The House of Representatives and Senate Compared

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 май 2024
  • Mr. Beat and Mr. Wernimont compare and contrast the two parts of the United States Congress- the House of Representatives and the Senate.
    Produced by Beat Productions, LLC and Matt Beat. All images and video by Matt Beat, used under fair use guidelines, or found in the public domain. Music by @ElectricNeedleRoom (Mr. Beat's band), Gunnar Olsen, and Otis McDonald.
    Here's an annotated script with footnotes: docs.google.com/document/d/1n...
    Sources/further reading:
    history.house.gov/
    www.senate.gov/
    Related videos:
    • Why Bills Die in the U...
    • Every Impeachment In A...
    • The Speaker of the Hou...
    Join this channel to get access to perks:
    / @iammrbeat
    For business inquiries or to send snail mail to Mr. Beat:
    www.iammrbeat.com/contact.html
    / iammrbeat
    How to support and donate to my channel:
    Subscribe to @iammrbeat & hit the notification bell 🔔
    Join for great perks on Patreon: / iammrbeat
    Donate to Mr. Beat on Paypal: www.paypal.me/mrbeat
    Buy Mr. Beat a coffee: ko-fi.com/iammrbeat
    Cameo: www.cameo.com/iammrbeat
    Subscribe to my second channel: The Beat Goes On
    Patreon for The Beat Goes On: / thebeatgoeson
    Connect with me:
    Links: linktr.ee/iammrbeat
    Website: www.iammrbeat.com/
    Podcast: anchor.fm/thebeatpod
    Reddit: / mrbeat
    @beatmastermatt on Twitter: / beatmastermatt
    Facebook: / iammrbeat
    Instagram: / iammrbeat
    Beatcord: / discord
    TikTok: / iammrbeat
    Merch:
    matt-beat-shop.fourthwall.com/
    www.bonfire.com/store/mr-beat/
    sfsf.shop/support-mrbeat/
    amzn.to/3fdakiZ
    Affiliate Links:
    Useful Charts: usefulcharts.com/?aff=12
    Fourthwall: link.fourthwall.com/MrBeat
    StreamYard: streamyard.com/pal/d/52723408...
    #apgovt #government #usgovernment
    Chapters:
    0:00 Introduction
    2:46 Who is in there?
    8:34 How they pass laws?
    11:05 Procedural stuff
    12:18 Exclusive responsibilities
    14:55 Impact and Legacy
    The United States Congress makes laws at the federal level. It’s the legislature of the federal government of the country. They meet in this cute little building, the U.S. Capitol. Members are directly elected by citizens in their home parts of the country.
    But did you know that Congress was bi?
    Bicameral, which means it’s separated into two groups, and those two groups, are the House of Representatives and the Senate
    At the Constitutional Convention in 1787, one big debate broke out between delegates of states with larger populations and delegates of states with smaller populations. The debate was over how many representatives each state would have in Congress. Delegates from larger population states argued that, since their states contributed proportionally more in taxes and resources, they should enjoy proportionally much more representation in Congress. Delegates from smaller states argued that, since they were afraid of having their voices ignored, all states should be equally represented in Congress. Thankfully, Founding Father Dudes Roger Sherman and Oliver Ellsworth came to the rescue. They created what today is commonly referred to as The Great Compromise, and it called for a bicameral federal legislature- an upper house to provide equal representation for each state, and a lower house to provide proportional representation based on a state’s population. On July 4, 1787 others at the convention got on board…I’m not joking…it was on that day that many of the delegates came around to Sherman and Ellsworth’s idea, and on July 16th the delegates officially adopted it…by a margin of one, single vote. Without that vote, there probably wouldn’t be a Constitution today.
    So that’s why there are two houses of Congress. But both are quite different. In this video, I’m going to compare the House to the Senate, with the help of my friend and fellow teacher Mr. Wernimont.

Комментарии • 744

  • @iammrbeat
    @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +462

    So which is better? The House of Representatives or The Senate?*
    *your voice will not be heard if you live in a gerrymandered congressional district (and probably not in the Senate, either)

    • @guywitcurlyhair
      @guywitcurlyhair 8 месяцев назад

      Both are full of liars and corruption, so honestly state legislature for the win!

    • @jakeconnah
      @jakeconnah 8 месяцев назад +22

      I think the senate

    • @ElementalSamurai
      @ElementalSamurai 8 месяцев назад +6

      will your voice be counted if you live in a guaranteed outcome district?

    • @Amibingus
      @Amibingus 8 месяцев назад +4

      Mr bean do something funny

    • @eldenfindley186
      @eldenfindley186 8 месяцев назад +64

      House reps are always vying for Senate seats, not vice-versa.

  • @EforEvery
    @EforEvery 8 месяцев назад +1136

    The simple answer: It took Mr. Beat a LOT longer to call every Representative than to call every Senator.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +165

      😄

    • @Momy69420
      @Momy69420 8 месяцев назад +5

      @@adityamishra6389 it was released early for members and patrons

    • @franciscoacevedo3036
      @franciscoacevedo3036 8 месяцев назад +3

      ​@@iammrbeat13:40 the Congress literally funds the Dept of justice/judicial branch so their co equal branch stuff is moot specially if they use it so they can ignore subpoenas about their flagrant bribing

    • @DeconvertedMan
      @DeconvertedMan 8 месяцев назад +3

      @@iammrbeat but that dude from starwars said "THE SENATE!" all creepy like!

    • @ToppieTygoTurbo
      @ToppieTygoTurbo 8 месяцев назад

      I think the house

  • @daveschmarder-1950
    @daveschmarder-1950 8 месяцев назад +109

    60 years ago this was taught to me in Jr. high school. I'm amazed at how much I remembered from that. Too bad I don't remember what I had for lunch.

  • @morganakira2045
    @morganakira2045 8 месяцев назад +375

    Thank you for your service, Mr. Beat.
    Both as a teacher and as a creator.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +51

      Well thanks for the kind comment!

    • @kevinumber7
      @kevinumber7 8 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@iammrbeatyou are NO teacher. LMAO.

    • @annoyedbrox4851
      @annoyedbrox4851 8 месяцев назад +14

      @@kevinumber7 he literally is

    • @cyrollan
      @cyrollan 5 месяцев назад +1

      ​@@kevinumber7 Citation needed.

  • @Liam-Carlson
    @Liam-Carlson 8 месяцев назад +227

    I always viewed the Senate as more aristocratic and “high-minded” and I guess that’s what the founders intended.

    • @3dpyromaniac560
      @3dpyromaniac560 8 месяцев назад +25

      Well, as alluded to in the video, the Senate is meant to represent the states. Originally it was meant to represent the state's legislatures and vote based off of the ideals/goals/visions of that state, think of how the EU is still a group of different nations; France for instance sends their people to speak to the EU commission on behalf of France.
      I personally wish it was still this way as it helped put more power in the hands of the states and put emphasis on local elections where the citizens have a much larger say do to the smaller and more localized voting base.

    • @joescrazylife8150
      @joescrazylife8150 8 месяцев назад +10

      That was until Mr. 17th came along

    • @3dpyromaniac560
      @3dpyromaniac560 8 месяцев назад +6

      @@joescrazylife8150 sadly...

    • @ginch8300
      @ginch8300 8 месяцев назад +6

      The founders explicitly said that it was meant to serve the interests of the upper class and safeguard them from the whims of the populace.

    • @olufemidavies2135
      @olufemidavies2135 8 месяцев назад +2

      I suppose it mirrors the Roman democracy in that way, with the senate for the patricians and the tribune for the commoners

  • @MinisDunyasi5
    @MinisDunyasi5 8 месяцев назад +167

    I think Roger Sherman and Oliver Ellsworth are underrated Founding Fathers. They were ahead of their time, but nowadays they’re overshadowed by the other Founding Fathers, especially presidents. I’m not saying they were better than the rest, but most people don’t give them enough credit.

    • @alonkatz4633
      @alonkatz4633 8 месяцев назад +5

      Couldn't agree more. At least the Senate added a painting of them to the Senate reception room, but they deserve so much more.

    • @thecongressman
      @thecongressman 8 месяцев назад +5

      Roger Sherman, especially. He was a signer of the Declaration of Independence, the articles of confederation, and the constitution. And he served in both houses of Congress.

    • @alonkatz4633
      @alonkatz4633 8 месяцев назад +4

      @@thecongressman But Ellsworth was also very influential. He pretty much led the Senate in the beginning, writing the Judiciary Act of 1789, and getting the first national bank off the ground. He also got George Washington to sign the Jay treaty and was instrumental in passing the bill of rights.

  • @daveowens271
    @daveowens271 8 месяцев назад +144

    That was actually a pretty darn good explanation of the differences between the two chambers! My wife works for our Congressman and it's really true about them being more connected. He regularly has "District Days" where he just visits different groups. My wife's job is to coordinate all of that. Most people of any influence have met him.

    • @froglady7491
      @froglady7491 8 месяцев назад +2

      Not only was it a good explanation, it was fun at the same time. People will remember more of it because we were more engaged. Thank you!
      As for the House being more connected. Just think of the average number of people each Senator represents. Then consider California with over 39 million people. Half of that is almost 15 million people. Texas, New York, and Florida are also in a similar situation. Now look at Wyoming. They have 1 House member for 580 k people, but 2 Senators for 290 k people each.

  • @BrandonHanson
    @BrandonHanson 8 месяцев назад +63

    Surprised the guy doing the Senate didn't dress up as Palpatine from Star Wars.
    "I Am The Senate."
    -Episode 3 reference.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +21

      Arggh...another missed opportunity!

    • @BrandonHanson
      @BrandonHanson 8 месяцев назад +2

      @iammrbeat all good, we love the knowledge you provide to us nonstop.

    • @kylewernimont3322
      @kylewernimont3322 8 месяцев назад +2

      I almost thought about doing this! Would have maybe made me too much of a villain though! 😅

    • @IaMaPh1991
      @IaMaPh1991 6 месяцев назад

      @@kylewernimont3322
      Just say it in McConnell's voice, he's already enough of a villain 😂🤣

  • @sambolino44
    @sambolino44 8 месяцев назад +186

    I voted for Jesse Ventura, the governor of Minnesota, who proposed a state constitutional amendment to make the state legislature unicameral (only one body) like Nebraska. His reasoning being that while bills are subject to public debate in either body, the final bill that goes to the governor for signing is usually crafted in a compromise committee, which is closed to the public. I support this idea, along with the idea that state and federal legislative districts should be created by independent, non-partisan commissions.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +65

      Yet another reason why I loved him as a governor.

    • @mikecollier7732
      @mikecollier7732 8 месяцев назад +8

      That definitely makes me look on him fonder these days.

    • @jeremym4451
      @jeremym4451 8 месяцев назад

      There is no such thing as a non-partisan it's all run by biased humans

    • @mathewfinch
      @mathewfinch 8 месяцев назад +14

      Jesse Ventura is interesting. He's pretty reasonable considering how absolutely crazy he is.

    • @JoshTalks11
      @JoshTalks11 8 месяцев назад +4

      Why is that a good thing though? Doesn't that have the potential to make legislature more corrupt (i.e., last minute private convos with money in hand subtly changing the bill)?

  • @charleswoolf6707
    @charleswoolf6707 8 месяцев назад +25

    From this Gov teacher - THANK YOU KING

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +8

      Thank YOU for your service. :)

  • @TheAndrewSchneider
    @TheAndrewSchneider 8 месяцев назад +91

    This was great! I could also have used a section on how members of each house are replaced in the event of removal, resignation, or death… which will definitely help clear up what happens in Mr Smith Goes to Washington.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +31

      I guess that has to be a separate video!

    • @TheAndrewSchneider
      @TheAndrewSchneider 8 месяцев назад

      @@iammrbeat Most certainly! #brendajones

    • @JZTechEngineering
      @JZTechEngineering 8 месяцев назад

      How is your comment from 1 day ago

    • @wiscopolo44
      @wiscopolo44 8 месяцев назад

      It could also be a short!

    • @TheMarianadealmeida
      @TheMarianadealmeida 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@JZTechEngineering it available for patrons and members first

  • @johnchessant3012
    @johnchessant3012 8 месяцев назад +63

    Usually politicians "move up" from the House to the Senate, but there are a few examples of politicians who went the other way, or attempted to. The most prominent is Claude Pepper, who served in the Senate from 1936 to 1951 and then the House from 1963 to 1989. The two recent attempts that come to mind are Larry Pressler (senator from 1979 to 1997, ran for the House in 2002 but lost the primary) and Rod Grams (senator from 1995 to 2001, ran for the House in 2006 but lost the general election).

    • @bonghunezhou5051
      @bonghunezhou5051 8 месяцев назад +2

      No one from Senate has gone on to HR _directly_ ! (eg. Claude Pepper became House member only after he lost his seat in the Senate)

    • @douglaskrueger3755
      @douglaskrueger3755 8 месяцев назад +1

      Uh, John Quincy Adams is not as "prominent" as Claude Pepper?
      He went from US Senate to Ambassador to Russia and the UK to Secretary of State to President and then to the House for 17 years. His years in the House are really much more impressive than his Senate (or Presidential) years, with his zeal for keeping the Union together and his impassioned opposition to slavery.

    • @johnchessant3012
      @johnchessant3012 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@douglaskrueger3755 I was only looking at the direct election era, i.e. after the adoption of the 17th amendment in 1913. You're right that former senators running for House was much more common before that, with other famous examples being John J. Crittenden, Richard Mentor Johnson, Charles Pinckney, and Henry Clay.

  • @royaltyblessed2454
    @royaltyblessed2454 8 месяцев назад +49

    Whether purposeful or not, the cheesiness of Mr. Beat videos is so on brand and appreciated by a Millennial like myself

    • @penonpaper3132
      @penonpaper3132 6 месяцев назад +2

      As a zoomer, I feel like the cheesiness is just inevitable. There are a select few subjects (math, science, or physics) where a teacher can rise above the cringe and make legitimately good videos on this platform. However, a history teacher making RUclips videos can never not be at least a little bit cringe. I think it helps Mr. Beat though by giving his videos more "character."

  • @LNERFlyingScotsman
    @LNERFlyingScotsman 8 месяцев назад +27

    Funny how the House and the Senate created and passed a Constitutional Amendment setting term limits for the President, but will reject a proposition introducing an amendment to set term limits on themselves.

    • @Shogun-my5nc
      @Shogun-my5nc 8 месяцев назад

      They passed a constitutional amendment because it was a precedent George Washington, a founding father set, a president stepping down after 2 terms. It passed by a supermajority as required by the constitution. There is no established precedent for senators and representatives’ term limits.

    • @coinbowl
      @coinbowl 6 месяцев назад

      hmm

  • @kalanlancaster6362
    @kalanlancaster6362 8 месяцев назад +24

    I love how you set up your videos that everyone can learn, like a classroom!

    • @instapizzabmx4206
      @instapizzabmx4206 8 месяцев назад +2

      Reminds me of taking online classes. I would be so damn happy tho if Mr. Beat was my Professor! 👌🏻

    • @ryleedjonovich8805
      @ryleedjonovich8805 8 месяцев назад

      Ikr! Funny yet well done and informative with clear info

  • @sergioventura2595
    @sergioventura2595 8 месяцев назад +10

    Never thought the house will be represented with fishing hat and a Hawaiian shirt

  • @anttibjorklund1869
    @anttibjorklund1869 8 месяцев назад +6

    More of Mr Wernimont please!

  • @ThaBobster
    @ThaBobster 8 месяцев назад +8

    This video was great!! Great job by the both of you! And the “at least we can both declare war” part was golden!

  • @Drew-dy4hc
    @Drew-dy4hc 8 месяцев назад +10

    Absolutely awesome. I'm using this video to educate friends

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +4

      That's amazing!

  • @richardnixon5068
    @richardnixon5068 8 месяцев назад +8

    I’m using your videos to fill my good half in on history and geopolitics so this is pretty much perfect. Thanks!

  • @Wingsaber
    @Wingsaber 8 месяцев назад +21

    I love the format of this video, definitely helps make educational content more entertaining 😊

  • @MLaserHistory
    @MLaserHistory 8 месяцев назад +3

    So the Senate is British and the House is American, got it.

  • @Bernie4life4182
    @Bernie4life4182 8 месяцев назад +31

    Fun Fact: Strom Thurmond is the oldest senator ever. He retired at 100.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +22

      And only retired due to severe health problems. He wanted to keep on going!

    • @MortanAMrk
      @MortanAMrk 8 месяцев назад +2

      No way people voted for a godamn 94 year old 💀, but i mean hey at least a triple digit senator existed

    • @Bernie4life4182
      @Bernie4life4182 8 месяцев назад +3

      @@MortanAMrk That's exactly what I was thinking the first time I learned that.

    • @DiamondKingStudios
      @DiamondKingStudios 8 месяцев назад +2

      I get the impression that he had as much endurance as his filibusters.

    • @SWLinPHX
      @SWLinPHX 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@iammrbeat Oh well. If he ever gets back on his seat he can run again (no term limits).

  • @TihetrisWeathersby
    @TihetrisWeathersby 8 месяцев назад +24

    The House is where thinks pass, The Senate is where they go to die

  • @zach7193
    @zach7193 8 месяцев назад +10

    Man, I find this enjoyable. Entertaining. Feel like I'm in government class again.

  • @sammysutfin1667
    @sammysutfin1667 8 месяцев назад +3

    Man I really enjoy your vidoes, been watching only for like 8 months now off and on but you really make thought out and well put together content. Wish I would’ve had you as a one of my history teachers.

  • @nategar412
    @nategar412 8 месяцев назад +12

    Very kind of you to say that Kevin Mccarthy is basically in charge of the House.

  • @JoshTalks11
    @JoshTalks11 8 месяцев назад +22

    Hi Mr. Beat, I think you should start a government explained series where you talk about how the US government works. It'd be really interesting for me as an American who doesn't know much (but should) about how his government works. You can even explain how the supreme court works which goes along with your supreme court briefs. Thanks

    • @eddiebellamy7605
      @eddiebellamy7605 8 месяцев назад +1

      I recommend the podcast Civics 101 made by NHPR. They do a great job at covering everything we either forgot or didn’t didn’t learn in high school.

  • @sydguitar99
    @sydguitar99 8 месяцев назад +8

    It is quite crazy how small population States like Montana and Wyoming can decide the Fate of hundreds of millions of people because of the Senate

  • @ElementalSamurai
    @ElementalSamurai 8 месяцев назад +14

    "did you know congress was bi?"
    *record scratch* *gasp*
    "bicameral that is"
    *awwwwwwwwwww*
    love it already

  • @Trich174
    @Trich174 8 месяцев назад +6

    Nicely done as usual sir!

  • @valeriag9443
    @valeriag9443 7 месяцев назад

    This is something I look up almost WEEKLY so THANK YOU!!!!

  • @jakeconnah
    @jakeconnah 8 месяцев назад +9

    you are one of my favorite youtubers keep doing the good work

  • @ryleedjonovich8805
    @ryleedjonovich8805 8 месяцев назад +4

    This video was just incredible in ever way, funny and informative, as a young man trying to learn more and more about the US government, thank you both so much! ❤🇺🇸

  • @davidfrankenberger4817
    @davidfrankenberger4817 8 месяцев назад +5

    Mr Beat, that was your best video. Funny and informative. Thanks 🇺🇲

  • @ScienceAsylum
    @ScienceAsylum 8 месяцев назад +4

    This was cringe-tastic and I loved it.

  • @theamerican7408
    @theamerican7408 8 месяцев назад

    That was awesome!! You made me feel young again! You are a great man!

  • @nasalegoboy
    @nasalegoboy 8 месяцев назад +3

    "Did you know that Congress is bi" is easily the best political joke I've ever heard

  • @Rubbly
    @Rubbly 8 месяцев назад +1

    I like how this video is formatted, very fun!

  • @zoanth4
    @zoanth4 8 месяцев назад

    Very informative and easy to learn in this format

  • @Virtusstrong
    @Virtusstrong 8 месяцев назад

    What are great video you two!, love being to learn while being entertained ❤️ from VA.

  • @jefferyjones7765
    @jefferyjones7765 8 месяцев назад +5

    This was awesome mr beat i have such a better understanding on how the house and senate works!
    Thank you!

  • @LiamOfficialIsGonnaEatYou
    @LiamOfficialIsGonnaEatYou 8 месяцев назад +5

    Here’s an idea for a compared video:
    Buenos Aires, Argentina and Montevideo, Uruguay

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +1

      Right on. Nice suggestion!

  • @violetscott5628
    @violetscott5628 8 месяцев назад +1

    I’ve been waiting for this video for years

  • @jeremiahabraham4216
    @jeremiahabraham4216 8 месяцев назад

    Thank you so much Mr Beat. Like your videos. This will help my visually impaired friend in studying American politics.

  • @MasterTSayge
    @MasterTSayge 8 месяцев назад

    I wish you were my teacher at my school. I didn't know all of this until Now.
    Thank You!!! 🎉

  • @matthewhedrichjr.5445
    @matthewhedrichjr.5445 8 месяцев назад +4

    I remember learning about this topic in Cary Grove when I was a junior.

  • @ObiCalmYouKnowMe
    @ObiCalmYouKnowMe 6 месяцев назад +1

    I learned so much. That was great. Thank you.

  • @chrisrae2238
    @chrisrae2238 8 месяцев назад +1

    A couple of months ago i left a comment and you responded 12 minutes later, that was really cool, it made my day

  • @jaewise6198
    @jaewise6198 8 месяцев назад

    Thanks Mr. Best I needed a fun refresher 😂

  • @darlinmanuelcasadoperez1092
    @darlinmanuelcasadoperez1092 8 месяцев назад

    Great video guys, I learned a lot.🙌

  • @JD..........
    @JD.......... 8 месяцев назад +2

    "Dad pretending to be cool" could be a Halloween outfit

  • @kurtJohnson1
    @kurtJohnson1 8 месяцев назад +4

    How are any of them getting paid that much for doing nothing?!?

  • @mrarganbright9964
    @mrarganbright9964 8 месяцев назад +7

    Beat, please do Minneapolis and St. Paul, they are the obvious cities to compare next! They're the Twin Cities!!

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +5

      But only Minnesotans would watch! lol

    • @mrarganbright9964
      @mrarganbright9964 8 месяцев назад

      @@iammrbeat Lol, I'm sure all the Texans watched the Austin & San Antonio one.

    • @benjason_94
      @benjason_94 8 месяцев назад +3

      im sure it will still get a decent amount of views, Dallas vs Houston got 1.3 Million views

  • @colinorryay
    @colinorryay 8 месяцев назад +14

    hopefully one day we can have a unicameral legislature, one day...

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +8

      I think that should be the long-term goal. It works well in Nebraska.

    • @JBaum55
      @JBaum55 8 месяцев назад +2

      I personally still think bicameral has some uses in a federal government, but I would prefer that most, if not all, state governments reform to remove them.

    • @EnigmaticLucas
      @EnigmaticLucas 8 месяцев назад +1

      I support a “sesquicameral” legislature (like what the UK has), where the Senate has the ability to introduce or amend legislation but doesn’t have the ability to reject it

    • @Y0ur_M0th3r
      @Y0ur_M0th3r 8 месяцев назад

      Sesquicameral?

    • @EnigmaticLucas
      @EnigmaticLucas 8 месяцев назад +2

      @@Y0ur_M0th3r I made that word up.
      The “sesqui-“ part is a Latinate prefix that means 1½.

  • @therealtony2009
    @therealtony2009 8 месяцев назад +1

    Love the content mr beast! Very accurate portrayal.

  • @DGAMINGDE
    @DGAMINGDE 8 месяцев назад +32

    I think you should compare US elections to for example Germany:
    - Both countries are incredibly similar in many ways. Both have a lower house (House/Bundetag)
    - Upper house representing the states (Senate/Bundesrat)
    - Both Bundesrat and US presidential elections us an electoral college
    - Both the US and Germany have electorates in elections for parliament (although the other half of the seats in the German Bundestag are elected proportionally based on party results, this distribution system is very similar to the system that is used for the house seats of different states)
    - Both the US and Germany have a system of federalism with state legislatures
    - Both the US and Germany have subdivisions like counties
    - The US uses a presidential system, while Germany has a parliamentarian system, normally if a party gets more than 50% their leader or another pre-determined prominent party figure will become Chancellor, while 2 or more parties have to form a coalition that represents more than 50% of the seats (Currently Social Democrats, Greens and Liberals)
    - German Chancellors are both more and less powerful than US presidents, as they usually lead a majority coalition, the house or Bundestag will normally not vote against the government and the government coalition can be sure to get the things they agree on done, however the coalition parties normally have to adjust their party policies to each other in a compromise and parties in the government can widraw and bring the government to fall, leading to new elections
    - Both the US and Germany have ministerial positions (Secetaries in the US and Ministers in Germany), its usual in both countries, that these positions rotate between people, but generally German ministers have much more power compared to the Chancellor in comparision to the US secretaries and German ministers and much better known by the general population, often being leaders of junior coalition parties
    - Liberals in both countries have some similarities in being generally pro-business (especially in Germany) and socially progressive, but this is seen as more left-leaning in the US and in Germany more as center to center-right, in the social democrats, greens and democratic socialists, there are 3 parties that are arguably more left leaning than Democrats
    - While in the US conservatism is associated with free-market capitalism, German conservatives are known for the buildup of the Social Market Economy, while but are capitalist system, Germany build more on independent instituations (publicly funded, neither private nor state owned) to regulate the market and a welfare state, while American conservatism are much more extreme against taxes and regulations
    - It is more usual for German parties to have state parties in all states (only Democrats and Republicans have state parties in all 50 states, while all 6 German major parties have state wings in all German states and it is generally easier and expected, even if the wings fail the 5%-state parliament threshold)
    - Both Germanies and Americas constitution share many fundamental right such as freedom of assembly and association, as well as seperation of church and state
    - There are some differences in priorization of rights, while there is slightly more freedom of speech in the US on paper, unions for example are stronger in Germany and have better protections, also richer people in the US and Germany of de-facto have more ways to shut down opponents with lawsuits
    - The US supreme court has 9 judges, while Germanies has 16, that are split into 2 senates
    - Alabama and the Saarland are very similar in ways
    This should be very interesting especially for people that constantly seem to claim that European countries very different to the US despite Germany for example after WW2 clearly has a system inspired by the US, but with a different and more proportional election system and bigger power sharing between ministries.
    I would also love to see American politics being compared to Denmark, but that would be depressive, because the Danish system is just so much better.

    • @Man-of-Steel674
      @Man-of-Steel674 8 месяцев назад

      I once saw a post that germany does not have a freedom of speech law bu something like freedom of thought kind of thing. Is this true I saw this in a Alt-right group so I am not sure about accuracy of this statement and I don't know enough german to read the law from the book itself.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +15

      I like this idea, but I feel someone else might to a better job with it since I mainly only study American political history.

    • @jonbojsenkvrndrup8180
      @jonbojsenkvrndrup8180 8 месяцев назад

      We Danes got rid of the two chamber system after WW2 - just one chamber now baby!

    • @DGAMINGDE
      @DGAMINGDE 8 месяцев назад

      @@jonbojsenkvrndrup8180 If you get rid of the 2% threshold it is literally a perfect system for any country in any situation.

    • @bobbywise2313
      @bobbywise2313 8 месяцев назад

      How is the power of the federal and state governments defined in Germany. In the USA the constitution as written makes federal powers limited and defined and state powers numerous and indefinite. We have got so far away that must people here don't really understand our federalism as written.
      So Germany has states and is also a state in the EU? How is the power between the central EU government defined. I realize the EU is not technically a federalism but unless powers are clearly defined the central government will gain power over time. The powers are clearly defined in the USA yet the central government is involved in all aspects of our lives today. The average person just assumes these are powers and roles of the federal government and even want more power given to the fed. The consequences of this are numerous but in a land as large and geographically as well as culturally different as ours one size can never fit all. That is the reason we have these division of powers. The same could happen to the EU but it would be the smaller states that really get trampled on by the central government the most. Germany has the largest population and is the strongest economically.

  • @Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation
    @Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation 8 месяцев назад +14

    The very institution of the Senate has always struck me as the opposite of *representative* democracy, which the United States supposedly is.

    • @Noticer333
      @Noticer333 8 месяцев назад +1

      Constitutional republic*

    • @Golladan
      @Golladan 8 месяцев назад +7

      @@Noticer333 Not mutually exclusive.

    • @Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation
      @Swedishmafia101MemeCorporation 8 месяцев назад +6

      ​@@Noticer333You do realize that a republic and a democracy are not different things, right? The American educational system is worryingly bad...

    • @FazeParticles
      @FazeParticles 8 месяцев назад

      Well that’s wrong. The US was created as a limited suffrage republic with a 10 amendment constitution. This notion of representative democracy is historical revisionism. And irresponsible.

    • @Shogun-my5nc
      @Shogun-my5nc 8 месяцев назад

      The republic of the United States is (well was until the latter 2000’s during major polarization) the very definition of democracy. The senate was established in the constitution, as elected officials of statewide elections. It gives power to the individual state as a whole, rather than a proportional system that may favor the minority party more due to things like gerrymandering. It was founded for a system of checks and balances, which certainly can function much better than having one parliament to settle disputes, which may favor the ruling party unfairly. I think it’s a great system.
      That being said, in this polarized environment, constitutional amendments and settling legislation that deal on massive scale simply don’t happen anymore as you need a 60% majority of both houses, states, and a presidential signature. Huge landslides don’t happen anymore.

  • @Michael-ip1sl
    @Michael-ip1sl 8 месяцев назад +4

    Fun fact my uncle worked in the staff of then United States senator from California Barbara Boxer

  • @gavinmarion4550
    @gavinmarion4550 6 месяцев назад

    Mr.Beat feeds my need to learn more about history/ politcs. I love thia channel

  • @jennifersalt3194
    @jennifersalt3194 8 месяцев назад +3

    Thanks for putting Civics education out into the world!!! I’d love to see Mr. Beat make a video on the responsibilities and duties of the Vice President. It would be a nice adjunct to this video, since you briefly mention the Vice President in terms of the senate. Many people think the Vice President is just on stand by mode in case something happens to the President-they don’t realize that Vice President is an office with its own set of responsibilities.

  • @frankstanley7079
    @frankstanley7079 8 месяцев назад +1

    This was a cool concept for a video. Having the back and forth reminded me of the “Epic Rap Battles of History” found on the early days of RUclips

    • @BelcarrigFarm
      @BelcarrigFarm 8 месяцев назад +1

      EPIC RAP BATTLES OF POLITICAL HISTORY
      THE SENATE
      VS
      THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
      BEGIN!

  • @scythal
    @scythal 8 месяцев назад +9

    I personally love your series on how the American Government works! I've definitely used the House and Senate as inspirations for the legislative assembly of my own fictional country (which confusingly also has a "House" and "Senate"), haha

    • @StrongandStable17
      @StrongandStable17 8 месяцев назад +1

      A lot of countries have a House and Senate so it's not a bad choice.

    • @DiamondKingStudios
      @DiamondKingStudios 8 месяцев назад +1

      Plenty of bicameral legislatures out there.
      Even Britain, who we declared our independence from, has two houses in its Parliament (not that Parliament!)

  • @gatlingrove
    @gatlingrove 8 месяцев назад +2

    Does Mr. W not have a RUclips channel? I looked him up and couldn’t find one. Funny guy. Seriously great video guys

  • @malafunkshun8086
    @malafunkshun8086 8 месяцев назад +4

    ‪P.S. Almost forgot to mention, Beat: ‬
    ‪Are you planning to do a vid on the non voting Delegates in the House? ‬
    ‪I think that would be a good one to explain to Americans, especially since they can’t vote but can still sit on Committees. ‬
    ‪Aloha 🤙🏼‬

    • @letitiajeavons6333
      @letitiajeavons6333 2 месяца назад

      Do one about D.C. Poor D.C. and Eleanor Holmes Norton have no vote and no Senators.

  • @jenniferdomingo1264
    @jenniferdomingo1264 8 месяцев назад +1

    Mr. Beat your videos are amazing.

  • @subparnaturedocumentary
    @subparnaturedocumentary 8 месяцев назад

    great vid as usual. idea for a video; any minimum age 25 representatives and minimum age 30 senators?

  • @timbob8977
    @timbob8977 8 месяцев назад +4

    Could you do a video all about governors? Thanks. 😀

  • @pghrpg4065
    @pghrpg4065 8 месяцев назад +5

    This basically rehashes 9th grade Civics class in a cooler way than was presented back when I was in school. Here is a topic that I never heard about in high school (and most know little about): the administrative state/executive agencies. I realize that would be tough to do in a neutral manner. I knew nothing about this until taking a State and Local Government Law class in a graduate program for Public Management.

  • @thinadlamini4671
    @thinadlamini4671 8 месяцев назад

    This will surely help me ace my test next week Thank you Mr Beat.🙂

  • @Zxardbar-ue6fw
    @Zxardbar-ue6fw 8 месяцев назад

    The Ultimate Comparison! Awesome Video 😎

  • @oldschoolguy80s
    @oldschoolguy80s 8 месяцев назад

    New subscriber here! Amazing presentation and great video. 😆👍 Thank you!

  • @thewempstinator
    @thewempstinator 8 месяцев назад +2

    It's almost like Mr Beat saw me NOT reading article one of the constitution 😂😂

  • @trentnorth6332
    @trentnorth6332 8 месяцев назад

    Hey, I was just wondering do you think you’ll ever do a video on all of the attorney generals in US history so far and what they’ve done?

  • @BiggestCorvid
    @BiggestCorvid 8 месяцев назад +1

    Very cool and very good will share

  • @tomhalla426
    @tomhalla426 8 месяцев назад +2

    I do believe the 17th Amendment was misguided. Having the Senate chosen by a different process makes it clear they are different, and might actually represent the interests of the states. Most “progressive” proposals were counterproductive.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад

      Especially Prohibition amirite?

    • @tomhalla426
      @tomhalla426 8 месяцев назад

      @@iammrbeat Definitely Prohibition. About the only reasonable proposal was the 19th Amendment, which corrected an error in the 14th Amendment, which presumed only adult men were eligible voters.

  • @augustodelerme7233
    @augustodelerme7233 8 месяцев назад +3

    Very informative video mr beat 👍

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +1

      I'm so glad you thought so!

  • @jerry3790
    @jerry3790 8 месяцев назад +3

    I really thought he was gonna be like “I am the senate”

  • @glenwest1911
    @glenwest1911 8 месяцев назад

    Excellent topic!

  • @user-ci8wx8zw2z
    @user-ci8wx8zw2z 8 месяцев назад +1

    I learned so many new things!

  • @edwardrhoads7283
    @edwardrhoads7283 8 месяцев назад +2

    Problem is with gerrymandering the house members no longer represent or answer to the people they represent their party first and foremost. And the people who pay for their reelection. And special groups like the NRA.

  • @aedanh99-jl8qd
    @aedanh99-jl8qd 6 месяцев назад +2

    what up Mr. Wernimont, didn't expect to see you in a Mr. Beat video lol.

  • @canadiannapoleon2203
    @canadiannapoleon2203 8 месяцев назад

    Pretty cool, I must say I would love to know if you're showing that video in class because it is something I would.

  • @juandavila4534
    @juandavila4534 8 месяцев назад

    Your channel is my very favorite :-)

  • @DanielKolbin
    @DanielKolbin 8 месяцев назад +3

    The epic compared

  • @toaolisi761
    @toaolisi761 8 месяцев назад

    Either Mr. Beat uses a great moisturizer or he's aging backwards. And this was a fun and informative video with a great collab.

  • @shayshayshayshayshayshayshay
    @shayshayshayshayshayshayshay 8 месяцев назад +2

    i love how this video made my entire 10th grade history class obsolete. he was a lovely teacher but damn this explains everything that man ever had tried to teach with the way the branches of government actually work

  • @BlurredUniverse357
    @BlurredUniverse357 8 месяцев назад

    GREAT VIDEO!

  • @malafunkshun8086
    @malafunkshun8086 8 месяцев назад +1

    Lol Beat, this was a good video!
    Entertaining….and Educational.
    Also love the loud Aloha shirt idea for the House (My Congressman wouldn’t be caught dead in that shirt, tho 😂).
    Aloha 😊🇺🇸🤙🏼👏🏼

  • @thelvadam7422
    @thelvadam7422 8 месяцев назад

    Loved this.

  • @alonkatz4633
    @alonkatz4633 8 месяцев назад +8

    I used to be strongly pro unicameralism, but after the recent events in my home country of Israel and hearing a great speech by Antonin Scalia (on American exceptionalism, everyone should watch it), I changed my mind. I think it's truly exceptional that the constitution can block bad legislation so effectively. I just think the 17th amendment could be repealed as long as gerrymandering is banned in all of its forms. The sate legislatures should all become unicameral though, like Nebraska, because there's virtually no difference in the election method in the two houses.
    But seriously, look up Scalia's speech. Even if you're not an American, it's still important and captures why America is exceptional.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +9

      Well put. I think if gerrymandering is banned I would be perfectly content with keeping the Senate as is.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +8

      Silent filibustering still needs to go though!

    • @alonkatz4633
      @alonkatz4633 8 месяцев назад +1

      @@iammrbeat True, I completely forgot about it!

  • @Momy69420
    @Momy69420 8 месяцев назад +4

    @Mr. Beat do you think that 25 year term limits for congress would be good or should it be lower

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +7

      12 years for Reps, 18 years for Senators, and 24 for SCOTUS

  • @TheRennDawg
    @TheRennDawg 8 месяцев назад +2

    I have read Article 1.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +1

      Good for you

  • @joshbethel417
    @joshbethel417 8 месяцев назад +1

    My own opinion here, but I think it would be a great idea to reform Congress with a big compromise Constitutional amendment:
    1) Liberals have wanted to expand the size of the House for decades, so let's do it. Let's double the size of the House of Representatives. That would cut the number of constituents for each House member in half and would make the House even more responsive to the needs of the People. We can tie the number of House Seats to the size population of the country too so it rises as the country grows.
    2) Conservatives have likewise wanted to abolish the 17th amendment and return the election of Senators to the State Legislatures for decades. So let's do that too. Let's repeal the 17th amendment.
    I think that would make both parties happy.

  • @harrypootis9519
    @harrypootis9519 8 месяцев назад +4

    That house has to be pretty big to hold all those people

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад +1

      Their offices are across the street from the Capitol.

  • @TrooperLITE
    @TrooperLITE 8 месяцев назад

    Your channel is making me a more informed US citizen.

    • @iammrbeat
      @iammrbeat  8 месяцев назад

      Thank you so much!

  • @PeterMichaels-hs4mb
    @PeterMichaels-hs4mb 8 месяцев назад +1

    You should do a top 10 politicians from every state's history.

  • @bssodeh-hb1xz
    @bssodeh-hb1xz 8 месяцев назад +1

    For non Americans it was impressive to wade through the American political system snd understand this side of it.

  • @jtgd
    @jtgd 8 месяцев назад +2

    He’s cute, and I like him, bring him back for more pls

  • @yoni-in-BHAM
    @yoni-in-BHAM 8 месяцев назад

    You guys are hilarious! 🤣