Switchbot Bot vs Fingerbot Plus
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 окт 2024
- Both the Switchbot Bot and Fingerbot Plus are devices that make existing buttons and switches controllable via your smartphone or voice assistant. Here I compare both of these devices.
Purchase Links:
Switchbot's Official Site: bit.ly/3f2tEF5 (Save 10% with 10UPAEL2CNLMHR)
Switchbot Bot on Amazon: geni.us/6gHW
Switchbot Hub on Amazon: geni.us/vHIMEB
Fingerbot Hub on Amazon: geni.us/Bnmm
Fingerbot Pro on Amazon: geni.us/BgSQQ
![🌟 Switchbot BOT (S-1) review. Smart switch button pusher, no wiring, and app enabled [445] ⭐️](/img/1.gif)
Purchase Links:
Switchbot's Official Site: bit.ly/3f2tEF5 (Save 10% with 10UPAEL2CNLMHR)
Switchbot Bot on Amazon: geni.us/6gHW
Switchbot Hub on Amazon: geni.us/vHIMEB
Fingerbot Hub on Amazon: geni.us/Bnmm
Fingerbot Pro on Amazon: geni.us/BgSQQ
I have Fingerbot and Fingerbot plus. After getting a Fingerbot plus to replace a broken Fingerbot, I was told I needed to upgrade to the "Mesh Hub" app. Once doing that integration through Alexa stopped working for adaprox, and the Mesh Hub app would not pair to Amazon/Alexa regardless of how I tried do it, and Adaprox support became nonexistent. Now I either use only their proprietary app, or nothing which makes the devices fairly useless to me..
Hi, if I have multiple rooms, do I need multiple hubs for switchbot? Shld I get mini hub or the normal hub to do this? Thank you so much for the informative video!!
It will depend how far away each device is from your Hub as they connect to the Hub via bluetooth. I've managed with one hub in a 2 bedroom house pretty easily
I wonder how much pressure/force the units exert, and if there are other products that have a stronger push. I also wonder what the mechanism is -- a threaded screw etc.
Neither are huge amounts of pressure but I’m not sure if there’s anything stronger out there either
@@MarksTechVlogs Thank you! The device I am trying to operate has hard buttons, thus, I might have to build a pusher from scratch from actuators.
Yolink finger
@@SmartySmarts Thank you, this one looks a bit more robust.
I am interested to know that if I dont want to use the hub how many phones can I connect to the Fingerbot at once? Can it only be paired with one device? I want to use it to push buttons on the garage remote fob and give bluetooth access to various colleagues.
I’m not sure if you can pair to multiple phones unless you have the app and same login on them but you can use it without the hub as long as you’re in Bluetooth range
Whats the limit of the sustain time option?
Love the mxpx bass
Can switchbot can connect to 3rd party bluetooth hub? (Tuya multi gateway hub) ?
I don't think so, Switchbot Hub only
Hi, is it possible to control this remotely, meaning i would turn switch from a distance? or this is Bluetooth based only so once i am out of the distance it wont work? Thanks
With both you can control remotely if you have the hub
@@MarksTechVlogswhat kind of hub do you mean?
The Switchbot needs the hub mini or hub 2 from Switchbot to work out of home whereas fingerbot have their own hub
Thanks for the video; it's nice to see them compared side-by-side!
I'm wondering if it's possible to use the app to program repeated presses... Say, a press every thirty seconds or every minute, and have that continue (when out of Bluetooth range) until commanded to stop. Are either of them able to do that?
(In my case, I'd like it to trigger my camera while being flown by a large kite. Related, but not so important, is there any significant weight difference between the two?)
I’m not sure about the fingerbot but the switchbot app has just added this ability in Scenes 3.0 (although I’m yet to test it out)
Thank you for taking the time to make this review :)
Hello. Please can you tell us how many hubs do you need with a group of fingerbots. For example: 1 hub per Fingerbot or 1 hub can control several Fingerbots. If so how nay Fingerbots can be controlled on 1 hub. Thanks
Hey, I can't find anything that says there is a limit for how many Fingerbots per hub however, they will all need to be in bluetooth range of the hub
Hi, I would like to switch on my computer remotely, not using wake on lan, from the office for example. Are these devices useful for that? Thank you in advance and congrats for the review!
It depends on the sort of button your computers have on them but in theory yes, these would work for that!
Hey, im considering buying something for the exact same reason (wake on lan doesnt work ). Did u buy any of theese products? If yes , could u share your experience please? Which products did u use?
So would you need a hub to activate once a day automatically?
Yes
I have 5ghz wifi but it has 2.4 as well, will the hubs for the switchbot automatically connect to the 2.4ghz or do i have to mess about with my router settings?
It may depend on your router but I’ve used these with my eero router which has both 2.4 and 5ghz networks with no issues or need to change any settings
At 4:43 the app photo misspelled the the word "Down" as Dowm...what else is wrong somewhere else in this product?
It does, I did point that out to the company and they fixed it…nothing else seems to be wrong 😀
You could literally CV glue a tiny plastic square onto the indented button and solve the issue of the switchbot bot not working though...
That’s genius! ⭐️
If you stick 2 together they can fight each other 👊🏼👊🏼
😂
How does Naran / Keymitt Microbot Push compare to these? Also it would be interesting to know how these integrate to Home Assistant.
I’ve not used either of those so can’t comment, I also don’t use Home Assistant but it’s TUYA compatible so if TUYA devices work on Home Assistant then this should
Hi, thanks for this - can you clone the switch to a fob (a garage fob)?
Do you mean use it to push a fob button? Possibly but you’d probably need to create some kind of housing for the fob
I'd like to clone the signal that the fob emits - if works for controllers (tv etc) but not sure if it'll clone a standard garage opening fob?
If it’s infrared then the switchbot hub 2 or hub mini should be able to do that as long as the hub close to the door receiver. Have you also considered one of these though? amzn.to/3RS3qoq
do you need the hub for zigbee connection?
Blutooth controller or wifi controller
Bluetooth
Are there any of these device types that work with Smartthings?
I’ve just double checked and Switchbot are compatible with smartthings
Do you need superglue or something to stick them to the device?
No, they both come with strong 3M sticky pads
will it mess up the system if I use switchbot and tried to turn on manually?
It’ll depend on what mode you have the device on. What’s your scenario?
I have read schedule use Can be done without hub for the switchbot bot. Please confirm.
This article suggests that you can as it doesn’t mention a hub support.switch-bot.com/hc/en-us/articles/13070869969047-How-do-I-set-up-the-schedule-for-a-Bot-
@@MarksTechVlogsThank you for the article. Maybe you should correct the video or add a comment.
It can be done without a hub. You will set up the schedule via the switchbot app. But, if you want to manually press the button and are not in bluetooth range the hub is required. So say you wanted to turn on the A/C from the car on your way home you would need a hub, but if you wanted to have your espresso machine turn on at 8am each day you would not need a hub.
I put a switchbot bot on my Door Buzzer for my apartment, and with the switchbot Hub can use google assistant to let myself in without having to use my keys.
Hope this helps!
@@alexcaggomg so helpful this is the exact answer I needed as I had the exact same question
does this work with sound activation?
They both work with Amazon and Google voice assistants plus Siri Shortcuts but you’ll need the hubs from Fingerbot or Switchbot for that to work.
@@MarksTechVlogsdo these come with its own hub? Or is that a separate purchase? (If yes, model?) thanks
They each require a hub, with switchbot it’s either a hub mini or hub 2 and with fingerbotnits their hubs. Links are in the video description 😊
Which robot finger has the highest torque? Yolink finger, switchbot, fingerbot? I need it to flush a toilet handle but the Yolink isn't powerful enough🤔 Any ideas?
Having used the fingerbot and switchbot I don’t think either could do that
What about a smart blinds motor.. seems like those are stronger?@@MarksTechVlogs
I ended up figuring it out with the YoLink finger and it works
Can the fingerbot connect to the Switchbot hub?
I’m afraid not
the fingerbot doesnt connect to alexa
It might be worth reaching out to them as it’s still listed as supported on their website
Does these work with apple homekit?
Neither work with HomeKit natively but using a Raspberry Pi and HomeBridge you can get them to
well I'm 10 seconds in and I thought I heard "finger butt" so let's see where this goes haha
😂 😂😂 that’s a whole other smart tech product I’m unlikely to review!
Yes but Switchbot you can connect on home WIFI but Fingerbot you can not?
The Switchbot doesn't connect directly to home wifi you need a bridge...the same goes for Fingerbot...they do a bridge to connect your bots to wifi too
@@MarksTechVlogs Thank you!!
Im gonna give the switch bot a shot because i bought 4 fingerbot plus' and all of them stopped working within a month. Im very disappointed in there product and they are not cheap
Have you contacted Fingerbot directly for support? Mine are still functioning fine so would be interesting to know what’s gone on
@@MarksTechVlogs no sir I have not I was told that the warranty was only 30 days , how true that is I don’t know and I didn’t buy them directly from adaprox. So I don’t know how that would work
Robot Head
Bro imma give you a pro tip im not a sub or going to sub im a buyer looking to see which one to get. Just put them side by side and show the best features of both. Im looking to see how fast they can press a button and how the app looks and works thats it. I don’t need a whole ahh college lecture. just show them working. not explanation needed .
I use both, can confirm, switchbot is rubbish....
I've got a fairly mushy yet probably quite stiff button on my dryer that I want to automate. I would guess FingerBot Pro is going to be the one to do it, if anything can?!