I don't understand why everyone in this comment section are criticizing for interviewing him. You don't have to like it or watch his films but he is allowed to discuss about his work and let his work speak for itself.
We are critisising him because this is a straight up ego-massage! 15:30 is literally a random compliment which provides no insight into his filmmaking process?
This is why I admire BR. Everyone should get the opportunity to say there opinion doesn't matter if you agree or not. Very well conducted interview and even Vivek Agnihotri agrees to that
this is like taking the interview for the Nazi propaganda minister Goebbels when you have a rising fascistic situation in the nation, decent analogy to consider I think
Wow! Splendid interview. The Best Vivek Agnihotri interview I have ever seen. Hats off to Bharadwaj Rangan for good research, good & relevant questions and making the conversation interesting. My favorite character from Vivek's films is Suniel Shetty as Rocker in Chocolate (2005)
I don't understand this hate. As an unbiased, credible film critic he's supposed to understand and encourage all kinds of cinema. To try dissect the motivation behind their films. This social media age riddled with hate speech disguised as freedom of expression makes it easy for us to quickly jump to conclusions and judge someone. Probably, BR wanted to bring out Vivek's side of the story to all this drama and chaos around his films. It's just his job and this is just an interview. Peace out.
An unbiased critic would pose questions and counter questions to a filmmaker regardless of where their politics lie. Baddy, unfortunately, has become part of the godification of social media
@@anandsharma7823 Baddy has always been respectful of anyone he is interviewing, and that makes his guests open up more than they would otherwise. To say he has become 'part of the godification of social media' just because he was also respectful of Agnihotri says a lot about how YOU think.
Not a big fan of VA on Twitter. But people getting riled up with Kashmir files is so funny. For that matter, the movie diluted the actual violence that happened. The movie gave a voice to the thousands who fled Kashmir valley facing the barrel of terror. Saying that their misery should never be shown on screen is precisely the same as suppressing voices that are oppressed. Raliv, Galiv, ya Chaliv - have people forgotten this call? Look up what it means! This really did happen. The incidents in the movie really did happen, and worse actually. The movie never showed anything against the minority. It showed a minority being oppressed violently, eradicated even, and definitely chased away from, a place which it once thrived in, and called its own.
His other works might be shitty but his Kashmir file was really good and hitting on point . You might call it propoganda but I have friends who don't even have any relation to politics have told me their grandparents went through everything that is shown in the film . And if you think Kashmir file is propoganda then you need to look at world where there is muslim majority population and minority has been asked to leave , convert or k*ll . Syria , Iraq , Lebanon Jews and Christians . Parsis in Iran . Hindu , Christian in Pakistan. There are enough proofs all around the world .
Yesterday we watched 'The Vaccine War'. Fact is, it is a beautiful film. Phenomenal acting by Nana Patekar, Pallavi Joshi and Raima Sen. As for Girija Oak, she is stunning.
Just by Interviewing him, BR has shown he not hypocrite or Biased. You can disagree, but let the man speak his views, that's the base of Freedom of speech. #RespectforBR.👍
We truly admire and applaud vivek agnihotri sir. I bought 5 tickets on 2nd October without availing buy 1 get 1 ticket offer. We are booking for our society members a Sunday show to support this kind of victory film. We are with agnihotri sir.
The Truth? When the bridge collapsed in Gujarat or when train accident happened in Odisha, he called both of them an "Urban Naxal conspiracy" . This guy will literally go to any depths to stop the govt from being questioned on a single matter.
@@gunjyot123 That has nothing to do with this interview.When I am telling about hike in the prices of rice you are telling about doom in the prices of pulses.Bloody Fool.
@@manoja9972How do u define truth and hate? Anti Brhaminism rhetoric is not hate, but projecting an event as it is termed as hate. What do u call Sardar Uddam Singh movie then? For me it was a good movie, but a white Brthisher and his sympathizer might term it as hate...
Hate against Vivek is politically motivated else he's one of the best director who has courage to show truth about Kashmir and real native kashmiri Hindus living there for centuries and just because of islamic terrorism Hindus had to fled from Kashmir valley only Vivek had courage to show that truth without sugercoting it like Bollywood used to do in earlier movie in which they used to glorify terrorists and terrorism. Kudos to Vivek and the team.
@@anandsharma7823 So, how do you criticize or show the people in the movie, who say "allah hu akbar", who said "kafirs have to leave kashmir", who go to mosque, organize protests around muslim identity, who takes support from paksitan just because of religion WITHOUT being called out as islamophobic?
when you showcase the issue as a problem with that religion, you showcase the problem without actually showcasing that the BJP(a hindutva driven right wing party) was in power in kashmir at the time, and their dear leader jagjivan ram chose not to do anything about it because the only way they know how to survive is to spread communal hatred. @@Astitha
@@anandsharma7823 I'm sorry to say that you are a gone case and brainwashed and seeped into deep hatred that you lack curiosity to even find the basic truths. Jagjivan ram was a dalit who was defence minister who liberated Bangladesh. Jagmohan was a governer who precisely came to Kashmir to putdown the flames. Jagmohan was a Congress man for most of his tenure. Just like how you said BJP is a hindutva right wing party, director Vivek called out Islamists in Kashmir
BR didn't ask the most important question there when he is said, 'he is the disruptor and always against the establishment' that, would he dare to do his disruption, if it is ideologically against the current government, from which he is getting all the support!
Because he supports the Govt, like you oppose the Govt ... only you should have that right? Just FYI, he current government is criticised every day ... not even a fraction of that was directed towards Congress, Indira Gandhi, MK Gandhi and Nehru for 70 years when clearly their crimes were much more Heinous!!
@@cookiemonsta6074 Every establishment existed or going to exist isn't beyond criticism. If Vivek is actually someone who's he pretending to be, he would be asking questions and presenting paradoxes instead of generating infuriations and fueling antagonisms. This is not a questioning of his right for freedom of speech, this is the criticism of his speech. And, for the last part of your comment, whataboutery won't get you anywhere. You won't move an inch forward. Period.
@@anonlegion8331i think he has been clear about his position, that he is propagandist just like others. And he is biased toward the current goverment. And he has been biased toward it and against left before BJP even came in power. But BJP provided him the space. He is openly ideologically right winger. He doesn't shy away from it. He is against left establishment. I guess. I dont agree with him all the times. But he is very opinionated. I respect that. He has a worldview unlike Bollywood stars who are clueless but will jump into anything for PR.
@@thethreespikes9737 Then he is not always against establishments right? He is contradicting himself. Moreover, just having an opinion on something is not respectable, and at the same time having a wrong opinion is condemnable. Also, THIS IS PR FOR HIM. He wants people to identify him as an intellectual, which he certainly not.
@@cookiemonsta6074 As a journalist, you are not support to support the establishment - you are supposed to hold power to account! that's what you bhakts don't understand!
The starting itself won hearts! ❤️ Thank you Bharadwaj Rangan sir for this .... I hope you too sigh a relief after getting out from the imprisonment of Film Companion 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
Why the hate, this man has literally interviewed Mohan G previously, obviously BR's intent is more so understanding these filmmakers rather than giving them a platform
@@anandsharma7823 why though? BR isn't a reporter or journalist to have to cross-question his guests or to even be a barometer of someone's morality, hell I don't agree with most of what Agnihotri passes off as facts but that doesn't mean I try to put a gag order on him
@@govardhanposina17 I think that the function of the press - which Baddy does fall under, given that he is interviewing VA to publish it on a public platform - is to question power, hold truth to it. VA is certainly a man of power - especially in that he has commanded audience imagination, and that he parrots what political powers today say - and as a journalist, he must hold him accountable for what he is propogating to people
Vivek uncle: There is no Truth. Also Vivek uncle: We'll bring out the truth. Vivek uncle is like Nathuram Godse. He would contradict himself before anyone else could.
Thanks a tonne for inviting him! Always a joy listening to Mr. Agnihotri and eagerly waiting for The Vaccine War and the Delhi Files, what a brilliant film maker and an even more wonderful human being.
@@anandsharma7823 Man you're literally copy pasting the same thing under every fn comment, seems like you gotta a lot of free times in your hands huh lol
even if vivek consciously is using unjustifiably selective facts and unjustifiably being biased to show his fair choice of making his subjective specific political stories, that doesnt mean there is no potential of making political stories others than the mainstream stories by the westernized elite who use self labels like liberal progressive leftists. Infact the fact that from the very beginning their was a monopoly of specific political stories contributed to the lack of development of alternative political stories relative to the mainstream. Also I think the use of political spectrum is just for convenience of the mind to use labels and categories , but unfortunately most people think that they have to think and act exactly according to a strict labelled group which they think they are in rather than creating their world view from ground up, in fact i think most people other than actual honest geniuses should just live their personal life and learn from that and always try to better themselves, rather than trying to pretend some global social scientist intellectual who feed their ego and give them a sense of purpose and think they are better than others while being in a closed labelled group
After this interview, Baddy is easily the best film journalist in India. Not that I am aware of all film journalists, but mad respect for Baddy, unbiased to the core!
I don't hate him but he contradicts himself too much , for example while explaining impact of his movies he cited that before tashkent files , when PM will tweet about Gandhi and shastri , gandhi's tweet would get more retweets than tweet about shastri but after his movie it has reversed. Now after few minutes he says i don't take social media seriously and it's a circus. Have a opinion and stick to it , don't swing both ways.
I don't intend to watch Vivek Agnihotri films anytime soon, disagree with him on almost everything, but love that BR is interviewing him. He spoke to Kangana as well sometime back. It's his job to interview people with no, or at least as less, bias as possible. Does it brilliantly.
VERY GOOD INTERVIEW OF AN AMAZING FILMMAKER WHO IS DARING...! The Vaccine war is gonna be a great film and anti nationalists can continue to scream..! Nobody cares.! India is going ahead..!!! The local political people will find it a difficult pill to swallow. !
It is so funny that a person who make films for current ruling party needs and given a yz+ security whereas so many number of people who criticize government live under threats without any security.
He picked a subject based on Kashmir unrest and Insurgency. Which is not over yet and it won't take those dadi walas across the border to divert one 72 Hoor seeker towards him whereas Govt is accountable for its action. It has to allow narrative that puts them on bad light, or else they will b questioned by the UN
Disappointed that Baddy didn't ask even a single critical question/did any cross-questioning but anyways by playing it straight and not fawning over him, the interview still has value and you get to know the person and how he views the world.
Telugu audiences absolutely love this director and his dear producer Abhishek Agrawal because they're all about celebrating propaganda movies. Karthikeya 2. Tiger and India House loading with Anupam Kher 💀
What propoganda? The film is an ode to India's scientists. Particularly women scientists. Phenomenal acting by Nana Patekar, Pallavi Joshi and Raima Sen. As for Girija Oak, she is stunning. Why should we not give credit where it is true.
Request mr. Vivek to kindly enrol in a film school or work with some director as asst to learn basics of how to make boring movies as engaging. Saw his movie for few mins. Such a lame woke boring screenplay man😂 even a baby's writing will look better than him..
Yes. Many can. This film is an ode to India's scientists. Particularly women scientists. Phenomenal acting by Nana Patekar, Pallavi Joshi and Raima Sen. As for Girija Oak, she is stunning. Giving credit where it is due is very important. Blind hate is very sad. Dr. Priya Abraham, Dr. Balram Bhargav deserve to be celebrated. We are alive because of great scientists like them.
I've lost respect for you today Baradwaj Rangan. The unnecessary flattery at 16:45 , the complete lack of any contrarian questioning, the relentless sucking up -- not cool.
Nobody is worried about you losing respect on BR. BR is BR, not Anupama Chopra. He is the real neutral. He Celebrates everyone in equal measure. He Celebrates Pa. Ranjith (he sucks upto him like anything) and Vivek Agnihotri. Your cancellation of some people based on the tropes you believe, is your problem. Not BRs. Goto Film Companion if you want to be legitimise your hate and leave BR to genuine Cimema lovers to us.
Ismein Anupama Chopra kahaan se aa gayi? Film Companion kahaan se aa gaya? My engagement with BR is limited to my engagement with him, not with anyone else. And as someone who has followed his work since his HIndu days, I believe that I should be able to vocalise my disappointment with his reportage, simply as a consumer of his work. @@curiouswanderer793
Sir pls don't interview these types of directors ...I am sharing an experience of the movie directed by him, I am not watching the trailer of the movie directed by him even for a minute.. The name of the movie was The Kashmir File....propaganda based director
If exodus of Kashmiri pandits in 1990 is fake, propaganda then the 2022 killing of tailor in udaipur, Rajasthan is also a propaganda, created by media to malign muslims. Agree ??
BR doing everything in his power to make us dislike him these days right from that positive Bawaal/Gadar reviews to now interviewing a propagandist bootlicker (also a subpar filmmaker nonetheless).
For all his neutral stand, did BR ask any question on how this man's movie flamed division and hate in India, with open calls of violence inside the theaters? Vivek Agnihotri monetised & weaponised the suffering of a community to spread hate. In his latest movie also, in his own words, he is hardly interested in patients, doctors or those who died during CoVid. He is only interested in defending the Government's interests & cover up the entire failure that was second wave of CoVid. BR giving him a platform to air his lame defenses is enabling/legitimising his propaganda. It is not like Vivek Agnihotri did not have other plarforms to talk. His fredom of expression is definitely not in danger. As a well known critic with so much SM influence, BR should have been more responsible. Extremely disappointed.
@@FreddieMurphy746 nobody in the world should be spared from questioning if they are given a platform. Nobody is saying he should not be given a platform. All meenakshy is saying is that he must also be questioned about the result his movies have
Yes. It has been mentioned time and time again - before elections, in the media, and even by the left wing - it's just that the right wing only understands social issues when portrayed as a threat to their own existence@@Besties591
I knew baddy will eventually sell his soul working for a platform that's so whorish like Galatta....that said him giving credibility and a platform to directors like this bigot really makes you sad....all his good work feels tainted.... Unsubscribe.... Take care BR.... wish you didn't sell out like this.... Thought u had integrity unlike the rest, alas.
I don't understand why everyone in this comment section are criticizing for interviewing him. You don't have to like it or watch his films but he is allowed to discuss about his work and let his work speak for itself.
Mostly these guys are Congress and Bollywood sponsored trolls
@@ghattamanenimahesh8814 you can do that just like how an individual wants to run his youtube channel.
True liberals are indian right wing
We are critisising him because this is a straight up ego-massage! 15:30 is literally a random compliment which provides no insight into his filmmaking process?
This is exactly happening when someone talk (left) ideology north India ... this is time to give it back
This is why I admire BR. Everyone should get the opportunity to say there opinion doesn't matter if you agree or not. Very well conducted interview and even Vivek Agnihotri agrees to that
BR also got paid in the process, let's not forget that. It is totally his prerogative who to work with and where to earn from.
this is like taking the interview for the Nazi propaganda minister Goebbels when you have a rising fascistic situation in the nation, decent analogy to consider I think
Wow! Splendid interview. The Best Vivek Agnihotri interview I have ever seen. Hats off to Bharadwaj Rangan for good research, good & relevant questions and making the conversation interesting.
My favorite character from Vivek's films is Suniel Shetty as Rocker in Chocolate (2005)
chocolate was indeed a true fdisplay of his calibre of filmmaking. he should have stuck to that only.
@@anandsharma7823 Isn't chocolate remake of the usual suspects?
I appreciate you for giving an equal platform for all types of directors and not restricting yourself due to personal ideologies.
I don't understand this hate. As an unbiased, credible film critic he's supposed to understand and encourage all kinds of cinema. To try dissect the motivation behind their films. This social media age riddled with hate speech disguised as freedom of expression makes it easy for us to quickly jump to conclusions and judge someone. Probably, BR wanted to bring out Vivek's side of the story to all this drama and chaos around his films. It's just his job and this is just an interview. Peace out.
Exactly...I don't understand why ppl hate him so much
These guys are mostly paid trolls sponsord by Bollywood ecosystem, congress etc
Marxism is an ideology whose main basis is hatred of successful people.
What’s so hard to understand?
An unbiased critic would pose questions and counter questions to a filmmaker regardless of where their politics lie. Baddy, unfortunately, has become part of the godification of social media
@@anandsharma7823 Baddy has always been respectful of anyone he is interviewing, and that makes his guests open up more than they would otherwise. To say he has become 'part of the godification of social media' just because he was also respectful of Agnihotri says a lot about how YOU think.
Great interview. All the best Vivek. Political ideologies should not take away credit from any artist. Glad Galata plus gave him a voice.
Art is politics - if your politics are rotten, your art must be viewed as a part of that same rotten whole.
Okay if you consider art as politics, then every political ideology needs to be given platform and voice to be heard.@@anandsharma7823
@@anandsharma7823 How can you consider his politics as rotten ?
Love you Bhardwaj sir.i didn't think we could ever see any self claimed critic wanting to give space to voices like VRA .Loved this interview
Deep respect for u sir. You did something nobody dares to do sir. Very proud of u hats off
Not a big fan of VA on Twitter. But people getting riled up with Kashmir files is so funny. For that matter, the movie diluted the actual violence that happened. The movie gave a voice to the thousands who fled Kashmir valley facing the barrel of terror. Saying that their misery should never be shown on screen is precisely the same as suppressing voices that are oppressed.
Raliv, Galiv, ya Chaliv - have people forgotten this call? Look up what it means! This really did happen. The incidents in the movie really did happen, and worse actually.
The movie never showed anything against the minority. It showed a minority being oppressed violently, eradicated even, and definitely chased away from, a place which it once thrived in, and called its own.
Thank you for this unexpected pleasure. The film is an ode to India's scientists. Hating on because of political compulsions is very sad.
Beautiful film. Watched it yesterday. Phenomenal acting by Nana Patekar, Pallavi Joshi and Raima Sen. As for Girija Oak, she is stunning.
His other works might be shitty but his Kashmir file was really good and hitting on point . You might call it propoganda but I have friends who don't even have any relation to politics have told me their grandparents went through everything that is shown in the film . And if you think Kashmir file is propoganda then you need to look at world where there is muslim majority population and minority has been asked to leave , convert or k*ll . Syria , Iraq , Lebanon Jews and Christians . Parsis in Iran . Hindu , Christian in Pakistan. There are enough proofs all around the world .
I have to disagree with you here - it was shoddy, base filmmaking, with incorrect facts
@@anandsharma7823fake id spammer
Yesterday we watched 'The Vaccine War'. Fact is, it is a beautiful film. Phenomenal acting by Nana Patekar, Pallavi Joshi and Raima Sen. As for Girija Oak, she is stunning.
Just by Interviewing him, BR has shown he not hypocrite or Biased. You can disagree, but let the man speak his views, that's the base of Freedom of speech. #RespectforBR.👍
We truly admire and applaud vivek agnihotri sir. I bought 5 tickets on 2nd October without availing buy 1 get 1 ticket offer. We are booking for our society members a Sunday show to support this kind of victory film. We are with agnihotri sir.
I want to see one full version of this interview with just BR’s face and him reacting while I hear VA talk. Pretty please.
"No one is more hated than Who He Speaks The Truth."
-PLATO
@@manoja9972 Hmmm So Genocides of Kashmir Hindus has never happened.Fine🙏
The Truth? When the bridge collapsed in Gujarat or when train accident happened in Odisha, he called both of them an "Urban Naxal conspiracy" . This guy will literally go to any depths to stop the govt from being questioned on a single matter.
@@gunjyot123 That has nothing to do with this interview.When I am telling about hike in the prices of rice you are telling about doom in the prices of pulses.Bloody Fool.
@@manoja9972How do u define truth and hate? Anti Brhaminism rhetoric is not hate, but projecting an event as it is termed as hate. What do u call Sardar Uddam Singh movie then? For me it was a good movie, but a white Brthisher and his sympathizer might term it as hate...
Which is why everyone brings up Arundhati Roy when we question VA
Hate against Vivek is politically motivated else he's one of the best director who has courage to show truth about Kashmir and real native kashmiri Hindus living there for centuries and just because of islamic terrorism Hindus had to fled from Kashmir valley only Vivek had courage to show that truth without sugercoting it like Bollywood used to do in earlier movie in which they used to glorify terrorists and terrorism. Kudos to Vivek and the team.
It's a BAD film, with shoddy storytelling, creating unnecessary islamophobia, and has inaccurate facts.
@@anandsharma7823tell me one fact that is inaccurate
@@anandsharma7823 So, how do you criticize or show the people in the movie, who say "allah hu akbar", who said "kafirs have to leave kashmir", who go to mosque, organize protests around muslim identity, who takes support from paksitan just because of religion WITHOUT being called out as islamophobic?
when you showcase the issue as a problem with that religion, you showcase the problem without actually showcasing that the BJP(a hindutva driven right wing party) was in power in kashmir at the time, and their dear leader jagjivan ram chose not to do anything about it because the only way they know how to survive is to spread communal hatred. @@Astitha
@@anandsharma7823 I'm sorry to say that you are a gone case and brainwashed and seeped into deep hatred that you lack curiosity to even find the basic truths.
Jagjivan ram was a dalit who was defence minister who liberated Bangladesh.
Jagmohan was a governer who precisely came to Kashmir to putdown the flames. Jagmohan was a Congress man for most of his tenure.
Just like how you said BJP is a hindutva right wing party, director Vivek called out Islamists in Kashmir
BR is the true definition of a platform. A pulpit should always remain a pulpit.
BR didn't ask the most important question there when he is said, 'he is the disruptor and always against the establishment' that, would he dare to do his disruption, if it is ideologically against the current government, from which he is getting all the support!
Because he supports the Govt, like you oppose the Govt ... only you should have that right? Just FYI, he current government is criticised every day ... not even a fraction of that was directed towards Congress, Indira Gandhi, MK Gandhi and Nehru for 70 years when clearly their crimes were much more Heinous!!
@@cookiemonsta6074 Every establishment existed or going to exist isn't beyond criticism. If Vivek is actually someone who's he pretending to be, he would be asking questions and presenting paradoxes instead of generating infuriations and fueling antagonisms.
This is not a questioning of his right for freedom of speech, this is the criticism of his speech.
And, for the last part of your comment, whataboutery won't get you anywhere. You won't move an inch forward. Period.
@@anonlegion8331i think he has been clear about his position, that he is propagandist just like others. And he is biased toward the current goverment. And he has been biased toward it and against left before BJP even came in power. But BJP provided him the space. He is openly ideologically right winger. He doesn't shy away from it. He is against left establishment. I guess. I dont agree with him all the times. But he is very opinionated. I respect that. He has a worldview unlike Bollywood stars who are clueless but will jump into anything for PR.
@@thethreespikes9737 Then he is not always against establishments right? He is contradicting himself. Moreover, just having an opinion on something is not respectable, and at the same time having a wrong opinion is condemnable. Also, THIS IS PR FOR HIM. He wants people to identify him as an intellectual, which he certainly not.
@@cookiemonsta6074 As a journalist, you are not support to support the establishment - you are supposed to hold power to account! that's what you bhakts don't understand!
The starting itself won hearts! ❤️ Thank you Bharadwaj Rangan sir for this .... I hope you too sigh a relief after getting out from the imprisonment of Film Companion 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
A GENUINE AND GEM DIRECTOR
Whaaat!! Genuine and gem director - this chippo? Who are you bro?
@@aravindsamyr9365Use Burnoil You slave
Why the hate, this man has literally interviewed Mohan G previously, obviously BR's intent is more so understanding these filmmakers rather than giving them a platform
I think that nobody should be given a platform without cross-questioning. Nobody has beliefs which don't require challenging - including you and me!
@@anandsharma7823 why though? BR isn't a reporter or journalist to have to cross-question his guests or to even be a barometer of someone's morality, hell I don't agree with most of what Agnihotri passes off as facts but that doesn't mean I try to put a gag order on him
@@govardhanposina17 I think that the function of the press - which Baddy does fall under, given that he is interviewing VA to publish it on a public platform - is to question power, hold truth to it. VA is certainly a man of power - especially in that he has commanded audience imagination, and that he parrots what political powers today say - and as a journalist, he must hold him accountable for what he is propogating to people
@@anandsharma7823 I feel that's a shaky line especially with film journalists but I do get your sentiment and approach
If this is a propaganda pro Modi film then Jawan is a propaganda anti Modi film. All filmmakers have the right to bring their perspectives out there.
Dear Comment section Freedom of Expression is Not only For Terrorists🙏
Thankyou baddy for interviewing Mr.Vivek Agnihotri Everyone criticizing you for interviewing him But "Reality is Reality". As he said 0:48
I dislike Vivek agnihotri but it’s awesome that BR would interview him as well since he is relevant now
Incredible interview .Two of my favorite people.
it was not an incredible interview by any yardstick. It was straight up an ego massage - that too with zero cross-questioning
Agree. Incredibly loud and without content - like his films.
He has the freedom of expression to make the movies he wants to make. Who decides that it is propaganda or not?
awesome someone is giving us indians thing to be proud of on a big screen.
Vivek uncle: There is no Truth.
Also Vivek uncle: We'll bring out the truth.
Vivek uncle is like Nathuram Godse. He would contradict himself before anyone else could.
😂😂😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Nathuram godse true hero who killed gandhi
How did godse contradict himself? I don't have historical context.
🤣🤣🤣
Vivek sir👏
Thanks a tonne for inviting him! Always a joy listening to Mr. Agnihotri and eagerly waiting for The Vaccine War and the Delhi Files, what a brilliant film maker and an even more wonderful human being.
15:03 thats the best compliment any critic gets.
Beautiful interview
This is a great interview. Kudos to BR.
it was not one of the best interviews. It was straight up an ego massage - that too with zero cross-questioning
One of the best interviews. Great BR.
it was not one of the best interviews. It was straight up an ego massage - that too with zero cross-questioning
@@anandsharma7823 Man you're literally copy pasting the same thing under every fn comment, seems like you gotta a lot of free times in your hands huh lol
even if vivek consciously is using unjustifiably selective facts and unjustifiably being biased to show his fair choice of making his subjective specific political stories, that doesnt mean there is no potential of making political stories others than the mainstream stories by the westernized elite who use self labels like liberal progressive leftists. Infact the fact that from the very beginning their was a monopoly of specific political stories contributed to the lack of development of alternative political stories relative to the mainstream. Also I think the use of political spectrum is just for convenience of the mind to use labels and categories , but unfortunately most people think that they have to think and act exactly according to a strict labelled group which they think they are in rather than creating their world view from ground up, in fact i think most people other than actual honest geniuses should just live their personal life and learn from that and always try to better themselves, rather than trying to pretend some global social scientist intellectual who feed their ego and give them a sense of purpose and think they are better than others while being in a closed labelled group
Thanks for giving the filmmaker of our times his due BR!!
Chocolate is his finest contribution to cinema, and let's be honest, it was all downhill from there.
Vivek, you are doing great work.
One of the best interviews...
Respect for you sir:)
Baddy invite Leo team for the interview
😂
After this interview, Baddy is easily the best film journalist in India. Not that I am aware of all film journalists, but mad respect for Baddy, unbiased to the core!
I don't think he is unbiased - he did not ask on ecounter question!
This men show us truth ❤️
Badde sir where is the review?
I don't hate him but he contradicts himself too much , for example while explaining impact of his movies he cited that before tashkent files , when PM will tweet about Gandhi and shastri , gandhi's tweet would get more retweets than tweet about shastri but after his movie it has reversed.
Now after few minutes he says i don't take social media seriously and it's a circus.
Have a opinion and stick to it , don't swing both ways.
I hate him, precisely because he contradicts himself while pretending to be a fair and stable messenger of the truth - and people fall for it.
Honest Interview
Nice interview
1:15 yes of course it’s propaganda.
Happy to hear that the film is tanking in box office
Greate interview 👍👌👌
I don't intend to watch Vivek Agnihotri films anytime soon, disagree with him on almost everything, but love that BR is interviewing him. He spoke to Kangana as well sometime back.
It's his job to interview people with no, or at least as less, bias as possible. Does it brilliantly.
Interesting interview.
baddie not review of vacine war ??? did u like it or not
Baddy, this is very disappointing. Giving equal platform to all opinions doesn't mean you enable hatemongers.
Every indian Should promote This Film 🙏
excited to know more about virology and vaccine.
Really appriciate BR sitting down eith Vivek ji..
VERY GOOD INTERVIEW OF AN AMAZING FILMMAKER WHO IS DARING...!
The Vaccine war is gonna be a great film and anti nationalists can continue to scream..! Nobody cares.!
India is going ahead..!!!
The local political people will find it a difficult pill to swallow. !
It is so funny that a person who make films for current ruling party needs and given a yz+ security whereas so many number of people who criticize government live under threats without any security.
He picked a subject based on Kashmir unrest and Insurgency. Which is not over yet and it won't take those dadi walas across the border to divert one 72 Hoor seeker towards him whereas Govt is accountable for its action. It has to allow narrative that puts them on bad light, or else they will b questioned by the UN
The most empty and lose talks I have heard in an interview.
Disappointed that Baddy didn't ask even a single critical question/did any cross-questioning but anyways by playing it straight and not fawning over him, the interview still has value and you get to know the person and how he views the world.
tq BR .
bravest critic on this planet hats off
What bravery does sucking up to the establishment require? I have the answer: none.
Mad respect for BR. The most liberal, professional, non-biased critic of our times. Salute to your ethics Sir...
What on earth are you on about? This is straight up a ego massage to VA?
Hare Krishna
great interview !! I watched film .. it's very good !
15:01 One n only King
Telugu audiences absolutely love this director and his dear producer Abhishek Agrawal because they're all about celebrating propaganda movies. Karthikeya 2. Tiger and India House loading with Anupam Kher 💀
No
What propoganda? The film is an ode to India's scientists. Particularly women scientists. Phenomenal acting by Nana Patekar, Pallavi Joshi and Raima Sen. As for Girija Oak, she is stunning. Why should we not give credit where it is true.
Lowest moment in Baradwaj's Career
BR did bring up that Jewish guy rant on stage
Now waiting for BR’s review of the vaccine war
Request mr. Vivek to kindly enrol in a film school or work with some director as asst to learn basics of how to make boring movies as engaging. Saw his movie for few mins. Such a lame woke boring screenplay man😂 even a baby's writing will look better than him..
oh wow andhbhakt can speak english?
Andhnamazi spotted 😅😅
Yes. Many can. This film is an ode to India's scientists. Particularly women scientists. Phenomenal acting by Nana Patekar, Pallavi Joshi and Raima Sen. As for Girija Oak, she is stunning. Giving credit where it is due is very important. Blind hate is very sad. Dr. Priya Abraham, Dr. Balram Bhargav deserve to be celebrated. We are alive because of great scientists like them.
“in this world of mediocrity….”…..as if he’s a genius 😂😂😂
in comparison with morons like Kjo and SRK he is comes across as Einstein ... ha ha
Compared to a nobody like you he's Aryabhatta
@@Rakshita442 kaun hai yeh bollywood waalein? aur kaunsi film genius hai? Kashmir files? I don't think so - it's shoddy, base filmmaking
The guy is so full of himself.. Pompous and filled with conceit and false notions
Baradwaj ❤//!.
You are the best interviewer sir
Propaganda directors 🤮
14:50
VA is the 2023 version of Naduram Godse.. BR Ji, why wasted your time and energy on this guy?
Love Nathuram Godse!!
@@cookiemonsta6074 shame on you
I've lost respect for you today Baradwaj Rangan. The unnecessary flattery at 16:45 , the complete lack of any contrarian questioning, the relentless sucking up -- not cool.
Nobody is worried about you losing respect on BR. BR is BR, not Anupama Chopra. He is the real neutral. He Celebrates everyone in equal measure. He Celebrates Pa. Ranjith (he sucks upto him like anything) and Vivek Agnihotri. Your cancellation of some people based on the tropes you believe, is your problem. Not BRs. Goto Film Companion if you want to be legitimise your hate and leave BR to genuine Cimema lovers to us.
Ismein Anupama Chopra kahaan se aa gayi? Film Companion kahaan se aa gaya? My engagement with BR is limited to my engagement with him, not with anyone else. And as someone who has followed his work since his HIndu days, I believe that I should be able to vocalise my disappointment with his reportage, simply as a consumer of his work. @@curiouswanderer793
Sir pls don't interview these types of directors ...I am sharing an experience of the movie directed by him, I am not watching the trailer of the movie directed by him even for a minute.. The name of the movie was The Kashmir File....propaganda based director
If exodus of Kashmiri pandits in 1990 is fake, propaganda then the 2022 killing of tailor in udaipur, Rajasthan is also a propaganda, created by media to malign muslims. Agree ??
Gud to c his interview
New low for Baradwaj Rangan. Disappointed.
After Praising Bawaal & Gadar 2, he's losing it
Thank you, Baddy!
Ok. Wtf BR?
Are you surprised or shocked ?? Am confused 😂
@@sainadh7 Yuck! 🤢
Why? context
WTF with you… learn tolerance! Dont want to listen, skip!
Rather telling BR what to do
@@ShivShankar-bv9xlNaam Hai Shiv shankar Harkate Bhootoon wali Waah 😂
BR doing everything in his power to make us dislike him these days right from that positive Bawaal/Gadar reviews to now interviewing a propagandist bootlicker (also a subpar filmmaker nonetheless).
@@prads1000Yes bro I hate hitler
Beauty of freedom of expression
For all his neutral stand, did BR ask any question on how this man's movie flamed division and hate in India, with open calls of violence inside the theaters? Vivek Agnihotri monetised & weaponised the suffering of a community to spread hate.
In his latest movie also, in his own words, he is hardly interested in patients, doctors or those who died during CoVid. He is only interested in defending the Government's interests & cover up the entire failure that was second wave of CoVid.
BR giving him a platform to air his lame defenses is enabling/legitimising his propaganda. It is not like Vivek Agnihotri did not have other plarforms to talk. His fredom of expression is definitely not in danger. As a well known critic with so much SM influence, BR should have been more responsible. Extremely disappointed.
If People like Rana Ayub & Arundati Roy can get platforms then why deny this guy. Why is Freedom of Expression being Monopoliesed here?
@@FreddieMurphy746 nobody in the world should be spared from questioning if they are given a platform. Nobody is saying he should not be given a platform. All meenakshy is saying is that he must also be questioned about the result his movies have
Yes. It has been mentioned time and time again - before elections, in the media, and even by the left wing - it's just that the right wing only understands social issues when portrayed as a threat to their own existence@@Besties591
❤
Kashmir files is a bitter truth even it is a propaganda film
It is the subjugation of truth to propaganda
Propoganda filmmaker in true sense. Not in sarcastic tone but in literal tone. Fraudster
What a fall BR👎
He is just a propagandist..
Buy Why?
Very bad baddy.....did not expect this from u......next also interview the makers of the kerala story..
Ps...did not watch this interview.
I knew baddy will eventually sell his soul working for a platform that's so whorish like Galatta....that said him giving credibility and a platform to directors like this bigot really makes you sad....all his good work feels tainted.... Unsubscribe.... Take care BR.... wish you didn't sell out like this.... Thought u had integrity unlike the rest, alas.
Man what?? 💩💩
Bro making all his efforts to hate him. Br it’s def working..
Propagandist
@@xdfckt2564 badhil : sangi kammunaati in any aspects of artistic form la vandha: Serupaala adipom. Propagandist nu solluvom. Period.
Your Tamil film makers are propogandists of toxic Dravidian ideologies