDN'T GIVE UP back in the day. This is DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION, and it is also the PROCESS of your DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION.🌷 It may sound simple, but in REALITY, ANYONE in the MIDDLE of this PROCESS has to ENDURE a LOT of SUFFERING, OVERCOME their FLESH, and LEAVE the FLESH ASPECTS of NATURE. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. 🙏☀️ Only AFTER EXPERIENCING ALL of this can a person partially understand his own nature. HAVING a little UNDERSTANDING about it, however, does NOT mean IMMEDIATELY being able to CHANGE a PERSON; MAN must ENDURE SUFFERINGS in the PROCESS. 🙏 Also, can you immediately start practicing after gaining some understanding of something? You cannot immediately start a practice. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. Sometimes, people are not ready to go through it, saying, "Why can't I do it that way? Do I have to do it this way?" Others say, "If you believe in God, then you should do it this way is true." WHEN people REACH a CERTAIN POINT where they have gone through SEVERAL TRIALS and ENDED up UNDERSTANDING WITH GOD'S will and some TRUTH, then they will be HAPPY no matter what and ready to act ACCORDING to TRUE PRINCIPLES. In the beginning, people were reluctant to practice the truth. Take conscientious fulfillment of duties as an example: You have a little understanding of fulfilling duties and being faithful to God, and you also understand the related truths, but when will you fully devote yourself to God? When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. Some people may correct you, others may criticize you. All eyes will be on you, and only then will you begin to realize that you are in the wrong and that the truth is that you have done something bad, that the lack of devotion to fulfilling your duty is unacceptable, and you should not be rash and careless. The HOLY SPIRIT will ENLIGHTEN you FROM WITHIN, and rebuke you when you sin. IN this PROCESS, you will UNDERSTAND some THINGS ABOUT YOURSELF, and YOU will REALIZE that you are VERY IMPURE, HARBOR too MANY PERSONAL MOTIVES, and have too MANY DESIRES while FULFILLING your DUTIES. ONCE you have UNDERSTOOD the MEANING of these THINGS, you will be ABLE to APPROACH GOD in PRAYER and TRULY REPENT; in this WAY, you WILL be CLEANSED of IMPURITIES. ☀️🙏 If, in this way, you often seek the truth to solve your own practical problems, you will gradually tread the right path of faith. The MORE one's CORRUPT DISPOSITION is PURIFIED, the MORE the DISPOSITION of their LIFE will CHANGE. 🙏 From "Should Know About Changing a Person's Disposition" Fulfillment in (Ezekiel 2: 9-10) and in (Revelation 19: 9,13) 📥Calling and leading everyone to His lowered Kingdom or Church because it is still standing on earth in the holy place in the air/ youtube "THE CHURCH OF ALMIGHTY GOD 💐 this is the fulfillment of what He said to Peter 2,000 years ago, recorded in (Matthew 16:18'19). This is the the only Church of each one of our spirit that we must listen to or eat and drink like how we eat, dress and sleep every day so that He can guide us and change us by rejecting the evil attached by satan so as to be perfect, having attained eternal life that will enter the coming replacement of the New Heaven and New Earth. 💌
@@parnamsaini4751 Not listening carefully to what Mahbubani said, that's why have to ask "Really?" Observe also the Chinese leafers' actions and one will know the truth of what Mahbubani said.
Wisdom, all those so-called experts in US and the west can learn from this guy. China is playing chess masterfully! I'm so proud of China, go China !!!
@@sammygit9486it's supremacism and being one of the 5 eyes is also beholden to US hegemony. With all honesty the more West try to contain China the worse it becomes for their own countries
@@sammygit9486 Sycophancy towards the US (or maybe fear of the US)....as is the case with many countries....hopefully such self-defeating behavior will lessen over time, but I doubt it. The behavior of Australia is sheer stupidity. I hope this answers your query.
China respects USA and the West. China's confucius concept is common prosperity. Every country can easily find a market for their economy. As China rises up, China has become a big market for Europe, USA, Japan, the West and Aesan... China is helping the small countries to stand up on their own feet and these countries will be a good market for USA, the west as well. win-win for all. Let's go, multipolar, no wars.
The problem is that the US wants to be the Main power in the world and it does this by destroying other nations, also the West have made many enemies it won't be easy for other country to forget what they have done to them.
@dennisluk "China respects USA and the West. Ch..."Only if you call stealing from, insulting and threatening, respect. China has been a small market for Europe and northern Americas. The so-called big Chinese market never eventuated, CCP makes it hard for non chinese enterprises to fully access the Chinese markets and keeps it small anyway by keeping wages low. Most western countries use China as cheap producer, not as a market, evidenced by the balance of trade figures. This sugar-coated nonsense in your comment is pure CCP propaganda.
The Chinese doesn’t hope us will collapse, but hope us will acknowledge n accept a Chinese rise. Because China from history has never wanted to be a global power, even at the height of of history dynasties.
Of course, Chinese or China don't want to see any country in this world collapse. The richest they are the more prosperous China will be. Because China can sell all the products to all the countries been the manufacturing country if the world.
The us plays by a zero sum game. If china doesn play ball the usd dominance will cease to exist and usa will nt be able to function wit its current national debt.
Tell that to Americans, they will never believe it. American mindset, when you are strong you bully other, grab others land, wife and anything then burn and destroy anything that you cannot bring along
@ LivFeng Zhang. “The Chinese doesn’t hope u…”. Never wanted to be a global power ??? Don’t you listen to Winnie ? He openly says, and repeats, that world power is exactly what CCP wants ! Your ‘dynasties’ were as often as not foreign invaders who easily subjugated a timid population but were confined to northern Asia because of fear of being defeated outside that geography against hardier people.
I don't think China was thinking of the BRI to counter the US/West. China wants US and the West to join too. Many European nations joined too, like Germany, Italy, Britain and France as they can also contribute⁹ in infrastructure projects. But under US's pressure, these Europeans dropped out of BRI. The rationale is clear. By building up infrastructure in emerging economies, these economies will grow to expand trade and investment for ALL. It's not a strategy only serving China's interests but also for ALL.
Exactly, unlike the sanctions giant and its weaponization of everything, China is not interested in such short-term myopic thinking of debt trappings that impedes long-term prosperity. China is very much invested in the success of the BRI countries for trade and development because that is how it thrives in the long-term. Your success is their success, your failure is also their failure to diversify trade away from the dollar.
The USA, worried about losing its hegemony, seeks to ensure that Europe does not become friends with China. Sad that the European leaders are not thinking for themselves.
@@JinJiaLat-vl1oj How do you know he doesn't? Just asked him your question. If he doesn't reply, then he probably think your question is not worth answering and then you can conclude that he has no honest opinion about India.
@@JinJiaLat-vl1oj You have no honest opinion about Prof Kishore and India. Prof Kishore talks with numbers about China, such as the trade. Do you have different trade numbers about India?
Two major factors that prevented China from collapsing: 1) China took a more stepwise approach in adopting marking economy and privatizing state-owned entities; 2) China did not swallow the heavy pill called democracy in a gulp. Instead, it started with building up its economy and social stability first.
🍌THE GOSPEL OF THE WORD OF ALMIGHTY GOD "the last age in which God is saving man from the imminent destruction of this old world" (The transformation of a person's disposition is not a change of behavior, or a feigned external change or a temporary change produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a real transformation of disposition that brings about a change in behavior. The transformation of disposition means that you have understood and experienced the truth, and that truth has become your life. Now that your disposition has changed, you not only understand the truth, but you also act on it. You are able to let go of the things you felt like doing the other day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. This is a transformation of disposition, and it is also the process of transforming your disposition. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. Only after experiencing all this can a person partially understand his own nature. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. In this process, you will understand some things about yourself, and you will realize that you are very impure, harbor too many personal motives, and have too many desires while fulfilling your duties. Once you have understood the meaning of these things, you will be able to approach God in prayer and truly repent; in this way, you will be cleansed of impurities. The more one's corrupt disposition is refined, the more the disposition of their life will change.) Almighty God said The TRANSFORMATION of a PERSON'S DISPOSITION is NOT a CHANGE of BEHAVIOR, or a FELT EXTERNAL CHANGE or TEMPORARY DIFFERENCE produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a REAL CHANGE of DISPOSITION which CAUSES a CHANGE in BEHAVIOR. Such a change in behavior is not the same as changes manifested in a person's outward behaviors and actions. The TRANSFORMATION of the DISPOSITION MEANS that YOU have UNDERSTOOD and EXPERIENCED the TRUTH, and the TRUTH has BECOME YOUR LIFE.🌷 In the PAST, you UNDERSTOOD the TRUTH of this matter, BUT you did NOT put it into PRACTICE; the truth is only doctrine to you that is not practiced. NOW that your DISPOSITION has CHANGED, you not only UNDERSTAND the TRUTH, but you also ACT ACCORDING to IT. You are LETTING GO of the THINGS you LOVED to do back in the day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. 🙏🌷 You are now ABLE to GIVE UP THINGS that you COULDN'T GIVE UP back in the day. This is DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION, and it is also the PROCESS of your DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION.🌷 It may sound simple, but in REALITY, ANYONE in the MIDDLE of this PROCESS has to ENDURE a LOT of SUFFERING, OVERCOME their FLESH, and LEAVE the FLESH ASPECTS of NATURE. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. 🙏☀️ Only AFTER EXPERIENCING ALL of this can a person partially understand his own nature. HAVING a little UNDERSTANDING about it, however, does NOT mean IMMEDIATELY being able to CHANGE a PERSON; MAN must ENDURE SUFFERINGS in the PROCESS. 🙏 Also, can you immediately start practicing after gaining some understanding of something? You cannot immediately start a practice. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. Sometimes, people are not ready to go through it, saying, "Why can't I do it that way? Do I have to do it this way?" Others say, "If you believe in God, then you should do it this way is true." WHEN people REACH a CERTAIN POINT where they have gone through SEVERAL TRIALS and ENDED up UNDERSTANDING WITH GOD'S will and some TRUTH, then they will be HAPPY no matter what and ready to act ACCORDING to TRUE PRINCIPLES. In the beginning, people were reluctant to practice the truth. Take conscientious fulfillment of duties as an example: You have a little understanding of fulfilling duties and being faithful to God, and you also understand the related truths, but when will you fully devote yourself to God? When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. Some people may correct you, others may criticize you. All eyes will be on you, and only then will you begin to realize that you are in the wrong and that the truth is that you have done something bad, that the lack of devotion to fulfilling your duty is unacceptable, and you should not be rash and careless. The HOLY SPIRIT will ENLIGHTEN you FROM WITHIN, and rebuke you when you sin. IN this PROCESS, you will UNDERSTAND some THINGS ABOUT YOURSELF, and YOU will REALIZE that you are VERY IMPURE, HARBOR too MANY PERSONAL MOTIVES, and have too MANY DESIRES while FULFILLING your DUTIES. ONCE you have UNDERSTOOD the MEANING of these THINGS, you will be ABLE to APPROACH GOD in PRAYER and TRULY REPENT; in this WAY, you WILL be CLEANSED of IMPURITIES. ☀️🙏 If, in this way, you often seek the truth to solve your own practical problems, you will gradually tread the right path of faith. The MORE one's CORRUPT DISPOSITION is PURIFIED, the MORE the DISPOSITION of their LIFE will CHANGE. 🙏 From "Should Know About Changing a Person's Disposition" Fulfillment in (Ezekiel 2: 9-10) and in (Revelation 19: 9,13) 📥Calling and leading everyone to His lowered Kingdom or Church because it is still standing on earth in the holy place in the air/ youtube "THE CHURCH OF ALMIGHTY GOD 💐 this is the fulfillment of what He said to Peter 2,000 years ago, recorded in (Matthew 16:18'19). This is the the only Church of each one of our spirit that we must listen to or eat and drink like how we eat, dress and sleep every day so that He can guide us and change us by rejecting the evil attached by satan so as to be perfect, having attained eternal life that will enter the coming replacement of the New Heaven and New Earth. 💌
don't forget wars in laos, vietnam, cambodia, bangladesh, indonesia, afghanistan that the us was involved in.coup in iran and resentment against american influence in iran during shah. the us has created a lot of enemis in asia. asian nations prefer proxy wars in other parts of the world and are incentivized to keep the us outside asia. they do not want a new us crusade like the one in 60s and 70s. what will the us offer? eastern europe, haiti, mexico, central america, russia in the 90s. if you are not white germanic teutonic and/or protestant, the us is less likely to make you rich.
And yet, the U.S. is trying to push NATO into Asian waters by pulling in its proxies - South Korea and Japan - while using Japan to lead this NATO forces in the Indo-Pacific region.
Catholic Indian here_ very resentful of evangelising and bribing the vulnerable and the marginalised. Leave India to manage its country and not start any movement that fragments one of the real democratic countries.
Thank you for sharing your informative perspective insights regarding Motherland, China & Team Motherland, China All The Way And Beyond Forevermore!👍🙏🇨🇳🙂☮️🌏❗️
I COME , I SEE , HE DIED Who said this ? Hillary clinton She was referring to uS bombing Libya n killing of libya leader Gaddafi when she was uS sec of state
Every country must think alike to build up their own society's vibrancy and resilience. Blindly accepting every Western ideology is suicidal. Every society must uphold their good values in the pursuit of development.
@@reebud Well, actually ... US will topple down your government. Disguise it as a liberation act. Turn your country into a banana republic. While their puppets run your country to fish for them. US get the fish, you get democracy. While China, they'll lease you a fishing rod. So now you can fish, but not to feed yourself. You had to sell the fish somewhere else, to pay the enormous amount of debt for those fishing equipmens. It's like pick your poison. Do you prefer to get mauled by a tiger or a bear?
Good. There's so much to add though. * China can see Japan and the Asian Tigers as closer to home and more recent than the USSR. The Plaza Accords and the Asian Financial Crash might be even more relevant than the Soviet example. * The role of Gorbachev in the USSR collapse was crucial. They easily could have sent tanks into Eastern Germany at the beginning of the revolt to reassert control. Gorbachev chose not to. I support his decision but opinions vary.
I would partially disagree with the George Cannon segment. That spiritual vibrancy he talks about applies mostly to the elites of these countries, not their societies as a whole.
Actually, this isn't too different from what China's been doing for thousands of years. China has always focused on creating a wealthy, vibrant society that extends opportunity to all. 2,500 years ago, Meng Zi said that "the people do not exist for the sake of the sovereign; the sovereign exists for the sake of the people." Rulers lost their Mandate if they did not take care of the people. Anyone who passed the imperial exams could obtain a position as an official; scholar/bureaucrats, not aristocrats, ruled over China. So China built massive public works like the Grand Canal to boost commerce and enrich the people, thousands of years ago. Regarding Kishore's second point, China has always maintained close diplomatic and trading ties with its neighbors. Despite being the most powerful nation in the region, it did not colonize them. So China is now doing what it's been doing for eons.
Karna kalian barat selalu meremehkan Asean, padahal kawasan ini di jaman dulu yang membuat makmur Eropa. Tidak ada salju di Asean, buah-buahan tumbuh setiap saat, potensial gas dan minyak yang melimpah, kekayaan hasil laut, Geografi yang strategis. Kami hanya membutuhkan sedikit investasi di bidang teknologi, dan Boom !! Miracle ekonomi. China sudah sekaya itu dengan berdagang dengan Asean, China bahkan belum menyentuh Kawasan Afrika.
Similarities to the South African situation are applicable. most "African countries desire to see RSA damaged and disintegrating. Thus, their posture is belligerent and hostile. In the last 30 years the RSA government had the basis to build a dynamic economy going along with a dynamic society with the talent abundant in RSA and resources, the government dismally failed. Now it is going to be further downhill from here onwards for majority of native South Africans.
When the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, American society had been quite strong for several decades. Fast forward three decades and we find that American society is quite weak. The American people are suffering a long litany of domestic problems such as homelessness, gun violence, poor health care, poor education, crumbling infrastructure, opioid addiction, mass incarceration, growing poverty, political turmoil, crushing national debt, etc. Chinese society, on the other hand, is quite strong. The Chinese are very happy with their nation's progress and their nation's governance. Chinese society is relatively peaceful and harmonious, while American society is chaotic. America is facing potential collapse. I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if another American civil war broke out.
Let's brutally honest (and might be taken as racist) here. American society was powerful when they were run by white people. Today there are too many immigrants, wokeness, diversity, affirmative action, LGBT rights and what not poisoning their society. China society is strong because it's relatively homogenous and dominant over their fringe minorities like Uighur or Hui. Not to mention the iron fist of the communist party.
But none of us wants to be tied with anyone, be it usa, europe or china, we all want to be free and choose whoever we want to do business with, as long as it benefits everyone. As long as China respects other’s independence and idelas, we will all be okay. Hopefuly it stays that way.
@@shankerram6076Were you there to observe the incident or did you participated? If not, then how did you know what happened? Don't be an ostrich with head in the sand and butts up in the air😂😂
Mahbubani is off here. I don't believe the Chinese leadership has ever viewed the breakup of China like that of the USSR as a concern. The Hans in China are far more predominant than the Russians were in the USSR, or even now in the Russian Republic. The intrinsic value of a strong economy has always been obvious to the Chinese leadership. A great deal of China's strength today is rooted from the predominance of the Hans that has provided the glue and direction. Ethnic diversity is a liability that can best be managed sensibly, with tolerance, but not a strength.
Your's is typical of US Neo-Cons' thinking. Mahbubani lives all his life in a Chinese community, and knows how the Chinese leadership thinks. Pres. Xi of China had made a similar warning about what Prof Mahbubani said in this video, i.e. US interference in other countries' internal affairs, at the SCO Meeting in Astana City, Kazakhstan. The Chinese are aware of the challenges that the US poses to its perceived rivals. "There's nothing that the increasingly desperate US would not do to try to maintain her hegemonic position over the rest of World, even though human history has clearly shown that the lifespans of past empires, consistently last increasingly shorter, successively. But hey, desperadoes are very reliable accomplices of their hasten demise.
A Westerner who thinks he knows the Chinese mind! Try taking Xizang(Tibet), Hong Kong, Macau, Taiwan from China and you will face the full force of China's response. China knows full well what the West is trying to do, so pls don't BS.
I don't think he is off. The Chinese studied everything seriously. The Chinese knows very well never to assume anything or underestimate their enemies (be it other countries, political thoughts, social phenomena etc) ; they analyse and plan many steps ahead. The causes of the rise and fall of their various dynasties are still being studied. Han is only a general ethnic group, but social adhesion, common vision and national pride are built and managed. They do not happen by chance. Play the game of weiqi.
@@csking6377agree with you and I disagree with the idea of Han being a vital factor. Ethnicity has long been diluted by adoption of Mandarin as common language. Nobody gives a hoot whether you are a Manchu or Han or Yue. On the other hand, a singular political system, ie the Communist Party is the most important factor for the rise of China because the political leaders are focused on long-term development whereas in Western democracies, politicians are only concerned with their 4- or 5-year term. In US, it’s amazing how much time and money are wasted on Presidential nominations and debates even before the actual Presidential election! In fact, the CCP is a more efficient democracy than US or UK democracy. The rise of a Chinese leader is truly meritocracy whereas some western democracies, it’s a matter of who is better with TikTok 😂
Your right but your conclusion is wrong. Very wrong assesment. First where are the manufacturers of America? Just an example: what made is your iphone or ipad? Because i could not see any iphone made in America although its an american brand. So whose fault is that?
The first statement is right, the winner for contest is by internal strength. but the conclusion China found the way to survive is far from proven, look at current China's issues, realtor collapse, high unemployment, low birth rate, old age, which is very similiar to Japan in 90's, so it is fair to say China may learn the lesson of Soviet Union, but not from Japan. The very interesting point is Kishore used to praising China as next super power over US, but now he put weight on how China survived from contest with US. Obviously he noticed the latest change.
This guy has been pro China all the way. He revisits some geopolitical historic events and glorifies them to suit his pro China narrative but omits all the atrocities of the CCP including the very dangerous ambition of China's hunger for world dominance.
Theres an old Chinese saying. Wealth does not last beyond three generations” (富不过三代) Deng was the founder, the first generation. Jiang and Hu expanded it they’re the second generation. Xi is squandering everything his predecessors have built. Xi represents the third generation. If you don’t believe this just look at the 80 million unfinished homes in ghost towns all over China and the anguish of the defrauded. Thank you Xi!
Simply saying it's flawed doesnt mean it's flawed. And BRI is much better than funding wars and petty petrified sanctions that the US constantly employs against other nations.
No, unlike the sanctions giant and its weaponization of everything, China is not interested in such short-term, myopic thinking of debt trappings that impedes long-term prosperity. China is very much invested in the success of the BRI countries for trade and development because that is how it thrives long-term. Your success is their success, your failure is also their failure to diversify trade away from the dollar.
Not exsactly good explanation of Soviet dissintegration. Multinational states,where nations poses their own teritories are in a long term doomed to dissintegration. Look at the europe!! A bunch of small states wirt dozens of autonomous nations is now defragmentated beyond any coherence and will continou to do in future: scotts,cataloniens,basks,flams will eventually get their own states,no doubts. China must not allowe any separate tensions. But that goes along with suppresing such tensions. They must learn from Yugoslavia's destiny. 6 or 7 miningless states.
Professor should study more as he do not understand underlying reality of Index Funds Ownership of all corporations, socialism created by this funds in USA and that USA is a USSR and now on the brink of collapse.
The teaching of Confucius+ Toiast teaching will lead the Chinese to lead the way to many centuries to come. It has under went thousand of year of testing + modification.
Chinese proverb; if you plan for 1 year plant rice, if you plan for 10 years plant trees, if you plan for 100 years educate people
一年之计，莫如树谷；十年之计，莫如树木；百年之计，莫如树人
well said
And then you have the great leap backwards or the cultural devolution
Yeah, really old and ancient Chinese proverb, and China never used it until now. The developed countries already went past those 100 years. LKY also knew it lah. You think only the Chinese know it ah? Everybody can see what China is doing now.
Depends on what kind of trees, depends on what kind of education. If you plant useless trees or teach only self serving propaganda…
US and EU did not want free trade with ASEAN bcoz they did not want them to be rich. See how they oppressed Africa.
The majority of people living in ASEAN countries are quite well off, and this is not thanks US and EU.
@@peterk5981 “The majority of people…”. Au contraire, both the US and EU are on the other side of the world yet are, respectively, the 2nd and 3rd largest trading partners with ASEAN countries. The US runs a $200 bil deficit. Without those 2 blocs, South East Asian countries would be, not only considerably poorer, but subject to the whims of capricious CCP,
@@angusmckenzie9622wrong, without western country not holding gun to asean head to force sell raw resources with extremely cheap price, asean would have rise long ago. Btw asean countries had been colonize for centuries by western countries only around 1945 and up they had their countries back, and that is with neo colonisation.
@@intanpermata5115 "wrong, without western country not...How does what happed for a couple of hundred years and finished 80 years ago make current trade figures wrong ? If you make a victim of yourself, you'll aways be a victim.
@@intanpermata5115 If u have no weapons to defend yourself, then u can't blame ppl for colonising u... Resources are useless if there's no machine that uses them... Come on, without the invention of Engines, you think Saudi Arabia will be rich? They will have plenty of oil in the ground and no one will want to dig them up... we have to thank Europe for the Industrial Revolution...
Very good assessment. America is telling all its NATO allies and the EU not to trade with China as well.
But American goes to do the exact opposite, taking over its allies' market share of products that they sold to China... Who need enemies when you have "friends" like the US.
US is full of hate
🍌THE GOSPEL OF THE WORD OF ALMIGHTY GOD "the last age in which God is saving man from the imminent destruction of this old world"
(The transformation of a person's disposition is not a change of behavior, or a feigned external change or a temporary change produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a real transformation of disposition that brings about a change in behavior. The transformation of disposition means that you have understood and experienced the truth, and that truth has become your life. Now that your disposition has changed, you not only understand the truth, but you also act on it. You are able to let go of the things you felt like doing the other day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. This is a transformation of disposition, and it is also the process of transforming your disposition. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. Only after experiencing all this can a person partially understand his own nature. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. In this process, you will understand some things about yourself, and you will realize that you are very impure, harbor too many personal motives, and have too many desires while fulfilling your duties. Once you have understood the meaning of these things, you will be able to approach God in prayer and truly repent; in this way, you will be cleansed of impurities. The more one's corrupt disposition is refined, the more the disposition of their life will change.)
Almighty God said
The TRANSFORMATION of a PERSON'S DISPOSITION is NOT a CHANGE of BEHAVIOR, or a FELT EXTERNAL CHANGE or TEMPORARY DIFFERENCE produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a REAL CHANGE of DISPOSITION which CAUSES a CHANGE in BEHAVIOR. Such a change in behavior is not the same as changes manifested in a person's outward behaviors and actions. The TRANSFORMATION of the DISPOSITION MEANS that YOU have UNDERSTOOD and EXPERIENCED the TRUTH, and the TRUTH has BECOME YOUR LIFE.🌷
In the PAST, you UNDERSTOOD the TRUTH of this matter, BUT you did NOT put it into PRACTICE; the truth is only doctrine to you that is not practiced. NOW that your DISPOSITION has CHANGED, you not only UNDERSTAND the TRUTH, but you also ACT ACCORDING to IT. You are LETTING GO of the THINGS you LOVED to do back in the day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. 🙏🌷
You are now ABLE to GIVE UP THINGS that you COULDN'T GIVE UP back in the day. This is DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION, and it is also the PROCESS of your DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION.🌷
It may sound simple, but in REALITY, ANYONE in the MIDDLE of this PROCESS has to ENDURE a LOT of SUFFERING, OVERCOME their FLESH, and LEAVE the FLESH ASPECTS of NATURE. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. 🙏☀️
Only AFTER EXPERIENCING ALL of this can a person partially understand his own nature.
HAVING a little UNDERSTANDING about it, however, does NOT mean IMMEDIATELY being able to CHANGE a PERSON; MAN must ENDURE SUFFERINGS in the PROCESS. 🙏
Also, can you immediately start practicing after gaining some understanding of something? You cannot immediately start a practice. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. Sometimes, people are not ready to go through it, saying, "Why can't I do it that way? Do I have to do it this way?" Others say, "If you believe in God, then you should do it this way is true."
WHEN people REACH a CERTAIN POINT where they have gone through SEVERAL TRIALS and ENDED up UNDERSTANDING WITH GOD'S will and some TRUTH, then they will be HAPPY no matter what and ready to act ACCORDING to TRUE PRINCIPLES. In the beginning, people were reluctant to practice the truth. Take conscientious fulfillment of duties as an example: You have a little understanding of fulfilling duties and being faithful to God, and you also understand the related truths, but when will you fully devote yourself to God? When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. Some people may correct you, others may criticize you. All eyes will be on you, and only then will you begin to realize that you are in the wrong and that the truth is that you have done something bad, that the lack of devotion to fulfilling your duty is unacceptable, and you should not be rash and careless. The HOLY SPIRIT will ENLIGHTEN you FROM WITHIN, and rebuke you when you sin. IN this PROCESS, you will UNDERSTAND some THINGS ABOUT YOURSELF, and YOU will REALIZE that you are VERY IMPURE, HARBOR too MANY PERSONAL MOTIVES, and have too MANY DESIRES while FULFILLING your DUTIES. ONCE you have UNDERSTOOD the MEANING of these THINGS, you will be ABLE to APPROACH GOD in PRAYER and TRULY REPENT; in this WAY, you WILL be CLEANSED of IMPURITIES. ☀️🙏
If, in this way, you often seek the truth to solve your own practical problems, you will gradually tread the right path of faith. The MORE one's CORRUPT DISPOSITION is PURIFIED, the MORE the DISPOSITION of their LIFE will CHANGE. 🙏
From "Should Know About Changing a Person's Disposition"
Fulfillment in (Ezekiel 2: 9-10) and in (Revelation 19: 9,13)
📥Calling and leading everyone to His lowered Kingdom or Church because it is still standing on earth in the holy place in the air/ youtube "THE CHURCH OF ALMIGHTY GOD 💐 this is the fulfillment of what He said to Peter 2,000 years ago, recorded in (Matthew 16:18'19).
This is the the only Church of each one of our spirit that we must listen to or eat and drink like how we eat, dress and sleep every day so that He can guide us and change us by rejecting the evil attached by satan so as to be perfect,
having attained eternal life that will enter the coming replacement of the New Heaven and New Earth. 💌
Mahbubani shows us how brilliant the Chinese leadership is.
Really??
@@parnamsaini4751 Not listening carefully to what Mahbubani said, that's why have to ask "Really?" Observe also the Chinese leafers' actions and one will know the truth of what Mahbubani said.
Little pink
And how hubristic and stupid the US has been😄
@@bin.s.s. top of the world. How many Nobel prize winners do you have?
Wisdom, all those so-called experts in US and the west can learn from this guy. China is playing chess masterfully! I'm so proud of China, go China !!!
Kishore is a remarkable thinker of the best kind.
Proud of Indian
He has no honest opinion about India
Sadly those bright sparks in Canberra are doing just that; participating in a containment policy against its largest trading partner, China.
and Their politicians angry when China stop buying from their farmers... idiot and privilege mentality of Westerner
Then why act against your own self interest? Is it ego? Racial discrimination?
@@sammygit9486 Like with segregation in the US, the poor white people are pitted against another race, while they are robbed by the rich whites.
@@sammygit9486it's supremacism and being one of the 5 eyes is also beholden to US hegemony. With all honesty the more West try to contain China the worse it becomes for their own countries
@@sammygit9486 Sycophancy towards the US (or maybe fear of the US)....as is the case with many countries....hopefully such self-defeating behavior will lessen over time, but I doubt it. The behavior of Australia is sheer stupidity. I hope this answers your query.
This is called WISDOM FROM THE EAST 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
China respects USA and the West. China's confucius concept is common prosperity. Every country can easily find a market for their economy.
As China rises up, China has become a big market for Europe, USA, Japan, the West and Aesan...
China is helping the small countries to stand up on their own feet and these countries will be a good market for USA, the west as well.
win-win for all. Let's go, multipolar, no wars.
The problem is that the US wants to be the Main power in the world and it does this by destroying other nations, also the West have made many enemies it won't be easy for other country to forget what they have done to them.
@dennisluk "China respects USA and the West. Ch..."Only if you call stealing from, insulting and threatening, respect. China has been a small market for Europe and northern Americas. The so-called big Chinese market never eventuated, CCP makes it hard for non chinese enterprises to fully access the Chinese markets and keeps it small anyway by keeping wages low. Most western countries use China as cheap producer, not as a market, evidenced by the balance of trade figures. This sugar-coated nonsense in your comment is pure CCP propaganda.
kishore knew China more than anyoneelse.brilliant
But he doesn't know India, his ancestral homeland.
@@JinJiaLat-vl1oj He knows about India, unfortunately there nothing positive to talk about India.
First-rated analysis and informative, highly recommended.
The Chinese doesn’t hope us will collapse, but hope us will acknowledge n accept a Chinese rise. Because China from history has never wanted to be a global power, even at the height of of history dynasties.
Of course, Chinese or China don't want to see any country in this world collapse. The richest they are the more prosperous China will be. Because China can sell all the products to all the countries been the manufacturing country if the world.
The us plays by a zero sum game. If china doesn play ball the usd dominance will cease to exist and usa will nt be able to function wit its current national debt.
In other words China wants to be America's sidekick
Pathetic
Tell that to Americans, they will never believe it. American mindset, when you are strong you bully other, grab others land, wife and anything then burn and destroy anything that you cannot bring along
@ LivFeng Zhang. “The Chinese doesn’t hope u…”. Never wanted to be a global power ??? Don’t you listen to Winnie ? He openly says, and repeats, that world power is exactly what CCP wants ! Your ‘dynasties’ were as often as not foreign invaders who easily subjugated a timid population but were confined to northern Asia because of fear of being defeated outside that geography against hardier people.
I don't think China was thinking of the BRI to counter the US/West. China wants US and the West to join too. Many European nations joined too, like Germany, Italy, Britain and France as they can also contribute⁹ in infrastructure projects. But under US's pressure, these Europeans dropped out of BRI.
The rationale is clear. By building up infrastructure in emerging economies, these economies will grow to expand trade and investment for ALL. It's not a strategy only serving China's interests but also for ALL.
China is working on bringing the world together.
US is making sure the world is divided.
Exactly, unlike the sanctions giant and its weaponization of everything, China is not interested in such short-term myopic thinking of debt trappings that impedes long-term prosperity. China is very much invested in the success of the BRI countries for trade and development because that is how it thrives in the long-term. Your success is their success, your failure is also their failure to diversify trade away from the dollar.
The USA, worried about losing its hegemony, seeks to ensure that Europe does not become friends with China. Sad that the European leaders are not thinking for themselves.
Nevermind. It is their great lost in generations to come. Let Asia prosper and pauperise the West.
BRICS will not want a bad apple in their basket.
It is always a pleasure to hear from Prof Kishore. He is a great thinker and commuicator 🎉
He has no honest opinion about India
@@JinJiaLat-vl1oj How do you know he doesn't? Just asked him your question. If he doesn't reply, then he probably think your question is not worth answering and then you can conclude that he has no honest opinion about India.
@@JinJiaLat-vl1oj You have no honest opinion about Prof Kishore and India.
Prof Kishore talks with numbers about China, such as the trade. Do you have different trade numbers about India?
Two major factors that prevented China from collapsing: 1) China took a more stepwise approach in adopting marking economy and privatizing state-owned entities; 2) China did not swallow the heavy pill called democracy in a gulp. Instead, it started with building up its economy and social stability first.
🍌THE GOSPEL OF THE WORD OF ALMIGHTY GOD "the last age in which God is saving man from the imminent destruction of this old world"
(The transformation of a person's disposition is not a change of behavior, or a feigned external change or a temporary change produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a real transformation of disposition that brings about a change in behavior. The transformation of disposition means that you have understood and experienced the truth, and that truth has become your life. Now that your disposition has changed, you not only understand the truth, but you also act on it. You are able to let go of the things you felt like doing the other day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. This is a transformation of disposition, and it is also the process of transforming your disposition. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. Only after experiencing all this can a person partially understand his own nature. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. In this process, you will understand some things about yourself, and you will realize that you are very impure, harbor too many personal motives, and have too many desires while fulfilling your duties. Once you have understood the meaning of these things, you will be able to approach God in prayer and truly repent; in this way, you will be cleansed of impurities. The more one's corrupt disposition is refined, the more the disposition of their life will change.)
Almighty God said
The TRANSFORMATION of a PERSON'S DISPOSITION is NOT a CHANGE of BEHAVIOR, or a FELT EXTERNAL CHANGE or TEMPORARY DIFFERENCE produced by enthusiasm; rather, it is a REAL CHANGE of DISPOSITION which CAUSES a CHANGE in BEHAVIOR. Such a change in behavior is not the same as changes manifested in a person's outward behaviors and actions. The TRANSFORMATION of the DISPOSITION MEANS that YOU have UNDERSTOOD and EXPERIENCED the TRUTH, and the TRUTH has BECOME YOUR LIFE.🌷
In the PAST, you UNDERSTOOD the TRUTH of this matter, BUT you did NOT put it into PRACTICE; the truth is only doctrine to you that is not practiced. NOW that your DISPOSITION has CHANGED, you not only UNDERSTAND the TRUTH, but you also ACT ACCORDING to IT. You are LETTING GO of the THINGS you LOVED to do back in the day, the things you used to want to do, your mental images, and your perceptions. 🙏🌷
You are now ABLE to GIVE UP THINGS that you COULDN'T GIVE UP back in the day. This is DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION, and it is also the PROCESS of your DISPOSITION TRANSFORMATION.🌷
It may sound simple, but in REALITY, ANYONE in the MIDDLE of this PROCESS has to ENDURE a LOT of SUFFERING, OVERCOME their FLESH, and LEAVE the FLESH ASPECTS of NATURE. Such a person must also experience correction and chastisement, chastisement and judgment, and trials and refinement. 🙏☀️
Only AFTER EXPERIENCING ALL of this can a person partially understand his own nature.
HAVING a little UNDERSTANDING about it, however, does NOT mean IMMEDIATELY being able to CHANGE a PERSON; MAN must ENDURE SUFFERINGS in the PROCESS. 🙏
Also, can you immediately start practicing after gaining some understanding of something? You cannot immediately start a practice. Although you have understanding, others cut you off and correct you and then force you and force you to act according to true principles. Sometimes, people are not ready to go through it, saying, "Why can't I do it that way? Do I have to do it this way?" Others say, "If you believe in God, then you should do it this way is true."
WHEN people REACH a CERTAIN POINT where they have gone through SEVERAL TRIALS and ENDED up UNDERSTANDING WITH GOD'S will and some TRUTH, then they will be HAPPY no matter what and ready to act ACCORDING to TRUE PRINCIPLES. In the beginning, people were reluctant to practice the truth. Take conscientious fulfillment of duties as an example: You have a little understanding of fulfilling duties and being faithful to God, and you also understand the related truths, but when will you fully devote yourself to God? When will you be able to fulfill your duties in name and deed? This will require a process. In this process, you may suffer a lot. Some people may correct you, others may criticize you. All eyes will be on you, and only then will you begin to realize that you are in the wrong and that the truth is that you have done something bad, that the lack of devotion to fulfilling your duty is unacceptable, and you should not be rash and careless. The HOLY SPIRIT will ENLIGHTEN you FROM WITHIN, and rebuke you when you sin. IN this PROCESS, you will UNDERSTAND some THINGS ABOUT YOURSELF, and YOU will REALIZE that you are VERY IMPURE, HARBOR too MANY PERSONAL MOTIVES, and have too MANY DESIRES while FULFILLING your DUTIES. ONCE you have UNDERSTOOD the MEANING of these THINGS, you will be ABLE to APPROACH GOD in PRAYER and TRULY REPENT; in this WAY, you WILL be CLEANSED of IMPURITIES. ☀️🙏
If, in this way, you often seek the truth to solve your own practical problems, you will gradually tread the right path of faith. The MORE one's CORRUPT DISPOSITION is PURIFIED, the MORE the DISPOSITION of their LIFE will CHANGE. 🙏
From "Should Know About Changing a Person's Disposition"
Fulfillment in (Ezekiel 2: 9-10) and in (Revelation 19: 9,13)
📥Calling and leading everyone to His lowered Kingdom or Church because it is still standing on earth in the holy place in the air/ youtube "THE CHURCH OF ALMIGHTY GOD 💐 this is the fulfillment of what He said to Peter 2,000 years ago, recorded in (Matthew 16:18'19).
This is the the only Church of each one of our spirit that we must listen to or eat and drink like how we eat, dress and sleep every day so that He can guide us and change us by rejecting the evil attached by satan so as to be perfect,
having attained eternal life that will enter the coming replacement of the New Heaven and New Earth. 💌
Still want to dominate South China Sea?
@@parnamsaini4751 Yeah as well as the side of the moon that is always dark
@@parnamsaini4751 South China Sea was traditionally theirs.
Brother, You assessment was on point! Love it!👌👌
China is great.
Really?
@@parnamsaini4751 Really, not perfect but great.
🇨🇳👍🏼✊🏻💪
From : Singapore 🇸🇬❤️💞🇨🇳
@@parnamsaini4751 Yes, has been for 5000 years.
@@Way827 their dams are tearing away, No?
don't forget wars in laos, vietnam, cambodia, bangladesh, indonesia, afghanistan that the us was involved in.coup in iran and resentment against american influence in iran during shah. the us has created a lot of enemis in asia. asian nations prefer proxy wars in other parts of the world and are incentivized to keep the us outside asia. they do not want a new us crusade like the one in 60s and 70s.
what will the us offer? eastern europe, haiti, mexico, central america, russia in the 90s. if you are not white germanic teutonic and/or protestant, the us is less likely to make you rich.
And yet, the U.S. is trying to push NATO into Asian waters by pulling in its proxies - South Korea and Japan - while using Japan to lead this NATO forces in the Indo-Pacific region.
Catholic Indian here_ very resentful of evangelising and bribing the vulnerable and the marginalised. Leave India to manage its country and not start any movement that fragments one of the real democratic countries.
Stop tiring liberal left narratives.
A very beautiful and insightful speech indeed.
on point
In the West profit for the one implies a loss for the other(s). In the East profit for the one is only possible with profit for the other(s).
The U.S. only sees a win-lose situation. Its mentality says there’s no such thing as win-win.
Thank you for sharing your informative perspective insights regarding Motherland, China & Team Motherland, China All The Way And Beyond Forevermore!👍🙏🇨🇳🙂☮️🌏❗️
US follow western philosophy of i come, i see, i conquer while chinese philosophy is equal prosperity.
I COME , I SEE , HE DIED
Who said this ? Hillary clinton She was referring to uS bombing Libya n killing of libya leader Gaddafi when she was uS sec of state
No one can explain the relation between the two powers as good as Mr Kishore............
Great analysis!👍🏻
I never knew China - Asean agreement was the biggest trade agreement in the world just 2 years ago. Wow.
Every country must think alike to build up their own society's vibrancy and resilience.
Blindly accepting every Western ideology is suicidal.
Every society must uphold their good values in the pursuit of development.
Brains over Braun wins every time 😂
Indonesian people definitely not going to become pro US, we prefer China and Rusia...
Nah. Indonesia is non-aligned
@@binsarpanjaitan9777
Outwardly non-aligned
Excellent 👍
Truly a powerful and profound thinker, this Prof Mahbubani ... 👍
But he has no honest knowledge about India.
Professor is a brilliant diplomat and scholar.
He has no honest opinion about India
I agree
Tell that to America😊
Kishore is divulging too much of China's strength. Kishore should divulge more of the US weaknesses.
Don't you think that US doesn't know about China's strategy?? US is too proud to admit that China's way is the best alternative to Western style
No...the US power is over estimated
Brilliant as always. I learn english and geopolitics with Mr. Mahbubani. Thanks from Uruguay ❤
us gives a fish; china teaches u how to fish
err... not really, US gives fish with a hook inside it.
@@reebud
Well, actually ...
US will topple down your government. Disguise it as a liberation act. Turn your country into a banana republic. While their puppets run your country to fish for them. US get the fish, you get democracy.
While China, they'll lease you a fishing rod. So now you can fish, but not to feed yourself. You had to sell the fish somewhere else, to pay the enormous amount of debt for those fishing equipmens.
It's like pick your poison. Do you prefer to get mauled by a tiger or a bear?
@@reebud Very well said 👍🏼
Very astute points!
Its not too difficult to snooker Joe Biden !
He should retire and live happily with his grand children in tow. Why get involved in fights and war at this age?
...nevermind...
all American presidents isi merely a puppet of greedy invincible force that wanted to dominate the world.
brilliant!
Good. There's so much to add though.
* China can see Japan and the Asian Tigers as closer to home and more recent than the USSR. The Plaza Accords and the Asian Financial Crash might be even more relevant than the Soviet example.
* The role of Gorbachev in the USSR collapse was crucial. They easily could have sent tanks into Eastern Germany at the beginning of the revolt to reassert control. Gorbachev chose not to. I support his decision but opinions vary.
Mahubani is a brilliant analyst !!
Love your topics so much insights
I would partially disagree with the George Cannon segment. That spiritual vibrancy he talks about applies mostly to the elites of these countries, not their societies as a whole.
✨✨
except for crazy Australia which when down the containment policy to its own detrement
Believable...
Actually, this isn't too different from what China's been doing for thousands of years. China has always focused on creating a wealthy, vibrant society that extends opportunity to all. 2,500 years ago, Meng Zi said that "the people do not exist for the sake of the sovereign; the sovereign exists for the sake of the people." Rulers lost their Mandate if they did not take care of the people. Anyone who passed the imperial exams could obtain a position as an official; scholar/bureaucrats, not aristocrats, ruled over China. So China built massive public works like the Grand Canal to boost commerce and enrich the people, thousands of years ago. Regarding Kishore's second point, China has always maintained close diplomatic and trading ties with its neighbors. Despite being the most powerful nation in the region, it did not colonize them. So China is now doing what it's been doing for eons.
❤Kishore❤
LKY : little-India is the future, where the future will never arrive
Karna kalian barat selalu meremehkan Asean, padahal kawasan ini di jaman dulu yang membuat makmur Eropa.
Tidak ada salju di Asean, buah-buahan tumbuh setiap saat, potensial gas dan minyak yang melimpah, kekayaan hasil laut, Geografi yang strategis.
Kami hanya membutuhkan sedikit investasi di bidang teknologi, dan Boom !! Miracle ekonomi.
China sudah sekaya itu dengan berdagang dengan Asean, China bahkan belum menyentuh Kawasan Afrika.
RFK Jr will lead the US to catch up with China on competent gov’t.
Meanwhile in the Philippines
Very true. All lies. Nobody trusts china.
The stake is probably stashed in a vault somewhere in US.
Someone wants his mother's 600 pairs of shoes back.
Still building more brothels, millions more fatherless kids, more maids, millions more eating pagpag, etc.....
@@jace1113😂😂😂😂
Similarities to the South African situation are applicable. most "African
countries desire to see RSA damaged and disintegrating. Thus, their posture is belligerent and hostile. In the last 30 years the RSA government had the basis to build a dynamic economy going along with a dynamic society with the talent abundant in RSA and resources, the government dismally failed. Now it is going to be further downhill from here onwards for majority of native South Africans.
When the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, American society had been quite strong for several decades.
Fast forward three decades and we find that American society is quite weak. The American people are suffering a long litany of domestic problems such as homelessness, gun violence, poor health care, poor education, crumbling infrastructure, opioid addiction, mass incarceration, growing poverty, political turmoil, crushing national debt, etc.
Chinese society, on the other hand, is quite strong. The Chinese are very happy with their nation's progress and their nation's governance. Chinese society is relatively peaceful and harmonious, while American society is chaotic.
America is facing potential collapse. I wouldn't be the least bit surprised if another American civil war broke out.
Let's brutally honest (and might be taken as racist) here. American society was powerful when they were run by white people. Today there are too many immigrants, wokeness, diversity, affirmative action, LGBT rights and what not poisoning their society. China society is strong because it's relatively homogenous and dominant over their fringe minorities like Uighur or Hui. Not to mention the iron fist of the communist party.
Time will tell, but the west is in sharp decline: Europe and the USA. NATO's mad behaviour is a real sign of how desperate the west is.
The bald eagle from Newzealand would not agree I am a American political junkie .
But none of us wants to be tied with anyone, be it usa, europe or china, we all want to be free and choose whoever we want to do business with, as long as it benefits everyone. As long as China respects other’s independence and idelas, we will all be okay. Hopefuly it stays that way.
China adheres to:
Mutual non-interference in each other’s internal affairs
Equality and mutual benefit through trade and peaceful co-existence.
@@gingermintrose That is how they killed Indian soldiers for no reason and got a bloody nose.
@@shankerram6076Were you there to observe the incident or did you participated?
If not, then how did you know what happened?
Don't be an ostrich with head in the sand and butts up in the air😂😂
@@gingermintrose It is also a money lender, No?
@@stevenliew2507 Sam Ting Wong
Highly debatable point.
What is highly debatable? You understand China matters better than Prof Kishore?
Mahbubani is off here.
I don't believe the Chinese leadership has ever viewed the breakup of China like that of the USSR as a concern. The Hans in China are far more predominant than the Russians were in the USSR, or even now in the Russian Republic.
The intrinsic value of a strong economy has always been obvious to the Chinese leadership.
A great deal of China's strength today is rooted from the predominance of the Hans that has provided the glue and direction. Ethnic diversity is a liability that can best be managed sensibly, with tolerance, but not a strength.
Your's is typical of US Neo-Cons' thinking. Mahbubani lives all his life in a Chinese community, and knows how the Chinese leadership thinks. Pres. Xi of China had made a similar warning about what Prof Mahbubani said in this video, i.e. US interference in other countries' internal affairs, at the SCO Meeting in Astana City, Kazakhstan. The Chinese are aware of the challenges that the US poses to its perceived rivals. "There's nothing that the increasingly desperate US would not do to try to maintain her hegemonic position over the rest of World, even though human history has clearly shown that the lifespans of past empires, consistently last increasingly shorter, successively. But hey, desperadoes are very reliable accomplices of their hasten demise.
There are always the danger of some charismatic fools being bought off by the U.S who starts some sort of breakaway plan, i.e Hong Kong and Taiwan.
A Westerner who thinks he knows the Chinese mind! Try taking Xizang(Tibet), Hong Kong, Macau, Taiwan from China and you will face the full force of China's response. China knows full well what the West is trying to do, so pls don't BS.
I don't think he is off. The Chinese studied everything seriously. The Chinese knows very well never to assume anything or underestimate their enemies (be it other countries, political thoughts, social phenomena etc) ; they analyse and plan many steps ahead. The causes of the rise and fall of their various dynasties are still being studied.
Han is only a general ethnic group, but social adhesion, common vision and national pride are built and managed. They do not happen by chance.
Play the game of weiqi.
@@csking6377agree with you and I disagree with the idea of Han being a vital factor. Ethnicity has long been diluted by adoption of Mandarin as common language. Nobody gives a hoot whether you are a Manchu or Han or Yue. On the other hand, a singular political system, ie the Communist Party is the most important factor for the rise of China because the political leaders are focused on long-term development whereas in Western democracies, politicians are only concerned with their 4- or 5-year term. In US, it’s amazing how much time and money are wasted on Presidential nominations and debates even before the actual Presidential election!
In fact, the CCP is a more efficient democracy than US or UK democracy. The rise of a Chinese leader is truly meritocracy whereas some western democracies, it’s a matter of who is better with TikTok 😂
Your right but your conclusion is wrong. Very wrong assesment.
First where are the manufacturers of America?
Just an example:
what made is your iphone or ipad?
Because i could not see any iphone made in America although its an american brand.
So whose fault is that?
The first statement is right, the winner for contest is by internal strength. but the conclusion China found the way to survive is far from proven, look at current China's issues, realtor collapse, high unemployment, low birth rate, old age, which is very similiar to Japan in 90's, so it is fair to say China may learn the lesson of Soviet Union, but not from Japan.
The very interesting point is Kishore used to praising China as next super power over US, but now he put weight on how China survived from contest with US. Obviously he noticed the latest change.
This guy has been pro China all the way. He revisits some geopolitical historic events and glorifies them to suit his pro China narrative but omits all the atrocities of the CCP including the very dangerous ambition of China's hunger for world dominance.
Not everything is true
Theres an old Chinese saying. Wealth does not last beyond three generations” (富不过三代)
Deng was the founder, the first generation. Jiang and Hu expanded it they’re the second generation. Xi is squandering everything his predecessors have built. Xi represents the third generation. If you don’t believe this just look at the 80 million unfinished homes in ghost towns all over China and the anguish of the defrauded. Thank you Xi!
I wanted to write something but I am not.
He also does not point out the inherent flaws of BRI { including containment } that smaller economies are recognizing right now
Pls elaborate.
Simply saying it's flawed doesnt mean it's flawed. And BRI is much better than funding wars and petty petrified sanctions that the US constantly employs against other nations.
@@adamiskandar5107 Yes!
No, unlike the sanctions giant and its weaponization of everything, China is not interested in such short-term, myopic thinking of debt trappings that impedes long-term prosperity. China is very much invested in the success of the BRI countries for trade and development because that is how it thrives long-term. Your success is their success, your failure is also their failure to diversify trade away from the dollar.
@@adamiskandar5107 What happened in Hamppanttota? Do you even know where it is?
Not exsactly good explanation of Soviet dissintegration.
Multinational states,where nations poses their own teritories are in a long term doomed to dissintegration. Look at the europe!! A bunch of small states wirt dozens of autonomous nations is now defragmentated beyond any coherence and will continou to do in future: scotts,cataloniens,basks,flams will eventually get their own states,no doubts.
China must not allowe any separate tensions. But that goes along with suppresing such tensions.
They must learn from Yugoslavia's destiny.
6 or 7 miningless states.
Absolute rubbish.
Professor should study more as he do not understand underlying reality of Index Funds Ownership of all corporations, socialism created by this funds in USA and that USA is a USSR and now on the brink of collapse.
So many Chyna glues
I just want to forget what I though, because of the bullshiter.
This guy has no honest opinion about India
china is very good at laughing others misfortune
He is a Chinese agent
@@YtMgk-hv6op earning renmibi?
A typical sino wahabi @mahboobani, unfortunately kishore
Guys, he doesn't have any clue at all.
Revolting little man.
Incredible wisdom snd soarkling language!!!!
The teaching of Confucius+ Toiast teaching will lead the Chinese to lead the way to many centuries to come. It has under went thousand of year of testing + modification.
where is the orig. video om youtube?