Great looking cards! The tough grading is a bummer. I've had similar results in the past and have shifted all my vintage grading to SGC as a result. Thanks for another great video!
I've definitely considered it , although I've had similar experiences with SGC so sometimes just have to ride out the storm. Either way , grades weren't awful at the end of the day
Just based on what you showed, and your thoughts, I have to agree that this lot was very inconsistent with the grades. Also the turnaround time is brutal. IMO, maybe that's why some of us are now choosing SGC for vintage baseball, because of their consistency and short turnaround time. That Aaron card is stunning, would look sharp in a SGC slab. As for the Anderson, puzzling is all that comes to my mind. Thanks for sharing.
Great cards! My favorite was the Pee Wee Reese card. In my opinion the grades are inconsistent, it depends on how the inspector is feeling that day. The grading companies should make available the inspection reports. They only need to upload a PDF file.
Oh man those are some amazing cards. I’m more of a SGC guy, I would definitely send it to them. PSA grading can at times be inconsistent. Crack that sparky case lol.
CONGRATULATIONS my man , you were the winner for this videos giveaway. Thanks for the comment make sure to email me Ballparkmemoriesinfo@gmail.com to claim the 1954 Topps Duke Snider !
Love the Paul Waner. The turn around time for PSA is still insane and the somewhat inconsistent grading is why I don’t think I’ll be sending my cards to PSA anytime soon. Solid video though, always enjoy the grading reveals.
The Worldwide Gum Goudeys are more rare? I have a 1935 SGC Frank Frisch Wheaties frame....and 5 others as well. Love your ‘51 Slaughter. The Sparky Anderson does look better than a “3”, but still desirable to someone. Send the Aaron to SGC. It will look great in a tuxedo.
Tough grading by PSA on these cards. The Sparky card looks pretty solid, no way a 3 imo. I would send that 54 Aaron in to SGC , would like pretty awesome in the tuxedo.
Great reveal. Have no ideas with how PSA grades anymore. Really. Just don't make sense. They say eýe appeal. A 7 o/c and a 4 with great colors etc.. I can't handle their inconsistencies. I get tired of spending my money on less value cards getting the premium grades and an occasional high grade on the more valuable cards.
It's always tough to guess ! More-so with higher grades which is why I try to stick to lower end. Also why I never guarantee anything will be higher than a 4 before I see it in a slab lol
![I.N "HALLUCINATION" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/n5B5q1Hwt_U/mqdefault.jpg)
Those 59's are sharp looking cards..😮 The Aaron RC has sweet eye appeal color/centering and registration..😍 Love it..😊 Take care..👍💕🔥👊
Thank you !! take care !
Great looking cards! The tough grading is a bummer. I've had similar results in the past and have shifted all my vintage grading to SGC as a result. Thanks for another great video!
I've definitely considered it , although I've had similar experiences with SGC so sometimes just have to ride out the storm. Either way , grades weren't awful at the end of the day
Great looking cards, PSA took forever. Thanks for sharing
Love all the vintage. That Sparky is really nice.
Thanks for the reveal, favorite is the Aaron, then the Ruth. All nice returns!
Thanks for the comment !
Just based on what you showed, and your thoughts, I have to agree that this lot was very inconsistent with the grades. Also the turnaround time is brutal. IMO, maybe that's why some of us are now choosing SGC for vintage baseball, because of their consistency and short turnaround time. That Aaron card is stunning, would look sharp in a SGC slab. As for the Anderson, puzzling is all that comes to my mind. Thanks for sharing.
Great cards! My favorite was the Pee Wee Reese card. In my opinion the grades are inconsistent, it depends on how the inspector is feeling that day. The grading companies should make available the inspection reports. They only need to upload a PDF file.
That would definitely be helpful ! You should work for PSA lol
Awesome to see all of the Cardinals cards, and Bob Feller
Can't go wrong with the birds !
Welcome back we want vintage thanks again
Thanks for watching and commenting brother !
Garrett u have some awesome cards. Great show 👏
Great video, Love the Hank Aaron.
Thank you !! Can't wait to get him back soon again from PSA
Oh man those are some amazing cards. I’m more of a SGC guy, I would definitely send it to them. PSA grading can at times be inconsistent. Crack that sparky case lol.
Love the 53 feller. PSA is sooooo inconsistent!
Agreed ! That's why I typically stick to lower end cards , much easier to predict a card will get between a 2-3 than predicting what will be a 6-7
Those Big and Little Poison Goudeys are 🔥🔥
CONGRATULATIONS my man , you were the winner for this videos giveaway. Thanks for the comment
make sure to email me Ballparkmemoriesinfo@gmail.com to claim the 1954 Topps Duke Snider !
Nice bump on the Babe. Stan was nice. 3 on Sparky was bad. A 6 if Curt was a 7. Aaron would look good in a Tux.
Inconsistent for sure , definitely disappointing, but either way some great cards
@@ballparkmemories Yes all GREAT cards!
Loved the reveal! Great cards!
Glad you enjoyed ! Thanks for watching !!
I'm a little late but I don't think PSA will ever slab a TRIMMED card. SGC might though. Love the video. Cheers!
The 68 Kaline woulda been nice.... oh well. Good Video, Thanks.
Love the Paul Waner. The turn around time for PSA is still insane and the somewhat inconsistent grading is why I don’t think I’ll be sending my cards to PSA anytime soon. Solid video though, always enjoy the grading reveals.
For sure ! I've had much better experiences at the $40 level , but the bulk is basically unusable at the moment
Welcome back.
The Worldwide Gum Goudeys are more rare? I have a 1935 SGC Frank Frisch Wheaties frame....and 5 others as well. Love your ‘51 Slaughter. The Sparky Anderson does look better than a “3”, but still desirable to someone. Send the Aaron to SGC. It will look great in a tuxedo.
WAY more rare ! I had a video on this titled "the ONLY undervalued sports cards" where I talked about them somewhat in depth
@@ballparkmemories, I’ll have to look for that one. I think I have watched it, but maybe I need to watch it again. Thanks for all the content.
Nice cards. Might send Sparky to SGC. Much faster return. Edwin Duke Snider is my guy.
Good call!
Tough grading by PSA on these cards. The Sparky card looks pretty solid, no way a 3 imo. I would send that 54 Aaron in to SGC , would like pretty awesome in the tuxedo.
A 6 month wait from PSA? That's insane. I get all my SGC graded cards back in 2-3 weeks. As a collector, I much prefer the look of the SGC slabs also.
Those are all phenomenal cards, regardless of the grade! Especially the old Goudeys!
😮
Nice return! I would send the Aaron to SGC.
Well done 🎉
Those last grades were all over the place. Yikes. Some nice cards in there for sure.
Sometimes the way it goes unfortunately. Still good order overall
Nice cards. Tough grader that day but at least the Ruth got the 1.
Tough sometimes but the way she goes
Sweet stuff man!
Thanks !!
Awesome cards!
Thank you !!!
Nice cards 👍
Thank you !
great stuff!
Thank you !!
I would definitely send the hank Aaron into SGC They tend to have card meat sizes.
Better than PSA.
Wow i won the Kaline. Thanks
email me at Ballparkmemoriesinfo@gmail.com to claim him !!
amazing videos man
Thanks Tyler !! I appreciate it
i find that any card that i feel is way undergraded usally has a surface problem under magnification that we cant see with the naked eye
Take the Sparky out of the slab and sell it raw. Definitely give the Aaron rookie another shot.
Aaron I just sent back to PSA , crossing my fingers this time
Great reveal. Have no ideas with how PSA grades anymore. Really. Just don't make sense. They say eýe appeal. A 7 o/c and a 4 with great colors etc.. I can't handle their inconsistencies. I get tired of spending my money on less value cards getting the premium grades and an occasional high grade on the more valuable cards.
It's always tough to guess ! More-so with higher grades which is why I try to stick to lower end.
Also why I never guarantee anything will be higher than a 4 before I see it in a slab lol
Sparky looks alot better than a 3.
Looks like some classic PSA pop control on a lot of these cards. Unfortunate.
you think off center is that big of deal? nope. but hey you thought it was.
SGC every day all Day,psa doesn't know how to grade!!