Between the recently departed Dr. Tim Keller and the also departed Dr. R.C. Sproul those two men delivered to me the kindest, truest, most heartfelt and intellectually stimulating arguments and teachings on the universal condition in relation to the univeral Triune-God. Dr. Keller was the most effective theologian on the relational humanity side of the equation I've ever heard. Rest in Peace Tim Keller, if it is possible and still an attractive idea at the time I'll look for you in Glory to thank you for your work.
Yes he has hope in culture and that we can affect it to change it and maneuver it. But the Gospel disappears in that he worries about doing more for the culture than for the Gospel. Preaching the Gospel is the power of God unto salvation. Not culture... American or any culture or hope in anything or anyone but God's Son.
@@wretchlikeme2506 I suppose context might be considered. He's not in a church service preaching a sermon. If you didn't hear the gospel maybe it's the listener? 🙏😊🙏
@@mikemccormick9667 he is well known for the( "Gospel" shaped life) that's his mission where he pushes to introduce that idea. Regardless of where he is. That's the context if it's something else it's just motivation I. Something to affect the American culture/community that is outside of our happiness.. That is not the Gospel, the Gospel is obscured greatly on our hope being misguided by our desires. There is no real hope in his message. Why.??? because the Gospel is not presented
You could spend your whole life looking for answers to life’s questions. Here Tim Keller give you the outline to save you much time and effort. These are the things that consumed 67 years of my life till now. Augustine, C. S. Lewis, J. R. Tolkien has it right about Eternity.
Pastor Timothy Keller always delivers such impactful messages. How has his teaching influenced your perspective? Share your thoughts and let's inspire each other! 🌟
I love how confident Keller can say 'i don't know' as much as the host pushed him. Indeed, Keller is a faithful man, he is Ok that he doesn't have the answer. Because God has ALL the answers. Thank you for Jesus 🙏✝️
When Francis Schaeffer passed, I often wondered who, if anyone, would then talk "sense" to the culture from the Christian world view. There are others, of course, but IMHO, Tim Keller has taken on Schaeffer's mantle. I love the intellectual coherence explained so well of the Christian system of Truth.
Thank you so much Dr Keller for this magistral lecture on our God given hope in this world. You said it so well and in such relevant terms to our post modern contemporaries. I prayed and thanked God for you the morning. Please press on.
The most profound and heart transforming talks I've ever listened to from Tim Keller. He was a bottomless well of wisdom and reasoning and am very sorry to have lost him from this world. Thank you for strengthening me in my hope and faith in the truine God.
Thank you , JESUS & my husband, for introducing me to Tim Keller, his wisdom and gift of communication, is now a valuable treasure in my life, and l pray, will be for, millions , that hear him now!
Pastor Timothy Keller's teachings are truly enlightening. What stood out to you in this message? Share your insights and let's grow together in faith! ✨
Wonderful message, however, the young people listening to this might not be able to relate nor absorb it the way an older person would; simply because this message of "nothing will really satisfy you" doesn't truly kick in until you've experienced life for a while. And when we're young we have plenty of energy, time and sometimes resources to fill our lives with entertainment and stuff that we don't really notice this dilemma.
Indeed we are here to serve others in need with the gifts and talent given by God. Don't sell out to Satan and the world and our own ego. Eternal life is more valuable and meaningful. We are not in this world for long. At most 150 if we were blessed.🙏✝️
What great insights regarding hope. I will be taking many notes listening to him again. I'm not Reformed but I greatly appreciate his intelligent presentations. I have never been disappointed listeneing to him. He was a great teacher. I find it shocking that other reformed pastors have attacked him, distorting what he was saying. Shame on them. The Reformed branch of Christianity lost it's greatest spokesmen. Even more so, he was one of best Christian pastors/teachers/authors of this present age.
I feel one of the causes of depression in our modern age is hopelessness and discontentment caused by disordered loves that have birthed our Hopes and dreams ,and when they fail which most do as Tim said we crush..This sermon is really great in addressing this Depression issue .Hope in God is for sure the best foundation as David said in psalms 42:5 ''Why, my soul, are you downcast? Why so disturbed within me? Put your hope in God, for I will yet praise him, my Savior and my God''..
We are complete in the pit of darkness and the salvation of God’s love. The pits of darkness are our delusions of finding truth in false gods ,gods of pride,death and physical things. There is no light without darkness or God without evil. Try having just pure love and you will experience pure darkness and in the pits of darkness we experience true hope.
50:20 Thank you for this question. It can be an exasperating reality, even for devout Christians. "How long, O Lord?" When life feels so tedious and crushing you would rather die, how do you keep going? When Heaven is the only good thing ahead, how can believers not contemplate immediate death as a liberation? There has to be encouragement and good things down here, too. I have felt this, and my life in Canada is comfortable enough, but when I start to think of my persecuted brothers and sisters whose life is basically torture for their faith, I feel so overwhelmed. Yes, some of them experience supernatural grace in their suffering, but others really wish to end it or fall away from the faith. This is a wonderful sermon, but these are difficult questions to consider. When the apostle Paul declares: "If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable." I really feel that sometimes.
How up lifting at this time living through the corona virus when people we love are going in death and life seems hopeless thank you Tim you’re here for this time some of us need your deep Christianity thinking
Mil Els I’m so sorry for your loss. Our extended family had been so “lucky”, as my husband of little faith, described our blessings. Then last year we lost his brother and our great niece, both people of great faith and service to the Lord, to the Kingdom. Both died of cancer but their witness was amazing. I’m sure many were brought to the Lord due to their example. A friend lost her older brother, her father figure, to what seems to have been a very virulent strain of the virus in Honduras. He was 84 but still working the week of his death; someone loved and admired by all.
Now we see dimly, but one day we will be face to face with Our Creator (His Hesed is present here on earth too).... I believe 💕LOVE RELATIONSHIPS LAST INTO ETERNITY.
claimouth I thought the same thing. Keller and Peterson are two peas in a pod in some sense, both working to address the big questions of life in different but authentic ways for the good of mankind.
maximsmaykillus dead Dr Peterson has been very ill, too. So many of the really great thinkers and men and women of God are leaving us. I was born and raised Presbyterian and my parents’ beliefs were so similar to Dr. Keller’s but I left the Presbyterian Church when it became soooo liberal. I live in El Salvador and I, a former activist with Democrats, see how wrong the World Council of Churches was to support what became a twelve year war here. The poor, especially the rural poor suffered so much and the rich, very little. Our son gave us these marvelous tablets and I woke up one day with one of Dr. Keller’s sermons. This faith carried my mom through twelve years of cancer, hardly ever complaining, never giving up on her rebellious daughter. I do attend a church Dr. Keller would approve of here in San Salvador. I don’t think Dr. Peterson has the faith in eternal life in Christ and his wife has had cancer. So sad. Please pray for both men. I don’t think any event in life has ever passed the test of veracity any better than the Resurrection, even according to many secular or even agnostic historians. Please just believe Jesus.
Tim Keller is one of my favorite speakers of the Gospel, now more so than ever. In 2012 I suffered a brain aneurism that put me in a coma for four weeks. When I regained consciousness, I said about my wife of 17 years, I'm not sure WHO she is, but I think I like her a lot. (And no, I don't remember saying this!). In 2013, the congregation I was serving when I got sick hosted a 'celebration service' that we filmed and posted onto RUclips. Run a search on my full name, "Charles Frank Kurtz" and you'll find it. Then tell everyone you know that miracles STILL happen!!! The fact that I'm alive to even SAY that is a miracle!!!
Very very well put Dr. Tim Keller on the reality of hope. I am better off after listening to this video. A quick lesson too from the interview: moderation ain't that easy, I found the moderator focusing so much to get all the questions and he ended up making Tim Keller seem like he was answering the questions to himself. Eye contact during the interview is very key.
16 MINs in. NO! I achieved my hopes and dream life and it did nothing but make me very happy. The cars made me happy the nice house made me happy, no financial stress made me happy and being able to help others less fortunate made me happy. Being able to give to charity made me happy. Rising to the top of my field made me happy. All my prayers were answered and god blessed me,. Hard work? yes.
Michael M Congratulations. I have a feeling that you, like our controversial President, have advocates in heaven who are plugging for you and begging God not to be too rough on you. I have no idea if that’s sound doctrine but hard work is, I think, a great way to love and serve as the Lord would want. While you’re still ahead, please listen to Dr. Keller. Jesus Paid It All. Millions of people here in El Salvador work very, very hard even though they have little to show for it.
DAN2014 Hay un FB que se llama Tim Keller en español. Creo que debería de haber traducciones de sus libros en español. No tengo traducción de subtítulos en mi tablet pero en mi computadora, si. Pruebe en un Cyber Café. Pregúnteme si hay algo que no entiendes porque en un corto periodo me he dado cuenta que Dr. Keller tiene muchas respuestas que ningún otro Cristiano tiene. He escuchado muchos sermones pero los de el son increíblemente acertados.
@@cottermcg123 tell that to the majority of Christians who think climate change is a hoax and that Jesus is going to come back on a white horse and make a new earth.
@@cottermcg123 you do realize that’s predicted by climate experts? It’s difficult to attribute a specific anomaly to fossil fuel burning, but the consensus currently is that it’s real. And relying on this Jesus guy coming one day on a white horse to restore a new earth isn’t evidenced. As much as I like Lord of the Rings. 😉
Please note that this comment takes root in another lecture where the comments had been disabled; as such perhaps some of the material I cover is not germane to this video. I like to listen to Tim Keller as a philosopher and a christian minister… he is going to present a well reasoned argument for belief in god….that only makes sense; if it were not the case that he could make an intellectually satisfying argument for the existence of God he himself would not be a minister….He could just as easily make money selling books that argue against god….. BUT Is the man a Christian? Can he present an actual account of Christianity? I want to argue that he is not/cannot….he is a very capable apologist, but the key to Christianity is faith… It is written For by grace you have been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves; it is the gift of God. In what sense does Mr Keller present faith? This is the way in which he and most use the term. Definition: and keep in mind I am arguing that this definition is utterly erroneous. Faith: (1) a belief normally having little or no evidence to support it / an opinion often formed by bios. (2) aspect of a world view based partially on evidence which has been by reason projected to a conclusion beyond that evidently supported often in the existence of god. (3) belief that also exhibits some degree of trust. Ok that’s the way the world is using the term and many that are self identified as Christians also employ the term faith in a like fashion….Just ask a christian/small c like Mr. Keller if he wouldn’t mind defining the term… In what sense is that a gift from God? All men/people have beliefs we don’t need God to form them you are forming one right now as you read this comment. So one can come to only one of two possible conclusions; either Faith as referred to by scripture is something different than the commonly held view, or scripture is ridicules. If the first Mr. Keller has at best a partial grasp of Christianity after all grace through faith is the end game no faith no grace no salvation. Or Christianity no matter the quality of the argument this man of philosophy can present is bankrupt…. Either way I don’t think he can be a Christian. All the same he may be though if so should defiantly not be a teacher. So what is faith? How, if so, does it differ from belief and why are the two words often seemingly interchangeable in scripture? Belief is one of the effects of faith so it is true to say that all those with faith believe but it is not true that all with belief have faith. The belief spoken of in Scripture if the context is taken into account will also present as something deeper….the best example I can give is the often misused statement (believe and confess and you will be saved)…in fact scripture says if you believe in your heart….which begs the question then what is meant by heart? Is it saying we really, really, really, believe? Cross my heart and hope to die? Again if so then scripture is ridicules, which I am very certain is not the case. The heart spoken of here is the core of the being, that aspect of a person underling even reason, the why a person might act in a way that reason would otherwise reject, both for good or bad, the spirit. The interesting thing of that statement is its assuming a person is capable of holding such a belief at such a foundational level. To do so would demonstrate the presence/condition of faith. It is also true of faith that trust in God ensues, but that trust is based in a personal knowledge of God, one can’t actually have trust of God without such a personal relationship. One could however trust in their own conclusions or opinions as often happens, and mistake that as a quality of faith while not actually experiencing faith. Bottom line what is faith, what is this gift of God? The second birth, the spiritual birth; that is what scripture is describing when it speaks of faith…. That is what Christianity is, a new life….lived through faith. We all experience a physical world with physical rules, does and don’ts, colors, tastes, sounds, brought to us by our senses….faith, the gift God gives is a new life full of different sights, sounds, rules, and experiences. Religion says come to god, believe, do your best, look at all that fruit. Christianity says God calls and those that responded are raised, given new life, and a new nature, the same can never die as they are preserved in Christ. It’s not about behaviour it’s not about works… It is written Therefore by the deeds of the law no flesh will be justified in His sight, for by the law is the knowledge of sin. If you have heard homosexuals are an abomination to God …that is a lie…the act is in that it hurts you the one God loves…..can you change is God asking, demanding that you do? ….NO….but in faith you will, possibly not fast, I am still in my sins but the difference in my sins and the world in theirs is; that mine are between a Father and son not a servant and court system…Mine are about love not rules. I know that out there in the world are Mormons, or Muslims that are convinced they have experienced god at some level….it is fair to ask why then would those experiences not be just as valid? I can assure you that given the opportunity to make an argument nothing would persuade those of the conclusion they hold. As a Christian I understand the spiritual world is complex, not every spirit is of the light. They are all however convincing. When a person has had that experience they become sure in it just as those who never undergo such an experience can never be. That doesn’t mean all are of God. What has been gain is not faith it is conviction. It is written Satan comes as a spirit of light…. We are warned to test every Spirit…not all do.
Let's consider who he is talking to at this moment in time. He is considering his audience. I do wish he had said at the end that in believing, you see. But you have to choose to believe, and that is faith. He may feel that those who seek and are interested enough to move forward will taste and see that the Lord is good and be led to faith in God.
@Timothy J Keller Tim Keller is a highly educated Philosopher whose bread and butter is argument. As Such his ability to form and articulate said arguments is superb but.....the author of this comment lacks those skills. As such I will assume you whoever you are, whoever you claim to be, you are not Tim Keller; and should be ashamed of yourself attempting to defraud people in the name of God..... I have decided to report your illegal activity.
Not at all. This person was a con-artist. I guarantee it. And I sat through a decent amount of his sermons. Very smug all the time. And he lived in a luxury condo all the while being surrounded by thousands of homeless New Yorkers. No different from a Joel Osteen or a Rick Warren.This person was actually the epitome of self-righteousness, self- centeredness.
![Born into Hope - Timothy Keller [Sermon]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/PNp4oQJ4Njg/mqdefault.jpg)
![Born into Hope – Timothy Keller [Sermon]](/img/tr.png)
![The Still Small Voice - Timothy Keller [Sermon]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/M38GY_fcDvg/mqdefault.jpg)
Between the recently departed Dr. Tim Keller and the also departed Dr. R.C. Sproul those two men delivered to me the kindest, truest, most heartfelt and intellectually stimulating arguments and teachings on the universal condition in relation to the univeral Triune-God. Dr. Keller was the most effective theologian on the relational humanity side of the equation I've ever heard. Rest in Peace Tim Keller, if it is possible and still an attractive idea at the time I'll look for you in Glory to thank you for your work.
Agreed!! He was brilliant and I look forward to meeting him in our Forever home. ❤
Just trespassing in this one.... 😮
I must admit that I was dazzled by the brilliance of Jordan B Petterson for a while but this man's teaching is on the next level.
Yes, Peterson I think is a great gateway drug to Tim Keller
He is the C.S. Lewis of this century.
Tim believes in God.
@@logofactory7730 *English please*
Pray for Tim and his wife through this difficult illness.
This man presents Christianity in the most cogent, intellectually stimulating way I have ever heard.
Yes he has hope in culture and that we can affect it to change it and maneuver it. But the Gospel disappears in that he worries about doing more for the culture than for the Gospel. Preaching the Gospel is the power of God unto salvation. Not culture... American or any culture or hope in anything or anyone but God's Son.
@@majafleur9646 😊😊m..
@@wretchlikeme2506 I suppose context might be considered. He's not in a church service preaching a sermon. If you didn't hear the gospel maybe it's the listener? 🙏😊🙏
@@mikemccormick9667 he is well known for the( "Gospel" shaped life) that's his mission where he pushes to introduce that idea. Regardless of where he is. That's the context if it's something else it's just motivation I. Something to affect the American culture/community that is outside of our happiness.. That is not the Gospel, the Gospel is obscured greatly on our hope being misguided by our desires.
There is no real hope in his message. Why.???
because the Gospel is not presented
@@wretchlikeme2506 🙏😊🙏
Rip Dr. Keller, God has used your life to touch many others. May this generation carry the torch well.
What an intelligent man of GOD!
Tim Keller thank you for your brainy sermons they speak to me every time!
mary taylor my wife says same thing, too wordy, but I love them, I hang on every word
EVERYTIME!
Our Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ is always exalted and glorified in the gospel-centered preaching of Dr. Tim Keller.
You could spend your whole life looking for answers to life’s questions. Here Tim Keller give you the outline to save you much time and effort. These are the things that consumed 67 years of my life till now. Augustine, C. S. Lewis, J. R. Tolkien has it right about Eternity.
2 of my friends said" u can do everything right, and life still happens " what a relief to hear those words
Pastor Timothy Keller always delivers such impactful messages. How has his teaching influenced your perspective? Share your thoughts and let's inspire each other! 🌟
Excellent, he changed some destinies that day.
I love how confident Keller can say 'i don't know' as much as the host pushed him. Indeed, Keller is a faithful man, he is Ok that he doesn't have the answer. Because God has ALL the answers. Thank you for Jesus 🙏✝️
When Francis Schaeffer passed, I often wondered who, if anyone, would then talk "sense" to the culture from the Christian world view. There are others, of course, but IMHO, Tim Keller has taken on Schaeffer's mantle. I love the intellectual coherence explained so well of the Christian system of Truth.
This man hits the nail right on the head constantly.
it is LIFE itself. wethout God, we lose LIFE
John 1:4 In Him was life, and that life was the light of men.
My heart soared at this message - the story is true! and my Hope is anchored in God. It holds me until I see him face to face.
These sermons jus keep getting better
Thank you Dr. Keller. This was so helpful.
Thank you Dr. Keller for your great teachings !
Thank you so much Dr Keller for this magistral lecture on our God given hope in this world. You said it so well and in such relevant terms to our post modern contemporaries. I prayed and thanked God for you the morning. Please press on.
I love Dr. Kellers clarity/description of love and how the disordering of love messes up Gods design...
So beautiful AND SO TRUE. Thank you😃
The most profound and heart transforming talks I've ever listened to from Tim Keller. He was a bottomless well of wisdom and reasoning and am very sorry to have lost him from this world. Thank you for strengthening me in my hope and faith in the truine God.
Thank you , JESUS & my husband, for introducing me to Tim Keller, his wisdom and gift of communication, is now a valuable treasure in my life, and l pray, will be for, millions , that hear him now!
He gets better with age!
Pastor Timothy Keller's teachings are truly enlightening. What stood out to you in this message? Share your insights and let's grow together in faith! ✨
Wonderful message, however, the young people listening to this might not be able to relate nor absorb it the way an older person would; simply because this message of "nothing will really satisfy you" doesn't truly kick in until you've experienced life for a while. And when we're young we have plenty of energy, time and sometimes resources to fill our lives with entertainment and stuff that we don't really notice this dilemma.
Jesus, Lord in heaven this cuts to the core! Thanks for posting.
Drive up with the new car you have a ppppppp
Hey bro sorry I’m late getting back on to you
Hey sweetie I’m just checking on my calendar and I have
Indeed we are here to serve others in need with the gifts and talent given by God. Don't sell out to Satan and the world and our own ego. Eternal life is more valuable and meaningful. We are not in this world for long. At most 150 if we were blessed.🙏✝️
What great insights regarding hope. I will be taking many notes listening to him again. I'm not Reformed but I greatly appreciate his intelligent presentations. I have never been disappointed listeneing to him. He was a great teacher. I find it shocking that other reformed pastors have attacked him, distorting what he was saying. Shame on them. The Reformed branch of Christianity lost it's greatest spokesmen. Even more so, he was one of best Christian pastors/teachers/authors of this present age.
Great talk. Thank you for sharing.
I feel one of the causes of depression in our modern age is hopelessness and discontentment caused by disordered loves that have birthed our Hopes and dreams ,and when they fail which most do as Tim said we crush..This sermon is really great in addressing this Depression issue .Hope in God is for sure the best foundation as David said in psalms 42:5 ''Why, my soul, are you downcast? Why so disturbed within me? Put your hope in God, for I will yet praise him, my Savior and my God''..
In believing, you see. Oh, taste! And see that the Lord is Good! :-) Thanks for the reminder of hope in truth.
HK IS MY FAVORITE PLACE BECAUSE THE PEOPLE GIVE ME THE GOSPEL IN 1996
We are complete in the pit of darkness and the salvation of God’s love. The pits of darkness are our delusions of finding truth in false gods ,gods of pride,death and physical things. There is no light without darkness or God without evil. Try having just pure love and you will experience pure darkness and in the pits of darkness we experience true hope.
50:20 Thank you for this question. It can be an exasperating reality, even for devout Christians. "How long, O Lord?" When life feels so tedious and crushing you would rather die, how do you keep going? When Heaven is the only good thing ahead, how can believers not contemplate immediate death as a liberation? There has to be encouragement and good things down here, too. I have felt this, and my life in Canada is comfortable enough, but when I start to think of my persecuted brothers and sisters whose life is basically torture for their faith, I feel so overwhelmed. Yes, some of them experience supernatural grace in their suffering, but others really wish to end it or fall away from the faith. This is a wonderful sermon, but these are difficult questions to consider. When the apostle Paul declares: "If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable." I really feel that sometimes.
How up lifting at this time living through the corona virus when people we love are going in death and life seems hopeless thank you Tim you’re here for this time some of us need your deep Christianity thinking
Mil Els I’m so sorry for your loss. Our extended family had been so “lucky”, as my husband of little faith, described our blessings. Then last year we lost his brother and our great niece, both people of great faith and service to the Lord, to the Kingdom. Both died of cancer but their witness was amazing. I’m sure many were brought to the Lord due to their example. A friend lost her older brother, her father figure, to what seems to have been a very virulent strain of the virus in Honduras. He was 84 but still working the week of his death; someone loved and admired by all.
I am a Chinese Christian knowing what he’s talking about
Now we see dimly, but one day we will be face to face with Our Creator (His Hesed is present here on earth too).... I believe 💕LOVE RELATIONSHIPS LAST INTO ETERNITY.
This is the most crucial sermon i‘ve ever seen! Hope replaces the biblical word for counterfeit gods. Incredible!
Excellent !
I love HK AND HKNESE SO MUCH AND THEY ARE SO CUTE AND PRETTY AND EFFICIENT AND SMART AMD HARD WORKING
This guy should go on a speaking tour with Jordan Peterson.
claimouth I thought the same thing. Keller and Peterson are two peas in a pod in some sense, both working to address the big questions of life in different but authentic ways for the good of mankind.
I just can't trust peterson.
maximsmaykillus dead Dr Peterson has been very ill, too. So many of the really great thinkers and men and women of God are leaving us. I was born and raised Presbyterian and my parents’ beliefs were so similar to Dr. Keller’s but I left the Presbyterian Church when it became soooo liberal. I live in El Salvador and I, a former activist with Democrats, see how wrong the World Council of Churches was to support what became a twelve year war here. The poor, especially the rural poor suffered so much and the rich, very little. Our son gave us these marvelous tablets and I woke up one day with one of Dr. Keller’s sermons. This faith carried my mom through twelve years of cancer, hardly ever complaining, never giving up on her rebellious daughter. I do attend a church Dr. Keller would approve of here in San Salvador. I don’t think Dr. Peterson has the faith in eternal life in Christ and his wife has had cancer. So sad. Please pray for both men. I don’t think any event in life has ever passed the test of veracity any better than the Resurrection, even according to many secular or even agnostic historians. Please just believe Jesus.
claimouth Both men have been very ill.
Claimouth, your statement is an insult to Jorden Peterson. Peterson is far more appreciative of scripture than Keller will ever be.
Char gave me a key... It's great symbolism! 😃🔑🔑🔑🔑🔑
Tim Keller is one of my favorite speakers of the Gospel, now more so than ever. In 2012 I suffered a brain aneurism that put me in a coma for four weeks. When I regained consciousness, I said about my wife of 17 years, I'm not sure WHO she is, but I think I like her a lot. (And no, I don't remember saying this!). In 2013, the congregation I was serving when I got sick hosted a 'celebration service' that we filmed and posted onto RUclips. Run a search on my full name, "Charles Frank Kurtz" and you'll find it. Then tell everyone you know that miracles STILL happen!!! The fact that I'm alive to even SAY that is a miracle!!!
Fantastic talk and brilliant interview afterwards.
I'm not a good listener, l can listen to u. Ex- Catholic, Born Again Christians. Our son who passed away, brought us to the Gospel Truth. 🇱🇧😰🇦🇺
Bless you, dear Sabah. You’ll have a glorious reunion together because of your trust in Jesus!! 🙌🙌💕💖💕🙌🙌
Sabah Amal I’m so sorry for your loss but Janet is right. “You’ll have a glorious reunion together because of your trust in Jesus.”
So Good.
Very very well put Dr. Tim Keller on the reality of hope. I am better off after listening to this video.
A quick lesson too from the interview: moderation ain't that easy, I found the moderator focusing so much to get all the questions and he ended up making Tim Keller seem like he was answering the questions to himself. Eye contact during the interview is very key.
TK at his finest 😚
For anyone who is interested, I think the J.R.R. Tolkien quotes come from an article called “On Fairy Stories.”
I agree
Anybody know if there is an MP3 of this talk? It's amazing.
His teaching is similar to my husband’s… interesting!
i.e. you always wake up next to Leah, not Rachel, in this world.
Well said.
HKNESE is my favorite because they are the ones introducing the GOSPEL To me in 1996 one year before they return to PR CHINA
16 MINs in. NO! I achieved my hopes and dream life and it did nothing but make me very happy. The cars made me happy the nice house made me happy, no financial stress made me happy and being able to help others less fortunate made me happy. Being able to give to charity made me happy. Rising to the top of my field made me happy. All my prayers were answered and god blessed me,. Hard work? yes.
Michael M Congratulations. I have a feeling that you, like our controversial President, have advocates in heaven who are plugging for you and begging God not to be too rough on you. I have no idea if that’s sound doctrine but hard work is, I think, a great way to love and serve as the Lord would want. While you’re still ahead, please listen to Dr. Keller. Jesus Paid It All. Millions of people here in El Salvador work very, very hard even though they have little to show for it.
Let’s HOPE all those feelings based on SELF continue into your much later years of life.
Hope? That must be Jesus Christ definitely 😊😊😊
16:52 bulls eye
Tim’s Next sermon here should be on god’s predestination of most to hell. And definitely do the q and a again.
The attack comes in September. They're out of time.
spanish please please
DAN2014 Hay un FB que se llama Tim Keller en español. Creo que debería de haber traducciones de sus libros en español. No tengo traducción de subtítulos en mi tablet pero en mi computadora, si. Pruebe en un Cyber Café. Pregúnteme si hay algo que no entiendes porque en un corto periodo me he dado cuenta que Dr. Keller tiene muchas respuestas que ningún otro Cristiano tiene. He escuchado muchos sermones pero los de el son increíblemente acertados.
Christianity seems a death nail to fighting climate change.
How so? If Christianity is true We should take care of the earth because one day will be living here again also it’s in our literal job description
@@cottermcg123 tell that to the majority of Christians who think climate change is a hoax and that Jesus is going to come back on a white horse and make a new earth.
@@zach2980 I think its too politicized and the facts are often ignored and change. all i know is its snowing in texas and that's not normal
@@cottermcg123 you do realize that’s predicted by climate experts? It’s difficult to attribute a specific anomaly to fossil fuel burning, but the consensus currently is that it’s real. And relying on this Jesus guy coming one day on a white horse to restore a new earth isn’t evidenced. As much as I like Lord of the Rings. 😉
@@zach2980 sadly science is extremely political. I'd argue just as political as the hall of congress or any other government.
A minister preaching of those living under some illusion? 😉
Please note that this comment takes root in another lecture where the comments had been disabled; as such perhaps some of the material I cover is not germane to this video.
I like to listen to Tim Keller as a philosopher and a christian minister… he is going to present a well reasoned argument for belief in god….that only makes sense; if it were not the case that he could make an intellectually satisfying argument for the existence of God he himself would not be a minister….He could just as easily make money selling books that argue against god…..
BUT
Is the man a Christian? Can he present an actual account of Christianity?
I want to argue that he is not/cannot….he is a very capable apologist, but the key to Christianity is faith…
It is written For by grace you have been saved through faith, and that not of yourselves; it is the gift of God.
In what sense does Mr Keller present faith?
This is the way in which he and most use the term.
Definition: and keep in mind I am arguing that this definition is utterly erroneous.
Faith:
(1) a belief normally having little or no evidence to support it / an opinion often formed by bios.
(2) aspect of a world view based partially on evidence which has been by reason projected to a conclusion beyond that evidently supported often in the existence of god.
(3) belief that also exhibits some degree of trust.
Ok that’s the way the world is using the term and many that are self identified as Christians also employ the term faith in a like fashion….Just ask a christian/small c like Mr. Keller if he wouldn’t mind defining the term…
In what sense is that a gift from God?
All men/people have beliefs we don’t need God to form them you are forming one right now as you read this comment.
So one can come to only one of two possible conclusions; either Faith as referred to by scripture is something different than the commonly held view, or scripture is ridicules.
If the first Mr. Keller has at best a partial grasp of Christianity after all grace through faith is the end game no faith no grace no salvation. Or Christianity no matter the quality of the argument this man of philosophy can present is bankrupt….
Either way I don’t think he can be a Christian.
All the same he may be though if so should defiantly not be a teacher.
So what is faith? How, if so, does it differ from belief and why are the two words often seemingly interchangeable in scripture?
Belief is one of the effects of faith so it is true to say that all those with faith believe but it is not true that all with belief have faith. The belief spoken of in Scripture if the context is taken into account will also present as something deeper….the best example I can give is the often misused statement (believe and confess and you will be saved)…in fact scripture says if you believe in your heart….which begs the question then what is meant by heart? Is it saying we really, really, really, believe? Cross my heart and hope to die? Again if so then scripture is ridicules, which I am very certain is not the case. The heart spoken of here is the core of the being, that aspect of a person underling even reason, the why a person might act in a way that reason would otherwise reject, both for good or bad, the spirit.
The interesting thing of that statement is its assuming a person is capable of holding such a belief at such a foundational level. To do so would demonstrate the presence/condition of faith.
It is also true of faith that trust in God ensues, but that trust is based in a personal knowledge of God, one can’t actually have trust of God without such a personal relationship. One could however trust in their own conclusions or opinions as often happens, and mistake that as a quality of faith while not actually experiencing faith.
Bottom line what is faith, what is this gift of God?
The second birth, the spiritual birth; that is what scripture is describing when it speaks of faith….
That is what Christianity is, a new life….lived through faith.
We all experience a physical world with physical rules, does and don’ts, colors, tastes, sounds, brought to us by our senses….faith, the gift God gives is a new life full of different sights, sounds, rules, and experiences.
Religion says come to god, believe, do your best, look at all that fruit.
Christianity says God calls and those that responded are raised, given new life, and a new nature, the same can never die as they are preserved in Christ. It’s not about behaviour it’s not about works…
It is written Therefore by the deeds of the law no flesh will be justified in His sight, for by the law is the knowledge of sin.
If you have heard homosexuals are an abomination to God …that is a lie…the act is in that it hurts you the one God loves…..can you change is God asking, demanding that you do? ….NO….but in faith you will, possibly not fast, I am still in my sins but the difference in my sins and the world in theirs is; that mine are between a Father and son not a servant and court system…Mine are about love not rules.
I know that out there in the world are Mormons, or Muslims that are convinced they have experienced god at some level….it is fair to ask why then would those experiences not be just as valid? I can assure you that given the opportunity to make an argument nothing would persuade those of the conclusion they hold. As a Christian I understand the spiritual world is complex, not every spirit is of the light. They are all however convincing. When a person has had that experience they become sure in it just as those who never undergo such an experience can never be. That doesn’t mean all are of God. What has been gain is not faith it is conviction.
It is written Satan comes as a spirit of light…. We are warned to test every Spirit…not all do.
Let's consider who he is talking to at this moment in time. He is considering his audience. I do wish he had said at the end that in believing, you see. But you have to choose to believe, and that is faith. He may feel that those who seek and are interested enough to move forward will taste and see that the Lord is good and be led to faith in God.
@Timothy J Keller Tim Keller is a highly educated Philosopher whose bread and butter is argument. As Such his ability to form and articulate said arguments is superb but.....the author of this comment lacks those skills.
As such I will assume you whoever you are, whoever you claim to be, you are not Tim Keller; and should be ashamed of yourself attempting to defraud people in the name of God..... I have decided to report your illegal activity.
Tim’s rationale tracks, if someone has desires for those of the same sex, there’s likely a consenting adult out there. ??
Not at all. This person was a con-artist. I guarantee it. And I sat through a decent amount of his sermons. Very smug all the time. And he lived in a luxury condo all the while being surrounded by thousands of homeless New Yorkers. No different from a Joel Osteen or a Rick Warren.This person was actually the epitome of self-righteousness, self- centeredness.
Why does he keep making killing yourself into a joke. This is the second sermon I've listened to of his where he and or others laugh about it.
Beward of Tim Keller. He is dangerous
whatever,leftard
Moron