So when I opened my box she was the first foil I got & I’ve already built a deck for her I call it Gretta’s Grocery list. She’s so strong as a food/token commander
I think there is a better order for the Academy Manufacturer example. Their example : Food > treaser+clue > food > 4 Squirrels But if Peregrin goes first: Food > food > 2 treasers+clues > 6 Squirrels Does that sound right?
5:29 Are you sure that’s how that works? I thought because they were all replacement effects they’d all essentially replace the original effect to create a token, a food, a squirrel, and then a food clue and treasure. I think it all happens at the same time but I’m also no judge.
all my gretta deck does is summon creatures that give you food tokens and sac those tokens to ping everyone, tho culling ritual might be a great surprise aoe mass nuke since i have so many on death triggers... i need another drivnod, carnage dominus
Wait im so confused on the confectioner/took combo. First of, wouldn't you only draw one card when you sac the 3 foods and not 3 since thats what he says. And secondly since Took's text says when you create one OR more, you would only create one food token when you creat multiple rats at once since you also sac the 3 foods at the same time. Or does it see the 3 sacrificed foods as 3 individual triggers for the rats? If so, then yeah it's an infinite.
I think because of this: cinfectioner says when you sac a food create a rat. You sac 3 foods to took, so cinfectioner will trigger 3 seperate times creating 3 seperate rats.
wont gyome be better as a commander though? he generates foods per turn if creatures enter the battlefield, also gives indestructible for the cost of 1 mana and a food, not to mention he can tap creatures
Hey Caleb. Sorry but I can't put your voice with your face. You look like an off brand Brian Kibler or Kyle Hill. All jokes aside, great content, hope your channel is successful and I hope you have a great day!
Not a 100% sure but I would think Academy Manufactor would replace Peregrin Took's replacement. Meaning you create the initial food and manufacturer splits that into the 3. Took sees that you're making 1 or more tokens and adds a food to it. Manufacturer sees the new food and splits it into the 3 types. Meanwhile chatterfang is over in the corner seeing all this birthing squirrels trying to keep up. Maybe I'm wrong though. Maybe manufacturer doesn't replace took's replacement idk. Rules lawyers out there let me know please
![VICTOR Denmark Open 2024 | An Se Young (KOR) [1] vs. Gregoria Mariska Tunjung (INA) [5] | SF](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Y3QEyCih85s/mqdefault.jpg)
So when I opened my box she was the first foil I got & I’ve already built a deck for her I call it Gretta’s Grocery list. She’s so strong as a food/token commander
The best part is adding counters to Marionette Master… just keeps adding to the power and doing more damage. Great finisher in the deck.
100%
Thanks for making such a specific commander video.
This deck is "Sweet"! Definitely something I can sink my teeth into.
Ohhh you😂
😂
What's the purpose of Root Maze in the deck list?
Thank you I’ve been wanting a Greta deck
She’s super fun!
I just build a Gretta Deck. I leaned a bit more into the food as well as removal/graveyard fun. Also more landramp over mana/dork ramp.
I think there is a better order for the Academy Manufacturer example. Their example :
Food > treaser+clue > food > 4 Squirrels
But if Peregrin goes first:
Food > food > 2 treasers+clues > 6 Squirrels
Does that sound right?
I do agree with you. Your scenario is the best out of the 3.
5:29 Are you sure that’s how that works? I thought because they were all replacement effects they’d all essentially replace the original effect to create a token, a food, a squirrel, and then a food clue and treasure. I think it all happens at the same time but I’m also no judge.
Abilities can't happen at the exact same time. So you have to pick an order. And they recheck the current state each time.
Great video!
I tried this deck. I needed culling ritual. Drew a bunch of cards got the ritual and got 86 mana. I won that game
That’s awesome!
all my gretta deck does is summon creatures that give you food tokens and sac those tokens to ping everyone, tho culling ritual might be a great surprise aoe mass nuke since i have so many on death triggers... i need another drivnod, carnage dominus
How? How could u possibly crank this out?!?!
---Your newest Janklord
We are always brewing 🤣
Have you ever made a Thromok deck? Personally it’s my favorite Timmy deck.
Interested in how you would spin it
Wait im so confused on the confectioner/took combo.
First of, wouldn't you only draw one card when you sac the 3 foods and not 3 since thats what he says.
And secondly since Took's text says when you create one OR more, you would only create one food token when you creat multiple rats at once since you also sac the 3 foods at the same time.
Or does it see the 3 sacrificed foods as 3 individual triggers for the rats? If so, then yeah it's an infinite.
I think because of this: cinfectioner says when you sac a food create a rat. You sac 3 foods to took, so cinfectioner will trigger 3 seperate times creating 3 seperate rats.
@@Rayan01012yes sir. It’s three separate triggers because it doesn’t say when you sac one or more so you’d get multiple tokens on multiple triggers.
@@Rayan01012Alright, thanks !
wont gyome be better as a commander though? he generates foods per turn if creatures enter the battlefield, also gives indestructible for the cost of 1 mana and a food, not to mention he can tap creatures
Hey Caleb. Sorry but I can't put your voice with your face. You look like an off brand Brian Kibler or Kyle Hill. All jokes aside, great content, hope your channel is successful and I hope you have a great day!
Hell yea! I really appreciate it! I’ve gotten that voice thing my whole life 😅
I do sometimes wonder why she isn't "make food on ETB OR attack."
Not a 100% sure but I would think Academy Manufactor would replace Peregrin Took's replacement. Meaning you create the initial food and manufacturer splits that into the 3. Took sees that you're making 1 or more tokens and adds a food to it. Manufacturer sees the new food and splits it into the 3 types. Meanwhile chatterfang is over in the corner seeing all this birthing squirrels trying to keep up. Maybe I'm wrong though. Maybe manufacturer doesn't replace took's replacement idk. Rules lawyers out there let me know please
Sense all 3 of them are replacement effects they don’t interact 😁 otherwise what you said would be true you’d get all the tokens lol
🙂
W newsom he’s so cool (totally not me)
😂 totally