Bro missed the best actor in the series. How can you forget Black Noir? He had the best acting, best expressions of any character. Definitely in Oscarworthy category
idk if this is a joke or not, but the actor who did Black Noir 1 did amazing with his body language as a mute character in a mask, and he is doing a good job portraying Back Noir 2 in Season 4
I saw anthony starr in Banshee he is even better there cause that show is literally all about his sensational acting in a very good plot he is one of the phenomenal actors I ve seen in my lifetime
Is it just me or does this guy not know a thing about the characters or even acting like all the stuff he said is so hit or miss sure Karl and Antony’s acting was on point but ranking kimikos acting as high as butchers??? Like she doesn’t even show emotion she’s either smiling most of her scenes or not using her facial muscles. Also with starlight if her character consistently shows subtle emotions why expect her to change in that one scene with Maeve? And about Maeve of course her hand wouldn’t move in her fist is clearly clenched with rage… chase crawford crying scene invoking emotion is absolute cap he’s amazing with his comic relief role given that he just seems stupid and clueless in every scene he’s in. Change ur career dude srsly
Yeah when he criticized Hughie not being frantic with his Dad in the A-train scene, it neglects the hardened growth Hughie went through by that point. S1E1 Hughie would probably react like that, but that episode Hughie was a changed man
Not having Stormfront and Soldier Boy on this list is weird considering they carried their seasons. Also Antony, Aya and Jensen are the only actors to have received awards for their roles which pretty much answers the top tier category lol.
Hughie not showing fear or desperate emotion is the whole point. He always thinks he's weak, especially you can see it in season 3. So he is trying his best to be brave and it was so good seeing someone who never blackmailed or manipulated someone actually succeeding at it (remember the part with Ezekiel or A-train), him standing up against Homelander when he was laughing at Starlight. Jack nailed this character so good. Amazing expressions, voice,, everything. Deserves an Amazing tier
@@oliverjames2655I think he didn't get it, it's suposed to be shock, he's terrified, sometimes putting too much emotion feels too over the top and exaggerated
Seems like you should’ve payed more attention to the roles these characters portrayed. Since you watched only for pure, by-the-book acting, you failed to realize what was supposed to be their own quirks that enhance who they’re supposed to be. As previously said, you missed that Hughie was supposed to be unnatural and “too little” worried in certain situations. He’s literally acting as a person who’s acting as a different person (Jack Quaid acting as Hughie who acts tougher then he truly is). Very few people can pull this off and Quaid did it perfectly. You were so objective in your analysis that you missed key, pivotal aspects of both the characters and the actors, which matters for their tier.
@@govenormayor87 thats a VALID point, thank you, I will defo consider there actual nature in my next review. So you mean more so, how there character was TRYING TO ACT? How hughie was unconfident because hes TYPICALLY shy but tried to be confident etc... .
@@KoshoReacts Because as someone pointed out to me a week ago, so many of The Deep's scenes are him talking with fish/himself and thus are really Chace Crawford acting with the wall yet he goes all in with those performances as if there's really someone there. You pointed out the scene of him breaking down and crying while talking to his gills and in that scene other than maybe someone reading the gills lines off screen it's just Chace performing to himself which is much harder than performing with someone to bounce off of.
@@KoshoReacts watch Chase in an interview, for the Deep he changes posture, he is always mewing, they like to have him eat because he does weird swallowing things with his neck. I get that he isn't dramatic but his physical acting is with every part of his body. I also think that very few people can pull off being a charismatic antagonist, in classic film James Mason was the go to, if you want a 2024 Humbert Humbert Chace is your guy. He is out here practicing bestiality and people are like oh what a scamp.
When good actors are acting they aren’t moving their eyebrows or quivering their lips on purpose. Acting isn’t thinking about it and actively deciding to do it, they are truly showing emotion. I do agree with a lot of these points on certain actors, but it also comes down to direction. When you said that butcher should have gotten in their faces a bit more in the supe victim meeting, it’s not like Karl is just deciding exactly how butcher is supposed to be. Sure, he’s the actor and he definitely puts his own spin on things, but the director gets the final say, and brings things like that up if it’s an issue.
I love ur comment I LIVE for this stuff, and yes I agree the director does have a lot of sway. I make suggestions more in the context of the SCENE and just in my opinion butcher would have had a more effective scene w more exaggeration (a pattern I tend to see that lacks), and yes acting for THEM isn’t about thinking but we can point to the elements that make their acting great etc…
I guess what I mean with the first half is that they do probably have certain key acting techniques of what they want to do, but actors aren’t thinking as themselves during the scene. In the scene, Antony Starr isn’t Antony Star, he’s homelander, and so he isn’t thinking “oh let me activate that lip quiver real quick” because that breaks character
@@KoshoReactsi feel like you're trying to bring in too much logistics of what makes acting stand out based on your set of standards; such as Maeve/Starlight/MM etc. they all have their own stand out moments of their existence being in place based on what transpired through their own wellbeing in the universe of The Boys...
What was Annie supposed to be happy for exactly when talking to Maeve? Not only does Maeve look like she got jumped, but she lost her powers, and that one less person on the 7 that’s against Homelander. Why does she need to be expressing joy when there’s so many other factors to consider. And who says she has to be happy in this scene anyway?
You’re confusing acting choices with acting capability. Just because an actor’s not emoting a certain way, that doesn’t mean they’re incapable of doing it. They’ve decided it’s not true to the character. If they made the choices you suggested, THAT would be over the top, out of character, bad acting.
okay dude a few tips since this clearly aint your thing... when hughie asked his dad to leave he CHOSE not to display fear as he wanted to keep the room as calm as possible. of course he was terrified, but he wanted his dad to remain calm and not do anything stupid. this is actually a pro for jack quaid and not at all a negative. secondly hughie aint the main character at all. there really isnt a definitive main character but both homelander and butcher take the center stage more than hughie. only season 1 could you say hughie might be the main character. also idk what your talking about with a-train being a comedic character. he's always been pretty serious, from being a main antagonist is season 1, to starting his redemption arc in season 3.
Fr, Hughie in this scenario, wasn’t afraid of A-train because he had the upper hand. He had Kimiko and V in his back pocket. He knew he was safe, so he had no reason to plead with his father similarly to Grant Gustin in the Flash
One thing I’m surprised you didn’t mention in Antony Starr’s acting techniques, is where he twitches his face to show anger and bottled up rage. Specifically his lips and check-bone muscles.
You say Dominique Mcelligot doesn't display confidence and is struggling to express herself but like isn't that kinda just what the character is going through?
9:25 Almost like he DOESN'T want to punch the new husband of his ex wife. I know, CRAZY This video is literally if aliens discovered acting and tried to give advice on it
When you said something about how Starlight's smile isn't genuine, I think it wasn't genuine on purpose. I feel like it wasn't a full blown smile because when Maeve is leaving with her girlfriend Starlight is happy about them, but it reminds her of the boys's still ongoing problem with Vought, which makes her feel like she can't let herself go yet.
Stan Edgar and Homelanders scenes are some of the best moments of acting in the entire show. The way they show agitation,emotion and their reactions are incredible.
You don’t need to listen to the guy, who judges the acting by the eyebrows. He is right about their acting level, but acting is not about facial expressions
Gotta disagree with that Starlight & Maeve take you had saying she was barely showing emotion. There was nothing to “celebrate”. Maeve lost her powers, Homelander is coming back even more angry than before. There are too many negatives over that positive for Starlight to be happy. It was over for Maeve. Shit storm was still coming for Annie
Its crazy you didnt include ashley tbh, she’s defo a top tier actor like dude 😭 you gotta make a part 2 of this🤩 Edit: nvm you put her in at the end but you should pay a lot more attention cus she’s actually really great
HAHAHA I DIDD include her, I just didn’t think there was enough to give her a ranking BUT TBH after watching season 4 she only amazes me MORE!! I can’t reupdate this early BUT I’d defo put her in “amazing” genuinly, what’d you think of my critique overall tho?
Obviously Hughie doesn't have rage smh, that's kinda the point, Hughie isn't very scary like Butcher or Homelander, he's kinda "a little bitch boy" And the reason he is having more and more rage is cuz of a little thing called character development. You're a little too focused on the actors you didn't seem to think about the characters or story, I'll let you slide on the otjer opinions but not this one, still much love to ya ❤
Pretty good video man. I don't agree with your entire list but you made some good points I agree with. Definitely doesn't deserve the 1300 dislikes, you can tell a lot of the people in the comments are toxic fanboys of the show. Btw, could you review Peter Capaldi's acting in Doctor Who? Especially his scenes from The Zygon Inversion and Heavent Sent episodes? He's a phenomenal actor which makes him my favorite Doctor overall
homie you are the biggest NPC on youtube, you should rename your channel to :KoshoTheNPC_Reacts. Also who are you to judge these actors? Ive never seen your face before
This list is pretty rough. I don't agree with a lot of points and the way you measure it all is just not it. Plus, using a CW show as an example of good acting? ...Yikes
You know, the main problem I see with your judgement is that it seems that you have more problems with the directing of the scenes than the acting, but still putting the "blame" on them? It doesn't seem fair to me. You still make some good points, but I feel like you're just being excessively critical for some of this actors
Hmmm thank you for ur input, can u point specific points out? ALWAYS looking to improve, I feel like I was DEFO fair in most, I mainly criticized acting and if the character didn’t report emotion how the SCENE deserved it etc
good video, it shows you put effort on it, but the clickbaiting thing with anthony having a “6/10” just to fish some views is a lil weird bruh, if you keep putting these effort and charisma you shouldnt be doing it
The thing is with hughie being compared to grant gustin in that scene is that zoom was a completely evil monster who killed without any emotion or motive, he hurt people for fun and barry knew that. He knew in that instant that his dad was dead so the only thing he could do was plead for his life. A train has a conscience, its not a strong one but he isnt evil, he’s just a celebrity who happens to have powers that could end people if he chooses. Hughies’ dad could potentially get hurt or killed if he doesn’t leave but if push comes to shove, it isn’t A trains style to just kill an innocent man without a strong motive, he didn’t have to plead for his dads life he just wanted him to be in a safer environment. That worry is understandable, especially from someone thats trying to act brave in front of his enemy and act strong in front of his dad, barry had gone past that point and was just desperate and powerless to save his dad, all he could do in that moment was beg.
@@KoshoReactsnot a "Lil "difference .one was literally held at knife point while in the other case A train wasn't even trying to kill his dad. And also puttin laz alonso in "average" is criminal.Hope u can understand
I disagree with the M.M. part, it is in his character to be calm and reserved. He is responsible and cautious of his own actions due to his ocd, he never wanted to hurt Todd and stayed civil. When he did punch him it was more of a jerk reaction. That being said I do agree that his facial expressions can have some improvement.
DONT EVEN WORRYY! I have a 5 page doc ready for it 🔥 just tryna finish some vids on the boys since its finale just came out. But if you’d like to give ur input on any specific parts/actors I’d love to hear 🤝
Considering Jensen Ackles was Emmy worthy (ie. Oscar Worthy) and carried season 3 is weird that he’s not mentioned here. Also shoutout to Stormfront. Should be on here (maybe not Oscar worthy but still great)
hughie not expressing fear is because he was confident in his plan. dumb point considering the character isn't scared so why should the actor portray fear
Elizabeth Shue is a veteran and she is extraordinary. Well deserved Oscar category. But I'll argue about The Deep, Chace is definitely in Amazing category. And now with season 4 is even more clear. I'll argue that Usher is above Erin as an actor, so I'll put him second in Good category (after Jack but definitely before Erin).
Given the context of A-Train being addicted to the Compound V and not being able to get it or something his kind of lighter tone in that scene with Hughie kind adds to the like unhinged withdrawal vibe he would have
7:03 Can we talk about how the fuck you somehow managed to make the subscribe button have a colored outline right as you were talking about subscribing?
I love jack quaid acting. He does the "average guy surronded with special people" acting so so well. He is like the only normal person in the show. He is going from this sheltered, trampled over guy like his dad to a real tough guy slowly but surely Also the moment you noted: I dont think hughie was scared in that moment, he was just worried and didnt want him to be here, but hughie was in control, he knew what to do, he had no reason to be scared.
I do think that Chace Crawford (The Deep) deserves a much higher rank! His scenes always get me and Im constantly wainting for more of it. To make it quick: he is phenomenal at showing pain and suffering. Yes, he is a comedy relief, however, only because we enjoy seeing an unlikable character suffering through a lot. The scene in which he must eat the octopus or (S4 spoiler) when he kills his "girlfriend". It is done SO well! I would have at least given him an Amazing if not Oscar winning, but that is just my opinion
I think Jack Quaide is the worst actor. He always gives some insincere smiles at people he loves, that if a person irl gave me I would think he is faking it and doesnt love me. I think he is probably plenty talented guy, but immature or something
Almost like the actors are acting like their characters...? also "batcher", "hughee"... c'mon man. Feels like you read into it way too hard and got it wrong plenty of times, makes you seem like you think you know what you're on about, but don't actually have a clue.
12:30 Maeve does not move nc she is super strong and cannot act on her emotions. She is afraid of hurting someone, thats why she is stiff. I think thats actually great acting
This dude doesn't know what he is talking about, Jack Quaid should be in amazing at least. You're not considering the type of characters they are playing and you are not judging based on established metrics. You sometimes mention a book but never say which one it is, so we don't know if it is reputable source or not.
Mate if you want to grow as a channel you need to improve your presentation. You need to cut out those shots of you reacting to the old clips--they absolutely add nothing to the video and are kind of narcissistic and annoying. Second, we don't need to see all the stuff in your room. Clean up the table and the background so we can focus on the analysis and not all the distracting objects here and there. Also, you need better lighting.
In season 1, episode 8 of For All Mankind Shantel VanSanten gave what I thought was one of the best performances of the season. And I don't mean the show's season - I mean that year's television season.
The problem with Maeve is that she is was given terrible lines. Her every sentence is some shitty one liner that is meant to be like big words, but just sounds cheesy. I Felt bad for the actress
It seems like you don't appreciate subtle emotions- it's most apparent in your comparison of Huey and the Flash. Never having seen the Flash, that dude was overacting
I appreciate ur input thank YOU ❤️ WITH that being said tho, in the SAME hughie comparison I praised him in the beginning for his sad scenes, w the eye twitching etc, I defo do appreciate subtle emotions BUT I just think WHEN he tried to show off aggressive scenes they landed flat :)
this video analyses the actors' acting well tbh. BUT it just doesn't factor in the story/context clues the actors are getting. It generalizes how a scene should have been acted and just goes with it. good watch, nonetheless.
Erin’s bad acting is not because of her ability, its because of the botox, her face looks like its gonna break if she smiles. Not surprised her best acting was in season 1 and one of her worst is in the later seasons
![Tee Grizzley - Blow for Blow (feat. J. Cole) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wNLN5xsx5dc/mqdefault.jpg)
WHICH SHOW’s actors should I review NEXT? LMK what else you wanna see ILY ♥️
Gen V if you haven’t done it already. I think it’ll be very interesting to see
@@Gchjghjhg YESS that is coming up forsure, just gonna do a few more phenomenal, elegant, spectacular vids about the boys FIRST
The Walking Dead
The Walking Dead, Game of Thrones, and The Sopranos
@@redrocketrider hmmm never watched the show, is it STILL popular?
Bro missed the best actor in the series. How can you forget Black Noir? He had the best acting, best expressions of any character. Definitely in Oscarworthy category
Yes
@@shawnyboi6228 sigma train 😔
idk if this is a joke or not, but the actor who did Black Noir 1 did amazing with his body language as a mute character in a mask, and he is doing a good job portraying Back Noir 2 in Season 4
@@mattnic001 ikr
I saw anthony starr in Banshee he is even better there cause that show is literally all about his sensational acting in a very good plot he is one of the phenomenal actors I ve seen in my lifetime
YESS just made a new vid and i included him in banshee specifically! His range truly improved in THAT show
@@KoshoReacts true
Alright but where is my boi Jensen 😭
Also where's Aya?
Is it just me or does this guy not know a thing about the characters or even acting like all the stuff he said is so hit or miss sure Karl and Antony’s acting was on point but ranking kimikos acting as high as butchers??? Like she doesn’t even show emotion she’s either smiling most of her scenes or not using her facial muscles. Also with starlight if her character consistently shows subtle emotions why expect her to change in that one scene with Maeve? And about Maeve of course her hand wouldn’t move in her fist is clearly clenched with rage… chase crawford crying scene invoking emotion is absolute cap he’s amazing with his comic relief role given that he just seems stupid and clueless in every scene he’s in. Change ur career dude srsly
BRO YOU’RE IGNORING THE CHARACTER THEY ARE FUCKING PLAYING, perhaps the acting isn’t bad but that’s how the fucking character would act.
thats what i think too, this dude just want all the character to act like he wants
I was thinking about that with M.M
@@simond3292 starlight too
Yeah when he criticized Hughie not being frantic with his Dad in the A-train scene, it neglects the hardened growth Hughie went through by that point. S1E1 Hughie would probably react like that, but that episode Hughie was a changed man
Not having Stormfront and Soldier Boy on this list is weird considering they carried their seasons. Also Antony, Aya and Jensen are the only actors to have received awards for their roles which pretty much answers the top tier category lol.
Only Anthony is in the Oscar winning tier
The closest is Karl Urban
@@MVN05 Well that's your opinion, but Stormfront and Soldier Boy at least deserve to be on the list. They're such pivotal characters to the show
Yeah my thoughts exactly lol, also would have been cool to have Claudia Doumit mentioned (Victoria Neuman)
Faxxx
@@finixmoon127 Yeah i agree that Victoria should also be on the list, same with Ashley but at least he included her as an honorable mention.
Hughie not showing fear or desperate emotion is the whole point. He always thinks he's weak, especially you can see it in season 3. So he is trying his best to be brave and it was so good seeing someone who never blackmailed or manipulated someone actually succeeding at it (remember the part with Ezekiel or A-train), him standing up against Homelander when he was laughing at Starlight.
Jack nailed this character so good. Amazing expressions, voice,, everything. Deserves an Amazing tier
Yes but realistically the situation with his dad shouldve pushed him to act out in fear and desperation
@@oliverjames2655I think he didn't get it, it's suposed to be shock, he's terrified, sometimes putting too much emotion feels too over the top and exaggerated
@@DamienGOD1128 I agree but it wasn't close to too much, it was a little too LESS
Seems like you should’ve payed more attention to the roles these characters portrayed. Since you watched only for pure, by-the-book acting, you failed to realize what was supposed to be their own quirks that enhance who they’re supposed to be. As previously said, you missed that Hughie was supposed to be unnatural and “too little” worried in certain situations. He’s literally acting as a person who’s acting as a different person (Jack Quaid acting as Hughie who acts tougher then he truly is). Very few people can pull this off and Quaid did it perfectly.
You were so objective in your analysis that you missed key, pivotal aspects of both the characters and the actors, which matters for their tier.
@@govenormayor87 thats a VALID point, thank you, I will defo consider there actual nature in my next review. So you mean more so, how there character was TRYING TO ACT? How hughie was unconfident because hes TYPICALLY shy but tried to be confident etc... .
Chace Crawford should be in the Oscar category, not joking
Oh my gosh, OSCAR?? Elaborate
@@KoshoReactsyo Korey elaborate ur shit
@@KoshoReacts Because as someone pointed out to me a week ago, so many of The Deep's scenes are him talking with fish/himself and thus are really Chace Crawford acting with the wall yet he goes all in with those performances as if there's really someone there.
You pointed out the scene of him breaking down and crying while talking to his gills and in that scene other than maybe someone reading the gills lines off screen it's just Chace performing to himself which is much harder than performing with someone to bounce off of.
@@KoshoReacts watch Chase in an interview, for the Deep he changes posture, he is always mewing, they like to have him eat because he does weird swallowing things with his neck. I get that he isn't dramatic but his physical acting is with every part of his body. I also think that very few people can pull off being a charismatic antagonist, in classic film James Mason was the go to, if you want a 2024 Humbert Humbert Chace is your guy. He is out here practicing bestiality and people are like oh what a scamp.
@@Gee-xb7rt😂
*actor has eyebrows*
This guy: Oscar.
LMAOOOOOO HAHAHAH
These ranking made me realize you don’t know what each charcter is meant to act like
I think the same
Syau
Good acting isn't who can portray the most emotion. It's not all about the big flashy scenes with a character screaming and crying
When good actors are acting they aren’t moving their eyebrows or quivering their lips on purpose. Acting isn’t thinking about it and actively deciding to do it, they are truly showing emotion. I do agree with a lot of these points on certain actors, but it also comes down to direction. When you said that butcher should have gotten in their faces a bit more in the supe victim meeting, it’s not like Karl is just deciding exactly how butcher is supposed to be. Sure, he’s the actor and he definitely puts his own spin on things, but the director gets the final say, and brings things like that up if it’s an issue.
I love ur comment I LIVE for this stuff, and yes I agree the director does have a lot of sway. I make suggestions more in the context of the SCENE and just in my opinion butcher would have had a more effective scene w more exaggeration (a pattern I tend to see that lacks), and yes acting for THEM isn’t about thinking but we can point to the elements that make their acting great etc…
this is not completely true but sure
I think the second half of this comment is a bit more true than the first half
I guess what I mean with the first half is that they do probably have certain key acting techniques of what they want to do, but actors aren’t thinking as themselves during the scene. In the scene, Antony Starr isn’t Antony Star, he’s homelander, and so he isn’t thinking “oh let me activate that lip quiver real quick” because that breaks character
@@KoshoReactsi feel like you're trying to bring in too much logistics of what makes acting stand out based on your set of standards; such as Maeve/Starlight/MM etc. they all have their own stand out moments of their existence being in place based on what transpired through their own wellbeing in the universe of The Boys...
What was Annie supposed to be happy for exactly when talking to Maeve? Not only does Maeve look like she got jumped, but she lost her powers, and that one less person on the 7 that’s against Homelander. Why does she need to be expressing joy when there’s so many other factors to consider. And who says she has to be happy in this scene anyway?
You’re confusing acting choices with acting capability. Just because an actor’s not emoting a certain way, that doesn’t mean they’re incapable of doing it. They’ve decided it’s not true to the character. If they made the choices you suggested, THAT would be over the top, out of character, bad acting.
okay dude a few tips since this clearly aint your thing... when hughie asked his dad to leave he CHOSE not to display fear as he wanted to keep the room as calm as possible. of course he was terrified, but he wanted his dad to remain calm and not do anything stupid. this is actually a pro for jack quaid and not at all a negative.
secondly hughie aint the main character at all. there really isnt a definitive main character but both homelander and butcher take the center stage more than hughie. only season 1 could you say hughie might be the main character.
also idk what your talking about with a-train being a comedic character. he's always been pretty serious, from being a main antagonist is season 1, to starting his redemption arc in season 3.
Thank you for watching fr, I disagree with the last 2 paragraphs forsure but luv u
@@KoshoReacts no hate still an entertaining video!
Thank you, I appreciate your opinion tho ❤️ welcome to the channel
Fr, Hughie in this scenario, wasn’t afraid of A-train because he had the upper hand. He had Kimiko and V in his back pocket. He knew he was safe, so he had no reason to plead with his father similarly to Grant Gustin in the Flash
agree 100%
One thing I’m surprised you didn’t mention in Antony Starr’s acting techniques, is where he twitches his face to show anger and bottled up rage. Specifically his lips and check-bone muscles.
YEAA I did mention that when he relaxed his face
You say Dominique Mcelligot doesn't display confidence and is struggling to express herself but like isn't that kinda just what the character is going through?
9:25 Almost like he DOESN'T want to punch the new husband of his ex wife. I know, CRAZY
This video is literally if aliens discovered acting and tried to give advice on it
When you said something about how Starlight's smile isn't genuine, I think it wasn't genuine on purpose. I feel like it wasn't a full blown smile because when Maeve is leaving with her girlfriend Starlight is happy about them, but it reminds her of the boys's still ongoing problem with Vought, which makes her feel like she can't let herself go yet.
Bros frame of reference for good acting is CW Shows 💀
grant gustin is phenomenal sweetie pie
@@KoshoReactsno he’s not, he’s mediocre at best
Tv shows show more emotion that block buster movies. Henry cavill vs Tom welling. Ezra miller vs Grant Gustin.
I agree, I was making a little joke
Someone who cant act judges top level actors. lmao what a joke
exactly what i said, he can’t even speak english correctly
Karen's dance routine in the hospital just added to the amazing character and actor that she is. So enjoyable.
Hahaha maybe I shodulvr reviewed and analyzed the dancing
Now he's reviewing The Boys? Bros finna review every show and movie in EXISTENCE
Bahahahah we r coming for it ALLL! What next?
L, homelander>>>
Womp womp bae
@@KoshoReactsbreaking bad
@@Thebigtom12 coming within THIS MONTHH!
I think in M.M's case, he wasn't oozing anger because he was trying to remain civil with todd infront of his daughter.
“Lets finish Antony off” ayooo??
I meant in a PROFESSIONAL WAY finishing off his in depth, analytical review. That is all.
gay @@KoshoReacts
@@peanutlover409AJEJRJEHEJEJ.
Stan Edgar and Homelanders scenes are some of the best moments of acting in the entire show. The way they show agitation,emotion and their reactions are incredible.
and the way stan edgar shows it is different to homelander, that means you dont need those over the top emotions to prove it
Imo best acting is Antony Starr- Homelander, Chace Crawford - Deep, Aya Cash - Stormfront and Jensen Ackles - Soldier Boy
And The actor for Ashley is also a honorable mention
You don’t need to listen to the guy, who judges the acting by the eyebrows. He is right about their acting level, but acting is not about facial expressions
Fax, i'm glad i didn't have to say it
Facial expressions is an integral part of acting. It's one of the core basics.
dude i dont think this guy has ever taken an acting class
yeah hes an NPC
Nah fr this dude is ass💀
@@thecuriousboihe feels like an ai thats just yapping and i dont know the first thing about acting
@@kroo702 what? have u ever seen an AI act before?
@@thecuriousboi the way he talks makes him feel like an ai
Gotta disagree with that Starlight & Maeve take you had saying she was barely showing emotion. There was nothing to “celebrate”. Maeve lost her powers, Homelander is coming back even more angry than before. There are too many negatives over that positive for Starlight to be happy. It was over for Maeve. Shit storm was still coming for Annie
It’s a crime that Soldier Boy isn’t a part of this video
I knoww maybe in part 2
Bruh you said EVERY 💀
Its crazy you didnt include ashley tbh, she’s defo a top tier actor like dude 😭 you gotta make a part 2 of this🤩
Edit: nvm you put her in at the end but you should pay a lot more attention cus she’s actually really great
HAHAHA I DIDD include her, I just didn’t think there was enough to give her a ranking BUT TBH after watching season 4 she only amazes me MORE!! I can’t reupdate this early BUT I’d defo put her in “amazing” genuinly, what’d you think of my critique overall tho?
@@KoshoReacts I don’t she could have had much less screen time than Becca’s actress
butcher is oscar worthy fs
Where's my soldier boi? *Clenches chest in pain 😔*
I don’t like you idk what it is 😂
have you watched the show? do you know how the characters act at all?
Obviously Hughie doesn't have rage smh, that's kinda the point, Hughie isn't very scary like Butcher or Homelander, he's kinda "a little bitch boy" And the reason he is having more and more rage is cuz of a little thing called character development. You're a little too focused on the actors you didn't seem to think about the characters or story, I'll let you slide on the otjer opinions but not this one, still much love to ya ❤
You left out Giancarlo Esposito. My Vought himself. Watch the scenes with him and Homelander...Excellent.
This is the first time I've ever heard someone actually pronounce the "times" for [season]x[episode] format lmao
have you considered that hughie's "acting skills" may be part of his character who is dead inside?
love watching a guy talk about acting, when he cant even act nor speak english well.
Muahhh
@@KoshoReacts you’re gay
So you need a degree to have an opinion?
@@KoshoReacts you’re disabled
@@M.W428 i have an opinion as well, your comment makes no sense
Pretty good video man. I don't agree with your entire list but you made some good points I agree with. Definitely doesn't deserve the 1300 dislikes, you can tell a lot of the people in the comments are toxic fanboys of the show.
Btw, could you review Peter Capaldi's acting in Doctor Who? Especially his scenes from The Zygon Inversion and Heavent Sent episodes? He's a phenomenal actor which makes him my favorite Doctor overall
My man Kosho is reviewing peak now! Let's go!!! 👏🏾
Such a PHENOMENAL SHOW omg! What’d u think about season 4
@@KoshoReacts Haven't fully watched it yet, but it's looking promising. If I had to choose a season, it would probably be S2, or 3.
Yea season 2 was SO good imo rlly insane story arc
I think due to the recent season MM and Frenchie should be Atleast 1 tier higher they’ve definitely kicked it up a notch
Lmao, what a terrible video.
homie you are the biggest NPC on youtube, you should rename your channel to :KoshoTheNPC_Reacts. Also who are you to judge these actors? Ive never seen your face before
I think chace Crawford deserves the amazing. He literally carries the whole show comedy
Billy Butcher and HomeLander are Oscar Worthy Gods
sending hate from New Zealand 🫶
This list is pretty rough. I don't agree with a lot of points and the way you measure it all is just not it. Plus, using a CW show as an example of good acting? ...Yikes
😭😭😭♥️♥️♥️♥️
„Hewgie“ 😭
You know, the main problem I see with your judgement is that it seems that you have more problems with the directing of the scenes than the acting, but still putting the "blame" on them? It doesn't seem fair to me. You still make some good points, but I feel like you're just being excessively critical for some of this actors
Hmmm thank you for ur input, can u point specific points out? ALWAYS looking to improve, I feel like I was DEFO fair in most, I mainly criticized acting and if the character didn’t report emotion how the SCENE deserved it etc
you literally pronounced like every name you possibly could wrong 😂😂😂
good video, it shows you put effort on it, but the clickbaiting thing with anthony having a “6/10” just to fish some views is a lil weird bruh, if you keep putting these effort and charisma you shouldnt be doing it
You should rate Hughie's dad for part 2. The actor def did a oscar level performance in his last moments imo.
Antony Starr is so good because he ain't acting
Definitely need a part 2 of this. Im sure you'll have fun analyzing storm front, Mesmer, and hopefully you talk about season 4 too
Hahaha appreciate it, HUGE vid about the bots coming soon and will defo cover season 4 soon!!
How can butchers terrible accent not get addressed, I literally thought he was Australian
The thing is with hughie being compared to grant gustin in that scene is that zoom was a completely evil monster who killed without any emotion or motive, he hurt people for fun and barry knew that. He knew in that instant that his dad was dead so the only thing he could do was plead for his life.
A train has a conscience, its not a strong one but he isnt evil, he’s just a celebrity who happens to have powers that could end people if he chooses. Hughies’ dad could potentially get hurt or killed if he doesn’t leave but if push comes to shove, it isn’t A trains style to just kill an innocent man without a strong motive, he didn’t have to plead for his dads life he just wanted him to be in a safer environment. That worry is understandable, especially from someone thats trying to act brave in front of his enemy and act strong in front of his dad, barry had gone past that point and was just desperate and powerless to save his dad, all he could do in that moment was beg.
14:58 ones dad is actually being held hostage while the others dad can jus walk away. There’s a huge difference
Ehhh not rlly, he wasn’t rlly just walking away a train had him there for a reason, but yes still a lil difference
@@KoshoReactsnot a "Lil "difference .one was literally held at knife point while in the other case A train wasn't even trying to kill his dad. And also puttin laz alonso in "average" is criminal.Hope u can understand
Muah
I disagree with the M.M. part, it is in his character to be calm and reserved. He is responsible and cautious of his own actions due to his ocd, he never wanted to hurt Todd and stayed civil. When he did punch him it was more of a jerk reaction. That being said I do agree that his facial expressions can have some improvement.
Nah Chace Crawford as Deep is so damn good its like hes so immersed in the character its exactly what the deep would behave
The crazy thing is that I never really paid attention to this. You being able to notice all these little details is absolutely stunning
Hahah thank you that means a lot ❤❤
Can you do this with Breaking Bad? I know it's not your type of genre but that''d be an awesome video.
DONT EVEN WORRYY! I have a 5 page doc ready for it 🔥 just tryna finish some vids on the boys since its finale just came out. But if you’d like to give ur input on any specific parts/actors I’d love to hear 🤝
Considering Jensen Ackles was Emmy worthy (ie. Oscar Worthy) and carried season 3 is weird that he’s not mentioned here. Also shoutout to Stormfront. Should be on here (maybe not Oscar worthy but still great)
I think butcher is the main character
Everything wrong with your analysis, sorry
hughie not expressing fear is because he was confident in his plan. dumb point considering the character isn't scared so why should the actor portray fear
W bae
muah
Elizabeth Shue is a veteran and she is extraordinary. Well deserved Oscar category.
But I'll argue about The Deep, Chace is definitely in Amazing category. And now with season 4 is even more clear.
I'll argue that Usher is above Erin as an actor, so I'll put him second in Good category (after Jack but definitely before Erin).
Given the context of A-Train being addicted to the Compound V and not being able to get it or something his kind of lighter tone in that scene with Hughie kind adds to the like unhinged withdrawal vibe he would have
bro please never cook again 🙏
7:03 Can we talk about how the fuck you somehow managed to make the subscribe button have a colored outline right as you were talking about subscribing?
7:47 amazing 🦅🦅🦅 acting skills
Where black noir
I love jack quaid acting. He does the "average guy surronded with special people" acting so so well. He is like the only normal person in the show. He is going from this sheltered, trampled over guy like his dad to a real tough guy slowly but surely
Also the moment you noted: I dont think hughie was scared in that moment, he was just worried and didnt want him to be here, but hughie was in control, he knew what to do, he had no reason to be scared.
No way you put MM in the average category. He deserves to be in tge good category
WHERES MY BOY SOLDIER BOY
yap yap yap
I think you should've put the Lenny stuff in the Karl Urban stuff. That was great
Antony in s4e4 was insanely good aswell
OMG YES, making a full vid on why 4x4 was the BEST episode yet.
Naw you did mm dirty
I do think that Chace Crawford (The Deep) deserves a much higher rank!
His scenes always get me and Im constantly wainting for more of it.
To make it quick: he is phenomenal at showing pain and suffering.
Yes, he is a comedy relief, however, only because we enjoy seeing an unlikable character suffering through a lot.
The scene in which he must eat the octopus or (S4 spoiler) when he kills his "girlfriend". It is done SO well!
I would have at least given him an Amazing if not Oscar winning, but that is just my opinion
I think Jack Quaide is the worst actor. He always gives some insincere smiles at people he loves, that if a person irl gave me I would think he is faking it and doesnt love me.
I think he is probably plenty talented guy, but immature or something
Almost like the actors are acting like their characters...?
also "batcher", "hughee"... c'mon man.
Feels like you read into it way too hard and got it wrong plenty of times, makes you seem like you think you know what you're on about, but don't actually have a clue.
4:25 THATS EXACTLY WHAT IVE BEEN THINKING, THEYRE THE SAME PERSON!
LMAOOO W REFERENCE
12:30 Maeve does not move nc she is super strong and cannot act on her emotions. She is afraid of hurting someone, thats why she is stiff. I think thats actually great acting
This dude doesn't know what he is talking about, Jack Quaid should be in amazing at least. You're not considering the type of characters they are playing and you are not judging based on established metrics. You sometimes mention a book but never say which one it is, so we don't know if it is reputable source or not.
Mate if you want to grow as a channel you need to improve your presentation. You need to cut out those shots of you reacting to the old clips--they absolutely add nothing to the video and are kind of narcissistic and annoying. Second, we don't need to see all the stuff in your room. Clean up the table and the background so we can focus on the analysis and not all the distracting objects here and there. Also, you need better lighting.
Wait wait wait...7:27?! I mean, woudln't we all😂
...and again at 8:39😭
LMAOOOO
STOP BRUH
In season 1, episode 8 of For All Mankind Shantel VanSanten gave what I thought was one of the best performances of the season. And I don't mean the show's season - I mean that year's television season.
The problem with Maeve is that she is was given terrible lines. Her every sentence is some shitty one liner that is meant to be like big words, but just sounds cheesy. I Felt bad for the actress
It seems like you don't appreciate subtle emotions- it's most apparent in your comparison of Huey and the Flash. Never having seen the Flash, that dude was overacting
I appreciate ur input thank YOU ❤️ WITH that being said tho, in the SAME hughie comparison I praised him in the beginning for his sad scenes, w the eye twitching etc, I defo do appreciate subtle emotions BUT I just think WHEN he tried to show off aggressive scenes they landed flat :)
this video analyses the actors' acting well tbh. BUT it just doesn't factor in the story/context clues the actors are getting. It generalizes how a scene should have been acted and just goes with it.
good watch, nonetheless.
Erin’s bad acting is not because of her ability, its because of the botox, her face looks like its gonna break if she smiles. Not surprised her best acting was in season 1 and one of her worst is in the later seasons
the worst scene in whole the boys is frenchie kissing that black guy😭😭😭😭
bro is one of those guys who talks with such confidence about shit he knows nothing about. gotta admire it walking this planet with such ignorance!
why you pronouncing hughie that way? Did you now watch the show where his name is being pronouned very clearly multiple times?
I also can review actor performances and have watched shows. How does this make your opinions more valid than anyone else’s?