The Ghost of Christmas Past (The English Tradition of Christmas Ghost Stories)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 3 дек 2022
  • An old, English tradition of telling spooky stories on Christmas still exists today. But not in the same manner as it started!
    Join us on Patreon
    / curioushistory
    Visit our Merchandise Shop
    www.etsy.com/shop/CuriousHist...
    All our Social Media
    linktr.ee/curioushistory

Комментарии • 240

  • @larauch13
    @larauch13 Год назад +14

    A Christmas Carol with Alister Sims has always been my favourite.

  • @thisolesignguy2733
    @thisolesignguy2733 Год назад +20

    The Yule log is actually a really cool story also. It was originally a nordic tradition. During the 12 days of Christmas (winter solstice) people would meticulously choose a tree and stick the largest end in the hearth to burn, with the tree sticking out the door. They would start the fire using the previous years remnants of the yule 'tree' soaked in wine (or grog in Norway). The tree would slowly burn down during the 12 days, with remnants being stored away for the following year. This was believed to protect against lightning and the ghosts of the previous years. France started the tradition of pouring wine on the logs to have a nice smell, and later they would sprinkle them with different materials to make different colored fires. Like Borax, which makes a bright green fire.

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +2

      Such wonderful information! Thank you! 😊😊😊

    • @brandyjean7015
      @brandyjean7015 Год назад

      I didn't know the Borax, trick thanks. I think you meant Glogg: the Nordic version of mulled wine. Grog is a Brit thing.

    • @WilhelminaHelenaPaulineMarie
      @WilhelminaHelenaPaulineMarie Год назад

      Very cool extra tidbits to know!!!

    • @thisolesignguy2733
      @thisolesignguy2733 Год назад

      @@brandyjean7015 yep! you're absolutely right about Glogg. Also, the other colors of fire are:
      Potassium Nitrate = Violet
      Barium Nitrate = Apple Green
      Borax = Vivid Green
      Copper Sulphate = Blue
      Table Salt = Bright Yellow

  • @DoloresJNurss
    @DoloresJNurss Год назад +13

    Grandma used to read poetry to us, late at night; after we woke up to greet her when she came back from the night shift at her factory, she'd read us back to sleep. Three of of my favorites were Christmas ghost stories. "Old Christmas Morning" by Roy Helton, "The Witch of Coos" by Robert Frost, and "The Cremation of Sam McGee" by Robert W. Service fit particularly well with the season. Check them out if you get a chance.

    • @sherrylowe8819
      @sherrylowe8819 Год назад +2

      my favorite Xmas carol movie is the old original movie

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +3

      Wonderful memories Dolores! ❤️❤️

    • @OscarOSullivan
      @OscarOSullivan 9 месяцев назад +1

      @@CuriousHistoryYTMy favourite is the 2009 animated version.
      I prefer the book it has more of that ghost story feel to it.
      The puritans were a very Calvinist group a lot of the first European Americans were Puritans.
      A Nightmare before Christmas is both a Halloween film and Christmas film

  • @ThreeFatCats
    @ThreeFatCats Год назад +10

    My favorite ghost stories are from M.R. James. He was a professor at King's College and Eton College around the turn of the 19th century. He had a tradition of meeting up with a small group of friends every Christmas and reading them a ghost story that he had written. You can see movies of a lot of his stories on RUclips, and the BBC even did a mini-series thing called "A Ghost Story for Christmas" where they dramatized his Christmas gatherings and several of his story readings. Highly recommend checking him out.

    • @joanhoffman3702
      @joanhoffman3702 Год назад +4

      M. R. James is a gem of a writer. “Ghost Stories of an Antiquary” is a must read for anyone interested in Victorian/Edwardian writers of what I call tales of terror.

    • @stefanjakubowski8222
      @stefanjakubowski8222 Год назад +4

      Our family always retold various family ghost and weird tales and Holidays was when the family gathered
      I actually did a college paper on the folklore of my family

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      Awesome!!! 😊😊😊

    • @m0L3ify
      @m0L3ify Год назад +3

      Thanks for the recommendation! I found a used copy of the collection on Amazon. Can't wait to read!

  • @ritataylor5610
    @ritataylor5610 Год назад +5

    My two favorite Christmas Carol movies are A Christmas Carol with Reginald Owen and Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol. I always thought of A Nightmare before Christmas as a Halloween story, but it could be considered both Halloween and Christmas.

    • @joanhoffman3702
      @joanhoffman3702 Год назад +2

      Yes! Mr. Magoo’s Christmas Carol is a personal favorite. I was delighted to find it on DVD a a few years ago. (Yes, I’m old. 🤪)

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Awesome! 😊😊😊

    • @ritataylor5610
      @ritataylor5610 Год назад

      @@joanhoffman3702 So am I ;)

  • @reginadrayton8374
    @reginadrayton8374 Год назад +5

    Anyone hit “like” as the video begins, just because we know it’ll be fantastic like the rest? 🤗

  • @elizabethmcglothlin5406
    @elizabethmcglothlin5406 Год назад +17

    This was beautifully told. Many thanks from one who has mostly considered it from the other (Pagan) side!

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      Thank you Elizabeth! 😊😊😊

    • @brandyjean7015
      @brandyjean7015 Год назад +2

      Me too, Elizabeth. So in case we don't meet again: Solstice blessings to you and yours.

    • @elizabethmcglothlin5406
      @elizabethmcglothlin5406 Год назад

      @@brandyjean7015 May the Season of Returning light be good to you, as well!

    • @elizabethmcglothlin5406
      @elizabethmcglothlin5406 Год назад

      @@CuriousHistoryYT I've always suspected that you tell ghost stories at Christmas because it would be too dangerous at Samhain, but safer after the sun has turned back. It's still a dark time, darker in those days, but the Christ--or the sun has been reborn.

  • @pheona1164
    @pheona1164 Год назад +9

    This was fascinating! I had no idea Christmas was basically outlawed at one point. In New England (Maine specifically), ghost stories during winter are fairly common among the older groups. The stories I have heard revolve around passed family members coming back to join the festivities. 👀Spooky. By far, the movie interpretation I most enjoy is the 1951 Christmas Carol. I think it best captures the grittiness of the times.

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Nice! Thank you for sharing this Pheona!

    • @frankharrington4881
      @frankharrington4881 Год назад +2

      My favorite version is the one with Alastair Sims, it may be the one you were talking about! Patricia Gambino Harrington

  • @restionSerpentine
    @restionSerpentine 7 месяцев назад +3

    I've always wondered why "Its the most wonderful time of year" had the line "There'll be scary ghost stories and tales of the glories of Christmases long long ago."

  • @GingerKraut
    @GingerKraut Год назад +5

    Thank you for another enlightening episode! I love the version with Sir Patrick Stewart (made by TNT, I think); and it's not Christmas until Rudolph and the Peanuts gang arrive! Oh, and if you want to sing more, have at it because you have a wonderful voice for singing and storytelling. Cheers!

  • @MikkiInWaiting
    @MikkiInWaiting Год назад +4

    Nightmare Before Christmas is a Christmas Eve viewing tradition in our family. I watch it on Halloween too! So got me, it’s both! 😊
    My favorite versions of A Christmas Carol are:
    First: 1984 version starring George C Scott
    Second: 1988 Scrooged starring Bill Murray

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Both excellent choices Mikki! The end of Scrooged with Bill Murray always gets me. Usually wiping tears away.

  • @TruffleAntylamon
    @TruffleAntylamon 7 месяцев назад +1

    As my first exposure to the story of A Christmas Carol as a kid, An All Dogs Christmas Carol will always be my favorite.

  • @RKusmie64
    @RKusmie64 Год назад +3

    The Alistair Simm version is my favorite, with the George C. Scott in a fairly close second. It's not Christmas season until I listen to Robert Goulet's Christmas album lol. You could do more singing as far as I'm concerned - you have a very pleasant voice :-) I really enjoyed this video, and the history behind some of our traditions. ~Robin

  • @nancybode6159
    @nancybode6159 Год назад +3

    My parents had that Andy Williams album. It's still one of my favorites!!
    My favorite Christmas Carol movie is the one with Patrick Stewart as Ebenezer Scrooge.

  • @bluesioux9538
    @bluesioux9538 Год назад +2

    Really fascinating background to both the "A Christmas Carol" and the tradition of storytelling at a somewhat scary time of the year (in olden times). The Muppet Christmas Carol is my favorite also and Pops, you have a wonderful singing voice!

  • @Rags2Itches
    @Rags2Itches Год назад +2

    My two Christmas movies are : A Christmas Carol starring George C Scott as Ebenezer Scrooge and the animated How the Grinch Stole Christmas. Both redemption stories. Plus Cindy Lou Who and Max the dog both are great.
    The saddest Christmas story to me, is The Little Match Girl.
    Good King Wenceslas, Christmas carol is all about a rich King trying to help and basically push a poor man (much bewildered by the King's actions in choosing him) into accepting the King's charity. Yet one of my favorites.
    As always the past history of the holiday is well done, John.
    All Soul's day in late November, Halloween, the Winter Solstice and the Day of the Dead seem more closely linked to the thinning of the veil than Christmas to me.
    Krampas is long before the emergence of Santa, yet similar with the you'd better be good ...or this will happen type of story.
    I got laughing over the telling of ghost stories at Christmas. Imagine telling children them on Christmas Eve, then tucking them in bed saying "Sleep well." ??
    John you have a wonderful singing voice. When does your Christmas carol album get released?

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      🤣🤣🤣 I’m certain that an album of Christmas carols sung by yours truly would mark the end of this channel but thank you for the positive feedback! 🤣🤣🤣
      I think the same as you Rags. Imagine tucking the kids in on Christmas Eve with a ghost story. It would be difficult for Santa to visit if the kids are too afraid to sleep!

  • @nian60
    @nian60 Год назад +4

    The Muppet Christmas Carol is my favourite. 🎄🐸 Costubers have remarked on how period accurate the Muppet costumes are. Check out Nicole Rudolph's recreation of Gonzo's costume, but made for a human. (Several videos, she even made the shoes).

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Thank you for this Ni An! I will definitely give it a look!

  • @stefanjakubowski8222
    @stefanjakubowski8222 Год назад +2

    The Stone Tapes one of my favorite Xmas personal traditions

  • @Bebecat477
    @Bebecat477 Год назад +1

    The Christmas Carol is my favorite tale.

  • @frankharrington4881
    @frankharrington4881 Год назад +3

    Love this one! A Christmas Carol starring Alastair Sims is my favorite version of all the Christmas Carols! You are absolutely the best at telling these stories! Thank you for this channel!! LOVE IT!!!! Patricia Gambino Harrington

  • @TheParanormalSide
    @TheParanormalSide Год назад +2

    I love the old version of Scrooge. The black and white version. Thanks for this video because I definitely learned something today about Christmas and ghost stories associated with it. Absolutely awesome.

  • @RajuDas-qu1li
    @RajuDas-qu1li Год назад +1

    Great video, John! Today is Sunday, 25th December! It is 7: 55 p.m. when I finish watching this video. A great video on a great day! The ghost stories are intregal part of Christmas. The third member of the godhead is referred as the Holy Ghost. It means He who is in the form of spirit. Without flesh, blood and bones. The connection between ghost stories and Christmas day is therefore purely spiritual.
    To evoke this spiritual realm perhaps the generations passed these stories down.
    Imagine it is a mediaeval Christmas day and it has been snowing all day long. When evening comes the wind starts hissing outside with occasional creaking of the doors and windows. Inside a dimly lit chamber, at the dinner table an old man goes on unceasingly telling the chilling tales that has been passed down to him by his grandparents. The listeners huddled together almost engulfed him. There are no noises except the voice of the old man and the occasional creaking of the doors and windows,the hissing sound of the wind outside and the sounds of the cutlery.
    Is there any time more perfect for evocation of the shapeless entity who reigns in the unseen world? It is purely a spiritual conjuration! The evocation of which produces awe and wonder at the same time.
    Thank you John for your wonderful video!
    Have a lot of cakes and ale! Merry Christmas to you, your family and your wonderful grandson!

  • @randywhite3958
    @randywhite3958 Год назад +4

    Nice job very informative as usual my favorite version of a Christmas Carol is the George C Scott one

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      Thanks Randy. George C Scott was born to play that role!

  • @jenniferbush41
    @jenniferbush41 7 месяцев назад +1

    My favorite A Christmas Carol is the 1984 version with George C Scott. Love it! It's usually the very first Christmas movie I watch every year! Funny enough, my favorite movie to watch on Halloween also stars George C Scott. It's the 1980 movie The Changeling. Awesome scary ghost story!

  • @brandyjean7015
    @brandyjean7015 Год назад +2

    From 1659-1681 the Puritans outlawed the celebration of Christmas in Massachusetts. Winter is cold, and often a struggle. Celebrating, with family & friends is something to look forward to, in my opinion.

  • @pisceanx8382
    @pisceanx8382 Год назад +3

    It seems like I say this a lot in the comments, but this one was one of your best yet!
    Looking forward to more good ones this month! 🎄 👻 🎅📯

  • @ricknixdorf7316
    @ricknixdorf7316 Год назад +2

    First John let me say what a great tenor voice you have! Who knew? Second, this tale of "Curious History" caused fans to delve deeply into their own Christmas Traditions and likes and dislikes. Judging from the comments, we are really a peaceful, loving, proud traditional society. Whether we want to admit it or not. It's obvious that lots of love, thought and research went into the making of this video. Wonderful job!!! Thank you once again and Merry Christmas!

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      Thank you Rick!
      I agree! Such an awesome community we have. Thank you for being a part of it! Merry Christmas! 😊😊😊

  • @fatherchristmas2998
    @fatherchristmas2998 7 месяцев назад +1

    Very good information I love listening to ghost audio books at winter. You can't feel a ghost story in the warmth of summer .you need the ice biting into your bones to enjoy but remember thousand were starving in England .wene a Christmas carol was written

  • @bethromanetto6279
    @bethromanetto6279 Год назад +1

    First off you have a beautiful singing voice!! I never knew about the history of telling ghost stories at Christmas. Seems a little odd that during joyous celebrations with family and friends that stories of fear, hauntings and death would be included. But when there's not a lot of entertainment options were available and you have to get creative!!

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Thank you Beth. Very kind of you to say.
      I agree with your comment about lack of entertainment back then. I guess they just made do with what they had!

  • @charlenegodard564
    @charlenegodard564 Год назад +1

    Nice singing voice, John! I'm going to see the Christmas Carol on stage next week! Keep up the good work, and may you and your family have a blessed and happy holiday season.

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Thank you Charlene! A happy holiday season to you as well! 😊😊😊

  • @kimquiggle259
    @kimquiggle259 Год назад +2

    Truly Enjoyed...
    Great Story Teller...
    Thank You For Sharing.

  • @violetmoonofthenorth
    @violetmoonofthenorth Год назад +2

    Love Charlie dickens ghost stories especially at Christmas .. 🇬🇧👻🤍 rich and deep in folklore and myths

  • @celiabays8393
    @celiabays8393 Год назад +2

    He can sing, awesome

  • @johnkolmos1593
    @johnkolmos1593 9 месяцев назад +1

    An American Christmas Carol with Henry Winkler and A Christmas Carol with George C. Scott

  • @esterherschkovich6499
    @esterherschkovich6499 Год назад +2

    Love ghost stories 🙂Hi from the UK...just seen an Amateur Dramatic group put on Christmas Carol it was good.

  • @dawnrichardson5283
    @dawnrichardson5283 8 месяцев назад +1

    Reginald Owen and Alistair Sim are my favorite Scrooge characters

  • @paigebiek1344
    @paigebiek1344 Год назад +1

    Scrooged with Bill Murray is my favorite, but I lean towards the spooky and campy. As a Pagan, I seasonally have to "defend" my holiday decor choices. Reminding others that our traditions are passed around and shared is also a nice time to say just be kind and respectful. Thank you for this video!

  • @michaelhunt681
    @michaelhunt681 Год назад +1

    I love your story telling. A Christmas Carol is a favorite story to read, as for film version I'll admit I'm particularly fond of Micky's version.

  • @passionforlust
    @passionforlust Год назад +2

    There was an understanding that on Christmas, ghosts could not harm the living, thus the tales. What I find strange about Dickens was he was not genuinely nice to his immediate family, for someone who wanted to bring about the change in the human condition in a mass way. My favorite Scrooge is Alistar Sim then Albert Finney, and George C Scott. Krampus is Germanic and is like Black Peter that the Dutch have, but instead of leaving a lump of coal in a bad child's wooden shoe, he takes them back to his cave and eats them, just a cautionary tale that goes back, so be good kiddies as you don't want Krampus getting you. As for the Krampus movies- Humbug and utter garbage. So Merry Christmas to you John and yours, and as Master Yogurt from Spaceballs Says-May the Schwartz be with you!

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      Thank you Dan! This is a great comment! Thanks for expanding the conversation!
      “Your Schwartz is as big as mine!” 🤣🤣🤣

    • @passionforlust
      @passionforlust Год назад +1

      @@CuriousHistoryYT Fixed Patreon, will keep my eye on it so you will get my subscription amount from now on!

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      ❤️❤️❤️

  • @leslieMClass80
    @leslieMClass80 Год назад +2

    Very fascinating!! Thank you for all your research! We are team Alister Sims! (Although also loved muppets when my kids were little) and hey… you’ve got a set of pipes!! Thanks again!

  • @catherinecrawford2289
    @catherinecrawford2289 9 месяцев назад +1

    1. We watch A Nightmare Before Christmas in November every year, because to us, it is both Halloween and Christmas.
    2. My favorite Scrooge version is Alastair Sims' version, but Muppets is a family favorite as well. I enjoyed George C. Scott's version from the 1980s as well as Patrick Stewart's version from the 1990s.

  • @michaelastandley8531
    @michaelastandley8531 Год назад +1

    An absolute classic. One you can’t miss at Christmas.😅

  • @m0L3ify
    @m0L3ify Год назад +1

    "Spirited" is a fun one! But, then again, I always was a sucker for musicals. 😄 I really like what they did to make the original story new and fun instead of just remaking the same old thing. They carried it into the 21st century really well!

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      I haven’t seen it yet! Can’t wait! 😊😊😊

    • @m0L3ify
      @m0L3ify Год назад +1

      @@CuriousHistoryYT It's super cute and heartwarming! You'll love it!

  • @chriswhittington294
    @chriswhittington294 Год назад +1

    This was such a fascinating topic!
    I personally like the George C Scott version of A Christmas Carol.
    You have a nice voice for speaking AND evidentally for singing as well! ❤️

  • @The_Smith
    @The_Smith Год назад +1

    Not English, and ghost stories weren't part of my tradition, But as an adult I've felt much closer to my Ghosts than at Hallowe'en, Merry Christmas, and thanks.

  • @amandathomas8646
    @amandathomas8646 Год назад +1

    I watch 'A Muppet's Christmas Carol' every single Christmas Eve.🎶 Cause after all there is only 1 more sleep till Christmas 🎶

  • @edwardkellogg1284
    @edwardkellogg1284 Год назад +1

    I never put ghost stories and Christmas together they way you explained it. I do like the black and white movie Scrooge. It seems whenever they remake an old movie, it is not the same. Great video, and your singing at the end was pretty good. Enjoy your week.

  • @jananderson672
    @jananderson672 Год назад +1

    Love your video about Christmas and pagan traditions. Also love your singing. Through the years, A Christmas Carol with Alastair Simms has also been my favorite. I saw it on TV as a child and watch it every year. It really captures the flavor of Victorian culture and it also was a commentary on England's rebuilding in the 50's after WW2. Thanks for the very educational video

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      My pleasure Jan. Thank you for watching my friend!

    • @jananderson672
      @jananderson672 Год назад +1

      @@CuriousHistoryYT it's a pleasure for all of us.

  • @leewalker1177
    @leewalker1177 Год назад +3

    Here in England..The Christmas Ghost Story is alive and well.

  • @judikoppendrayer9356
    @judikoppendrayer9356 9 месяцев назад +1

    My favorite Christmas Carol movie is the Patrick stewart version. I also like the movie The Man Who Saved Christmas with Dan Steven's. It's awesome.

  • @neva_nyx
    @neva_nyx Год назад +1

    I had no idea Dickens had written more stories. I'm going to look one up and read it at the end of our party.

  • @sharonnichols9625
    @sharonnichols9625 Год назад +1

    Wonderful story and my favorite is the one with George C Scott

  • @The1952trouble
    @The1952trouble Год назад +1

    I like a Christmas Carol with George c Scott the best.

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      George C Scott was born for that role! 😊😊😊

  • @Liz-cmc313
    @Liz-cmc313 Год назад +2

    I prefer the original black and white. But my favorite Christmas movie is It's A Wonderful Life. This was wonderfully done.

  • @drumdad54sdl47
    @drumdad54sdl47 Год назад +1

    Very well narrated & presented.
    You have a fine singing voice, Sir!

  • @edithparra3356
    @edithparra3356 Год назад +1

    Beautifully told, learned something new. My favorite Christmas Carol films are George C. Scott's version and Patrick Stewart's version :)

  • @WilhelminaHelenaPaulineMarie
    @WilhelminaHelenaPaulineMarie Год назад +1

    Delighted at the song near the end of the video. Quite a voice really!! Fascinating history. Love it!

  • @kiwisunshine9631
    @kiwisunshine9631 Год назад +2

    Another great video, and very informative! You always do such great research of your stories! I like Mr. Magoo's Christmas Carol, but there are so many great movies it was heard to choose just one! Many thanks for this great video!

  • @elizabethpodsiadlochefsing8588
    @elizabethpodsiadlochefsing8588 9 месяцев назад +1

    So enjoyed your segment. Loved the carol at the end. Thank you for sharing!

  • @nataliewoods8656
    @nataliewoods8656 Год назад +1

    I agree both christmas Carol's are good movies I grew up watching the muppet christmas Carol but the older version is good too

  • @jamesrader3329
    @jamesrader3329 Год назад +1

    I like the George c Scott of a Christmas carol. Version. That was an amazing story. Again love the way your videos are done. Crisp clean and right to the point. If your ever in Baltimore MD. Let me know.

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Thank you James! I will certainly let you know! 😊

  • @failedfoster6187
    @failedfoster6187 Год назад +1

    Thank you so much for this! Learning while being entertained. No better way to learn!

  • @nancygrabowski64
    @nancygrabowski64 Год назад +1

    Thank you for your continued posting. Merry Christmas

  • @lostgoyle3249
    @lostgoyle3249 Год назад +1

    Beautifully told and sung! I'm late on this one but thank you for posting!!! Happy New Year!

  • @Lewman211
    @Lewman211 Год назад +1

    Hi John, what another beautiful episode of Curious History, right in time for the Holidays! As for the movie? The 1984 version of A Christmas Carol starring George C. Scott is perhaps my favorite, with the Muppets coming in 2nd. For some reason I love the Victorian area, and things involving the 18th Century, i don't know why but i do. I'm so glad that Charles Dickens wrote A Christmas Carol, because i'm sure back in the day that were many that had a change of heart just by reading what happened to Scrooge, and perhaps thought it might happen to them. I look forward to seeing your next episode with a glad heart, and wish you and your family one of the best, brightest, and glorious Christmastimes you all can have. Many, Many thanks for all your videos, over this past year, and i would like to wish you all a Very Merry Christmas, to you and your family as well. In closing, let's remember the immortal words of Tiny Tim, "God bless us, Everyone!"

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      A very Merry Christmas to you Lewis! Thank you for all your support this year! 😊😊😊

    • @Lewman211
      @Lewman211 Год назад +1

      I'm hoping to get financed better after the holidays so I can help you on Patreon.

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      I appreciate the support either way Lewis! Thank you my friend!

    • @Lewman211
      @Lewman211 Год назад +1

      @@CuriousHistoryYT You all are most welcome!!!!!

  • @joyalexander5842
    @joyalexander5842 Год назад +1

    I never thought of ghost stories at Christmas. Of the Christmas movies you mentioned, there is a version that is a musical. That is my favorite. Then, the 2 you mentioned. I sang with you by the way. 😆

  • @barbarajean6538
    @barbarajean6538 Год назад +2

    John, great video (as usual). Happy holidays!

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Thank you Barbara Jean! Happy Holidays to you as well! 😊😊😊

  • @ontargetthomunclesam3926
    @ontargetthomunclesam3926 Год назад +1

    What a wonderful and beautiful story to tell for sure thank you for sharing it with us you know John during the intro to the video I could only picture you sitting in front of a Yuletide fire with a hot toddy in one hand and a Cuban cigar in the other it was quite the mental picture thanks again greatly appreciated my friend and wishing you and your family a very Merry Christmas and a joyous New year

  • @davidkelly2088
    @davidkelly2088 Год назад +1

    Great show. Thank you

  • @David-zh1rn
    @David-zh1rn Год назад +1

    I once dated Christmas Carol! She was an odd duck. She kept calling me Ebeneezer! I guess, though, that was better than Tiny Tim! Ha, ha!

  • @christosvoskresye
    @christosvoskresye Год назад +1

    There's more to it. There seems to be a tradition for spookiness and the threat of evil before Holy Days. Spooky stories on Christmas Eve, then the holiness of Christmas Day; spookiness on Halloween, then the holiness of All Saints' Day. Walpurgisnacht and the Feast of St. John also fit the pattern. It's arguably a pattern that goes back to the first chapter of Genesis: "Evening came, and morning followed."

  • @stoned-soup
    @stoned-soup Год назад +1

    Great singing...Great history...Thank you for the research. I thoroughly enjoy your videos...Merry Christmas....

  • @sandyalseth4550
    @sandyalseth4550 Год назад +1

    Merry Christmas to you!!🥰🌲

  • @nellykevbbc
    @nellykevbbc Год назад +1

    wonderful research and presentation of the history....of this subject....

  • @garycordle5295
    @garycordle5295 Год назад +1

    Thanks for the history story 👍

  • @Kamoj85
    @Kamoj85 Год назад +4

    You have a wonderful voice. It's funny i constantly tell people that most of the "traditions" are actually pagan and have nothing to do with Christ and no one believes me. I believe in the more pagan history over christ being born on xmas day(which ppl who studied the bible had proven meticulously with the descriptions in the book and the timing BTW) Including Santa being Odin as an origin of the bearded traveler giving gives to those worthy, and watching over. I love reading ghost stories or legends around the holidays, it always gives an extra togetherness feeling

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +2

      Very well said Soz!
      The origins of Santa have always intrigued me. I may need to do some research! 😉

    • @jananderson672
      @jananderson672 Год назад +3

      I too have tried to tell others about the pagan traditions of Christmas and get blank stares and disbelief. From the colors of Christmas to yule logs, it's old pagan rituals given new names and meanings.

    • @Kamoj85
      @Kamoj85 Год назад +2

      @@CuriousHistoryYT it's very amusing research and a big rabbit hole for the jolly man. have fun with it

  • @user-go7uz6qz9c
    @user-go7uz6qz9c 10 месяцев назад +1

    So happy I found you guys😂

  • @cecilprice6496
    @cecilprice6496 Год назад +1

    That was a cool video I really enjoyed that John you got a good singing voice

  • @danawildman8766
    @danawildman8766 Год назад +1

    Very interesting, thank you!!
    I love Muppet Christmas Carol!!

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      Dana your last name is my mother’s maiden name. Wonder if we are related!?

    • @danawildman8766
      @danawildman8766 Год назад +1

      You never know! My husband is descended from Thomas Wildman who arrived here in Connecticut from England in 1634.

    • @danawildman8766
      @danawildman8766 Год назад

      You never know! My husband is descended from Thomas Wildman who arrived here in Connecticut from England in 1634.

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      Any relatives in Iowa?

    • @danawildman8766
      @danawildman8766 Год назад +1

      @@CuriousHistoryYT No relatives in Iowa. 🙁

  • @shirleyleichliter4487
    @shirleyleichliter4487 Год назад +1

    This was a great video my favorite

  • @saraseifert6005
    @saraseifert6005 Год назад +1

    Scrooged is my favorite!

  • @mrs.g.9816
    @mrs.g.9816 Год назад +1

    It's a tossup between the Alistair Simm version and the George C. Scott version. There is also an excellent, well-animated version produced by Chuck Jones in 1972. Alistair Simm (just his voice) reprised his role as Scrooge. I like that in this cartoon Bob Cratchit had a cockney accent, which would have been more authentic.
    I have to admit I like the Mr. Magoo Christmas Carol because I remember when it first aired on our black and white RCA TV when I was just six years old. Just hearing the music and songs from the cartoon brings me back to that cozy evening surrounded by family so long ago.

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      I’m going to need to rewatch Mr Magoo! Thanks for this Mrs. G! 😊😊😊

  • @roserobertson7181
    @roserobertson7181 Год назад +1

    George C Scott, my favorite version!

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      Such an amazing version! George C Scott was made for that role!

  • @cherjohnson5807
    @cherjohnson5807 Год назад +1

    Always enjoyable 👍

  • @kathleenevans1201
    @kathleenevans1201 Год назад +1

    Mt favorite version had always been the 1938 version staring Reginald Owen and Gene Lockhart.

  • @randomlyweirdjeff4638
    @randomlyweirdjeff4638 7 месяцев назад +1

    I like the 2009 version of a Christmas Carol with Jim Carrey

  • @larrystultz7545
    @larrystultz7545 Год назад +1

    Excellent

  • @frankharrington4881
    @frankharrington4881 Год назад +1

    HAPPY NEW YEAR!!!! Patricia Gambino Harrington

  • @curtislavallee8444
    @curtislavallee8444 Год назад +1

    🎄😇 thank you

  • @RedcoatsReturn
    @RedcoatsReturn Год назад +1

    Thank you 👍👍 for reminding today’s generation…why…the Christmas Ghost story..has deep roots…and is a great old custom! 😄 God bless the pagan traditions! 😄👻😉

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Thank you for watching Redcoat’s Return! I really appreciate it! 😊😊😊

  • @JustCallMeJ.
    @JustCallMeJ. Год назад +1

    My Favorite Christmas Carol Movies are ...
    A Christmas Carol 1938 with Reginald Owen
    A Christmas Carol 1951 with Alistair Simm
    Scrooged 1988 with Bill Murray
    A Flintstones Christmas Carol 1994
    And I think that The Nightmare Before Christmas is Both a Halloween AND Christmas Movie .
    👴🏻👻👻👻👻

  • @imspooky2024
    @imspooky2024 Год назад +1

    One of my favorite movies. I sent you the lyrics to the Christmas song it's the most wonderful time of the year where they tell go stories. I don't know why they told ghost stories by the Christmas tree bit sounds like my kind of tradition.
    I'm a newby. Happy to meet you. I enjoy the videos very much I'm from Connecticut. I got ghost stories..
    It's the most wonderful time of the year
    With the kids jingle belling
    And everyone telling you "be of good cheer"
    It's the most wonderful time of the year
    It's the hap-happiest season of all
    With those holiday greetings
    And gay happy meetings when friends come to call
    It's the hap-happiest season of all
    There'll be parties for hosting
    Marshmallows for toasting
    And caroling out in the snow
    There'll be scary ghost stories
    And tales of the glories
    Of Christmases long, long ago

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад +1

      Nice to meet you as well I’m Spooky!
      Living in Connecticut, I bet you have plenty of ghost stories to tell!
      Thank you so much for watching! 😊

  • @kimmyhawley9247
    @kimmyhawley9247 Год назад +1

    Don't forget a truce was called during ww1 on christmas just the one year though, so singing,story telling and sharing of rations, football and things,there were stories passed down in my family from it, but the following year,the higher ups made sure it didn't happen...i know..probably to far in future for relevance to your story..i the trenches picture in your story reminded me of it...sorry if this message was off base..i truly enjoy listening to you and your daughter..thank you for your insites and the muppets are a staple for me

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Not far off at all Kimmy! I’ve been researching that story! 😉

    • @kimmyhawley9247
      @kimmyhawley9247 Год назад +1

      @@CuriousHistoryYT really..i would love to hear more about it..i can ask my family if they still have their letter that was sent back with the story in it if you would like a copy ..no promises as there have been a few house fires over the years but its worth the look through...

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      That would be awesome!

    • @kimmyhawley9247
      @kimmyhawley9247 Год назад +1

      @@CuriousHistoryYT is there a way for snail mail..we were talking about it tonight and yes..looking into where it is now..

    • @kimmyhawley9247
      @kimmyhawley9247 Год назад +1

      @@CuriousHistoryYT we also have stories of sharing between soldiers during the civil war..sugar and tobacco fron north to south..and chicory and peanuts south to north on christmas day..singing..playing games..letters and getting messages to families...

  • @carriemaxwell4695
    @carriemaxwell4695 Год назад +1

    NBC is both a Halloween and Christmas film, the bridge between the two.
    My favorite Christmas movies are The Grinch, Scrooged, and the Muppet Christmas Carol. After NBC of course.
    I like satire and macabre themes. I cannot stand the carbon copy hallmark films that rehash the same tropes over again with over the top emotional drama and sappiness.
    And other films that give us a snippet of Christmas like Narnia (the first one) are alright too because it had just enough "spirit" and light heartedness in what a technically a war setting.
    Lady and the Tramp's beginning and end come full circle with Christmas nicely and Love Actually beautifully ties in so many people separated by a degree or two in their lives. Not everyone lives happily ever after, and some get the very thing they wanted only to realize it's not what they need, as is life.

  • @leeradford76
    @leeradford76 6 месяцев назад

    You are my favourite i wish you merry christmas thangsgiving for you and your family all the best for future

  • @oaksgate9914
    @oaksgate9914 Год назад +1

    1938 version with June Lockhart and parents.

  • @lexielue1063
    @lexielue1063 Год назад +1

    Good morning, very informative vlog. This is one I didn't know. I enjoyed both of them, could not pick between them. The animated one was different. Just didn't like it to much. Another movie I loved was Miracle on 30th Street, loved the remake a little better. Hope everyone is doing well, see you next time. Linda from south Arkansas 😆 😆 💕 💕 🎅

  • @lisad476
    @lisad476 Год назад +1

    🎄

  • @gerrywood5325
    @gerrywood5325 Год назад +1

    I am partial to the film version played by Alastair Sim as my first choice, the version played by George C. Scott as my second choice and the numerous animated versions being led by the Muppet's as my third. As I get older though my wife has declared that I am becoming like Ebenezer Scrooge especially with the way businesses display Halloween on one side of a shelf, Thanksgiving on the other side of the same shelf and Christmas Decorations beginning on the next aisle over. There once was a time in America when Halloween would have been over for at least two weeks before the Thanksgiving and Christmas decorations were even thought about. Usually, Thanksgiving and Black Friday was the signal for Christmas to be put out on the shelves, and would somebody please tell me where some of the colors that are coming out for Christmas decorations coming from? I know that Christmas gets in the way of some religions, but Christmas is supposed to be about bright reds, blues and greens, not black, dull and boring. Anyway, Merry Christmas to you and yours.

    • @CuriousHistoryYT
      @CuriousHistoryYT  Год назад

      Thank you Gerry! Merry Christmas to you too! 😊😊😊

  • @allisonbenesch6962
    @allisonbenesch6962 Год назад +1

    Allister Sim...