DOSTCAST 0:00 - Intro 2:53 - Learning about Ishta devtas 11:51 - Taking pride in idol worship 25:50 - Why rituals are important 31:11 - Rituals that are personal to Amish 34:42 - The importance of questioning rituals 39:56 - There is no reason to judge idol worship 42:08 - Amish wants to mostly live and die in India 45:21 - Parts of UK culture we should recreate and reject 54:32 - Amish loves London’s multiculturalism 55:51 - Learning to interact with other cultures 59:14 - Conclusion
STOP using CLICKBAITY thumbnails for YOUR PERSONAL BENEFIT. "Idol worship is wrong" I'd like to ask vinamre and his team in the greed of getting views shouldn't you have atleast put up a question mark after this blatant statement? Respect the dharma on behalf of which you are garnering views, however small it may be. Hope someone from his team read the comments and change the thumbnail.
Our gurukul education system was eradicated systematically and that is why we are so confused about our own sanatan dharm. western culture and leftism propaganda have made us feel bad about everything related to our culture
Such an interesting discussion indeed. Living abroad, I can say that whatever you have said is 💯 true. That all indians have to learn. All the best. I have become your fan sir. ❤️
वैदिक काल में कोई मंदिर नहीं थे। मूर्ति पूजा साधना की बहुत प्रारंभिक अवस्था हैं। हमारे ऋषि ब्रह्माण्ड के कण-कण में ईश्वर का अनुभव करने में सक्षम थे इसलिए उस समय मंदिरों की आवश्यकता नहीं थी। ऐसा नहीं है कि जो लोग मूर्ति पूजा नहीं करते वे यह मानते हैं कि केवल एक ही पुरुष ईश्वर है। इसका अर्थ केवल यह है कि ईश्वर आकार से परे है और हर रूप या आकार ईश्वर से ही उत्पन्न हुआ है। आपने तो अपना प्वाइंट साबित करने के लिए बस गैर-मूर्ति पूजकों की निंदा की। मूर्ति पूजा से शुरुआत करना अच्छा है लेकिन स्वयं के हृदय में ध्यान या आंतरिक पूजा पद्धति के माध्यम से ईश्वर को खोजना बेहतर है।
ISHTHA DEV can be explained like a medical Dr you attached to for your day to day ailments or consultation. But he could direct you to a specialist depending upon you medical needs. We all are evolving every second depending upon our KARMA and experiences of life. Therefore at different stage of evolution. Thus our needs for ISHTHA DEV will be different and sanatan let's you to choose your way of life.
Idol worship is a stage in sanatan dharm ..ultimately one has to move forward towards formless form. Nirgun, nirakaar Aatma/Satya/Brahma/Parbrahma. Bhagwad Gita also mentions it.
@@pkm7776Because once you're with yourself, you stop seeking God in human form. When you're closer to the source, the need for external worship starts to disappear.
@@pkm7776In other words, the search for divine becomes internal. I would not call idol worship as an initial stage, although it makes sense why it would be called so, but formless worship is equally a good place to start, if you're past karma are that powerful.
Religion is the most confusing matter. There are several faiths but certainly God is common. So just believe there is God, we don't know the gender of God, we don't know what God looks like. It is not necessary that God looks like a man or woman. Just believe in God and stop fighting in religion.
Great Interview, I love this Amish guy. Just one thinking from my side: The word Idol does NOT, in any way, describes "Vigraha" or "Murti" worship. English word idol was coined to describe our Carved Deities. The word idol in no way is enough to describe the Sanskrit word Vigraha or Murti. English is too limited and inadequate to describe anything in Sanskrit language. And we get tangled in english language thinking it is the most superior language to describe anything because we have been brainwashed to think it is so. Please understand your Dharma in your own language because only your language can accurately describe your Dharma and not an outsider. Hari Om. 🙏
Hey ..could u plz invite Dr alok Kumar (professor at State University of New York) Unki book *ancient Hindu science* pe unse baat Krna.... Awareness bdhegi logo main ancient India k knowledge k prati🙏🏾
Great episode.. but some unsolicited advice to Vinamre is to really introspect on your own deracination from Indic culture (I know the feeling because I have been there). It was really disappointing that you had no idea about the Rotterham crimes against humanity.
Idol worshipping cultures creates corruption, divisions, segregation, moral differences, sexual immorality, and selfish spirituality. Therefore the society becomes an anarchy. The result is seen in the chaos and selfish outlooks and hypocrisy of our society. Ancient Jewish cultures had the problem of idol worshipping and multiple prophets saw consistently that the downfall began when idol worshipping began. So multiple prophets kept noticing the social effects and warning against it therefore Jewish faith is monotheistic strictly formless. And Christianity and Islam branched out from there. Idol worshipping will stagnate you spiritually.
“Bramhan” as in travelling?? He said it, he said it! Where is your basic background man, where is some level of homework? I am flabbergasted by how such naive ones get these many views :(
Like outcome of science is fans ,cars ,tech Outcome of santana dharma are temples and rituals the claim that knowledge was kept with nobles but it was put in form of temples and rituals to society
After listening to Acharya Prashant Ji, Amish is sounding very lame. Purans are relatovely newer text compared to Vedas. Bhagwad Gita mentions about Parbrahm.
tu ek illogical theist which belives in imaginary energy (called as god) and astrologers ke saath podcast bna sakta h, but ek intellectual vegan activist ke saath nhi, tune jo pichla nutrition ka podcast bnaya tha usme side mei ek vegan activist ko bhi bitha ke rakhta na, fir hoti complete conversation hypocracy ki bhi seema hoti h i challenge u, if u had a podcast with 'arvind activist' or 'voice of vegans' jaise kisi vegan activist ke saath podcast bna, and at the end of the podcast agr tu vegan na bnjaye coming to the point in this podcast, if money jo ram mandir and various other religious culture ko flourish kerne mei use hote h, agr ussi paise ko schools, offices, hospitals jaise productive emplyoment generation mei lagaya jata toh aaj India unemplyment ke liye nhi jana jata
यहां पर आप थोड़ा सा गलत हो vedvyas ji Brahman the unke pitaji ऋषि पराशर ब्राह्मणी तो थे हां उनकी माता जी को पालने वाले माता-पिता मछुआरे थे लेकिन उनका जन्म देने वाले पिता भी ब्राह्मण थे मैं सिर्फ आपको करेक्ट कर रही हूं मुझे कास्ट से कोई जरूरत नहीं है पर यह वाला एग्जांपल यहां पर सूट नहीं कर रहा
But according to iitian guru acharya Prashant murti puja concept did not existed in Hinduism , it is not there in the Vedas. Abrahamics are right on this one!!
@@sharda_244 and you think you know about Hinduism more than a guru like acharya Prashant who is an iitian and iim graduate? He has even clearly said that God does not exists
bro he told that murti pooja is an effective way to reach god in podcast with dhruv rathi. he told that even Islam is doing murtipuja by praying in certain direction. Every prayer that uses some physical aspect or ritual or even a mental image even in any form is a murti puja only. hence we can't deny it
No !!! What Acharya Prashant says about "मूर्ति पूजा" (idol worshipping) is 👇 Idols are the सगुण (finite form) of that "ब्रह्म (the truth)" which is in निर्गुण form Idol worshipping is a "method" developed for those people who don't understand "निर्गुण" If idol worship, helps you reach that "ब्रह्म (the ultimate Truth) Then Idol worshipping is GOOD If it doesn't helps you to reach to that Ultimate Truth called ब्रह्म then idol worship is NOT Good
exactly. we can't reduce god to our level but idols are a means through which we can worship and communicate with God as per our limited fragmented imagination. An idol is not an end but a means to reach that. @@tonguewarrior5020
@@sharda_244 These so called Gurus, Babas and Sants have *MISINTERPRETED* our scriptures And they DON'T care nor give importance to वेदांत, उपनिषद, योग सूत्र, ब्रह्म सूत्र, योगवशिष्ट, अष्टावक्र गीता, and भगवद गीता Religion is a TRAP and a huge Business ‼️ ✅Choose Spirituality over Religion
Sorry but i believe agr aap zindagi bhr bas murti pooja karte rahunge toh aap 0 zero percent bhagwan ke baare kuch paunge 🙏Own experience and please murti is just murti end of discussion ✅🙏
@@sharda_244 Bhai maine toh logic ki baat ki hai agr mein aapko krshn ki murti de deta pooja krne ke liye or bolta ye ye ritual hai but aapko ni pta krshn kya the teachings kya thi aap bas bhagwan maan ke pooja krre jaare woh murti ki but agr mein aapko bhagwat geeta deta fir aab murti ek taraf dekhte toh kya sochte woh murti krshn hai ya pura universe?, As i agree everyone had there different experiences but baat toh saabki yahi khtm hori hai na…
@@sharda_244Murti yaar is just murti agr mein respect karunga for representation of god as symbolist that is just another thing but iska mtlb ye murti ko mein ye chada raha dhoodh se saaf kr raha pura pura din bas murti ki aarti krra toh you don’t think so about that ysb faltu hai? ritual aapne jagah but murti pooja is waste
Moorti is just moorti because tum mein bhaav nahi hai ..aur jahan bhav nahi wahan prabhav nahi...baaki bhaav hontoh moorti ke sahare Meera bai ne apni bhagwad prapti kar li. Ek murti ke sahare Tukaram, Eknath, narsih mehta jaise kitne tir gaye...baaki bas itna kahunga, " jaaki rahi bhaavna jaisi, prabhu murat dekhi tin waisi. "
DOSTCAST
0:00 - Intro
2:53 - Learning about Ishta devtas
11:51 - Taking pride in idol worship
25:50 - Why rituals are important
31:11 - Rituals that are personal to Amish
34:42 - The importance of questioning rituals
39:56 - There is no reason to judge idol worship
42:08 - Amish wants to mostly live and die in India
45:21 - Parts of UK culture we should recreate and reject
54:32 - Amish loves London’s multiculturalism
55:51 - Learning to interact with other cultures
59:14 - Conclusion
STOP using CLICKBAITY thumbnails for YOUR PERSONAL BENEFIT.
"Idol worship is wrong"
I'd like to ask vinamre and his team in the greed of getting views shouldn't you have atleast put up a question mark after this blatant statement?
Respect the dharma on behalf of which you are garnering views, however small it may be.
Hope someone from his team read the comments and change the thumbnail.
Amazing to see vinamre adapting and improvising to the circumstances and lack of resources. Dostcast to the moon !!! . Jupitor’s moon Europa !
Our gurukul education system was eradicated systematically and that is why we are so confused about our own sanatan dharm. western culture and leftism propaganda have made us feel bad about everything related to our culture
Quite true
Such an interesting discussion indeed. Living abroad, I can say that whatever you have said is 💯 true. That all indians have to learn. All the best. I have become your fan sir. ❤️
Beautiful podcast vinamre bhai
This deserves a lot more views!
great pod bro
Many new perspectives.. Awesome podcast
M so thankful I came across your channel ..since 2022
I loved this video. Blessings for you both.🙏🙏🙏🙏
What a wonderful podcaster only apt amount of questions and interactions..🎉🎉
अति सार्थक वार्ता जो सोचने और समझने का पर्याप्त अवसर देने में समर्थ है🙏
वैदिक काल में कोई मंदिर नहीं थे। मूर्ति पूजा साधना की बहुत प्रारंभिक अवस्था हैं। हमारे ऋषि ब्रह्माण्ड के कण-कण में ईश्वर का अनुभव करने में सक्षम थे इसलिए उस समय मंदिरों की आवश्यकता नहीं थी। ऐसा नहीं है कि जो लोग मूर्ति पूजा नहीं करते वे यह मानते हैं कि केवल एक ही पुरुष ईश्वर है। इसका अर्थ केवल यह है कि ईश्वर आकार से परे है और हर रूप या आकार ईश्वर से ही उत्पन्न हुआ है। आपने तो अपना प्वाइंट साबित करने के लिए बस गैर-मूर्ति पूजकों की निंदा की। मूर्ति पूजा से शुरुआत करना अच्छा है लेकिन स्वयं के हृदय में ध्यान या आंतरिक पूजा पद्धति के माध्यम से ईश्वर को खोजना बेहतर है।
Iswar has no gender. So you seems to Abrahmic
Moorty pooja creates positive vibes & constant pooja creates good energy centres which has subtle positive effects on the surroundings.
ISHTHA DEV can be explained like a medical Dr you attached to for your day to day ailments or consultation. But he could direct you to a specialist depending upon you medical needs.
We all are evolving every second depending upon our KARMA and experiences of life. Therefore at different stage of evolution. Thus our needs for ISHTHA DEV will be different and sanatan let's you to choose your way of life.
🙏🙏🙏 nice to see amish sir
Shocking revelations Amishji🫣
Idol worship is a stage in sanatan dharm ..ultimately one has to move forward towards formless form. Nirgun, nirakaar Aatma/Satya/Brahma/Parbrahma. Bhagwad Gita also mentions it.
Why do u have to move away from Idol worship. Why can't u do what do u believe instead of saying ultimately have to move towards formless form.
@@pkm7776 Because original text Upanishads describe it as formless
@@pkm7776Because once you're with yourself, you stop seeking God in human form. When you're closer to the source, the need for external worship starts to disappear.
@@pkm7776In other words, the search for divine becomes internal. I would not call idol worship as an initial stage, although it makes sense why it would be called so, but formless worship is equally a good place to start, if you're past karma are that powerful.
Religion is the most confusing matter. There are several faiths but certainly God is common. So just believe there is God, we don't know the gender of God, we don't know what God looks like. It is not necessary that God looks like a man or woman. Just believe in God and stop fighting in religion.
Bro, restricting us to manifesting God in different ways while at the same time saying to stop fighting in religion - what a hypocrite.
Nice interpretation of Hinduism...and ieast dev....
Great Interview, I love this Amish guy. Just one thinking from my side: The word Idol does NOT, in any way, describes "Vigraha" or "Murti" worship. English word idol was coined to describe our Carved Deities. The word idol in no way is enough to describe the Sanskrit word Vigraha or Murti. English is too limited and inadequate to describe anything in Sanskrit language. And we get tangled in english language thinking it is the most superior language to describe anything because we have been brainwashed to think it is so. Please understand your Dharma in your own language because only your language can accurately describe your Dharma and not an outsider. Hari Om. 🙏
Hey ..could u plz invite Dr alok Kumar (professor at State University of New York)
Unki book *ancient Hindu science* pe unse baat Krna....
Awareness bdhegi logo main ancient India k knowledge k prati🙏🏾
52:09 Yogi Adityanath like leader needed in UK
❤❤❤
Please bring episode on reality of ias by an ias officer himself or herself
Great episode.. but some unsolicited advice to Vinamre is to really introspect on your own deracination from Indic culture (I know the feeling because I have been there). It was really disappointing that you had no idea about the Rotterham crimes against humanity.
Idol worshipping cultures creates corruption, divisions, segregation, moral differences, sexual immorality, and selfish spirituality. Therefore the society becomes an anarchy. The result is seen in the chaos and selfish outlooks and hypocrisy of our society. Ancient Jewish cultures had the problem of idol worshipping and multiple prophets saw consistently that the downfall began when idol worshipping began. So multiple prophets kept noticing the social effects and warning against it therefore Jewish faith is monotheistic strictly formless. And Christianity and Islam branched out from there. Idol worshipping will stagnate you spiritually.
“Bramhan” as in travelling?? He said it, he said it! Where is your basic background man, where is some level of homework? I am flabbergasted by how such naive ones get these many views :(
Jay Shree RAM
53:40 Congratulations to Bharat for copying the same single parent culture.
❤
Ved is real sanatan dharm. Vedant is real philosophy. @prashantacharya
Like outcome of science is fans ,cars ,tech
Outcome of santana dharma are temples and rituals the claim that knowledge was kept with nobles but it was put in form of temples and rituals to society
dull reasoning
After listening to Acharya Prashant Ji, Amish is sounding very lame. Purans are relatovely newer text compared to Vedas. Bhagwad Gita mentions about Parbrahm.
Content can be uploaded in english so that a lot of people can gain knowledge 😢
Shiva Triology
Puremanav ka karma granth ekhi hai or voh hai 4 vedas q ki vedomein god ishwar allah ka koe ansh nahi hai isme faqt nature ko mana hai.
That phone holding is very annoying
Host ko ek advice hai ... Bich Mai mat bola kar, aata jata kuch hai nhi bakwas Bina baat ki karta hai
Ham yaha Amish ji ko sunene aaye hai
tu ek illogical theist which belives in imaginary energy (called as god) and astrologers ke saath podcast bna sakta h, but ek intellectual vegan activist ke saath nhi, tune jo pichla nutrition ka podcast bnaya tha usme side mei ek vegan activist ko bhi bitha ke rakhta na, fir hoti complete conversation
hypocracy ki bhi seema hoti h
i challenge u, if u had a podcast with 'arvind activist' or 'voice of vegans' jaise kisi vegan activist ke saath podcast bna, and at the end of the podcast agr tu vegan na bnjaye
coming to the point in this podcast, if money jo ram mandir and various other religious culture ko flourish kerne mei use hote h, agr ussi paise ko schools, offices, hospitals jaise productive emplyoment generation mei lagaya jata toh aaj India unemplyment ke liye nhi jana jata
Tera Paisa Thodi lag ra h, donations ka lag ra h. Tujhe Kyu chul machi h😂
Watch his interview with Abhinandan Sekhri. That's it 🤧😂
Rituals vagere jo panditonekaha vahi humne mana.yeh sab brahman.mulla.padri ka khelhai magar ye vedomenahi hai
यहां पर आप थोड़ा सा गलत हो vedvyas ji Brahman the unke pitaji ऋषि पराशर ब्राह्मणी तो थे हां उनकी माता जी को पालने वाले माता-पिता मछुआरे थे लेकिन उनका जन्म देने वाले पिता भी ब्राह्मण थे मैं सिर्फ आपको करेक्ट कर रही हूं मुझे कास्ट से कोई जरूरत नहीं है पर यह वाला एग्जांपल यहां पर सूट नहीं कर रहा
But according to iitian guru acharya Prashant murti puja concept did not existed in Hinduism , it is not there in the Vedas. Abrahamics are right on this one!!
@@sharda_244 and you think you know about Hinduism more than a guru like acharya Prashant who is an iitian and iim graduate? He has even clearly said that God does not exists
bro he told that murti pooja is an effective way to reach god in podcast with dhruv rathi. he told that even Islam is doing murtipuja by praying in certain direction. Every prayer that uses some physical aspect or ritual or even a mental image even in any form is a murti puja only. hence we can't deny it
No !!!
What Acharya Prashant says about "मूर्ति पूजा" (idol worshipping) is 👇
Idols are the सगुण (finite form) of that "ब्रह्म (the truth)" which is in निर्गुण form
Idol worshipping is a "method" developed for those people who don't understand "निर्गुण"
If idol worship, helps you reach that "ब्रह्म (the ultimate Truth)
Then Idol worshipping is GOOD
If it doesn't helps you to reach to that Ultimate Truth called ब्रह्म then idol worship is NOT Good
exactly. we can't reduce god to our level but idols are a means through which we can worship and communicate with God as per our limited fragmented imagination. An idol is not an end but a means to reach that.
@@tonguewarrior5020
@@sharda_244
These so called Gurus, Babas and Sants have *MISINTERPRETED* our scriptures
And they DON'T care nor give importance to वेदांत, उपनिषद, योग सूत्र, ब्रह्म सूत्र, योगवशिष्ट, अष्टावक्र गीता, and भगवद गीता
Religion is a TRAP and a huge Business ‼️
✅Choose Spirituality over Religion
Aap kadvi dawa shakkar lagake pilateho aur yahi pakhandhai.
according to nirgunvadis others things are wrong
according to sagunwadis others things are wrong
God is a fiction
But a great one
Most of our beliefs are
Sorry but i believe agr aap zindagi bhr bas murti pooja karte rahunge toh aap 0 zero percent bhagwan ke baare kuch paunge 🙏Own experience and please murti is just murti end of discussion ✅🙏
@@sharda_244 Bhai maine toh logic ki baat ki hai agr mein aapko krshn ki murti de deta pooja krne ke liye or bolta ye ye ritual hai but aapko ni pta krshn kya the teachings kya thi aap bas bhagwan maan ke pooja krre jaare woh murti ki but agr mein aapko bhagwat geeta deta fir aab murti ek taraf dekhte toh kya sochte woh murti krshn hai ya pura universe?, As i agree everyone had there different experiences but baat toh saabki yahi khtm hori hai na…
@@sharda_244Murti yaar is just murti agr mein respect karunga for representation of god as symbolist that is just another thing but iska mtlb ye murti ko mein ye chada raha dhoodh se saaf kr raha pura pura din bas murti ki aarti krra toh you don’t think so about that ysb faltu hai? ritual aapne jagah but murti pooja is waste
Moorti is just moorti because tum mein bhaav nahi hai ..aur jahan bhav nahi wahan prabhav nahi...baaki bhaav hontoh moorti ke sahare Meera bai ne apni bhagwad prapti kar li. Ek murti ke sahare Tukaram, Eknath, narsih mehta jaise kitne tir gaye...baaki bas itna kahunga, " jaaki rahi bhaavna jaisi, prabhu murat dekhi tin waisi. "
⚠️wrong ek dam GALAT ❌️ bagain 🍆
Sanatani sanskriti freeze status laga na hi mukti ka pasta hai🤘😎
@@sharda_244Stop crying; Murti pooja is just sum percentage of Sanatana. The rest is like dark matter for you all, Pakhandis
@Shriprashant
Lmao one more religious bullshit podcast . I miss old kasana
@@sharda_244 lmao last night your mother came here 💀