Juyeon is getting more confident with his voice now better than their debut. Thanks for your lovely words, he deserves recognition not just as a visual but as a main dancer and a vocalist.
When talking about Ju Hak-nyeon: " To me, he is potential city " Me, having him as my first bias when I joined the fandom, thinking: sounds about right! Mnet really did him dirty on produce, he was the reason I was interested in the Boyz cause I remembered him being so talented already on that show.
@@nikolashakos_ Don't you express your negativity here. Yes, he was talented. he could sing, he could dance, he managed to stand out. Lipsycning? For the dance performance yes but so did everyone else. He will be more successful than you will ever be and you don't need to spread hate. What you just said is not constructive criticism.
@@Nina-df3zq Just ignore them, that person is obsessed with tbz and haknyeon, they're literally spreading hate in tons of videos as if people would actually agree 💀
i laughed a bit when you stated jacob had a voice of an angel and no less than 5 seconds later the first vocal clip had him with a halo headband on. probably not that funny but whatever lmao.
Results on your 'How-do-I-pronounce-this-idol's-name-quiz?' Sun-oo: Correct (The W in the English spelling is there only for decorative reasons, I guess. There is no W in the Korean spelling) Ju Hak-nyeon: Wrong (This one should be pronounced as Ju Hang-nyeon. A K before an N gets a nasal tone, so it becomes 'ng'. Congratulations, you got 1 of 2 correct! Good luck with your next pronunciation!
It's rather ha(g) because his name is 학년 (_hagnyeon_) but due to accent it may come out as 'ng' (my pronunciation comes out as a 'g' but when I talk quickly, it comes out as a 'ng', so it really depends)
i agree completely with this except i would switch kevin and hyunjae!! my bias is chanhee/new and i think he's an amazing singer but i agree that he can sometimes be inconsistent in his upper register and i think overall sangyeon just has a great supported sound no matter what register he's using! the boyz are one of my ult groups so i really appreciate you making this video from one singer to another :]
i think in terms of pitch, new is one of the most consistent idols out there. HE NEVER MISSES. i wonder if he has perfect or perfect relative pitch bc he’s able to enter the note RIGHT on the correct pitch, which is so pleasing to hear.
If I’m being honest, I am quite nervous for your BLACKPINK ranking. I’m crossing my fingers and praying that Blonks don’t come for you with their pitchforks if they disagree with your ranking 💀😂😅
This is really so sad that people are afraid of that fandom. * Sigh * At least they'll bring views to the video so that's something? I'm expecting queen Jisoo at second or first cause she is really stable live, they just make her sing a higher pitch than she's actually used to. Same with Rose
Their reveal version on road to kingdom was just chef's kiss. Really glad they won, even though I'm also a fan of Oneus. I really like this group, hope they will gain a lot of fans with Kingdom
i think, the boyz fandom is already big.. cause the boyz is the only group from road to kingdom (along with pentagon) that have over 100k album sales and join the list of million seller boygroup cause the total all of the boyz album sales is over than 1million
I'm so glad you made it to the Boyz! They are really nice vocally and Sangyeon is actually the only bias I have that I stanned purely based on his vocals. While you didn't seem blown away by them for me they just carry a resonance and emotion I love, so I'm glad to see him high up although even I didn't expect first! Anyway stan our underatted leader y'all :).
Don't worry, I've listened to so many amazing singers, that my bar is super high, and it takes alot for me to get blown away, doesn't take away from the fact that they were all great 😊
I've stanned The Boyz since debut. Before seeing this I'd have placed Juhaknyeon higher as I never really compared them in this way but your analysis was an eye opener and gave me more appreciation for some of the members that tend to be overlooked.
i’ve been waiting SOOO long for this, they’re such talented kings and their Road To Kingdom win was well deserved, i just love the vocal lines voices ❤️
Sam Bradley no apologies needed! you put out so much quality content very willingly and always doing our request! proud to be a subscriber and patreon of yours
Thank you! I was so excited about this. I also didn't expect Q to be so low but maybe im a bit biased lol. And I was a bit surprised when sangyeon got 1st instead of New (not complaining) i just felt like sangyeon has always been a bit underrated vocally, its good to see him get some acknowledgement
Groups to add to your reaction list: 1. F(x) - SM 2nd gen girl group 2. SF9 - Good vocal group 3. Golden Child - Infinite's younger brother, debate about who is #1 4. ONF - pronounced On and Off, already know who #1 is just curious about the rest 5. 2PM - 2nd gen JYP boy group 6. Winner - YG boygroup, again know who #1 is, but curious about the rest 7. IKON - YG boygroup, please include B.I. 8. TVXQ (OT5)- SM 2nd gen boygroup, vocal gods of Kpop even with only 2 members today 9. Oh My Girl - 7 member girl group 10. Wannaone - Would like to see a ranking especially now since most have the chance to show more.
Kōôl kîd ahh yes!! Personally I’m really curious about Golden Child, ONF, Oh My Girl and Wanna One! I feel like ONF and Oh My Girl are very underrated vocally but they’re really good (especially their main vocalists!)
I agree that Sangyeon is the number 1!! Just like what you said, his voice is always full. also, he’s the one who’s always stable on their live performances. Also, I always have in my mind that Haknyeon has a potential! dang, he sing to highnotes easily
❤️❤️❤️ I’m not sure if anyone has requested B.A.P but I need your ranking in my life lol They are so underrated (& hopefully not forgotten 😭) and Daehyun is another vocal god lol
I low-key want The Boyz to see this so that it helps them improve. They're already amazing. But the potential that they hold as a group is immense and this could really help tbh.
I like how you reference how they will sound in the future with more practice and there potential, it makes me feel I guess less disappointed when who I expected to be higher is a bit lower. But once again this was an excellent analysis!! Also I'm excited for Blackpink! I feel like each ranking I see is completely different...
i hope you can do LOONA someday!! I know you don't usually go for the girl groups and also they're a big group but there's lots of individual content and group content so I hope you can learn their voices and decide the ranking quickly! -an orbit :)
@@sambradley8297 I'm not saying this to pile on more pressure on you, but I don't think the solo songs are truly representative of every member. Just letting you know! Jinsoul is considered one of the strongest vocalists but her solo Singing in the Rain is widely viewed as among the worst solos and fails to show the real power and range of her voice (she does have a non-LOONA solo, As Time Goes, for a TV show soundtrack and it's much better at showcasing her skills!). Yeojin, while not considered one of the stronger singers in the group, was obviously forced to sing in an unnaturally high voice in her solo Kiss Later. Unlike, say, Momo from Twice; this is not just a theory, because other songs in the LOONA discography generally allow Yeojin to sing in her natural mezzo tone.
i’m especially interested in rowoon’s analysis because he isn’t always mentioned when people are talking about how good sf9’s vocalists are, but his voice is my personal favorite!
This was really cool to watch, especially since I´ve been getting into the boyz lately after they caught my attention on road to kingdom (I see you got a lot of clips from those performances, they were great right). It makes sense that Jacob and Kevin have a western style bc they´re both Canadian, maybe they were influenced by the music they grew up with? This group has great music, amazing choreography and stage presence, I can totally see them becoming one of my favorites in the near future. Also, I am really excited to hear what you have to say about Blackpink :)
I've been looking forward to this video since you first mentioned doing The Boyz - one of my absolute favourite super underrated groups! And you fanboying over Sunwoo is really a damn mood (Sunwoo biased right here). Your pronunciation of his name is basically spot on - the Hangul is 선우 which in English is essentially the word 'sun' and the sound 'oo'. Haknyeon's name was also super confusing to me when I first started getting into The Boyz - mainly because he uses his full name as his stage name 😹. Basically his surname is 주 or 'joo' and his name is 학년 - 'hak' and 'nyeon'. It's really weird to try and put into English but your pronunciation in the video is just about right! Really enjoy your videos, thank you for putting so much time and effort into them, it's really great to see the channel growing! As someone who's been around since the first few analyses you put out it's been awesome to watch you grow and simultaneously learn so much about my favourite idols. Also sorry for the super long comment - I don't typically comment on videos but when I do I leave long ones. 🤦🏻♀️😹 Until next time!
I might be late but I kinda agree with you. Yesung's voice have a built-in emotions. You can definitely feel it when you hear him sing. I think it's the same case for Chanhee's (New) voice. He also has the built-in emotion. Not on the same level as Yesung's though. That man (yesung) sings like he had gone through multiple divorce. Anyways, I hope Chanhee's voice will develop more in the future. I'm looking forward to it ❤️
But i dont fall for sunwoo at all ,, i fall for eric and changmin 💖💝 when first i know The Boyz i directly fall for eric and changmin and sometimes younghoon.
You turned this out surprisingly fast! I was so excited for this, like you have no idea. What I find interesting about their vocal line is that Cre.ker gave Kevin a main vocal title but treats him like a lead vocal, and usually treats Hyunjae like a main vocal, at least now. By the way, totally self indulgent question, what's your favorite Road to Kingdom performance from them?
Aaah! I wasn't expecting this but I'm so glad you gave them an analysis! I've always felt The Boyz have a lot of untapped vocal potential that they can explore with the right guidance.I'm glad you pointed Haknyeon's potential because I feel like has a lot of room for growth.And yes Sangyeon is fantastic.
new and sangyeon’s voice is rlly competing like... i really like chanhee’s range and he’s very good in adlibs but sometimes it sounds very tight, then sangyeon’s voice is very whole and very clean, smooth and easy to hear but his range is low...
u should look for sangyeon fancam for their kingdom 'spark' performance. I was shocked, that guy actually has huge range but didn't have much chance to show it
I agree with your rankings, and that was a good analysis of strengths and (current) weaknesses. The first thing I would do with Kevin is teach him to shape and support vowels. That alone would give his vocals a more professional quality. But boy, he's very good at articulating and phrasing a lyric.
Please consider doing ONF in the future! Thank you for your vocal rankings, I've been watching your vocal rankings since the EXO one and since then I have barely watched any other ones because you explain everything very well!
0:21 Yaaas, queen. Stan The Boyz. I literally love almost every song they have. They have phenomenal b-side tracks. Also glad you included Hwall even though he's no longer a member.
Thanks for your review 🥺👍🏼 Reli, Stan the Boyz and u won’t regret!! 🥰 In my opinion, if Sunwoo get a chance to try going solo, I wish it would be a R&B song 🙈🙈 His low voice is just so good~~ 😌
Me (this morning): I really need to check out The Boyz and learn more about them. I've heard great things. Maybe I'll watch some MVs this week. Me (after watching this QUALITY analysis): Sam has certified their pure talent. No time to lose. I'm stanning.
I really respect your opinions! You researched well on them and it shows you really put thought into your analysis! I guess I basically agree with you haha. However New is my bias so maybe I’m just biased in believing he’s “the best” but Sangyeon is really amazing too. I find New’s voice really unique and I’m attracted to it more for that reason haha, but thank you for this video I enjoyed watching it!
thank you so much for doing a vocal analysis on the boyz !! it’s so much appreciated bc of how little they’re talked about on youtube in terms of analysis when all the members are all so talented so thank you so much for this. also just a quick note, hyunjun (hwall) left the group in october 2019 due to health reasons, however, recently he has been getting into solo work and even released a song called ‘baragi’. if you have the time please give it a listen and maybe one day include it in a future analysis if he chooses to continue to pursue a music career?
I have to confess that the thing that less got my attention about The Boyz was their vocals. I got to know them during R2K and beyond being impressed with everything else about them, I was waiting for an outstanding vocal (I'm a vocal stan, so...) that, in my opinion, didn't came in R2K performances. But after your video I got quite impressed with Sangyeon, even he being the one who most called my attention in the group, he didn't shine brighter in R2K stages, and he has such potential! It was nice to see how good he is and I truly need to see more things of him.
LetItGo hey i would recommend to watch a few of videos of them singing live, they do not have a very power house vocal but every member is stable enough: ruclips.net/video/46wwslB8H6g/видео.html (they were barely 1 year during this time and some members have improved alot now especially haknyeon and juyeon) ruclips.net/video/ZTa1HEJjcXE/видео.html (new, kevin, jacob) ruclips.net/video/ZpbkKHqea4E/видео.html (guesting on immortal songs) extra: ruclips.net/video/lIjuAxbCZ0o/видео.html (sangyeon, haknyeon, younghoon during fanmeet lmao)
LOVE your Ranking and it‘s reasons! I‘d suggest you to check out The Boyz I‘m Your Boy Debut Showcase Performance, in which you can see Younghoon shine more and TATTOO by The Boyz, in which Sangyeon does the Adlibs in the end! Imo, The Boyz Vocal Line hasn‘t reached their full potential yet in studio recordings. Their Songs are mostly ‚safe‘ with belts above an E4 (or A4 if you count checkmate) being rare and falsetto/adlibs being done by the same few members - when more have the potential! I really hope that in the future each member will be able to show their full potential and/or range. But yes, I looove your analysis and I hope that in a year or so you can do an update on your thoughts about their technique etc. :>
This was such a great analysis I’ve been looking for one of tbz for ages, and you even included hyunjoon🥺I think a lot of people forget how amazing of a vocalist sangyeon is because they have so many good vocalists so thanks for highlighting that!
Haha it's cool you noticed Kevin and Jacob have a western sound. They grew up in Canada! New is my bias but I agree that right now Sangyeon is a bit more solid. But it's amazing to hear how much faith you have in New's potential 🤩
Thank you for the continuous uploads! I've been wanting to stan The Boyz, & this video is gonna make me check out more of their music for sure. Great analysis as always!
The ranking is finally online!! Thank you, it was a great analysis of their voices :). I completely understand you for having Sunwoo as a bias. Ever since I got to know them I have a really hard time staying loyal to Q because of this talented man.
I haven't listened much to The Boyz but I really like their vocals and your ranking seems very good, as always. I'm excited for you to do Blackpink since they're a more rap based group, they all have different vocal colors, and since I've seen them ranked many different ways.
but New is technically better than sangyeon in terms of belting and flexibility, Sangyeon is great when he uses his falsetto. And if we're talking about technique for me Sangyeon goes to the third place, because sometimes he can't hold a stable notes while singing life, the second is Kevin
this is not true at all 😭 new is not as flexible in his belting bc he mainly uses his throat, sangyeon is the one with a better technique. kevin is not better than sangyeon. kevin gets easier parts and singing while dancing does not reflect ability, that’s stamina.
really appreciated this video i went crazy trying to find a vocal ranking done by a professional, looking forward to more rankings!! is it possible to make some sort of tier with all the groups you've analyzed so we know how well of a vocal group the boyz (and other groups) are?
victon plz >_< theyre only 7 and have been around for long enough and have many live concerts and always singing in their vlives lolololol (finding content would be easy)
Thank you for this! I really appreciate your analysis! I always thought Kevin was like the best of the best so I was shocked to see where he places. But anyways, I hope you can do other second gen groups like After School. I am also hoping to see an analysis on Nu'est! 😭 A lot international kpop stans don't know/like them though TT
Great ranking and in depth view of a group that doesn’t usually get this type of spotlight, it’d be interesting to see something similar with LOONA. Also can’t wait for what new thoughts will be brought up for the BLACKPINK ranking lol
Loved this one! Would you ever consider doing a Wanna One vocal ranking? They’ve got 11 members but they’ve disbanded now because they were only a temporary group. They’re my ult group so I’d love you to do a video for them but I understand if you don’t want to do a disbanded group!
Wow this is pretty much how I expected the ranking to go (besides New and Sangyeon, I wasn’t sure who would be first but I was pretty sure they would both be at the top). I think I was only surprised by New and Sangyeon because I personally prefer New’s voice but I have heard him strain more than Sangyeon although his range is better so I was confused, haha! Excited to see Blackpink, I have literally no idea how I’d rank them 😄
OMGGG WHY DID I SEE THIS JUST NOW AJHSKAJSSJ thank you for taking the time to do this, and my bias is juyeon but i completely agree with your ranking! AAAAA stan tbz. ☺️❤️
Would you consider making a ranking chart to compare singers across groups like the chart that the dance chann On the Scene shows at the end of their videos? I'm really interested to see how groups compare to each other. I think that could be a good way to do it and minimize fanwars.
ahhh i’m so happy with this ranking! it’s kind of what I expected, but I love hearing more detailed things about their voices. Thank you for looking at The Boyz and i’m glad you’re becoming a fan!
amazing video as always! personally my favorite voice is jacob's like its so amazing especially his high note in reveal (at around 2:38~2:44 in the song) and in shine shine with his iconic 'do you like what you see' part so amazing tbz are truly all rounded idols
![Oasis - Oasis Live '25 [Official Trailer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gol_JnuEtKM/mqdefault.jpg)
Sam fanboying over sunwoo is such a mood
If a man say he won't bias by Sunwoo he lie.
I'm big fanboy of this guy hahaha
Well, makes sense that the Canada Line got "westernised" voices XD
Juyeon is getting more confident with his voice now better than their debut. Thanks for your lovely words, he deserves recognition not just as a visual but as a main dancer and a vocalist.
How can he get appreciation for something he is not good at?
When talking about Ju Hak-nyeon: " To me, he is potential city "
Me, having him as my first bias when I joined the fandom, thinking: sounds about right!
Mnet really did him dirty on produce, he was the reason I was interested in the Boyz cause I remembered him being so talented already on that show.
He was what? Talented? Wtf? Where did he expose his talent exactly? In pretending to be an acrobat? Or at lipsyncing?
@@nikolashakos_ Don't you express your negativity here. Yes, he was talented. he could sing, he could dance, he managed to stand out. Lipsycning? For the dance performance yes but so did everyone else. He will be more successful than you will ever be and you don't need to spread hate. What you just said is not constructive criticism.
@@Nina-df3zq Just ignore them, that person is obsessed with tbz and haknyeon, they're literally spreading hate in tons of videos as if people would actually agree 💀
i laughed a bit when you stated jacob had a voice of an angel and no less than 5 seconds later the first vocal clip had him with a halo headband on. probably not that funny but whatever lmao.
Results on your 'How-do-I-pronounce-this-idol's-name-quiz?'
Sun-oo: Correct (The W in the English spelling is there only for decorative reasons, I guess. There is no W in the Korean spelling)
Ju Hak-nyeon: Wrong (This one should be pronounced as Ju Hang-nyeon. A K before an N gets a nasal tone, so it becomes 'ng'.
Congratulations, you got 1 of 2 correct! Good luck with your next pronunciation!
Hahaha thank you very much!
It's rather ha(g) because his name is 학년 (_hagnyeon_) but due to accent it may come out as 'ng' (my pronunciation comes out as a 'g' but when I talk quickly, it comes out as a 'ng', so it really depends)
i agree completely with this except i would switch kevin and hyunjae!! my bias is chanhee/new and i think he's an amazing singer but i agree that he can sometimes be inconsistent in his upper register and i think overall sangyeon just has a great supported sound no matter what register he's using! the boyz are one of my ult groups so i really appreciate you making this video from one singer to another :]
Agree! For me hyunjae's voice is more flat than kevin's
i think in terms of pitch, new is one of the most consistent idols out there. HE NEVER MISSES. i wonder if he has perfect or perfect relative pitch bc he’s able to enter the note RIGHT on the correct pitch, which is so pleasing to hear.
If I’m being honest, I am quite nervous for your BLACKPINK ranking. I’m crossing my fingers and praying that Blonks don’t come for you with their pitchforks if they disagree with your ranking 💀😂😅
Haha same. But you guys rock. You can protect me haha
Anjali Nambakam the ranking is quite obvious imo
lmao, that's why i'm always nervous to call myself part of the fandom. but i can't wait to see a bp ranking!
This is really so sad that people are afraid of that fandom. * Sigh *
At least they'll bring views to the video so that's something?
I'm expecting queen Jisoo at second or first cause she is really stable live, they just make her sing a higher pitch than she's actually used to. Same with Rose
blackpink will and always be
1-rose
2-jisoo
3-jennie
4-lisa
PERIOD
Their reveal version on road to kingdom was just chef's kiss. Really glad they won, even though I'm also a fan of Oneus. I really like this group, hope they will gain a lot of fans with Kingdom
i think, the boyz fandom is already big.. cause the boyz is the only group from road to kingdom (along with pentagon) that have over 100k album sales and join the list of million seller boygroup cause the total all of the boyz album sales is over than 1million
damn hyunjae really got the visuals dancing AND vocals
the boyz= taste
I'm so glad you made it to the Boyz! They are really nice vocally and Sangyeon is actually the only bias I have that I stanned purely based on his vocals. While you didn't seem blown away by them for me they just carry a resonance and emotion I love, so I'm glad to see him high up although even I didn't expect first! Anyway stan our underatted leader y'all :).
Don't worry, I've listened to so many amazing singers, that my bar is super high, and it takes alot for me to get blown away, doesn't take away from the fact that they were all great 😊
@@sambradley8297 ah totally, I figured the bar is just high! Honestly you're always very thoughtful with your content so thanks for doing all this :)
I've stanned The Boyz since debut. Before seeing this I'd have placed Juhaknyeon higher as I never really compared them in this way but your analysis was an eye opener and gave me more appreciation for some of the members that tend to be overlooked.
Excuse me, but why would you place Juhaknyeon higher? Does his voice even have anything satisfying in it?
i’ve been waiting SOOO long for this, they’re such talented kings and their Road To Kingdom win was well deserved, i just love the vocal lines voices ❤️
So sorry it took me a while!
Sam Bradley no apologies needed! you put out so much quality content very willingly and always doing our request! proud to be a subscriber and patreon of yours
Thank you so so much 😊😊😊
Thank you! I was so excited about this. I also didn't expect Q to be so low but maybe im a bit biased lol. And I was a bit surprised when sangyeon got 1st instead of New (not complaining) i just felt like sangyeon has always been a bit underrated vocally, its good to see him get some acknowledgement
kevin's vocal reminds me of rose bp and lia itzy. theyre all main vocals with unique tone, and they suit more with jazz/indie music
Groups to add to your reaction list:
1. F(x) - SM 2nd gen girl group
2. SF9 - Good vocal group
3. Golden Child - Infinite's younger brother, debate about who is #1
4. ONF - pronounced On and Off, already know who #1 is just curious about the rest
5. 2PM - 2nd gen JYP boy group
6. Winner - YG boygroup, again know who #1 is, but curious about the rest
7. IKON - YG boygroup, please include B.I.
8. TVXQ (OT5)- SM 2nd gen boygroup, vocal gods of Kpop even with only 2 members today
9. Oh My Girl - 7 member girl group
10. Wannaone - Would like to see a ranking especially now since most have the chance to show more.
Kōôl kîd ahh yes!! Personally I’m really curious about Golden Child, ONF, Oh My Girl and Wanna One! I feel like ONF and Oh My Girl are very underrated vocally but they’re really good (especially their main vocalists!)
Yes I'm curious about Golden Child and Oh my girl, like the debate of the main vocals 💙
sangyeon's singing is so beautiful and i'm really glad you appreciated that
*My brain:* You have 5 exams this week. You don’t know any inmunology. STUDY FFS!!
*My heart:* Vocal analysis, Sam fanboying & pretty boys 💕
I really love hyunjae's voice and i think his vocal is underappreciated so im really grateful that you make this analysis.
I agree that Sangyeon is the number 1!! Just like what you said, his voice is always full. also, he’s the one who’s always stable on their live performances.
Also, I always have in my mind that Haknyeon has a potential! dang, he sing to highnotes easily
Yes thank you. Stan The BOYZ,Stan talent
Never realised how good the first place's voice was! This really opened my eyes, need to pay more attention to him!
the king has uploaded
❤️❤️❤️ I’m not sure if anyone has requested B.A.P but I need your ranking in my life lol They are so underrated (& hopefully not forgotten 😭) and Daehyun is another vocal god lol
True!! B.A.P are amazing :D For some reason I thought he had already done them but he didn't xD
Eyyyy we got the same bias whoop whoop. Sunwoo is a legend and I actually love him.
I didn't expect Q and Younghoon to be that low, but you explained everything really well
I mean, they’re below JuHaknyeon and Vocal line, there’s nowhere else for them to go
I low-key want The Boyz to see this so that it helps them improve. They're already amazing. But the potential that they hold as a group is immense and this could really help tbh.
I like how you reference how they will sound in the future with more practice and there potential, it makes me feel I guess less disappointed when who I expected to be higher is a bit lower. But once again this was an excellent analysis!! Also I'm excited for Blackpink! I feel like each ranking I see is completely different...
Finally so early!! This video saved my night ^_^
PS: As he said stan TBZ people, you won't regret that choice~
i hope you can do LOONA someday!!
I know you don't usually go for the girl groups and also they're a big group but there's lots of individual content and group content so I hope you can learn their voices and decide the ranking quickly!
-an orbit :)
I will for sure some day soon. Just yeah they scare me a bit. It took me long enough learning these guys. And I'm much better with male faces haha
@@sambradley8297 that's great, take your time!
@@sambradley8297 every one of them has a solo song, so you have a basis for everyone😊👌
Oh really. Hallelujah haha
@@sambradley8297 I'm not saying this to pile on more pressure on you, but I don't think the solo songs are truly representative of every member. Just letting you know! Jinsoul is considered one of the strongest vocalists but her solo Singing in the Rain is widely viewed as among the worst solos and fails to show the real power and range of her voice (she does have a non-LOONA solo, As Time Goes, for a TV show soundtrack and it's much better at showcasing her skills!). Yeojin, while not considered one of the stronger singers in the group, was obviously forced to sing in an unnaturally high voice in her solo Kiss Later. Unlike, say, Momo from Twice; this is not just a theory, because other songs in the LOONA discography generally allow Yeojin to sing in her natural mezzo tone.
Can you do Sf9 people don't really talk about them but personally I think they have really good vocals
omg please do sf9
i’m especially interested in rowoon’s analysis because he isn’t always mentioned when people are talking about how good sf9’s vocalists are, but his voice is my personal favorite!
Yes please!! 😄😄
We rly need it.... im especially confused who is better in rowoon or taeyang.
@@illyuzion what about inseong???
This was really cool to watch, especially since I´ve been getting into the boyz lately after they caught my attention on road to kingdom (I see you got a lot of clips from those performances, they were great right). It makes sense that Jacob and Kevin have a western style bc they´re both Canadian, maybe they were influenced by the music they grew up with? This group has great music, amazing choreography and stage presence, I can totally see them becoming one of my favorites in the near future. Also, I am really excited to hear what you have to say about Blackpink :)
I've been looking forward to this video since you first mentioned doing The Boyz - one of my absolute favourite super underrated groups!
And you fanboying over Sunwoo is really a damn mood (Sunwoo biased right here). Your pronunciation of his name is basically spot on - the Hangul is 선우 which in English is essentially the word 'sun' and the sound 'oo'.
Haknyeon's name was also super confusing to me when I first started getting into The Boyz - mainly because he uses his full name as his stage name 😹. Basically his surname is 주 or 'joo' and his name is 학년 - 'hak' and 'nyeon'. It's really weird to try and put into English but your pronunciation in the video is just about right!
Really enjoy your videos, thank you for putting so much time and effort into them, it's really great to see the channel growing! As someone who's been around since the first few analyses you put out it's been awesome to watch you grow and simultaneously learn so much about my favourite idols. Also sorry for the super long comment - I don't typically comment on videos but when I do I leave long ones. 🤦🏻♀️😹
Until next time!
Sunwoo stans!! 😊
I could be 120% wrong but New’s voice reminds me so much of Super Junior’s Yesung
I know a bit what you mean. The technique is a little bit different. But I can hear it
New’s voice is closer to Ryeowook than anyone
I might be late but I kinda agree with you. Yesung's voice have a built-in emotions. You can definitely feel it when you hear him sing. I think it's the same case for Chanhee's (New) voice. He also has the built-in emotion. Not on the same level as Yesung's though. That man (yesung) sings like he had gone through multiple divorce. Anyways, I hope Chanhee's voice will develop more in the future. I'm looking forward to it ❤️
I feel like if Sunwoo isn’t your bias, he’s definitely one of your bias wreckers 😂 We all fall for him
Also I absolutely loved this video. It’s great to listen to you talk about their voices and what makes them all good! My bias is Eric
yes
He was my first bias 🗿 but now I'm full Eric stan 😌
But i dont fall for sunwoo at all ,, i fall for eric and changmin 💖💝 when first i know The Boyz i directly fall for eric and changmin and sometimes younghoon.
You turned this out surprisingly fast! I was so excited for this, like you have no idea. What I find interesting about their vocal line is that Cre.ker gave Kevin a main vocal title but treats him like a lead vocal, and usually treats Hyunjae like a main vocal, at least now. By the way, totally self indulgent question, what's your favorite Road to Kingdom performance from them?
Danger. Literally blew my mind apart. The ideas and execution were stunning. The team work and the energy will still with me for a long time!
Same here! That performance will be legendary
Aaah! I wasn't expecting this but I'm so glad you gave them an analysis! I've always felt The Boyz have a lot of untapped vocal potential that they can explore with the right guidance.I'm glad you pointed Haknyeon's potential because I feel like has a lot of room for growth.And yes Sangyeon is fantastic.
Yessss The Boyz are slept on vocally, thank you for this!
new and sangyeon’s voice is rlly competing like... i really like chanhee’s range and he’s very good in adlibs but sometimes it sounds very tight, then sangyeon’s voice is very whole and very clean, smooth and easy to hear but his range is low...
u should look for sangyeon fancam for their kingdom 'spark' performance. I was shocked, that guy actually has huge range but didn't have much chance to show it
sangyeon belts almost as high as new tbh, he just doesn’t have as much ease up there. News highest belt is F5 and sangyeon is E5.
I agree with your rankings, and that was a good analysis of strengths and (current) weaknesses. The first thing I would do with Kevin is teach him to shape and support vowels. That alone would give his vocals a more professional quality. But boy, he's very good at articulating and phrasing a lyric.
Please consider doing ONF in the future! Thank you for your vocal rankings, I've been watching your vocal rankings since the EXO one and since then I have barely watched any other ones because you explain everything very well!
0:21 Yaaas, queen. Stan The Boyz. I literally love almost every song they have. They have phenomenal b-side tracks. Also glad you included Hwall even though he's no longer a member.
Thank you, I love your videos !!😘
Please, could you make a ranking for B.A.P , Victon , up10tion or Everglow ? 😃
Please do victon ranking they have good and distinct voice
i’ve never clicked on a video so fast! commenting this before I actually see the rankings!
Thanks for your review 🥺👍🏼 Reli, Stan the Boyz and u won’t regret!! 🥰 In my opinion, if Sunwoo get a chance to try going solo, I wish it would be a R&B song 🙈🙈 His low voice is just so good~~ 😌
thank you for ranking the boyz :) i'm glad you ended up really liking them, although ranking them was difficult.
Me (this morning): I really need to check out The Boyz and learn more about them. I've heard great things. Maybe I'll watch some MVs this week.
Me (after watching this QUALITY analysis): Sam has certified their pure talent. No time to lose. I'm stanning.
I really respect your opinions! You researched well on them and it shows you really put thought into your analysis! I guess I basically agree with you haha. However New is my bias so maybe I’m just biased in believing he’s “the best” but Sangyeon is really amazing too. I find New’s voice really unique and I’m attracted to it more for that reason haha, but thank you for this video I enjoyed watching it!
thank you so much for doing a vocal analysis on the boyz !! it’s so much appreciated bc of how little they’re talked about on youtube in terms of analysis when all the members are all so talented so thank you so much for this. also just a quick note, hyunjun (hwall) left the group in october 2019 due to health reasons, however, recently he has been getting into solo work and even released a song called ‘baragi’. if you have the time please give it a listen and maybe one day include it in a future analysis if he chooses to continue to pursue a music career?
I have to confess that the thing that less got my attention about The Boyz was their vocals. I got to know them during R2K and beyond being impressed with everything else about them, I was waiting for an outstanding vocal (I'm a vocal stan, so...) that, in my opinion, didn't came in R2K performances. But after your video I got quite impressed with Sangyeon, even he being the one who most called my attention in the group, he didn't shine brighter in R2K stages, and he has such potential! It was nice to see how good he is and I truly need to see more things of him.
LetItGo hey i would recommend to watch a few of videos of them singing live, they do not have a very power house vocal but every member is stable enough:
ruclips.net/video/46wwslB8H6g/видео.html (they were barely 1 year during this time and some members have improved alot now especially haknyeon and juyeon)
ruclips.net/video/ZTa1HEJjcXE/видео.html (new, kevin, jacob)
ruclips.net/video/ZpbkKHqea4E/видео.html (guesting on immortal songs)
extra:
ruclips.net/video/lIjuAxbCZ0o/видео.html (sangyeon, haknyeon, younghoon during fanmeet lmao)
I wish Hyunjae would get used to winning on music shows because he's always shaken that he couldn't showcase his vocal prowess during encores
Thank you for doing The Boyz!! 💖💖💖
You finally did the Boyz! I've been waiting for a while 🤧🤧🤧
Hoping for Victon vocal analysis 🌝but damn it's nice to discover some new group 💪 thanks to u🐈
LOVE your Ranking and it‘s reasons! I‘d suggest you to check out The Boyz I‘m Your Boy Debut Showcase Performance, in which you can see Younghoon shine more and TATTOO by The Boyz, in which Sangyeon does the Adlibs in the end! Imo, The Boyz Vocal Line hasn‘t reached their full potential yet in studio recordings. Their Songs are mostly ‚safe‘ with belts above an E4 (or A4 if you count checkmate) being rare and falsetto/adlibs being done by the same few members - when more have the potential! I really hope that in the future each member will be able to show their full potential and/or range. But yes, I looove your analysis and I hope that in a year or so you can do an update on your thoughts about their technique etc. :>
This was such a great analysis I’ve been looking for one of tbz for ages, and you even included hyunjoon🥺I think a lot of people forget how amazing of a vocalist sangyeon is because they have so many good vocalists so thanks for highlighting that!
If I'm not mistaken, Hwall left the group due to health reasons last year. So that's probably why you can't find as much from him or less lives.
In my opinion, I definitely prefer Sangyeon. Chanhee is an amazing runner up tho💖
Haha it's cool you noticed Kevin and Jacob have a western sound. They grew up in Canada!
New is my bias but I agree that right now Sangyeon is a bit more solid. But it's amazing to hear how much faith you have in New's potential 🤩
Thank you for the continuous uploads! I've been wanting to stan The Boyz, & this video is gonna make me check out more of their music for sure. Great analysis as always!
Ally A you won't regret stanning them 🤧💖
Me: getting ready to do the "NYAAA" in Kevin's DDD clip
Sam: cuts that out
Me: 👁👄👁
Sorry, I was 6 hours deep into editing and my brain was fried haha
Sam Bradley lmao don't worry. Midterms got my brain fried as well:'v
Thanks again for the ranking and keep stannin The Boyz!!!
The ranking is finally online!! Thank you, it was a great analysis of their voices :).
I completely understand you for having Sunwoo as a bias. Ever since I got to know them I have a really hard time staying loyal to Q because of this talented man.
ohh I’ve been waiting for this one!! I can’t imagine how much effort you put into these thank you
I haven't listened much to The Boyz but I really like their vocals and your ranking seems very good, as always. I'm excited for you to do Blackpink since they're a more rap based group, they all have different vocal colors, and since I've seen them ranked many different ways.
finally!!! thank you so much
but New is technically better than sangyeon in terms of belting and flexibility, Sangyeon is great when he uses his falsetto. And if we're talking about technique for me Sangyeon goes to the third place, because sometimes he can't hold a stable notes while singing life, the second is Kevin
this is not true at all 😭 new is not as flexible in his belting bc he mainly uses his throat, sangyeon is the one with a better technique. kevin is not better than sangyeon. kevin gets easier parts and singing while dancing does not reflect ability, that’s stamina.
I'm honestly kinda sad that Kevin is not in the top three alongside his fellow main vocalist, I hope his voice gets more appreciated 🥺💕
really appreciated this video i went crazy trying to find a vocal ranking done by a professional, looking forward to more rankings!!
is it possible to make some sort of tier with all the groups you've analyzed so we know how well of a vocal group the boyz (and other groups) are?
yes!
After watching this from now on I'm gonna stan the boyz.. i suggest Onewe, Victon, Exo their good too.......
Sunwoo is my bias so i can relate to the fanboying on a spiritual level lmaoo
victon plz >_< theyre only 7 and have been around for long enough and have many live concerts and always singing in their vlives lolololol (finding content would be easy)
Yesssss victon
Please do victonnnn
Thank you for this! I really appreciate your analysis! I always thought Kevin was like the best of the best so I was shocked to see where he places. But anyways, I hope you can do other second gen groups like After School. I am also hoping to see an analysis on Nu'est! 😭 A lot international kpop stans don't know/like them though TT
it's quite sad that eric can't show what he could or can do because he only sing less than five seconds in every song but i really agree overwall
Great ranking and in depth view of a group that doesn’t usually get this type of spotlight, it’d be interesting to see something similar with LOONA. Also can’t wait for what new thoughts will be brought up for the BLACKPINK ranking lol
Thank you for analyzing and supporting The Boyz ♥️ your videos are super interesting and I'm always eager to listen to your opinion ✨
Loved this one!
Would you ever consider doing a Wanna One vocal ranking? They’ve got 11 members but they’ve disbanded now because they were only a temporary group. They’re my ult group so I’d love you to do a video for them but I understand if you don’t want to do a disbanded group!
Wow this is pretty much how I expected the ranking to go (besides New and Sangyeon, I wasn’t sure who would be first but I was pretty sure they would both be at the top). I think I was only surprised by New and Sangyeon because I personally prefer New’s voice but I have heard him strain more than Sangyeon although his range is better so I was confused, haha! Excited to see Blackpink, I have literally no idea how I’d rank them 😄
OMGGG WHY DID I SEE THIS JUST NOW AJHSKAJSSJ thank you for taking the time to do this, and my bias is juyeon but i completely agree with your ranking! AAAAA stan tbz. ☺️❤️
I love Younghoon's voice is perfect for ballads and give me chills
I Said It before and i repeat, please do b1a4!
Would you consider making a ranking chart to compare singers across groups like the chart that the dance chann On the Scene shows at the end of their videos? I'm really interested to see how groups compare to each other. I think that could be a good way to do it and minimize fanwars.
Sam yay!! Down for your love and this video🥳
Also i'm sorry this joke was horrible
Thank you for the ranking I thoroughly enjoyed watching it, your videos bring big smiles to my face whenever they come out which I deeply appreciate
ahhh i’m so happy with this ranking! it’s kind of what I expected, but I love hearing more detailed things about their voices. Thank you for looking at The Boyz and i’m glad you’re becoming a fan!
thank you for the analysis and ranking of theboyz ! ive been waiting for this :) must have been scary HAHAH
YAAAIII THE BOYZ
Chanhee’s vocal color is kinda sounded like Baekhyun sometimes
wow I’m surprised about Kevin’s ranking, have you seen his cover is almost is never enough by Ariana Grande? He sounds amazing in it!
please do golden child!!
I'll hold off on golden child, until we have a little more to work with. But I will for sure do them one day!
Sangyeon leader king💜
Thank you for ranking them!! Wowww I’ve been waiting for a proper vocal ranking of them for two years
amazing video as always! personally my favorite voice is jacob's like its so amazing especially his high note in reveal (at around 2:38~2:44 in the song) and in shine shine with his iconic 'do you like what you see' part so amazing tbz are truly all rounded idols
Summary Rank
1. Sangyeon
2. New
3. Hyunjae
4. Kevin
5. Jacob
6. Haknyeon
7. Younghoon
8. Q
9. Sunwoo
10. Juyeon
11. Hwall
12. Eric
Cool! Wasn't expecting you made one for The Boyz. One of my faves.
Just curious tho, what group will you be doing next? I hope it's Iz*one
thank you so much for doing such a thorough and detailed analysis of tbz's vocals ♡ !!!
I finally have the time to watch this and I must say, I agree with your ranking and everything you said. Thank you for doing this
I still haven't learned all of the Boyz so hopefully this will help 😁