@MatildeVallespinCasas At 73, I have seen too many children raised by an unwed mother who turned out a mess. Being raised in a family of God's design with a father and mother is almost always the best course.
@@ronniemaynor4434 and I have seen many kids raised by unwed mothers who turned just fine. It played a big part the fact that they were not treated as scum by self righteous people like the ones who went to church every Sunday. And don't get me started with the Amish molesters and the stunts they do in court
@carolina_girl3484 Michael Landon's affair with Cindy Clerico had major consequences. For one thing, it made things "incredibly awkward" on the set of "Little House on the Prairie" because the cast knew Landon's family, Karen Grassle wrote (via Showbiz CheatSheet). "I knew his wife," she recalled. "I had been in their home. She had been kind to me. And I thought about her children - there were three of them still at home ... and younger than Cindy." The affair also damaged Landon's relationship with co-star Melissa Gilbert, who played his TV daughter Laura. "I have to work with Mike, I can't take sides, yet he's done something that's turned my world into angry, opposing sides." Gilbert wrote in her own memoir "Prairie Tale." "I was put in a horribly, uncomfortable position." Things came to a head when Lynn Noe followed Landon and Clerico after learning of the affair, according to the New York Post, who reported that Noe confronted her husband and threw a bottle of vodka at his head. At first, however, it looked like the pair might get back together, and Landon even said they would renew their vows. But this was not to be. The mistress becomes the wife Cindy Landon Eventually, Michael Landon and Lynn Noe split up, according to the New York Post. Cindy Clerico became pregnant before the divorce could be finalized. Landon and Clerico were married in 1983. The entire situation hurt Landon's career and relationship with his co-stars. He lost several endorsements including from Kodak. He also lost the respect of co-stars like Melissa Gilbert, who had looked up to Landon as a father figure.
It proves that a film can be watchable, interesting and engaging without sex scenes, blood and gore, even worse swear words and worst of all blasphemous words. It makes it beautiful.
@@nothingworksworks3511 not just America, European films too are absolutely filthy which is shameful considering they were Christian countries, on the other hand, Chinese and Korean who are mostly pagans are more reserved. The West who is supposedly Christian has become a stumbling block for others to come to the Christ.
An excellent movie that shows love prevails amidst family matters and truth sets one free. The unification of child and parent is foremost of importance. A must see movie for all. Life is short,so, take love as utmost importance. ❤
I would have liked to have seen her meet her biological mother. This was a good movie. Michael Landon, Jr. directed the movie and he has his Father's touch.
Beverly Lewis is a true Blessing. ALL of her books are well worth anyone's time. This is an amazing series, and there is so much more to it. I Highly recommend it. Be Blessed by her ministry.
Shunning is a cruel practice. In one of Paul's epistles, he urges that sinners be restored in a kindly manner. Thank you for this beautiful, sensitive film.
i am glad the Amish have these practices. Look at how Western society has fallen. Truly, they have had the last word and they were clearly the right ones. God bless those who still keep the faith and do not give into the ways of death. Please read more of your bible not just some of the scriptures. The above user has given you a good place to start.
@@carolynshoaf8306 Why would we need to guess? Let us see what Jesus said in Matthew 18:15-18 - Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone: if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother. But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established. And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican. Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.
@@carolynshoaf8306 Also 1 Corinthians 5:9-13 - I wrote unto you in an epistle not to company with fornicators: Yet not altogether with the fornicators of this world, or with the covetous, or extortioners, or with idolaters; for then must ye needs go out of the world. But now I have written unto you not to keep company, if any man that is called a brother be a fornicator, or covetous, or an idolator, or a railer, or a drunkard, or an extortioner; with such an one no not to eat. For what have I to do to judge them also that are without? do not ye judge them that are within? But them that are without God judgeth. Therefore put away from among yourselves that wicked person.
"The Shunning" was followed by "The Confession" and "The Reckoning." "The Confession" (2013) is the continuing story of Katie Lapp, a young Amish woman who goes on a journey in search of her identity - only to find herself embroiled in a mystery that must be solved before she can be reunited with the "Englisher" mother who gave her up to adoption 20 years earlier. "The Reckoning" (2015)is the conclusion to the story.
Beautiful story. It is an absolute confirmation that the truth will truly set you free. We may not play God over another's decision and life. I love the values and morals. She will now truly be theirs forever. They will never have to fear losing her again.
The ending made me cry 😢 , no one can never explain this pain to you . I feel sad for all of them especially her adoptive parents and her biological mother. Thank you for sharing, i learn something very important from it 🙏🏾❤️❤️.
Absolutelly stunning drama movie. Profoundly beautiful and full of messages of love, compassion and hope. ❤ Not many movies like that. It moved me. Thank you.
You might find this hard to believe, but in the summer of 1988 with permission of Mr. John Lapp (it must be a common surname) he allowed me to pitch my tent on his farmland for two weeks. Twice I ate at their table with the whole family. I was working at a nearby restaurant. I found this film difficult to watch remembering how kind they were to me. This film brought back many memories.
So this was my first time ever seeing this movie I see why it got such a good rating so can any one tell me if this how the Church of the later day saints are
HookBeak_66: Even mafia bosses can be kind, and it’s also “good p.r.” to be “kind to strangers/outsiders.” It’s those they hold the ball & chain over who know what they do; who they are. They enslave and “rule” through creating “fear of losing everything.” Many people have committed suicide. They destroy the lives of many, trust me, I know.
I and my great grandfathers have worked among Amish, they are loving and caring, To this day I don't have any complaints about them. I am 54 yr old married with 3 adult children. What Amish have taught me, I will follow it for life.
It is nice to see Danielle again playing an adult role outside of dis and nick made film aimed at children. She and her little sis have always been talented at picking good films
In the book, her shunning is much harsher. She endures it for much longer. She ends up going to live with her mom's cousin who is Mennonite. It is from there that she leaves from New York. In the book, while her parents certainly love her, they follow the old Amish dictates to the letter of the law regarding her shunning. I like the ending to the movie much more than the book. The 2nd and 3rd books are also amazing, although the first movie portrayed her birth mother, Laura's, story, much differently in the books.
SING IT OUT! Psalm 150 Praise the Lord! Praise God in his sanctuary; praise him in his mighty heavens![a] 2 Praise him for his mighty deeds; praise him according to his excellent greatness! 3 Praise him with trumpet sound; praise him with lute and harp! 4 Praise him with tambourine and dance; praise him with strings and pipe! 5 Praise him with sounding cymbals; praise him with loud clashing cymbals! 6 Let everything that has breath praise the Lord! Praise the Lord!
Great movie! Very touching! I love these communities were respect, love, and discipline rule. I was hoping to see her meeting her biological mother and the decision she would make afterwards.
I lived in Ontario (Canada) for several years. There are a lot of Amish people around in these small villages and towns. Just like in this movie you can still see these carriages pulled by horses. I read several books about their lives. The shunning is still practiced against those who do not submit to the council of elders. But other religious groups, such as Jehovah's Witnesses, Mormons, and Mennonites, have similar practices. This also happens in some Protestant churches. I have experienced similar “rejection” ( by the Protestant group) because I had a different opinion. So I understands perfectly what happened in this movie. The end of this movie showed beautifully how love prevails. Both parents finally had a strength and broke what was rooted in them... they understood their daughter and realized that the world they live in can be very cruel. This young girl decided to leave the group, I think for two reasons. She wanted to find contact with her biological mother and did not want her parents who raised her to be shunned by this group like she was. I am sure they found a way to stay in contact …,
Yes in the series that this book is based on she does eventually stay in contact and has a reoccurring mention/ roles in the books that follow. Beverly Lewis is a wonderful author in this genre. I recommend her books and this is one of my favorite series of hers. There's 2 more books after the shunning that follow Katie's story. And I totally agree with your comment about the type of isolation placed on people within "religious" groups and it's sad. If we use the Bible as God's authority and not man's conviction we should never have that problem but...we're fallible and sinful and prideful so we do.. and instead of just agreeing to disagree on the different conclusions we come to concerning scripture we become offended and react incorrectly. Thank God for Jesus and grace because we definitely need both.
The “Mormons”, or members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, of which I am, do not shun those who no longer believe, and it certainly is not a formal practice. Rather, we are told to keep loving them, and love them back into the fold. You really should take the time and effort to research before you end up writing falsehoods about certain religions when you name them.
@@valeriehinkle8995 I am a member in Sweden. In our congregation we have members from the other Nordic countries, Africa, South America, USA, Ukraine, Russia, Asia... All people are beloved children of God and we are all the same in his eyes.
Extraordinaire actress Danielle Panabaker, very pretty and good singer❤ I loved the precious landscapes and indoors scenes, the script very well elaborated indeed, thanxs from México 😅😂
@@sandtx4913 They read the same one. These are rules made up by the Amish church, has nothing to do with the bible only a desparate attempt in keeping their people among them hidden under the veil of faith.
MIXED FEELINGS ABOUT THIS MOVIE - FEEL THE ENDING IS INCOMEPLETE. You could have at least showed some interactions between Katie and her biological mother.
Good story. With so much evil in the world and getting worse, don’t blame them for trying so hard to keep it out. If only the rest of the world was smart enough to reject evil.
@@osamedennadi6309 We are going to admire the Amish very soon, and how they have been able to live without modern amenities. We Americans are shortly going to wish we had those skills. Unless of course, you are living amongst the elite, which most of us are not.
This is about the reality of adoption world wide, the consequences of what happened when children weren't told of their beginnings. People shouldn't judge the Amish people and their beliefs. No one religion is perfect but they are wrong to treat her like that - the parents & the community should have been given advice too. The parents & community can't change how she feels inside. Both mums made huge sacrifices.
I'm American, not English, of French/Irish extraction. But yeah, as a disciple of Jesus Christ I've been shunned by 'the church'. 1 John: if you say you love God, but don't love your brother, you're a liar, 'and the truth is not in you.'
It's not about fear and change. It's about, you are supposed to be in the world but not OF IT. ROMANS 12:2. By bringing worldly things to their home she broke the rules. I do think that amish music rules are too harsh. If someone played an instrument perhaps they could king on key.
😂and in the end, I praise God for miracles!!!! I do wish my own father had been so loving in his good-bye. But after 15 years, I'm grateful that distance made us closer.
I am sure there is second part don’t know the name. It has the same cast would watch it again. We can learn from it to be tender hearted to one another
The development of this severity in the Amish faith did NOT come from the spiritual roots but developed under the hatred, imprisonment, and murder that reigned down on Amish and fellow baptism-in-adulthood faiths. The idea that only an adult could make a conscious decision for baptism flew in the face of other Christian faiths which did infant baptism - both positions strongly believed by their respective faith believers and practitioners. I am NOT denying that it is a problem, particularly shunning - but understanding how dangerous it was to be Amish/Anabaptist early on in the history of these faiths, and how keenly they strived for isolation only because they were safer that way, may help us understand and feel compassion for this horrific historical experience, and understand how the isolationist features have become strongly held practice. It is my understanding that the degree to which, and details of the stricter restrictions, are held in various communities varies widely, due to independent softenings of this strategy.
More like religious abuse , which all religions do.. guaranteed. The Amish also enjoy sexual abuse- by the father and brother/siblings of the girls and young women.
they listen to hymns which is very much music, just spiritual music.. a lot of the music we listen to today is evil!! And furthermore, if we were to live by the Bible completely… a lot of people would be shunned in today’s time, the Bible does speak of separating ourselves from unbelievers… and we are supposed to separate ourselves from unbelievers and not allow their sin in our homes or lives!! But today people want to change the Bible to their own beliefs… it doesn’t matter how much you try to change it or how much you don’t agree with it… we are in the last days and he is coming back very soon, day we will have no excuses!! g God is a good God and a faithful God BUT…. You have to live your life according to his laws, his commandments.!! God gave his own son to die for the sins of the world an ungrateful world.. who is always trying to change his word to fit thier desires… Shunning is mentioned in the Bible, not using the word shun, but it does tell us to separate ourselves from sinners and their sin!!
@@authorcole The Bible also tells us of helping sinners repent, and try and show them the way of God. So, how can you do that if you're not in contact, a minimum at least?
I know it is their religion but they did the wrong thing by not telling her. Shunning is terrible. Smashing the guitar was so unchristian, The adopted parents truly loved her as their daughter. Thank you. A very beautiful movie
Smh, if anybody should be shunned is the adoptive parents for keeping the secret about their adopted daughter. And they suppose to set an example? Smh,🥴
50 years ago, I was shunned by my best friend. It impacted my life so much. I'd always thought we'd be Grand ma's and enjoy our grand kids. I made lots of bad choices after that and am not married or have children.. Don't shun.
My so called best friend did the same to me after I got married and had a baby, it was heartbreaking. Then I began to look back on the 25 years we'd been friends, I began to realize that she really only wanted me around when she had the upperhand, she was married 20 years before me, we lived together during university from there we stayed friends and during the 20 years I was unmarried, no kids. I spent much of my vacations watching her children so she and her husband could go on vacations. she started a business right out of university and it did very well, she worked incredibly hard, no doubt about that. I on the other hand worked my way up the corporate ladder and it took me a very long time to dig myself out of a lot of debt. she always had more, she had the fancy cars, the big fancy house, pool etc. I lived in a one bedroom condo and drove a car that cost 1/4 of what hers cost. then I met someone and got married, had a baby. She changed, she no longer called me everyday, she was short with me all the time. After my son was born I became very sick, I was just hitting my stride in my career, finally making some decent money. I was able to buy a nice home and we put a pool in, I will never forget a call I had with her after we put the pool in and she asked me what it cost, I didn't think much of it and told her, she says " omg, if I had your money I would burn mine". WHAT?? this was the first very crack in what I would later come to realize was an incredibly toxic relationship from the begining. During our "friendship" I would often show up at her house to go shopping, or go here or there, if I had makeup on and did my hair she would make fun of me, every single time...I would laugh it off and say well ya, I have NOTHING else to do with my time, I dont have 3 kids, lol. When I traded up and got a new car, was so happy and proud of it...yet her husband still made fun of it, why? This was the entire relationship. So when the wheels really fell off was 2021, sept. I messaged her and told her a VERY close of mine ( she and I also lived together in University) I messaged her to tell her my friend had been killed in a hit and run accident, I was beside myself. She knew her of course, we had all lived together at one point breifly in our 20's.she did not even respond. She saw the message I saw that she opened the message. I gave her two days to respond, nothing. So I finally blocked her and we have not spoken since. Sometimes these people do us a favour by showing us who they really are. If your friend shunned you, they were never ever a friend. I hope you can look at the situation and know that YOU did nothing wrong. I hope you can move forward and come to truly know in your heart that this person was/is a very unkind person and you deserve so much better.
I want the rest of the story. What happened to her friend that disappeared? I was hoping to see her meet her bio mom and maybe find her friend or learn what happened to him then return home to start her amish life with her parents who loved her so much.
Everyone shuns no matter the society religious or non-religious Families, friends, and workplaces, you name it religious and non-religious.. I think the Amish as a whole are good people.
I see the movie different then you see it. It moved me deeply, the story, ambient, landscape, non violence and sex scenes. (Except her father that adopted her, break the guitar).
I was shunned and I took it as a lovely discipline I was not a good association that's the truth and helped to me realized I wasn't good but I was able to speak to my immediate family, it worked for me, God Is Love!
The only thing I don't like is she walked away from her horse. The Amish are very cruel to their horses and livestock. Good story but I am sad at the walk from her companion that got her around.
The Amish as I understand it don't treat animals as pets, just as something to perform work. We just rescued a Standardbred horse who has been with the Amish for around ten years, she was a in a kill pen, came here pretty shut down but little by little she's coming out of her shell. She definitely has never been treated as a pet, she doesn't even know what treats are at all.
Makes me wonder, though. The Amish live separately from the modern world yet a medical emergency has them running to the modern hospital and needing to go on an extended trip has them using modern transport. Seems like they want to make use of modern ways when it suits them.
Living without tv and social media is great for them. Everyone has meaningful work. And decent shelter. Using modern doctors does not endanger their souls.
This was hard to watch. The lies, deceptions and untruths . The hypocrisy. So sad & destructive. I want to vomit. God would Never treat anyone like that.
The moral of this film. No matter what mask one has chosen to wear, underneath is a flawed individual. So, all the burning of letters...or books, will not, a fact change.
![Twenty One Pilots - The Line (from Arcane Season 2) [Official Audio]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XCz7WUotXs8/mqdefault.jpg)
I love this movie and the unselfishness of the unwed mother. This is true love. This is a great lesson many of our young girls today.
Sure, very valuable lesson. Dump your kid to somebody else, like a true mother.
@MatildeVallespinCasas At 73, I have seen too many children raised by an unwed mother who turned out a mess. Being raised in a family of God's design with a father and mother is almost always the best course.
@@ronniemaynor4434 and I have seen many kids raised by unwed mothers who turned just fine. It played a big part the fact that they were not treated as scum by self righteous people like the ones who went to church every Sunday. And don't get me started with the Amish molesters and the stunts they do in court
Michael Landon Jr directed this movie!! He's just like his father. They produced the best films !
@carolina_girl3484
Michael Landon's affair with Cindy Clerico had major consequences. For one thing, it made things "incredibly awkward" on the set of "Little House on the Prairie" because the cast knew Landon's family, Karen Grassle wrote (via Showbiz CheatSheet). "I knew his wife," she recalled. "I had been in their home. She had been kind to me. And I thought about her children - there were three of them still at home ... and younger than Cindy."
The affair also damaged Landon's relationship with co-star Melissa Gilbert, who played his TV daughter Laura. "I have to work with Mike, I can't take sides, yet he's done something that's turned my world into angry, opposing sides." Gilbert wrote in her own memoir "Prairie Tale." "I was put in a horribly, uncomfortable position."
Things came to a head when Lynn Noe followed Landon and Clerico after learning of the affair, according to the New York Post, who reported that Noe confronted her husband and threw a bottle of vodka at his head. At first, however, it looked like the pair might get back together, and Landon even said they would renew their vows. But this was not to be.
The mistress becomes the wife
Cindy Landon
Eventually, Michael Landon and Lynn Noe split up, according to the New York Post. Cindy Clerico became pregnant before the divorce could be finalized. Landon and Clerico were married in 1983. The entire situation hurt Landon's career and relationship with his co-stars. He lost several endorsements including from Kodak. He also lost the respect of co-stars like Melissa Gilbert, who had looked up to Landon as a father figure.
It proves that a film can be watchable, interesting and engaging without sex scenes, blood and gore, even worse swear words and worst of all blasphemous words. It makes it beautiful.
How they live in two different times
Quite the antidote to any don trump speech...I feel bogged down & sad for America
I can't heart your comment enough!❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
@@TxNWmn thank you. God bless you.
@@nothingworksworks3511 not just America, European films too are absolutely filthy which is shameful considering they were Christian countries, on the other hand, Chinese and Korean who are mostly pagans are more reserved. The West who is supposedly Christian has become a stumbling block for others to come to the Christ.
An excellent movie that shows love prevails amidst family matters and truth sets one free. The unification of child and parent is foremost of importance.
A must see movie for all.
Life is short,so, take love as utmost importance.
❤
Very good movie. Well acted and believable. Shunning would be so hard, an eye opener. Glad her parents relented and just loved her.
I would have liked to have seen her meet her biological mother. This was a good movie. Michael Landon, Jr. directed the movie and he has his Father's touch.
Yes I too, I was waiting.
Watch the next movie called The Reckoning. It's in that movie.
The Reckoning
Really she didn't meet her mama in this movie,I was looking forward to that
Yesssss I know
I have watched this a number of times but it still makes me tear up at the love there is between Katy and her parents. 😢✝️🙏
❤🎉😢😮😅😊agoodmovieiwasi cultmoo ieiwaslu k ecauseiwasi somuchdaman
Beverly Lewis is a true Blessing. ALL of her books are well worth anyone's time. This is an amazing series, and there is so much more to it. I Highly recommend it. Be Blessed by her ministry.
Fantastic movie. I watched it many times over the years. You watch all three movies.The shunning, the confession and the reckoning for the full story.
Where can you find the last part of the movie
Shunning is a cruel practice. In one of Paul's epistles, he urges that sinners be restored in a kindly manner. Thank you for this beautiful, sensitive film.
1st Corinthians 5:11
i am glad the Amish have these practices. Look at how Western society has fallen. Truly, they have had the last word and they were clearly the right ones. God bless those who still keep the faith and do not give into the ways of death.
Please read more of your bible not just some of the scriptures. The above user has given you a good place to start.
Yes we should keep the faith and be obedient to God. I can’t see Jesus being accepting of shunning as a practice.
@@carolynshoaf8306 Why would we need to guess? Let us see what Jesus said in Matthew 18:15-18 -
Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone: if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother.
But if he will not hear thee, then take with thee one or two more, that in the mouth of two or three witnesses every word may be established.
And if he shall neglect to hear them, tell it unto the church: but if he neglect to hear the church, let him be unto thee as an heathen man and a publican.
Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.
@@carolynshoaf8306 Also 1 Corinthians 5:9-13 -
I wrote unto you in an epistle not to company with fornicators:
Yet not altogether with the fornicators of this world, or with the covetous, or extortioners, or with idolaters; for then must ye needs go out of the world.
But now I have written unto you not to keep company, if any man that is called a brother be a fornicator, or covetous, or an idolator, or a railer, or a drunkard, or an extortioner; with such an one no not to eat.
For what have I to do to judge them also that are without? do not ye judge them that are within?
But them that are without God judgeth. Therefore put away from among yourselves that wicked person.
"The Shunning" was followed by "The Confession" and "The Reckoning." "The Confession" (2013) is the continuing story of Katie Lapp, a young Amish woman who goes on a journey in search of her identity - only to find herself embroiled in a mystery that must be solved before she can be reunited with the "Englisher" mother who gave her up to adoption 20 years earlier. "The Reckoning" (2015)is the conclusion to the story.
Thank you for telling us all how to continue the story❤
@alisong2328 Thank you so much for sharing.🌹
THANK YOU for sharing 🙏
Ok, thanks, good to know this was not just a weird ending.
Books good too!!
It was a lovely movie. It had all the feels, anger, hurt, love, and betrayal. But so good.
I turned the movie off half ways and came back to find a treasure
She portrays her character Katie Lapp, with honesty and integrity.
"The miracle IS not the life you missed, but the life you got", wise and beautiful Words!
Beautiful story. It is an absolute confirmation that the truth will truly set you free. We may not play God over another's decision and life.
I love the values and morals.
She will now truly be theirs forever. They will never have to fear losing her again.
The ending made me cry 😢 , no one can never explain this pain to you . I feel sad for all of them especially her adoptive parents and her biological mother. Thank you for sharing, i learn something very important from it 🙏🏾❤️❤️.
Father’s love for her daughter is immeasurable, but many a times underrated.
🎉🎉. O x.9 00am 9 😊x.
Absolutelly stunning drama movie. Profoundly beautiful and full of messages of love, compassion and hope. ❤ Not many movies like that. It moved me. Thank you.
You might find this hard to believe, but in the summer of 1988 with permission of Mr. John Lapp (it must be a common surname) he allowed me to pitch my tent on his farmland for two weeks. Twice I ate at their table with the whole family. I was working at a nearby restaurant. I found this film difficult to watch remembering how kind they were to me. This film brought back many memories.
I’m sure it was a wonderful experience for you
So this was my first time ever seeing this movie I see why it got such a good rating so can any one tell me if this how the Church of the later day saints are
Oh I really cried hard true story I could tell
Yes, Lapp is a common surname in the Amish community.
HookBeak_66: Even mafia bosses can be kind, and it’s also “good p.r.” to be “kind to strangers/outsiders.” It’s those they hold the ball & chain over who know what they do; who they are. They enslave and “rule” through creating “fear of losing everything.” Many people have committed suicide. They destroy the lives of many, trust me, I know.
I and my great grandfathers have worked among Amish, they are loving and caring, To this day I don't have any complaints about them. I am 54 yr old married with 3 adult children. What Amish have taught me, I will follow it for life.
I always thought the Amish woman didn't wear all that makeup , but obviously l am wrong,
@@helenwilson9732 No, you're right. They don't. 🙂
It is nice to see Danielle again playing an adult role outside of dis and nick made film aimed at children. She and her little sis have always been talented at picking good films
I understand each faith in God has its way to protect their way❤❤❤her Amish parents really loved her and that's all that is important ❤❤❤
Would of liked to see Katie's reunion with her biological mum,good movie, great acting. 😊❤
Me too! We need Part 2 😊
There is a sequal called The Reckoning - different girl but its the 2nd part to this movie
There are 2 more movies to this series
so true ☺
@@donellekokenos5009 The Confession, then The Reckoning
In the book, her shunning is much harsher. She endures it for much longer. She ends up going to live with her mom's cousin who is Mennonite. It is from there that she leaves from New York.
In the book, while her parents certainly love her, they follow the old Amish dictates to the letter of the law regarding her shunning.
I like the ending to the movie much more than the book.
The 2nd and 3rd books are also amazing, although the first movie portrayed her birth mother, Laura's, story, much differently in the books.
The last part made me cry.. Those Amish parents really loved Katie ❤❤.
SING IT OUT! Psalm 150
Praise the Lord!
Praise God in his sanctuary;
praise him in his mighty heavens![a]
2 Praise him for his mighty deeds;
praise him according to his excellent greatness!
3 Praise him with trumpet sound;
praise him with lute and harp!
4 Praise him with tambourine and dance;
praise him with strings and pipe!
5 Praise him with sounding cymbals;
praise him with loud clashing cymbals!
6 Let everything that has breath praise the Lord!
Praise the Lord!
Amen. Make a joyful noise unto the Lord. That guitar & beautiful voice is joyful noise & God gave her that gift.
Great movie! Very touching! I love these communities were respect, love, and discipline rule. I was hoping to see her meeting her biological mother and the decision she would make afterwards.
Its in Part 2 and 3
Such a beautiful story and yes, I am crying. We need more of these stories in our world. 😢😢😢❤️❤️❤️❤️🌻🌻🌻
Just read some of the other comments. Glad to know there are 2 more movies the complete the story. Thanks to thevperson that posted the info
I lived in Ontario (Canada) for several years. There are a lot of Amish people around in these small villages and towns. Just like in this movie you can still see these carriages pulled by horses.
I read several books about their lives. The shunning is still practiced against those who do not submit to the council of elders. But other religious groups, such as Jehovah's Witnesses, Mormons, and Mennonites, have similar practices. This also happens in some Protestant churches. I have experienced similar “rejection” ( by the Protestant group) because I had a different opinion. So I understands perfectly what happened in this movie.
The end of this movie showed beautifully how love prevails. Both parents finally had a strength and broke what was rooted in them... they understood their daughter and realized that the world they live in can be very cruel.
This young girl decided to leave the group, I think for two reasons. She wanted to find contact with her biological mother and did not want her parents who raised her to be shunned by this group like she was. I am sure they found a way to stay in contact …,
Yes in the series that this book is based on she does eventually stay in contact and has a reoccurring mention/ roles in the books that follow. Beverly Lewis is a wonderful author in this genre. I recommend her books and this is one of my favorite series of hers. There's 2 more books after the shunning that follow Katie's story. And I totally agree with your comment about the type of isolation placed on people within "religious" groups and it's sad. If we use the Bible as God's authority and not man's conviction we should never have that problem but...we're fallible and sinful and prideful so we do.. and instead of just agreeing to disagree on the different conclusions we come to concerning scripture we become offended and react incorrectly. Thank God for Jesus and grace because we definitely need both.
Όλες αυτές οι αιρέσεις είναι για να έχουν τον έλεγχο των ανθρώπων....λυπάμαι ο Θεός λένε είναι αγάπη,μα αυτοί γυρνούν την πλάτη.... ντροπή και πλάνη
The “Mormons”, or members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, of which I am, do not shun those who no longer believe, and it certainly is not a formal practice. Rather, we are told to keep loving them, and love them back into the fold.
You really should take the time and effort to research before you end up writing falsehoods about certain religions when you name them.
@@deboraholsen2504 question; why aren't there any black folks or other ethnic groups within the Mormon faith?
@@valeriehinkle8995 I am a member in Sweden. In our congregation we have members from the other Nordic countries, Africa, South America, USA, Ukraine, Russia, Asia... All people are beloved children of God and we are all the same in his eyes.
Follow your heart. To the parents that adopted her out of love..God will always bless you.
Oh God very heart touching scen when father hugs her daughter 😢
Extraordinaire actress Danielle Panabaker, very pretty and good singer❤ I loved the precious landscapes and indoors scenes, the script very well elaborated indeed, thanxs from México 😅😂
beautiful film i cried a lot thanks to producer
Shunning is evil, nowhere in the Bible does Jesus say we have to shun each other. The poor girl.
Yes shunning is totally against God's teachings
I think they have their own version of the bible.
Totally agree
But that was the mildest shunning in the history of shunnings.
@@sandtx4913 They read the same one. These are rules made up by the Amish church, has nothing to do with the bible only a desparate attempt in keeping their people among them hidden under the veil of faith.
MIXED FEELINGS ABOUT THIS MOVIE - FEEL THE ENDING IS INCOMEPLETE. You could have at least showed some interactions between Katie and her biological mother.
It has a sequel.
I read the series but don't know the name of the others and when she meets the boy again.
@@SMD2308oh name of it pls?
@@vl9488 "The confession "and "The reckoning"
@@vl9488 it's called The Confession. If you find the link to the full movie, please post it here.
I have read the all book and was desperately searching for the book...alas I ,ve found it...😊❤
Good story. With so much evil in the world and getting worse, don’t blame them for trying so hard to keep it out. If only the rest of the world was smart enough to reject evil.
True but cutting yourself off from the world is a kind of weakness. We should be strong enough to resist evil. It strengthens and matures the spirit.
Psalm 72 describes the reign of Jesus on earth!
trying to ignore progress doesnt make it go away
@@olavwilhelm6843 progress can be upwards or downwards. Humanity as it is now is progressing downwards.
@@osamedennadi6309 We are going to admire the Amish very soon, and how they have been able to live without modern amenities. We Americans are shortly going to wish we had those skills. Unless of course, you are living amongst the elite, which most of us are not.
I read the books years ago. So pleased to find the movie of it! Thanks.
Oh what's its name?
name of the books please
The Shunning
The Confession
The Reckoning
👍🏼
Hi anyone watching from Nigeria 🇳🇬… Lovely movie. Thanks for posting
I represent, Naija!
Yesoo, Abuja
@@mapitsithamaga-xn3oi ride on
@@mapitsithamaga-xn3oiWhere in Abuja do you reside please I've lived in Abuja for 8yrs😂
Yes, watching from Nigeria.
You make me cry ..this love story of this family ......God bless🙏❤️
She looks like a cross between Winona Rider, Anne Hathaway, and Julia Roberts.
Random
This is about the reality of adoption world wide, the consequences of what happened when children weren't told of their beginnings. People shouldn't judge the Amish people and their beliefs. No one religion is perfect but they are wrong to treat her like that - the parents & the community should have been given advice too. The parents & community can't change how she feels inside. Both mums made huge sacrifices.
Does the Amish Bible say lying is a sin? The parents lied (at least by omission) that girls whole life!
Lll@@Robin-lh9wr
@@Robin-lh9wrmust be..for ex in Islam it is a big sin..we say the believer don't lie❤❤
@@Robin-lh9wr not only they lie, the adopted mother wanted the birth mother to lie. When the girl acted out, they punished her.
WOULD have been good toseewhatshesaytomptherdidshegoback
What A crazy mentality from her adopted father. He is close-minded like the rest of them. Poor Kate
Thank God! Old ladies in every culture, and most 'religions' are willing to SHUN the rules & support LOVE! ❤❤❤❤
@drleesadr do you speak from experience ?
@l.d.d.2062 I was never Amish,.but was raised in a fundamentalist Christian church. So from that experience, Yes, I speak.
@@drleesadrAnd? what about Fundamentals?
I'm American, not English, of French/Irish extraction. But yeah, as a disciple of Jesus Christ I've been shunned by 'the church'. 1 John: if you say you love God, but don't love your brother, you're a liar, 'and the truth is not in you.'
Shunning is disgusting and away of control . All about Religion and bible study, where does it say to be so unforgiving afraid of change.
It's not about fear and change.
It's about, you are supposed to be in the world but not OF IT. ROMANS 12:2. By bringing worldly things to their home she broke the rules. I do think that amish music rules are too harsh. If someone played an instrument perhaps they could king on key.
😂and in the end, I praise God for miracles!!!! I do wish my own father had been so loving in his good-bye. But after 15 years, I'm grateful that distance made us closer.
If you hang around a evil crowd you have to shun❤ and their isn't nothing wrong with her lovely singing it comes from the heart ❤
I KNOW this is just a movie. VIR: The Amish man would NEVER kiss his fiancé before the wedding!!!
Fantastic movie shame we didnt see her meet her mum thanks for showing this movie really good.
Sherry Springfield used to be an actress in police series and medical series. Really good quality actress
She played on ER
The ending was so emotional. Good watch.
The amish parents sinned by not telling their friends and family that their daughter was adopted.
Right. Omission. Where's their full transparency? I don't know if adoption if accepted though.
What a great movie. You know it’s good when you cry good tears
God is Love. 'Religion ' can & often is not about love. That is tragic😢
I am sure there is second part don’t know the name. It has the same cast would watch it again. We can learn from it to be tender hearted to one another
It's called "The Confession" and came out in 2013.
Thank you for your answer I will have a hunt for it.
It’s amazing the different responses to the same film.
I could not imagine a life without music.. These people are completely controlling! Its called spiritual abuse..
The development of this severity in the Amish faith did NOT come from the spiritual roots but developed under the hatred, imprisonment, and murder that reigned down on Amish and fellow baptism-in-adulthood faiths. The idea that only an adult could make a conscious decision for baptism flew in the face of other Christian faiths which did infant baptism - both positions strongly believed by their respective faith believers and practitioners. I am NOT denying that it is a problem, particularly shunning - but understanding how dangerous it was to be Amish/Anabaptist early on in the history of these faiths, and how keenly they strived for isolation only because they were safer that way, may help us understand and feel compassion for this horrific historical experience, and understand how the isolationist features have become strongly held practice. It is my understanding that the degree to which, and details of the stricter restrictions, are held in various communities varies widely, due to independent softenings of this strategy.
Wrong Taylor Swift lost by music and the new generation with social media and woke upbringing
More like religious abuse , which all religions do.. guaranteed.
The Amish also enjoy sexual abuse- by the father and brother/siblings of the girls and young women.
they listen to hymns which is very much music, just spiritual music.. a lot of the music we listen to today is evil!! And furthermore, if we were to live by the Bible completely… a lot of people would be shunned in today’s time, the Bible does speak of separating ourselves from unbelievers… and we are supposed to separate ourselves from unbelievers and not allow their sin in our homes or lives!! But today people want to change the Bible to their own beliefs… it doesn’t matter how much you try to change it or how much you don’t agree with it… we are in the last days and he is coming back very soon, day we will have no excuses!! g
God is a good God and a faithful God BUT…. You have to live your life according to his laws, his commandments.!! God gave his own son to die for the sins of the world an ungrateful world.. who is always trying to change his word to fit thier desires… Shunning is mentioned in the Bible, not using the word shun, but it does tell us to separate ourselves from sinners and their sin!!
@@authorcole
The Bible also tells us of helping sinners repent, and try and show them the way of God. So, how can you do that if you're not in contact, a minimum at least?
WHERE IS PART 2??? 😫🤞🏻
I want to see her meet her bio mother!! ❤
is there a part two?
@@dianabartha7886 I don’t think so…. but would love for them to make part 2
I think the name of the sequel is The Reckoning
The Confession and part 3 is The Reckoning.
What a beautiful movie. I didn't want it to end.
I know it is their religion but they did the wrong thing by not telling her. Shunning is terrible. Smashing the guitar was so unchristian, The adopted parents truly loved her as their daughter. Thank you. A very beautiful movie
But,,,, they Ain't Christian!!!!
Smh, if anybody should be shunned is the adoptive parents for keeping the secret about their adopted daughter. And they suppose to set an example? Smh,🥴
Thanks for the movie but at least we would see the poor girl meeting her mum
50 years ago, I was shunned by my best friend. It impacted my life so much. I'd always thought we'd be Grand ma's and enjoy our grand kids. I made lots of bad choices after that and am not married or have children.. Don't shun.
My so called best friend did the same to me after I got married and had a baby, it was heartbreaking. Then I began to look back on the 25 years we'd been friends, I began to realize that she really only wanted me around when she had the upperhand, she was married 20 years before me, we lived together during university from there we stayed friends and during the 20 years I was unmarried, no kids. I spent much of my vacations watching her children so she and her husband could go on vacations. she started a business right out of university and it did very well, she worked incredibly hard, no doubt about that. I on the other hand worked my way up the corporate ladder and it took me a very long time to dig myself out of a lot of debt. she always had more, she had the fancy cars, the big fancy house, pool etc. I lived in a one bedroom condo and drove a car that cost 1/4 of what hers cost. then I met someone and got married, had a baby. She changed, she no longer called me everyday, she was short with me all the time. After my son was born I became very sick, I was just hitting my stride in my career, finally making some decent money. I was able to buy a nice home and we put a pool in, I will never forget a call I had with her after we put the pool in and she asked me what it cost, I didn't think much of it and told her, she says " omg, if I had your money I would burn mine". WHAT?? this was the first very crack in what I would later come to realize was an incredibly toxic relationship from the begining. During our "friendship" I would often show up at her house to go shopping, or go here or there, if I had makeup on and did my hair she would make fun of me, every single time...I would laugh it off and say well ya, I have NOTHING else to do with my time, I dont have 3 kids, lol. When I traded up and got a new car, was so happy and proud of it...yet her husband still made fun of it, why? This was the entire relationship. So when the wheels really fell off was 2021, sept. I messaged her and told her a VERY close of mine ( she and I also lived together in University) I messaged her to tell her my friend had been killed in a hit and run accident, I was beside myself. She knew her of course, we had all lived together at one point breifly in our 20's.she did not even respond. She saw the message I saw that she opened the message. I gave her two days to respond, nothing. So I finally blocked her and we have not spoken since. Sometimes these people do us a favour by showing us who they really are. If your friend shunned you, they were never ever a friend. I hope you can look at the situation and know that YOU did nothing wrong. I hope you can move forward and come to truly know in your heart that this person was/is a very unkind person and you deserve so much better.
I wish there was a part two of this movie 😢
A religion and way of life that could be so cruel… 😢is that what faith could be about? 😭😭No please
Beautiful movie. Thank you for sharing ❤️
I want the rest of the story. What happened to her friend that disappeared? I was hoping to see her meet her bio mom and maybe find her friend or learn what happened to him then return home to start her amish life with her parents who loved her so much.
I guess you have to read the book
The ending was perfect. We often wish for something more, which she was searching for but had it all along and the bio mom the dress did it.
Great story with emotions and we can't never juge the differente believe. Thank you.
Ty , what a wonderful movie!! Hope, love + forgiveness is all we need in this world.🙏💞
All children deserve to know if they were adopted.
I don't think so because how to explain that the mother didn't want her. It hurts. There's no point to tell about the adoption and hurt the child
I loved the book, I hope they finish the story, it really is a beautiful story.
Shunning is all about keeping them in in control.
Everyone shuns no matter the society religious or non-religious Families, friends, and workplaces, you name it religious and non-religious.. I think the Amish as a whole are good people.
I see the movie different then you see it. It moved me deeply, the story, ambient, landscape, non violence and sex scenes. (Except her father that adopted her, break the guitar).
I was shunned and I took it as a lovely discipline I was not a good association that's the truth and helped to me realized I wasn't good but I was able to speak to my immediate family, it worked for me, God Is Love!
Men never do evil so completely and so cheerfully as when doing it from religious conviction.
Such a beautiful movie but it felt incomplete. I needed the scene where she finally meets her mum.
What a lovely movie😢❤
Love is very powerful in spite of what happens in our lives. Beautiful movie!
It’s a movie…not a documentary…
Thank you for the upload. We'll appreciate The Confession and The Reckon also. Thank you in advance
The only thing I don't like is she walked away from her horse. The Amish are very cruel to their horses and livestock. Good story but I am sad at the walk from her companion that got her around.
Dogs too!!! UNGODLY RELIGION THAT IS NOT BIBLICAL! It is more of a culture.
The Amish as I understand it don't treat animals as pets, just as something to perform work. We just rescued a Standardbred horse who has been with the Amish for around ten years, she was a in a kill pen, came here pretty shut down but little by little she's coming out of her shell. She definitely has never been treated as a pet, she doesn't even know what treats are at all.
So much tears in my heart for this story ❤
Makes me wonder, though. The Amish live separately from the modern world yet a medical emergency has them running to the modern hospital and needing to go on an extended trip has them using modern transport. Seems like they want to make use of modern ways when it suits them.
Living without tv and social media is great for them. Everyone has meaningful work. And decent shelter.
Using modern doctors does not endanger their souls.
Oh well.
Definitely a worthy watch 💯
I didn't know the Amish wore lipstick and eyeliner!
You go Katie, soar, new life and opportunities 🎉
Excellent cast, thoughtful script . Heartwarming movie!
How could she be living the life that was meant for her without her music
Such an excellent movie. It’s a shame they had wedding bands on. In my 71 years I have never witnessed wedding bands on an Amish person
And they all had makeup on 🙄
I get emotional, this movie is nice and sweet
Thanks for this amazing movie❤❤❤❤
this was a really emotional movie.
probably the deepest "Amish-Movie" I've seen yet.
I am watching this movie 4/29/2024, Vancouver, Canada
30/04/24 Trinidad and Tobago
Watching it tonight from Papua New Guinea 01/05/2024
Watching from San Antonio Texas 5/1/24.
Watching from he Caribbean....Dutch Antilles....accent sounds a little like a Dutch accent.....
4.05.24 Watching from Sydney, Australia 😊❤
There is something more above any the church. You know you can guess what it is? You always find it in you, it is in your heart, it is you.
This was hard to watch. The lies, deceptions and untruths . The hypocrisy. So sad & destructive. I want to vomit. God would Never treat anyone like that.
I think you described religion in general
Beautiful story! Love and forgiveness
O was looking forward to seeing the biological mum face and reaction 😞☹️
Two more movies
Awesome movie, unexpectedly, a lesson of what true love is
The best amish movie and true story is amish grace
That was a genuinely beautiful movie!
The moral of this film.
No matter what mask one has chosen to wear, underneath is a flawed individual.
So, all the burning of letters...or books,
will not, a fact change.