How the Movement of Other Planets Affects Earth - Yes, Really
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 сен 2024
- Scientists have found at least three cycles in nature that can be traced back to the alignment of the planets. And while they won’t tell you anything about your love life or personality, by studying them, we can learn about our planet’s past and future-and even how the solar system has changed.
This video was sponsored by Skillshare. The first 1000 people who click the link will get 2 free months of Skillshare Premium: skl.sh/scishow...
Hosted by: Hank Green
SciShow has a spinoff podcast! It's called SciShow Tangents. Check it out at www.scishowtang...
----------
Support SciShow by becoming a patron on Patreon: / scishow
----------
Huge thanks go to the following Patreon supporters for helping us keep SciShow free for everyone forever:
Kevin Bealer, Jacob, Katie Marie Magnone, D.A. Noe, Charles Southerland, Eric Jensen, Christopher R Boucher, Alex Hackman, Matt Curls, Adam Brainard, Scott Satovsky Jr, Sam Buck, Ron Kakar, Chris Peters, Kevin Carpentier, Patrick D. Ashmore, Piya Shedden, Sam Lutfi, Charles George, Christoph Schwanke, Greg
----------
Like SciShow? Want to help support us, and also get things to put on your walls, cover your torso and hold your liquids? Check out our awesome products over at DFTBA Records: dftba.com/scishow
----------
Looking for SciShow elsewhere on the internet?
Facebook: / scishow
Twitter: / scishow
Tumblr: / scishow
Instagram: / thescishow
----------
Sources:
link.springer....
www.scienceale...
link.springer....
eos.org/articl...
www.syfy.com/s...
www.swpc.noaa....
www.jpl.nasa.g...
www.pnas.org/c...
phys.org/news/...
www.smithsonia...
www.universeto...
www.eurekalert...
pdfs.semantics...
phys.org/news/...
www.smithsonia...
www.scientific...
Image Sources:
www.videoblock...
svs.gsfc.nasa....
archive.org/st...
eol.jsc.nasa.g...
commons.wikime...
www.sci-dril.n...
svs.gsfc.nasa....
solarsystem.na...
www.flickr.com...
www.nasa.gov/c...
This video was sponsored by Skillshare. The first 1000 people who click the link will get 2 free months of Skillshare Premium: skl.sh/scishowspace
I was excited for the opportunity, until I couldn't proceed without providing CC, and wondered at the chances of missing the deadline to cancel, in this CCPVirus shutdown daze. But thanks, anyway.
So, what's your sign?
HANK!! How could you NOT tell us where we are, currently, in these cycles? The eleven year and the 405,000 year ones? This is information we should have! Awesome vid, btw!
Electric Universe much? How's that soft disclosure going?)
The title made me think of the witcher's the conjunction of spheres. And I kept wondering if someone was making a late April fool's lol
"We haven't had a memorable solar storm in a while"
Considering how bad this year is going, I don't think we're too far away from a big solar storm lol
It appears the Mayans were probably dislexic. I don't even wanna see what December holds.
Or 2021.
And we here thinking 2019 was bad.
Hope not or we are all doomed 😮
Have you watched the Japanese movie ‘survival family’?
True
@@bidishadey3815 no... Is it good? Give us a synopsis
It’s by far more entertaining to hear about what Mars does to really old mud than to horoscopes.
:o
But it is interesting to think that these ancient astrologers 5000 Years ago maybe onto something, even with their limited obervational capabitilities. Then came the religious people and twist everything of course.
Toaster Bath Challenge
they WERE the religious people; the divide is relatively recent
You know, many geniuses believed in astrology and this video in my opinion is the proof that it is real because see how intricate and complex and sensitive the universe is how everything is connected we have studies that show that we evolved to have more activity during full moons because it helped us see at night when we were evolving and in fact in full moon the crime rate just go off the charts police knows that as a training basics so you see we don’t really understand life to know it’s cycles if it’s connected even with the influence the planets but this video sure makes me think about it and if mars influence mud you bet us too after all we are basically made of mud so... yeah
@@Luigilr Literally every horoscope: *insert generic human trait here*
I can\t thumbs up this enough. This is the type of macro-level science we, as a species, need to focus on.
I can only give it one thumbs up ... :/
So what... fuc% biology?
Why the check do we need to focus on this 🤣🤣. We can’t do nothing bout it
@@jamesvincent1567 as we know it, yes because we've been bamboozled and only told half the story
@@SugarCaine1 this shows that man has no effect what so ever on our climate! And we better understand it a repair for the coming cooling or the death toll will be staggering
Wow, my mind just got blown. This is so logical once you hear it, yet I would not have thought of it in 60 million years. What an incredible new way to connect the dots of our planet history.
When scientists can dig into the Earth to tell you about space, somebody is way too smart or really obsessed with dirt.
Probably both
Sounds like the Royal Canadian Kilted Yaksmen are at it again (s2e12).
Probably both
It's also a nice way to make the rest of us to feel dumb.
Basically like "Asteroid in Love" anime
Aamazing stuff, I wonder what a core take from the moon would tell us
The first thing it would tell us is that we got a coring machine to the moon. Beyond that, I doubt it would tell us much about anything beyond the formation of the moon, since there’s no deposition or sediment on the moon because there’s no atmosphere or water bodies.
@@ahgflyguy I wonder what one on Mars would tell us or if we somehow built one to survive on Venus
@@ahgflyguy yes, no sedimentation, but it would tell us *a lot* about the formation of earth
which... isnt that related, we wouldnt be able to date the columns of rock in the same way
@@saffroncoasts6950 probably mars, venus is TOO MUCH, MAN
@@geekjokes8458 I mean in the 70s the Russians made a probe that landed on Venus and took images for 2 hours or so. We might be able to make one that lasts twice as long. Question is can we get a drill there, drill and get back out in 4 hours?
These days came out news (even on scishow space if I recall correctly) noting that the Sun is a lot less active than the average Sun-like stars observed, with less flares and sunspots.
Could it be because of this? Our star has the necessary combination and distribution of planets needed to make this 11-year solar activity "reset"? Thus preventing the star reaching the solar activity common on other similar stars?
That actually sounds like a valid theory to me. But who knows.
@@miracufelix It definitely is a valid hypothesis but without the ability to accurately identify planetary systems around a significant sample of sun like stars it will be hard to tell. It would also matter since the previous suggestion for why the sun had low activity relied on the Sun having less angular momentum than other sun-like stars which the Parker Solar probe's observations have flat out rejected due to the far more extreme co-rotation of the solar wind which might actually indicate the Sun has been prevented from losing the amount of angular momentum it should have according to solar models. So in a way this looks to be a promising candidate for possibly explaining both problems simultaneously but unfortunately we can't test it as we can only see planets around other stars if we get lucky.
@@Dragrath1 That's what future generations will hopefully do. As for now, let's hope the James Webb telescope goes up soon!
No reason to believe other stars with exoplanets don't have a similar resetting mechanism. Orbital mechanics favours orbital resonance; most exoplanets we've found have some kind of orbital resonance.
So this Allignment thing happens every 405000 years. How far are we from the next time?
@Martin Macak As far as I know, the current climate change is much quicker than past climate changes (10s of years vs 1000s of years) so I doubt that it has a big role in it. I also didn't catch (maybe he didn't metion) if the allignment makes the climate hotter or colder.
@@BurningTrapezoid At 3:37
@@BurningTrapezoid We're currently in a warm period, that's independent of global warming, the astronomical cycle that affects the Earht's climate will lead to a cold period.
@@Shenron557 Oops, didn't catch that. Btw, I looked it up and we are now in the most round orbit phase so in the next 200000 years the orbit will get more and more elyptical but this will obviously not be noticable in our lifetime.
@@Welverin Look at the record going back to the Younger Dryas Period.
We're actually in a warm period but we're near the lowest temp since the last ice age.
"Global warming" isn't even a blip on the graph at that scale. It's been warmer for damn near the entire recorded history of man on that scale.
Don't let my family see this video. I hear enough about Mercury retrograde without them thinking science backs it up.
That is such a gemini thing to say.
What exactly makes Mercury be in retrograde? How does this work geometrically? I thought it was outer planets like Mars and Jupiter that exhibit apparent retrograde motion against the background of the stars as a result of Earth passing them up on the inside track.
@@carultch It's actually a pattern of light that makes it look like it turned around in constellations that make the Zodiac/Horoscope, but it doesn't really turn. But it can look like turned around or Retrograde. But there is still an energy on Earth when this supposed thing happens so...it's probably just that planet messing with Earth's electrical grid. Mercury ironically does this 3 times a year because of how fast it travels.
@@katiearbuckle9017 Can you be more specific about what this "pattern of light" is?
@@carultch Imagine Mercury on the opposite side of Earth from the sun. Both are moving in the same direction of a circle, clockwise. To us, though, this clockwise motion appears to be going left. When it's on the same side of the sky, it, along with earth moves right. This makes it seem like it is moving with us.
I noticed that every time the earth and the sun line up that it is either day or night where I live. Coincidence? I think not!
I believe you're on to something.
Evans! Explain!
And when the moon lines up it disappears. Magic?!?
This is madness. Heresy! Burn him at the stake!
Illuminati: Stay right where you are.
This is super cool! I grew up in Payson, Az, which locals call "rim country" because the edge of the Colorado plateau, the Mogollon Rim, is visible and a short drive from the town. My favorite place in the world is sitting on the edge of the rim, it's literally this gigantic cliff that stretches for miles. You can see all the different layers of rock, its super cool!
Idk why but this video starts approaching VSauce levels of interconnectivity. We just need a good existential crisis at the end to wrap it up haha. Awesome video
Wait, so the Earth, Venus, and Jupiter line up once every 405,000 years which causes a noticeable change in climate? Okay, got it. But... the Earth and Jupiter line up without Venus every 1.08 years (right?) since Juptier's year is 12 Earth years. So two questions:
1) Is the pull of Venus so strong that the measured effect isn't seen every 1.08 years because tiny Venus isn't aligned with Earth and the massive Jupiter?
2) The orbit of Venus is 225 days or 0.616 years. You're telling me the lowest common multiple of 0.616, 1, and 1.08 is 405,000 ?
I must be missing something.
Anyone?
Im just here waiting for the answer, dude
You're not accounting for the fact that the planets don't sit in one spot one day, and then jolt to the next spot the next. Direct alignment is not a day-long event, and realistically lasts a matter of seconds.
He said they line up every 11 years, not every 405,000. 1:31
I can offer a part of the answer, although not all of it. We are used to models depicting the solar system without proper distances being observed, that we forget how much variation there is in planetary distancing. (Looking at you, SciShow! 2:51 ) Venus is SO much closer to Earth than Jupiter that despite its small size, it has similarly significant gravitational effects on Earth.
Venus is 108,000,000 kms (0.72 Astronomical Units) from the Sun. Earth is 150,000,000 kms (1 AU) from the Sun. Jupiter is a whopping 779,000,000 kms (5.19 AUs) from the Sun. (Averages used for simplicity.)So assuming a two dimensional system, Venus is about 0.28 AUs at closest approach to Earth, while Jupiter never gets closer than about 4.19 AUs. A difference of 1496%! The inverse square law of gravity means that Venus' influence on Earth is very significant despite its small size and plays a significant part in conjunctions with Earth.
In regards the second part of the question, the 405,000 years *might* take into account planetary "wobble" from the plane of the solar system where the planets are only truly in conjunction at these intervals and at other times are slightly out alignment above or below the plane.
First he said when the 3 line up every 11 years, they cause the magnetic field of the sun to swap and reset the activity. The second one where it seems like the same event pulls earth 5% out of orbit every 405k years confuses me aswell. My guess is, there is missing some crucial information, like for ex. if another massive planet like saturn lines up, too. I don't know. I think we are missing the same thing here.
EDIT: Or maybe the point is, that for the 11 year event the three only have to be somewhat in line, because the sun is huge and it's diameter extremely large in comparison, but for the second one, it has to be extremely precise to happen.... I really have no idea.
2:20 I remember the 1989 geomagnetic storm that knocked out power here in Quebec. It was freaky!
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/March_1989_geomagnetic_storm
Yet another confusing thing about Quebec... not wanting a reliable source of energy from within your own country.
CG Account: I accept the jab, but... Quebecers prefer electricity, a clean, reliable and renewable source.
The wires were fixed within days and they figured out how to ground 735kV lines.
If that was a jab about petroleum and pipelines, I myself am rather pro-pipeline inasmuch as a pipeline is much, much safer than boats or rail to transport.
So I’m more on your side than you think.
And I hope you’ll agree should be using our finite petroleum for more useful things like plastics and chemicals than just to burn to get to the corner.
2:15 carrington event.
*Love Scishow video early in the morning*
This video was incomplete. When was the last occurrence of these events or where are we in the cycles?!?
Now this is what SciShow should be like every episode. Real science, and not stupid questions like what makes the sky blue. You should make a Kiddie Science channel for stuff like that, and give us back the real science info you used to give us like this. Thanks.
Interesting choice of photo to show Jupiter and Venus when talking about alignment... If both Jupiter and Venus are inthe same photo, from an Earth-orbiting observer, then the three planets cannot be "in alignment" wrt. the sun.
Of course !
"Ah! So *the planets* are causing climate change."
Dave P. Underrated comment.
Don't forget about the Sunny disposition!
You would think that where we are now in the two cycles would be shared in this video...
@@Lodoz they wouldn't dare, RUclips Police Department would crack on them immediately xD
Lol at the climate change deniers
Oh, the 'Crystals and Cards' people are gonna run with this....
'crystals and cards' person here, we already have our own understandings of the effects of the planets positions on human lives, knowledge of how the planets affect other planets and the sun materially doesnt really pertain to that ! :-)
@@zeinab9222 "'crystals and cards' person here" 😂😂🤣🤣👌👌
@@zeinab9222 so youre saying.. the only force that could (and does, as the video just showed) have any influence over "our lives" is _irrelevant_
and dont come with "non-materialism", we're talking about interactions of *physical objects*
@@geekjokes8458 not interested in debating my beliefs with you, just stating what i think :-) not /everything/ the planets do is relevant to astrology.
This was an amazing video. I loved the info. Please keep us updated on this topic 🙏
Thank you for Skillshare, you're the BESTESTEST!
Every space video I see so special so much to take in. Simple days I watch and listen to music I like imagine me travel the space. New rock and legend rock like delta parole, slash, BTS.
A series I just finished watching call this Harmonic Convergence
harmonic Convergence was supposed to happen in the 1980's some time.
@@blueears5429 what's your point?
I love SciShow!😻
Could it be that all planets aligning may help to push earth into a magnetic field reversal as well?
No
Wow! Like this material!!
*sits and stares in awe* I'm reasonably science-savvy, and while SciShow is always bringing me new and interesting information, I have never once had my mind so completely blown as by this episode. Holy crap, this is SO COOL!
holy crap is right.
Mind blowing!
Had to check the date of publication that it wasn't April 1st..
Headline: "Scientist revist models of planetary motion by digging in a lake in NJ"... Amazing!
Don’t say we haven’t had a solar storm in a while, you’ll give 2020 ideas
Finally! Thermodynamic! Love it!
Finally, astrology was right!
You should have mentioned the Milankovitch cycles.
my mind LOVED this video. yes indeed.
00:59 beautiful whatever-graphy where did you find the "complete plate"? in internet I found only a cropped one, thanks
Very insteresting, as always....
I have bad news for people excited by this paper (Stefani et al., 2019). After reading it and some other studies it cites, I learned two things. First, little is new in the paper. The hypothesis was first posted by Wood in 1972 and the actual discovery of the phase-locked correlation of the 1000-year Schove series with the 3 planet conjunctions was done by Okhlopkov (2016). Second it is based on a circular argument. The Schove series is created by fitted sparse data on a phase-locked 11.1 year cycle. So the phase-locking Okhlopkov discovered and Stefani et al. build on was actually a case of circular reasoning.
Harmonic Convergence
I love Scishow! So much to learn. Always interesting.
Ever learning and never coming to a knowledge of the Truth.
It seems like there is huge potential for mistaking correlation for a causation.
What is the reasoning we have for attributing a true causal relationship between the events?
Whoa.
If correct, this would explain a lot!
Super cool!
I've been watching Sci Show Space for years. I liked their videos. That is why I decided to create my own sci-fi/futurist Channel. 👍🙂
We actually had a coronal mass ejection similar to the one that wrecked the telegraph system in the year 2012; it was a close call, it missed Earth by only about a week.
Is there a time/cycle that all the planet's line up and "tug" at the sun with a little more than just Venus Earth & Jupiter, if so does all the planetary mass of our solar system on one side of the sun have an effect?
Probably, but you gotta remember that space is *vast* and even with all planets being in one side they're so far away that any effect could be negligible.
Well technically the whole solarsystem is turning aroung the centre of gravity between the sun and the planets, but since the mass difference is so enormous, I don't think it changes much if all planets are alligned or just the close ones. Neptune and Uranus are pretty far away from the sun.
Hah, don't give any ideas to 2020 Hank :D Its bad enough as it is lol
@ 2:23, 2020 be like
*Note that down, Note that down!!*
Thank you. When is the next cycle due please?
Lookin sick man you good?
great video
This is so cooollll
Yes! Another video heck yeah
5:35 Mars Mars :)
that's why real astrology is science
Damn that’s cool.
Well now that's interesting
Wow sciencie is progressing day by day and turning into Astrology a thousands of year old education
5:33 Mars Mars at opposition in 2003.
Slight typo? Also what does "at opposition mean"?
Is google broken where you live?
If only you could look at the root of the word and make an educated guess...
Bah what am I talking about. No one remembers literally any English class ever.
Mars at its closest to us.
So Sun, Earth, Mars are in alignment.
Syzygy :)
It's things like this that make me smile at "global warming"...not that it isn't happening just that there are SO many factors, yet, they focus on one of them and freak out.
Hey Hank nice Mountain Goats shirt
Henk you're a awesome video maker.
Haven't had a memorable solar storm in a while? This is not a good year to tempt fate sir!
Obviously, Harmonic Convergence happens.
Harmonica virgins.
Hi! Huge fan great Videos Dude! 🤟🤟🙂🙂
We're currently at the very beginning of a solar cycle, meaning solar activity is currently low, but slowly amping up. For 2020 it's supposed to be quiet, slowly increasing until 2023-25 were it will peak, and then decrease again. The last cycle was considered "weak" with mild solar activity, and this coming cycle is anyone's guess.
How about planet 9, it aligns sometime with the rest or had or never have . So every time it aligns.. who knows if it can torch the planets with 1/ 2000-3000 of a degree every turn so how much enery is relesed -where ?
awesome how they discovered this from that sample
3:25 Scientist dig up 100 million year old Rubik's cube showing quite clearly that human intelligence hadn't evolved yet as the cubs where not solved.
That's so cool... Good job science!
PoppyCock The gig is up man
*SciShow Space:* How exactly would Venus, Earth, and Jupiter, having as minimal influence on the sun as described, cause Sol's magnetic field to flip? That seems like an extreme event. Perhaps Hank means the cumulative effect of several instances of that alignment, causing enough magnetic twisting to turn it over.
So there is other influences that could impact global warming, I mean climate change. Maybe we need to keep planets at that social distance so everything stays Normal.
This kind of change happens over much longer timescales, so we would more easily be able to adapt to them.
Man-made climate change happens much faster and it is expensive to fix the damage caused by it.
did ya notice that at 0:57 "SCHEMATIC" was spelled "SCEHMATIC?"
Wowww
It begins! The Grand Conjunction!!
Who has the crystal shard? And can we suck out their essence? Lol
Closed captioning keeps turning on despite ke having it turned off in my general settings. This silliness started a few weeks ago and it is REALLY annoying. How do I keep them from turning on?
Ok but where are we in each cycle? Why wasn’t that mentioned?
Good song, Continue like that :)
this is COMPLETELY off-topic but its something very annoying that happens randomly on youtube (only on the computer because of the shortcuts involved)
so you know how you can press ctrl+backspace or delete to delete a word? sometimes it simply erases the whole comment! luckily pressing ctrl+z works, but its incredibly frustrating
even weirder, it started happening only in the notifications, then more recently on any video
i have no idea whats causing that, and cant even figure out because sometimes it just sorts itself out, or if i go to another window (but less frequently if i use alt+tab) - just now, i opened word to check if this wasnt something wrong with my computer itself, and i came back and writing here was working normally again; sometimes it is isolated to one tab, sometimes closing that tab works and others i have to close the window itself
I've been commenting on sci-show videos for years... this will take some getting used to.
Sky Safari seems to indicate that all the planets and the moon are in the same quadrant of the sky right now (May 14, 2020)
i must be the dumbest subscriber. i initially thought the picture at 3:15 was of a set of books with colorful bindings
You're not alone xD
I just really want to see hank as a guest on star talk with Neil deGrasse Tyson.
Right! No more stuff that might, even conceivably scare me. There are no planetary influences, no sun cycles, Earth pole reversals, certainly no precession of the poles and volcanoes are no longer a thing. As for asteroids.... makey-uppy.
It’s amazing that given how little we know about earth climate history, there are still always climate alarmists telling us the world will end in 12 years.
They’ve been saying that for 100 years now….
Do all the planets ever line up?
I hope you are doing well, 🙏
The 405,000-year climate cycle is the Milankovitch cycle. It's a quite a well-known cycle and it's odd that the video never mentions the name. If we take this cycle seriously, we are in a cooling trend for the next 23,000 years.
So, what are we doing to stop this from happening again?
Does anyone know when the next time this happens
www.theplanetstoday.com/?fbclid=IwAR1hWUiartyClZA8_eaVtjrHvGABkiE5SFePTSm4r2RfX6JRBUZetToj9xc
This is AMAZING! Does this coincide with earth's seemingly random magnetic field reversals? Perhaps deep time MF reversals might have had celestial explanations.
The timings are off though
I wonder if the influence of the planetary alignment is why our sun is unusually calm, suppressing sunspot activity.
Remember The Jupiter Effect? In my memory, Not much happened.
What the planets told me:
You will meet people today, one of which may or may not be an old friend, and you will have to make a financial decision which may be either inconsequential or consequential
What about taking samples from mars and i dont mean the first few layers
When will all 3 be aligned again?
Saturn and Jupiter doing something
405,000 yeeeers
We have had solar storms recently they just missed us.
So Kepler was right as Pythagoras - it is just a beautiful DANCE - just look at the kiss of VENUS! IMAGINE STEPPING OVER THE WHOLE LOD FROM ABOVE LIKE GOD’S SPIRIT HOVERING OVER THE DARK AND DEEP- WHAT WOULD WE SEE???? I BET A REAL BEAUTIFUL SACRED GEOMETRY MANDALA ! ALL IN ONE!