@@feloniouz770I watched the whole thing, but, somehow missed that. Honestly, I was hoping he'd just destroy the card or something, but I am glad someone else also called him out on the utterly ridiculous decision to put a card that "cannot be" in the graveyard.
@@DeusExNihiloof course you could never recognize it as it’s happening, but there could absolutely be a moment when the channel switches to having consistent audio, you would just have to identify it after the consistency has been demonstrated.
Sharpie MTG is my favorite MTG, because it hasn’t even been a full round yet and we have “you may cast creatures (you may cast them)” and “this creature can’t be”. Fantastic.
Same goes for restore balance and profane tutor, yet they still qualify as 0 cost CMC for cascade and other checks. Lack of a listed mana value simply means the cost is 0, but inaccessible by normal means@@LazarusIsBackBaby
When Charlie gave away Spell Weird to Drew, the turn before his Azorious Arrester had re-entered the battlefield from dieing in combat. He should have lost from talking
39:12 For those that are curious, mtg does actually have a rule about sorceries entering the battlefield! "307.4. Sorceries can’t enter the battlefield. If a sorcery would enter the battlefield, it remains in its previous zone instead." I have no idea why this was needed in the rules, but it's there lol
Flickering a manifested sorcery would make it enter the battlefield but because it can't enter it remains exiled. Source: I'm a disgusting Kadena morph player and have tried everything possible with manifests/morphs
Had the thought halfway through the video, Any could've created a copy of any sac outlet with Ooooooo out on the battlefield to instantly assemble Exodia. I'm dead from laughing too hard at this episode. Absolutely loved it.
The funniest thing about the Exodia play is that it wouldn't have won from having all the pieces, he'd need to attack with it. Exodia is only an isnta-win if all five pieces are in the hand, not on the field lmao
My thought was create 5 “tap: untap target creature” cards on the first turn or technically just 4 because after the 4th untap u could create a piece of exodia and next turn create the other 4 pieces
Even if exodia pieces were in his hand it wouldn't do anything, exodia's effect says you win the duel and a game of magic isn't a duel, you may however challenge someone to a duel and win it instantly
He could have started with Pemmin’s Aura, used a blue to untap any, then cast Black Lotus repeatedly, making infinite mana, at which point he can untap infinitely, at which point you can win any number of ways, the first I think of is Lab Man and repeated Wheels of Fortune to deck everyone out and win
I was thinking about leyline of the guildpact in this.... [If] Leyline of the Guildpact [is in your opening hand, you] may begin the game [with it] on the battlefield. Each [nonland] permanent [you control] is [all colors.] Land[s] you control [are every basic] land [type] in addition to their other types. Or rather: Leyline of the Guildpact may begin the game on the battlefield. Each permanent is Land you control in addition to their other types. Fair and balanced card :)
43:16 awww he cheated because Any says copy a target that hasn't been named and Exodia has already been named Great video I would love to see more of this
Maybe I'm an overgrown child but the card "Duce" is the hardest I've laughed in weeks. A+ to whoever sharpie'd that one. Please do more of these, this was a delight to watch.
I love the win condition of assembling Exodia with any, especially because it doesn't work the original intended way (Exodia needs to be in your _hand_ to win), but still works anyways because they're YuGiOh cards so they just have crazy stats for Magic
Charlie and all the other guys are fun to watch together playing on any platform. The editing style of this content to keep it easy to digest for a wider audience is great. It doesn’t matter what you guys game on, I’m sure it will be entertaining.
I really love how Charlie went for the Exodia win initially, not realizing all five pieces have to be in the hand and not on the field to insta-win lmfao
I gave birth a few days ago, to a beautiful baby boy, named Dameon, he’s perfectly healthy, and is super beautiful, while I recover from the birth, I’ve been consuming the Olympics (I love basketball) and need culture, just been consuming anything magic the gathering. Thank you guys for helping me keep myself distracted during this recovery period
This was an absolute blast to watch. You guys did a great job, I feel you also stayed consistent in spite of the absurdity of the effects, great job, I would watch way more of this
I would love more of this is was great! Super funny and love the up to interpretation of cards. Means that you could technically use the same decks but have someone else play them even
this was one of the most silly and fun games of Magic i have seen in a while, from the text changes to the actual effects they had on the game. please do more of these
TL;DR: The "Land" cards Drew plays can't tap for mana. Basic land types are what give lands the intrinsic abilities to tap for the corresponding colors. Plains for white, island for blue, swamp for black, forest for green, and mountain for red. The land subtype doesn't provide any such abilities. It's not a Wastes card because Wastes actually have Oracle text saying "[Tap]: Add (C)" in order for them to function as intended and fit the feel of a basic land by not having any text on the card despite having no basic land type. Those "Land" cards, for all intents and purposes, are basic lands with no abilities and therefore cannot tap for mana. It's certainly still a land and can be affected by things that can affect or refer to lands. You can Stone Rain it or even sacrifice it to a Sylvan Safekeeper, but you cannot tap it for mana unless you give it a basic land subtype. Given this is a joke format, really just do whatever. I am of the mind in casual formats that if something is funny, it supersedes actual rules. I mean, they say they're a land right in the name! That IS a LAND. ISLAND. Lands tap for mana. That's how it works. Get fucked, WotC.
This is a funny comment and they very well might’ve actually written on the cards which is crazy. You can accomplish the same thing with double sleeving and a sharpie and not mess up your cards. Hope you don’t have to sell your body any more lmao
@LowPho I tend to proxy decks I'm play testing and any cards that are Essentials or just too expensive. Like the high tier mana rocks, duel lands, dockside, and stuff like that. Please don't proxy an entire deck. Also don't proxy in the sharpie format either. The point of this format is to take janky bulk cards and make them super strong, not to take staples and make them even more ridiculous.
This is 1000x better that any other Commander game ive seen. If there isnt more I will cry until im a dried husk of a human being and I wither into the dust I came from.
I hated this idea at first but actually unironically a chill way to watch magic without having to concentrate and pay really close attention. I vote for more! My poor attention span loved this
Takes me back to my first times playing, 7th Edition/Invasion block period. Just vibing with friends having no idea what the cards did but as long as it made sense to us it was all good.
This was an all-time classic the moment Matt read "this creature can't be"
Though, the fact that it didn't at least go to exile made that much more disappointing.
The card actually said "This creature can't be a"
@@jaredwonnacott9732 It did go to exile? Did you only watch the first 12 seconds of play?
@@feloniouz770I watched the whole thing, but, somehow missed that. Honestly, I was hoping he'd just destroy the card or something, but I am glad someone else also called him out on the utterly ridiculous decision to put a card that "cannot be" in the graveyard.
I am like 1k!
The moment this channel gets consistant good audio is the day the universe implodes on itself lol
they definitely need Frank Tonmann the Tonmann from germany
Good thing a consistent factor can never be a single moment then
@@DeusExNihilo No room for logic here in a youtube comment section. How dare you.
@@DeusExNihiloof course you could never recognize it as it’s happening, but there could absolutely be a moment when the channel switches to having consistent audio, you would just have to identify it after the consistency has been demonstrated.
Humanity won't be around
First card properly cast, and it just cant be.
I fucking love sharpie magic.
Another good moment is 'is he the arrogant brat?' 'Just hit me.'
@@jamesfilyawDigginGabeMy favorite was the "until your next turn, you are silent." into "Whenever you attack, enemy victory." combo.
Sharpie MTG is my favorite MTG, because it hasn’t even been a full round yet and we have “you may cast creatures (you may cast them)” and “this creature can’t be”. Fantastic.
"You can cast CARDS" Makes lands castable and able to trigger cast triggers lol
Oh my god. Old Impulse draw just got playable
Nah bc they don't have a casting cost
Same goes for restore balance and profane tutor, yet they still qualify as 0 cost CMC for cascade and other checks. Lack of a listed mana value simply means the cost is 0, but inaccessible by normal means@@LazarusIsBackBaby
@@LazarusIsBackBaby they 0 cost then and you can cast them lmao
He can also play cards from everyone's graveyard , exile , etc. If it's a card, he can cast it.
"we have unsets at home."
unsets at home:
This concept has big RoboRosewater energy and I love it
This is unsets at home, but your mom is celebrity chef Bobby Flay
This felt better than any Un set. Max silliness. 😂😂😂
Question: if this became an unset, would it become popular?
orat man : If you would win the game instead never succeed.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Charlie's rock has the tap symbol sharpied out. My guy has infinite blue and white mana like right away lol
Yeah I was wondering how that would work for him. He can just add mana whenever I’m guessing
There was no colon, so it wasn't an activated ability. I understood it to be an ETB effect
@@joedoe7572that’s what I thought, 2 mana artifact that on ETB add 1 of W/U and draw a card.
@@BrootalMetalBanjo Nah because it's a permanent and the cards don't say "on ETB". He just adds it.
LETTING YOU KNOW LOUDLY THAT I WANT A LOT MORE! This was so funny and such a great time
i second thias
Agreed
When Charlie gave away Spell Weird to Drew, the turn before his Azorious Arrester had re-entered the battlefield from dieing in combat. He should have lost from talking
39:12 For those that are curious, mtg does actually have a rule about sorceries entering the battlefield!
"307.4. Sorceries can’t enter the battlefield. If a sorcery would enter the battlefield, it remains in its previous zone instead."
I have no idea why this was needed in the rules, but it's there lol
Flickering a manifested sorcery would make it enter the battlefield but because it can't enter it remains exiled.
Source: I'm a disgusting Kadena morph player and have tried everything possible with manifests/morphs
Charlie should've sent out Shaharzad every time he cast his commander and kept making new games
Bro😂😂😂
Coulda drawn his whole deck and just gotten thoracle to win
I really hope Sharpie Commander becomes a series. This on it's own is so fucking funny and I need more of it
This is some old school anime yugioh rules.
This card does whatever the fuck I say it does.
Everybody at the table: sure, alright.
Had the thought halfway through the video, Any could've created a copy of any sac outlet with Ooooooo out on the battlefield to instantly assemble Exodia. I'm dead from laughing too hard at this episode. Absolutely loved it.
The funniest thing about the Exodia play is that it wouldn't have won from having all the pieces, he'd need to attack with it. Exodia is only an isnta-win if all five pieces are in the hand, not on the field lmao
My thought was create 5 “tap: untap target creature” cards on the first turn or technically just 4 because after the 4th untap u could create a piece of exodia and next turn create the other 4 pieces
Even if exodia pieces were in his hand it wouldn't do anything, exodia's effect says you win the duel and a game of magic isn't a duel, you may however challenge someone to a duel and win it instantly
@@TwilightWolf2508 than the final cards
He could have started with Pemmin’s Aura, used a blue to untap any, then cast Black Lotus repeatedly, making infinite mana, at which point he can untap infinitely, at which point you can win any number of ways, the first I think of is Lab Man and repeated Wheels of Fortune to deck everyone out and win
this is genuinely the BEST magic video ive watched at least in the past 3 years
I was thinking about leyline of the guildpact in this....
[If] Leyline of the Guildpact [is in your opening hand, you] may begin the game [with it] on the battlefield.
Each [nonland] permanent [you control] is [all colors.]
Land[s] you control [are every basic] land [type] in addition to their other types.
Or rather:
Leyline of the Guildpact may begin the game on the battlefield.
Each permanent is
Land you control in addition to their other types.
Fair and balanced card :)
33:42 Azorius Arrester entered but he said "I'll pass" when he should remain silent. That's a shock collar trigger.
Shock Collar Sharpie Commander when.
PLEASE MAKE MORE VIDEOS OF THIS I LOVED THE ABSOLUTE JOY ON YALLS FACE READING THOSE CARDS SUPER HILARIOUS- large text as per Ryan’s request
43:16 awww he cheated because Any says copy a target that hasn't been named and Exodia has already been named
Great video I would love to see more of this
Maybe I'm an overgrown child but the card "Duce" is the hardest I've laughed in weeks. A+ to whoever sharpie'd that one.
Please do more of these, this was a delight to watch.
I'm glad this series is a thing and I'm enjoying it
I love the win condition of assembling Exodia with any, especially because it doesn't work the original intended way (Exodia needs to be in your _hand_ to win), but still works anyways because they're YuGiOh cards so they just have crazy stats for Magic
Big Deck Energy is perfect sleep content, I’ve never been able to fully get into commander but this series lets me relax while learning, W ep
I love that they didnt make the cards good, but made them funny. Makes this format way more enjoyable to watch lol
Has the audio ever been unscuffed? I know the struggles of microphones too well 😔
Charlie and all the other guys are fun to watch together playing on any platform. The editing style of this content to keep it easy to digest for a wider audience is great. It doesn’t matter what you guys game on, I’m sure it will be entertaining.
I really love how Charlie went for the Exodia win initially, not realizing all five pieces have to be in the hand and not on the field to insta-win lmfao
I definitely wanna play this format with my friends! This game was hilarious and looked so fun!
Please bring this back, I rarely watch commander gameplay but would watch every single sharpie game! This was amazing
That was great, it’s so easy to make super busted stuff with sharpies but y’all kept it fun. Thanks for the video!
Spell Weird feels truly in the spirit of Sharpie Magic, it seems like a real idea for an Un-Set card.
Between this and the shock collar episode, this is my new favorite commander channel now!
I never would have thought that an episode of something crazy like "sharpie" could appeal to me so much.
Man i was out here thinking of using any to make Exodia or silly things.
Judge guy just going straight for coalition victory. Savage
Love the sharpie commander content, looking forward to more!
"Tap Target Controller's Father" fucking killed me
This was hilarious and has convinced me todothis with my group. I'd love to see more Sharpie games!
2:18
"Would you stop saying my name" oh I couldn't stop laughing with how he said it and how serious he looked
I gave birth a few days ago, to a beautiful baby boy, named Dameon, he’s perfectly healthy, and is super beautiful, while I recover from the birth, I’ve been consuming the Olympics (I love basketball) and need culture, just been consuming anything magic the gathering. Thank you guys for helping me keep myself distracted during this recovery period
Congratulations! I hope you guys are and stay happy and healthy!
I second n00bz sentiment! Congratulations!
Thanks for the wishes guys, he’s been a handful, but nothing I can’t handle with my partner 💪
I wish for your child to have a happy and prosperous life!
Congrats!
This whole video is like if you mix Magic with Quelf and I’m 100% here for it
This is exactly what I was thinking. Especially Spell Weird and the creature that forced the player to be silent until their next turn.
This was an absolute blast to watch. You guys did a great job, I feel you also stayed consistent in spite of the absurdity of the effects, great job, I would watch way more of this
this is exactly how they came up with Un-sets... probably
I would love more of this is was great! Super funny and love the up to interpretation of cards. Means that you could technically use the same decks but have someone else play them even
this format is absolutely incredible. PLEASE make more 😂
This was a riot! So many gut-wrenching bursts of laughter.
This episode made me laugh so hard, the entire time. You gotta do more of these.
this was one of the most silly and fun games of Magic i have seen in a while, from the text changes to the actual effects they had on the game. please do more of these
this was a gem of a magic game PLEASE continue with the Sharpie commander!
This is probably the best magic content I've seen in months!
I've been crying from laughter. Thank you so much, I need more of this in my life! xD
Plz keep doing this, I imagine it’s fun to play because it looks fun to play and it’s fun to watch
This was really really funny, i had the best laughs in a long while, please give us more of sharpie magic
This was the most entertaining video of magic I've ever seen! Pls do more!
I want to play magic 24/7 but this is a good enough hit of MTG to satisfy my craving. Thank you for making these.
The dunkin napkin BROKE ME
TL;DR: The "Land" cards Drew plays can't tap for mana.
Basic land types are what give lands the intrinsic abilities to tap for the corresponding colors. Plains for white, island for blue, swamp for black, forest for green, and mountain for red. The land subtype doesn't provide any such abilities. It's not a Wastes card because Wastes actually have Oracle text saying "[Tap]: Add (C)" in order for them to function as intended and fit the feel of a basic land by not having any text on the card despite having no basic land type. Those "Land" cards, for all intents and purposes, are basic lands with no abilities and therefore cannot tap for mana. It's certainly still a land and can be affected by things that can affect or refer to lands. You can Stone Rain it or even sacrifice it to a Sylvan Safekeeper, but you cannot tap it for mana unless you give it a basic land subtype.
Given this is a joke format, really just do whatever. I am of the mind in casual formats that if something is funny, it supersedes actual rules. I mean, they say they're a land right in the name! That IS a LAND. ISLAND. Lands tap for mana. That's how it works. Get fucked, WotC.
I would watch hundreds of hours of this format
Lol i love charlie not realizing the tap symbol was blacked out... that mana fizzled
This is exactly what I’d hope a game of sharpie magic would play like
This is the silliest homebrewed Un-game I've ever seen! ❤️
This is my first time experiencing sharpie magic, this is brilliant comedy. Hope others do this!
"I'll keep his dad around."
*Editor weeping*
Zac technically is just a 6/6 with flying and exproof, unless you have a Niv-Mizzet, Guildpact in your library
Keep these up there so much fun
*They're*
This was great, don't know about every video being sharpie magic but a couple every now and then could be a nice change up.
I'm over here selling my body on the corner to afford a booster box, and these Chads are like "fuck it we ball" and destroy 250 cards
This is a funny comment and they very well might’ve actually written on the cards which is crazy. You can accomplish the same thing with double sleeving and a sharpie and not mess up your cards. Hope you don’t have to sell your body any more lmao
Just proxy cards
@LowPho I tend to proxy decks I'm play testing and any cards that are Essentials or just too expensive. Like the high tier mana rocks, duel lands, dockside, and stuff like that. Please don't proxy an entire deck.
Also don't proxy in the sharpie format either. The point of this format is to take janky bulk cards and make them super strong, not to take staples and make them even more ridiculous.
@@psych0CS2 I proxy my entire deck. All of them. It's great and my wallet is happy
@@psych0CS2 I'll stop proxying decks when Wizards stops screwing over the fan base.
This was my favorite thing you have done so far
I would very much like more of this please. There is so much UNTAPPED potential in this game mode
New to magic like literally 2 weeks new just bought my first commander deck and I’ve watched ALL of your guys videos already😂
Yeahhhh the brain rot is real 💀
This is 1000x better that any other Commander game ive seen. If there isnt more I will cry until im a dried husk of a human being and I wither into the dust I came from.
I ENJOYED THIS. PLEASE DO MORE!!
I love the sharpie magic card trend
Poor Charlie not realizing you need every piece of Exodia in your hand, not on the field, to win.
I'm gonna start blocking out text on a bunch of commons and see where it takes me. Love this Episode!
This was the funniest gameplay video I have seen in a very long time across many other context creators, I hope I will see many more 😂
This really does just feel like a really fun Un-set.
13:16
"You can't speak."
"Yeah."
I don't know why, but it sent me to the moon.
That was fun as hell to watch! KEEP MAKING MAGIC VIDS!!! Thank you guys
Definitely need more of this! Very funny 😆
Please keep doing these i was having a blast watching
This was tremendously funny and good to watch!
Amazing video! Could watch this style forever.
Fishing is a acceptable excuse for trespassing
This was so funny, please do more!!!
W sound fixing by the editor, had the note not been at the beginning of the video i wouldve never known the audio was screwed
This was amazing, I definitely want to see more of this
6:28 uuuhhh wait that's just infinite mana HEY CHARLIE IT DOESN'T NEED TO TAP
I took it more as when it enters add a w or u there is no : so it's not an activated ability
i have no comprehension of mtg, but I need to see more of this!!! NEED MORE!
I build a Satoru deckas a powered down version of my Yuriko deck thanks to Charlie. Love it.
I also built a Satoru deck because of Charlie, but Japanese and demon-themed
More please, this was hilarious
I really like when the video tells me who's turn it is ❤
This was really funny to watch. Keep up the content, great stuff!
I hated this idea at first but actually unironically a chill way to watch magic without having to concentrate and pay really close attention. I vote for more! My poor attention span loved this
Finally a magic game I can understand!
Whoever invented Sharpie TCG, comedic genius
This is the funniest thing I’ve seen in awhile
ONe of the funniest shows yet. really loved this one, feel sorry for the magic cards lol
Please keep doing this! Best commander game yet
Dear lord please bless us with more sharpie shenanigan's
Takes me back to my first times playing, 7th Edition/Invasion block period. Just vibing with friends having no idea what the cards did but as long as it made sense to us it was all good.