Hi - I have 2 separate channels on the harmonic pedal, one in English the other in French: If you're interested to know more about the 4th pedal, here are the channel links: ruclips.net/user/Harmonicpianopedal ruclips.net/user/LaPedaleHarmonique
@@andreszentay7446 Well actually it was a pretty good joke because Supa Hot Rekter is a friend of mine and he plays piano (that's why the comment was over the top) and it's a real coincidence to see him in the comment of this video, I wasn't expecting it. Just that. (Never mind, it's our kind of humor)
It's a good interpretation, but if I have to say something is that he's not keeping that long notes long enough... He just lets them go as if they were staccato or portato
@Jaeden Vaithianathan Pour moi, c' est pas top de tout piquer dans Bach. Personnellement je suis pas fan de jouer trop à la baroque, d 'une manière caricaturale en gros.
I have a piece request if at all possible: “The Lark” by Mikhail Glinka. Thank you so much for sharing your playing with us; you’re truly one of my favorites because you play with such passion and make the pieces come alive.
I've been having the exact same thought the past few weeks, and was actually going to recommend them to him on his next video (this one). What a coincidence. :p But seriously, these pieces would be perfect for a overhead playing/sheet music video like this one. They would make a great possible series after WTCII. There's such great variety in them too: No.4 in E Minor has such an enigmatic prelude. No.5 in D Major has a gentle prelude and a super joyful, quirky fugue (with a very catchy subject). No.15 in Db Major has a perfect concert prelude; very exciting and bombastic. It's fugue is also very interesting, it's subject acts the same way as Bach's "Wedge" fugue (BWV 548). No.22 in G minor has a cool, mysterious prelude. No.24 in in D Minor is an absolute masterpiece. The prelude and fugue work perfectly together, and both are expertly constructed. With emotions ranging from solemn and dignified, to unbridled passion. It's a perfect capstone for the whole set. This is my favorite interpretation so far: ruclips.net/video/7wNxgM-1DV4/видео.html That recording has the sheets going along with it, as well as timestamps for each one, so it's a perfect reference video.
Thank you. Just one observation, I don't know if it is my speakers or your microphone or that's the way your piano is supposed to work, but the higher notes, say from one octave higher than middle C, come out VERY loud indeed and at times that's the only thing you hear. Thank you again for your recording ;)
I just love your version and interpretation of this..I keep coming back to it for tips and enjoyment. The one I recorded doesnt come close to this perfection, lol! Can you do more P&Fs from Bach?
Great a good tip would be to pedal between the repeated chords int he first theme for less separation, also the first two mordants are four note mordants but the last two should be three note mordants, the way to pick which is to find which one’s starting note provides dissonance with the harmony. Just something I learned when studying this piece with my piano professor of Juilliard. Love your elephant playing videos very peaceful!
Merci pour cet outil d'entraînement; j'ai parfois l'impression que la partie jeu / interprétation est en décalage par rapport au défilement de la partition.
amazing. i gave up on the well tempered clavier for now after i couldn't succeed for the life of me to play any piece except the first one as well as i wanted to....
Hey Paul! Great performance as always. I would like to make a suggestion: Rachmaninoff's arrangement of the Gavotte from Bach's Violin Partita nº3 BWV 1006. Thanks in advance!
i know its besides the point of the video, but i just wanted to ask why your left wrist is labelled with your last name? fantastic playing as always, great technique
@@adamnagy1832 I disagree. In Baroque period it was normal to leave out ornamentation to allow for the performer to add in ornaments. I'm not saying he HAS to add ornamentation, but just because there is no excessive ornamentation doesn't mean Bach did not intend it.
There is no any F bemol in measure 17 but I see one in measure 26, and other in 27 for m. In fact there are some dissonances in this prelude that I don’t know where Bach got from. I know, he took from his mind, but are “insane” Those G bemol, F bemol, C bemol , D natural in the measures 24, 25, 26, and two chord progression at least in the prelude, by the way, one is this of the measures I quoted but it started some measures before. The other is related to this one but in opposite direction. They seem have elements of chromatic progression plus circle of fifths, but are very odd, in the good meaning of this word.
@@codonauta Yes - you are correct. I checked measure 17 and did not see a Fb; I don't know why I referred to measure 17. My mistake. Thanks for bringing my attention to my error.
hello I follow you from Italy and I find your tutorials very interesting..but unfortunately you have deactivated the subtitles and I can't understand anything .. I hope you unlock this situation to follow your videos fully ... let's hope soon !!
i am one of common folk and to hear what is obviously music at the level that's kings and queens of world should be privy to brightens my heart ..thank you for all videos with elephants I plan to study for my theories(told you a bit of Mt hypothesis on another one of your recent videos)about music may be a building block of universe just like atoms and electrons protons ect ect..i also three in some ideas about studying your elephants for signs of P.T.S.D and told you you could have all tights to intellectual properties encapsulated within that idea.but if you make any money from or are funded for research ,please share with local poor humans where your ate in name of JESUS..i went on to show that through different proofs I can almost unequivocally proof that through many masterful strokes and new scientific evidence that there is noise and vibration happening all over universe that is hitting earth and if we as humans could heat it all with the innocent mind of a child or animal it would and will be greatest symphony ever and GOD often speaks of a keeping a record of all sounds and utterances made.i believe we will all be gathered together for the most impressive symphony ever...so I thank you I'm going to study elephants behavior to see if there is information to be gleaned in their particular movements...p.s I like how you will play ragtime and Appalachian type music others with your incredible talents might scoff at because you know elephants like a snappy number every now and again..they must not be musical snobs and considering birds if a feather flock together they have put in a good recommendation on your behalf...ok thank you again..p.s do you have any brooding russian music you could lay on us...haven't been on classical music scene in about 37 years..used to really love it when I was younger,listened for like 10-12 hours a day don't know what happened..but I've definitely heard enough to see you are one of best on modern scene..In the old Hebrew some of words describing satan (i believe one of first being made and 1 of original arch angels like Micheal Gabriel ,angels mentioned by name)but in old original hebrew his name had the conigtation that he had musical instruments as part if his being..whatever that means...but in my theory of music being a building block of our reality..and there is music happening all around us as part of fabric of reality.....but not to go too far..thank you again and I'm glad you got gift of GOD to know who you truely are, most if like none of us get that gift so you must be special to GOD ...
what is harmonic pedal? is it one of the 3 common pedals?
Nah it's a 4th one, I think he did a video about it
Hi - I have 2 separate channels on the harmonic pedal, one in English the other in French: If you're interested to know more about the 4th pedal, here are the channel links: ruclips.net/user/Harmonicpianopedal
ruclips.net/user/LaPedaleHarmonique
@@DFADbeats hmm ok thank's for the info, but I don't think a non-pianist should open his fcking mouth so shut the fuck up
Le Mentholé wtf is wrong with you? Are you salty? Respect Mr.barton channel.
@@andreszentay7446 Well actually it was a pretty good joke because Supa Hot Rekter is a friend of mine and he plays piano (that's why the comment was over the top) and it's a real coincidence to see him in the comment of this video, I wasn't expecting it. Just that.
(Never mind, it's our kind of humor)
This is one of my favorites from the WTC II. I hadn’t heard it in a very long time. Thank you!
This is one of my favorites! Thank you for your wonderful interpretation, Paul.
Same!! So excited to see this upload!
Thanks, Micolash.
It seems if there is a whole orchestra playing. Paul is a Master.
Very nice playing, thx for uploading. I am currently playing this prelude and fugue. The temp is perfect!
Bravo! This was very enjoyable. I love seeing what your hands are doing while listening and following the score
As usual Brilliantissisissississimo
🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🏽🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
Such a great old-school Bach fugue
This fugue just gets better every time you listen to it.
A v beautiful, emotional Bach gem.
It's a good interpretation, but if I have to say something is that he's not keeping that long notes long enough... He just lets them go as if they were staccato or portato
@Jaeden Vaithianathan Pour moi, c' est pas top de tout piquer dans Bach. Personnellement je suis pas fan de jouer trop à la baroque, d 'une manière caricaturale en gros.
what is a portato
Yes but it can’t be legato too
I have a piece request if at all possible: “The Lark” by Mikhail Glinka. Thank you so much for sharing your playing with us; you’re truly one of my favorites because you play with such passion and make the pieces come alive.
Omg! I'm in love with this one
Thank you so much
Hi Paul! Have you learnt any of the Shostakovich Prelude and Fugues, Op. 87? I would love to hear your interpretation of them.
I've been having the exact same thought the past few weeks, and was actually going to recommend them to him on his next video (this one). What a coincidence. :p
But seriously, these pieces would be perfect for a overhead playing/sheet music video like this one. They would make a great possible series after WTCII.
There's such great variety in them too:
No.4 in E Minor has such an enigmatic prelude.
No.5 in D Major has a gentle prelude and a super joyful, quirky fugue (with a very catchy subject).
No.15 in Db Major has a perfect concert prelude; very exciting and bombastic. It's fugue is also very interesting, it's subject acts the same way as Bach's "Wedge" fugue (BWV 548).
No.22 in G minor has a cool, mysterious prelude.
No.24 in in D Minor is an absolute masterpiece. The prelude and fugue work perfectly together, and both are expertly constructed. With emotions ranging from solemn and dignified, to unbridled passion. It's a perfect capstone for the whole set.
This is my favorite interpretation so far: ruclips.net/video/7wNxgM-1DV4/видео.html
That recording has the sheets going along with it, as well as timestamps for each one, so it's a perfect reference video.
Thank you.
Just one observation, I don't know if it is my speakers or your microphone or that's the way your piano is supposed to work, but the higher notes, say from one octave higher than middle C, come out VERY loud indeed and at times that's the only thing you hear.
Thank you again for your recording ;)
Wow! That is so beautiful.
Is that a very well recorded piano or is it a software piano? It sounds great!
From now on i would address you as Sir Paul Barton.
Great version! Thanks for sharing. By the way that prelude is haunting...
I just love your version and interpretation of this..I keep coming back to it for tips and enjoyment. The one I recorded doesnt come close to this perfection, lol! Can you do more P&Fs from Bach?
Beautiful
Wow, sounds good with the harmonic pedal!
It seems like a great invention for this kind of music! (baroque, and classical era)
I am just about to start learning the prelude
Wish me luck
How’s it going???
@@samson1148 well I’ve been really busy with work recently and have not done any piano in a month so funny you asked
prelude is easy, wait till u learn the fugue😂😂
That Bach guy ripped this off one of Jem's songs called 'They'. Great playing! 🎹👍
Très beau et apaisant
This makes me want to take out my old Bach book but I know i will stop practicing in 5 minutes lol
Ahaha best one. Bach means love and hate at the same time!
Took me about 10mins to get the notes down so I think you’ll be fine
When you have to study a Bach’s piece, you hate it, but when you learn well how to play that, it becames very funny to play!😁😁😁😁
Great a good tip would be to pedal between the repeated chords int he first theme for less separation, also the first two mordants are four note mordants but the last two should be three note mordants, the way to pick which is to find which one’s starting note provides dissonance with the harmony. Just something I learned when studying this piece with my piano professor of Juilliard. Love your elephant playing videos very peaceful!
MÃOS ABENÇOADAS. Deus abençoe.
I didn't know Jem singer has copied beginning of "They" song from this.
Сергей Иванов Sampled*
JayBoo210 same thing
I was an idiot back then It’s not the same thing
fuck you man dont say that shit here man what the fuck man
Great interpretation! Just out of curiosity though, why do you often play the crotchets at quaver length in the bass?
Wonderful! Thanks for sharing!
Magnificent.
So glad I clicked on this.
Bravo!
Merci pour cet outil d'entraînement; j'ai parfois l'impression que la partie jeu / interprétation est en décalage par rapport au défilement de la partition.
amazing. i gave up on the well tempered clavier for now after i couldn't succeed for the life of me to play any piece except the first one as well as i wanted to....
try book one, number six in d minor. it was my first, it's not that hard to play, just have to put some time into it
Hey Paul!
Great performance as always. I would like to make a suggestion: Rachmaninoff's arrangement of the Gavotte from Bach's Violin Partita nº3 BWV 1006. Thanks in advance!
4:53 can really see you are having fun with this when you use multiple fingers for playing the f
I guess its for articulation
Brilliant!
i know its besides the point of the video, but i just wanted to ask why your left wrist is labelled with your last name? fantastic playing as always, great technique
He had a video about this a while back ruclips.net/video/UCwuZYG6r88/видео.html
Hi, the wrist ID on overhead videos that only show hands in for copyright dispute purposes, please see the video linked in the info.
ah, interesting, thanks very much! keep up the great work :D
Keep going💕
Beautiful!!
How to learn the fuga? 😭
Skill and practice
You don't.
Just practice. 3hrs a day for 5 days, memorized and ready to play. That is, if you're a professional pianist like Barton and I lol
@@jponz85a professional pianist learns a fugue such as this in like 2 hours. After that is when the work begins.
@DanielSilva-gc4xz not memorized and ready to go no they don't.
3:15/4:37.Там нота fa а исполнитель(ница)берет ноту sol.Почему?
4:53
Hello, i looking title of popular song which is on this theme from Bach praeludium f minor. Anybody knows this title?
Hey guys do you wanna talk about JEM - They?
Beautifull.
Very good... But I think you've made a little mistake at 4.38 . Measure 66. Isn't?
Great!
I wished you would add some ornaments to the repeats. Nice playing though.
I rather listen to it as Bach envisioned it, but to each their own. No offence to Andras Schiff's interpretation.
@@adamnagy1832 I disagree. In Baroque period it was normal to leave out ornamentation to allow for the performer to add in ornaments. I'm not saying he HAS to add ornamentation, but just because there is no excessive ornamentation doesn't mean Bach did not intend it.
@@jordidewaard2937 Some even criticized Bach for being too specific with his ornaments.
Paul, why did Bach use “Fb” verses “F natural” in measure 17? “Fb” definitely gets my attention.
There is no any F bemol in measure 17 but I see one in measure 26, and other in 27 for m. In fact there are some dissonances in this prelude that I don’t know where Bach got from. I know, he took from his mind, but are “insane” Those G bemol, F bemol, C bemol , D natural in the measures 24, 25, 26, and two chord progression at least in the prelude, by the way, one is this of the measures I quoted but it started some measures before. The other is related to this one but in opposite direction. They seem have elements of chromatic progression plus circle of fifths, but are very odd, in the good meaning of this word.
@@codonauta Yes - you are correct. I checked measure 17 and did not see a Fb; I don't know why I referred to measure 17. My mistake. Thanks for bringing my attention to my error.
the first part has some taste of early romanticism period, although it was written 50-60 years before.
amazing!!!!
what's happening at min 2:42, in the left hand ?
what is the 4 th harmonic pedal?
Excelente.What edition is the score?
Jem’s “They” brought me here
How is your practicing like? Your technique is so polished.
As Mr. Barton once said(typed) it's not about how long you practice for but what you practice and how! ❤️🎹
@@marcussfebruary9104 That actually is what he asked for.
I want to make a piano tutorial , I need a software like above . Anybody knows the name of software ? Thanks a lot
Please record Czerny Op.776 Impromptu Fugue
Its ok, but I have one question: Why are you playing in bar 66 and 67 in right hand of the perlude note G, when it starts with F and only then with G?
I noticed that too. It ruins the scalar line.
04:50
Can you play 2 concerto by Rachmaninoff?
0:10
4:53
hello I follow you from Italy and I find your tutorials very interesting..but unfortunately you have deactivated the subtitles and I can't understand anything .. I hope you unlock this situation to follow your videos fully ... let's hope soon !!
daniela spalluto he doesn’t say anything
nice👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
0:57
A note for myself
Oh my
HUGS
Slower tempo on the fugue would have been better to really amplify the dynamic contrast more but still AMAZING!
Glenn Gould la joue vite, et pour moi c' est le prélude qui aurait pu être joué plus vite.
2:08
And I'm sorry, so sorry
I'm sorry it's like this
Omg i have to play this in my 8th grade exam & i still haven't learned shit. The fugue is so hard 😭
Self-taught?
I was struggling with bars 16 - 20 until I tried right hand over left 😂
paaaul the entertainer pls I can't wait
I just wanted to get to 12 and will have a Ragtime break :)
Im sorry so sorry song... Bach lives in any form
in bar 65 Palu playnig ohter veriosn. not the same like in notes.
Mi inglish is whit translate google 😬😭
I came here from Adam.
👏👏👏👏👏
After Repeat 2:01 (for myself)
In measure 66 you played a g twice instead of an f
Any Anime fans here? No? Because an Requiem Aranea hears like the prelude
i am one of common folk and to hear what is obviously music at the level that's kings and queens of world should be privy to brightens my heart ..thank you for all videos with elephants I plan to study for my theories(told you a bit of Mt hypothesis on another one of your recent videos)about music may be a building block of universe just like atoms and electrons protons ect ect..i also three in some ideas about studying your elephants for signs of P.T.S.D and told you you could have all tights to intellectual properties encapsulated within that idea.but if you make any money from or are funded for research ,please share with local poor humans where your ate in name of JESUS..i went on to show that through different proofs I can almost unequivocally proof that through many masterful strokes and new scientific evidence that there is noise and vibration happening all over universe that is hitting earth and if we as humans could heat it all with the innocent mind of a child or animal it would and will be greatest symphony ever and GOD often speaks of a keeping a record of all sounds and utterances made.i believe we will all be gathered together for the most impressive symphony ever...so I thank you I'm going to study elephants behavior to see if there is information to be gleaned in their particular movements...p.s I like how you will play ragtime and Appalachian type music others with your incredible talents might scoff at because you know elephants like a snappy number every now and again..they must not be musical snobs and considering birds if a feather flock together they have put in a good recommendation on your behalf...ok thank you again..p.s do you have any brooding russian music you could lay on us...haven't been on classical music scene in about 37 years..used to really love it when I was younger,listened for like 10-12 hours a day don't know what happened..but I've definitely heard enough to see you are one of best on modern scene..In the old Hebrew some of words describing satan (i believe one of first being made and 1 of original arch angels like Micheal Gabriel ,angels mentioned by name)but in old original hebrew his name had the conigtation that he had musical instruments as part if his being..whatever that means...but in my theory of music being a building block of our reality..and there is music happening all around us as part of fabric of reality.....but not to go too far..thank you again and I'm glad you got gift of GOD to know who you truely are, most if like none of us get that gift so you must be special to GOD ...
When i played this i didn’t use a pedal.
Vaaauuuu
je préfère écouter le prélude en accéléré X 1,5 et la fugue en X 1,25. faites le test.
lol
A battuta 62 non fai le legature di valore
In-Case-He-'Forgets'-His-Left-HAND!!!??? >(*U^)< (Joke)
Beautiful, now stop chaining elephants
Bach with the pedal ?! Terrible !
All play without any explanations does no good to a student.
MÃOS ABENÇOADAS. Deus abençoe.
MÃOS ABENÇOADAS. Deus abençoe.