Reacting to - Red Velvet - IRENE & SEULGI 'Monster' MV & Naughty!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 ноя 2020
- #RedVelvet #Naughty #reaction
Wow - I loved both of these songs.
So differerent!
GO FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER:
/ siraustin11
LINKS TO ORIGINAL VIDEOS:
Red Velvet - IRENE & SEULGI 'Monster' MV
• Red Velvet - IRENE & S...
Red Velvet - IRENE & SEULGI Episode 1 "놀이 (Naughty)"
• Red Velvet - IRENE & S... 
Видеоклипы
![Cordae - Saturday Mornings (feat. Lil Wayne) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/z2GYJua09F0/mqdefault.jpg)
When he said they will say "Monsta" and not pronounce the R, I knew he was a genius
True👍
Really? I think RV, and mostly Korean, said monsta bcs Korean can't pronounce that 'R' sound
yh no he's right but it's also just how korean pronounce the word
Yes, its both! Him being someone into this field who understands how vocals work and also how koreans (bonus: and Japanese) pronounce monster
yes he is
I'm not 100% sure about this, but a lot of people has said "MONSTER" is based on a very old lesbian vampire story. Sooo yea
Yassss! the Carmilla theory
@@meinbow yeah you're right an old Victorian novel.
@@meinbow oh my god the web series was so amazing when it came out ... (I red the novel too but like ... Elise and Natasha)
Yes! I re-read Carmilla after watching this and the fact that the lyrics say "1 to 5 to 7 I'm a dancer in the darkness"referencing to the part in the novella where the lead character Laura says that 'Carmilla never comes out of her room before 1' shook me! Such small details have also been picked up from the novella. Its sad that the company probably never tell the girls in detail about what the mv is about :(
@@Ninja8996 bc they be spoiling everything. a la joy with rbb doing into details on a scene that's not out yet. lmao Sm artists, the best at spoilers 😂 it's best to not tell them anything.
the dance style you were referring to is called tutting and it is ridiculously hard to pull off well. It's actually kind of insane that Monster was the title track for the mini, yet they spent months on learning and perfecting a tutting choreo that most of the viewers will probably never realize is insanely difficult. What a flex.
I think monster is more catchy, but naughty was an incredible song with a very difficult dance. I wish they release naughty as another comeback... they would’ve received more recognition.
Actually Naughty wasn't going to be as prominent as it was. It was just their couple song but Lee Soman saw them performing it and he was HELL YEAH YOU HAVE TO PERFORM THIS LIVE GIVE IT A MV WHILE WE ARE AT IT
The Naughty choreo is tutting! Irene and Seulgi actually took about 4 months to learn and perfect the choreo
I thought Stay Tonight was wild, but Naughty topped it in 'hand moves complexity' 😅
They used Carmilla as concept, it’s a old lesbian vampire. The first female vampire in literature.
They’re really close friends, but they don’t really do physical contact like that unless it’s for a music video, Irene tends to shy away from moves like that. They couldn’t stop laughing in the behind the scenes for that scene. If you want to listen to live vocals I would recommend you listen to their cover of Milky Way.
Also would you
Redvelvet is know has the girl group that give the most lesbian vibes, AND WE AINT COMPLAINING!
Yup. In Korea twice are known to have a lot of male fans whereas redvelvet have a lot of female fans
Even as a straight female, I am so _whipped_ for these girls. They're just so mesmerizing 😻.
This subunit is ICONIC. That little pointing-at-self move at 4:37 imo is the single most iconic dance move in 2020. And the choreo for "Naughty" will go down in history as one of the most complex choreos; I can't see any group topping that for a long while.
Didn't notice this - thanks!
I totally agree on that move being iconic, I found it incredibly inventive too.
The really neat thing about Red Velvet is that they all have these really super unique voices but when you put them together it makes this beautiful sound. It is what drew me to them to be fair, just like Mamamoo really.
Seulgi is main dancer and lead vocal in RV & Irene is lead dancer, main rapper and sub-vocalist, but both SLAYED so hard! Love your reaction
seulgi's lead vocal and main dancer in RV, Irene is main rapper and lead dancer
Part 2 is Irene's dance video, but part 3 is Seulgi's solo song
of course they're just "close friends" 😏
React to an unhelpful guide to red velvet
Also Irene and Seulgi are like the one of biggest ship in red velvet
Literally stopped EVERYTHING at work to watch this. So excited
me too!
I am not a fan of red velvet but i think they are really talented and hope people appreciate their music❤
the each go different ways at the end because seulgi has a solo song and irene has a solo dance video( with multiple irenes)
Omg yes my Red Velvet bias and bias wrecker
definitely you need to become ReveLuv, love your reaction! you should react to some b-sides like Kingdom come, Remember forever and a ballad called One of these nights💖
YASSS! vocals there are stunning, i'm sure he will love them♥
Ok but im pissed of how lucky reveluvs are. They have a whole Mv with Irene and Seulgi "lesbianing together" and we moomoos have Decalcomanie MV. Unfair :/. Jokes aside, Red Velvet have awesome songs, and you should check out more about Seulgi and Wendy's voices, idk about the other members since i've never heard their vocals outside the group, but Seulgi and Wendy are wonderful vocalists :) Also: you post vids really fast man, i wish i was that productive :/
Don't forget that we have Um Oh Ah Yeh MV! ;))
@@isanghaee3123 yes! I forgot that! , but is not the same since the girls pretended to be guys 😔 and when Solar discovered Byul was a girl, she got mad lol
@Afiq Hakimi I know Wendy's vocals because of the "Halo" cover she did back in high school and i find her voice sooo beautiful and powerful, sadly as you said, they don't have many songs where they showcase their vocals. And yes! Moomoos and Reveluvs should be known for staning talented vocalists 😊
@@bmba1341 Both Solar & Wendy are my bias so I agree that MooMoo and Reveluvs should support each other, because both groups are awesome.
If moonsun lesbianing together you know all hell would break lose with moomoos. Jesus would be descending to earth. Yong would scream isanghae every second on the behind the scene. Wheesa would be so done with everything. Moonbyul would be freaking glowing
LOL "are they just really close friends"
You should check out the “Monster” by EXO as well. It has been top 1 most viewed video from SM for years. One of the best songs from them
Seulgi also has a solo called "Uncover" that got a special performance clip as part of this project! I wouldn't be surprised if Moonbyul gave her some inspiration for that one. Small wonder she has so many female fans
I listen to Uncover by Seulgi every day, her vocals and her dancing 😭😍that’s the part 3, part 2 is titled “IRENE” and it’s her dancing with herself. Irene’s dancing, singing and rapping is often overshadowed because people outside of the fandom and media focuses on her looks more than her talent which they are clearly sleeping on. As a reveluv and as someone who’s ultimate Kpop bias is Irene I was so happy when the I&S subunit came out because she got to showcase her talents a bit more. Also as a lesbian I was screaming with the gay activity on Monster MV, they also delayed the MV release a few hours because they had to “edit” some stuff, us gays believe they edited the gay bomb. 😂
also, they are sweethearts all of them so I really recomend watching their reality shows and the variety shows they are on. There’s actually a lot of content, go to ReVelUp Subs everything is there ✨Seulgi also was on Secret Unnie with Sunmi and it was so great to watch even more gay activity 😂 Sunmi even made a song for Seulgi and it’s the last track of her latest album, Wheein was also on the show with Hyoyeon from Girls Generation so if you don’t know what to watch and youre scrolling endlessly through Netflix like i do those are my recommendations 😂 Moonbyul was also on Level Up! Thrilling project which focused on I&S. Moonbyul was even flirting with Irene 😂
Monster is supposedly about our dark side trying to corrupt us so technically they're two sides of the same person OR maybe they're just REALLY good friends, that works too. imo their voices aren't really similar, not in tone or level of technique.
Episode 2 that you saw is Irene dancing to a mix of all the songs on their mini-album and episode 3 is Seulgi's solo from their mini as well. highly recommended!
red velvet do everything, we never know what to expect from them each time
i wasnt expecting this reaction right now, im so happy
You got the girls names right! Monster is a bop and there's no heterossexual explanation to this mv and no one can change my mind (and yes, there is some stories and teories about it but i kinda suck at this lmao)
can't wait for more red velvet in your channel!!
When I tell you SM is the pioneer of every trend in kpop. I think it's because they don't mind if the general public would like it but the mindset is general public WILL like it, no matter how long it will take them but at the end of the day it's something that will grow on everyone. Literally classical musicians reacting even to their bsides because the quality is just really *chef's kiss*
Seulrene are a very popular ship and my third realest gay ship in kpop lol😂
Why I love sm? eventhough their views in YT are not too high. I knew that producers, vocal coaches and professional music critics/review can give them a better recognition. Thus, you may notice that every kpop idols covering their songs.
Their voices aren’t similar imo. Irene’s voice is deeper and softer while seulgi’s is more higher and as you said unique
I personally like Seulgi's lower register more...same with Irene's, as opposed to the majority of the title tracks where they seem to sing more bright and happy. Irene's voice in both monster and naughty really impressed me...and i liked Seulgi's singing style (technique? not sure what to call it) in Naughty. I wish they'd let them sing lower in more title tracks
i agree with ur username.
The duo Irene and Seulgi are the main dancers of Red Velvet. So yeah, that's why the choreo is damn superb! I still can't get my head with their choreo. ITS INSANE!
The one with the lighter hair is Seulgi (pro. Sulgi) and the one with the darker hair is Irene (pro. The Original Visual)
We are getting more and more closer to sir Austin full reveluv haha
Dude that back line on Seulgi in Naughty, the fit men. Seulgi is amazing such a well rounded idol she sing and dance so good that could be easily any other group main vocalist and of course main dancer. So talented 😍
Btw i love they didnt covered the dancer's tatoo. In Korea usually they cover the idols and dancers tatoo but recently MVs are showing them more
Thank you i can rest in peace now.
Part 2 is Irene's solo dance performance on a remix/medley of other songs from the mini album.
The third part is Seulgi's solo song, Uncover (emotional eargasm).
The bsides of the mini album are great too, you should check them out (Diamond, Feel Good and Jelly).
But first if you want to hear live OT5 vocals, I recommend you to give a listen to Milky Way, it's a harmonical journey, and you really can hear HOW GOOD their voices sound together.
STAN RED VELVET.
Seulgi and irene are v much shipped together, they do have some...moments
Fact from Naughty: girl, who made choreo - was filmed scene with Seulgi (after 1st solo scene with Irene, when Seulgi was dance tutting and hands in white clothes dance with her)
Their choreograph was keep camera with help mouth and dance (you can see it, if search in RUclips making film vifeo from choreograph)
oh i think you mean "tutting" with the hand gesture dancing, correct me if im wrong.
I think that’s it!
Chung Ha has it in "Stay Tonight", the comments said it's voguing. But I'm not a dancer so just random information here :D
@@crazyr2113 To my understanding, voguing focuses more on the arms while tutting focuses more on the hands. They use a mix of both
@@crazyr2113 Chung Ha is voguing in her dance, its different from tutting. im not an expert by any means, but the difference i see between the two voguing is more arm and hand work setting a broader framework of the dance and tutting is more focused intricate finger and hand work. if that makes any sense.
@@-EchoesIntoEternity- Agreed, with your assessment of the differences between tutting and voguing
Irene, the one and only original and best visual she's exceptionally pretty
yeah i agree with you seulgi’s voice is very unique.
Again thank you for reacting to red velvet! Monster and Naughty are so different and they were such a blessing in this year in which we’ve had no group comeback. The other episodes after this are a dance solo for Irene and a Seulgi solo but I recommend you watch either Dumb Dumb, Automatic or One of these nights next! And a guide that I would recommend is An unhelpful guide Psycho era by arystocats :)
up
You should react to Taemin's solos
Idea
Criminal
Move
Thirsty
Yeeees, Taemin is so awesome!
red velvet is a group of vocal chameleons theyre versatile, they can all sound very different from each other but can also sound similar. when u hear them harmonize, that’s when you know it’s red velvet.
It's called Tutting! They practices the dance for MONTHS to get it right. Loved both songs, and you're right. Red Velvet in general is always a surprise! You never know what to expect.
OH MY GOD yes to the spells on The Magicians 😍 I’m not aware of this but now that you bring it up they do look like they’re tutting!
I didnt expect this reaction but yay ! thanks ! I've watched ur RV vids and it's interesting ur opinions and explanations (cause u know about music, if im not wrong vocal coach, right?) hope u continue reacting to them!
I&S or aseul (Airin in korean and seulgi) are closest friends, they've been together for like 10 years and they kinda were the only suvivors from the "oldie" trainees (Seulgi 7 years of training and Irene 5) also their age diff is not that much, so they are pretty close. Pretty sure producers and everyone know how spectators love their relationship (Seulrene) so they kinda play with that , but at the same time, there's a good story behind that video and lyrics.
lol when u explain about "monster" and the pronunciation i was like wooo he's cool hahaha
about Naughty, that its tutting, its pretty hard cause u have to be very precise and u have to control ur movements (a lot of strength but at the same time, control it cause if u dont it will be so forced)
the other parts are Irene dancing vid (remix of their songs) and "Uncover" Seulgi's solo song (and dance too).
if you wanna check out about their vocals, i recommend u "Milky way" (pretty recently, after wendy's recovery), Would u (accoustic version, with out Joy cause she was filming a drama), look at me cover by Joy (pretty recently, Joy voice is so sweet), good bye (Team Rocket, Joy Seulgi and Wendy in immortal song), Blue lemonade (Wendy's voice ! even when i love Seulgi's i know how versatile and kinda different voices has Wendy, so when i heard that song i was surprised, in a good way, cause diversity) and from this sub unit i recommend u "so good" , if u see the lyrics (omg hahaha) it would be nice for u and for us to understand more about what u said (having different voices but at the same time there's something similar) but i kinda think the same, not the voice, but there's something similar, kinda more low sound? idk but if u react i would love to see ur perspective !
have a nice day and take care !
Okay so.
Monster can be interpreted a few different ways. It can A: be interpreted as 2 sides of a person's personality fighting for control (Hence a lot of the choreography looking "combative"), or B: a lesbian romance inspired by the 1872 gothic novella, 'Carmilla'. Naughty's choreo just makes me wanna throw up its so good lmao. Tutting, voguing and waacking ALL in the same...It is SO DIFFICULT but when done properly is SO MIND BOGGLING AND COOL.
Seulgi, for reference, is the one with the hyper unique voice, and she has one of THE MOST Unique voices in kpop. She starts the first verse, Irene starts the second verse. Also is the one holding the freaky ass dolls, and gets dipped w/ the oni face edit.
To help to familiarize Seulgi is that her best feature was she was the only member that has monolids.
UGH! I love when people get into Red Velvet cause is like opening a surprise box full of weird and amazing goodies. Im a Reveluv and Seulgi is my bias (with OG visual Irene as my bias wrecker because have you seen her elegance and then hear her laugh like a freaking 5 year old?!) The concept for Monster was a dual concept from what both the members AND their company, SM, have said, one been of a story about having duality and having a light and dark sides to yourself fighting inside of you, which is why theres a mention of two shadows when standing under a single light, so literally and figuratively speaking fighting with the monster that we all have inside. Which matches very well the entire vibe of the mini album. The second concept was of the vampire novel Carmilla and how it was about monsters and sinners, about things been more complicated than good and bad, light or dark....about being seeing as a monster from being different or wanting different things, it is also a very homoerotic, lesbian leaning novel and story so thats why theres some lesbian imagery in the video and also because SM knows how to cater to one of the biggest ships in Red Velvet which is Seulrene, Seulgi and Irene as they are really close and they have a lot of "moments" within their fandom so its a good marketing step and we love it and eat it uppppp! I hope you keep your reactions going cause I love your musical inside and I love watching people discover their love for red velvet.
PS: If you can, give the mini album a listen and you will get more range of their vocals, how well they mix together and the whole duality concept they were going for....and all the songs are bangers.
They are doing tutting and voguing. Tutting is the angles and isolation of the arms , one of the hardest dance style. So they spent 4 months total learning the choreo for Naughty.
For me Red Velvet is the top girl group. They have everything, vocal, dancer, visual etc... I love them.
This is one of the best debut songs ever, it's so good, one of my favourite songs of the year. The dancing is called tutting i believe.
PS: I love "the magicians" too
You should definitely listen to ‘One of these nights’ by Red Velvet. It is one of the best killing vocal songs in Red Velvet. Also ‘One of these nights’ is actually a ballad genre which was even a title song of the album.
thank you for react to red velvet again, please react to them more, (fyi, their bside tracks are insane)
The sapphic humor that comes out of Monster reactions is gold.
oh my goshhhh. you should react to their other songs on the monster album! you're going to enjoy them for sure! i really love how they're utilizing their lower registers on most of them :))
" Milky Way " and " Psycho" @ ReVe festival performance will show you their incredible vocals.
The dance style for Naughty is a combination of Tutting and Voguing.🤗
Naughty dance is probably the hardest girl group dance I've seen
“Cause I remember Seulgi’s voice is very unique”, “her voice is interesting” exactly!! 😭😭 she has one of the most unique voices, faces, and dance moves I’ve ever known 😭 that’s why I think no one can replace her for me 😭😭
'Which one is the original visual?' I mean yas! They both look stunning. Their voice are amazing. That's 2/5 from Red Velvet yet they really served. Their album also shows more of their deep voices too. Thank you so much for this reaction. ❤️
Love the reactions always spot on with the voice impressions that he gives Seulgi's voice is indeed unique, and Irene got so much confidence after their duo, you should react to Milky Way and One of these Nights
Thank you so much for reacting to them! Their episode 2 is a dance with Irene and episode 3 is Seulgi's solo song Uncover! I think you would want to watch Uncover cuz it showcases her dancing aND rich voice fkfmfm
I love the dark concept at Red Velvet or like here, their sub unit. It suits them so well. Thank you for reacting ❤️
The word you're searching is TUTTING 😁
YAY I’m so glad you reacted to it!
this duo/subunit was actually iconic.
The difficulty level and just the creativity of Naughty's choreography is insane. To add up also not only muscle memory but also coordination is needed since they are singing too. They had to be stable all throughout and even find the freaking camera in music shows just so much to put your mind into.
It took them 1 month to learn the basics of tutting at least 10 individual lessons and then they started to learn the choreography after. It took 2 months to make the choreography and spent 4-5 months for the overall preparation before its release according to their choreographer Spella and Shim Jaewon (who is also the choreographer of the iconic pre debut Be Natural performance of the duo, you should definitely check it out.)
Or you can just check out the Be Natural MV of Red Velvet with the 4 members (the youngest has yet to debut yet because of her age) in it! The song was actually a remake from their senior, S.E.S.
MONSTER The best video of the 2020..also NAUGHTY's choreo is another level
Lets be honest Seulgi and Irene slay it.. Real QUEENS
The best decision SM did is to have them as a Duo
well, Seulgi once said that she and Irene are "sisters" 🤭
Yayyy this sub unit is everything to me because both Irene and Seulgi are my TV biases hahaha
You are watching one of the most iconic duo in K-Pop :) Reveluvs are blessed to have them in the same group. Look up "Seulrene".
Seulgi's voice always does things to me.
yasss OMG ive been waiting for this reaction of yours! ❤❤
In Monster, brown lipstick is Seulgi, red lipstick is Irene (original visual). ^_~ Monster is said to be inspired by the 1870s novella "Camilla" by Joseph Sheridan Le Fanu. It's a vampire book and has lesbian themes as well. So yeah, you would not be wrong with the "are they gonna embrace?" I love Naughty's choreography, tutting ON FIRE!!!! (Also, it's so funny that you said something about The Magicians, because I sent the Naughty video to my husband when it came out and said, "Look at these ladies casting spells up in here!!")
It's sooooo fun to see you getting into RV and the Seulgi/Irene subunit. Their first subunit song, if I am recalling correctly, was a dance to their song "Be Natural" (a very "Velvet" concept). It's super sexy, and it was early on after their debut. The whole song is great too! I think it was before Yeri joined (?? not 100% sure). I loved their songs, and yes Monster was a HUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUGE hit, esp among the LGBT community.
I love how you keep saying "You never know what you're going to get" hahaha! I said something similar early on about how they are super experimental and they do all kinds of things but everything they do is "them." You are learning what I meant! xD! I love this
you NEED to listen to them mini album, the best, or one of the best, album from this year
Mamamoo's Moonbyul has a solo featuring Seulgi. You should check it out, not for the song (it's not one of my favorites) but for the collab itself. Two angels 🥰
Finally!! I have been waiting for this :DD
I believe that hand kind of dancing is called "tutting" from my 10 p.e class (I hope I'm correct). They're the best duo for me huhu. I hope they have more activities as a sub unit and I hope we'll get a comeback from Red Velvet this year. And yeah what do we expect? They're from SME, please react into From Home/Misfit/Make a Wish from NCT U, they're also from SM their vocals and talents are insane.
Omg ive been waiting for this.... queens indeed
irene and seulgi have known e/o the longest. seulgi entered sm in 2007, irene in 2009 while yeri in 2011 and both wendy and joy in 2012. so yup they are undoubtly very close and if youve watched most of (if not all) rv contents, you can really tell that they have a very good and soft chemistry. you are recommended to watch be natural 2014 (by irene & seulgi), Greedy stage on smtown and their level up's thrilling project too to see more of their dynamic :) hope you enjoy!
The video isn’t even in minute one and I already know I’ll love it. It’s Austin magic
Binge watching all rv reactions again! I'm a solid EXO-L, Elf, sone, reveluv, nctzen, just a whole SM stan and I'm loving your channel really hard sir Austin!!!!
I just watch all your reaction videos with Red Velvet in 4 hours today 😂😂 i just can’t stop you know? Im a hard red velvet stan. And Wendy is my Bias.
And I love when you said before that you love their red side more, then couple times as you go along you also mentioned you love their velvet dark concept. Hahaha same !! You just can’t stop loving them. Any concept! Any genre! Any song!
Yeessssss!!! Oh my reveluv heart is happy,, thank you Austin. I am glad you like them
There is a continuation to Naughty. Episode 2 "Irene" is a dance choreo performance, and Episode 3 is a solo vocal song by Seulgi that was a b-side on the Monster EP
yesss I've been waiting for this!
For me , the best sub-unit in Korea actually!
Dropped the other vid I'm watching for Sir Austin ❤️❤️❤️
Babe do more of RV reaction please 😭❤️ when u start watching them you'll eventually become a reveluv. they also hav a lot of crack moments
You've no idea how excited I was for another red velvet reaction. I just saw your badboy and really bad boy reaction too. I'd dm you on twitter to tell you more about them but im kinda shy hehe
Awesome video :3 can’t wait to see your reaction to a guide. I suggest irenesfilter 2020 guide!!
if you want to hear their live vocals i recommend watching their "one of these nights" performance at yu huiyeol's sketchbook event it's not that recent though. i would also recommend watching them sing psycho live as ot5!
Not a fan of red velvet but i love seulgi so much❤️ this girl is just everything🥰
Red velvet never heard of the word recycle. queens that can do it *all*
The producers of many of the SM artists songs (and in other artists but in general SM) Are MOONSHINE, naughty is from them, u can the word 'moonshine' in the beginning of the songs they made
The symbolism of them going in 2 different directions at the end is that they went on to each do a solo song after this came out
Love your vids, keep it up!!!
Yay, Red Velvet's subunit! I agree with you, Irene and Seulgi's voice are a bit similar yet very different and compliment each other well. I'm no specialist but I think it maybe because they sound a bit nasal but in different ranges. And they both sound very nice when singing low, very "full".
I'll continue my Red velvet agenda and recommend you Ladies Night live again, as well as Kingdom come!
I'd really like to hear you fully analyze their voices! Keep up the good work!
Edit: you can find Ladies night live on their Vlive channel (Umpah umpah camping date, 2019.08.23 at around 24 minutes), but I don't know about the copyright there :/